Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Table 1 : Risk factors for VTE Jain et al6 conducted a prospective study in post – surgical
Surgery patients with total knee (26 patients) and hip arthroplasty (45
Trauma (major trauma or lower – extremity injury) patients), and showed a very low incidence (2/71) of DVT. They
Immobility, lower – extremity paresis concluded that the incidence of DVT in Indian patients is very
Cancer (active or occult) low in comprasion to west and emphasized the fact that no
Cancer therapy (hormonal, chemotherapy, angiogenesis inhibitors, radio- thromboprophylaxis is needed in Indian patients undergoing total
therapy) Hip / Knee arthroplasty if they have no known risk factors for
Venous compression (tumor, hematoma, arterial abnormality) DVT.Vijayraghavan et al7 did a retrospective study on DVT in the
Previous VTE South Indian population and showed an incidence of 1.79 / 1,000
Increasing age population.Agarwal et al8 conducted a study in patients undergoing
Pregnancy and the postpartum period total hip / knee arthroplasty and revealed an overall incidence of
Estrogen-containing oral contraceptives or hormone replacement therapy DVT in 60% cases in the non prophylaxis group. This data was
Selective estrogen receptor modulators comparable to the date from other parts of Asia and West and
Erythropoiesis-stimulating agents emphasized the need of thromboprophylaxis. The Smart Study
Acute medical illness Group9 conducted a prospective observational study on Asian
Inflammatory bowel disease
patients (2420 Patients) undergoing major orthopaedic surgery
Nephrotic syndrome
without thromboprophylaxis and revelaed symptomatic VTE in
Myeloproliferative disorders
2.3% patients and sudden death in 1.2% patients. Prospective
Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria
Obesity
registry on venous thromboembolic events (PROVE)10 conducted
Central venous catheterization in 19 countries enrolled 3526 patients with symptomatic DVT, out
Inherited or acquired thrombophilia of which 667 were from India. DVT was found proximally and in
the calf in 54% of Indian patients which is comparable to western
Source : American College of Chest Physicians evidence based clinical
date. Sharma et al11 in a prospective study of 112 patients who
practice guidelines (8th Edition), Chest 2008 : 133 : 381S – 453S.
underwent surgery for fractures around hip joint found a 19.6%
of procoagulant factors (Fibrinogen, prothrombin, factor VIII, IX, of incidence of DVT. A prospective study conducted in PGIMER
XI), increased basal procoagulant activity, impaired fibrinolysis and , Chandigarh by Nagi et al12, revealed 8% incidence of DVT after
increased basal innate immunity activity and reactivity predisposes major orthopaedic surgery.
to thrombosis (thrombophilia). Inherited thrombophilias interact Bhan et al 13, in a multicentric study, found an incidence of 23.34% of
with clinical risk factors (eg. Pregnancy, hormone therapy, surgery) DVT in the nonprophylaxis group as compared to nil in the group
to increase the risk of incident thromboembolism. Genetic which received mechanical prophylaxis. Lee et al14 conducted
interaction increases the incidence of incident and recurrentVTE5. a retrospective study in CMC Vellore from (1996-2005) to
determine the incidence of VTE among hospitalized patients and
Western Scenario showed an overall incidence of confirmed DVTs to be 17.46
per 10,000 admissions with 64% being non surgical non trauma
VTE among whites is 108 per 100,000 person-years with about
patients. PE was diagnosed in 14.9% of the study patients. Mortality
250,000 incident cases occurring annually among US whites. The
in those with confirmed PE was 13.5%.A recently published study
incidence appears to be similar or higher among Blacks and lower
from Dept. of Medicine, AIIMS, New Delhi by Pandey et al15, 75%
among ASIAN and Native Americans. The incidence among US
of the patients admitted to Medicine ward and medicine ICU had
– Blacks is about 78 per 100,000, suggesting that about 27000
the highest risk for DVT and PE. Only 12.5% had DVT prophylaxis
incident VTE cases occur annually among US Blacks. Recent data
within first two days of admission. They emphasized the need to
suggests that more than 900 000 incident or recurrent, fatal and
aggressively implement DVT risk stratification strategy in medical
non fatal VTE occur in the US annually. The incidence of VTE has
patients and provide prophylaxis unless contraindicated. Shead et
not changed significantly over the last 25 years5.
al16 found a 28% incidence of post operative DVT in 50 paients
above 50 years of age in South India.
Indian Scenario
Autopsy provides the final diagnosis of PE. Shead et al16 showed
The prevailing belief that VTE in the ASIAN population is less
major PE to have occurred in 1.9% cases in a retrospective
than in the western population has been disproved by recent
analysis of autopsy examination performed on 432 patients dying
studies and there appears no reason to believe that it should
postoperatively and stressed on the disproportion between
be any different in India. The incidence of VTE in India is highly
the frequent occurrence of post operative DVT and the low
underestimated because of lack of adequate studies highlighting
incidence of PE at autopsy. In the study by Kakkar and Vasishta17
the incidence of VTE especially in medical patients, existence of
the overall incidence of PE in medical autopsies (all three groups
a few but conflicting studies in post surgical patients and paucity
– fatal, contributory and incidental) was 15.9%. Incidence of PE
of data from autopsied patients as autopsy is being done in very
contributing significantly to the death of the patient (fatal and
few institutions in India.
contributory) was 12.6% . Thus PE very significantly contributed
330
Venous Thromboembolism- Indian Perspective
Table 2 : Wells Prediction Rule for Diagnosing DVT : Table 3 : Wells Prediction Rule for Diagnosing Pulmo-
Clinical Evaluation Table for Predicting Pretest Prob- nary Embolism : Clinical Evaluation Table for Predicting
ability of DVT*. Pretest Probability of Pulmonary Embolism*
Clinical Characteristics Score Clinical Characteristics Score
Active cancer (treatment ongoing, within previous 6 months, or 1 Previous pulmonary embolism or deep venous thrombosis +1.5
palliative) Heart rate > 100 beats per minute + 1.5
Paralysis,paresis, or recent plaster immobilization of the lower 1 Recent surgery or immobilization +1.5
extremities Clinical signs of deep venous thrombosis +3
Recently bedridden >3 days or major surgery within 12 weeks 1 Alternative diagnosis less likely than pulmonary embolism +3
requiring general or regional anesthesia. Hemoptysis +1
Localized tenderness along the distribution of the deep venous 1 Cancer +1
system
* Clinical probability of pulmonary embolism : low, 0-1; intermediate, 2-6;
Entire leg swollen 1
high, >7, Reprinted from Am J. Med. 2002; 113 : Chagnon I, Bounameaux H,
Calf swelling 3 cm larger than asymptomatic side (measured 10 cm 1
Aujesky D, et al, Comaprision of two clinical prediction rules and implicit
below tibial tuberosity)
assessment among patients with suspected pulmonary embolism 269-275.
Pitting edema confined to the symptomatic leg 1
Collateral superficial veins (nonvaricose) 1 low pretest probability of DVT or PE, obtaining a high sensitivity D-dimer
Alternative diagnosis at least as likely as deep venous thrombosis -2 is a reasonable option, and if negative indicate a low likelihood of VTE.
* Clinical probability : low, <0; intermediate, 1-2 high, >3. In patients with Recommendation - 3 :Ultrasound is recommended for patients
symptoms in both legs, the more symptomatic leg is used. Reprinted from. with intermediate to high pretest probability of DVT in the lower
Wells PS, Anderson DR, Bormanis J, et al.Value assessment of pretest prob-
extremeties.
ability of deep-vein thrombosis in clinical management. The lancet 1997;
351 : 1795-8. Recommendation-4 : Patients with intermediate or high pretest
probability of PE require diagnostic imaging studies.
to death in 79.24% (126/159) of above group of patients. Bergqvist
Thromboprophylaxis : Almost all hospitalized patients have
and Lindblad18 found an incidence of 23.6% PE at autopsy in surgical
at least one risk factor forVTE, and approximately 40% have three
patients half of whom were not operated upon. Rubenstein et al19
or more risk factors.Without thromboprophylaxis, the incidence
found an incidence of 3.4% (Fatal and contributory) at autopsy
of objectively confirmed, hospital acquired DVT is shown in
in medical patients. Stein et al20 found an incidence of 0.23% of
Table -425. The mortality, acute and long term morbidities and
acute pulmonary embolism in tertiary care general hospital but
resource utilization related to unpreventedVTE strongly supports
a previous study by Datta et al21 from the same institute found
for effective preventive strategies at least for moderate to high
an incidence of 3.1% at autopsy, but their study was purely based
risk patients25. Evidence based consensus guideline for VTE
on gross morbid anatomical analysis only. Antemortem diagnosis
prophylaxis have been available for more than 15 years, despite
of PE has been poor in various studies carried out in different
which VTE prophylaxis remains under-used globally2.According to
parts of the world22,23. Kakkar and Vasistha17 found that PE affected
ENDORSE Study2 of hospitals from 32 countries worldwide,about
younger population as 79.87% of the overall patients, 66.67% of
65% of surgical patients and 42% of medical patients were found
the fatal group and 73% of combined group. This is incontrast
to be at risk of VTE, however only 59% of surgical and less than
to western studies where young adults or adolescents were
half (40%) of medically ill patients received thromboprophylaxis.
occasionally affected.
In India, while a comparable portion (45%) of medical in- patients
were found to be at risk, only 19% received thromboprophylaxis.
Diagnosis of VTE & PE
There is increased use ofVTE thromboprophylaxis among surgical
It is difficult to establish an accurate diagnosis of VTE because of patients than medical patients worldwide because of several
its nonspecific history, and clinical findings and the lack of simple, reasons.According to Pandey et al15 from AIIMS, New Delhi, 75% of
conclusive, low cost , low risk test for establishing a diagnosis. the patients admitted to the medicine ward and medical ICU had
Major PE remains undiagnosed in around 40 – 70% cases because the highest risk of DVT & PE but only 12.5% had DVT prophylaxis
of such reasons. A clinical practice guideline from the American within first two days of admission.Within two weeks of admission,
Academy of Family Physicians and the American College of 30.8% of patients were discharged, and 16.2% died. 72.6% of the
Physicians summarize, the current approaches for the diagnosis patients still in the wards belonged to the highest risk category.
of VTE / PE 24.
Recommendation 1: Validated clinical prediction rules should be
Rationale for Thromboprophylaxis :
used to estimate pretest probability of VTE, both DVT and PE and for The rationale for use of thromboprophylaxis is based on solid
the basis of interpretation of subsequent tests. principles and scientific evidences (Table 5)25.
Recommendation 2 : In appropriately selected patients with
331
Medicine Update 2010 Vol. 20
332
Venous Thromboembolism- Indian Perspective
therapy is not recommended (Grade IB). Indian sub-continent is underestimated. Indian scenario is very
much like that of the western scenario. Despite solid scientific
2. In acute DVT /PE, initial treatment with LMWH, UFH, or
evidences, VTE prophylaxis remain under- used even in premier
Fondaparinux for at least 5 days rather than a shorter
institutes. Hospital wide strategies to assess patients’ VTE risk
period is recommended (grade I C) and initiation of vita-
should be implemented, together with measures that ensure that
min K antagonists (VKAs) together with LMWH, UFH, or
at-risk patients receive appropriate VTE prophylaxis.
fondaparinux on the first treatment day and discontinua-
tion of these heparin preparations when the INR is > 2.0
REFERENCES :
for at least 24 hrs (Grade IA).
1. Agarwal S, Lee AD, Raju RS, Stephen E : Venous Thromboembolism :
3. For patients of DVT / PE secondary to a transient risk factor A problem in the Indian / Asian population ? Indian J. Urol 2009 : 25 :
(reversible), treatment with a Vit K antagonist for 3 months 11 – 16.
is recommended (Grade IA) and then all patients are evalu- 2. Cohen AT, Tapson VF, Bergmann JF et al :Venous thromboembolism risk
ated for the risks to benefits of indefinite therapy (Grade and prophylaxis in the acute hospital care setting (ENDORSE Study);
a multinational cross-sectional study, Lancet 2008; 371 : 387 – 94. Er-
IC). Indefinite anticoagulation therapy is recommended for ratrum in : Lancet 2008 : 371 : 1914.
first unprovoked proximal DVT or PE and low risk of bleed- 3. Deitcher SR, Rodgers GM :Thrombosis and antithrombotic therapy : In
ing when this is consistent with patients preference (Grade : Greev JP, Foerster J, Rodgers GM et al. eds wintrobes clinical Haema-
IA) and for most patients with a second unprovoked DVT tology 12th Edition, Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins, 2009 : 1464-1508.
(Grade IA). 4. Parakh R., Somaya A,Todi SK. : Consensus Development Recommenda-
tions for the Role of LMWH in prophylaxis of venous thromboem-
4. Dose of VKA be adjusted to maintain a target INR of 2.5 bolism : An Indian perspective, supplement of JAPI : 2007; 55; (Suppl)
(INR range 2.0 – 3.0) for all treatment durations (Grade IA) 5 – 30.
5. Heit J.A. : The Epidemiology of venous thromboembolism in the Com-
5. For prevention of post thrombotic syndrome (PTS) after munity; Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis and vascular Biology 2008 ; 28:
proximal DVT, use of an elastic compression stocking is rec- 370-372.
ommended (Grade IA). 6. Jain V, Dhoan BK, Jaiswal A et al : DVT after total hip and knee arthro-
plasty in Indian patients. Postgrad Med J. 2004;. 80; 729-31.
6. For DVT of upper extremity, similar treatment as for DVT
7. Vijayraghwan KS, Sharma S, Pai VM et al : DVT in South Indian Popula-
of leg is recommended (Grade IC). tion. Indian Journal of Surgery 2001 : 63 : 199 – 201.
7. Selected patients with lower extremity (Grade 2B) and up- 8. Agarwal S, Bhagat A, Modhe JM et al : Incidence of DVT in Indian Pa-
tientn : A prospective study in 104 patients : Indian J. Ortho. 2003 : 37
per extremity (Grade 2 C) DVT, thrombus removal using : 159 – 162.
catheter based thrombolytic techniques may be considered.
9. Leizorovicz A et al. For the SMART study group; Epidemiology of ve-
8. For extensive superficial vein thrombosis, treatment with nous thromboembolism in Asian patients undergoing major orthopae-
dic surgery without thromboprophylaxis.The SMART study. J.Thrombo
prophylactic or intermediate doses LMWH or intermediate Haemost 2005 : 3 : 28 – 34.
doses UFH for 4 weeks is recommended (Grade IB). 10. Pinjala RK, Agarwal MB, Turpie AGG : A Characterisation of patients
with symptomatic DVT in India; for PROVE investigators ; J. Thromb
ROLE OF STATINS IN PREVENTION OF VTE27: Haemost 2005 : 3 : 1043.
11. Sharma H, Maini L, Agarwal N et al : Incidence of Deep vein Thrombosis
Jupiter trial, a randomized trial reveals that rosuvastatin (20mg in patients with fracture around hip joint. A prospective study. Indian J.
/ day) was associated with a significant reduction in the risk of Orthop 2002 : 36 : 157 -9.
VTE, an independent benefit of statin use. During a median follow 12. Nagi ON, Dhillon MS, Katariya S. et al. DVT after major surgery : Evalu-
up period of 1.9 years (maximum 5 years) the rates of VTE were ation by compression ultrasonography : Indian. J. – Orthop 1993 : 33 :
0.18 and 0.32 events per 100 person – years in rosuvastatin and 200 – 203.
placebo groups respectively. The rates of PE were 0.09 and 0.12 13. Bhan S, Dhaon BK, Gulati Y, Aggawal S; DVT prophylaxis : A multicentric
study : Indian J Orphtop 2004 : 38 : 178 – 82.
events per 100 person years in the rosuvastatin and placebo
groups respectively. Rosuvastatin apart from its favourable lipid 14. Lee AD, Stephen E, Agarwal S, Premkumar P : Venous – Thromboem-
bolism in India : Eur. J.Vasc. Endovasc surg : 2009 : 37 (4) : 482 – 485.
profile and anti-inflammatory properties inhibits isoprenylation of
15. Pandey A, Patni N, singh M, Guleria R. : Assessment of Risk and pro-
signalling proteins, reduces tissue factor expression and thrombin phylaxis for DVT and PE in medically, ill patients during their early days
generation, attenuates fibrinogen cleavage and activation of factor of hospital stay at a tertiary care centre in a developing country: Vasc.
V &VII. Statins augment the activity of transcription factor Kruppel Health risk manag 2009 : 5 : 643-648.
- like factor 2 (KLF-2) promoting thrombomodulin expression on 16. Shead GV, Narayanan R. Incidence of Post-operative venous thrombo-
endothelial cells, thereby enhancing the activity of the protein-C embolism in South India. Br. J. Surg 1980 : 67 : 813-814.
– anticoagulant pathway. 17. Kakkar N, Vasishta RK : Pulmonary embolism in medical patients : An
autopsy based study; Clinical Applied Thrombosis / Hemostasis 2008 :
14 (2) : 159 – 67.
CONCLUSION 18. Bergqvist D, Lindblad B : Embolism verified at autopsy : An analysis of
VTE is a major public health issue globally. Incidence of VTE in the 1274 surgical patients : Br. J. Surg 1988 : 72 : 2 : 105-108.
333
Medicine Update 2010 Vol. 20
19. Rubinstein I, Murray D, Hoffstein V : Fatal Pulmonary embolism in hos- 24. Qaseem A, Snow V, Barry P. et al : Current diagnosis of Venous Throm-
pitalized patients. An autopsy study. Arch intern med 1988 : 148 : 1425 boembolism in primary care : A clinical practice guideline from the
– 26. American Academy of Family physicians and the American College of
20. Stein PD, Huang HL, Afzal A, Noor HA : Incidence of Acute pulmonary Physicans. Ann. Fam Med 2007 : 5 : 57-62.
embolism in a general hospital. Relation to age, sex and race. Chest 25. Geerts WH, Bergqvist D, Pineo GF et al : Prevention of VTE, American
1999 : 116 (4) 903 – 913. College of Chest Physicians Evidence – Based Clinical Practice Guide-
21. Datta BN, Ramesh K, Bhusnurmath B. Autopsy incidence of pulmonary lines (8th Edition) : CHEST 2008 : 133 : 381 S – 453S.
vascular episodes. A study of 218 cases. Angiology 1986 : 37 : 744 – 50. 26. Kearon C; Kahn SR, Agnelli G. et al : Antithrombotic therapy for venous
22. Macintyre IMC, Buckley CV : Pulmonary embolism – a clinical and au- thromboembolic disease, ACCP Evidence based clinical practice guide-
topsy study. Scott Med J. 1974 : 19 : 20-24. lines (8th edn) CHEST 2008 : 133 : 454S – 545S.
23. Sandritteer W, staeudinger M, Drexier H. Autopsy and clinical diagnosis 27. Glynn RJ, Danielson E, Fonseca FAH et al : A randomized trial of Ro-
: Pathol. Res pract 1980 : 168 : 107-4. zuvastatin in the prevention of VTE; NEJM – 2009 : 360 : 1851 – 1861.
334