Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 12
The next four chapters discuss issues associated with adaptation to the biological
environment of captive animals. Topics covered include feeding and drinking,
predation and infectious diseases/parasites, interaction with humans and the
social environment. This chapter begins with a general discussion of the transition
from nature to captivity and variation in captive environments. However, the
major focus of the chapter concerns issues related to feeding and drinking by
captive animals. Diet selection, methods of food delivery and feeding schedules
are discussed as well as experimental work developing more naturalistic feeding
regimes and methods for reducing competition for food. The chapter concludes
with a discussion of self-imposed food deprivation by animals newly introduced to
captivity.
105
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:30 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
96 Chapter 12
In nature, animals learn that their behavior can exact changes in the environ-
ment, often in a consistent and predictable manner. Consequently, they remain
motivated to respond to environmental stimuli. In contrast, captive animals have
fewer opportunities to learn that their behavior can modify their environment
and that the stimuli around them are subject to control (Mason, 1978). Under
such circumstances, captive animals often lack the experience to respond
optimally to novel stimuli and changes in their environment when they occur.
As a consequence, cognitive processes may develop differently in captivity than
in the wild (Carlstead, 1996).
106
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:30 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
tobacco hornworms (Manduca sexta) accepted host food plants that their wild coun-
terparts rejected, based on a change in the sensitivity of contact chemoreceptors.
When man provides food for captive animals, there is little incentive
for animals to exhibit optimal foraging strategies and energy-saving feeding
behaviors. Consequently, relaxed selection on such traits may follow. Gustafsson
et al. (1999a) and Andersson et al. (2001) examined the foraging behaviors of wild
and domestic (hybrid) pigs (S. scrofa) and chickens (G. domesticus), respectively, but
the results were equivocal. To a great extent, both wild and domestic strains
behaved in accordance with general predictions of optimal foraging theory.
107
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:30 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
98 Chapter 12
Fig. 12.1. Feeding selectivity of Japanese flounder larvae for Artemia prey
(open circles) and rotifers (solid circles) throughout the larval stage at 09.00 h
(Dou et al., 2000).
108
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:31 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
three- to fivefold greater than larvae fed the artificial diet. Enz et al. (2001) found
that whitefish larvae (Coregonus suidteri) fed live zooplankton grew significantly
larger than those fed frozen zooplankton. Larvae fed a commercial dry diet grew
as well as those fed frozen zooplankton, but mortality rates were considerably
higher (34% vs. 3%). Mischke and Morris (1998) showed that bluegill sunfish
larvae (Lepomis macrochirus), like many fish larvae, had to initially be fed a diet of
live brine shrimp (Artemia franciscana) to later grow and survive on a commercial
diet. The initial feeding of live prey may facilitate the ingestion, digestion and
assimilation of dry diets when subsequently offered and may be important in
activating proteolytic enzymes (see references cited in Mischke et al., 2001).
Hickman and Tait (2001) found that weaning New Zealand turbot larvae
(Colistium nudipinnis) from a natural, live food diet (Artemia) onto inert, manu-
factured feeds was a major hurdle in attempts to domesticate turbot for large-scale
commercial production in captivity. Hamlin and Kling (2001) describe the
sensitivity of larval haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) to the timing of weaning to
a formulated diet for commercial production. Survival was only 2.5–6.3% when
weaning was initiated between 14 and 35 days post-hatch, compared to 38%
survival for larvae maintained on live food throughout the study. When weaning
was initiated at 42 days, survival matched that of the live-food controls. Crawford
(1984, cited in Hart and Purser, 1996) reported 100% mortality of hatchery-
reared greenback flounder larvae, Rhombosolea tapirina, when abruptly weaned
from live food (Artemia) to an artificial diet. In contrast, Hart and Purser (1996)
found only 18% mortality when the larvae were gradually weaned from the live
Artemia diet to the artificial diet (provision of live feed is reduced and the supply of
artificial diet is increased) over a 10-day period starting at 23 days post-hatch.
Mortality increased to 62% by waiting until 58 days to initiate the 10-day weaning
process. The lack of a functional stomach or the lack of digestive enzymes prior to
20 days post-hatch prohibits feeding the artificial diet as the first feed. Waiting too
long to initiate the weaning process allows the larvae to physiologically adapt to
the uniform live diet, making the transition to the artificial diet more problematic.
Duration of the gradual weaning process (5, 10 or 20 days) had no effect on
survival, but growth rates improved with the longer weaning periods. Since
feeding a live diet is expensive, the 10-day weaning period was believed to be most
cost effective.
Brown et al. (1997) demonstrated that larval lumpfish (Cyclopterus lumpus)
ingested more food and grew faster when they were fed live prey intermittently
(two or three times per day) rather than the same total amount of prey fed
continuously. Savory (1974) demonstrated that feeding chicks (G. domesticus) their
food in pellets rather than as a mash reduced feeding time. Growth rates were
also improved, perhaps due to the reduced energy expended in feeding, or in the
case of Leghorns, improved digestibility. Deeming and Bubier (1999) noted that
the failure of captive ostrich chicks (Struthio camelus) to recognize food items (e.g.
pellets) is a frequent cause of starvation. The color of potential food items may
influence acceptability. Bubier et al. (1996) found that 9-day-old captive ostrich
chicks pecked at strips of green tape ten times more frequently than white tape,
109
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4409 - Price - Vouchers.vp
Tuesday, November 05, 2002 11:39:00 AM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
100 Chapter 12
while red, blue, black and yellow were largely ignored. An interest in white objects
may be related to the white urates (salts of uric acid) accompanying the feces
of adult birds (Deeming and Bubier, 1999). In the wild, young ostriches may be
inoculated with beneficial microflora through coprophagy.
Stereotypies exhibited by captive herbivores fed diets largely consisting of
concentrated feeds, which are rapidly consumed, appear to result from the lack
of opportunity to perform foraging, consumption and digestive behavior patterns
(Appleby and Lawrence, 1987; Terlouw et al., 1991). Baxter and Plowman (2001)
reported that increasing the fiber content of the diet of giraffes (Giraffa camelo-
pardalis) by feeding them hay resulted in increased time spent ruminating and
decreased time spent performing oral stereotypies (tongue-playing and repetitive
licking of walls, bars, trees, etc.) while feeding time did not significantly change,
suggesting that oral stereotypies may be connected to rumination rather than
feeding in this species.
110
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:31 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
Feeding Schedules
The timing of feeding events may influence the behavior of captive animals.
Bloomsmith and Lambeth (1995) showed that feeding fresh produce to captive
chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) on a predictable schedule (within a 30-min period)
four times a day resulted in more time inactive and a tendency towards greater
atypical behavior than feeding chimps on a more unpredictable schedule (within a
150-min period). Social interactions were not influenced by feeding schedule. The
predictable schedule appeared to encourage inactivity during the pre-feeding
period as if the animals were waiting for food to be delivered. Scheduling
of feeding times in zoos to facilitate public viewing may actually create an
undesirable situation in which visitors are more likely to see animals in an inactive
state or possibly engaged in atypical behaviors. Other studies have shown that
feeding captive animals on a predictable schedule may reduce social disturbances.
Carlstead (1986) demonstrated that domestic pigs (S. scrofa) fed on a regular
schedule each day were less aggressive towards one another than pigs fed on an
unpredictable schedule.
111
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:31 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
102 Chapter 12
Fig. 12.2. ‘Equiball’ feeding device for horses. (Photo courtesy of Natalie
Waran, University of Edinburgh, UK.)
more time engaged in feeding than dogs fed from bowls. Interestingly, repetitive
behaviors (including stereotypic behaviors such as jumping, circling and pacing)
were considerably less in the pens with hoppers. Anderson and Chamove (1984)
reported that providing macaque monkeys with litter in which to forage for grain
increased foraging behavior fivefold and reduced aggression within the group.
Shepherdson et al. (1990) noted that a captive kinkajou’s (Potos flavus) stereotypic
behavior was reduced tenfold by requiring it to search and climb for food hidden
in its enclosure.
Keepers of captive animals do not have to replicate the natural environment
of the species to provide a behaviorally relevant captive habitat (Markowitz,
1982). The principles of operant conditioning and behavioral engineering can be
used to create an environment that, although unnatural, provides the animal
with opportunity to exercise species-typical behavior patterns (Markowitz and
LaForse, 1987). The use of various operant conditioning devices (e.g. Skinner box)
to force animals to work to obtain food represents an acceptable and behaviorally
relevant management tool to assist many animal species in adapting to confine-
ment (Moore et al., 1975; Markowitz and Woodworth, 1978; Stevens, 1978). Such
feeding techniques provide captive animals with a biologically acceptable means
of adapting to relatively sterile environments while giving them greater control
over their living environment, a condition that has a natural intuitive appeal to
animal keepers. A number of researchers have demonstrated that captive animals
112
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:32 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
will work to obtain food that is otherwise freely available (Carder and Berkowitz,
1970; Duncan and Hughes, 1972; Inglis and Ferguson, 1986; Shepherdson et al.,
1993; Reinhardt, 1994). Carlstead et al. (1991) found that providing food snacks to
a captive American black bear (Ursus americanus) by a machine that automatically
dispensed food at variable intervals during the day was less successful in reducing
stereotypic behavior than when the animal had to search for snacks hidden in
manipulable exhibit furnishings (e.g. hollow logs, under rocks, etc.).
113
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:32 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
104 Chapter 12
resources and subordinate animals get what is left over. Boussiou (1970) showed
that differences in the feeding times of dominant and subordinate pairs of cattle
(B. taurus) are reduced when feeding troughs are partitioned to protect the head of
the subordinate animal (Fig. 12.3). Holmes et al. (1987) obtained a similar result
with horses (E. caballus) and demonstrated that a wire-mesh feed-trough partition,
which permits the subordinate to see the dominant animal at all times, is more
effective than a solid partition. Hamill et al. (2001, unpublished results) found that
impeding the vision of dominant horses using fine-mesh fly masks doubled the
feeding time of subordinate mares in close proximity. Huon et al. (1986) reported
that partitioned feed troughs did not reduce the aggressive behavior of feeding
chickens (G. domesticus) but feeding time was reduced by 36% and feed consump-
tion was lower (21%) relative to chickens feeding in unpartitioned feeders.
114
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:33 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
Fig. 12.4. Mean daily food consumption of male Norway rats trapped as adults
and forced to occupy activity wheels starting at 0, 4 and 25 weeks of age (Price
and Stehn, 1977). (A–D = pre-test; 1–7 = days in wheels; X–Z = post-test days.)
115
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4348 - Price.vp
Tuesday, October 29, 2002 12:06:34 PM
Color profile: Disabled
Composite Default screen
106 Chapter 12
in food consumption of both juvenile and adult rats placed in home cages rather
than wheels immediately after capture were similar to the animals immediately
placed in wheels. Rats trapped as juveniles consumed significantly more food per
unit body weight than rats trapped as adults, and gained more weight while in the
wheels. Bringing a wild Norway rat into captivity as a juvenile rather than an adult
had little influence on its response to being placed in the novel environment after
25 weeks in the laboratory. In a similar study, Price (1972) found that first-
generation captive-reared prairie deermice (P. m. bairdii) exhibited a reduction in
food consumption during the first 2 days of forced occupation of activity wheels,
whereas food consumption did not change for a comparable stock of deermice
20–25 generations removed from the wild. Reduced reactivity resulting from
relaxed and/or directed natural selection in captivity provided the best explana-
tion for the more rapid adaptation of the semi-domestic stock to their new living
quarters.
Conclusions
Selection and effective delivery of appropriate diets at each stage of development
is critical for the adaptation and well-being of animals in captivity. Accomplishing
this objective in new domesticates may require a thorough study of the species’
natural history and a degree of experimentation. Effective delivery of food
includes proper timing and predictable scheduling of meals to facilitate intake and
minimize social competition. Experimental feed delivery systems designed to
mimic naturalistic foraging and hunting strategies and increase feeding time
promise to improve the well-being of captive animals. Animal welfare may be
jeopardized by self-imposed food deprivation frequently displayed by wild-caught
animals when first brought into captivity.
116
Z:\Customer\CABI\A4348 - Price\A4409 - Price - Vouchers.vp
Tuesday, November 05, 2002 11:39:26 AM