Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A Comparative Analysis
PREFACE
Businesses face ever increasing pressure on costs and growing Financing requirements as a
result of intensive competition in globalize markets. Many of them are therefore considering
ways of making themselves more efficient. In identifying possible options it is important
not to focus exclusively on income and expense items, but also to take the balance sheet
into account.
Improvements to the existing capital structure can free up valuable resources and bring
increased efficiency. Active working capital management is an extremely effective way to
increase enterprise value. Optimizing working capital results in a rapid release of liquid
resources and contributes to an improvement in free cash flow and to a permanent reduction
in inventory and capital costs.
The attempt is aimed to analyze the various aspects of working capital management of
Ranbaxy and compare it with that of Dr Reddy’s and with industry standards.
By adopting various calculation and analysis and then making interpretation with the
solution of specific problem, best efforts on giving appropriate suggestion to the company
have been made.
To this context various methods and techniques like ratio analysis DuPont analysis,
statistical tool, Correlation analysis, and working towards the optimal level of working
capital, estimation of working capital and various ratios have been used to draw an exact
picture of company.
Page 2 of 91
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Abstract 06
Introduction 07
Industry Profile 08
Research and Development 11
Organizational profile 14
Working capital 32
Defining the problem 39
Literature review 41
Methodology 43
Financial performance of Ranbaxy
Liquidity Ratios 48
Profitability Ratios 51
Liquidity Analysis 53
Ratio Analysis 63
Liquidity Ranking 76
Credit Analysis & Policies 81
Conclusion
Limitations 89
Summary of findings 90
Recommendations and Suggestions 92
References 95
Page 3 of 91
A project work is a mandatory requirement for the Business Management Programme. This
type of study aims at exposing the young prospective executive to the actual business world.
This project gives me knowledge about the working capital of the company. Working
capital refers to the funds required for day to day operations of the organization. It is very
effective way to judge a company’s cash flow prospects, as cash is like blood life for any
company.
The report initially begins with the company profile, followed by the detailed analysis of
company, like businesses of the company, products offered by the company, financials of
the company, etc
The report involves a lot of research to understand what exactly working capital is, why
companies require working capital, what are the ideal ratios for Working Capital a
Company should maintain, etc. The purpose is to develop an action plan that creates
such a working capital that will upgrades and standardize the quality of business
analysis.
Various tools, including financial tools, are used in this project to calculate and compare the
financial position of the company, e.g. ratio analysis, DuPont analysis, SWOT analysis, etc.
Page 4 of 91
INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this project is to examine the trends in working capital and its impact on
firm’s performance. The trend in working capital needs and profitability of firm is
examined to identify the causes for any significant differences.
The rest of the report is organized as follows: It starts with the Industry profile & then a
detailed introduction of the company. The following section of the report looks briefly at
the theoretical underpinnings and the relevant literature which attempts to explain the link
between poor performance and working capital management.
After that, the analysis part covers in depth analysis of working capital of Ranbaxy. Finally
the conclusion is made & it has been observed that the overall structure of working capital
of the co. is good and it is a growing concern. The company uses various techniques to
maintain its working capital.
Page 5 of 91
INDUSTRY PROFILE
Industry Definition
“The Indian pharmaceutical industry is a success story providing employment for millions
and ensuring that essential drugs at affordable prices are available to the vast population
of this sub-continent.”
Richard Gerster
The Indian Pharmaceutical Industry today is in the front rank of India’s science-based
industries with wide ranging capabilities in the complex field of drug manufacture and
technology.
Facts about the Role of Pharmaceutical Industry in Indian Gross Domestic Product (GDP):
• Indian Pharmaceutical Industry ranks fourth in the world, pertaining to the volume
of sales.
• The estimated worth of the Indian Pharmaceutical Industry is US$ 6 billion.
• The growth rate of the industry is about 13% per year.
• Almost most 70% of the domestic demand for bulk drugs is catered by the Indian
Pharma Industry.
• The Pharma Industry in India produces around 20% to 24% of the global Generic
drugs.
• The Indian Pharmaceutical Industry is one of the biggest producers of the Active
Pharmaceutical Ingredients (API) in the international arena.
• The Indian Pharma sector leads the science-based industries in the country.
• Around 40% of the total pharmaceutical produce is exported.
• 55% of the total exports constitute of formulations and the other 45% comprises of
bulk drugs.
• The Indian Pharma Industry includes small scaled, medium scaled, large scaled
players, which totals nearly 300 different companies.
• As per the present growth rate, the Indian Pharma Industry is expected to be a US$
20 billion industry by the year 2015.
• The Indian Pharmaceutical sector is also expected to be among the Top Ten
Pharma based markets in the world in the next ten years
• The sales of the Indian Pharma Industry would worth US$ 43 billion within the next
decade.
Page 6 of 91
• The multinational companies, investing in research and development in India may
save up to 30% to 50% of the expenses incurred
• The cost of hiring a research chemist in the US is five times higher than its Indian
counterpart.
• The manufacturing cost of pharmaceutical products in India is nearly half of the cost
incurred in US.
• The cost of performing clinical trials in India is one tenth of the cost incurred in
US.
• The cost of performing research in India is one eighth of the cost incurred in US.
Following the de-licensing of the pharmaceutical industry, industrial licensing for most of
the drugs and pharmaceutical products has been done away with. Manufacturers are free to
produce any drug duly approved by the Drug Control Authority. Technologically strong and
totally self-reliant, the pharmaceutical industry in India has low costs of production, low
R&D costs, innovative scientific manpower, strength of national laboratories and an
increasing balance of trade. The Pharmaceutical Industry, with its rich scientific talents and
research capabilities, supported by Intellectual Property Protection regime is well set to take
on the international market.
ADVANTAGE IN INDIA
Competent workforce: India has a pool of personnel with high managerial and technical
competence as also skilled workforce. It has an educated work force and English is
commonly used. Professional services are easily available.
Cost-effective chemical synthesis: Its track record of development, particularly in the area
of improved cost-beneficial chemical synthesis for various drug molecules is excellent. It
provides a wide variety of bulk drugs and exports sophisticated bulk drugs.
Legal & Financial Framework: India has a 53 year old democracy and hence has a solid
legal framework and strong financial markets. There is already an established international
industry and business community.
Page 7 of 91
Consolidation: For the first time in many years, the international pharmaceutical industry is
finding great opportunities in India. The process of consolidation, which has become a
generalized phenomenon in the world pharmaceutical industry, has started taking place in
India.
India's US$ 3.1 billion pharmaceutical industry is growing at the rate of 14 percent per year.
It is one of the largest and most advanced among the developing countries.
Over 20,000 registered pharmaceutical manufacturers exist in the country. The domestic
pharmaceuticals industry output is expected to exceed Rs260 billion in the financial year
2002, which accounts for merely 1.3% of the global pharmaceutical sector. Of this, bulk
drugs will account for Rs 54 bn (21%) and formulations, the remaining Rs 210 bn (79%). In
financial year 2001, imports were Rs 20 bn while exports were Rs87 bn.
The above graph shows the percentage of pharmaceutical products export by various
countries.
(SOURCE Competitiveness of the Indian pharmaceutical industry in the new product patent
regime a report by FICCI)
Page 8 of 91
RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
Drug discovery and development is very expensive; of all compounds investigated for use
in humans only a small fraction are eventually approved in most nations by government
appointed medical institutions or boards, who have to approve new drugs before they can be
marketed in those countries. Each year, only about 25 truly novel drugs (New chemical
entities) are approved for marketing. This approval comes only after heavy investment in
pre-clinical development and clinical trials, as well as a commitment to ongoing safety
monitoring. Drugs which fail part-way through this process often incur large costs, while
generating no revenue in return. If the cost of these failed drugs is taken into account, the
Page 9 of 91
cost of developing a successful new drug (New chemical entity or NCE), has been estimated
at about 1 billion USD.
A study by the consulting firm Bain & Company reported that the cost for discovering,
developing and launching (which factored in marketing and other business expenses) a new
drug (along with the prospective drugs that fail) rose over a five year period to nearly $1.7
billion in 2003.
These estimates also take into account the opportunity cost of investing capital many years
before revenues are realized (see Time-value of money). Because of the very long time
needed for discovery, development, and approval of pharmaceuticals, these costs can
accumulate to nearly half the total expense. Some approved drugs, such as those based on
re-formulation of an existing active ingredient (also referred to as Line-extensions) are
much less expensive to develop. The consumer advocacy group Public Citizen suggests on
its web site that the actual cost is under $200 million, about 29% of which is spent on
FDArequired clinical trials. For me-too-drugs and for generics, the cost are even less.
Calculations and claims in this area are controversial because of the implications for
regulation and subsidization of the industry through federally funded research grants.
There have been increasing accusations and findings that clinical trials conducted or funded
by pharmaceutical companies are much more likely to report positive results for the
preferred medication.
In response to public outcry about specific cases in which unfavorable data from
pharmaceutical company-sponsored research was suppressed, the Pharmaceutical Research
and Manufacturers of America have published new guidelines urging companies to report
all findings and limit the financial involvement in drug companies of researchers. As a
result of this public outcry and Pharma response the US congress signed into law a bill
which requires phase II and phase III clinical trials to be registered by the sponsor on the
NIH website
In the United States, new pharmaceutical products must be approved by the FDA as being
both safe and effective. This process generally involves submission of an Investigational
new drug filing with sufficient pre-clinical data to support proceeding with human trials.
Page 10 of 91
Following IND approval, three phases of progressively larger human clinical trials may be
conducted. Phase I generally studies toxicity using healthy volunteers. Phase II can include
Pharmacokinetics and Dosing in patients, and Phase III is a very large study of efficacy in
the intended patient population.
A fourth phase of post-approval surveillance is also often required due to the fact that even
the largest clinical trials cannot effectively predict the prevalence of rare side-effects.
Postmarketing surveillance ensures that after marketing the safety of a drug is monitored
closely. In certain instances, its indication may need to be limited to particular patient
groups, and in others the substance is withdrawn from the market completely. Questions
continue to be raised regarding the standard of both the initial approval process, and
subsequent changes to product labelling (it may take many months for a change identified in
post-approval surveillance to be reflected in product labelling) and this is an area where
congress is active.
The FDA provides information about approved drugs at the Orange Book site.] In the UK,
the British National Formulary is the core guide for pharmacists and clinicians.
Orphan drugs
Industry revenues
For the first time ever, in 2006, global spending on prescription drugs topped $643 billion,
even as growth slowed somewhat in Europe and North America. The United States accounts
for almost half of the global pharmaceutical market, with $289 billion in annual sales
followed by the EU and Japan. Emerging markets such as China, Russia, South Korea and
Mexico outpaced that market, growing a huge 81 percent. US profit growth was maintained
even whilst other top industries saw slowed or no growth. Despite this, "...the
pharmaceutical industry is — and has been for years — the most profitable of all businesses
in the U.S. In the annual Fortune 500 survey, the pharmaceutical industry topped the list of
the most profitable industries, with a return of 17% on revenue."
Pfizer's cholesterol pill Lipitor remains the best-selling drug in the world for the fifth year in
a row. Its annual sales were $12.9 billion, more than twice as much as its closest
competitors: Plavix, the blood thinner from Bristol-Myers Squibb and Sanofi-Aventis;
Nexium, the heartburn pill from AstraZeneca; and Advair, the asthma inhaler from
GlaxoSmithKline.
Page 11 of 91
Teradata Magazine predicted that by 2007, $40 billion in U.S. sales could be lost at the top
10 pharma companies as a result of slowdown in R&D innovation and the expiry of patents
on major products, with 19 blockbuster drugs losing patent.
Indian companies need to attain the right product-mix for sustained future growth. Core
competencies will play an important role in determining the future of many Indian
pharmaceutical companies in the post product-patent regime after 2005. Indian companies,
in an effort to consolidate their position, will have to increasingly look at merger and
acquisition options of either companies or products. This would help them to offset loss of
new product options, improve their R&D efforts and improve distribution to penetrate
markets.
Research and development has always taken the back seat amongst Indian pharmaceutical
companies. In order to stay competitive in the future, Indian companies will have to refocus
and invest heavily in R&D.
The Indian pharmaceutical industry also needs to take advantage of the recent advances in
biotechnology and information technology. The future of the industry will be determined by
how well it markets its products to several regions and distributes risks, its forward and
backward integration capabilities, its R&D, its consolidation through mergers and
acquisitions, co-marketing and licensing agreements.
Page 12 of 91
INTRODUCTION TO RANBAXY
COMPANY PROFILE
“A company empowered by one mission –to place itself on the world map. An
enterprise propelled by one force-that synergizes its energies to charter unexplored
markets. Organizations fuelled by one dream-to transform competition into opportunity.”
Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd. was incorporated in June 1961, in the name of M/S LEPITIT
RANBAXY LABORATORIES LTD and it commenced its business in MARCH 1962, in
technical and financial collaboration with an international company named LEPTIT SPA,
MILAN, ITALY.
Ranbaxy Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. merged with “Leptit Ranbaxy Laboratories Pvt. Ltd.” in
1962 Ranbaxy and company also merged with this company in 1966. The collaboration
arrangement with M/S LEPTIT was terminated in 1966; after which Indian nationals
acquired the entire share capital of the company.
Therefore the word Leptit was removed from the name of the company. The name is known
as RANBAXY LABORATORIES LIMITED. In 1973 the company issued shares to the
general public and became a full fledged PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANY.
Page 13 of 91
Today, Ranbaxy has emerged as a Leading
Pharmaceutical Company on the Indian firmament,
with the second largest market share and enjoys an
enviable reputation for its high standard of ethics and
quality around its core strength of anti-infective, it has
produced new brands in emerging therapeutic areas
like cardiovascular, central nervous system and
nutritional. Supporting this expansion, the company
has invested in world class manufacturing
infrastructure that leverages India’s comparative cost
Advantage and skilled manpower, while delivering international quality.
The company’s drive for Internationalism is guided by the well planned brand strategy that
covers some of the world emerging markets like China, Central Europe and Latin America .
Its position today is in league of the Top Ten Pharmaceutical companies of three world an
decent ranking as the eleventh largest company in the international generics space is the
resounding endorsement of its strategic mind.
It is clear that for a long time, the dominant share of revenues of the company would
continue to come from the ever expanding global generics market. Hence the intent of
Ranbaxy mission is to achieve a sustained growth rate through the continuous pursuit of
innovation phase one trials for pervasion, a compound for treating prosthetic males have
been completed. Phase 1 trials with clafrinast, an asthma compound is an important step
towards research based value creation.
This company also had success with Ciplofloxacine, an ingenious form, created through the
novel drug delivery systems research. As the demand of the bulk drugs inside the country
and abroad was increasingly rapidly a new, plant was set up at Toansa near Ropar in 1987.
This was a higher capacity plant designed to cater to the present and future needs, initially
antibiotics like Ampicillin, Trihydrate and Doxycycline were manufactured.
Later, on the other drugs like Cephalexin monohydrate and Ranitidine were also prepared.
The plant at Toansa was designed to meet the stringent standards set by the Food and
Drug
Administration (FDA) of U.S.A. This plant has been approved by FDA and this will open
up American and other newer markets for Ranbaxy’s products
.
At present Ranbaxy have four plants for the manufacture of bulk drugs two at Mohali, one
at Dewas (M.P) AND Another at Toansa near ROPAR. At present, Ranbaxy is the second
most Indian company engaged in the manufacturing of Pharmaceuticals, Bulk Drugs and
Fine Chemicals.
RANBAXY’s vast range of highly pure laboratory reagent and chemicals enjoy a place of
pride in the market. IT trends, has rebuilt As a step towards leveraging information for value
creation using its information backbone around an ERP application, along the focus on
Page 14 of 91
reengineering several business processes around the internet and has putting place business
solutions that challenge existing ways of doing Business. The undying spirit of the
company’s human assets and their intensive competitive and entrepreneurial energy has
played a great part in transforming the company into a multicultural and multiracial team.
Today, Ranbaxy is the largest exporter accounting for 12% of the industry exports
pharmaceutical substance and dosages forms to over 50 countries with the internationals
sales comprising of 45% of the total turnover.
Page 15 of 91
VISION GARUDA
During the year 2002, the company has evolved a 10-year vision till 2012, for sustaining
significant growth consistent with its mission to be an international research based
Pharmaceutical Company, under the rubric ‘Vision Garuda’, with increasing emphasis on
Novel Drug Delivery Systems Research (DDR).
In licensing and out licensing, relationship with other important pharmaceutical entities,
expansion of manufacturing facilities both in India and strategic overseas locations,
revamping of organizational structures to cater to the wider and more dispersed span of
operations, and streamlining and standardizing the business processes through out the global
organization, are other areas that receive focus and attention of management on priority.
Page 16 of 91
Mission
Vision
Aspirations
Page 17 of 91
BRAZIL : Ranbaxy S.P. Medicamentos Ltd.
CHINA : Ranbaxy (Guangzhou China) Ltd.
EGYPT : Ranbaxy Egypt Ltd.
GERMANY : Basics Gmb H.
HONG KONG : Ranbaxy (Hong Kong) Ltd.
INDIA : Rexcel pharmaceuticals Ltd., Solus
pharmaceuticals Ltd., Vidyut Travel
Services ltd.
IRELAND : Ranbaxy Ireland Ltd.
MALAYSIA : Ranbaxy (Malaysia) Sdn. Bhd.
NETHERLANDS : Ranbaxy Pharmaceuticals B.V.
NIGERIA : Ranbaxy Nigeria Ltd.
PANAMA : Ranbaxy Panama SA.
POLAND : Ranbaxy Poland Sp. Zo.
SOUTH AFRICA : Ranbaxy (SA) (Pty.) Ltd.
THAILAND : Unichem pharmaceuticals LTD.,
Unichem Distributors Ltd. Part,
Ranbaxy Unichem CO.Ltd.
U.K : Ranbaxy (UK) Ltd
USA : Ranbaxy pharmaceuticals Inc. Ohm
Laboratories Inc.,
Ranbaxy Schein Pharma, LLC
VIETNAM : Ranbaxy Vietnam Company Ltd.
Page 18 of 91
ALLIED BUSINESSES
The Animal Health division saw an encouraging growth despite the prevailing poor market
conditions. The division grew at twice the growth rate recorded in the industry. On the basis
of having a vast dome satiated animal population, the livestock, poultry business and pets
business are among the fastest growing sectors in India. A vast infrastructure of veterinary
colleges, agricultural institutes, technologists and researchers are helping farmers to source
healthy, cost effective products. In conjunction with the present scenario, the AHC division
of Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited has introduced several latest generation products.
Diagnostics
The diagnostics division has aggressively focused on market expansion activities based on
strategy of reliability, quality products and efficient service.
Introduction of products in ‘Point of Care’ markets has expanded market presence and over
the next 1 – 2 years this segment will see considerable expansion in line with world trends.
The Dade Behring segment has increased its installation base by 60% in leading hospitals
and laboratories. Plans are afoot for the introduction of more parameters for the ‘Point of
Care’ market and the launch of Special
Page 19 of 91
Chemistries, a range of drug assays, plus an entry into automated microbiology in both the
Base and Dade Behring business areas.
The company has also witnessed significant milestones in the area of Novel Drug Delivery
Systems (NDDS). The company has entered into strategic business arrangements with
companies such as Bayer AG, Glaxo-Wellcome, Eli-Lilly etc. for production and co-
marketing operations. Many innovative developments have been taking place in recent
times. The company’s research team is capable of developing one NDDS product every 12
to 18 months. Also, two new products: Roletra-D and Altiva-D, will soon be launched in
India.
In order to expand and promote global growth, the company opened several new markets
during the year, notably in Brazil, where 25 filings were undertaken in a span of 2-3
months.
The company has planned to build and protect intellectual property with the help of IPC,
which addresses all matters pertaining to patents. CQA supervises the implementation of
standard operating procedures (SOP) and ensures compliance to corporate quality assurance
policy in all technological operations of the organization. The company is committed to
invest 6% of the sales in R and D by 2003, of which 7% of the expenditure will be
earmarked for research on New Drug Discovery and Novel Drug Delivery Systems. There
will be continuous emphasis on augmenting R and D performance and productivity with
advanced scientific and technological tools.
Page 20 of 91
VALUES OF RANBAXY LABORATORIES LIMITED
Page 21 of 91
VARIOUS DIVISIONS OF RANBAXY LABORATORIES LTD.
1. India and Middle East 2. Europe, CIS and Africa 3. Asia Pacific and Latin
America 4. North America
Page 22 of 91
JOINT VENTURE OF THE COMPANY.
Page 23 of 91
BRIEF INTRO OF RANBAXY PLANTS IN INDIA
In the chemical division, various bulk drugs are manufactured. The chemical division had
three units in Punjab. One is located at Toansa, two are located at Mohali and one unit is
located at Dewas near Indore in Madhya Pradesh, where Ciprofloxacine is manufactured. In
the plant of the chemical division, various drugs like Antibiotics, Anti-malarial,
Antibacterial and Anti-ulcer are manufactured. One of the older plants of Ranbaxy was
closed after the accident in June 2003.the second one is still working
The 1991, the Toansa plant started functioning in 1992 and the Dewas plant started
functioning in 1999. Various plant heads independently manage all these plants.
In each unit, separate facilities with respect to the manufacture of drugs, along with their
manufacturing areas have been provided. This is required to reduce the chances of any cross
contamination under the drug laws and to comply with good manufacturing practices.
At Mohali plant, separate blocks have been provided for the preparation of each drug .The
Toansa, Mohali and Dewas plants are planned in such a way that their system, facilities,
manufacturing practices and standards meet the requirements of FDA. Mohali Plant also
mainly in the manufacturing of Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (API). The Plant is
divided into two plant areas A8 and A9
Page 24 of 91
THE VARIOUS DEPARTMENTS
The basic function of the human resource department in the modern corporate world is
knowledge management. The HR department strives to maintain cohesiveness among
employees. It also ensures interdepartmental cooperation in achieving targets. The appraisal
system is also taken care by this department. The HR department delves deep into the
employee’s psyche to analyze the positives and negatives of each employee, so that a proper
system of delegation and / or empowerment can be evolved.
Finance Department
The finance department takes care of the regular financial needs of the company it ensures
proper allocation of funds and takes care of the working capital requirements. It verifies
capital raised by different departments and sends them for approval to the higher authorities.
Stores Department
The function of this department is to provide adequate and proper storage and preservation
of various items to meet the demand of various other departments by proper issues and
maintaining accounts of consumption. It also keeps a track of stock accumulation and
abnormal consumption.
As the name suggests, this department identifies new projects and helps in erecting them.
This department also undertakes major modifications of equipment.
ERP Department
ERP department helps to integrate the entire enterprise starting from the supplier to the
customer, covering financial and human resources. This will enable the enterprise to
increase productivity by reducing costs. It also ensures a single solution to the information
needs of the whole organization.
Production Department
Page 25 of 91
Laboratories Limited has increased the investment in the production department. It is the
most important department of the company and has the following objectives:
Engineering Department
Purchase Department
The purchase department provides material to the factory without which the wheels of
machines cannot move. The various functions performed by this department include:
Securing good vendor performance, including prompt deliveries of supplies of acceptable
qualities.
1. To develop satisfactory sources of supply and maintaining good relationships with
the suppliers.
2. To pay reasonably low prices.
The purpose of QC & QA departments is to ensure that the desired quality standard is
achieved. It also ensures that the processing or fabrication of material conforms to the
specific characteristics selected, to assure that the resulting product will in fact perform its
intended function.
Page 26 of 91
PRODUCT REVIEW
Ranbaxy’s therapeutic width covers five of the top six categories including
Anti-infective, Gastrointestinal, Nutritionals, Cardiovascular, Central Nervous System,
Respiratory, Dermatological and others. While anti-infective contribute 56% of the total
sales, Ranbaxy’s other brands like Simvotin and Storvas in the cardiovascular segment,
Serlift in CNS and Revital and Riconia in Nutritionals, are on their way to success in
multiple markets. During Jan - Dec 2000, amongst the top products of Ranbaxy, Sporidex
(Cephalexin) was the Number 1 brand, closely followed by Cifran (Ciprofloxacin).
Anti - Infectives
Anti- infective has been the main driver of Ranbaxy’s sales. The important brands in this
category are Cifran (Ciprofloxacin), Sporidex (Ciphalexin), Enhancin (Amoxyclav), Crixan
(Clarithromycin), Vercef (Cefaclor), Oframax (Ceftriaxone), Cepodem (Cefpodoxime
Proxetil), Zanocin (Ofloxacin), Ceroxim (Cefuroxime Axetil), and Loxof (Levofloxacin).
Cifran (Ciprofloxacin) is the key brand in the anti- infective portfolio, with estimated sales
of US $ 32 Mn, currently being marketed in 15 countries.
Sporidex is another leading brand in Ranbaxy’s product portfolio with worldwide annual
sales of US $ 35 Mn. It is available in eight different dosage forms including capsules, dry
powder for suspension, redimix, dispersible tablets, paediatric drops, soft gelatin capsules,
sachet and advanced formulation for twice-daily administration. It is currently marketed in
15 countries. In India, Sporidex is the leading brand with a market share of 36% of the
Cephalexin segment.
Keflor is available in seven different dosage forms and is the third-largest selling brand for
Ranbaxy worldwide. The dosage forms list includes capsules, dry syrup, modified release
tablets, dispersible tablets, drops and redimix.
Page 27 of 91
Cepodem is currently available in three different countries outside India, and will be rolled
out to 13 different countries in the near future.
Cardiovasculars
Cardiovascular is projected to be the second-best category for Ranbaxy. Statins have been
the key drivers for this segment. The sale of Simvastatin has grown substantially in the past
few years, a trend that is likely to continue in the future. In India, Simvotin (Simvastatin) is
the market leader in the cholesterol reducer segment. Another leading brand in this category
is Storvas (Atorvastatin). Storvas has been one of the fastest-ever to enter the top-300 brands
list of the Indian pharma industry. Other global cardiovascular brands are Covance (Losartan)
and Caslot (Carvedilol).
The Central Nervous Segment is one of the important focus areas identified by
Ranbaxy, with Serlift being the key brand. In India, Serlift is number 1 amongst Sertraline
brands. New product introductions will be drivers of growth in this category.
Gastrointestinal
Currently, gastrointestinal drugs are the second-largest category for Ranbaxy. The key
brands in this category include Histac and Romesac. The current annual sales of Ranitidine
are estimated to be around US $ 16 Mn and the product is marketed in more than 20
countries.
Rheumatologicals
The first generation Cox-2 inhibitors principally drive worldwide growth in rheumatology.
This category is estimated to grow exponentially for Ranbaxy, with brands like Celecoxib.
This year, Rofibax (Rofecoxib) introduced in India, has established itself as a leader in the
Cox-2 inhibitor category and has overtaken all Celecoxib brands. It has been identified as a
key Global brand for the future.
Nutritonals
Nutritionals have been a major contributor to Ranbaxy’s sales. Two of the important
products in this category are Revital and Riconia. With annual sales estimated at about US $
10 Mn, Revital contributes a significant share of total sales. It is a leading brand in India
and has done exceedingly well in some parts of the world as an OTC product.
Page 28 of 91
Dermatologicals
The dermatology category is mainly driven by India region and is likely to show a good
growth pattern in the future. Some of the key brands doing well in this segment are
Mobizox, Silverex, Moisturex, etc.
INTRODUCTION
As levers of financial management go, none bears more weight than working capital. The
viability of every business activity rests on daily changes in receivables, inventory and
payables. It’s the lifeblood of the business, and every manager’s primary task to keep it
moving and put shareholders capital to work efficiently and effectively.
Working Capital is the capital used for the day-to-day operations in the organization. It
denotes the money that circulates in the organization for smooth functioning of the
organization.
Page 29 of 91
Current Assets are the resources which are in cash or will soon be converted into cash in
“ordinary course of business”. The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for
working capital and investment.
Good management of working capital will generate cash, help to improve the profits,
solidify the relationships with suppliers and customers, and reduce risks.
This project was undertaken to analyze the working capital policies, working capital
management of the company and to reduce down their problems and finding the solutions
with respect to the working capital management of the company.
Working in an organization, especially with a brand like RANBAXY the main objective is
to learn maximum from the intellectually stimulating mentors and multi-dimensional
colleagues in the organization.
• To study and compare the working capital of RANBAXY with its competitors in
the industry
• To see whether the company is prepared with enough working capital to face
any kind of contingencies.
• To assess Liquidity position, Long term solvency, operational efficiency, and
overall profitability of RANBAXY
Page 30 of 91
A well designed and implemented working capital management is expected to contribute
positively to the creation of a firm’s value The purpose of this project is to examine the
trends in working capital management and its impact on firms’ performance.
This project would help Ranbaxy in comparing its financial status with its competitors. The
in depth analysis might bring out some key issues that may be ignored but may prove
significant for the company. Various analyses conducted for analyzing the working capital
will prove beneficial to the company.
Working Capital:
“Working Capital includes the current assets and current liabilities areas of the
balance sheet. Working Capital can be called by its alternative name - "Net Current
Assets”.
Working Capital Management is the process of planning and controlling the level and mix
of current assets of the firm as well as financing these assets. It may be regarded as a life
blood of a business; its effective provision can do much to ensure the success of a business,
while its efficient management may lead not only to loss of profits but loss to ultimate
downfall in a going concern. Analysis of working capital is of major importance to internal
and external analysis because it is closely related to the current day-to-day operations.
• Stock - stocks of raw materials, partly completed production and finished goods
awaiting sale.
Page 31 of 91
The three major characteristics of current assets are:
• The typical uses of working capital are as follows: • Adjusted net loss from
operations
• Purchase of non-current assets:
• Repayment of long-term debt (debentures or bonds) and short-term debt (bank
borrowing)
• Redemption of redeemable preference shares
• Payment of cash dividend.
Page 32 of 91
ADVANTAGES OF ADEQUATE WORKING CAPITAL
• Increase in debt capacity and goodwill: Adequate working capital represents the
financial soundness of the company. If one company is financially sound it would
be able to pay its creditors timely and properly. It will increase company’s
goodwill. Thus a firm with adequate working capital can raise requisite funds from
market, borrow short-term credit from banks, and purchase inventories of raw
materials, etc., for the smooth operation of its business.
• Increase in production efficiency: With adequate working capital the firm can
smoothly carryout research and development activities and thus adds to its
production efficiency.
• Solvency and efficiency of fixed assets: It helps to maintain the solvency of the
company, so that payments could be made in time as and when they fall due.
Page 33 of 91
DISADVANTAGE OF INADEQUATE WORKING CAPITAL
• Loss of goodwill and creditworthiness: As the firm fails to honor its current
liabilities it loses it goodwill and creditworthiness among its creditors.
• Firm can’t make use of favorable opportunities: The firm fails to undertake the
profitable projects, which not only prevent the firm from availing the benefits of
favorable opportunities but also stagnate its growth.
• Adverse effects of credit opportunities: The firm also fails to avail the attractive
credit opportunities but also stagnate its growth.
Company must have adequate working capital pursuant to its requirements. It should
neither be excessive nor inadequate. Both situations are dangerous. While inadequate
working capital adversely affects the business operations and profitability, excessive
working capital remains idle and earns no profits for the company. So company must
assure its working capital is adequate for its operations.
Page 34 of 91
STUDY OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT OF RANBAXY
LABORATORIES LTD
Businesses face ever increasing pressure on costs and growing Financing requirements as a
result of intensive competition in globalize markets. Many of them are therefore considering
ways of making themselves more efficient. In identifying possible options it is important
not to focus exclusively on income and expense items, but also to take the balance sheet
into account.
Improvements to the existing capital structure can free up valuable resources and bring
increased efficiency. Active working capital management is an extremely effective way to
increase enterprise value. Optimizing working capital results in a rapid release of liquid
resources and contributes to an improvement in free cash flow and to a permanent reduction
in inventory and capital costs.
The attempt is aimed to analyze the various aspects of working capital management of
Ranbaxy and compare it with that of Dr Reddy’s,others competitors and with industry
standards.
By adopting various calculation and analysis and then making interpretation with the
solution of specific problem, best efforts on giving appropriate suggestion to the company
have been made.
Page 35 of 91
DEFINING THE PROBLEM
Areas of working capital has different problems and these are discussed separately in the
following sections:
1. Stock control
Problem
If too much stock is held, the organisation wastes money through a variety of factors:
• Money is tied up in stock when it could be put to better use.
• There are superfluous warehousing and storage costs.
2. Debtor Control
Problem
Page 36 of 91
• If you get the money in quickly you can use it for other purposes which will advance
the organisation's objectives.
• Giving credit costs money, even if it is only a small amount of interest foregone. If
you have an overdraft, the costs rise sharply.
• If a large client demands an unreasonable amount of credit you may have to simply
walk away from the contract. You cannot afford to risk running out of cash.
• If stage payments are delayed, you may perhaps have to say, for example, that you
will be unable to complete the contract; this may help with neogitations
3. Cashflow Management
4. Creditor control
Page 37 of 91
LITERATURE REVIEW
1) target levels for each category of current operating assets and liabilities, and
Generally good working capital policy (i.e. under conditions of certainty) is considered to
be one in which holdings of cash, securities, inventories, fixed assets, and accounts payables
are minimized. The level of accounts receivables should be used as a means of stimulating
sales and other income. Previous literature on working capital management has found a
negative association, overall, between level of working capital and operating performance
as measured by operating returns and operating margins (Peterson and Rajan, 1997). Under
conditions of certainty (i.e. sales, costs, lead times, payment periods, and so on, are known),
firms have little reason to hold more working capital than a minimum level. Larger amounts
would increase the level of operating assets, increase the need for external funding,
resulting in lower return on assets and a lower return on equity, without any increase in
profit.
However the picture changes when uncertainty (i.e. uncertain growth) is introduced
(Brigham and Houston, 2000). Larger amounts of cash, securities, accounts receivables,
marketable securities, inventories, and fixed assets will be needed to support increased sales
Required levels will be based on expected sales levels and expected order lead times.
Additional holdings may be needed to enable the firm to deal with departures from the
expected values. Further, firms will also attempt to increase their accounts payable balances
as a means of financing increased levels of current operating assets. Firms which are in high
growth stages will face the challenge of maintaining the necessary level of operating assets
to support subsequent growth, while at the same time attempting to maintain adequate
performance indicators.
This study focuses on understanding how IPO companies manage their working capital and
other balance sheet items to support subsequent growth. This study supports the existing
literature on working capital and contributes to the existing literature by examining a sample
of firms (i.e. recent IPO firms) which have a wider range of growth levels than nonIPO
firms. Our study examines the impact of working capital management on the operating
performance and growth of new public companies. The study also examines these
relationships under three categories of growth (i.e. negative growth, moderate growth, and
high growth). The study also examines other selected firm characteristics in light of
working capital management: firm operating and financial risk, amount of debt, firm size,
and industry.
An underlying theme of this study is that high growth certainly does not ensure high
operating performance. Consistent with prior research (Peterson and Rajan, 1997) this study
provides further evidence that good working capital management is positively associated
with better operating performance. Higher levels of accounts receivable are associated with
Page 38 of 91
higher operating performance, in all three of the growth rate categories. The study also finds
that maintaining control over levels of cash, securities, inventory, fixed assets, and accounts
payables is associated with higher operating performance. We find that firms which are
experiencing very high growth will hold higher levels of cash, securities, inventory, fixed
assets, and accounts payable to support the high growth. The study suggests that these firms
are sacrificing operating performance (accepting lower operating returns) to support the
high growth. This, in turn, increases financial and operating risk for these firms. Perhaps
IPO firms should stay more focused on their operating performance, while maintaining
more moderate growth levels
Another aspect of this study is that it fills a void in the initial public offerings literature.
Recent literature finds that new public companies underperform the market after going
public. Ritter in his 1991 paper reports substantially lower stock returns for IPO firms
between 1975 and 1984 than for a size-and-industry-matched sample of seasoned firms.
Since then there is a growing literature explaining IPO underperformance as related to
agency cost (Smith, 1990), institutional holdings (Field, 1995), venture capital (Jain and
Gompers, 1997; Jain and Kini, 2000), market timing of IPO (Benninga, 2004), and earnings
management (Teho et al., 1998; Ahmad-zaluki et al., 2008). However, there is no study
linking the working capital management and post-IPO performance. Our paper tries to fill
the void. The findings of this study would be interesting to investors and creditors of new
public companies.
Page 39 of 91
METHODOLOGY
A study by analyzing the trends of working capital of the firm and to examine the possible
causes for any significant differences. The data has been collected from the financial
statements. For the purpose of this study, profitability is measured by Return on Total
Assets (ROTA), which is defined as profit before interest and tax divided by total assets.
All important ratios have been calculated to know the financial health of the company with
the help of past trends, mainly profitability & return ratios considered in section I of
analysis part. It also covers the DuPont analysis and correlation analysis of working capital
& its impact on profitability of the company. Section II consists of in depth analysis of
every component of working capital.
All important components of working capital have been analyzed in detail i.e, Inventory,
Cash, and Payables etc
Page 40 of 91
The methodology to be adopted is as follows:
• Collection of financial data of RANBAXY and Dr Reddy from annual reports and
company’s internal resources.
• Computation of various financial ratios and comparing them with standards and with
each others.
• Analyzing the trends of working capital of the firm and to examine the possible
causes for any significant differences.
• Various tools of analysis like correlation analysis, DuPont analysis, Ratio analysis
etc to be applied.
• All important components of working capital to be analyzed in detail i.e.
Receivables, Inventory, Cash, Payables and Operating cycle.
• Making comparison of the above computations with that of Dr Reddys.and industry
standards.
• Analysis of results, drawing conclusions and giving recommendations.
Page 41 of 91
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE OF RANBAXY
Page 42 of 91
Though the Sales of the company had been on a constant increase over the last 10 years,
there was a sudden fall in the Profit After Tax (PAT-Profit available to the Equity holders
and the organization itself) in 2005, 2006 and 2008. The key reason for the sudden fall in
PAT can be attributed to the sudden hike in the R&D expenditure in 2005.
In 2008, there was an unprecedented economic downturn across all markets globally and the
fluctuating financial and Forex environment created a substantial negative impact on
profitability. Further prohibition on drugs by the US Food and Drug Administration and
pricing stress has acted as a wet blanket in the periodical figures of the company. The trend
line shows the reason behind the fall in profitability.
The following financial comparison has been made keeping in view the scale of operations
of the company and the Industry Standards. The Industry standards have been taken from
Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE), March 2009.
Page 43 of 91
3. Dr Reddy’s Laboratories
4. Lupin
5. Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd.
For any company functioning in the free market, its important how best it operates but this
is equally important (if not more) that how it performs viz-a-viz its rivals i.e. other similar
companies in the market. Here, to find out about Ranbaxy, a comparison has been made
with 5 other companies operating on comparable size to see whether Ranbaxy is following
industry norms or not or whether Ranbaxy is doing better (or worse) compared to its rivals.
Its liquidity position has been compared by considering Working Capital Turnover Ratio,
Current Ratio and Quick Ratio and further Profitability of Ranbaxy viz-a-viz other
companies have been compared by considering Return on Capital Employed and Earnings
per share.
Liquidity Ratios
The liquidity refers to the availability of cash and cash convertible assets with an
organization to meet its short-term obligations i.e. creditors and other Current Liabilities.
Any company's liquidity may vary due to seasonality, the timing of sales, and the state of
the economy. But liquidity ratios can provide small business owners with useful limits to
Page 44 of 91
help them regulate borrowing and spending. Some of the best-known measures of a
company's liquidity include:
From the Industry comparison, it is apparent that Ranbaxy is way above the Industry
standards in 2008 which implies that the sales generated by Ranbaxy Laboratories has
always been much higher than the cost incurred to generate those sa les as compared to
other Pharmaceutical giants in the Industry.
2. Current Ratio
The current ratio of Ranbaxy has been compared with the Top five Pharmaceutical
organizations for the year 2008. A Current ratio measures the ability of an entity to pay its
Page 45 of 91
nearterm obligations. Though the ideal current ratio depends to some extent on the type of
business, a general rule of thumb is that it should be at least 2:1. The higher the current
ratio, the greater the "cushion" between current obligations and a firm's ability to pay them.
A lower current ratio means that the company may not be able to pay its bills on time, while
a higher ratio means that the company has money in cash or safe investments that could be
put to better use in the business.
The ideal Current ratio to be maintained by the pharmaceutical cannot be accurately
assessed because the scale of operations and the inventory size has been different for all the
concerns in the Industry. According to CMIE Industry Standards the current ratio for 2008
is 1.535.
As per the above graph, the Current ratio maintained by Ranbaxy in 2008 is way below the
normal industry standards. The reason for a lower Current Ratio is the heavy amount of
Current liabilities incurred mainly due to huge loss on derivative valuations. Ban in U.S
market for more than 30 generic drugs and depreciation in several currencies were other
factors for Ranbaxy’s dismal performance in 2008.
3. Quick Ratio
Quick Ratio also known as „Acid Test Ratio‟ is an even conservative measure of liquidity.
The ratio expresses the degree to which a company's current liabilities are covered by the
most liquid current assets. Here Quick assets include all current assets except inventories.
Page 46 of 91
A high ratio indicates under stocking and low ratio indicates over stocking. Stock is
excluded because it may take time to be converted into cash. Quick ratio measures those
assets, which are immediately converted into cash without much loss. Though there is no
way to measure an ideal Quick ratio but as a rule of thumb, it should be at least 1:1.
From the above comparison, it can be inferred that a Ranbaxy’s Current liabilities were
much more as compared to other companies. This is because although the Quick Ratio
maintained by Ranbaxy is very near a said ideal ratio of 1:1 but that way below the Industry
standards of 1.19 of the year 2008. Moreover, it can be clearly viewed from the Balance
Sheet that a decent component of the Current liabilities includes fair valuation loss on
derivatives.
Page 47 of 91
Profitability Ratios
Profit is the difference between revenue and expenses over a period of time. The
profitability ratios are calculated to measure the operating efficiency of the company.
As compared to other Pharmaceutical rivals in the Industry, Ranbaxy has a negative return
on Capital employed and way below the Industry standards of 8.06% for the year 2008. This
means that the Profit before Tax (PBT) of the company is heavier on the Total Assets which
is dragging down the Return on Capital Employed. This is mainly because of the forex
decline due to global economic downturn and ban on generic products in the U.S market.
EPS states a corporation's profits on a per share basis. It can be helpful in further
comparison to the market price of the stock. It is an index of profitability from shareholder’s
Page 48 of 91
point of view. The higher the earning per share, the more attractive will be the investment
plan.
From the Industry comparison, it is clear that the earnings per share for the Equity
Shareholders of Ranbaxy are negative. The main reason for the figure of EPS being
negative is the drastically low Profits it has incurred in the year 2008.
Page 49 of 91
LIQUIDITY ANALYSIS OF
Liquidity of any company is the indicator as to how the company is placed with reference to
its capacity to meet its current financial obligation. This means that here we have to
consider the current assets which can be easily converted into cash to meet its immediate
financial obligations or dues. Liquidity position of Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited has been
analyzed in the following paragraphs based on different measures.
Current Assets
Ranbaxy has a growth of around 318.23% in current assets over the period of ten years.
From Rs 12310.24 Million in 1998-99, The Company has increased its current assets to Rs
51485.24 Million. Coefficient of variation for this period has been 49.11 which indicate that
the growth of current assets during the period under consideration has been sustainable
except for the year 2007-08 which shows a sharp increase in current assets which is largely
due to increase in cash and bank balances which has increased more than ten times as
compared to 2007.
Page 50 of 91
Liquid Assets
Company has also witnessed significant increase in liquid assets. From Rs 8382.22 M in
1998-99 to Rs 39500.05 M in 2007-08, there has been a growth of 371.24% in ten years. As
it is clear from the above mentioned data, liquid assets growth has been slightly more than
the growth of current assets. Standard deviation and coefficient of variation for this period
has been Rs 9079.38 M and 57.81% respectively.
Page 51 of 91
Current Liabilities
From 1998-99 to 2007-08, current liabilities for Ranbaxy Laboratories have increased from
Rs 4152.78 M to Rs 42725.97 M with average current liabilities over this period being Rs
13067.47 M. As we see here, growth rate for current liabilities in this period has been
928.85% which is much higher than the growth for current and liquid assets which shows
that current liabilities have increased at a higher pace than its corresponding assets. Further,
coefficient of variation for this period is 84.91 which also reflect more flexibility in current
liabilities during this time. Current liabilities increased more than four times from 2007 to
2008 primarily because of huge loss on derivative valuations. Ban in U.S market for more
than 30 generic drugs and deprecation in several currencies were another factors for
Ranbaxy’s dismal performance in 2008.
Working Capital
Net working capital is an important measure which itself indicate margin of safety or
cushion of protection provided to the creditors. As the following diagram shows, the
company has all over positive net working capital. The greater the amount of net work ing
capital, the greater the liquidity of the firm. NWC of the company increased from Rs
8157.46 M to Rs 8759.27 M i.e. overall growth of 7.38% only. Coefficient of variation for
the NWC is also 20.99% which is also less as compared to current assets or current
liabilities. There is a decrease in Net working capital in the year 2008.Even though there is
Page 52 of 91
an increase in current asset and current liabilities however increase in current liabilities is
much more which has let to decline in Net working capital. There is a decrease in Net
working capital in the year 2008.Even though there is an increase in current asset and
current liabilities however increase in current liabilities is much more which has let to
decline in Net working capital.
Page 53 of 91
Working Capital (Quick)
However, the measure of Net Working Capital does not indicate the true ability to pay
current debts when they become due. The reason being the NWC being access of current
assets over current liabilities and since these current assets comprises of illiquid inventory,
the measure of Quick Net Working Capital has been adopted. This is nothing but liquid or
quick assets less the current liabilities. Quick assets refer to current assets less inventory.
Following diagram shows that even though QNWC of the company has all along been
positive, during 2003-04, it has been substantially low. Further, in 2007-08 it was negative
because of exceptional increase in current liabilities.
Page 54 of 91
Page 55 of 91
Components of Gross Working Capital
Gross Working Capital has many constituents like inventory, sundry debtors, cash and bank
accounts etc. Composition has been calculated in Annexure-B at the end of this part of
report. Gross Working Capital has been calculated considering four components namely
Inventory, Sundry Debtors, Cash & Bank Balances and Loan & advances.
Out of all four components of working capital, the component, namely sundry debtors
contributed highest to the working capital. It varied from a lowest of 19.69% in 2002-03 to
the highest of 40.40% in 2005-06. Over the period of time, on an average, sundry debtors
contributed 33.2% to the working capital. The increase in percentage of sundry debtor
reflects a liberal credit policy with chances of bad debts and collection charges.
Next major component after sundry debtors is the inventory which decreased from 31.91%
in 1998-99 to 23.28% in 2007-08 with the highest contribution in 2004-2005 that of
39.33%. Over the period of time, on an average inventory has contributed 33.43% to the
working capital. However, in these ten years, there have not been substantial changes as far
as inventory percentage is concerned as also evident from the diagram below.
Page 56 of 91
Cash & Bank to Gross Working Capital
Cash and Bank balances have contributed the least to the gross working capital. It varied
from 4.09% in 1998-99 to 37.58% in 2007-08 with lowest of 1.11% in 1999-00 and highest
of 37.58% in 2007-08. On an average, in this period, cash and bank balance has contributed
7.30% only to the working capital. Even the average of 7.30% is because of high percentage
in 2007-08, in all other financial years this component has contributed very little to Working
Capital. In a business which is comfortable financed, cash and bank balance should not run
less than 5 to 10% of the current assets. Further, as the current liabilities are not expected to
exceed half of the current assets, the cash percentage should not run under 10 to 20%. This
data indicates that the company had not maintained sufficient cash and
bank balance and this definitely affects the profitability of the company except for the year
2008 which was high due to increase in deposit accounts of scheduled banks.
Page 57 of 91
Loan & Advances to Gross Working Capital
Loan and advances even though constituted one of the most important component of net
working capital in 1998-99 (i.e. 25.02%), declined over the period of time as percentage of
working capital. Over these ten years, approximately 26% working capital has been
contributed from loans and advances with a highest of 43.09% in 2002-2003.
Page 58 of 91
Page 59 of 91
Ratio Analysis
Even though above analysis based on composition provide some indicator to the liquidity
position of the company, these do not show the extent of margin of safety provided for
current creditors. For this, ratio analysis has been done as follows:
Current Ratio
Relationship between current assets and current liabilities is shown by current ratio. It
basically measures company‟s ability to meet its short term obligation out of its short term
resources. Higher the current ratio, the greater is the assurance of the ability to pay the
current liabilities and vice versa. However, even though a higher value of current ratio is
good for the creditors against their credit, it may not be good for the management as it will
indicate poor financial planning and over capitalization. In normal circumstances,
hypothetical norm of 2:1 is supposed to be a good current ratio and if the current ratio for
the company is less than that, the solvency or liquidity of the company becomes
questionable.
As it is evident from the following table and the graph, the company had an average current
ratio of 1.87 over the period of seven years from 2002 to 2008. However, as it is clear from
the data that it varied from 2.19 to 1.21 which shows a variation over the years. Further, a
current ratio of less than 2 is normally not supposed to be good as such it can be considered
the company passed through a difficult phase of liquidity in 2004 and 2008.
Page 60 of 91
However, over all for this period, the company was sound as far as its liquidity was
concerned and it had liquidity facilities available for the creditors. The performance
standards of the Indian Pharmaceutical Industry for 2002-2008, as published by Centre for
Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) are 1.51 to 1.54.The current ratios are always above
the standards during the study period indicating a comfortable liquidity position for the
company except for 2008. The average was also higher than the standard set by the CMIE.
However, current ratio considers the quantity of current assets only and not its quality. So a
more in-depth analysis is required for definite inference to be drawn for the company’s
liquidity.
Current assets sometime also include a high amount of slow moving inventory or which
may not move at all which means that even though current ratio of a company is very high,
even though it may not be in a position to meet its immediate liabilities. For that, an
analysis of quick ratio is also needed which shows the extent of cushion provided from the
quick assets to the current creditors. This ratio excludes the inventory and bank overdraft,
which are normally difficult to realize at short notice. Quick ratio is defined as the ratio of
quick assets to quick liabilities. Under normal circumstance, an ideal quick ratio of 1:1 is
supposed to be good enough which will reflect a satisfactory current financial condition.
Page 61 of 91
Page 62 of 91
Above data for Ranbaxy Laboratories indicates that Acid Test Ratio for the period under
study has consistently been above 1 except for 2008 where it was lowest of 0.92 and an
average of 1.23. It shows that the company has a healthy liquidity position in this period. As
per the set standards according to Indian Pharmaceutical Industry, norm for Acid Test Ratio
is 1.07 to 1.19 and as such, considering the above data, it can be said that company’s
immediate payment position was satisfactory and its liquid assets were adequate to meet its
short term obligations.
Even more rigorous than the quick ratio is the absolute liquidity ratio which is calculated
even excluding receivables from the current assets. It does away with the doubts about the
realization of receivables and debtors. Absolute liquidity ratio or cash position ratio is
calculated by dividing cash including bank balances and marketable securities by the
amount of current liabilities. Basically, it shows that how much cash is available for
immediate payment for the current obligations. A high cash position ratio is good from the
creditors‟ point of view but from the management point of view, it indicates poor
Page 63 of 91
Above data indicates that absolute liquidity ratio of cash position ratio of the company has
been consistently very low compared to the industry norm except for the year 2007- 2008
where it rose to 0.45. It varied from a lowest of 0.03 to highest of 0.45. Over the period of
time, its average has been only 0.14. This shows that company has followed a policy of not
maintaining a high cash position ratio and rather focused more on utilization of cash
resources. However, from a creditors point of view, cash position ratio for the company was
not acceptable for the said duration. As compared to Industry standards of CMIE, the
average was much lower than the acceptable norm.
Page 64 of 91
Inventory to Sales Ratio or Inventory Turnover Ratio
Relationship between the sales and average stock kept by the company is normally reflected
by the Inventory to Sales Ratio which is also called as Inventory Turnover Ratio. This is
also an indicator for the liquidity of the concern as it will reflect the rate at which
inventories are being converted into sales and subsequently cash. A higher inventory to
sales ratio will show higher efficiency on the part of the management and vice versa.
Following table shows that Inventory Sales Ratio varied from 3.78 in 2001-02 to 4.38 in
2007-08. On an average, the value of Inventory Sales Ratio remained 3.82 for this period.
Further, it is also evident from the table and the graph, that from 2001-02, efficiency of
management has improved as far as conversion of inventory into sales was concerned. As
per the industry norm, normally an inventory sales ratio of more than 2 to 2.5 is considered
acceptable. As during this time, average of inventory turnover ratio in Ranbaxy was higher
than the Industry standard of CMIE, the inventory management of the company can be said
to be satisfactory from 2001-02 to 2007-08.
Page 65 of 91
Debtors to Sales Ratio or Debtors Turnover Ratio
A company adopts a policy for credit and collection and this is important to find out how
the debtors are performing over the year. Debtors to Sales Ratio or Debtors Turnover Ratio
is the indicator of number of times the debtors are turned over during the year. Since debtors
constitute a major element of current assets, the credit and collection policy of a concern
must be under continuous watch. The liquidity of a firm depends upon the quality of debtors
to a great extent. Debtors Turnover Ratio measures the rapidity or slowness of debtors‟
collectability. Generally, the higher the value of the debtors‟ turnover ratio, the more
Company, the average debtors‟ turnover ratio is 4.92. This shows that the debtor‟s turnover
ratio in the Ranbaxy was lower than the standard set by the industry norms which is not a
good sign from the liquidity point of view.
Page 66 of 91
Working Capital Turnover Ratio
There is a close relationship between sales and the working capital and the working capital
turnover ratio is an indicator of that. This ratio is computed by dividing the net sales by the
net working capital. It basically helps to understand the efficiency with which net working
capital is being utilized. The higher the turnover, the greater is the efficiency and the larger
is the rate of profit earned. However, a very high working capital turnover ratio is also
indicative of over trading and lack of working capital. In other words, if the working capital
turnover ratio is very less, it means that working capital has not been efficiently utilized. In
the table below, Ranbaxy has successfully improved its performance with reference to
relationship between working capital and sales as is evident from the fact that Working
Capital Turnover Ratio has improved from 2.95 in 2001-02 to 5.12 in 2007-08. For the
Page 67 of 91
duration of seven years, average ratio has been 3.46. It also means that for generating a sale
of Rs 1, the company invested Rs 0.29. This shows that the management was active to take
assume risk and tended to reduce the size of working capital in relation to sales volume over
the period of time. The average of working capital turnover ratio for the company was
higher than the standard set by CMIE.
Page 68 of 91
Current Assets to Sales Ratio
Current Assets Turnover Ratio or Current assets to sales ratio is applied to measure the
turnover and profitability of the total current assets employed to conduct the operations of a
firm. This is calculated by dividing the amount of sales by the amount o f current assets.
This will give an overall impression of how rapidly the total investment in current assets is
bring turned. Lower the turnover of the current assets, the worse is the utilization of current
assets and vice-versa.
This is to say that analysis of current assets to sales ratio over a period of time will show the
overall efficiency of the working capital management of the company.
Following table again shows that the company over the period of time has improved its
efficiency as it is reflected by the fact that Current Assets to Sales Ratio has improved from
1.6 in 2001-02 to 1.48 in 2006-07 except for 2007-08 where it has again decreased to 0.87.
For the period of seven year, average current assets turnover ratio has been 1.45 with
standard deviation of 0.26 and coefficient of deviation as 18.13%. It shows that the
decreased volume of current assets in relation to sales was put in a commercially prudent
manner. The average of working capital turnover ratio for the company was lower than the
standard set by CMIE.
Page 69 of 91
Page 70 of 91
Current Assets to Total Assets Ratio
This ratio indicates the relationship between the total amount of current assets and the
amount of investments in total assets. It indicates the extent of funds invested for working
capital purpose out of total investment.
Page 71 of 91
Table above shows that current assets to total assets ratio was 0.63 in 2001-02 which came
down to 0.44 in 2007-2008. Over the period of seven years under consideration, average
current assets to total assets ratio has been 0.5 with standard deviation of 0.13 and
coefficient of variation as 25.47%. Higher investment in current assets shows that the firm
had a better liquidity in the beginning however it also shows that profitability was less as
higher liquidity normally results in lesser profitability. The average of working capital
turnover ratio for the company was lower than the standard set by CMIE
Table given in Annexure C shows the calculation of all the ratios in addition to its mean,
standard deviation and coefficient of variation. By comparing CV for different variables,
consistency of different ratio can be compared with. Greater the CV, less consistent is the
ratio or it can be considered more fluctuating.
As evident from the table, absolute liquidity ratio is least consistent and fluctuates a lot
between different values whereas inventory to sales ratio is the most consistent with very
little fluctuations.
Page 72 of 91
Liquidity Ranking
order to evaluate the overall liquidity position, Motaal‟s comprehensive test has been
applied. In this test, a method of ranking has been applied to arrive at a more comprehensive
assessment of liquidity in which four different factors viz inventory to current assets ratio,
sundry debtors to current assets ratio, cash & bank to current assets ratio and loans &
advances to current assets ratios have been computed and combines in a points score. To
calculate that, a high value of sundry debtors to current assets ratio, cash & bank to current
assets ratio and loans & advances to current assets ratios shows a relatively favorable
liquidity position and ranking has been done in that order. Contrary to this, a low inventory
to current assets ratio indicates more favorable liquidity position and hence, ranking has
been done accordingly. Final ranking has been done on the basis that the lower the total of
the individual ranks, the more favorable is the liquidity position of the company and vice
versa.
A comprehensive calculation sheet is attached at Annexure D which resulted in following
results.
Above table shows that the Ranbaxy had the most sound liquidity position during the year
1998-1999 and 2006-2007. On the contrary, 2003-2004 was the weakest year as far as the
liquidity position was concerned.
Coefficient of a Rank Correlation and testing the significance
As the liquidity and profitability, both are important for any company, I have analyzed the
relationship between the two by using Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient. Further, to
judge the significance of the relationship, the t-test has been applied.
Page 73 of 91
To do this analysis, liquidity indicator has been taken to be the ratio of current assets to total
assets. Ratio of return on capital employed has been taken as the indicator for profitability.
A detailed calculation has been done in the excel table which has resulted in the following:
Rank correlation coefficient between the liquidity and profitability of the company has been
calculated as 0.452562. To study the significance of the computed value of correlation
coefficient, the t-test has been applied as:
H0: Null Hypothesis – There exists no significant correlation between the liquidity and
profitability of Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited.
H1: Alte rnative Hypothesis – There exists a significant correlation between the liquidity
and profitability of Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited.
Say 5 % level of significance, α = 0.05
Critical Value of t for 5 % level of significance = 2.306
Page 74 of 91
In above case, t has been calculated in above table itself which comes out to be 2.571 which
is greater than the critical value of t i.e.2.262 which shows that the null hypothesis may be
rejected which means that there is significant relationship between liquidity and
profitability.
Need of working capital could be met in many ways. However, it‟s normally consists of
Short term financing and long term financing. Cost of financing is different for short term
and long term financing and it‟s this reason that an attempt has been made to analyze the
As is evident from the above table, during 1998-99, % of long term finance used for
working capital requirement was 38.02% which has seen an overall decline in the period
under consideration to 7.48% in 2007-08. It has reached the maximum in 1998-99 to
38.02%. There is a clear indication that company has with passage of time shifted its
preference towards short term financing (aggressive policy) which might be primarily
because of the uncertain and short term nature of the pharmaceutical market.
Page 75 of 91
Working Capital Trend Analysis
Working capital trend is very important to study about the practice and policy of the
management of the company with regard to whether the company is following a proper
policy towards working capital or some improvement is needed for better management of
working capital funds. The trend value of working capital has been calculated as follows:
It is evident from the above table that working capital has increased over the period of time
from Rs 8157.46 M in 1998-99 to Rs 8759.27 M in 2007-08. It had an increasing trend
except in the year 200-01, 2003-04 and 2007-08 where the working capital had actually
declined.
Page 76 of 91
CREDIT ANALYSIS
Besides establishing credit standard, a firm should develop procedures for evaluating credit
applicants. The second aspect of credit policy of a firm is credit analysis and investigation.
The first step in credit analysis is obtaining credit information on which to the base
evaluation of a customer. The sources of information are:
Internal Sources: Usually company requires their customers to fill various forms and
documents giving details about financial operations. Some times company also asks for
references. Another source of internal information is the records of the firm contemplating
an extension of credit.
• External Sources: Some of the external sources of information are
• Financial Statements
• Bank References
• Trade References
• Credit Bureau Reports
Once the credit information has been collected from different sources, it should be analyzed
to determine the credit worthiness of customer. The analysis should cover two aspects.
Quantitative Analysis The assessment of the quantitative aspects is based on the factual
information available from the financial statements, past records of the firm and so on.
First step in this assessment is to prepare an aging schedule to calculate average age of
accounts payable. Another method is ratio analysis, i.e. calculation of liquidity, profitability
and debt capacity ratios, of the applicant. These ratios will help to find out financial strength
of applicant.
Page 77 of 91
Credit Period
It is the duration of time for which trade credit is extended – during this period the overdue
amount must be paid by the customer.
Cash Discount
This is the amount for which the customer can take advantage of by making early payment.
Sometimes company offer its customer a condition that if they will pay amount early than
the scheduled the time than they will get some discount. This is called cash discount. Cash
discount provided by the company can affect the sales volume, average collection period
and profits of the company.
It refers as duration during which the cash discount can be availed of. It is directly related to
sales generally. For instance, if company increases its cash discount period than its average
collection period will also increase. With the increase in average collection period sales
level is also increases.
CREDIT POLICIES
Collection policies refer to the procedures followed to collect the account receivables when,
after the expiry of the credit period they become due. It includes two aspects:
It refers what degree of efforts; company is using to collect its receivables. If company use
strict efforts than bad debts costs will decline, and average collection period will also
reduce. But cost involved in this kind of strategy is comparatively high. Also sales volume
can be decline with this policy. On the other hand, lenient efforts are just opposite to strict
efforts. So company has to decide that method in which overall cost is low and revenue is
high.
Page 78 of 91
CREDIT POLICY OF RANBAXY
As we know that a manufacturing company is frequently deals with debtors and most of its
sales are credit sales. A huge amount of capital is blocked in to receivables. Therefore to
make an effective credit policy is very important for the company. Ranbaxy is, like many
other companies, involves in both kinds of sales i.e. domestic as well as exports. It have
different credit policies for both domestic and export customers.
For domestic customers: Most of the domestic sales of Ranbaxy are based on advance
payment. Some part of contract money is received in advance and then sale is made.
Remaining amount is received later on. Generally, the credit period allowed by Ranbaxy is
up to 45 days but sometimes it went up to 60 days also (only via prior approval of
management). Company also doesn’t plan for any bad debts losses, but if any bad debt
happen than it has to be written off fully.
For obtaining information related to the new applicants only internal sources are used. As
company generally deals with blue chip companies or old customers, it is not a difficult job
to obtain information about them. No external source is used by Ranbaxy.
And for the analysis part, company use both qualitative and quantitative tools. As per
qualitative tool, company generally go for market reputation and past record of customer
and for quantitative tool, company use the size of order, financial position of customer etc.
As far as collection efforts are concerned, company generally uses lenient efforts. But in
some cases company also go for strict methods. Ranbaxy normally uses all types of
collection efforts like letters including reminders, telephone calls, personal visits & legal
actions. But company doesn’t take help of collection agencies.
The collection cost is very nominal in domestic sales and difficult to determine. Whereas
capital cost is equal to the cost of working capital which is not determined because of
confidentiality.
For Export Sales: From the sale data of Ranbaxy it was found that around 66% of sales are
based on exports. Therefore it is very important area for planning. Exports are based on
letter of credit. A foreign company who want to purchase the material from Ranbaxy sent an
LC first. Than on the basis of that LC, export order is made. Copy of that order is sent to
corporate office and head office at Gurgaon and New Delhi respectively.. From the
manufacturing plants, the material is dispatched as per the export order and LC is sent to
bank for collection. Banks collects the amount and transfers it to Ranbaxy’s account. No
other credit policy is present for export sale of Ranbaxy.
Collection cost is around 0.5 – 1 % of export order. Capital cost is here also equal to the
working capital cost.
Page 79 of 91
CASH MANAGEMENT
Cash flows in a cycle into, around and out of a business. It is the business's lifeblood and
every manager's primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow to generate
profits. If a business is operating profitably, then it should, in theory, generate cash
surpluses. If it doesn't generate surpluses, the business will eventually run out of cash and
expire. The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment. The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right within
business.
The goal is to receive cash as soon as possible while at the same time waiting to pay out
cash as long as possible. Even profitable companies fail if they have inadequate cash flow.
Liabilities are settled with cash not profits. Here a firm already is holding the cash so the
goal is to maximize the benefits from holding it and wait to pay out the cash being held until
the last possible moment. The primary objective of working capital management is to
ensure that sufficient cash is available to:
Cash is both the balancing figures between debtors, stock and creditors, and also the control
element. It is not possible to extend credit, order stock or pay creditors if there is not the
cash available to meet working capital demands.
Here the liquidity, risk and return of investments must all come into play with the length of
time before funds are needed playing an important role.
More fundamental than this is cash flow control – making sure funds are available when
needed. In the short term this is best achieved by preparation of weekly or monthly forecasts
for comparison with actual results.
The finance profession recognizes the three primary reasons offered by economist John
Maynard Keynes to explain why firms hold cash. The three reasons are for the purpose of
speculation, for the purpose of precaution, and for the purpose of making transactions. All
three of these reasons stem from the need for companies to possess liquidity.
Speculation:
Here company holding cash as creating the ability for a firm to take advantage of special
opportunities that if acted upon quickly will favor the firm. An example of this would be
purchasing extra inventory at a discount that is greater than the carrying costs of holding the
inventory.
Page 80 of 91
Precaution:
Holding cash as a precaution serves as an emergency fund for a firm. If expected cash
inflows are not received as expected cash held on a precautionary basis could be used to
satisfy short-term obligations that the cash inflow may have been bench marked for.
Transaction:
Firms hold cash in order to satisfy the cash inflow and cash outflow needs that they have.
The firm needs cash primarily to make payments for purchases, wages and salaries, other
operating expenses, taxes, dividends, etc. The need to hold cash would not arise if there
were perfect synchronization between cash receipts and cash payments.
Cash Planning
Cash planning is a technique to plan and control the use of cash. It helps to anticipate the
future cash flows and needs of the firm and reduces the possibility of idle cash balances and
cash deficits. Cash planning protects the financial condition of the firm by developing a
projected cash statement from a forecast of expected cash inflows and outflows for a given
period. Cash planning may be done on daily, weekly or monthly basis. The period and
frequency of the planning generally depends upon the size and nature of business of
company.
Page 81 of 91
SHORT TERM CASH PLANNING
Methods
(i) operating,
(ii) non-operating
(iii) Financial.
Cash sales and cash received from debtors come under operating cash flows. Non –
operating income includes sale of fixed assets, dividends & interest income. Issue of shares
& loans etc. considered as financial inflows.
The next step is to determine cash outflows. Cash outflows include:
Cash management system adopted by Finance Department in Ranbaxy is very reliable and
transparent. As cash is a very important activity for a good operation of company here in
RLL cash is monitored every day and intimated to Finance Department. The daily cash
report includes the all details of cash inflows and outflows. Monthly cash budgets are
maintained for the estimated of monthly cash inflows and outflows. Finally the annual cash
budget is made by the Finance Department in the corporate head office.
Page 82 of 91
The corporate office allocates different amount of each to different manufacturing units as
per their requirement. Corporate office acts as a linkage between the manufacturing unit and
creditors. Corporate office has determined the credit facility for every units of the company
and this keeps on changing from year to year depending up on company’s position
transactions, profitability and inventory position.
The corporate office provides cash to manufacturing units but there most function is
controlled in unit itself. All the need related to inventory is met through corporate office as
well as individual efforts of unit.
Fund Allocation:
Here the initial allocation for manufacturing units is done by corporate office and all
supplementary requirements are to look upon by Commercial department.
Fund Utilization:
Company operates an annual ‘Cash Budget’ and a rolling ‘Cash Plan’ drawn up every
month. Although specific forecasting technique is used, funds are deployed to different
departments as per their requirements. Daily reports on cash transaction are prepared by
Procurement department to keep a track of all payments made in the days work. Every
month cash transaction report is sent to Finance department in the corporate office showing
all the transaction of cash, (inflow and outflows) actual utilization of cash and allocation of
fund is compared. If the utilization of cash is more than the allocation of fund, then the plant
has to justify its more utilization.
To meet the requirement of cash company approach to bank and present the required
detailed by the bank. RLL kept less cash in hand to meet the entire cash requirement it
depends on financing process.
LIMITATIONS
• Availability of the financial data was very limited which is not disclosed due to
sensitive nature for the company.
• The year ended for Ranbaxy is December, and that of Dr Reddys is March. So
figures taken are past 4 years but 3 months difference is there in the corresponding
figures of RLL & DRL.
• The main component of working capital is cost of capital, which is not described in
the project because of confidential nature.
• External environment influence was not considered while doing the theoretical
standard rather than the industrial standard because of unavailability of any such
specific standard.
• Efficiency falls to a great extent due the technical errors in the system. These errors
refer to the following:
Page 83 of 91
The SAP server goes low due to the exhaustive load on a single
server. There is lack of machines at disposal because of which the speed
of work goes down.
The hardware provided to the staff is not up to the mark which
adversely affects the efficiency to a great extent.
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
Page 84 of 91
financing is concerned. Ranbaxy has a good earning record; thus it enjoys great
confidence of the suppliers, as it is looked upon favorably.
• As far as components of working capital are concerned, on the domestic front, sales
have increased as well as the finished goods inventory has also increased.
• The increase in the current ratio of 2001 as compared to that of the previous year
indicates that the liquidity position of the company is improving. The inventory
turnover ratio of the company is not very high. It should try to achieve a quicker
movement of stock into sales. There is an inverse relationship between sales and
working capital at Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited.
• In general higher the ratio, more efficient is the management. Since Ranbaxy
Laboratories Limited has a low working capital ratio, it should look carefully into
this area to ensure its effective utilization.
• After analysis of the debtors turnover ratio, it was found out that Ranbaxy
Laboratories Limited has a low debtors turnover ratio, which may be a result of a
liberal and inefficient credit and collection policy. This involves the risk of bad
debts and the burden of high interests. This is another area that should be looked
into.
• After analysis of this ratio, we can conclude that Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited is
holding an unfavorable quantity of inventory. Since, the inventory turnover ratio is
not very high, we can conclude that the management of inventory is not very
efficient because the stocks are not sold very frequently, as a result of which a large
amount of money is required to finance the working capital requirement.
QUICK RATIO
• Ranbaxy has a satisfactory liquidity position.
CURRENT RATIO
Page 85 of 91
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SALES AND GROSS WORKING CAPITAL
• There exists a negative correlation between the two, which indicates that the sales are
low and this has led to an accumulation of stock.
• Sales and net working capital have a negative correlation, which implies that there is
an inverse relationship between sales and net working capital. It shows that the sales
are low and this has led to an accumulation of stock.
• The return ratios are not showing an increasing trend which is not a
good sign for the company’s growth. But return of working capital is
increasing which means that company is doing more sales with less
working capital.
• Gearing ratio is low which shows that it is less levered firm, which is a
good sign for company and moreover its liquidity position is very
strong.
The overall liquidity position is very strong. The company’s current
ratio is approx.
3.5 from last many years which mean that company can manage any sort
of financial contingencies.
• As far as Receivables are concerned co.’s credit policy varies from party
to party and according to the nature of the business & one can say that
this policy is good for a pharma company. Most of the domestic sales of
Ranbaxy are based on advance payment. Some part of contract money is
received in advance and then sale is made Ranbaxy’s total exports
accounts for 66% & the balance 33% represent sales in India.
• The Inventory Holding Period (IHP) is almost constant due to this their
Net Working Capital cycle is also not showing a significant change.
Page 86 of 91
RECOMMENDATIONS AND SUGGESTIONS
• It is suggested that the firm should neither have too high nor too low
debtor turnover ratio.
• There is an increase in the current ratio suggesting that there may be idle
funds with the company. It is therefore recommended that the company
should invest the excess cash in marketable securities. This would be
more profitable than holding idle cash.
Page 87 of 91
• Ranbaxy should focus on maintaining its consistency or increasing it as
there is a decline in their Operating Profit from last 3 years. It can be
done by increasing its sales and decreasing its operating costs. If
company’s operating profit will increase, then it will help in increasing
its overall profitability.
• As it was clear that company have high liquidity in its capital structure,
it means a close observation is required for the benefits of share holders.
It should chanalize its investments towards those areas where returns
would be higher.
• The company should try to reduce its inventory holding to lower down
the holding cost & increase its Raw Material Turnover. It can also help
in lower down the operating cycle.
• The company should also try to reduce its Average collection period to
It can also help in lower down the operating cycle.
Page 88 of 91
Pertaining to Work Culture and Working Conditions:
Pertaining to Technology:
Page 89 of 91
The number of machines on the floor at accounts department
needs to be increased because the existing systems are not able to
do the needful.
The SAP system is over-loaded due to exhaustive usage. This
needs to be corrected by taking the required measures. It can be
rectified by changing or adding a server for supporting SAP in
Ranbaxy.
REFERENCES
Page 90 of 91
• Journals of Ranbaxy
• Text Books & Literature (I.M Pandey).
• Financial Management Kalyani publishers
WebPages
• www.pharmaceutical-business-review.com
• http://www.ranbaxy.com
• http://www.cipla.com
• http://www.google.com
• http://www.wikipedia.com
• http://www.drreddy.com
• http://www.lupingroup.com
• http://www.sunpharma.com
• http://www.moneypore.com
• www.bizstats.com
• www.reuters.com
• www.economictimes.com
• www.dereddys.com
• www.bloomsberg.com
• www.livemint.com
• www.studyfinance.com
• www.bized.com
• www.bpubs.com
Page 91 of 91