Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/280861973
CITATION READS
1 5,313
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Properties of Superpave Asphalt Concrete Subjected to Impact of Moisture Damage View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Saad Sarsam on 18 August 2015.
Abstract. In Iraq, under the effect of heavy traffic loading, high temperature and water damages, specific requirements are
needed to control the quality of highway pavement materials in order to increase durability. The primary objectives of this
study are evaluating the durability of superpave asphalt concrete mixtures which has been assessed through moisture damage
resistance. The properties of superpave mix have been verified using indirect tensile strength test, double punch shear strength,
compressive strength test, and rutting resistance under repeated loading. The impacts of moisture damage on such superpave
asphalt concrete properties were evaluated. To meet the objective of this research, available local materials were used
including asphalt cement (40-50), aggregate with nominal maximum size of 12.5 mm, and mineral filler. Three asphalt
percentages were implemented, optimum asphalt content and an asphalt content of 0.5 percent above and 0.5 percent below
optimum as per superpave procedure. The Superpave Gyratory Compaction was used to prepare the asphalt concrete
specimens. The moisture damage impacts on conditioned specimens exhibits low resistance to indirect tensile strength,
punching shear, and compressive strength by (-19%, -33%, -6%) at optimum asphalt content as compared with un-condition
mix. The moisture-conditioned mix has lower resistance to permanent deformation (at 1000 cycles) by 93% as compared with
the unconditioned mixture. Superpave asphalt concrete was shown to be durable against moisture damage by 81% at optimum
asphalt content when compared to the requirement of (SCRB, 2007).
Keywords: Asphalt concrete; Indirect tensile; Moisture damage; punching shear; Retained strength; Rutting.
2.4. Selection of Design Aggregate Gradation arithmetic scale of sieve size in millimeters, raised to
the 0.45 power. The aggregate blend selected has
The Superpave aggregate gradation controls are nominal maximum size of 12.5 mm usually adopted
maintained using the FHWA 0.45 power chart. This for wearing course as per (SCRB, 2007). Fig.1 shows
chart uses a unique technique where the ordinate the selected aggregate gradation.
shows the percent passing and the abscissa is an
454
International Journal of Scientific Research in Knowledge, 2(10), pp. 453-462, 2014
3. PREPARATION OF SPECIMENS FOR AASHTO TP4 to the level of compaction required for
RESISTANCE TO MOISTURE DAMAGE TEST the tests to be conducted. They were compacted using
gyratory compactor at air void content of 7±1 percent,
The aggregate are dried, separated into the desired which was fixed by changing number of gyrations and
size and recombined with the mineral filler in order to pressure of 600 kPa. Specimens were considered
meet the required gradation. The aggregates are then conditioned after they were subjected to vacuum
heated to a temperature of 160 °C before mixing with saturation followed by a freeze cycle followed by a 24
asphalt cement which has already been heated to a hour thaw cycle. Tests were accomplished by
temperature that produce a kinematic viscosity. Then, performing AASHTO T-283. The total number of
the desired amount of asphalt cement is weighed, specimens was (70 specimens).
added to the heated aggregates, and mixed until all
aggregate particles are coated with asphalt. Four 3.1. Compressive Strength Test
asphalt binder contents, at 1% of the estimated asphalt
content, and at 0.5 % increments have been This test is conducted to determine the suitability of
implemented and prepared. Test specimens of 115 asphalt concrete mixtures for pavement under given
mm in diameter and 150±5 mm in height were loading and environmental conditions. The test
prepared according to method AASHTO TP4. The followed the procedure of (ASTM D1074-02).
optimum asphalt content was 4.8%. Compressive strength specimens which were prepared
Three sizes of cylindrical specimens were prepared and stored in air bath at 25ºC for 4 hours, then, the test
for evaluating the impact of moisture damage, was performed by applying a compressive load at a
Specimen of 150 mm in diameter and 95±5 mm in constant rate of 5.08 mm/min to measure the
height were constructed for indirect tensile strength maximum load at failure. Fig.2 shows part of the
and tensile strength ratio. Specimens of 101.6 mm in prepared specimens.
diameter and 101.6±1.3 mm in height were prepared
for Double Punch Test, Compressive Strength test, 3.2. Double Punch Shear Test
and Index of Retained Strength Test. The third size
was specimens of 101.6 mm in diameter and 203±3 Jimenez (1974) developed this test procedure at the
mm in height for Permanent Deformation tests. University of Arizona, and it was used to measure the
Specimens were prepared at optimum asphalt content stripping of the binder from the aggregates, this test
and at asphalt contents of 0.5 percent above, and 0.5 was reported by many studies (Solaimanian, 2004;
percent below optimum as recommended by Turos, 2010; Kiggundu, 1988; Sarsam, 2006).
superpave procedure (AASHTO PP2, 1999). The Specimens used for this test were conditioned by
asphalt-aggregate mixture was then subjected to short- placing them in water bath at 60ºC for 30 min. The
term oven aging (STA) for 4hrs at 135° C according test was performed by centrally loading the cylindrical
to (AASHTO PP2). This aging represents the aging specimen, using two cylindrical steel punches placed
that occurs in the field between mixing and placement on the top and bottom surface of the sample. The
and allows for absorption of the asphalt binder into specimen was centered between the two punches (25.4
the aggregate pores. The mix was stirred every 30 mm in diameter), perfectly aligned one over the other,
minutes during the short-term aging process to and then loaded at a rate of 25.4 mm/minute until
prevent the outside of the mixture from aging more failure. The reading of dial gage at the maximum load
than the inner side because of increased air exposure. resistance was recorded. Fig.3 shows double punch
Mixing and compacted HMA sample according to shear test in progress.
455
Sarsam and Alwan
Impact of Moisture Damage on Rutting Resistance, Shear and Tensile Properties of Asphalt Pavement
3.3. Index of Retained Strength Test for these specimens was computed (ITS for
unconditioned specimens). The other two specimens
This method covers measurement of the loss of were subjected to vacuum saturation between 70 and
cohesion resulting from the action of water on 80 percent with water and is placed in the freezer (-
compacted asphalt concrete mixtures. The test 18°C) for 16 to 18 hours. The frozen specimens then
followed the procedure of (ASTM D1075-07). A set are moved to a water bath at (60°C) for 24 hours
of four specimens were prepared for this purpose. (thaw cycle), then they were placed in a water bath at
Two specimens were stored at air bath for 4 hours at 25ºC for 1 hour, and they were tested for indirect
25ºC, and then tested for compressive strength and the tensile strength, the average value was computed (ITS
average value was recorded. The other two specimens for moisture-conditioned specimens). The specimens
were stored in water bath at 60ºC for 24 hours, then were tested for the resilient modulus, indirect tensile
they were stored in another water bath at 25ºC for 2 strength, indirect tensile strength ratio, double punch,
hours, and the compressive strength test was compressive strength, and permanent deformation.
performed on these specimens, and also the average Two specimens for each mixture type were tested, and
value was recorded. the average value was recorded. The ratio of the
average tensile strengths of the conditioned and
3.4. Indirect Tensile Strength and tensile strength unconditioned specimens is known as the tensile
Ratio Test (TSR) strength ratio (TSR). The minimum acceptable TSR as
per AASHTO is 70%, (Roberts et al., 1996). The
The test was performed to evaluate the moisture results of these specimens are compared, to clarify the
damage resistance of mixtures, and the procedure effect of unconditioned and conditioned mix on
followed (AASHTO T 283). A set of four specimens mixture performance. Fig.4 shows the vacuum
were prepared, two specimens were tested for indirect saturation, while fig.5 shows the failure mode of ITS
tensile strength (ITS) by storing them in a water bath test specimen. On the other hand, fig.6 presents the
at 25ºC for 30 minutes, and an average value of ITS freeze- thaw cycle process.
Fig. 3: Double punch shear test Fig. 4: Specimens under vacuum process Fig. 5: Indirect tensile test
456
International Journal of Scientific Research in Knowledge, 2(10), pp. 453-462, 2014
3.5. Permanent Deformation Test 0.9 sec. rest period to simulate the truck loading
condition in the field as per shell procedure. Two
The axial repeated load tests were conducted using the temperatures 40° C, and 60° C are used in the tests,
pneumatic repeated load system (PRLS). The tests and the applied stress level was 20 psi. to simulate the
were performed on cylindrical specimens, 101.6 mm testing condition explained by Shell procedure that’s
(4 inch) in diameter and 203.2 mm (8 inch) in height. addressed in (Moghaddam et al, 2011; Yoder and
In these tests, repetitive compressive loading was Witczak, 1975). The testing temperatures of (60, 40)
applied to the specimen and the axial permanent ºC was used in the test, and the applied stress level
deformation was measured under loading repetitions. was 20 psi. fig.7 shows the tested specimen in the
Compressive loading was applied in the form of repeated loading chamber, while fig.8 demonstrates
rectangular wave at a constant loading frequency of the schematic diagram of accumulation of permanent
60 cycles per minute and two different loading strain under repeated loading.
sequences; which included 0.1 sec. load duration and
Fig. 7: Permanent deformation test Fig. 8: Accumulation of permanent strain under repeated loading
457
Sarsam and Alwan
Impact of Moisture Damage on Rutting Resistance, Shear and Tensile Properties of Asphalt Pavement
Fig. 9: Indirect tensile strength of asphalt concrete Fig. 10: Tensile strength ratio %TSR of asphalt concrete
Fig. 11: Punching shear strength of asphalt concrete Fig. 12: Punching shear ratio of asphalt concrete
4.3. Impact of Moisture Damage on Compressive design criteria established by the Iraqi Specification
Strength and Index of Retained Strength (IRS) (SCRB, 2007).
The index of retained strength (IRS) has been used to 4.4. Impact of Moisture Damage on Resilient
evaluate the resistance of mixture to water damage. Modules (Mr)
According to (SCRB, 2007), the minimum acceptable
value of Index of Retained Strength is (70%), The resilient modulus (Mr) properties are used to
therefore mixture with lower IRS is considered evaluate the moisture damage of the HMA mixtures,
susceptible to water damage. The detailed results for the Mr test is a nondestructive test that can be
compressive strength test are presented in Fig.13, conducted on the same samples before and after
while Fig.14 present the Index of Retained Strength. moisture conditioning, the Mr is an engineering
The compressive strength values of the conditioned property that can be used to estimate the response of
mixtures were lower than the unconditioned mixtures HMA pavements under traffic loads, (Tara, 2003).
by 6 % (at optimum asphalt content). When asphalt Table 4 summarizes the Mr properties of the
content percentage increases from 4.3 % to 4.8 %, the unconditioned and moisture conditioned HMA
resistance to compressive forces increases by 1 % for mixtures. The data show that the resilient modulus of
unconditioned mix, while when asphalt content moisture-conditioned specimens is significantly lower
increases from 4.8 % to 5.3 % the compressive than the values obtained for unconditioned mix by
strength increase 9 % for unconditioned mixes. Such 21% at optimum asphalt content. When the asphalt
finding are in agreement with (Sarsam, 2005) work. content percentage change from 4.3 to 4.8 percentages
Results of IRS shows a good performance of optimum the Mr value decreases by 18%, and decreases by 27%
asphalt content percentage as shown in Fig.14, it when asphalt content changes from 4.8 to 5.3 %. The
shows that mixes with variable asphalt content are change in testing temperature from 40 to 60 °C has a
considered unsusceptible to moisture damage since it negative influence on Mr by 20% at optimum asphalt
has IRS more than (70%). These values meet the content.
458
International Journal of Scientific Research in Knowledge, 2(10), pp. 453-462, 2014
Fig. 13: Compressive strength of asphalt concrete Fig. 14: Index of retained strength %IRS of asphalt concrete
4.5. Impact of Moisture Damage on Resistance to rutting distress mechanism at a slower rate. The
Permanent Deformation analysis of the table shows that the moisture
conditioned mix has lower resistance to permanent
Table 4 shows the impact of moisture on permanent deformation (at 1000 cycles) by 93% as compared
deformation. The analysis of permanent deformation with the unconditioned mixture; it has shorter life and
in this study is based on intercept, and slope fails before the unconditioned mix. Such finding is in
parameters and permanent deformation at 1,000 load agreement with (Sarsam and Lafta, 2014; Sarsam,
cycles. The pneumatic repeated load system was 1999). The higher permanent deformation is
implemented. The permanent deformation (vertical associated with the increases in asphalt content. It can
plastic strain) is measured using the dynamic test at be seen that the intercept and slope increases in
temperature of 40° C and 60° C, with a stress level of conditioned mix, that gives indication that the un
0.138 MPa. The intercept represents the permanent conditioned mixtures have low permanent microstrain
strain at N=1, where N is the number of the load as compared with conditioned mix. Table 4 shows the
cycles. The higher value of intercept, the larger strain effect of temperature on permanent microstrain, when
and hence the larger the potential for permanent testing temperature changes from 40 to 60° C, the
deformation as mentioned in the study carried out by permanent microstrain increases. Fig.15 show the
(Sarsam and AL-Zubaidi, 2014). While slope impact of moisture damage on the permanent
represents the rate of change in the permanent strain deformation at both testing temperatures and various
as a function of the change in loading cycles (N) in asphalt percentages. The resilient modulus decreases
the log-log scale, high slope values for a mix indicate after moisture damage for all asphalt percentages,
an increase in the material deformation rate hence less while it decreases as asphalt percentages increases as
resistance against rutting. A mix with a low slope demonstrated in table 4.
value is preferable as it prevents the occurrence of the
459
Sarsam and Alwan
Impact of Moisture Damage on Rutting Resistance, Shear and Tensile Properties of Asphalt Pavement
Fig. 15: Permanent deformation of asphalt concrete at various asphalt content and testing temperatures
460
International Journal of Scientific Research in Knowledge, 2(10), pp. 453-462, 2014
461
Sarsam and Alwan
Impact of Moisture Damage on Rutting Resistance, Shear and Tensile Properties of Asphalt Pavement
Prof. Saad Issa Sarsam was born in Baghdad (1955), got his BSc. In Civil Engineering (1977), Post
graduate diploma in Transportation Engineering (1978); MSc in Transportation Engineering (1980).
He worked as senior material Engineer for NCCL (1982-1992); He joined the academic staff at
University of Mosul (1992-2005) and got the Assistant Professor degree at (2002); He joined the
academic staff at University of Baghdad (2005 until now) and got the Professor degree at (2007).
Areas of specialization and interest: (Roller compacted concrete; modified asphalt concrete; Asphalt
stabilized embankment models; Road user characteristics).
Ali Hussein Alwan was born in Baghdad, (1987), got his BSc. in Civil Engineering (2011), MSc. in
Civil Engineering (Transportation),( 2013). Worked for Al-Hamed Company as supervising Engineer
on Building of International football stadium Municipality of Al-Muthana (2011-2012). He worked for
City Dimension Contracting Company as Soil investigation engineer on the construction of oil storage
tanks /Municipality of Al-Basra. (2012-2013). Worked for Osman Qader Company as Surveyor
Engineer on construction of a sewage disposal station (Al-Hussenia)/Municipality of Baghdad (2013 –
2014). He is working for Setraco Company as site engineer and as QC and QA on construction of
roads and bridges, Baghdad- Karbala Project.(2014 until now).
462