Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Name of Lecturer: Dr. Woo Kwan Kit, Dr. Ong Ying Hui
Jetropha oil can be extracted from the seeds by three ways: mechanically, chemically and
enzymatically. Oil press method can be done by either powered or manually driven mechanical
device for the purpose of oil extraction. The most commonly used press is Bielenberg ram press
which can extract 60-65% of the oil among the different oil presses. Oil expeller is one of the
methods to extract oil. The Sayari oil expeller and the Komet Expeller are the conventional types
of oil expeller. The Sayari expeller is a device which operates using diesel while Komet expeller
is a single-screw oil expeller. In less developed area, the traditional method which is using simple
equipment by hand to extract the oil from the seeds is still employed. Other than that, hot oil
extraction that requires high pressure is introduced to extract oil from seeds. Then cold oil
extraction method is practiced to extract the oil from hot oil extraction because high viscosity
allows the oil flow easily.
Figure 1.2: Equipment design for Hexane Solvent Extraction and Recycle
In this modern era, aqueous enzymatic treatment is a chemical method to increase the
amount of Jetropha oil that can be extracted. Hexane is chosen as a chemical in the close system
which is batch-wise operation. Before hexane is add into the reactor, Jetropha seeds will be grinded
up to increase the surface area which will expose to hexane solvent. The seeds and solvent will be
allowed to contact for approximate 20 minutes. The wet seed cake which contains remaining
hexane will be sent to rotary dryer whereas miscella will be transported to stripper for hexane
recovery. The wet seed cake is dried by the steam produced from boiler, followed by sent to
incinerator. The vapour consists of hexane will be condensed and collected into a decanter.
To recover the hexane content from the miscella, stripper is used by allow two streams,
miscella and steam stream enter into stripper. Owing to different boiling point of hexane and seed
oil, the hexane is vapourise first before seed oil. The remaining product remained in the mixture
is seed oil that will be pumped to storage tank. The vapourised hexane will be condensed and
collected into the decanter where hexane and water will be separated base on difference in densities.
Water is excreted to sewer whereas hexane is recycled back to the process in order to save the cost.
Most of the industry prone to use a base catalyzed reaction with methanol and sodium
hydroxide (NaOH) for applications of transesterification. The reason choosing this reaction is
because acid catalyst mechanism involves high heat and time-consuming. Before adding the
mixture into the process, NaOH is dissolved in the methyl alcohol. NaOH not only could
deprotonate the alcohol before insertion into medium but simplifies the mixture of base catalyst
into the immiscible Jetropha oil. There are many chemical equation involved in the conversion of
biodiesel. The equation of alcohol mixture adding into the Jetropha oil involves:
The equation of carbonyl group being attracted by a positive charge on the triglyceride is as shown
in Figure 1.3.
Figure 1.3: Equation of carbonyl group with triglyceride.
After the reaction, the unstable tetrahedral intermediate breaks into an ester and a di-glycerol. The
equation proceeds as follows in Figure 1.4:
In the end, this process is repeated with two more carbonyl group to produce two additional esters
and a glycerol. The equation is shown in Figure 1.5:
Figure 1.7: Properties of the Jetropha oil used for biodiesel production
Figure 1.8: Standard specification of Jetropha oil
Figure 1.10: Properties of POME are within the biodiesel America standards ASTM and
European Standards EN.
Catalyst for the reaction is prepared by mixing methanol and a strong alkaline such as sodium
hydroxide (NaOH) or potassium hydroxide (KOH). The OH ion of base abstracts the hydrogen
ion from the methanol to form water molecules and let the CH3O- available for the reaction. The
methanol must be as dry as possible in order to prevent side-reaction product which is unwanted.
Present of water will possibly make a side-reaction occurred that form soap. Following diagram
are the side-reaction of trans-esterification process.
After the catalyst is prepared, the reaction of palm oil molecule (triglyceride) will react with the
methanol. Excess methanol was used to ensure complete reaction due to it was the limiting
reagent. The 3 attached carbon with hydrogen react with OH- ions form glycerine and the CH3
group react with free palm oil molecule to form POME.
Figure 1.13: Quantity of chemical reactant needed for the trans-esterification process.
The diagram above shows the quantity of chemical reactant needed for the trans-esterification
process. Excess methanol (about 2times theoretical value) are required in order to achieve
complete reaction. Normally the reaction take place at temperature between 45-60°C and 1-4
hours for reaction time. The higher the reaction temperature will use shorter reaction time to
complete the reaction. Due to the methanol will evaporate at temperature above 65°C, if the
process wants to operating above the temperature a pressure vessel is required and instalment of
the vessel will also help to increase the methanol to oil molar ratio.
The following diagram shows the production of POME in industry scale. The glycerol formed
during reaction have to be removed from the production. Water is added into both glycerol and
POME to removed unwanted product which is glycerol and the water will evaporate and
removed from POME inside separator. To neutralized the unwanted product (glycerol), acid is
added in neutralizer for neutralisation process of the glycerol.
Figure 1.14: Process flow for neutralisation process of the glycerol.
The process by produce POME using supercritical methanol is known as Supercritical process.
The process is catalyst-free and use supercritical methanol at high temperature and pressure. In
supercritical state, the alcohol and oil are under single phase to make the reaction occurs rapidly.
This process method can tolerate water in the feedstock and no side-reaction occurred that form
unwanted product.
Jetropha plant can grow on most of the climatic condition especially in Malaysia with constant
weather changes, relatively stable of humidity and temperature. The plant is drought resistant
which means it can withstand a period of time without water. It also has the ability to grow on
poor and infertile soil.
2) Low costing
The price of the jetropha seed is cheaper compare with another biofuel plant. No special step to
be taken during the cultivation of seed.
The jetropha seed have high oil content which means it can produce more amount of oil per seed
with the sufficient supplied of nutrient. Besides, it grows quickly which means it can be harvest a
few times a year than harvest annually.
The plant can sustain for 50 years to be harvest which can maximize the profit tremendously
compare with the initial seed investment.
Disadvantages:
1) Host for disease
The rust on the leaf and root on the jetropha plant is found to be the suitable as the host of
disease such as African cassava mosaic virus(ACMV), anthracnose (Colletotrichum
gloeosporioides) and so on. This disease will infect other plant as well and causing the massive
changes on the botanical ecology.
2) Poisonous by-products
Jetropha plant has poisonous fruit and seeds which has no future processing value after
extracting the oil. It is not suitable to ingest by organisms as it can cause diarrhea and nauses.
Plantation of Jetropha plant required larger space compare with other plant because of the size of
the plant is reaching 6m or more.
Although it is the plant that can withstand drought, but to make sure the stability of the oil
content, the water supplied must be enough to ensure the oil produce by the plant is maximize.
The factory or plant require higher investment than the plantation site because the process of
extracting the oil is very complicated and also the further process of detoxification of the
remaining seeds.
6) Food vs fuel
There is always the argument between plants for food or fuel. For examples, if originally the
corn is served as food sources all over the world, but now due to the production of bioethanol,
the large amount of corn are now used as fuel sources. The food prices will increase and the
hunger and malnutrition issues will become more serious.
Palm Oil Methyl Ester (POME)
Advantages:
1) Renewable resources
Unlike petroleum products that will vanish in years, biodiesel is a renewable energy which can
be produced from animal and vegetable fat.
Significantly reduced the GHGs (CO2, CO) up to 78% compare to petroleum diesel. Reduction
of GHGs also protect the environment from global warming.
3) Environmental friendly
Biodiesel is the only biofuel has successfully meet the emissions testing accordance with the
Clean Air Act. It is biodegradable which means the spillage of biodiesel is less harmful to the
environment and clean up job is easier.
4) Safer
Biodiesel is about ten times less toxic than table salt through the research found. It has a higher
flash point than conventional diesel. Thus, the storage and transportation is easer and safer.
Little or no modifications is required for the current diesel engine in order to use biodiesel.
Biodiesel can be either used with B100 (100% biodiesel) or blended with petroleum diesel.
Biodiesel has the properties of high fuel lubricity. It improve the engine lubrication and prolongs
the working life of the engines.
As the natural resources of crude oil are going to deplete in the near future, the development of
biodiesel is reducing the dependence on petroleum diesel.
Disadvantages:
1) Gelling effect in low temperature
The gel point of biodiesel is relatively low. This means biodiesel would not be likely used in the
cold climates countries. The fuel tank need heating to use the biodiesel in cold climates.
2) Food vs fuel
The biodiesel can be made from the animal or vegetable oil. It will affect the food oil supply in
the market if all the farmers plant the crops for biodiesel manufacturing. The oil prices will rise
up due to the supply shortage for food usage.
To produce more biodiesel, the more crops are needed to plant to meet the demand. There will be
more fertilizer used and lead to soil erosion and even land pollution or underground water
pollution.
From the researches, it was found that B20 mixtures can reduce the fuel efficiency by 1 to 2 %
which equal to 10 % reduction in power. It would need 1.1 gallons of biodiesel to equal 1 gallon
of standard diesel.
5) More expensive
As the increment of the price of the feedstock and the production problems cost, the biodiesel is
more expensive than the petroleum diesel.
Q3) Select the best among the two options for biofuel production in terms of:
The pilot run of these demonstrations must include the small and marginal farmers and
cultivators as these will act as a business enterprise that oversees soil, water, and other natural
resource system as well as crop management and business enterprise cluster creation. This
approach will allow the energy farm enterprise to explore different technology alternatives and
identify the best cultivation methods for Jetropha plantation management. Such demonstration
can also promote plant-based diesel farming and serve the energy needs of agricultural
communities, as well as provide rural employment and alternative income.
There is a lot of opportunity for this diesel fuel to be substitute the diesel like what is
taken place during WWII as the lack of production of diesel forces scientist to produce diesel
fuel substitute from seeds oil. But there is also some thread facing for plant based fuel especially
to Jetropha oil as the by product is toxic in nature and not suitable to make them as animal food.
Moreover, to substitute a country’s energy with biodiesel will be very high in the first few years
as the percentage of the country’s fuel supply will be not too high.
Unlike Jetropha oil, palm oil is facing the different challenging. Among them is the wide
uses of palm oil, this situation caused the choice of palm oil as an alternative for diesel more
challenging. Palm oil is now widely use as cooking oil and some food manufacturing. The
sudden increase in need on the need of palm oil will be a big impact on the palm oil industry and
causing the increase in palm oil pricing which might affect the whole economic as it is consider
one of the main in food source.
In order to commercialise the biodiesel, there are a few advices to be given in a nutshell.
First, there are still much work to be done in order to increase the efficiency of the extraction and
production of the biodiesel, and the process of treating the waster production. Besides, the
substitution of the diesel to biodiesel should be implement phrase by phrase to prevent the
sudden impact on the society. Moreover, the variety of possibility energy source of biodiesel
should be study and making the biodiesel of these variety to be as universal as possible. This
conversion will make the possibility of producing cheapest oil in different location with different
plant. Last but not least, the government and industries should look more closely in the situation
of biodiesel fuel and provide the necessary help in terms of money and skill.
For the Palm Oil Methyl Ester, there are currently 3 government body that make regulations and
make improvisation on the technology which is Malaysian Palm Oil Board (MPOB), Malaysian
Palm Oil Council (MPOC) and Palm Oil Research Institute of Malaysia (PORIM). Besides,
Federal Land Development Authority (FELDA, Lembaga Kemajuan Tanah Persekutuan) also
works with some companies included Sime Darby, Genting Plantations, IOI that own palm oil
plantation to increase the Palm Oil production in Malaysia. With the alliance of these body and
company, the price of palm oil is relatively stable throughout the years and increasing gradually.
From here, we can know that the management regards the palm oil in Malaysia is more complete
than Jetropha Oil. To transform our country from palm oil based to both oil share the biodiesel
market together, the are a lot of effort need to be done either in assist from government, standard
of the oil grade and so on. So that the Jetropha oil can meet the consumer or industrial required
standard and able to monetize and export to other country in the world.
Reference:
Buikema, B., Gabbadon, S., Lee, H. C., & Workman, M. Biodiesel Production from Seed Oil of
the Jatropha Curcas Plant.
Castro Gonzáles, N. (2016). International experiences with the cultivation of Jatropha curcas for
biodiesel production. Energy, 112, pp.1245-1258.
Folaranmi, J. (2013). Production of Biodiesel (B100) from Jatropha Oil Using Sodium
Hydroxide as Catalyst. Journal of Petroleum Engineering, 2013, pp.1-6.
Raja, S. A. (2011). Biodiesel production from jatropha oil and its characterization. Res J Chem
Sci, 1, 81-87.
Warra, A. (2012). Cosmetic potentials of physic nut (Jatropha curcas Linn.) seed oil: A
review. American Journal of Scientific and Industrial Research, 3(6), pp.358-366.
9.2 The Reaction of Biodiesel: Transesterification. (n.d.). Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
https://www.e-education.psu.edu/egee439/node/684
Advantages of Jatropha Plant, Bio diesel, Buy Oil, Fuel Jatropha Products. (n.d.). Retrieved
April 11, 2018, from http://www.aumkiipure.com/advantages-of-jatropha.html
Nazir, N., Mangunwidjaja, D., & Yarmo, M. A. (2012). Production of Biodiesel and Nontoxic
Jatropha Seedcakes from Jatropha curcas. Advanced Biofuels and Bioproducts,525-551.
doi:10.1007/978-1-4614-3348-4_23
Parawira, Wilson. (2010). Biodiesel production from Jatropha curcas: A review. Scientific
Research and Essays. 5. 1796-1808.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Biodiesel Fuel. (2017, June 08). Retrieved April 11, 2018,
from https://greentumble.com/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-biodiesel-fuel/
Thinking about Producing Palm Oil Biodiesel? (n.d.). Retrieved April 11, 2018, from
http://www.answers-to-your-biodiesel-questions.com/palm-oil-biodiesel.html
Yunus, S., Abdullah, N. R., Mamat, R., & Rashid, A. A. (2013). An overview of palm, jatropha
and algae as a potential biodiesel feedstock in Malaysia. IOP Conference Series: Materials
Science and Engineering,50, 012055. doi:10.1088/1757-899x/50/1/012055
Yunus, S., Yusoff, N., Khaidzir, M. F., Alias, S. K., Wong, F. R., Latip, S. A., & Rashid, A. A.
(2015). Engine Performance Investigations of Palm Oil, Jatropha Oil and Waste Cooking Oil as
Alternative Fuel. Advanced Materials Research,1113, 674-678.
doi:10.4028/www.scientific.net/amr.1113.674