Reference(year) Methodology Performance

Chazal et al.,2000 No. of Features: 128 ACAC = 89.8%

Features: ACSE = 86.5%
1.) Statistical features from RR ACSP =91.9%
Duration
2.) PSD of RR interval
3.) R-peak
4.) Spectrum of R-wave
Classifiers:
Linear Discriminants(LD)

Chazal et al.,2003 No. of Features: 88 ACAC = 90%

Features: ACSP =92.3\%$
1.) Statistical features OF EDRP
and RR duration ACSE = 86.4%
2.) PSD of RR interval
3.) R-peak PSD of EDR signal
Classifiers: LD, quadratic
discriminants(QD)

Chazal et al.,2004 No. of Features: 8 ACAC = 90%

Features: K-value=0.8
1.) Statistical features of EDRP
and RR duration
2.) PSD of RR interval
3.) R-peak PSD of EDR signal
Classifiers: LD

Babaeizdeh et al.,2010 Features: ACAC = 84.7%

Spectral Power in different ACSE = 76.7%
frequency ranges ACSP =89.6%
Classifiers:
Quadratic Classifier

Bsoul et al.,2011 No. of Features: 111 ACAC = 89.08%

Features: ACSE = 96.05%
1.) Daubechies DWT based F1 score = 0.9
Statistical features From
EDRP and HRV in time domain:
20
2.) From EDRP and HRV in
spectral domain: 91
Classifiers: Gaussian SVM

Xie and Minn,2012 No. of Features: 111 ACAC = 77.74%

Features: ACSE = 69.82%
1.) Statistical features in time ACSP=80.29%
domain:20
 2.) Statistical features in
spectral domain:91
Classifiers: Bagging with
Reduced Error Pruning Tree

Liu et al.,2012 No. of features: NM ACAC = 79.1%

Features: Hilbert Huang ACSE = 73.1%
Transform ACSP =71.2%

Kesper et al.,2012 No. of features: NM ACAC = 80.5%

Features:
Hilbert Huang transform
Statistical features in
spectral domain

Sadr and Chazal,2014 No. of features: 68 ACAC = 87.7%

Features: ACSE = 81.3%
1.) Statistical features in time ACSP=91.7%
and frequency domain 4
2.) Power Spectral density of RR
level:32
3.) Power spectral density of
EDR signal:32
Classifiers:
Extreme Learning machine
classifier (ELM)

Nguyenet al.,2014 No. of features: 32 ACAC = 83.77%

Features: ACSE = 86.37%
Recurrence Quantification ACSP=83.47%
Analysis features of
Heart Rate Viability
Classifiers: SVM and Neural
Network

Hassan et al.,2015 No. of features:25 ACAC=83.77%

Features:
EMD based statistical features
of intrinsic mode
Functions
Classifiers:
Extreme learning machine
Varon et al., 2015 No. of Features: 28 ACAC=84.74%
Features: ACSE=84.71%
1.)Standard deviation of RR (S1) ACSP=84.69%
2.) Serial correlation
coefficients (r): 5
3.) Standard deviation of EDR
signals (S2): 3
4.) Principal Component's
Relative
power (PC)
5.) Orthogonal subspace
 projections(F): 18
Classifiers:
Least Squares–Support Vector
Machine (LS–SVM)
Hassan et al., 2016 No. of Features: 36 ACSE=81.99%
Features: TQWT based - ACAC=87.33%
1.) Scale factor of normal ACSP=90.72%
inverse Gaussian
probability distribution
function (NIG pdf): 18
2.) Tail Heaviness of NIG pdf: 18
Classifiers: Adaptive Boosting

Surrel and Murali, 2018 Features: ACAC=83.2%

Power spectrum analysis
Li et al., 2018 No. of Features: NM ACAC=84.7%
Features: ACSE=88.9%
Markov model based features
with decision fusion
SVM and ANN classifiers

Proposed Method No. of Features: 12 ACAC=90.11%

Features: SDBS-OEBFB based - ACSE=90.87%
1.) FE: 6 ACSP=88.88%
2.) LE: 6 AUC=0.95
Classifiers: F1-score=.92
LS-SVM