Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 26

S. N. Title Dwg No.

Description & Comments


4 HVAC
4.1 HIGH LEVEL COMMENTS
4.1.1 UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT - OSD BLOCK 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- The shown length (4.4m)) of shown air cooled chiller (375 T.R) is not correct. The
804 length of the 375 TR chiller is 11-12 m minimum.
4.1.2 OSD Block Missing duct works and air distribution layouts (plans and sections) for the OSD
block
4.1.3 OSD Block Missing design schedules for the Air Handling Units including the (sensible heat,
entering and leaving air temperatures, external static pressure, etc)
4.1.4 OSD Block Missing cooling load calculations for OSD block spacing, using computer program
like Carrier HAP
4.1.5 OSD Block Missing smoke extraction drawings for the corridors and the warehouse area

4.1.6 OSD Block Missing tender documents, drawings and schedules for the two cold rooms (GF-
028), (GF-031)
4.1.7 OSD Block Missing ventilation works for the generator within the OSD block and air
conditioning works for the electrical substation
4.1.8 GF HVAC CUTOUTS 547-P-1-DCPL-AC-D- Missing outdoor condensing units with their associated refrigerant piping for the
703A- VRF cassette types.
4.1.9 scrap yard building Missing ventilation / air conditioning works drawings for the scrap yard building

4.1.10 security block Missing ventilation / air conditioning works drawings for the security block

4.1.11 pump room Missing ventilation / air conditioning works drawings for the pump room

4.1.12 solvent store Missing ventilation / air conditioning works drawings for the solvent store

4.1.13 BOILER HOUSE EQUP.LOCATION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing ventilation works for the boiler plant
812

4.2 DETAILED COMMENTS


S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
4.2.1 OSD Block , (UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT) 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- The shown length (4.4m) of shown air cooled chiller (375 T.R) is not correct. The
804 length of the 375 TR chiller is minimum 11-12 m.
4.2.2 OSD Block , (UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT) 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- The recommended clearance between the two chillers is 3m as per the
804 manufacturers catalogues
4.2.3 OSD Block , (UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT) 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing air and dirt separator at the suction of the chilled water pumps
804

4.2.4 OSD Block , (UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT) 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Validate the size of the chilled water expansion tank (1000 liter), and hot water
804 expansion tank (500 liter) by calculations
4.2.5 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-1-DCPL- 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Indicate the ventilation works for the utility plant (GMF-082), provide calculations
UT-D- 802 (UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT) 802 for size of the associated fans considering the heat loss from the compressors. Show
also the discharge duct from the air compressors.

4.2.6 OSD Block Missing duct works and air distribution layouts (plans and sections) for the OSD
block
4.2.7 OSD Block Missing design schedules for the Air Handling Units including the (sensible heat,
entering and leaving air temperatures, external static pressure, etc)
4.2.8 OSD Block Missing smoke extraction drawings for the corridors and the warehouse area

4.2.9 OSD Block Missing cooling load calculations for OSD block spacing, using computer program
like Carrier HAP
4.2.10 OSD Block Missing tender documents, drawings and schedules for the two cold rooms (GF-
028), (GF-031)
4.2.11 OSD Block (GF HVAC CUTOUTS) 547-P-1-DCPL-AC-D- Missing outdoor condensing units with their associated refrigerant piping for the
703A VRF cassette types.
4.2.12 OSD Block - DUST COLLECTOR 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing design schedules for the dust collector fans including their tags, types and
864 external static pressure
4.2.13 Missing design schedules , tender documents for the air cooled chillers
4.2.14 OSD Block (BOILER HOUSE 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing size of the boiler chimney and thickness and type of its insulation. Provide
EQUP.LOCATION) 812 installation details for its fixation
4.2.15 OSD Block (BOILER HOUSE 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing ventilation works for the boiler plant
EQUP.LOCATION) 812
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
4.2.16 HVAC CONCEPT NOTE 547-AC-CN-V.1 Provide detail calculations for one AHU from each class to verify the selected fresh
air rates, supply air flow rates (based on the cooling loads / required air change per
hour), pressure difference between the adjacent rooms, infiltration and ex-filtration
air flow rate

4.2.17 scrap yard building Missing ventilation / air conditioning works drawings for the scrap yard building

4.2.18 security block Missing ventilation / air conditioning works drawings for the security block
4.2.19 pump room Missing ventilation / air conditioning works drawings for the pump room
4.2.20 solvent store Missing ventilation / air conditioning works drawings for the solvent store
4.2.21 general Missing installation details for the air-cooled chillers hook up, expansion tanks,
refrigerant piping, condensing units, chemical feed units

5 PLUMBING
5.1 HIGH LEVEL COMMENTS
5.1.1 Waste treatment plant Missing design, drawings and tender documents for the waste treatment plant

5.1.2 Site works Missing design, drawings and tender documents for the site domestic, drainage and
irrigations works
5.1.3 Site works Missing design, drawings and tender documents for the domestic, irrigation and
firefighting tanks and their associated pump rooms
5.1.4 OSD Block 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing domestic water connections and drainage connections for several spaces
817, 818 and wet areas within the OSD block.
5.1.5 OSD Block 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing sizing for the domestic water networks in the ground and mezzanine floors.
817, 818
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
5.1.6 RAIN WATER INFILTRATION SYSTEM 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- The shown schematic for the rain water infiltration system and using the collected
866 water from the side ditches, pond is not accepted for the following reasons:
1- The schematic indicates that the town water (make up) water is directly supplied
to the side ditches/ pond. This will cause lead to lose large volume of this water
directly through evaporation and infiltration through soil before being used by the
irrigation system.
2-There is no controlled volume of the required storage volume of the irrigation
system.

5.1.7 OSD Block , GROUND FLOOR PLAN 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- Missing floor plans layouts for the purified water distribution in the ground floor
823 and mezzanine floors plans.
5.1.8 OSD Block , MEZZANINE FLOOR 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- Similarly, missing floor plans layouts for the purified water distribution in the
PLAN 824 mezzanine floor.
5.1.9 OSD Block 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- There is conflict between the capacity of the PW generation plant as shown in
851 & 547-P-1 drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D-851 and the tender document 547-UT-TD-WST-001 is
1500 liter/hr and the peak load of 3420 liter /hr as shown in drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-
WS-D-852

5.1.10 OSD Block , UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing compressed air after cooler at the discharge of the air compressors
804
5.1.11 OSD Block - P & I DIAGRAM FOR HSD Missing site plan drawings for the location of the fuel tanks, HSD pump room, filling
547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- points, pipe network, etc.
865
5.1.12 OSD Block , P & I DIAGRAM FOR HSD 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing drawings for the fuel supply system of the diesel generator
865
5.1.13 OSD Block , BOILER HOUSE Missing steam, condensate , feed water & HSD piping layouts within the boiler plant
EQUP.LOCATION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
812
5.1.14 scrap yard building Missing plumbing works drawings for the scrap yard building
5.1.15 security block Missing plumbing works drawings for the security block
5.1.16 pump room Missing plumbing works drawings for the pump room
5.1.17 solvent store Missing plumbing works drawings for the solvent store
5.1.18 sceco building Missing storm drainage works drawings for the sceco building

5.2 DETAILED COMMENTS


S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
5.2.1 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing sizing for the domestic water networks in the mezzanine floor
5.2.2 OSD Block , drawing 817
547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Conflict between the lavatory in the ladies toilet (GMF-016) and the structural
817 column at axis (C-2)
5.2.3 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing water supply to the handicapped toilet (GMF-012) and the janitor room
817 (GMF-011)
5.2.4 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Relocate the domestic water pipes serving the water closets in toilets (GMF-014) ,
817 (GMF-016) in the cavities below the W.Cs instead of being imbedded in the wall.
Provide access door to this cavity

5.2.5 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing sizing for the domestic water networks in the ground floor
5.2.6 OSD Block , drawing 818
547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing water supply to the toilet (GF-012), laundry (GF-050), janitor rooms (GF-
818 154), (GF-089), (GF-061) and the ablutions (GF-051) &(GF-157)
5.2.7 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Conflict between the domestic water pipes and the structural column at axis (B-14')
818
5.2.8 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Why the toilets domestic water pipes are imbedded inside the walls? while all the
818 toilets are provided with reflected ceiling. relocate the domestic water pipes above
the reflected ceiling to allow for their inspection and maintenance (typical to all
toilets)

5.2.9 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- The title of sheet 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-817 (Ground Floor Plan) to be corrected to
817 Mezzanine floor plan
5.2.10 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Similarly, The title of sheet 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-818 (Mezzanine Floor Plan) to be
818 corrected to Ground floor plan
5.2.11 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-151 Missing drainage for the cold rooms
5.2.12 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-151 Indicate the capacity for the rain water collection tank at axis (9-A') and provide
calculations for its volume. Indicate also the depth of the storm trench and the size
of the pipes connecting to it

5.2.13 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-151 Similarly, indicate the capacity for the collection chamber for the machine drain at
axis (16-A) and indicate how it will be accessed
5.2.14 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-151 Missing oil drainage system from the generator room
5.2.15 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-151 Missing drainage works to the entry room (GF-053), janitor room (GF-061) and the
laundry room (GF-050), furthermore, the drainage of the laundry to be connected
to lint interceptor before being connected to the sewage network
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
5.2.16 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-151 The storm pipes to be terminated with spout nozzles for free discharges
5.2.17 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-151 Indicate the invert levels for the inspection chambers all around the building

5.2.18 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-152 Missing drainage for the hand wash (attached to the dining area)
5.2.19 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-152 Missing the continuation of the roof rain water leaders at axis C
5.2.20 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-152 Redistribute the drainage points in the compressed air ( utility) plant to avoid the
surface drainage.
5.2.21 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-152 Ensure having a floor drainage point adjacent to the AHUs cooling coils
5.2.22 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-153 Show the termination points of the drainage / vent stacks on the roof floor, use roof
vent caps
5.2.23 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-153 Similarly for the termination of the domestic water pipes, use automatic air vents

5.2.24 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-153 Validate the size of the roof storm water gutters
5.2.25 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-171 To 175 The shown toilets detailed layouts are not related to the toilets layouts ( fixture
distribution) as shown in the floor plans
5.2.26 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-171 To 175 The shown toilets detailed layouts indicate domestic ( cold) water supply to the
hand sprays of the water closets, while toilets layouts as shown in the floor plans
indicate domestic (cold & hot) water supply connections to the hand sprays of the
water closets

5.2.27 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-171 To 175 The general notes and abbreviations shown within the drawings frames are not
related to the mechanical works, typical to other plumbing drawings.

5.2.28 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-171 To 175 Revise the sewage isometric for toilet detail-02 and toilet detail-04
5.2.29 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-171 To 175 Missing isometric detailed layouts for the toilets
5.2.30 OSD Block , drawing 547-P-PG-171 To 175 Missing water hammer arrestors on the domestic water supply to the toilets (typical
to all project buildings)
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
5.2.31 RAIN WATER INFILTRATION SYSTEM 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- The shown schematic for the rain water infiltration system and using the collected
866 water from the side ditches, pond is not accepted for the following reasons:
1- The schematic indicate that the town water ( make up) water is directly supplied
to the side ditches/ pond. This will cause lead to lose large volume of this water
directly through evaporation and infiltration through soil before being used by the
irrigation system.
2-There is no controlled volume of the required storage volume of the irrigation
system.

5.2.32 OSD Block OSD Block Indicate the function of the gas store room (GF-019), provide layouts and details

5.2.33 OSD Block , drawing - PID for 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- For the PW generation, obtaining the raw water from the combined fire fighting &
PRETREATMENT & PW GENERATION 851 water tank is not accepted. The tank should be separated, the raw water source
should be the water tank only.

5.2.34 OSD Block , drawing - PID for 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- Missing pipe sizing for the different processes
PRETREATMENT & PW GENERATION 851

5.2.35 OSD Block ,GROUND FLOOR PLAN 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- Missing floor plans layouts for the purified water distribution in the ground floor.
WITH PURIFIED WATER PIPING 823
LAYOUT

5.2.36 OSD Block , GROUND FLOOR PLAN 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- Missing PW supply in the pallet wash room (GF-034)
WITH PURIFIED WATER PIPING 823
LAYOUT

5.2.37 OSD Block , MEZZANINE FLOOR 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- Similarly, missing floor plans layouts for the purified water distribution in the
PLAN WITH PURIFIED WATER USER 823 mezzanine floor.
POINT LOCATION

5.2.38 OSD Block , MEZZANINE FLOOR 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- Missing PW water supply to the wash room (GMF-053), wet lab (GMF-049),
PLAN WITH PURIFIED WATER USER 823 instrument lab (GMF-043), dissolution (GMF-045), media dest. (GMF-075)
POINT LOCATION
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
5.2.39 OSD Block , MEZZANINE FLOOR 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- Missing piping layout inside the PW pre-treatment & generation plant
PLAN WITH PURIFIED WATER USER 823
POINT LOCATION

5.2.40 OSD Block , MEZZANINE FLOOR 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- Show the raw water supply line to the PW pre-treatment & generation plant.
PLAN WITH PURIFIED WATER USER 823
POINT LOCATION

5.2.41 OSD Block , 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D- There is conflict between the capacity of the PW generation plant as shown in
851 & 547-P-1-DCPL- drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-WS-D-851 and the tender document 547-UT-TD-WST-001 is
WS-D-852 1500 liter/hr and the peak load of 3420 liter /hr as shown in drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-
WS-D-852

5.2.42 OSD Block ,UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing compressed air after cooler at the discharge of the air compressors
804

5.2.43 OSD Block , UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing compressed air after cooler (with moisture eliminator) at the discharge of
804 the air compressors
5.2.44 OSD Block , UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- The shown compressed air receiver to be divided into two; wet air receiver (1/3 of
804 the overall required air receiver capacity )before the drier and one dry receiver (2/3
of the overall required air receiver capacity)after the drier.

5.2.45 OSD Block , UTILITY PIPING LAYOUT 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- The compressed air filters quantities and efficiencies in compressed air plant room
804 as shown in drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- 804 is different than that in the
compressed air generation PID (drawing 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-853)

5.2.46 OSD Block , PID FOR COMPRESSED 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Check the shown pressure drop of 2 bar(g) at the compressed air receiver
AIR GENERATION 853 ( upstream pressure is 9 bar (g), while downstream pressure is 7 bar (g))
5.2.47 OSD Block , PID FOR COMPRESSED Check the shown capacity of the air receiver, provide calculations to validate the 3
AIR GENERATION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- m3 capacity.
853
5.2.48 OSD Block , PID FOR COM AIR 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing pressure regulators upstream the compressed air end points (served
DISTRIBUTION 854 equipment)
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
5.2.49 OSD Block , PID FOR SOFT HOT 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Check the shown head of the soft water pumps (3.5 bar), since the required head at
WATER (PROCESS) GENERATION & 856 the end points (served equipment) is 3.0. Provide calculations for the pressure in
DISTRIBUTION the network including the pressure drop in the heat exchanger

5.2.50 OSD Block , PID FOR SOFT HOT 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Indicate the flow rate of the main headers, and change the unit of the flow rate
WATER (PROCESS) GENERATION & 856 from l/ shift to l/hr for checking the pipe sizes
DISTRIBUTION

5.2.51 OSD Block , PID FOR HVAC HOT 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Indicate the term (SOPT-LH)
WATER GENERATION 857-
5.2.52 OSD Block , PID FOR HVAC HOT 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Provide mass and heat balance calculations for the boiler and the feed water tank
WATER GENERATION 857-
5.2.53 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Indicate the capacity of the boiler feed water pumps, HSD pumps, provide
GENERATION 858 calculations for their capacity and head
5.2.54 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Provide calculations for the feed water tank capacity
GENERATION 858
5.2.55 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Missing steam separator at the steam supply line.
GENERATION 858
5.2.56 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- Indicate the size of the header at the suction side of the fuel duplex filters
GENERATION 858
5.2.57 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM Missing legend for the used valves, sensors and instrumentations
GENERATION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
858
5.2.58 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM Provide strainer before the steam flow meter
DISTRIBUTION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
859
5.2.59 OSD Block ,PID FOR STEAM Indicate the capacity of the condensate pumps, provide calculations for its flow rate
DISTRIBUTION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- and head. Verify the percentage of condensate return. Provide heat and mass
859 balance

5.2.60 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM Indicate the location of the PRS, steam traps within the diagram
DISTRIBUTION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
859
5.2.61 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM Indicate the flow rates for the steam headers, piping , connections to services. Same
DISTRIBUTION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- for the condensate network
859
5.2.62 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM For the solu pre. wash, the steam line size is 20 mm , while its associated line valve
DISTRIBUTION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- size is 50 mm.
859
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
5.2.63 OSD Block , PID FOR STEAM Missing legend for the used valves, sensors and instrumentations
DISTRIBUTION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
859
5.2.64 OSD Block , COLD SOFT WATER Indicate the make- up water flow rates for the chillers and heating system
DISTRIBUTION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
860
5.2.65 OSD Block , COLD SOFT WATER Indicate the flow rate of the main headers, and change the unit of the flow rate
DISTRIBUTION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- from l/ shift to l/hr for checking the pipe sizes
860
5.2.66 Waste treatment plant Missing design, drawings and tender documents for the waste treatment plant

5.2.67 Site works Missing design, drawings and tender documents for the site domestic, drainage and
irrigations works
5.2.68 Site works Missing design, drawings and tender documents for the domestic, irrigation and fire
fighting tanks and their associated pump rooms
5.2.69 OSD Block , P & I DIAGRAM FOR HSD Provide calculations for the head of the HSD pumps
547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
865
5.2.70 OSD Block , P & I DIAGRAM FOR HSD Missing site plan drawings for the location of the fuel tanks, HSD pump room, filling
547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- point, pipe network, etc.
865
5.2.71 OSD Block , P & I DIAGRAM FOR HSD Provide calculations for the size of the main and daily HSD tanks
547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
865
5.2.72 OSD Block , P & I DIAGRAM FOR HSD Missing drawings for the fuel supply system of the diesel generator
547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
865
5.2.73 OSD Block , P & I DIAGRAM FOR HSD Missing the fire fighting works (foam system) serving the above ground tank , check
547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- using underground fuel tank instead
865
5.2.74 OSD Block , PID FOR PROCESS Provide mass and heat balance calculations for the two hot water generators.
MACHINE SYSTEM 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
867
5.2.75 OSD Block , BOILER HOUSE Indicate the usage of elevated feed water tank, while the PID drawing (547-P-1-
EQUP.LOCATION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- DCPL-UT-D-858 ) indicates the usage of feed water pumps to serve the boiler
812

5.2.76 OSD Block , BOILER HOUSE Missing steam, condensate , feed water & HSD piping layouts within the boiler plant
EQUP.LOCATION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
812
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
5.2.77 OSD Block ,BOILER HOUSE Missing location of the steam manifold, daily HSD tank, pumps, feed water service
EQUP.LOCATION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D- tank, feed water pumps within the boiler plant layout
812
5.2.78 OSD Block , BOILER HOUSE Missing boiler blow down, drainage system for the boiler room
EQUP.LOCATION 547-P-1-DCPL-UT-D-
812
5.2.79 OSD Block , TENDER DOCUMENT 547-UT-TD-BOL-042 The tender document for the boilers indicate two boilers ( one operating and one
FOR BOILER stand by), while the design drawings indicate only one working boiler and one for
future.

5.2.80 OSD Block , TENDER DOCUMENT 547-UT-TD-BOL-042 The tender document for the boilers indicates that the capacity of the feed water
FOR BOILER tank is 3m3, while the design drawings indicate 1.5 m3 tank capacity.
5.2.81 OSD Block , UTILITY CONSUMPTION 547-UT-CL-MCH-001 Justify the 68 m3 raw water storage based on the number of persons and value
SHEET mentioned in the design report of 100 liter/ day/ capita
5.2.82 OSD Block , UTILITY CONSUMPTION 547-UT-CL-MCH-001 Indicate the irrigation system requirements.
SHEET
5.2.83 OSD Block , UTILITY CONSUMPTION 547-UT-CL-MCH-001 Provide calculations for the soft water requirements of the boilers and PW
SHEET generation system
5.2.84 OSD Block , UTILITY CONSUMPTION 547-UT-CL-MCH-001 Justify the shown compressed air flow rate for the boiler, ETP and chiller plants
SHEET
5.2.85 OSD Block , UTILITY CONSUMPTION Provide calculations table for the condensate pipe sizing
SHEET 547-UT-CL-MCH-001
5.2.86 OSD Block , COMPRESSED AIR PIPE Recheck the calculated pipe sizes for the compressed air piping based on 87 psi
SIZE CALCULATION 547-UT-CL-MCH-002 pressure
5.2.87 OSD Block , HVAC CHILLED WATER For the chilled water pipe sizing, while the gpm/ T.R is not a constant value, since
PIPE SIZE CALCULATION 547-UT-CL-MCH-007 the same chilled water temperature difference is used for all equipment/ AHUs

5.2.88 Security block Missing domestic water plan for the security block
5.2.89 Security block Missing isometric layout for the toilets details
5.2.90 Security block, drawing Show the termination points of the drainage / vent stacks on the roof floor, use roof
547-SE-PG-151 vent caps
5.2.91 Security block, drawing The storm pipe to be terminated with spout nozzle for free discharge
547-SE-PG-151
5.2.92 scrap yard building Missing plumbing works drawings for the scrap yard building
5.2.93 security block Missing plumbing works drawings for the security block
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
5.2.94 pump room Missing plumbing works drawings for the pump room
5.2.95 solvent store Missing plumbing works drawings for the solvent store
5.2.96 sceco building Missing storm drainage works drawings for the sceco building
5.2.97 general Missing installation details for roof drainage points, floor drainage points, cleanouts,
toilet fixtures installations, inspection chambers, manholes filters, irrigation system
details, etc.

5.2.98 site works Missing irrigation works calculations


5.2.99 Site works Missing water metering strategy

6 FIRE PROTECTION
6.1 HIGH LEVEL COMMENTS
6.1.1 All buildings Missing fire fighting drawings, riser diagrams for all the buildings
6.1.2 Site works Missing fire fighting drawings for the site works
6.1.3 Fire fighting pump room Missing fire fighting pump room drawing, schedules and details

6.2 DETAILED COMMENTS


6.2.1 All buildings Missing fire fighting drawings, riser diagrams for all the buildings
6.2.2 Site works Missing fire fighting drawings for the site works
6.2.3 Fire fighting pump room Missing fire fighting drawings for all the buildings

7 MECHANICAL DESIGN
REPORT

7.1 Design report Replace the FM200 clean agent system by the NOVEC 1230 system (page-77)

7.2 Design report Provide fire fighting hydraulic calculations using computerized software

7.3 Design report Replace the C02 flooding system in the generator room by the foam system (page-
81)
S. N. Title Dwg No. Description & Comments
7.4 Design report Replace the C02 flooding system in the electrical substation room by the NOVEC
1230 total flooding system (page-81)
7.5 Design report Provide detailed site storm drainage report including the design return period,
surface run off calculations using the rational method, IDF curves, evaporation rate,
soil permeability, water depth, etc.

7.6 Design report Provide the measures done within the design to achieve the STRATEGY FOR
SUSTANABLE DEVELOPMENT
Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?

Ok. We will modify and revert Indore (Rajiv and team)

Indore (Ashish Jadhav and HVAC


team)
Ok we will provide Mumbai (Nidhi)

Providing justification note for our Mumbai (Nidhi)


excel sheet
Ok we will provide Indore (Ashish Jadhav and HVAC
team)
Ok we will provide Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok we will provide Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok we will provide Indore (Ashish Jadhav and HVAC


team)
Ok we will provide Indore (Ashish Jadhav and HVAC
team)
Ok we will provide Indore (Ashish Jadhav and HVAC
team)
Ok we will provide Indore (Ashish Jadhav and HVAC
team)
Ok we will provide Indore (Ashish Jadhav and HVAC
team)
Ok we will provide Indore (Ashish Jadhav and HVAC
team)
Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will revise and resubmit. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Y-strainers are provided before Indore (Rajiv and team)


pumps and Air seperator will be
provided before chiller inlet.

We will attach calculation sheet for Indore (Rajiv and team)


your reference.
Discharge duct from air compressor Indore (Rajiv and team)
will be shown after receipt of
finalised GAD.

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)

Justification note attached for your Mumbai (Nidhi)


reference,
Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)


Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)


Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)


Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)
Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Nidhi)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Dhananjay)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)


Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)


Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)
Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)


Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)


Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)


Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)
Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)


Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)


Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)


Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)


Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)
Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Sharad and team)

IT is a storage room for gas cylinders


of Nitrogen, Oxygen, Argon, Helium
and Zero air. These gases are
required in QC laboratory.

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)


Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

This will be a part of the air Indore (Rajiv and team)


compressor itself hence it is not
provided.

Moisture eliminator is included in Indore (Rajiv and team)


the part of air compressor.
Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

This is a typographical error. We will Indore (Rajiv and team)


revise and resubmit.
This is a typographical error. We will Indore (Rajiv and team)
revise and resubmit.
Pressure regulators in the form of
air flow regulators are provided
wherever applicable. Also for
equipment they will be a part of
equipment manufacturer's scope.
Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

SOPT is steam operated pumping


trap
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Dhananjay)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

No. This is not required since we will be using Carbon stee

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Dhananjay)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)


Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Mumbai (Dhananjay)

The boiler requires feed water at


high pressure, hence the usage of
multi stage pumps. Also the pumps
require a flooded suction hence the
feed water tank is kept at an
elevated level.

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)


Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)


Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)


Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)
Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)


Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)


Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)


Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)
Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

These will be provided by the


firefighting contractor as he will be
getting it verified from a third party.

Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)


Work to be done by which Remark
DCPL Reply DCPL office?
Ok. We will revise and resubmit Indore (Rajiv and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)

Ok. We will provide the details. Indore (Sharad and team)