Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Mental illness refers to a wide range of mental health conditions — disorders that affect your
mood, thinking and behavior. Examples of mental illness include depression, anxiety
disorders, schizophrenia, eating disorders and addictive behaviors. According to WHO
around 20% of the world's children and adolescents have mental disorders or problems,
mental and substance use disorders are the leading cause of disability worldwide, and Over
800 000 people die due to suicide every year and suicide is the second leading cause of death
in 15-29-year-olds.
It has been well established now that Cultural dynamics play and important role in shaping
the perceptions, beliefs and practises of people towards mental illness and its Treatment
(Satcher,2001). Every society has its own culture and social norms which is distinct from
others and these cultural and social norms define the person as normal or deviant ( Siewert,
1999). It has been seen that the Culture influences the Epidemiology, Phenomenology,
outcome, and treatment of mental illness (Viswanath and Chaturvedi, 2012).
Theoretical Perspective
To better understand how culture influences mental illness there are three theoretical
perspectives explained by Berry in 1995, which are:
1. The absolutist view assumes that culture has no role in the expression of behaviour.
This view implies that the presentation, expression, and meaning of mental illness are
the same, regardless of culture.
2. Relativist view with the view that all human behaviour (including the expression of
mental illness) ought to be interpreted within a cultural context.
3. The universalist view takes more of a middle position, with the assumption that
specific behaviours or mental illnesses are common to all people, but the
development, expression, and response to the condition is influenced by culture. A
study was done by Draguns in 1990 where it was confirmed that though sad mood,
anxiety, lack of energy and tension was reported as the common symptoms of
depression across cultures, the westerns reported guilt whereas non westerns somatic
symptoms in addition to the common symptoms.
3. Pathoplastic effects- refer to the ways in which culture contributes to the modeling or
‘plastering’ of the manifestations of psychopathology. Culture shapes symptom
manifestations at the level of the content presented. The content of delusions, auditory
hallucinations, obsessions, or phobias is subject to the environmental context in which
the pathology is manifested.
For instance, an individual’s grandiose delusions may be characterized by the
belief that he is a Russian emperor, Jesus Christ, Buddha, the president of the
United States, or the prime minister of the United Kingdom, depending on
which figure is more popular or important in his society.
5. Pathofacilitative effects- imply that, although cultural factors do not change the
manifestation of the psychopathology too much – that is, the clinical picture can still
be recognized and categorized without difficulty in the existing classification system
– cultural factors do contribute significantly to the frequent occurrence of certain
mental disorders in a society. In other words, the disorder potentially exists and is
recognized globally, yet, due to cultural factors, it becomes prevalent in certain
cultures at particular times. Thus, ‘facilitating’ effects make it easier for certain
psychopathologies to develop
A liberal attitude towards weapons control may result in more weapon-related
violence or homicidal behaviour (Westermeyer, 1973); cultural permission to
consume alcohol freely may increase the prevalence of drinking problems.
6. Pathoreactive effects- indicate that, although cultural factors do not directly affect
the manifestation people’s beliefs and understanding of the disorders and mould their
‘reactions’ towards them.
An example of pathoreactive effects is susto. Susto is a Spanish word that
literally means ‘fright’. The term is widely used by people in Latin America to
refer to the condition of loss of soul (Rubel, 1964; Rubel et al., 1985). Susto is
based on the folk belief that every individual possesses a soul, but, through
certain experiences, such as being frightened or startled, a person’s soul may
depart from the body. As a result, the soul-lost person will manifest certain
morbid mental conditions and illness behaviour.
Indian Perspective
India is culturally diverse country where it is believed that, in every twenty five miles we
come in contact of people from a diverse culture( Srivastava, 2002).
3. Biochemical theory- Shows that chemical imbalances occur in the brain and are
causes of mental illness.
So the treatment sought by the people depends on their beliefs about the cause of mental
illness, people who believe in supernatural causes for mental illness prefer traditional healing
practises to address mental illness. Upto about 70% to 80% of the population of mentally ill
belong to rural areas and first visit religious places for their treatment( Trivedi and Sethi,
1979; Thara et al., 1998). People who have the knowledge of modern medicines prefer to
consult with the Psychiatrist for their treatment.
Disorders- Prevalence, phenomenology and outcome
1.Schizophrenia
.The prevalence of schizophrenia in “least developed” countries was significantly lower than
in the “emerging” and “developed” countries. Indian studies have suggested that the
prevalence of schizophrenia is lower in India than in the West. One reason for this difference
could be underreporting. Indian studies have found FRS to be generally culture free.
However, there is a lower occurrence of FRS in non-Western countries. FRS were present in
35% in India ( Avasthi, 2012).The Madras longitudinal study and the study of factors
associated with course and outcome of schizophrenia demonstrated that two-thirds of
schizophrenia patients in India have partial to full remission of symptoms (Thara, 2004). Kala
and Wig, 1978 studied the content of delusions in paranoid schizophrenia in Indian patients
and found that the common themes were of murder, assault, magic and religion.
2. Affective disorders
The prevalence of affective disorders has been found to be lower in most Indian studies than
the West ( Chandrashekhar, 2007). A comparison of depression in Western and non-Western
societies noted that disorders of conduct and somatic complaints were more common in non-
Western cultures (Venkoba Rao, 1966).The outcome of affective disorders has been found to
be favourable in India than in developed countries. In a 4-year follow-up of first-episode
manic patients from Ranchi, 40% of the patients did not have any recurrences and 25% had
one recurrence( Khess et al., 1997).
Religious and contamination concerns and repeating compulsions may be more common in
Muslims than Christians due the emphasis on religious cleansing rituals and the practices of
repeating religious phrases (to ward off sin and blasphemous thought) that forms an integral
component of Islamic religion and culture(Okasha et al, 1996).
###########################################################################
References: