Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
2019
Christina E. Vitale
Professor: D Harper
INTRODUCTION
The classroom setting is a lasting icon in all our lives, it consumes about 1,000
waking hours of children’s lives each year (Hours), the graph noted to your left indicates
educational future. It’s a foundation that is established as soon as children can walk and
talk.
The American education systems started more than 150 years ago,
Massachusetts became the first state to provide all its citizens access to a free public
education. Over the next 66 years, every other state made the same guarantee. The
about 28 students of roughly the same age are taught by one teacher, usually in an 800
square-foot room. This model has been the dominant archetype ever since (Education).
experiences occur for children. One experience is student achievement, which is often
purely looked at from the perspective of the strength of the curriculum and the quality of
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 2
the teachers. However, study after study demonstrates that facilities themselves have a
huge impact on student behavior, grades, teacher tenure and even community
satisfaction (Students). That's why the promise of educational innovation is less about
technology and software code and more about the opportunity to release from general
assumptions regarding how instruction is organized and delivered. The innovation today
should go beyond merely designing and producing new tools (Students). Rather, the
focus should primarily be to design new classroom models that take advantage of
physical environment.
In the early 1900s, classroom sizes were double that of today. Children would sit
in rows of tiered classroom/school tables, like a theatre, so they could all easily see the
teacher. There was no segregation of students based on age or learning ability, unlike
today, and often a whole family of youngsters would be in the same class. The large
rooms would have been heated by coal fires, before radiators were invented
(Classroom Size).
A great example of this type of classroom structure 30 years ago, was when one
of my Naval Instructor Andy Jones, went to school where there were 20-30 students in a
classroom with one teacher. The classroom set-up was lined up with traditional rows of
tables and chairs aligned together. Andy noted that it was very efficient because there
would be times where he felt like there was no personal space, so it was an
lecture. Andy had various classes that he attended in his youthful years, but as he
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 3
thought about a physical classroom layout that really made his learning experience
effective was the classroom arrangement that had four tables that were put together in a
group or square. The students faced each other, had more space and at the same time
became a team. This classroom set up seemed to have been the most effective to him.
The only downfall with this set-up he noted, was when it came to individual assignments
it was harder to get away from the teamwork establishment, so the privacy and
Going back twenty years ago, the classroom set up seemed to have been the
same for Daycare provider and Clerical Advisor at the Clarksville daycare Denise Bryd.
She had the traditional row of table set up, just like the arrangement in the figure below.
Which compared to Andy was a bit more efficient for her learning experience. She
expressed that the set up helped with the individual and team work learning
environment. There was someone that was always sitting next to her on both sides,
aiding with team work. When there were individual projects, she felt that the privacy and
individual space was perfect. The biggest downfall to this traditional set-up for Denise
was the spacing in between the rows. Children would back up into her table or get
The function and design of a desk is merely taken as just a simple desk that you
sit at to conduct multiple functions. In the classroom setting desks are used for hours
throughout the day, so it honestly is more than a desk. They hold pencils, books, paper
and all your school supplies. What is not taken into consideration is the shapes of the
desk, the storage areas and the desk workspace. After speaking with my son about his
classroom desk, he noted that he doesn’t have a storage area under his desktop and
must use a basket or supply box to store all his school work. This takes up his desktop
working area and is a distraction. This takes away from the comfort aspect of the
classroom and lost space that my son and his peers could be utilizing.
Continuing to explore the ideas of comfort, imagine walking into the corner of a
desk. Your first thought is why is this desk here and how did I run into it. Classroom
desks are all square and have sharp or curved edges. The classroom needs be a safe
and comfortable environment. There are days that children must stay inside due to the
weather, they will be playing and running around in the classroom. So, having these
types of desk is a risk and hazard for the students and teachers. Running into desks
really withdraws that comfort level. After speaking with my mentor Bill Haynie about the
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 5
desk construct, he noted that autistic children tend to act impulsively, and take off
running suddenly. For this reason, it is a good idea to avoid sharp angles and mobility
hazards within the classroom. It’s a physical risk factor that must really be taken into
consideration when designing a safe and hazard free physical classroom environment
(Education).
not make the cut. The classic model for schools, where mentors must compete with
discomfort, can be traced back hundreds of years to the "reading" and "writing" schools
designed to give children the skills to access God's word in the Bible (Comfort). Very
little has changed from the traditional classroom set up to the current. Most public
schools today are twentieth-century adaptations of the schools in the original American
colonies (Comfort). Every school building of those that I have interviewed and buildings
that I have attended have a mirrored goal. Classroom after classroom are aligned along
each side of a corridor, have disciplined rows of hard chairs symbolizing that have strict
Shuffling children through school ensuring they received their education and
passing was the focus in the classroom environment. There was no way that the idea of
how comfort and the physical environment was a very important aspect of children’s
learning experience. When I asked my interviewees’ Bill Haynie and Denise Bryd how
they thought about their physical classroom environment settings, they all noted that it
was set up as uncomfortable on purpose, they felt that the schools thought it was a
likely that your mind pictures lined up rows of desks almost immediately. This is
because for centuries we’ve been doing it all wrong. The era of desks in uniform rows is
coming to an end. Now is the time to get on board with the evolution of the classroom
(Evolution). Breaking the mold and breaking free from the static classroom model, that
most associate with K-12 schools, promotes a much more successful learning
environment. It’s time to say goodbye to row after row of unengaged students and it’s
time to set up classroom layouts like the ones similar to the visual below.
topic. There are so many factors to identify. Upon my interview with my mentor and
internship supervisor Bill Haynie, he discussed the barriers with acoustics for his autistic
daughter. The noise level for children with autism is a great concern because they have
difficulty filtering out background noise (e.g., noise from a hallway, pencil sharpeners, or
water fountain). Children with autism become agitated and sometimes unruly when
confronted with higher noise levels (Quiet Place). They sometimes must wear noise
When discussing problems within the classroom we have identified that all
classrooms mirror each other. They all follow the same format and layout, not taking
into consideration the many facets that can distract students. Architects take a lot of
time and consideration when they build their massive buildings (Education). Each floor
has specific uses and functions, catered towards the people that consume them daily.
Think back to your high school or middle school days. Were there times where
you couldn’t hear the teacher’s lecture? If the acoustics aren’t set up correctly, students
tend to lose focus and get distracted. Considering the variety of teaching methods,
many classrooms have been designed to be open rather than closed. Therefore,
insulation will reduce distracting noises. This is such an important aspect, as some
students work more comfortably and more successfully in quiet rather than noisy
settings (Quite Place). Therefore, a quiet setting is generally more beneficial overall,
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 8
children need to hear the teacher and not be distracted by outside noises. Ensuring this
is not a barrier in this classroom is a key element and would really take away from the
considerations for the classroom. But, what if the classroom has bright painted walls
and patterns surrounding the students. This then becomes a hinder and a visual
distractor within in the classroom. When defined, color is an important aspect of sight
because it provides “better detection of spatial features, highlights specific items, and
sets the mood within interior spaces” (Color). So, depending on what types of colors are
displayed throughout the classroom, it can affect the children and teacher’s moods. A
certain color can bring a certain emotion into the classroom and set a good or bad tone,
color. Robert M. Gerard (1957), an early researcher, studied the use of colored light and
person’s reaction to color is based on three precepts: (1) people respond to color with
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 9
different feelings and emotions, (2) their entire bodies can be affected—autonomic
imaginary response), and (3) they may be affected by previous learning experiences or
their culture (Gerard, 1957). This research reinforces the concept that humans react to
color both physically and psychologically, and people have different responses to color
(Color). A simple suggestion of hues of greens and blues can elaborate sophistication
and focus, it also creates a cool and relaxing environment (Child style).
Traditional classrooms have a bland appeal to them when it comes to the color
schemes that incase the classroom. White or manila walls were what Denise Bryd
remembers in her classrooms. Her memories of the walls weren’t welcoming, she felt
like she was in a prison. This distracted her learning environment because it made the
classroom setting boring and scary at the same time. Not having posters on the walls or
the right type of colors to create the welcoming appeal made her not want to go to class
Speaking of the physical factors, there are moments that seem to distract your
attention, like flickering lights in a space that just sidetrack your ability to concentrate.
Your concentration is deterred and all you can do is wish that you could just stop that
light from blinking. Imagine this occurring in a classroom full of students that lose focus
the minute something interesting catches their attention. Maintenance and lighting play
a very valuable roll within the classroom setting. Lighting can hinder one’s ability to see
the board clearly, or even distract students from learning if the right light bulbs aren’t put
in the correct environment. Illumination can contribute to a dull and boring classroom,
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 10
through the manipulation of brightness contrast, leading to a real challenge for the
interior designers (Light). As indicated in the productivity graph below, blue lighting can
create fatigue, while the warmer reds and yellows create a sense of comfort and
relaxation.
Lighting plays a pivotal role in our lives, often without us being aware of it.
Altering lighting in a classroom will transform a space and can even create a dramatic
impact on the emotional state within the classroom. People feel more alert, energetic,
and positive on a sunny day, a day marked by bright highlights and crisp shadows. By
providing brightness contrast, the lighting designer can create an environment that has
the attributes of a sunny day. In truth, the significant difference between a “dull, dreary”
day and a “bright, cheerful” one is the quality of light (Light). An example of how lighting
While I was stationed on board the USS GEORGE H.W. BUSH, the whole ship that
holds over 5,000 Sailors has fluorescent lights that were as dull as can be. One day I
noticed that the Electricians onboard were changing out the light bulbs during one our
underway periods during the day. We work 24/7 hours onboard the ship, it’s our home.
As I completed my shift for the day, I headed to my sleeping area. It was dark by this
time, I walked through the main hang bay of the ship where it gets dark. Now,
remember the electricians had replaced the lights earlier that day. Well, they replaced
all the lights on the ships with LED lights. Those lights brought a ray of hope and a smile
to my face. We had been underway and away from our families for eight months. For
the first time in a long time, those lights brought warmth into my life. I always think back
Another very warming aspect of light is the great existence of sweet natural
sunlight. Not having the sun beam through the windows in a classroom can illuminate a
very negative classroom environment. Through windows we look out at the world and
the world looks in at us. The placement of windows not only is important to the wall
arrangement of windows)—a crucial part of the style and character of the exterior
(Windows). Denise Bryd spoke of her experiences with windows in such delight, that it
made me smile and think of the warm sunshine. When she was in school, just knowing
that when the students were done with their assignments they could go to the
play/activity area by a tall vertical window in the back of the classroom just made her
motivated to finish her work, so she could enjoy the splendors that enticed her as she
The emotion and sheer happiness can bring into children’s lives is simply
remarkable. Where I grew up in San Bernardino, Ca. windows were a rare commodity. I
lived in a neighborhood where there were gang members, drug dealers, you name it.
So, some of our portable classrooms that had windows had a screen with bars over
them. The reason the bars were there was because people liked to break into those
classrooms. Portable classrooms are built a lot more poorly than the functioning
classrooms we are used to, so these were targets for people to steal our classroom
computers and classroom essentials. It wasn’t until around high school when one of our
English teachers took us outside to read, made me wish that we had true windows in
our classrooms, so we could see the beautiful rays of light in our classroom
environment.
think of another memory in elementary school. My not-favored teacher Mrs. Wall, she
was a woman with mean identifying glasses, was always dressed proper with a nice
dress and had these square shaped heels that I will never forget. Though I remember
her mean stature, I do always have fond memories of her Classroom, it was
unforgettable. It had its own identity compared to the rest of the teachers I ever had. It
was clean, organized and welcoming. She always changed out themes in the room to
correlate towards what we were learning each month and really kept us on our toes.
The impact that the classroom had was so profound, that even though I disliked Mrs.
Even though her room was truly the best classroom environment I ever had, the
flooring was the worst. It was half tile and half carpet. This caused a lot of us to trip over
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 13
the barrier that overlapped the connection of the carpet and flooring. Slips and falls are
the leading cause of injury in schools, and the choice of flooring has an important role to
play in minimizing the incidence of injuries. Hard surfaces often become slippery,
especially in wet conditions (as a result of recent mopping, or snow or rainfall being
tracked into the building). Carpet offers significantly more traction than hard surface
products and reduces the likelihood of slips and falls occurring as a result. In the event
of a fall, carpeting can also reduce the risk of injury. Only 17% of falls on carpet result in
Another aspect to look at when it comes to carpets, is the spill factor. We always
spilled so much water and paint on the carpet, so it was ruined by the end of the school
year. It was a distracting element but wasn’t too much of a distractor to not love the
classroom.
durable and have a quiet atmosphere to enable students to learn effectively (Flooring).
Considering all the options and styles that are available, will enhance the right
atmosphere for the classroom. The most effect and reliable floors are specified:
Marmoleum:
Flotex:
performance contributes
and designs with a choice of impact sound reduction of 15, 17 & 19dB.
It is said that classroom flooring, like other building materials, can enhance the
learning environment and help create the optimal setting for students to achieve
(Flooring). The choice of flooring can help manage ambient noise levels. Hard surface
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 15
flooring including laminate and vinyl composite tile have a poor acoustic profile - sound
bounces off the surface and reverberates through the classroom space, this was the
type of flooring most of my classrooms growing up had. Luxury vinyl tile offers the best
acoustic profile of all hard surface flooring types thanks to its layered construction - but
even that can't match the sound absorption qualities of carpet (Flooring). As I spoke to
many of my Sailors at work and Bill, no one ever mentioned having carpet in their
classrooms. The acoustic ratings compared to the hard would or tiled flooring is so
much more efficient. The best option for sound absorption is cushion-backed carpet.
Carpet tiles with cushion backing absorb 50% more noise than hardback carpet, which
in turn absorbs 3x more noise than hard flooring (Flooring). Thinking back to the stained
carpet in my classroom in Mrs. Walls class, I think of the reasoning behind why most
classes don’t have carpet. As I researched further into the fallback with carpeted
classes, it came to my attention that funding was a major factor that lead towards the
Factoring expenses into education shouldn’t be a hurdle in our day and age.
supplies to school. These days, children like my own must bring items to school. If I had
to do this back when I was in elementary school, I don’t think I would have made it
through school because I know my mother couldn’t afford supplies for all six of her
children. The budget size for schools are dwindling down and the physical classroom
setting, like the school supply setting is getting demanding. While I was at one of my
sons Christmas school events, I overheard the teachers talking about how they had to
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 16
bring in their own writing boards and any extra furniture they had to help with the small
As the digital age expands into the classroom environment, students in lower-
income families will struggle to keep up with their peers academically. Considering the
resources available online these days, information found on the internet is outpacing
traditional textbooks. This can cause problems for students without internet access at
home and hinder their learning opportunities (Digital). Digital equipment within the
classroom, can also be a hinderance to children that learn well with this type of
Decentralizing the learning environment and breaking away from the typical
desks in a row structure allows the instructor to move freely throughout the classroom,
from student to student, with a purpose, rather than having to continually stand in front
of a large group and lecture. This creates better opportunities for individual instruction
as well as the promotion of collaboration amongst students in the classroom, which are
two extremely beneficial tactics of knowledge retention. Separating the classroom into
different zones, based on different lesson focusses, promotes higher spans of attention
When you separate classrooms into different zones you are creating a central
area for a specific topic or lesson. This welcomes a collaborative working environment
and an area where you know you will focus solely on the topic at hand. Common
working spaces for teachers and students in this area bring about more ideas and
activities that everyone can participate in. But, with every change or idea there are
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 17
difficulties. Change, uncertainty, variability, transition and novelty are a reality of life.
The extent to which young people effectively respond to this reality will have a
significant bearing on their life course – beyond the influence of other important factors
second home, when a structure or a setting is changed within the classroom on them it
Encouragingly, research and practice show that young people can successfully
adjust their behavior, thought, and emotion – with some at-risk or underachieving youth
perhaps requiring more intensive and sustained support to do this. Young people can
be taught how to be more adaptable, and then in turn better embrace the opportunities
Going through change can be a big deal, but one of the biggest changes in the
classroom environment is how technology has shaped the way children learn. The
invention of the chalkboard in 1890 heralded a new era for learning, and when the
pencil became widespread in 1900, this signaled an end to the inkpot and a new dawn
for easier writing. When the radio was introduced in the 1920s, this also provided a new
style of learning, while the invention of the overhead projector in 1930 enabled students
to view images on a screen. The arrival of the photocopier in the late 1960s made
copying learning materials easier in the classroom, and the advent of computers in the
increasingly digitalized, with the use of mobile technology and iPads to individualize
learning, provide feedback and conduct research. Teachers can use technology to
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 18
monitor students' work from their desk, without needing to walk around the classroom
The new technology-based change within the classroom affects the physical
classroom arrangement. With the ipads and monitoring of students, there is less need
for desks with drawers or cubby holders underneath their desks to hold all their pencils
and supplies. The furniture for this type of digital environment must be noted and the
SUMMARY
Being aware of environmental factors such as lighting and temperature can either
stifle or encourage productivity for students. But the truth is, classrooms—the ‘work
spaces’ of our youth—should also be the product of careful consideration and design
(Design). The history of the classroom has taught us a lot and has had a lot of lessons
learned to make classrooms more welcoming. While the lighting and window
placements could hinder or improve the mood or visual experience for their working
environment. The furniture placement may have to sharp of an edge and could cause a
hazardous environment. Acoustics within the classroom can affect an autistic student
learning ability because there are too many distracting noises that weren’t controlled or
inspected. The neon-yellow paint on the walls just screamed distraction, so every
students learning experience was depleted because it was such a big distraction. There
are so many environmental factors that contribute to a loss within the classroom
environment. But alas, the most interesting of all is that by simply creating a more
effective classroom design (once you have identified these problems), then you can
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 19
improve students’ performance by 25%. The graphic depicted below has a great layout
CONCLUSION
With so much time being consumed in the classroom environment, are the
students surrounding environments affecting them emotionally and mentally in the right
capacity? The classroom is their second home. It’s where they meet their friends that
they keep forever, a place they learn where they love math, art, or science. It is the
place where you learn the most fascinating things about life. The encompassing shell of
that 800-sqare foot classroom holds all these moments and helps create these forever
memories.
With the memories that we will never forget from the schools we attended, we
must never forget the historical aspects and characteristics of the physical classroom
environment that worked. The classroom’s furniture, walls, lighting and enticing
aesthetics that made us feel warm inside. We must take the reins of our curiosity to
improve the physical environment within the classroom. It’s our duty to be mindful of the
influences on the auctions, thoughts and emotions that take hold when designing a
classroom. These very intricate details and empathies will affect the interior space and
function of a classroom that will grow into the future and time of children’s lives.
“There is certainly strong evidence that this is true in early childhood; we have in
recent years learned a great deal about the effects that adverse environments have on
children's early development. And there is growing evidence that even in middle and
environment.” (Classroom)
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 21
Works Cited
Change, Coping with change: teaching adaptability will help kids grow
https://theconversation.com/coping-with-change-teaching-adaptability-will-help-kids-grow-19726,
Chesapeake, Chesapeake School Board OKs plan for new school to replace Great Bridge Primary,
https://pilotonline.com/news/local/education/article_6118ac38-c4ad-5b88-bdfc-
08b750e75a3c.html
Child Style, Tinder-Durik, Amy, “Ideas & Projects for children’s spaces”, Better Homes and Gardens
Magazine
Classroom, The Physical Classroom Environment: Why Your Classroom Need Not Be Pretty,
Color, Nussbaumer, L. L. Human Factors in the Built Environment. [The Art Institutes]. Retrieved from
https://digitalbookshelf.aionline.edu/#/books/9781609019433/
Digital, How Budget Cuts Hurt Students and Teachers (And What to Do About It),
http://inservice.ascd.org/how-budget-cuts-hurt-students-and-teachers-and-what-to-do-about-it/,
https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/05/how-to-break-free-of-our-19th-century-
https://www.epiphanymgmt.com/protected/ArticleView.aspx?iid=6GUBY32&dasi=30G2, web
Flooring, How To Choose The Right Flooring For Elementary School Classrooms,
https://blog.millikencarpet.com/how-to-choose-the-right-flooring-for-elementary-school-
Interviewee Bill Haynie, Jan. 2nd, 2018, Interview of the classroom setting and how it affects children.
Light, Gordon, G. Interior Lighting for Designers. [The Art Institutes]. Retrieved from
https://digitalbookshelf.aionline.edu/#/books/9781118415061/
Quiet Place, Nussbaumer, L. L. Human Factors in the Built Environment. [The Art Institutes]. Retrieved
from https://digitalbookshelf.aionline.edu/#/books/9781609019433/
https://www.dudesolutions.com/community/discover/blogs/how-does-your-schools-physical-
https://digitalbookshelf.aionline.edu/#/books/1260229599/
The Physical Environment of Classrooms Vitale 23
Images Cited
th
web accessed Jan. 12 , 2019
th
Classroom-Seating-Arrangements-32, web accessed Jan. 12 , 2019
th
language-school/images@5055, web accessed Jan. 12 , 2019
th
Jan. 12 , 2019
https://www.nextgenlearning.org/articles/does-your-classroom-design-affect-student-learning,
th
web accessed Jan. 15 , 2019
https://www.nextgenlearning.org/articles/does-your-classroom-design-affect-student-learning,
th
web accessed Jan, 12 , 2019
THE PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT
OF CLASSROOMS
CHRISTINA E. VITALE
PROFESSOR: D HARPER
The American education systems started more than 150 years ago, Massachusetts became the first state to provide
all its citizens access to a free public education. Over the next 66 years, every other state made the same guarantee.
The result was a publicly-funded system where, in every American classroom, groups of about 28 students of roughly
the same age are taught by one teacher, usually in an 800 square-foot room. This model has been the dominant
archetype ever since (Education).
In this standard 800 square-foot modeled classroom environment, numerous experiences occur for children. One Figure 1. Waking Hours spent at School
experience is student achievement, which is often purely looked at from the perspective of the strength of the
curriculum and the quality of the teachers. However, study after study demonstrates that facilities themselves have a
huge impact on student behavior, grades, teacher tenure and even community satisfaction (Students). That's why the
promise of educational innovation is less about technology and software code and more about the opportunity to
release from general assumptions regarding how instruction is organized and delivered. The innovation today should
go beyond merely designing and producing new tools (Students). Rather, the focus should primarily be to design new
classroom models that take advantage of design solutions to stimulate motivation, creativity and empowerment in the
classroom physical environment.
HISTORY OF THE CLASSROOM
Going back twenty years ago, the classroom set up seemed to have been the
In the early 1900s, classroom sizes were double that of today. same for Daycare provider and Clerical Advisor at the Clarksville daycare Denise Bryd.
Children would sit in rows of tiered classroom/school tables, like a She had the traditional row of table set up, just like the arrangement in the figure below.
theatre, so they could all easily see the teacher. There was no
segregation of students based on age or learning ability, unlike today,
and often a whole family of youngsters would be in the same class. The
large rooms would have been heated by coal fires, before radiators were
invented (Classroom Size). Traditional Rows or Columns
A great example of this type of classroom structure 30 years ago, The rows configuration (also
known as the columns
was when one of my Naval Instructor Andy Jones, went to school where configuration) is the most common
there were 20-30 students in a classroom with one teacher. The classroom arrangement. This type
classroom set-up was lined up with traditional rows of tables and chairs of setup complements class
structures that revolve around
aligned together. Andy noted that it was very efficient because there teacher-based instruction and
would be times where he felt like there was no personal space, so it was presentations. Students are more
an uncomfortable environment that caused a distraction while he was focused on coursework and
independent assignments. They
trying to listen to a lecture. Andy had various classes that he attended in are also less likely and/or able to
his youthful years, but as he thought about a physical classroom layout cheat with this layout. Though this
that really made his learning experience effective was the classroom seating arrangement can be used
with any class size, large classes
arrangement that had four tables that were put together in a group or may often see uneven levels of
square. The students faced each other, had more space and at the interaction as students in the front
same time became a team. This classroom set up seemed to have been row will participate more while
those in the back may lose focus.
the most effective to him. The only downfall with this set-up he noted,
was when it came to individual assignments it was harder to get away
from the teamwork establishment, so the privacy and individual
experience was then lost.
HISTORY OF THE CLASSROOM CONT’D (Function & Comfort)
Continuing to explore the ideas of comfort, imagine walking into the corner of a
desk. Your first thought is why is this desk here and how did I run into it. Classroom desks
are all square and have sharp or curved edges. The classroom needs be a safe and
Which compared to Andy was a bit more efficient for her learning comfortable environment. There are days that children must stay inside due to the weather,
experience. She expressed that the set up helped with the individual and they will be playing and running around in the classroom. So, having these types of desk is
team work learning environment. There was someone that was always a risk and hazard for the students and teachers. Running into desks really withdraws that
sitting next to her on both sides, aiding with team work. When there were comfort level. After speaking with my mentor Bill Haynie about the desk construct, he noted
individual projects, she felt that the privacy and individual space was that autistic children tend to act impulsively, and take off running suddenly. For this reason,
it is a good idea to avoid sharp angles and mobility hazards within the classroom. It’s a
perfect. The biggest downfall to this traditional set-up for Denise was the
physical risk factor that must really be taken into consideration when designing a safe and
spacing in between the rows. Children would back up into her table or get hazard free physical classroom environment (Education).
squished when they tried to walk behind her. If we were to assemble a list of adjectives to describe school, comfortable would not
The function and design of a desk is merely taken as just a simple make the cut. The classic model for schools, where mentors must compete with discomfort,
desk that you sit at to conduct multiple functions. In the classroom setting can be traced back hundreds of years to the "reading" and "writing" schools designed to
desks are used for hours throughout the day, so it honestly is more than a give children the skills to access God's word in the Bible (Comfort). Very little has changed
desk. They hold pencils, books, paper and all your school supplies. What is from the traditional classroom set up to the current. Most public schools today are
not taken into consideration is the shapes of the desk, the storage areas twentieth-century adaptations of the schools in the original American colonies (Comfort).
and the desk workspace. After speaking with my son about his classroom Every school building of those that I have interviewed and buildings that I have attended
desk, he noted that he doesn’t have a storage area under his desktop and have a mirrored goal. Classroom after classroom are aligned along each side of a corridor,
must use a basket or supply box to store all his school work. This takes up have disciplined rows of hard chairs symbolizing that have strict attention to create a
serious purpose in the classroom atmosphere.
his desktop working area and is a distraction. This takes away from the
Shuffling children through school ensuring they received their education and
comfort aspect of the classroom and lost space that my son and his peers passing was the focus in the classroom environment. There was no way that the idea of
could be utilizing. how comfort and the physical environment was a very important aspect of children’s
learning experience. When I asked my interviewees’ Bill Haynie and Denise Bryd how they
thought about their physical classroom environment settings, they all noted that it was set
up as uncomfortable on purpose, they felt that the schools they all noted that it was set up
as uncomfortable on purpose, they felt that the schools thought it was a good set up
because it created self-disciplined kids, not pampered softies.
HISTORY OF THE CLASSROOM CONT’D (Furniture Layout)
Children’s development & behaviors within the classroom is a very complex topic. There
are so many factors to identify. Upon my interview with my mentor and internship supervisor
Bill Haynie, he discussed the barriers with acoustics for his autistic daughter. The noise level
for children with autism is a great concern because they have difficulty filtering out background
noise (e.g., noise from a hallway, pencil sharpeners, or water fountain). Children with autism
become agitated and sometimes unruly when confronted with higher noise levels (Quiet
Place). They sometimes must wear noise reduction headphones, so they can concentrate.
When discussing problems within the classroom we have identified that all classrooms
mirror each other. They all follow the same format and layout, not taking into consideration the
many facets that can distract students. Architects take a lot of time and consideration when
they build their massive buildings (Education). Each floor has specific uses and functions,
catered towards the people that consume them daily. It’s time to do the same with classrooms.
Think back to your high school or middle school days. Were there times where you
couldn’t hear the teacher’s lecture? If the acoustics aren’t set up correctly, students tend to
lose focus and get distracted. Considering the variety of teaching methods, many classrooms
have been designed to be open rather than closed. Therefore, identifying appropriate
materials, creating acoustical barriers, and using methods of insulation will reduce distracting
noises. This is such an important aspect, as some students work more comfortably and more Figure 4. Common sources of noise within a classroom
successfully in quiet rather than noisy settings (Quite Place). Therefore, a quiet setting is
generally more beneficial overall, children need to hear the teacher and not be distracted by
outside noises. Ensuring this is not a barrier in this classroom is a key element and would
really take away from the children and the teacher if lessons cannot be heard.
CHILDREN’S DEVELOPMENT
&
BEHAVIORS WITHIN THE CLASSROOM CONT’D (Acoustics & Color)
The ability to concentrate and good acoustics are important planning considerations for the classroom. But, what if the classroom has
bright painted walls and patterns surrounding the students. This then becomes a hinder and a visual distractor within in the classroom. When
defined, color is an important aspect of sight because it provides “better detection of spatial features, highlights specific items, and sets the
mood within interior spaces” (Color). So, depending on what types of colors are displayed throughout the classroom, it can affect the children
and teacher’s moods. A certain color can bring a certain emotion into the classroom and set a good or bad tone, leading to a distraction or
positive learning environment. Human behavior is affected by color. Robert M. Gerard (1957), an early researcher, studied the use of colored
light and its effect on people physically and psychologically. Psychologically, he found that a person’s reaction to color is based on three
precepts: (1) people respond to color with different feelings and emotions, (2) their entire bodies can be affected—autonomic functions,
muscular tension, brain activity, and affective-ideational responses (emotional imaginary response), and (3) they may be affected by previous
learning experiences or their culture (Gerard, 1957). This research reinforces the concept that humans react to color both physically and
psychologically, and people have different responses to color (Color). A simple suggestion of hues of greens and blues can elaborate
sophistication and focus, it also creates a cool and relaxing environment (Child style).
Traditional classrooms have a bland appeal to them when it comes to the color schemes that incase the classroom. White or manila
walls were what Denise Bryd remembers in her classrooms. Her memories of the walls weren’t welcoming, she felt like she was in a prison.
This distracted her learning environment because it made the classroom setting boring and scary at the same time. Not having posters on the
walls or the right type of colors to create the welcoming appeal made her not want to go to class at times. If there is not a positive physical or
psychological color scheme connection within the classroom, a student’s existence or focus could be lost.
STUDENT ATTITUDE & ACHIEVEMENT
WITHIN THE CLASSROOM (Lighting)
Lighting plays a pivotal role in our lives, often without us being aware of it. Altering lighting in a classroom will transform a space and can
even create a dramatic impact on the emotional state within the classroom. People feel more alert, energetic, and positive on a sunny day, a day
marked by bright highlights and crisp shadows. By providing brightness contrast, the lighting designer can create an environment that has the
attributes of a sunny day. In truth, the significant difference between a “dull, dreary” day and a “bright, cheerful” one is the quality of light (Light). An
example of how lighting can affect someone emotions or productivity, from personal a personal experience. While I was stationed on board the USS
GEORGE H.W. BUSH, the whole ship that holds over 5,000 Sailors has fluorescent lights that were as dull as can be. One day I noticed that the
Electricians onboard were changing out the light bulbs during one our underway periods during the day. We work 24/7 hours onboard the ship, it’s
our home. As I completed my shift for the day, I headed to my sleeping area. It was dark by this time, I walked through the main hang bay of the
ship where it gets dark. Now, remember the electricians had replaced the lights earlier that day. Well, they replaced all the lights on the ships with
LED lights. Those lights brought a ray of hope and a smile to my face. We had been underway and away from our families for eight months. For the
first time in a long time, those lights brought warmth into my life. I always think back to those lights and how they affected my whole persona.
Another very warming aspect of light is the great existence of sweet natural sunlight. Not having the sun beam through the windows in a
classroom can illuminate a very negative classroom environment. Through windows we look out at the world and the world looks in at us. The
placement of windows not only is important to the wall composition of the interior but largely determines the fenestration (architectural arrangement
of windows)—a crucial part of the style and character of the exterior (Windows). Denise Bryd spoke of her experiences with windows in such
delight, that it made me smile and think of the warm sunshine. When she was in school, just knowing that when the students were done with their
assignments they could go to the play/activity area by a tall vertical window in the back of the classroom just made her motivated to finish her work,
so she could enjoy the splendors that enticed her as she gazed out the window.
STUDENT ATTITUDE & ACHIEVEMENT
WITHIN THE CLASSROOM (Lighting)
The emotion and sheer happiness can bring into children’s lives is
simply remarkable. Where I grew up in San Bernardino, Ca. windows
were a rare commodity. I lived in a neighborhood where there were gang Even though her room was truly the best classroom
members, drug dealers, you name it. So, some of our portable environment I ever had, the flooring was the worst. It was
classrooms that had windows had a screen with bars over them. The half tile and half carpet. This caused a lot of us to trip over
reason the bars were there was because people liked to break into those the barrier that overlapped the connection of the carpet and
classrooms. Portable classrooms are built a lot more poorly than the flooring. Slips and falls are the leading cause of injury in
functioning classrooms we are used to, so these were targets for people schools, and the choice of flooring has an important role to
to steal our classroom computers and classroom essentials. It wasn’t until play in minimizing the incidence of injuries. Hard surfaces
around high school when one of our English teachers took us outside to often become slippery, especially in wet conditions (as a
read, made me wish that we had true windows in our classrooms, so we result of recent mopping, or snow or rainfall being tracked
could see the beautiful rays of light in our classroom environment. into the building). Carpet offers significantly more traction
As I look back on my lighting experience on board my ship and than hard surface products and reduces the likelihood of
my classrooms, I think of another memory in elementary school. My not- slips and falls occurring as a result. In the event of a fall,
favored teacher Mrs. Wall, she was a woman with mean identifying carpeting can also reduce the risk of injury. Only 17% of
glasses, was always dressed proper with a nice dress and had these falls on carpet result in injury, compared to 46% of falls on
square shaped heels that I will never forget. Though I remember her hard surfaces (Carpet).
mean stature, I do always have fond memories of her Classroom, it was Another aspect to look at when it comes to carpets,
unforgettable. It had its own identity compared to the rest of the teachers I is the spill factor. We always spilled so much water and
ever had. It was clean, organized and welcoming. She always changed paint on the carpet, so it was ruined by the end of the school
out themes in the room to correlate towards what we were learning each year. It was a distracting element but wasn’t too much of a
month and really kept us on our toes. The impact that the classroom had distractor to not love the classroom.
was so profound, that even though I disliked Mrs. Wall, I truly felt save
and at home.
STUDENT ATTITUDE & ACHIEVEMENT
WITHIN THE CLASSROOM (Physical)
It is said that classroom flooring, like other building materials, can enhance the learning environment
and help create the optimal setting for students to achieve (Flooring). The choice of flooring can help manage
ambient noise levels. Hard surface flooring including laminate and vinyl composite tile have a poor acoustic
profile - sound bounces off the surface and reverberates through the classroom space, this was the type of
flooring most of my classrooms growing up had. Luxury vinyl tile offers the best acoustic profile of all hard
surface flooring types thanks to its layered construction - but even that can't match the sound absorption
qualities of carpet (Flooring). As I spoke to many of my Sailors at work and Bill, no one ever mentioned having Figure 7. Flotex
carpet in their classrooms. The acoustic ratings compared to the hard would or tiled flooring is so much more
efficient. The best option for sound absorption is cushion-backed carpet. Carpet tiles with cushion backing
absorb 50% more noise than hardback carpet, which in turn absorbs 3x more noise than hard flooring (Flooring).
Thinking back to the stained carpet in my classroom in Mrs. Walls class, I think of the reasoning behind why
most classes don’t have carpet. As I researched further into the fallback with carpeted classes, it came to my
attention that funding was a major factor that lead towards the less expensive route when I came to flooring
choices.
Factoring expenses into education shouldn’t be a hurdle in our day and age. Even though I grew up in a run-down
neighborhood, I never had to bring my own supplies to school. These days, children like my own must bring items to school. If I
had to do this back when I was in elementary school, I don’t think I would have made it through school because I know my
mother couldn’t afford supplies for all six of her children. The budget size for schools are dwindling down and the physical
classroom setting, like the school supply setting is getting demanding. While I was at one of my sons Christmas school events, I
overheard the teachers talking about bring in their own writing boards and any extra furniture they had to help with the small
budget size they had at their school.
As the digital age expands into the classroom environment, students in lower-income families will struggle to keep up with
their peers academically. Considering the resources available online these days, information found on the internet is outpacing
traditional textbooks. This can cause problems for students without internet access at home and hinder their learning
opportunities (Digital). Digital equipment within the classroom, can also be a hinderance to children that learn well with this type
of instructional delivery method.
THE CLASSROOM PHYSICAL ENVIORNMENT CHANGE
&
POTENTIAL FUTURE
Decentralizing the learning environment and breaking away from the typical desks in a row structure allows the instructor to move freely
throughout the classroom, from student to student, with a purpose, rather than having to continually stand in front of a large group and lecture. This
creates better opportunities for individual instruction as well as the promotion of collaboration amongst students in the classroom, which are two
extremely beneficial tactics of knowledge retention. Separating the classroom into different zones, based on different lesson focusses, promotes
higher spans of attention (Evolution of the Classroom).
When you separate classrooms into different zones you are creating a central area for a specific topic or lesson. This welcomes a collaborative
working environment and an area where you know you will focus solely on the topic at hand. Common working spaces for teachers and students in
this area bring about more ideas and activities that everyone can participate in. But, with every change or idea there are difficulties. Change,
uncertainty, variability, transition and novelty are a reality of life. The extent to which young people effectively respond to this reality will have a
significant bearing on their life course – beyond the influence of other important factors such as resilience and personality (Change). The classroom
environment is a child’s second home, when a structure or a setting is changed within the classroom on them it can affect them mentally and
emotionally.
Encouragingly, research and practice show that young people can successfully adjust their behavior, thought, and emotion – with some at-risk
or underachieving youth perhaps requiring more intensive and sustained support to do this. Young people can be taught how to be more adaptable,
and then in turn better embrace the opportunities of their ever-changing world (Change).
Going through change can be a big deal, but one of the biggest changes in the classroom environment is how technology has shaped the way
children learn. The invention of the chalkboard in 1890 heralded a new era for learning, and when the pencil became widespread in 1900, this signaled
an end to the inkpot and a new dawn for easier writing. When the radio was introduced in the 1920s, this also provided a new style of learning, while
the invention of the overhead projector in 1930 enabled students to view images on a screen. The arrival of the photocopier in the late 1960s made
copying learning materials easier in the classroom, and the advent of computers in the 1980s completely revolutionized the classroom environment.
These days, learning is increasingly digitalized, with the use of mobile technology and iPads to individualize learning, provide feedback and conduct
research. Teachers can use technology to monitor students' work from their desk, without needing to walk around the classroom peering over their
shoulders.
The new technology-based change within the classroom affects the physical classroom arrangement. With the ipads and monitoring of
students, there is less need for desks with drawers or cubby holders underneath their desks to hold all their pencils and supplies. The furniture for this
type of digital environment must be noted and the focus on furniture should be approached with a minimal focus in mind.
SUMMARY
With so much time being consumed in the classroom environment, are the
students surrounding environments affecting them emotionally and mentally in the
right capacity? The classroom is their second home. It’s where they meet their
friends that they keep forever, a place they learn where they love math, art, or
science. It is the place where you learn the most fascinating things about life. The
encompassing shell of that 800-sqare foot classroom holds all these moments
and helps create these forever memories.
With the memories that we will never forget from the schools we attended,
we must never forget the historical aspects and characteristics of the physical
classroom environment that worked. The classroom’s furniture, walls, lighting and
enticing aesthetics that made us feel warm inside. We must take the reins of our
curiosity to improve the physical environment within the classroom. It’s our duty to
be mindful of the influences on the auctions, thoughts and emotions that take hold
when designing a classroom. These very intricate details and empathies will
affect the interior space and function of a classroom that will grow into the future
and time of children’s lives.
“There is certainly strong evidence that this is true in early childhood; we
have in recent years learned a great deal about the effects that adverse
environments have on children's early development. And there is growing
evidence that even in middle and high school, children's noncognitive capacities
are primarily a reflection of the environments in which they are embedded,
including, centrally, their school environment.” (Classroom)
WORKS CITED
Change, Coping with change: teaching adaptability will help kids grow https://theconversation.com/coping-with-change-teaching-adaptability-will-help-kids-grow-19726,
Chesapeake, Chesapeake School Board OKs plan for new school to replace Great Bridge Primary, https://pilotonline.com/news/local/education/article_6118ac38-c4ad-5b88-
bdfc-08b750e75a3c.html
Child Style, Tinder-Durik, Amy, “Ideas & Projects for children’s spaces”, Better Homes and Gardens Magazine
WORKS CITED
Classroom, The Physical Classroom Environment: Why Your Classroom Need Not Be Pretty, https://davestuartjr.com/physical-classroom-environment/,
Color, Nussbaumer, L. L. Human Factors in the Built Environment. [The Art Institutes]. Retrieved from https://digitalbookshelf.aionline.edu/#/books/9781609019433/
Digital, How Budget Cuts Hurt Students and Teachers (And What to Do About It), http://inservice.ascd.org/how-budget-cuts-hurt-students-and-teachers-and-what-to-do-about-it/,
Education, How to Break Free of Our 19th-Century Factory-Model Education System, https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/05/how-to-break-free-of-our-19th-
century-factory-model-education-system/256881/
Flooring, How To Choose The Right Flooring For Elementary School Classrooms, https://blog.millikencarpet.com/how-to-choose-the-right-flooring-for-elementary-school-classrooms,
Interviewee Bill Haynie, Jan. 2nd, 2018, Interview of the classroom setting and how it affects children.
Light, Gordon, G. Interior Lighting for Designers. [The Art Institutes]. Retrieved from https://digitalbookshelf.aionline.edu/#/books/9781118415061/
Quiet Place, Nussbaumer, L. L. Human Factors in the Built Environment. [The Art Institutes]. Retrieved from https://digitalbookshelf.aionline.edu/#/books/9781609019433/
Students, How does your school's physical environment affect students?, https://www.dudesolutions.com/community/discover/blogs/how-does-your-schools-physical-environment
Figure 5. How Lighting Affects the Productivity of Your Workers, https://onlinemba.unc.edu/blog/how-lighting-affects-productivity/, web