Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 6

Exhibit ML -2

NERC GADS Report of Availability

Generating
Unit
Statistical
Brochure

2003-2007

October 2008

Generating
Availability
Data
System
EQUATIONS
Un-weighted Capacity Weighted*

Average Run Time· ART Weighted Service Factor. WSF


[SH/Actual Unit Starts] [r(SH x NMC)/ r(PH x NMC}] x 100 (%)

Starting Reliability· SA Weighted Availability Factor WAF M

[Actual Unit Starts/Attempted Unit Starts] x 100 (%) [r(AH x NMC)/ r(PH x NMC)] x 100 (%)

Net Capacity Factor· NCF Weighted Equivalent Availability Factor - WEAF


[NAG/(PH x NMC)J x 100 (%) {r (AH x NMC) - r[(EUDH + EPDH + ESEDH) x NMC)/
r(PH x NMC)J x 100 (%)
Net Output Factor - NOF
[NAG/(SH x NMC}] x 100 (%) Weighted Forced Outage Rate" WFOR
(r(FOH x NMC)/ r[(FOH + SH) x NMC]) x 100 (%)
Service Factor· SF
(SH/PH) x 100 (%) Weighted Equivalent Forced Outage Rate - WEFOR
(r[{FOH + EFDH) x NMC]/
Availability Factor· AF r[(FOH + SH + EFDHRS) x NMC]) x 100 (%)
{AH/PH} x 100 (%)
Weighted Scheduled Outage Factor - WSOF
Equivalent Availability Factor - EAF [r(SOH x NMC)/ r(PH x NMC)J x 100 (%)
{[AH (EUDH + EPDH + ESEDH}]/PHj x 100 (%j
Weighted Forced Outage Factor - WFOF
Forced Outage Rate - FOR [r(FOH x NMC)/ r(PH x NMC}] x 100 (%)
[FOH/(FOH + SH}] x 100 (%)
*Applies to groups of units only.
Equivalent Forced Outage Rate· EFOR
[(FOH + EFDH}/{FOH + SH + EFDHRS)] x 100 (%)

Scheduled Outage Factor· SOF


(SOH/PH) x 100 (%)

Forced Outage Factor· FOF


(FOH/PH) x 100 (%)

Equivalent Forced Outage Rate demand - EFORd


[(f"FOH) + Ifp"EFDH1J"100
[SH + (f"FOH)]
where ip= (SH/AH) .
1 1 1 1 r = Average Forced Outage duration = [FOH / (number of FO occurrences)]
f= (1--' ..1/._
+. + + .... ) 0 = Average demand time = [SH/ (number of actual unit starts)]
/ r T J~r T O T = Average ReselVe Shutdown time = [RSH / (number of attempted unit starts)]

Unplanned Outage Factor ~ UOF


(UOH/PH) x 100 (%)

Equivalent Unplanned Outage Factor - EUOF


[(UOH + EUDH)/PH] x 100 (%)

Equivalent Unplanned Outage Rate ~ UFOR


[(UOH + EUDH)/(UOH + SH + EUDHRS)] x 100 (%)

Notes:
f'::quivalent hours arc computed for each derating and then summed. Size of Reduction is determined by subtracting the Net Available
Capacity (NAC) from the Net Dependable Capacity (NDC). In cases of multiple deratings, the Size of Reduction of each derating is the
difference in the NAC of the unit prior to the initiation of the derating and the reported NAC as a result of the derating.
DEFINITIONS
Actual Unit Starts Net Available Capacity· NAC
Number of times the unit was synchronized to the The NDC, modified for equipment limitations.
transmission system.
Net Actual Generation· NAG
Attempted Unit Starts Net electrical megawatthours (MWh) produced by
Number of attempts to bring the unit from the unit during the period being considered.
shutdown to synchronization.
Net Dependable Capacity· NDC
Available Hours· AH NMC modified for ambient limitations.
Sum of all SH, RSH, Pumping Hours, and
Synchronous Condensing Hours. Net Maximum Capacity· NMC
Capacity a unit can sustain over a specified period
Equivalent Forced Derated Hours· EFDH when not restricted by ambient conditions or
Product of the Forced Derated Hours and the Size equipment deratings, minus the losses associated
of Reduction, divided by the NMC with station service or auxiliary loads.
Equivalent Forced Derated Hours During Period Hours· PH
Reserve Shutdowns· EFDHRS Number of hours a unit was in the active state. A
Product of the Forccd Derated Hours (during unit generally enters the active state on its
Reserve Shutdowns (RS) only) and the Size of commercial date.
Reduction, divided by the NMC
Reserve Shutdown Hours· RSH
Equivalent Planned Derated Hours· EPDH Total number of hours the unit was available for
Product of the Planned Derated Hours and thc service but not electrically connected to the
Size of Reduction, divided by the NMC transmission system for economic reasons.
Equivalent Seasonal Derated Hours· ESEDH Service Hours· SH
NMC less the NDC, times the Available Hours Total number of hours a unit was electrically
(AH), divided by the NMC connected to the transmission system.
Equivalent Unplanned Derated Hours· EUDH Scheduled Outage Hours· SOH
Product of the Unplanned Derated Hours and the Sum of all hours experienced during Planned
Size of Reduction, divided by the NMC Outages and Maintenance Outages plus any
Scheduled Outage Extensions associated with
Equivalent Unplanned Derated Hours During those outages.
Reserve Shutdowns· EUDHRS
Product of the Unplanned Derated Hours (during Unplanned Derated Hours· UDH
Reserve Shutdowns (RS) only) and the Size of Sum of all hours experienced during Forced
Reduction, divided by the NMC Deratings and Maintenance Deratings plus any
Scheduled Derating Extensions of any
Forced Derated Hours· FDH Maintenance Deratings.
Sum of all hours experienced during Forced
Dcratings. Unplanned Outage Hours· UOH
Sum of all hours experienced during Forced
Forced Outage Hours· FOH Outages and Maintenance Outages plus any
Sum of all hours experienced during Forced Scheduled Outage Extensions of any Maintenance
Outages.
Outages.
INTRODUCTION
This brochure highlights some of the information federal segments of the industry. NERC aggregates
from NERC's Generating Availability Report these data and presents the results annually in its
(GAR). Statistics are shown for the cumulative five GAR.
years, 2003-2007, and are calculated using both the
capacity-weighted technique and the traditional, un- The GAR provides an overview of the availability
weighted method. performance of classes of generating units. More
specific data are available from NERC's GADS
Generating Availability Report database to use in detailed unit- or equipment~level
Continuing the effort to bring timely, useful reliability, availabilily, and maintainability (RAM)
information to the industry in an efficient manner, analyses. GADS data are used in a wide variety of
NERC again will "publish" the 2003-2007 deterministic and probabilistic applications to:
Generating Availability Report in electronic format.
The report is available for downloading from the • benchmark unit performance against
Internet. A printed, bound version of the GAR is not statistically validated peers,
available. • conduct loss-of~load and similar system-wide
analyses,
The electronic GAR consists of a series of formatted • optimize maintenance schedules and prepare
files ready for printing on any laser printer set to a cost~benefit analyses,
condensed font. Ineluded are all the tables and • compare the reliability of original equipment
graphs found in previous printed editions of the manufacturers' (OEM) components, and
report, and more. The traditional unit groupings - by • prepare reports for state and federal regulators.
generation technology, size and, in some cases, fuel
type - have been retained. You can conduct your own GADS special analyses
with a software product called pc-GAR., available
The new GAR is available to everyone at no cost. To from NERC on CD-ROM. GADS data for special
download the GAR from the NERC home page applications are also available by calling NERC.
(http://www.nerc.com)go to "Assessments and Call or e-mail (gads@nerc.com) NERC for further
Trends," then "Generating A vailabilily Data System information.
(GADS)," then (on the left side in white lettering)
"Reports," then "Generating Unit Statistical Historical Availability Statistics
Brochure" and download the self-extracting zip file Back again this year is the 1982-2007 Historical
GAR2007.EXE. That's all there is to it! Availability Statistics (HAS) report. Based on
previous GAR publications, this report provides
GADS Data Applications statistics for individual, five, ten, and twenty~three­
The statistics in this brochure and the GAR are year periods.
calculated from data that electric utilities report
voluntarily to NERC's Generaling Availability Data
System (GADS). Operating histories for more than
6,500 eleclric generating units reside in GADS. Data
arc reported by more than 230 utilities in the United
States and Canada representing investor-owned,
municipal, state, cooperative, provincial, and
North American Electric Reliability Council
Princeton FOITestal Village
116-390 Village Boulevard
Princeton, New Jersey 08540-5731

Phone: 609-452-8060' Fax: 609-452-9550


Internet: http://www.nere.com
E-mail: gads@nere.com
2003-2007 Generating Unit Statistical Brochure - All Units Reporting

_.
Revised April 13.2009
NOTE: Thoa bfocltu•• conl.i... del. on.lI unit.. wMlhe, lhey repon...._ ..corda or I'lOl. For •• ..new 01 elelittice _e1";", only 1 ' - unit. l"-t ,eporl'" ....nt•. _ lhe bfoclture -20030mll7 O_IOtI", Unit SIIOt;IOtI...1e.oclture _ Unit. R.pon;", E_a-.
fIhe ditt..

Unit Type
. . n_ IOtittiea with or with _ a

••
""".
""".
,-
will.~, In equetione.-eli", ""lOti", InlormMion "",h . . EM, EFOA. _

NO'
01.... ~i_. The toqUIOI'_.re more .........1. 11._....

... '0'
,eporl....)

.." w" W" W,,,


"" '" "" " " '"' EFOR EFORd SO<'
""" ''''''' "'"' """ WFOR WEFOfI

"""'-
AlF..JT_
M ....
'·N
I,H7
m
un.n ~".lt n.n n."
n.n
7'." U.2~ 17"1
... n
15.10 5.61
,...
7.U 1.16 1.10 J.n 5.'1 7.1$ 10.10
....
'.61 2.00
I."
72.51 ".17 1'.41 5.20 1.10

".IS .
alt.n I'S.t! n.02 'f.42 n .• 7 17.~. 7.U 7." 1.12 LIS 5.n 7.~' a.OJ 52.10 If.Sf I7.U '.n '.40

.......
'0(1.," '" 17S2.n 21'.0' ".~. 41." n.lo 16.21 17.70

.....
".'5 5.1' 7.56 '.5~ a.$7 J.7' I.O~ a.ol II.Of 1.21 2.21 17.12

.....
17.12

..,.
u.n 5.11 7.lI

_
_......
,..'"
""N
no
'"
m
m
ao,.n
122.00
110a.SI
su.n
ao.GoO
155.70
311.1'
131.&0
nl."
91.'2
91.'0
91.21
n.Sf
U.U
50.n
Sf.u
n.n
12.71
77.B
7l.U
10,'5
1S.7'
".61
u.s.
n .• o
76.7'
.. n

".at
n.n
".n
".I~
14.14
" .01
1).57
I.Of
4.5'
5.~0
5.~2

~.fO
7.U
1.50
7.at
7.26
7.05
5.7t
'.U
I.U
a .• J
'.10
f.n
'.76
4.14
J.n
4.02
4.21
'.U
5.5~

5.92
5.71
I.n
7.U
7.7~

7.75
4.)7
10.11
f.fO
,. n
f.n
'.11
7.'0
7.71
1.21
1.12
2.~0
1. '0
1.SS
14.5'
1f.01
n."
71."
".3~
15.1l
14.02

U.1t
11.47
17.n
'.17
'.5'
5.11
5.30
~.as
7.74
I."
7.a
1.n

"" ..... " 5IC.5' 91.21 1).'7 ".21 I7.U J.60 J.J' '.41 2.22 1.16 5.U 1.01 1.40 14.14 .... J l.54

-- -__...... .....
U 1$.00 727. " n.n 72.14 ".n 10.n n.u ".41 7.40 I." I.n 11.10 1.41 I.n 10.4f 11.71 '.lI 1.'0 Il.n 12.n 10.05 7.17 1.60

n.n n.n
"'" M ....
'·N '"
no
un.7$
nl.so
525.'1
2".H
".'4
n.n S5.U
1S.71
73.'0 n.n
17.74
".40
".11
15.41
4.7'
5.n
1.7'
7."
'.56
7.11
1.01
7.S2
4.U
4.~1
5.'1 a.OI
1.51
f.04
10.n
'.15
5.1'
1.7)
2.17
15.10 17.10
15.55
4.70
S.H
I.n
1."

.....
' .• 4 7'." ".$7

.......
10(1.'" '"
'""
I1n.n
uO.n
In •• ~
560.75
UI.lI
91.04
91.47
n.n
U.42
72.47
73.71
71.70
n .• l
n.ll
n.n
".12
17.U
".56
".24
17."
15.0'
15.0'
1S.2'
•• Sf
4.41
'.U
I."
1.01
1.31
'.54
5.f3
1.21
7.41
7.70
1.23
4.04
4.01
LI2
5."
5.U
5.47
I.U
7.70
7.U
'.4'
I.n
1.21
5.41
'.01
1.$1
1.'2
1.U
1.n
".40

I1.S7
".41
".27
".Il
1$.07
IS.OI
1$.'0
4.5l
4.'l
'.1l
'.11
S."
1.11
_N 1$'."
n.1l 7.11

.....
5 ... n 7 •. 54 I).U 5.10 7.a 7.U ".l~ 5.05
'" 7.0.0'
4$1.50 727.1~
n.n
f4.37 71.U
".76 1S.1l ".21
14.10 4.n '.40
'.11 •. 61
4.a
1.21
5.U
1.1I
7.4~
'.Ol 7.51 1.10
1.~0
1$.'1
".2~ ".Sf 4.71 I.n
" ".21 ".1) '.12 1.0f ".03

.......
".'1 '.n 7.'2
,n.n 17.U 2.17 3.7) 7.72 ".55 ".IS 17.14
, " 125.00 ".21 10.11 ,I.Jl 11.55 J.SS J.S4 I.n 2.12 4.54 4.91 1.11 2.a2 J."

-- - ......,." U 10.00 7H.U n.u 75.40 ,o.t? 12.51 12.10 10.12 7.n 1.15 I.U 10.7S I.U 7.10 '.12 10.11 '.41 I.lS 12." n.lI 10.51 7.0~ I.n

".21 n.n n.n '.If 13.01


'" HO

""
531.02
1'1.7$
".5'
n." ".$7
22.02
24.71
$4.70
'1.75
JI.51
n.fl
n.n
1$.11
Il.JI
n.H
11.01
14." 1'."
10.n
10.15
II.S'
'.11
S.02
S.70
7.71
1.20
'.U
10.13
20.n
24.73
I.n
I.n
~. 74
2.50
'O.JI
'O.ll
n.20
".n n.lI 11.0' 17.~.

.......
10(1.," n •. n '0.2' ".05 11. I f 5S.~I lO.n 12.11 .o.n n.04 11.51 11.14 12.73 •• S2 7.10 1.40 22.47 10.10 2.51 ll.'0 1I.1f 71.57 II." 10."

_
_......
,..'" "
"
",
"
H.n
71.~S
n.50
n.n
72.'4
1'1.o,
a'.10
'5.50
".01
".72
".04
n.n
15.22
l1.22
21.10
15.1$
SI.OI
n.n
n.Ol
50.14
a.10
5l.2I
".70
lO.17
14.42
n.lo
".02
12.51
72.14
11."
1'.52
10.4\
n.ll
),02
5."
1l"1
n.lo
S.lI
1.02
17.lI
27.01
•• 21
5.14
10.'~
f.22
I t .54
ll.~'
n.41
lI.n

..
1.11
~. 7.

~
a.l1
4.1'
I."
5."
11.10
1.27
7.21
'.05
10.15
10.11
n.4'
22.'0
7."
11.15
7."
10.n
1.74
3.20
l.7$
2."
JI.20
52.31
".lO
H.l1
73.10
n.~4

15.'.
82.31
71.12
11.13
".n
10.15
J~.n

3.IJ
5.25
11. . .
tl.1I
S."
,.~O

17.n

....
-- --.......__......
17.n 357.51 ".25 IS." 52.l1 lO.25 ".IS ".51 ~.n 2.71 ~.21 n.n 0.7) 1.71 1.17 s.n 11.40 0." JO.2I ".n ".10 2.n ~.71

a- M ....
'·N
100.1"
."
'"
'"
In5.n
n •. 75
41 •. 5'
'7.22
'5.30
lS.n
".71
".J4
".Of
14.n
1.05
IS.n
l'.'2
42.0'
n.42
n.n
11.41
lI.42
".n
12.45
17.05
l7.lI
'1."
1S.17
1.21
\l"2
7.5'
14.l'
f.55
1.40
7.4'
'.01
.."
'.Ol

10.14
3."
3."
~.Il
5.30
4.22
5.17
1.01
•. 4~
I.n
11.2'
21.U
1I.n
'.5'
1.12
7.01
2."
1.17
J.07
n.15
lI.l~

35.0?
... n
12 ...
17.10
l5.n
.....
'1.71
7.Sl
11.17
7.11
'.lI
12.10
t.n
"" 112.$1 1l2.~5 ".11 II.IS 'O.SJ '1.21 I$.n
1$.1$
U.7S I.n
7.11
I."
I.U
•. U 10."
11.11
J." 5." 7.0) H.H
14.11
1.05 2.50 ".51
n.Is
15."
I5.U
1t.1f
15.21
I."
7.JO
I.U
I."
17$.H 102.~0 ".'0 \l.17 30." lI.n 15.11 5." ~." 5.'0 I." I.~' 2."
'.12 2 ... n ... 15.17 ... n 7.07 '.11
.... ,...
21).00 ,J." IS. 10 n.17 1$.70 I.1f 1.14 11.11 2.17 5.H I.U 14.01 I."
" n.n
".n l'.lS ".51
IS. IS '.12 2 •. J7 10.11 II." 7f.n n."
U
, J7.50
ISO. SO
115.7)
n.25
".11
11.tS
21.12
n.lI
'5 . . ,
H.04
".21
11.70
".11
10.23
17.14
lJ.OI
l.25 4.30
11.40
J.JO
D.II
10.22
4.14
I.SI
1.27
4.37
10.01
?'S
l.n
2.71 ".51 ".21 11.30 l.ll
1'.'0
4.14

UgoIiIePloitwy M ....
" 91.00 70l." ".n n .• 2 n.OJ If. $7 If. 51 ".11 3.2f 5.10 5.10 7.lI l.05 '.30 1.'1 7.0. 1.0' 1.2f ".'1 n.n ".7f 3.5' 5.'2

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi