Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Xanthan gum is used extensivelyfor enhanced oil recoveryas a mobilitycontrol agent, in drilling operations to increase
the suspension capacity of the drilling mud, and in gels to improve the volumetric sweep efficiency.Flow properties,
injectivity, and adsorption characteristics depend on acetate and pyruvate content of xanthan. This reviewdiscussesvar-
ious methods and techniques available for measuring the concentration of xanthan and its pyruvate and acetate content
in laboratory and field samples. It includes a description of the principles of each method, advantages, limitations, inter-
ferences, and other information necessaryto understand the strengths and weaknessesof each.
*Current address: Laboratories Department, P.O. Box 62, The phenol-sulfuric acid m e t h o d relies on
Saudi Aramco, Dhahran 31311, Saudi Arabia. the formation o f a colored complex from the
reaction of sugars with a phenol compound or surfactant flooding project and concluded that
thioglycolic acid in concentrated sulfuric acid. no interference with polymer determination
The method measures the total carbohydrate occurred. Similar results are expected for
content of a sample. Phenol, anthrone, orci- emulsions containing xanthan.
nol, 3-phenyl phenol, and thioglycolic acid Size exclusion chromatography is ideally
have been used in this method (Auerbach, suited for highly contaminated samples. Sam-
pers. commun., 1991"*; Dubois et al., 1956; ple throughput rates of three to five samples
Jeanes et al., 1976; Philips et al., 1985; Que- per hour are typical.
mener, 1986; Ranjbar-Hamghawandi, 1988,
1990, 1992). The method is accurate within
_+2%, with a range of 2.5-35 mg/1 sugar (Du- Radioactive labelling
bois et al., 1956) and has been used for bio-
polymer determination in high salinity brine
Carbon-14, a fl-ray emitter, was incorpo-
(Ranjbar-Hamghawandi, 1990). The concen-
rated into xanthan by adding carbon-14-1a-
tration of glucose or other sugars must be
belled glucose to the fermentation broth late in
known, because they will result in a positive
the growth cycle (Sorbie et al., 1987). They
interference (Jeanes et al., 1976). Color gen-
produced a carbon-14-labelled xanthan with a
eration is affected by high salinity or the pres-
specific activity of 1.8 MBq/cm 3 ( 48.6 X 10- 6
ence of Fe 3+ (Philips et al., 1985). Littmann
Ci/cm 3) at a xanthan concentration of 3200
et al. (1992) used the method to determine
mg/l. Quantitation is generally performed with
xanthan concentration in brine produced from
a commercial liquid scintillation counter.
a polymer flood field test. Samples were di-
Goodyear et al. (1992) used carbon-14-la-
alyzed prior to analysis to remove salts and
belled xanthan in the measurement of polymer
potential interferences.
retention levels. Crushed rock with adsorbed
The phenol-sulfuric acid method provides
polymer was heated to decompose the poly-
good sensitivity and reproducibility. How-
mer into carbon dioxide and water. Radioac-
ever, the method is relatively slow, and the ef-
tively labelled carbon dioxide was absorbed in
fect of interferences common in oilfield brines
a scintillation cocktail, and radioactivity was
(especially formaldehyde) is largely unknown.
measured.
The most significant drawback of radioac-
Size exclusion chromatography
tive labelling as a method for xanthan deter-
This method uses a column to separate the mination is that it can not be used for com-
polymer from low-molecular-weight impuri- mercial samples. Labelled samples must be
ties. This allows the use of ultraviolet (UV) or grown in culture, and their properties may not
refractive index detectors that would other- exactly match a commercial sample of interest.
wise be unsuitable with unpurified samples.
The UV detector is more sensitive, with detec- Organic carbon content
tion limits as low as 0.6 mg/1 (Hunt et al.,
1988). Beazley (1985) examined samples
from a viscous emulsion produced by a par- Measurement of total organic carbon in
tially hydrolysed polyacrylamide/sulfonate aqueous samples has been used by Lecourtier
et al. ( 1987 ) and Muller et al. ( 1986 ) for xan-
**M.H. Auerbach, pers. commun., 1991. Pfizer Proce-
dure: "Total Carbohydrate Assay by Phenol-Sulfuric Acid
than determination. Solutions containing high
Method". Pfizer Central Research, Easter Point Road, amounts of salt may interfere with the com-
Groton, Conn., USA. plete combustion of carbon compounds, be-
XANTHAN BIOPOLYMERS 275
cause sodium carbonate may be formed pref- lecular weight distribution will affect the solu-
erentially. Any carbon containing species will tion viscosity, reducing the accuracy of
interfere with the method, making it unsuita- measurement.
ble for the determination of polymer concen-
tration in the presence of surfactants, biocides
such as formaldehyde, or emulsions. Refractive index
Metachromatic method
This method requires polymer concentra-
tion to be proportional to the refractive index
The metachromatic acid method by Mo-
of the solution and has been used by Queme-
raine and Rogovin ( 1971 ) uses the dye tolui-
n e r ( 1 9 8 6 ) . The specific refractive index in-
dine blue O which forms an insoluble complex
crement of xanthan was found to be 0.144
with aqueous xanthan. When the mixture is
cm3/g at 633 nm (Hunt et al., 1988 ) and 0.155
extracted with a petroleum ether, the complex
cm3/g at 546 nm (Milas and Rinaudo, 1984).
adsorbs at the interface. The method measures
Lindstr~Sm and Srremark (1976) used a
the decrease in absorbance of the aqueous
Knauer refractometer thermostatted to
phase as dye is lost due to the formation of the
_+0.005°C, and claimed an accuracy of _+1
insoluble complex. It is reported to be of use
mg/1 for acrylamide copolymers in wood pulp
at xanthan concentrations as low as 20 mg/l.
suspensions in distilled water. The refractive
The effect of interferences is not known.
index increment of this polymer is similar to
that ofxanthan (Hunt et al., 1988).
Precipitation
The use of refractive index for the determi-
nation of polymer concentration can produce
Xanthan can be purified and isolated by first
acceptable results only when solutions of low,
dissolving the polymer in water and then pre-
constant ionic strength are used. Temperature
cipitating it in a water-miscible nonsolvent
must be accurately controlled to reduce
such as isopropanol (Hassler and Doherty,
changes in refractive index. Ideally, only solu-
1990), methanol (Moraine and Rogovin,
tions of xanthan in distilled water or dialyzed
1966) or ethanol (Jeanes et al., 1961; Milas
samples should be considered for this method.
and Rinaudo, 1984). For careful analytical
work, several reprecipitations may be neces-
sary. This method can be a useful technique Hydrolysis with glucose determination
for polymer concentrations greater than 10
g/l.
Hassler and Doherty (1990) quantitated
Viscosity xanthan by first hydrolysing the polymer to its
constituent sugars, then determining glucose
This method requires that viscosity varies concentration with an enzyme test kit (Sigma
proportionally with polymer concentration, Procedure No. 16-UV) using hexokinase and
and assumes that the viscosity of xanthan so- glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase. This
lutions is independent of salinity. By measur- method is also useful for determining glucose
ing viscosity at a fixed shear rate for a range of impurities in xanthan. The efficiency and re-
polymer concentrations, Philips et al. (1985) producibility of the hydrolysis step has not
obtained a different nonlinear calibration been established, nor has the method been
curve for each commercial polymer used. Any evaluated for interferences common in oilfield
change in temperature, pH, shear rate, or mo- brines.
276 K.C. TAYLOR AND H.A. NASR-EL-DIN
Lecourtier, J., No'tic, C., Barbey, P. and Chauveteau, G., metric microdetermination of polysaccharides. Fre-
1987. Semi-rigid polysaccharides for polymer flood- senius Z. Anal. Chem., 331: 759-760.
ing in high salinity reservoirs. Syrup. Proc. 4th BASF Ranjbar-Hamghawandi, M., 1990. Photometric determi-
AG et al. Enhanced Oil Recovery Europe., pp. 105- nation of biopolysaccharides in brine. Fresenius. Z.
116. Anal. Chem., 366: 41-42.
Lindstr~m, T. and SOremark, C., 1976. Adsorption of Ranjbar, M., 1992. Colorimetric determination of xan-
cationic Polyacrylamides on Cellulose. J. Colloid In- than with thioglycolic acid. Erdrl Erdgas Kohle,
terface Sci., 55(2): 305-312. 108(2): 74-75.
Littmann, W., Kleinitz, W., Christensen, B.E. and Stokke, Rinaudo, M., Milas, M., Lambert, F. and Vincendon, M.,
B.T., 1992. Late results of a polymer pilot test: per- 1983.1H and ~3C NMR investigation ofxanthan gum.
formance, simulation, absorption, and xanthan stabil- Macromol., 16:816-819.
ity in the reservoir. SPE/DOE 8th Symp. Enhanced Rochefort, W.E. and Middleman, S., 1987. Rheology of
Oil Recovery, Tulsa, Okla., SPE/DOE 24120. xanthan gum: salt, temperature, and strain effects in
McComb, E.A. and McCready, R.M., 1957. Determina- oscillatory and steady shear experiments. J. Rheol., 31:
tion of acetyl in pectin and in acetylated carbohydrate 337-369.
polymers. Anal. Chem. 29(5): 819-821. Sandford, P.A., Pittsley, J.E., Knutson, C.A., Watson,
Milas, M. and Rinaudo, M., 1984. On the existence of P.R., Cadmus, M.C. and Jeanes, A., 1977. Variation
two different secondary structures for the xanthan in in xanthomonas campestris NRRLB- 1459; character-
aqueous solutions. Polym. Bull., 12: 507-514. ization of xanthan products of differing pyruvic acid
Milas, M. and Rinaudo, M., 1986. Properties ofxanthan content. In: P.A. Sandford and A. Laskin (Editors),
gum in aqueous solutions: role of the conformational Extracellular Microbial Polysaccharides. Am. Chem.
transition. Carbohydr. Res., 158:191-204. Soc., Washington, DC, Syrup. Ser., 45: 192-210.
Milas, M., Linossier, J.L. and Contat, F., 1988. The effect Schultz, T.H., 1965. Determination of acetyl in pectin.
of thermal aging on xanthan solutions. J.Appl. Polym. Methods Carbohydr. Chem., 5:187-189.
Sci., 35: 1115-1122. Shatwell, K.P., Sutherland, I.W., Dea, I.C.M. and Ross-
Moraine, R.A. and Rogovin, P., 1966. Kinetics of poly- Murphy, S.B., 1990. The influence of acetyl and py-
saccharide B- 1459 fermentation. Biotechnol. Bioeng., ruvate substituents on the helix-Coil transition behav-
8:511-524. iour ofxanthan. Carbohydr. Res., 206: 87-103.
Moraine, R.A. and Rogovin, P., 1971. Xanthan biopoly- Sloneker, J.H. and Jeanes, A., 1962. Exocellular bacterial
mer production at increased concentration by pH con- polysaccharide from xanthomonas campestris NRRL
trol. Biotechnol. Bioeng., 13: 381-391. B-1459. Can. J. Chem., 40: 2066-2071.
Morris, E.R., Rees, D.A., Young, G., Walkinshaw, M.D. Sloneker, J.H. and Orentas, D.G., 1962. Pyruvic acid, a
and Darke, A., 1977. Order-disorder transition for a unique component of an exocellular bacterial polysac-
bacterial polysaccharide in solution. J. Mol. Biol., 110: charide. Nature, 194: 478-479.
1-16. Smith, 1.H., Symes, K.C., Lawson, C.J. and Morris, E.R.,
Muller, G., Anrhourrache, M., Lecourtier, J. and Chau- 1981. Influence of the pyruvate content of xanthan on
veteau, G., 1986. Salt dependence of the conforma- macromolecular association in solution, Int. J. Biol.
tion of a single-stranded xanthan. Int. J. Biol. Ma- Macromol., 3: 129-134.
cromol., 8: 167-172. Smith, I.H., Symes, K.C., Lawson, C.J. and Morris, E.R,,
Nisbet, B.A., Bradshaw, l.J., Kerr, M. and Sutherland, 1984. The effect of pyruvate on xanthansolution prop-
I.W., 1982. Characteristics of microbial exopolysac- erties. Carbohydr. Polym., 4: 153-157.
charides for E.O.R. use. Proc. 2nd Eur. Syrup. EOR, Sorbie, K.S., Parker, A. and Clifford, P.J., 1987. Experi-
Paris, France, pp. 71-77. mental and theoretical study of polymer flowin porous
Paradossi, G. and Brant, D.A., 1982. Light scattering study media. Soc. Pet. Eng. Res. Eng., 2(3): 281-304.
of a series of xanthan fractions in aqueous solution. Sutherland, I.W. and Kierulf, C., 1987. Downhole use of
Macromolecules, 15: 874-879. biopolymers. Inst. Petrol. Microbiol. Comm. Micro-
Philips, J.C., Miller, J.W., Wernau, W.C., Tate, B.E. and bial Problems in the Offshore Oil Industry. Int. Conf.
Auerbach, M.H., 1985. A high-pyruvate xanthan for Aberdeen, 1986, pp. 93-103.
EOR. Soc. Pet. Eng. J., 25(4): 594-602. Sutherland, I.W. and Wilkinson, J.F., 1968. The exopo-
Quemener, B., 1986. Mrthodes d'identification et de dos- lysaccharide of Klebsiella aerogenes A3 (SI)(Type
age des polysaccharides. In: P. Colonna and J.F. Thi- 54). Biochem. J., 110: 749-754.
bault (Editors), Propr. Fonct. Polysaccharides. Conf. Wernau, W.C., 1981. Xanthomonas biopolymer for use
Sess., pp. 333-364. in displacement of oil from partially depleted reser-
Ranjbar-Hamghawandi, M., 1988. Quantitative photo- voirs. US Patent No. 4,296,203.