Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Executive Summary
This report compares the quantitative and qualitative data over 2 years
between 2 major retailers in UK which are Mark and Spencer and NEXT. It
London Stick Exchange and appears in FTSE 100 index. Compared to year
16/17 in 17/18 group revenue has been increased by only + 0.7% while Profit
Before Tax has been reduced by 5.4%. Besides that total assets have also
been reduced by 9% while total liabilities have been reduced by 10.6%. M&S
financial ratios are well below industry averages yet they understand that they
Table of Contents
1. Introduction 4
1. Introduction
M&S has founded in 1884 in Leeds as a small stall where all products were
sold for a penny (Burt, 2002). Since its establishment M&S has become the
UK’s most thriving brand in clothing, home-ware and food. Michael Marks
and Thomas Spencer founded M&S and currently it is listed on the London
spotlight on item quality, value for cash and customer services (M&S, 2008).
outlets (Mintel, 2008). Amid late 90's and mid 2000's, M&S experienced falling
network the executives, substandard items and insufficient cost the board.
UK and moving to more online based retail stores. Compared to year 16/17 in
17/18 group revenue has been increased by only + 0.7% while Profit Before
Tax has been reduced by 5.4%. Besides that total assets have also been
NEXT is UK's second, most favoured apparel retailer, after M&S and has
designing outfits with a contemporary look, offering a decent value for money
to clients (Mintel, 2008). It began its retail business amid 1982; transcendently
extended its diversity by providing clothes for men and kids. NEXT has lost
impressive piece of the overall industry since late 90's, because of poor cost
control and forceful evaluating procedure that limited shopper spending (Next,
NEXT.
organization to pay off its short-term debts. Forthcoming creditors and lenders
liabilities stated in company’s most recent balance sheet. When the ratio is
high it shows the ability of the company to pay off its obligations or creditors in
a timely manner. There are 2 main ratios, which are Current Ratio, and Quick
Assets Ratio.
“The current ratio measures a company's ability to pay off its current liabilities
(payable within one year) with its current assets such as cash, accounts
receivable and inventories. The higher the ratio, the better the company's
Current Assets
Current Ratio = Current Laibilities
obligations with its most liquid assets and therefore excludes inventories from
M&S Current Ratio (CR) has not changed though Next CR has been reduced
to 1.96 from 2.29. Yet compared to NEXT M&S CR is very low and this is due
to the loosing cash and cash equivalents, which lead to creating a gap in
current assets compared to 2017. Ideal CR should be minimum 2:1. Thus only
NEXT was able to achieved ideal CR value in 2017 though 2018 it is reduced
by 14.4%. Higher value of current ratio indicates more liquid of the firm’s
ability to pay its current debts in timely manner. In M&S CR value has been
stable for those 2 years yet it clearly shows its decline in both Current assets
and liabilities. This may be able to happen due to closure of physical stores
across UK.
In 2017 and 2018 M&S Quick Assets Ratio (QAR) has been further declined
managed to keep the QAR above 1. The ideal QAR is 1:1 and M&S was not
able to reach those ideal levels in both 2017 and 2018. There is no huge
current liabilities has gone down by 22.88% while Current assets also gone
down by 23.56%.
Nirosh
Figure Amadoruge
6 QAR Line Chart of M&S and Student ID – 1927488
9
Profitability ratios are a class of financial metrics that are used to assess a
balance sheet assets, and shareholders' equity over time, using data from a
specific point in time. Profitability ratios also show how well companies use
their existing assets to generate profit and value for shareholders. Higher ratio
results are often more favourable, but ratios provide much more information
when compared to results from other, similar companies, the company's own
(COGS) from total revenue and dividing that number by total revenue. Direct
Revenue
Compared to 2017 M&S Gross Profit margin in 2018 has slightly decreased.
Even though revenue has slightly increased gross profit was decreased. So
this happens when the cost of sales is increased. Compared to M&S NEXT
The operating profit margin ratio indicates how much profit a company makes
after paying for variable costs of production such as wages, raw materials,
Sales Revenue
produces from its operations before interest and tax charges. It is calculated
2.38% to 1.46%. Though revenue has slight drop could see huge loss in
operating profit in 2018. In November 2016 M&S group has announced 5-year
online share of sales yet attract some initial heavy expenses including the
Capital
Employed 4624.8 4862.1 1,646.70 1,679.80
ROCE % 3.38 5.2 46.15 49.27
ROCE reflects ability to earn a return on all of the capital it employs. M&S
ROCE ahs decreased from 5.2% to 3.38% by 2018 while NEXT ROCE has
mainly due to less revenue and increased cost of sales. M&S equity
Figure 11 ROCE
Declined equity has occurred due to declined cash and cash equivalents in
net assets while non current/ long term liabilities remain the same.
Equity 2954.2 3150.4 482.6 510.5
RI % 0.98 3.67 122.63 124.44
ROI of M&S has further declined in 2018 and NEXT ROI is looking very
attractive in both years. ROI is mainly decreased due to declined profit after
Figure 12 ROI
will attract more and more shareholders due to its higher ROI, as investors will
and it measures company it’s basic financial solvency. The working capital
ratio can be calculated by dividing current assets by current liabilities and 1.5
industry averages and low turnover implies weak sales or over stocking while
Cost of Sales
M&S took 43 days in 2017 and 42 days in 2018 in overall to sell out all
it’s inventory while NEXT shows 63 days in both years, which is higher than
M&S. M&S is selling more variety of products than NEXT which includes
clothing and home supplies hence those items require longer period to be
sold. NEXT turnover days are consistent and managing its inventory quiet
well.
This represents the time lag between a credit sale and receiving
plays a vital role when it comes to liquidity. M&S shows very low receivable
Payable payment days (PPD) are an essential financial ratio that financial
A higher PPD implies that the company is taking more time to pay its sellers
and providers than company with a littler PPD. Companies with high PPDs
have points of interest since they are more fluid than Companies with littler
PPDs and can utilize their money for momentary speculations. M&S PPD has
NEXT
Cash Coonversion Cycle = (Inven: Days+ Recei: Days) - Payable Days
Payable
Year Inven: Days Recei: Days Days CCC
2017 63.12 88.16 86.8 64.48
2018 63.63 97.36 80.86 80.13
The Cash Conversion Cycle (CCC) is a metric that demonstrates the measure
of time it takes a company to convert its inventory into cash. M&S has a
negative CCC, which means it generates revenue before pays off suppliers
and creditors.
generate sales from it assets by comparing net sales with average total
assets. M&S has a ratio of 1.87 in 2018 compared to its 2017 1.79 ratio it’s a
slight increment. M&S has lower ratio compared to NEXT and this due to the
and structure of the firm. These ratios help to identify financing techniques
used by the business and focus on solvency position. Equity ratio, debt
ratio, debt to equity ratio, interest cover ratio is the main capital structure
ratios.
M&S has increased debt to equity ratio by 25.45% compared to 2017. This is
mainly due to decreased cash and increased Net debt. Although NEXT has
much higher ratio than M&S it can be more risky for ordinary shareholders yet
quicker profitability.
PBIT/
Interest Cover Interest
NEXT
Company Mark & Spencer (M&S) £m £m
Years 2018 2017 2018 2017
PBIT 156.5 253.20 759.90 827.70
Interest 113.8 113 35.1 37.8
Int; Cover Ratio 1.38 2.24 21.65 21.9
M&S Interest Cover ratio has further gone down due to downfall of PBIT.
NEXT has a higher ratio and proves its financial position. Since M&S ratio is
below 1.5 it’s ability to meet interest expenses may be questionable. The ratio
measures how many times over a company could pay its outstanding debts
Stock market performance ratios are vital as they use to explore how
investors can assess a company by analysing its past execution and its
Figure 20 EPS
each share of common stock. Higher the value investors will pay more for firm
expecting higher profits. M&S EPS has reduced heavily and this is due to
higher selling and administrative expenses. NEXT shows a higher EPS yet it’s
2.5.2. PE Ratio
Figure 21 PE Ratio
indicates that investors paid 168.88p for very penny earned by the company.
The higher PE ratio of M&S reflects that investors paid more money for the
company that earned less. NEXT will be the company to invest as its
attractive low PE ratios in 2017 and 2018 respectively 9.79p and 11.42p with
an aim of faster return. Higher PE ratio of M&S means that investors are
In the graph X- Axis presents the period and Y- Axis shows the Share price.
According to the graph in 2014 M&S gained a higher share price and from
2014 to 2015 has a huge downfall in the price. In 2016, 2017 and 2018
average share prices are 333.30p, 295.10p and 270.30p respectively. Once
reason for this decline is the heavy selling of shares by hedge funds, which
Change in
Mark & Spencer %
Company & Year M&S 2018 M&S 2017
Revenue 10,698.20 10622
(+ 0.71%)
Cost of Sales -6650.9 -6534.2 (+1.78%)
Gross Profit 4047.3 4,087.80 (- 0.00%)
Selling & Admin Expenses -3426.2 -3460.4 (- 0.98%)
Other operating Income 49.5 63.2 (- 21.67%)
Underlying Operating Profit 670.6 690.6 (- 2.89%)
Non Underlying Items -514.1 -437.4 (+ 17.53%)
Operating Profit 156.5 253.20 (- 38.19%)
3. Conclusion
derived from historical results. This does not imply that similar
you can utilise ratio analysis on pro forma data and contrast it with
Inflation - On the off chance that the rate of inflation has changed in
any of the periods under audit, this can imply that the numbers are not
similar across periods. For instance, if the inflation rate were 100% in
one year, deals would seem to have multiplied over the preceding year,
When the 2018 financial ratios of M&S are compared with 2017 ratios Quick
QAR is declined due to less cash or cash equivalent in current assets, which
also have an impact on ROI. Since 2016 M&S group commenced 5-year
online share of sales yet attract some initial heavy expenses including the
Operating margin, ROCE, ROI, Current Ratio, QAR, Interest cover ratio all are
well below industry averages. While PE ratio and Debt to equity ratios are
way over industry averages. M&S Assets Turn Over ratio is 1.87 while it’s
above industry averages. M&S has lower ratio compared to NEXT and this
due to the nature of M&S business model and it’s net assets. Generally M&S
has less revenue and increased cost of sales, which started affecting most of
cutting back short term over head expenses. Rather using short-
debt obligations on time. Beyond that M&S can seek for vendors
The organisation can sell its assets and after that rent them back.
This will actuate an income that can be utilised to satisfy a few debt
obligations.
Reference