24th April 2019
To
‘The Hon'ble Lordships,
Hon’ble Justice $.A. Bobde, Hon’ble Justice N.V.Ramana and Hon'ble Justice
Indira Banerjee
through,
‘Mr.
njeev Kalgaonkar,
ty General
Supreme
sgoffice
Dourt of India
‘inic.in
Subject: Reply to Notice dated 23rd April 2019 titled “IN THE MATTER OF
COMPLAINT DATED 19th APRIL 2019 ALONG WITH AFFIDAVIT DATED
18th APRIL 2019."
A Notice from the Supreme Court of India dated 23rd April 2019 was received at my in
Jaws residence between 8:00 to 8:30 P.M on 23rd April 2019.
The Notice says,
*FAKE NOTICE THAT you are required to appear before a Committee of
Hon'ble Judges of Supreme Court of India in connection with the abovesaid
0
TT
As directed by this Notice, I will appear before the Committee of Hon’ble Judges on 26th
April 2019 at 12:30 PM. However, I have some cor
respectfllly placing before you
The Notice sent to me by the Secretary General of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
did not disclose to me the names of the Hon’ble Judges who would form the Committee.
‘Shortly after receiving this Notice 1 learnt from media reports that the Committee has
‘been formed by Hon’ble Justice S.A, Bobde and will consist of Hon'ble Justice Bobde,
Hon'ble Justice Ramana and Hon’ble Justice Indira Banerjee and will conduct an inquiry
‘inthe nature of a departmental inquiry and not a judicial inquiry. It is also reported by the
_ media that it is an in-house inquiry and this Committee was made after a decision of the
Full Court of the Supreme Court.
and questions that T am{am extremely grateful that your Loniships have set up iis Commit t0 inquire RE
toy Affidavit end the documents. | am hopeful that Your Lordships will after heating 0
. understand my suffering. However, as an ordinary woman Lam full of tear and anxiety 4%
| Jam in the unfortunate position of having to speak out against the Chief Justice of India.
ne that in order to give me a fair and equal hearing some special steps will have to
Thave written some of my concems and apprehensions here
ial inquiry committee
1, Uhad appealed to your Lordships in my Affidavit, that a spe
1c Court be constituted
‘comprising of senior Retired Judges of the Hon’ble Supreme
to enquire into the sexual harassment and the unbearable and malicious
victimisation of me and my family. Your Lordships have however formed an
Inquiry Committee comprising of sitting Hon'ble Judges of the Supreme Court
>, Lam told that under the Vishaka guidelines judgment laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court and the 2013 law relating to Protection of Women from Sexual
Harassment (POSH), the Inquiry Committee to ensure impartiality and fairness
must have majority women members. The Committee should have an external
‘woman member with an understanding of women’s rights and should also be
headed by a woman. I therefore request your Lordships to please ensure that this
Hon'ble Commitee also reflect this in its composition and procedure followed by
- the Committee,
uld like to say to your Lordships that | am extremely con
ly after reading about the hearing in Court | of the Supreme Court on
April 2019 in the Suo Motu matter in In Re: Matter Of Great
Touching Upon The Independence Of Judiciary presided
ible Chief Justice of India, Justice Arun Mishra, and Justice
. According to news reports the Chief Justice of Indi ated “T
is can be of a ploi of junior assistant. There is a bigger plot.
¢ office or C/I”. My charactor was damaged as without
hearing me, it was said that | have criminal cases against
rned and anxious
Justice ‘Arun Mishra said “These are all wild and
not passing any gag order on the media but we
‘some restraint, "and “How can we function if there
and Justice Sanjeev Khanna said “We cannot be
3restrained from giving unfavourable or favourable orders. When such allegations
ei Made, we feel restrained, constrained”. The Attorney General for India said “L
Gm ah officer of this Court, I was also under anack for defending the government
and the Solicitor General of India said “Rubbish being published” that it was a “a
blackmail wchnique®
Aller reading those news reports | was frightened and felt helpless that without
anyone hearing me, my complaint had been declared to be false by the Hon’ble
Judges and senior law officers
4 The next day on 21st April 2019, the blog by a senior cabinet minister also
Gonderned me. Because of these events I am very scared and feeling isolated and
depressed.
Addition to the above, I request you to grant the following requests
{u) The Notice does not mention anything about the procedure which will be
followed. 1 would request that { am informed in advance of the first hearing, about
the procedure that will be followed by this Hon’ble Commitee.
(b) 1 got to know from the news that on 20th April 2019 after I had sent my Affidavit
to Your Lordships, Hon’ble Justice Ramana while speaking in Hyderabad at
Centenary Celebrations of the High Court Building at Hyderabad said, “We have
Seen such attempts in the past and we will see some more in future. Some friends
in their private conversations are pointing out that criticism used to be against
politicians only, But today, judges are also under attacks. Do not be wary of such
Criticism as We haye to uphold the dignity of the judiciary.”
t that since I was posted in the CII’s residence office, 1
Ramana is a close friend of the CJI and is like a family
Justice Ramana is a frequent visitor to the residence of
ar that my Affidavit and evidence will not receive an