Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Startup Lessons
An Entrepreneur’s Handbook
by
George Deeb
Blog Into Book
www.BlogIntoBook.com
2 Marketing
Lesson #6: Structuring Strategic Partnerships for Your Startup
Lesson #20: Setting Product & Pricing Strategy For Your Startup
Lesson #21: Setting a Sales & Marketing Plan For Your Startup
Lesson #22: How to Calculate ROI on Your Marketing Spend
Lesson #23: How to Design Effective Advertising Copy &
Creatives
Lesson #24: How to Choose a Name For Your Startup
Lesson #44: The Importance of Blogging
Lesson #48: Trade Show Strategies for Startups
Lesson #52: Viral Marketing Via Social Media
Lesson #53: Search Engine Marketing Strategies
Lesson #54: Incorporate Video Into Your Marketing Efforts
Lesson #68: Mobile Apps & Location-Based Services
Lesson #69: The Marketing Power of Free Publicity
Lesson #72: The 10 Basics of Website Design
Lesson #74: Brand Building for Your Startup
Lesson #77: The Basics of Email Marketing
Lesson #79: Determining Customer Lifetime Value
Lesson #88: The Basics of Online Display Ads
Lesson #95: The Basics of Telemarketing
Lesson #99: The Basics of Direct Mail Marketing
3 Human Resources
Lesson #2: Building the Right Team for Your Start-Up
Lesson #9: Spreading Equity to Key Employees and Partners
Lesson #13: Creating The Right Culture for Your Startup
Lesson #14: The Role of a Startup CEO
Lesson #15: Hands-On vs. Hands-Off Management of Startups
Lesson #16: The Plusses & Minuses of Virtual Employees
Lesson #18: The Right Work-Life Balance for a Startup
Lesson #30: When to Hire Employees vs. Contractors vs.
Crowdsources
Lesson #34: How Best to Recruit Employees For Your Startup
Lesson #35: How to Read Resumes & Screen Employee Candidates
Lesson #42: Is Working With Family Members a Good Idea?
Lesson #51: No Public Displays of Rejection
Lesson #55: Creating a Healthy Office Environment
Lesson #58: How to Determine Employee Compensation
Lesson #59: Determining Employee Benefits for Your Startup
Lesson #60: Importance of Employee Handbooks
Lesson #75: How to Implement Layoffs
Lesson #76: How to Implement an Employee Change
Lesson #83: Startup Roles & Responsibilities
Lesson #93: Make Your Employees Feel Appreciated
4 Technology
Lesson #36: Picking The Best Technology for Your Web Startup
5 Fund Raising
Lesson #4: How to Raise Capital for Your Startup
Lesson #5: Finding Angel Investors for Your Startup
Lesson #10: How Best to Approach VC’s or Angel Investors
Lesson #27: How VC’s Define a Backable Management Team
Lesson #32: How to Value Your Startup Business
Lesson #49: How to Get a Loan, or Not!!
Lesson #66: Preparing for a Due Diligence Process
Lesson #97: Securing a Small Business Grant
6 Finance
Lesson #61: Set Up Proper Accounting Controls
Lesson #67: Managing Accounts Payable & Accounts Receivable
Lesson #78: How to Build a Budget
7 General Business
Lesson #3: The Importance of Timing and Luck for Your Startup
Lesson #8: Startups Require Flexibility to Optimize Business Model
Lesson #28: Expect the Unexpected – Always Have a Cushion
Lesson #29: No Matter How Bad It Gets, Persistence Wins
Lesson #31: The Power of a Pivot - Thinking Out of the Box
Lesson #39: The Art of Negotiation
Lesson #40: Focus! Focus! Focus! Build One Business at a Time.
Lesson #47: The Importance of Networking
Lesson #50: Do What You Love!! Passion Drives Success
Lesson #71: Launch Fast! Fail Fast!
Lesson #85: Tap Into Your Local Startup Ecosystem
Lesson #86: Perception Often Outshines Reality
Lesson #87: The Art of Decision Making
Lesson #90: Proper Business Etiquette for Startups
Lesson #92: Building Your Personal Brand
8 Sales
Lesson #21: Setting a Sales & Marketing Plan For Your Startup
Lesson #25: How to Structure Your Sales Team & Procedures
Lesson #26: Designing Sales Incentives to Motivate Your Sales
Team
Lesson #98: Securing a Government Contract
9 Operations
Lesson #33: The Importance of Customer Service
Lesson #41: Security Considerations for Your Startup
Lesson #56: Frequent Legal Questions of Startups
Lesson #62: Insurance Protection for Startups
Lesson #70: Protect Your Intellectual Property
Lesson #73: Consumer Usability Testing
Lesson #80: Pitfalls to Avoid When “Reeling in the Whale”
Lesson #82: Project Management & Prioritization
10 Case Studies
Lesson #84: Lady Gaga—An Entrepreneurial Case Study
Lesson #89: Startup Lessons from Scrabble
Lesson #91: My Entrepreneurial Heroes
Lesson #94: Netflix—A User Experience Meltdown
11 Miscellaneous
Lesson #46: 23 Motivational Quotes for Entrepreneurs
Lesson #57: Required Reading for Startup Entrepreneurs
Lesson #101: Plusses & Minuses of Entrepreneurship
So, who ultimately figured out the winning business model in online
travel? Planning sites like Trip Advisor, which was ultimately
acquired by Expedia to improve their business. Trip Advisor
appealed to all travelers looking for hotel reviews, so a mass-market
opportunity. But, unlike Expedia who was dependent on low margin
air, car and hotel bookings, Trip Advisor successfully built an
online advertising based revenue model that was wildly lucrative to
its bottom line. So, Trip Advisor won the best business idea in the
online travel space, with the biggest market opportunity and the
most profitable revenue model.
Once you have completed your business plan, you would materially
pare back this information before presenting it to investors,
depending on your need (e.g., a 1-2 page executive summary for
preliminary introductions to investors via email; 14-15 slides for an
in-person presentation). Never lead with a 30-40 page document;
nobody will read it past the first page given limited investor
attention span and lots of competing investment opportunities. So,
make sure you get to the point, short and sweet. And remember,
graphic presentations always make a better impact than words,
where possible. So, provide screenshots of the product, instead of
describing it in sentences.
Overall, I think these programs are terrific for first time CEOs who
can quickly get up the learning curve with the help of mentors and
investors that have “been there, and done that”. Plus, your odds of
raising capital are vastly improved given the tight screening
processes of these groups, which naturally raise the creme de la
creme to the top, from the 1000’s of applicants they receive each
year. Competition is naturally fierce to get one of these coveted
spots, so make sure you have a fine-tuned pitch and leverage your
network to help pull some strings for you.
Good luck!
Lesson #12: How to Structure Your Board of
Directors or Advisory Board
Properly structuring your board of directors and advisory board
could be one of the most important pieces of determining the
success for any venture. These are the people you are going to be
relying on for strategic direction, or voting on all key decisions. So,
it is important you get this right.
The last key consideration for your board members and advisers is
to make sure they are appropriately compensated for their time
commitment, and incentivized to help you grow your business. For
you and your cash investors, you are appropriately motivated as is,
with your material equity stakes. But, for outside board members or
advisers, I would suggest setting aside a small piece of the
company’s equity to distribute between these key people based on
their level of involvement. Let’s say you set aside 5% of the
company for these purposes, and your outside board member may
get a 1% stake, and your 8 outside advisers may each get a 0.5%
stake (in the form of options or warrants). And, make sure all equity
grants have vesting periods, so earned over time invested, and can
easily be repurchased or recaptured if things go wrong down the
road, in case you need to make a change.
This is a lot to cover in one lesson, but hopefully you have a better
sense to the big picture items here.
The fit with the team in terms of skillset and personality is obvious
enough. It is important you can get along with your new partners,
giving the long hours you will be working together. So, if you clash
in style or personality, it will never work. And, it is important that
you each are bringing a unique and non-overlapping skillset to the
table. So, if the company already has a strong tech leader and
operations leader, maybe you bring strong marketing or financial
skills to the table, to balance the team. You don’t ever want to be in
a situation where job roles are not clearly defined upfront, to avoid
stepping on eachother’s turf, especially when impassioned founders
are involved.
As for management control, let’s say you have been made an offer
to become the new CEO of the business. You need to be perfectly
clear up front that you have the final decision making authority in
terms of business direction, and that the founders are willing to
follow your lead, even if it may be in a different direction than the
company was currently heading. This could even include making a
change in management, if the CEO believes the founder is not the
right person in that position. That said, you have to do this in a
consensus building way, making sure you support any moves with
hard numbers that back up your assumptions. Since the founders
will clearly need an education to make a material move from where
they may have been heading, with firm and entrenched ideas there.
Equity control is your option, whether you are willing to work with
a majority or minority stake in the company. Your equity stake is
typically dictated by your level of cash investment and importance
of your role in the company. But, if absolute control of the business
is important to you, as a new CEO, for example, make sure you
invest enough to get you over that 51% threshold. Or, if
economically you cannot get there, put in a mechanic like super-
voting shares to make sure no strategic decisions get made without
your support.
This last piece about corporate governance is the one that people
typically forget about, especially in LLCs. There are scenarios
where you may be the strategy leading CEO, with 51% equity
ownership and 51% board control, and still not control the key
change in control decisions of the company. The operating
agreement of an LLC, or the charter of a corporation, may have
special rules in place around changes in control. For example, it
may require the sole approval of a founder for any change in
control, who may veto any deal that you are a proponent of. So, get
your lawyers engaged, and read the fine print in the corporate
governance, to make sure nothing gets in the way of your long-term
desires.
Once the high-level research is done, you need to start digging even
deeper. This will include asking prospective customers of your
business, if they are aware of any similar businesses in the market.
And, similar businesses could also include tangential businesses that
could easily pivot into your space if you are successful. For
example, if you are launching an online restaurant reservation
software, competition could easily pop up from tangential players
like point of sale register manufacturers (e.g., Micros, Radiant) or
other large online businesses in the restaurant space (e.g.,
Restaurant.com, OpenTable.com, Zagat.com).
Another example includes making sure you think about all players
that are aggressively going after the same target audience, even if in
very different businesses. Let’s say you are building a fishing
website. In addition to all the fishing websites, you are also
competing with magazines like Field & Stream, cable networks
likes Sportsman Channel, retailers like Cabela’s, fishing gear
manufacturers like Daredevil lures and online portals like Yahoo
(that may have a fishing content section). All of these businesses
will be putting a lot of consumer marketing muscle to work to own
the online fishing space, so prepare for a lot of competition from
many different businesses all looking for the same fisherman
eyeballs.
Once you fully assess who your current or potential competitors are,
then you have to assess their strengths (e.g., customer base, revenue
base, cash resources, product offering) and weaknesses to see if you
can build a better “mouse trap” within your budget. Some
companies decide not to move forward at this point, because it is
simply too much of an uphill battle to win the space, or will require
much more monies than are available to spend. But, if you are
confident you can offer a better product, better pricing, better
marketing tactics or bigger budgets than your competitors, then
“bring it on!”
For a franchisor, the advantages are pretty clear: you have opened
up a near limitless supply of investment capital from your
franchisees footing the bill of your expansion. That is how
companies like Starbucks, Subway and Dunkin Donuts have seen
rapid expansion on a global basis. Yes, you now need to manage
this network of franchisees, which can be distracting. But, no more
so than managing your own growth. And, by franchising, you get
your brand to market much faster, before somebody else comes in
with a competing concept. And, what many franchisors do, is use
franchising to roll out the brand as quickly as possible, and then buy
back their best-performing franchisees over time, as cash from
operations start flowing through the business, and they have the
resources to scale up revenues with company-owned locations.
Quite a clever model, as the franchisor, with the franchisees taking
most of the financial startup risk. The only downside is the
franchisees may not be required to sell, so the franchisor may
permanently lose key markets long term (so, plan ahead for which
markets will be most critical for your long term strategy).
When you have found a target, how you approach them will go a
long way towards increasing your odds of getting to the finish line.
Sometimes it makes sense to approach them directly, and other
times it makes sense to approach them through a third party
intermediary. The latter is better with highly competitive businesses
or with executives that may not present well on a first call. And,
when you do approach targets directly, I recommend not jumping
right into merger discussions. This is all about building up a
relationship and comfort for the target company. So, I like to start
with “potential partner” discussions, that ultimately evolve into
“potential merger” discussions down the road. And, worth
mentioning, the word “merger” sounds less harmful than
“acquisition”, for the target who is not quite ready to let go the
reins.
During due diligence of the target company, make sure you have
your lawyer send over a detailed information request list, which
could include, review of: (i) all company financial statements,
historical and projected; (ii) all company ownership history and
shareholder records; (iii) list of all known assets of the business; (iv)
a list of all known liabilities of the business, or its shareholders; (v)
a list of all current and past employees by title, including resumes;
(vi) a list of all contracts of the business; and (vii) a list of all
intellectual property, to name a few. These schedules will become
the basis of any representations or warranties made by the seller in
the closing documents. But, more important than anything, make
sure you trust the people you are “getting in bed” with. So, make
sure there is a good personality fit, a good skill fit and a good trust
factor with the selling company and their shareholders. Call their
trade and personal references as a critical step during due diligence.
But, if you do not like what the relative contribution method has to
say, or if you don’t want any outside shareholders in Newco, cash
will be your primary currency using one of the techniques discussed
in Lesson #32. Beyond making the cash or equity acquisition
decision, other structural considerations include the following. The
most important is deciding between an “equity purchase” or an
“asset purchase”. The latter is preferred, as it leaves all the liabilities
and other “skeletons in the closet” with the target company’s
shareholders, and do not transfer to Newco. The timing of payments
is another consideration. If you don’t have all the cash day one, you
can structure payments over time if the seller is willing to take a
seller’s note from the buyer at closing. Or, if you cannot agree on
upfront valuation, you can put earn-out mechanisms in place, to get
the target future upside payments if certain projection thresholds are
met. But, earn-outs are complicated to write for both the buyer and
the seller, so get good legal advice here. The other structural
consideration is making sure the seller gives the buyer proper
representations and warranties (from both the company and their
underlying shareholders, individually and collectively), to make
sure there are refunds to the buyer if anything was not delivered as
promised after closing. And, don’t forget to make sure the target
company is delivered to you with an adequate amount of working
capital, in line with historical levels.
At the end of the day, there are a lot of things that go wrong with
acquisitions, and very few go perfectly to plan. So, be conservative
in your forecasts, and consider haircutting target revenues by 50%
as a cushion, especially if the “entrepreneurial fire” of the target’s
CEO are not going to be a part of Newco. And, before going down
this road in the first place, make sure you have done a complete
“buy vs. build” analysis for this decision. As, it may be cheaper to
ultimately build the solution yourself, and not have to deal with any
of the business combination or cultural integration issues of a
merger or acquisition. Proceed only with caution here, to not upset
the apple cart.
Hopefully, you get the point here: any startup requires long-term
defensible barriers to entry to attract investors, protect its turf and
increase odds of long term revenue growth. Critically assess your
own business, and look for opportunities to build your own barriers
to entry against potential future competitors.
Always remember: you are not alone in your startup efforts, there is
a wide base of mentors and business coaches you should tap into to
help you accelerate and optimize your efforts. Good luck.
So, critically assess your business and think creatively who such
targets could be. And, remember, the bigger the buying company,
the bigger your business needs to be to get their attention. Expedia
wouldn’t even talk to iExplore, without having $5MM in EBITDA,
since any acquisition smaller than that, was less than a decimal
point rounding error for their multi-billion dollar business. The
flipside of this is, the small the business you approach, the less
likely they will be able to fund an acquisition with free cash or
otherwise, which may push them to only considering a stock-based
deal (which may not be as attractive to you as a cash based deal).
So, prioritize your prospective suitors accordingly, to find the right
mix of business size and liquidity to increase the odds you get to the
finish line.
If you are less than this, you are most likely taking about
negotiating a “recap” with a venture capital firm, which is a lot
tougher to do, since venture capitalists prefer their cash to grow the
business, not take out selling shareholders. And, remember, both
private equity firms and venture capitalists are not going to play
unless a going forward management team is in place. So, plan
accordingly with members of your own team, or otherwise.
Equity or Asset Deal. An equity deal is when the buyer takes over
100% of your capital stock, and all the related assets and liabilities
of the business. An asset deal is when the buyer only acquires the
key assets of the business (and whatever specific liabilities they are
willing to take on, like current accounts payable). For the most part,
buyers of startups are looking to do asset deals. It helps lower their
downside risk of not knowing what skeletons are in your closet to
creep up and bite them on the butt. So, that means, asset deals will
be your most likely requested scenario from your prospective buyer,
which is fine. Provided you understand you will need to resolve all
open liabilities not taken by the buyer with any proceeds you get
from the sale, which are hopefully enough to cover them.
As for a case study here. Groupon believed they were a first mover
with a unique product and that they needed to move at light speed to
expand their product in most major global markets overnight. But,
they had hundreds of millions of dollars in venture capital to work
with, and could afford that call. That said, some would argue that
they expanded too fast, as in China, where they are having a tough
time with operations and are already going through a round of
layoffs there.
VERTICAL GROWTH—DOMESTIC
VERTICAL GROWTH—INTERNATIONAL
SEMI-VERTICAL GROWTH
HORIZONTAL GROWTH—ENDEMIC
HORIZONTAL GROWTH—NON-ENDEMIC
So, keep this startup checklist handy. If you check-off most of the
items on the above list, you should be “off to the races” in building
a winning business that should attract smart venture investors for
your business. Wishing you the world of success (and luck) in your
entrepreneurial adventure.
2 Marketing
A few key considerations for any deal: (i) make sure the equity
component is fair in comparison to the level of marketing support
being provided (e.g., put a cash value on that support as a percent of
your company valuation); (ii) make sure the marketing support is
well documented so when it gets handed down from the biz dev
department to the people in the trenches, they have to execute it
with no wiggle room for interpretation; (iii) make sure the deal
works in good times (cash rich) and in bad times (cash poor); (iv)
make sure the strategic partner invests some amount of cash (even if
minimal), so they have skin in the game to help protect their
investment; (v) make sure the partnership has tight performance
deadlines to implement your marketing support, as big companies
can move very slowly without them; and (vi) make sure nothing
impedes your marketability to venture capitalists or limits your
potential exit options down the road, as discussed above.
But, product is only part of the offering; price is the other key
driver. If you are not offering your clients a substantially better
value than current solutions, you might as well pack up your bags
right now. At iExplore, we not only offered a unique product in the
market, as described above, we offered it at a price point 35% lower
than similar products in the market (the exclamation point behind an
already terrific product offering). And, at my other business,
MediaRecall, our entire value proposition was largely around price
(and speed). Why spend $10MM on your project, when we can do it
for $1MM (in a fraction of the time)?
And, on the world wide web, prices are often moving to FREE, with
alternative ad supported revenue models. Why do you think all the
newspapers are going out of business? Because people do not want
to pay for day-old content that a user can now find up-to-the-minute
on the internet for free. Why do you think the music industry has
been struggling? Because people do not want to pay $14.99 for a
whole album of songs, when they can simply buy the one track they
like for $0.99 on iTunes or find it for free on any of the file sharing
services. This trend is particularly true for mobile apps. In my
opinion it is better to offer it for free, for some period of time, to
build up mass user adoption and word of mouth, and then
implement your revenue model later. That is exactly what Google,
Twitter and Facebook did, and we all know what happened to those
companies, dominating the web..
Most B2B companies are sales driven organizations, and most B2C
companies are marketing driven organizations, with numerous
examples of companies overlapping between the two. The reasons
most B2B companies are sales driven are three fold: (i) they are
usually dealing with a much smaller base of customers, more easily
reachable by a sales team; (ii) corporate customers are typically
relationship driven, and want the comfort of working with a
salesperson that best understands their needs; and (iii) the average
transaction size can get very large, often into the millions, which
needs the comfort provided from a face to face meeting to close a
sale (e.g., the trust factor).
The downsides of marketing are: (i) it can get expensive for any
budget, so you will need to have cash resources to spend; (ii) the
results are not always perfectly attributable to a specific marketing
piece, so you may not be able to know with 100% certainty which
tactics are working better or worse than others; and (iii) we are
living in a world where small budget startups are competing with
big budget brands for the same marketing real estate.
Given the importance of these topics, I will dig into more details in
following lessons.
Although it is harder to do, you can also use the same level of
tracking on your offline marketing activities. As an example, if you
send a direct mailer, use a unique promotion code that the customer
shares at the time of purchase with your call center staff. If you are
promoting a 1-800 number in your TV advertisements, use a unique
1-800 number for each cable channel you are advertising on, or
more specifically, each specific program you are advertising on. In
your magazine buys, use different promotional URLs to point your
traffic by magazine (e.g., .com/TimeMagOffer). Not all consumers
will end up contacting you via these tracking mechanisms, going to
your main website instead. But, a good portion will, and you will be
able to make smart interpretations and extrapolations from there.
Then, once you know the profitable metrics for your business (e.g.,
never spend more than a $2CPM on any online banner ads), you
need to religiously live by those metrics. Only buy ads that fall
below that criterion. And, often times, your desired sites will not
allow you to buy committed advertising at a level well below their
rate card. So, in those cases, you need to be really creative when
negotiating those deals. Tell them you don’t need to buy committed
space at $10CPM, you are willing to buy remnant, unsold inventory
at $2CPM, which may be more digestible to them instead of letting
remnant inventory going unsold for zero revenues.
So, as a first time CEO, I was really excited about the prospective
results from this campaign. And, the advertising industry would
have certainly guessed the same, as this campaign won a ton of
awards for best creatives in the travel industry.
Then reality hit us in the face like a ton of bricks. This campaign
was not selling any trips!! We were spending a lot of money buying
double page print ads in expensive magazines like National
Geographic, Conde Nast and Travel & Leisure (and even NYC
billboards in Times Square!!), but there were very little revenues to
cover the massive costs of this effort. So, we were hemorrhaging the
cash provided from our venture capitalists.
Ignoring the fact we were spending a lot of money offline, when we
should have been better spending most of this money online, as an
internet company, let’s study what was specifically wrong with
these creatives. The first problem was the creative size itself.
Buying double page spreads in the major travel magazines was
VERY expensive as a startup company. We would have been much
better served with single page, or even half page ads to start,
stretching out our budget over a longer period of time.
The second problem was the iExplore name and business was
unknown to anybody, and the tagline did not do a good job
describing the business. Instead of an inspirational message like
“Come Back Different”, it should have been more descriptive about
our business, like “Adventure Travel Experts”. It is perfectly
acceptable for Nike to use the brand-building tagline “Just Do It”,
when they were a 20-year-old company, and everyone already new
them as an athletic apparel and footwear manufacturer. But, not for
iExplore, a brand new company that needed to educate the market
on its core business offering. We thought we were doing a good job
explaining the business in the paragraph of copy at the bottom of the
ad, but didn’t realize that magazine readers turn the page at an
average flip time of two seconds. Nobody was reading the
paragraph in two seconds, and we needed to get the message out
faster.
The third problem was the biggest of them all. Where was the call to
action?? There wasn’t one!! There should have been a message like
“Book Your Trip by December 1st and Save 10% “, or “Free
Airfare with Any Tour Purchase by December 1st”. This tells the
reader more about the business (e.g., that we sell trips), gives them a
special deal (e.g., to save money), and gives them a sense of
urgency to make an action (e.g., by a certain date). We could have
easily doubled our revenues from this campaign with more call-to-
action oriented messaging.
A fourth problem was the limited frequency of the print ads. In the
travel magazine world, new issues were coming out once a month.
And, it typically takes 6-7 ad impressions before it catches
someone’s attention to make it actionable. So, that meant 6-7
months of expensive print ad buying before we would really know
the full success from the campaign. Travel sections of newspapers
would have been a much better vehicle, since the ads were coming
out daily/weekly, not monthly. Or the travel sections of the Yahoo
or MSN websites would have been even better, since the ads would
be running online, and the action is simply “one click away”,
instead of print readers having to get to their computers to make an
action.
At the end of the day, this campaign was a complete disaster, for all
the reason mentioned above. And, to make matters worse, we ended
up pulling the campaign after only 3-4 months, which meant that
any repeated impressions we were building up towards the 6-7
month requirement, were entirely flushed down the toilet midstream
(no pun intended). Believe me, after that first year at iExplore, we
never made those same marketing mistakes again!! And, we
established key disciplines for tracking our marketing ROI on a
line-by-line basis, as discussed in our last lesson.
This is just one example of the things you need to consider when
designing the copy, creatives, frequency and placements for your
advertising efforts. The summary is: (1) startups need to be crystal
clear on what they do with as few words as possible; (2) there needs
to be a strong, time-sensitive call to action, to trigger a transaction;
(3) design your campaign with maximizing frequency in mind, to
build up repeated impressions; (4) pick creative sizes that are most
affordable to your budget; (5) if possible, make sure the campaign is
easily cancellable if not working; and (6) place ads in the medium
most logical for your business (e.g., e-commerce companies should
bias online advertising).
I hope this post saves you a lot of misspent advertising dollars. I
surely wished I had all that venture capital back, to do it right the
second time!
As for the name itself, you really have two roads to consider: (i)
choosing an intuitive, descriptive name for your business (e.g.,
Restaurant.com, Toys R Us, YouTube, Netflix); or (ii) creating a
whole new memorable name, not specifically related to your
business (e.g., Google, Yahoo, Hulu, Twitter). If you have tons of
money to spend, maybe creating a unique name is the right way to
go. But, for the most of us, starting a business on a shoestring
budget, I always vote for a clean and clear name that simply
describes your core product offering. It will take less marketing
money to educate a consumer on your business the clearer your
name is. As an example, people will intuitively know Tennis
Superstore is a place to go to buy tennis related products, without
any other words or marketing message required. Which is important
for consumers with very limited attention spans, getting bombarded
by marketing messages from every direction.
Now, there are alternative opinions that a unique name is the way to
go. And, I clearly understand their arguments. For example, how
great it would be for your marketing efforts, if your brand name
became the de facto term for an industry. Instead of saying “look for
it on the search engines”, you say “Google it”. Instead of saying,
“overnight it to me”, you say “FedEx it to me”. Instead of saying,
“pass me a tissue”, you say “pass me a Kleenex”. But, that typically
takes a lot of money and a lot of time to build up to that kind of
brand position in an industry.
I thought the most clever name for a startup in the last couple years
was Groupon. Because it did both things: it clearly explained their
business (e.g., group coupons), and it was a cool and edgy name. I
think their name was as much a part of their marketing success than
anything else, as the name was virally spread from friend to friend
around the internet trying to take advantage of a special daily deal.
Customers saying “I bought a Groupon”, sounds a lot cooler than “I
bought a Living Social”.
But, coming up with a name, is only half of the chore. Making sure
it is available and non-competitive is the other half of the chore.
More important than the name itself, is making sure your desired
name is available for all potential uses and in all potential markets.
So, the first place I start is the U.S. and international trademark
databases, to make sure nobody is already using, or has reserved the
use, of a potential name in the industry and countries you plan on
operating.
The next place I look is the WHOIS records of the domain name
registries, to make sure the desired domain name is available in all
the variations I may need (e.g., com, .co, .uk, .com, .au, .ca). And, to
me, a desirable domain name means a clean .com extension in the
U.S., since so many people are familiar with .com addresses in the
U.S.. So, BrandName.com is preferred to Brand-Name.com or
BrandName.net. Business struggles aside, there was a reason Yahoo
renamed Del.icio.us to Delicious.com after it acquired the business
(a lot more intuitive for consumers who may have been looking for
the site at the latter domain).
But, as we all know, .com extensions are the oldest, and the
toughest to find good available names, at least for a low price still
owned by the registries. But, if you can afford it and it is not too
expensive, sometimes it makes sense to acquire a domain name
from a third party, if it helps you achieve your long term branding
and marketing goals. As an example, I acquired iExplore.com for
$20,000 back in 1999. Although this was a painful short-term move,
it was a minimal long term investment for building the optimal long
term brand for the business (in this case, an online adventure travel
company). The “i” indicated internet based and the “Explore” was
the core word we wanted to leverage for global exploration.
That said, if I could have found a better name for $19.99, I would
have gone that route. But, Conquest.com,
TheAdventureExperts.com, Explorama.net and BananaPlanet.com
didn’t fit my desired brand or marketing goals. Conquest was too
“hardcore” and “macho”. People would type
“AdventureExperts.com”, not “TheAdventureExperts.com”. People
would type “Explorama.com”, not “Explorama.net”. And, is
BananaPlanet a place for adventure travel, fruit or porn?
The blog that provided this content for the book you are reading
now is an example of that. I, as the Managing Partner of Red Rocket
Ventures, a startup consulting and fund raising firm, am trying to
come across as an expert in startups who has lived through the same
battles you now find yourself fighting through. Not to mention, for
many of you, this is your first time ever hearing about Red Rocket.
You may be asking, “Why should I trust this firm to help me solve
my startup-related problems?”. Well, hopefully the quality of the
content on this blog not only educates the readers on various topics,
but it also instills trust to get prospective clients to actually pick up
the phone and engage with me on their various needs.
Also, the blog gives my readers the chance to voice their agreement
or disagreement with various points that I am making. For example,
when I wrote my post on best practices for marketing, a reader
rightly pointed out that offering deep discounts to attract new
customers may work better for B2C facing businesses than B2B
facing businesses. Hence, further enhancing reader education on the
topic, and creating a two-way dialog with my readers, so they too
feel like they are participating in the discussion.
So, for the reasons above, consider a blog a vital component of your
website, search marketing and social marketing strategies. And,
don’t forget to ask for new followers, as I do in my last sentence in
each of my posts.
But, for B2B companies, trade shows can be one of the most
important and targeted ways to market their businesses to
prospective clients, given the highly targeted nature of the audience
at that show (e.g., corporate buyers of their product or services). As
an example, if you are a developer of a digital video platform for
government clients (e.g., Department of Defense, NASA), where
better to find targeted clients than at the annual Government Video
Expo, where sellers of government facing technologies exhibit to
government buyers of such technologies in this very niche market
segment (where all key people will be in one place at the same
time). So, as a B2B company, it is critical you research the key trade
shows in your industry, and incorporate them into your marketing
plans. And, the more targeted the trade show the better (e.g.,
Government Video Expo, better than Video Expo, in this example).
So, prioritize accordingly.
Now, identifying the trade shows is only half of the exercise. More
importantly, you need to decide how you plan on participating at
these trade shows. Will you exhibit with a booth? Or, sponsor the
show? Or, be a presenter or a panelist? Or, simply attend? The
answer to that question is directly proportional to: (i) the importance
of the show to achieving your overall sales goals; and (ii) your
budgets to afford the various options.
Based on Katy’s direct experience with clients (e.g., the Where I’ve
Been travel site grew from zero to 145,000 Twitter/Facebook
followers in 2.5 years from very inexpensive efforts), she believes
that a successful startup needs to focus on the following five things
in setting their social media strategies, and hopefully terrific viral
growth with follow: (i) stay educated on the latest trends in the
social media industry; (ii) create domain expertise within your own
industry; (iii) identify and motivate brand ambassadors that help
you spread the word; (iv) integrate social media throughout your
entire user experience, not just in marketing activities; and (v) hire a
social media expert whose sole job is to grow your business through
these channels. We will tackle each of these points in the following
paragraphs.
Study The Latest Trends. By the time this chapter is written, there
may already be a new favorite tactic being used by social marketers.
So, it is important to stay on top of these key tactics. As an example,
the hot strategies today include the use of viral videos (like Evian’s
roller-blading babies), social gaming tactics (like Farmville) and
customized Facebook company pages (like Coke). The other key
tactic being used today, is the use of hashtags within Twitter posts,
to assists users looking for similar content within Twitter (just like
users search keywords in Google). Hashtags.org is a great resource
to see what topics users are searching and to see what topics you
should be engaging with for your business, to get in front of an
immediate and targeted audience.
The second thing I would add is that there are some great tools out
there to help you forecast the timing and scale of your word-of-
mouth efforts based on: (i) how engaging your message is (e.g.,
what % of forwarded information gets acted upon); and (ii) the viral
cycle time (e.g., how much time before the recipient forwards the
message to their friends). Check out this terrific Viral Growth
Model and Tutorial by David Skok, a five time serial entrepreneur
turned VC at Matrix Partners.
Thanks again to Katy Lynch, for her terrific insights. Be, sure to
reach out to her at www.SocialKaty.com for any additional help
from here.
Lesson #53: Search Engine Marketing
Strategies
As a startup, there is no more cost effective, targetable and trackable
marketing tactic than marketing through the search engines (e.g.,
Google, Bing, Yahoo). So, driving search engine traffic should rank
very high as a priority within your overall marketing budget. In this
lesson we are going to discuss the two primary search marketing
tactics: (i) search engine optimization (SEO) for organic search; and
(ii) search engine marketing (SEM) on a pay-per-click (PPC) basis.
But, before we jump into that, you first need to do a little bit of
research as to what specific keywords are most important for
driving traffic for your business. Some businesses are very simple to
market for, with only a handful of keywords they need to optimize
for. And, some businesses are very complicated to market for, with
millions of keywords they need to optimize for based on the breadth
of their product offering (e.g., think about every SKU available for
sale at Amazon or eBay). And, to make matters worse, you need to
think through all the numerous variations and typical misspellings
of the keywords, and include those in your efforts, as well (e.g.,
“startup consultant” different than “startup consulting”, “Israel
travel agent” different than “Isreal travel agent”).
And, worth mentioning, although there are many services which can
help you grow your backlinks, and there are many “black hat”
tactics your developers can consider when coding your pages (e.g.,
content stuffing with hidden white text), you should avoid these
efforts. As the last thing you want is to end up blacklisted by
Google and de-indexed from the results by trying to game the
system. Google is very smart to know when companies are trying to
game them (e.g., can see when backlinks are adding too quickly), so
don’t even go down that road. Always use a very reputable SEO
expert.
In terms of PPC traffic from SEM, there are many things you need
to optimize for besides the list of keywords. This includes: (i) your
cost per click objectives for driving ROI; (ii) where the ads will
display (e.g., in search only, or in related content pages too); (iii)
what variations of the keywords (e.g., exact match or broad match);
(iv) the copy used in the ads (e.g., title/descriptions/offers); (v) the
landing pages used for the inbound traffic (e.g., to targeted/unique
pages matching the keywords); (vi) any geographic targeting (e.g.,
users in specific cities or countries); (vii) any day-parting (e.g.,
display ads on specific days, or during specific time ranges) and
(viii) your budget (e.g., unlimited or capped each day). So, as you
can see, there are a lot of moving pieces to PPC that you need to
optimize for to ensure a healthy and profitable campaign. Here too,
there are many reputable services and technologies you can use to
assist you with your campaign design, management and
optimization.
The most important thing for PPC marketing is to make sure you
have a clear understanding of the relationship between paid clicks
and the resulting leads/sales, to ensure you are driving a good ROI
from your efforts. So, don’t spend full force out of the gate. Do a
bunch of testing to start, at various ranking positions, various CPCs,
with various creatives, with various landing pages until you get the
right mix for your business. Therefore, it is critical you have a way
to track all inbound leads/sales activity from this campaign (e.g.,
inbound tracking links on e-commerce bookings or email leads or
call center surveys), so you know exactly how much revenue is
coming from your PPC spend, to ensure you are covering your
costs.
It has gotten to the point that website users are expecting to see a
corporate branding video front and center on the home page of any
company’s website. Gone are the days of the static, text-intensive
“About Us” pages, and welcome the era of dynamic “story-telling”
via videos. Videos create emotion, personality and excitement much
better than static text, and helps you to better communicate your
corporate brand message. And, a professionallyproduced corporate
video can be produced for as little as $2,500, with many production
shops fighting for your business (e.g., Switch Video, Vismo Media,
How It Works Media, Kicker, PixelFish, Say It Visually). There is
even a crowdsource of video animators and producers called
Wooshii, where you name your video desires and budget, and
interested contractors submit their ideas to you (with you only
paying for your favorite contractor, if you decide to move forward
with them).
And, videos should not be produced only for your overall corporate
brand message, you should figure out how to leverage it around all
your products and services. Nothing can teach a user how to use a
product, or better explain the benefits of a service, than video. And,
the better you educate your consumers on the value of your offering,
the higher odds they will convert into sales. As an example, when I
was at iExplore, we added this South Africa Tour Video, to our
South Africa tour description pages, and we saw a 4x increase in
leads and sales for that tour. This four-minute video did a lot better
job of “dream creation”, than one page of static text and one still
photo could do. Not only did it tell a “better story”, it helped to
better position the business as a trusted, high-end tour operator in a
competitive space, which means a lot to consumers ready to plunk
down $5,000 per person on a trip half way around the world in a
foreign destination.
As you will see, what do these viral video examples all have in
common: really funny humor or interesting content that people want
to share with their friends. So, if your product lends itself to
something funny or interesting, maybe you will hit the social media
jackpot with the next big viral video to spread over the web. To stay
on top of the best viral videos overtime, be sure you bookmark this
Top 10 Viral Video Chart, updated weekly by Visible Measures and
Ad Age with the most watched viral videos of the week.
If a picture is worth a thousand words, then a video is worth a
million words, in our attention-deprived culture where nobody likes
to read anything. So, the earlier you embrace video, the sooner your
marketing efforts will flourish.
As you can see from these few examples, mobile technologies and
location-based services are really improving the user experience in a
wide array of uses and industries. I challenge you to take a critical
look at your own businesses, to see how mobile apps or location-
based services can dramatically improve efficiencies for your
business, and more importantly, for your customers’ businesses.
Please re-read lesson #36 on Picking the Best Technology For Your
Startup, as it discusses various ways to build-out mobile apps.
Lesson #69: The Marketing Power of Free
Publicity
Before you put a penny into traditional marketing activities, you
need to figure out how to get the free buzz started in the media via a
formal public relations (PR) effort. And, I am not talking about
engaging an expensive PR firm here, as that does not make sense
for the tight cash position of most startups. But, what I am talking
about, is identifying all the places where potential customers are
reading, watching, listening or engaging about products and services
for your industry, and reaching out to the various
editors/producers/bloggers of such magazines, websites or radio/TV
programs.
Keep in mind, when you approach these key influencers, you need
to do so with “kid’s gloves”. They are often bombarded by a lot of
other startups trying to get free publicity for their business. So, you
need to figure out a way to approach them in a win-win kind of
way, that clearly distinguishes your product or service from the
masses of others. But, the good news is, they are already in the
“news” business, and are constantly on the hunt for the next big
thing in their industry. So, they should be open to hearing from you.
But, do so in a way that helps them look smart, not is a way that
tries to simply promote your company.
For example, with the trade media, you don’t open with “I want to
introduce you to my new startup”. You open with “this key
trend/pain point is happening in the industry, and I think we have
the right fix which may be interesting to your readers”. The
difference is, you are helping to make them smart on a particular
industry topic, which will be the feature of the article. But, you will
get mentioned and quoted in the article as an expert in the space,
which accomplishes your goal of getting the free exposure you
desired. Sending the media free samples of your product or service,
also goes a long way to getting their attention. And, for smaller
publications, actually helping them write the articles as a guest or
ghost writer, can assist them with the heavy legwork and speed up
the process.
Look and Feel. Here, we are talking about the graphics, colors and
mood your site creates. Such look and feel should be consistent with
your brand. So, the color scheme should match your logo and other
marketing materials. And, use graphics that are most consistent with
your brand image and desired demographics (e.g., photos of teens, if
you are targeting teens). In addition, I am always of a fan of keep a
site clean and uncluttered, doing more with less. And, keep in mind,
B2C sites are designed differently than B2B sites. And, even within
B2C, best practices for e-commerce sites are different than content
sites or social networking sites. So, plan accordingly for your
industry.
Usability. If a user can’t easily and quickly find what they are
looking for from a website, they typically get frustrated and move
on to the next site. To me, this element is the most important
element in any website design. As an example, Craig’s List is not a
pretty website by any means, but at least it is easy to use, which
satisfies the needs of millions of users. So, make sure your users can
find what they are looking for easily and quickly in your website
design, within one click from the home page, where possible.
Beyond the content areas of your site, you need to incorporate other
key elements into your major or sub navigation tabs, including
“Contact Us” and “About Us” as two most expected tabs from any
website. I am also a fan of using a wayfinder bar, so the client
knows where they are within the navigation of a site, from any page
therein (e.g., Home > Trip Finder > Asia Trips > China Trips). And,
in all cases make sure your site includes a Site Map page, for users
that need help navigating the site (and for the additional SEO
benefits site maps provide).
Interior Page Layout. As for interior page layout, there a lot of ways
to design a page. You could have one column, two columns or three
columns, depending on your needs. The number of columns is
typically driven by business needs (e.g., showing related links to the
page you are on) and advertising needs (e.g., making room for
advertisements to be published on your site). As an example, on
iExplore’s “Guide” page for Egypt, we would have a left column
including a table of contents for the Guide (e.g., When to Go, What
to See, Geography, Climate, Culture, Photos, Videos), and our right
column would publish advertising. Figure out the needs of your
business, and plan your interior page design accordingly.
Your logo. Your logo is the first visual a consumer gets about your
company. What does your logo visually represent about your
business. When we built the iExplore logo, we wanted a globe as
the “o”, as we wanted consumers to know iExplore could help them
explore the world. When we built the Red Rocket logo, I wanted
startups to think we could help their business take off, like a rocket
ship. Amazon added the smile to their logo, because they wanted
you to feel happy about your customer experience with them. So,
make sure your logo “tells the right story” for your brand message.
Your marketing tactics. The demographics you market to, and the
vehicles you market with, will directly impact your brand position.
You don’t see Gucci or Armani promoting their brand in Walmart
or Sears. You see them seeking distribution in Saks Fifth Avenue
and Neiman Marcus, luxurious department stores firmly focused on
serving affluent consumers. You don’t see the Four Seasons or Ritz
Carlton hotel chains cutting their prices, or offering deep discounts
at Travel Zoo. You see them maintain their prices, at 2x the level of
a Hilton or Marriott, because they want you to have the perception
they are the best, and worth the extra price. So, give careful
consideration to whom and how you market your business, how you
set your prices and where you distribute your products, as these will
all impact your brand.
Design email collection forms. The more data you ask for in your
sign-up form, the less people will actually take the time to fill in the
form. So, my suggestion is to keep your form very simple to start, to
get them to hand over their email address. And, then you can
subsequently collect additional information over time, from follow
up emails. So, don’t initially ask for a ton of data fields (e.g., name,
title, company, address, phone, age, gender, education level, income
level, interests). At a minimum, you can simple ask for their email
address only or other basic information you will need to fine tune
your marketing efforts (e.g., name, age, gender).
Link to your privacy policy. Put a link to your privacy policy right
next to your sign up request. And, add a note that “we will not spam
you”. This will help the user feel more comfortable handing over
their email address, if they know you take their privacy seriously.
Determine opt-in vs. opt-out strategy. Opt-in means the user needs
to click a check box to sign up. Opt-out means the users needs to
unclick a check box to not sign up. You will get a lot more names
with opt-out, but you will get a lot higher quality from opt-in. So,
decide what is best for your business, given the nature of your
product. And, keep in mind, the cleanest list will come from a
double-opt-in strategy, that the user not only checks the sign up box,
but needs to click a confirmation link on a test email that goes to the
user. I am always a fan of double-opt-in for getting the best list and
ensuring email addresses actually work.
Grow your list internally. From your own website, you want your
sign up form accessible everywhere it is logical to do so. That could
include a main navigation button or email entry box in the header of
your website (e.g., “Sign Up for Newsletter”), that is seen on every
page of your website. And, this can include adding the opt-in check
boxes around all other contact entry forms (e.g., when user is
buying a product, also ask them to join your list).
Grow your list externally. You can grow your list via banner ads
that run on third party websites. Or, via co-registration campaigns
on third party websites (e.g., user can sign up for your list too, while
signing up for someone else’s email list from that site). Or, you can
buy/rent email lists for your use. Banner ads could get expensive for
this purpose, combining cost of the media placement with the cost
of the incentive to sign up the user, so I would be careful here. I
really like co-registration campaigns, if done on sites with very
similar demographics (e.g., iExplore did co-registration with Conde
Nast Traveler Magazine’s website). But, make sure you are not
paying too much for the co-registration (e.g., a two way free
campaign is best, allowing partner to sign up names from your site
too). I would avoid buying/renting lists as the quality is usually
garbage and it is not worth the price paid.
Target your list. While growing your list, you also want to be
targeting your list. The more you can target your users’
demographics and interests, and deliver them customized and
relevant content, the better your email efforts will perform.
Targeting can be done on demographics, like gender, age or
education. Or, based on psychographics, figuring out what interests
the user has. Or, based on asking their current demand (e.g., what
are users currently looking to buy). As an example, when iExplore
promoted an Alaska trip to people that previously indicated they
wanted to travel to Alaska, our open rates and conversion rates were
4x better, than sending that same Alaska trip to the entire list.
Design your email content. The content of your emails need to be:
(i) consistent with what you promised the user at the time they
signed up; (ii) customized to each targeted user, where desired and
possible; and (iii) provide really compelling offers and unique
content. The better the offers, the more your users will forward the
emails to their friends, further helping your acquisition efforts. I
also like to include: (a) main navigation links back to the website, in
case the email reminds them to buy something else not offered in
the email; (b) simple unsubscribe buttons, so you don’t piss off
users that don’t want your emails anymore; and (c) a link to a
webpage of the newsletter, in case they are having trouble reading
the email format itself.
Design your subject line. Short, sweet and impactful is the best
strategy for subject lines. The subject line can make or break
whether a user opens the underlying email. Something generic like
“monthly newsletter” is less exciting than highlighting a juicy offer
therein, like “50% Off All Orders This Month”. And, make sure
your company name is clearly mentioned, either in the subject line,
or the “From” field of the emailing, so the user knows the emailing
is coming from you.
Be sensitive to spam filters. Most email software has built-in “spam
testing”, which you should always use prior to sending any
emailing. Certain keywords in the content of your email or subject
line, may trigger spam alerts to the major ISPs, directing your email
to the spam folders of your users, instead of their inbox. You don’t
want any of these words (like “special”, “deal”, “free”) to hurt your
efforts, so filter them out ahead of time. And, the additional
advantage of using an established email software program like Mail
Chimp or Cheetahmail, is they usually have “white list”
relationships with the ISPs, and can quickly get you off any “black
lists” for spamming. Also, at the time of registration, let your users
know to add your email address to their personal “white lists”, so
your emails don’t end up in their spam folder by mistake.
Track your results. You always want to track your new subscription
rate, your unsubscribe rate, your open rate, click rate and sell
through rate from any emailing. Constantly test what vehicles are
doing the best to grow your list, what emails upset users to the point
of unsubscribing, and how your emails are performing versus
industry averages. As a rough guide, a generic mailing to your
entire list should see a 15%-20% open rate (on number sent) and a
15%-20% click rate therefrom (2%-4% click rate on number sent).
The formula for calculating LTV is: (i) your average transaction
size; (ii) times your average gross margin; (iii) times your average
number of transactions per year; (iv) times the number of years a
customer buys product from you; (v) times your retention rate of
customers from one year to the next; (vi) less any marketing costs
required to retain your customer over time; (vii) discounted back to
present day dollars. For number of years, I wouldn’t model anything
greater than five years. For retention rate, I wouldn’t model
anything greater than 80% of the preceding year’s customer base.
And, for your discount rate, that should be your weighted average
cost of capital (somewhere around 10%--blending 5% cost on your
debt and 15% required return on your equity, in one example).
As you can imagine, these inputs can wildly vary from one business
to the next. So, let’s run through a couple examples. In the first
example, we have restaurant business, whose average transaction
size is $50 and customers come to the restaurant about 4x per year.
That suggests $200 in revenues in year one, and then attrition down
(at 80% a year) to $160 in year two, $128 in year three, $102 in year
four and $82 in year five. So, total five-year revenues per customer
of $672, on average, and total gross profit of $224, assuming this
restaurant averages a 33% gross margin.
So, net, at the end of five years, the customer drove $672K in
revenues (or $224 in gross profit), less $67K in original COA
marketing, less $97 for four years of retention marketing for a total
profit of $60, prior to discounting these cash flow back to their net
present value. The net present value of these cash flows using a
10% discount rate is $44, the LTV in this example.
So, incorporate LTV into your thinking for all marketing activities
and build your LTV model according to the specifics of your
business.
First of all, display ads are much less cost effective than other
online marketing vehicles, like search engine marketing, email
marketing or affiliate marketing. So, I suggest not launching a
display ad campaign until you have tapped into these other more
cost effective vehicles first. That said, display ads are designed
more for use as a “branding” tactic, than a “marketing” tactic.
Which means they are used less for immediate transactions and
ROI, and more for driving long-term awareness and recognition for
your brand. And, most startups do not have the luxury of spending
branding dollars, given the longer-term payback. So, plan
accordingly, based on your available cash resources and desired
timeline for customer engagement.
The creative technologies you can deploy within these ads can be as
simple as a static image, to moving parts (with technologies like
Eyeblaster), to expandable size when rolled over with the user’s
mouse (with technologies like Pointroll), to data-entry forms for
sign-ups, to moving video. There are also pullback technologies you
can deploy, that drops a cookie on the user’s PC when they first
visit your site, and then pushes them ads on third-party sites after
they leave your site, to try and get them back. As you can imagine,
the more complex the creative is to build, the more expensive it is to
run. As an example, producing a video is much more labor intensive
than creating a static image ad. And, using technologies like
Eyeblaster or Pointroll, comes at the additional cost of $3-$5 cost
per thousand impressions (CPM) to serve ads using their
technologies.
The great thing about online display ads is you have many ways to
target the placements of your ads. You can either run ads run-of-site
(ROS), on any page of a publisher’s website. Or, preferably, you
can target your ads based on: (i) demographics of the user; (ii)
subject matter of the content (or behavior of the user); or (iii) time
of day/week, to name a few. But, although the performance of deep
targeting is materially better than ROS ads, publishers typically
charge a premium for each level of targeting you desire. For
example, a ROS ad for “general travel” may cost you $2-3CPM and
a deep targeted ad for “rich adventure travelers looking at Kenya
content” could cost you $10-$20CPM, depending on how many
levels of targeting you desire (e.g., rich, adventure, Kenya in this
example).
Typical CPM rates for display ads come in a very wide range. They
can be $0.50CPM for a static graphic ad on a remnant ROS basis, to
$10CPM for a committed/targeted basis, to $35CPM for a video ad,
to $50CPM for a targeted email inclusion. Of course, rates are
typically tied to expected click performance of these placements,
where clicks can be 0.05% for that cheap remnant ROS ad, all they
way up to 5.0% for a targeted email inclusion. And, don’t forget,
CPM’s and clicks also rise for using various technologies or
targeting your placements, as we discussed above. As an example, a
static ad may get a 0.2% click rate and a moving/expandable ad may
get a 0.6% click rate. Or, a ROS ad may get a 0.2% click rate, and a
deep-targeted ad could get a 0.6% click rate. So, make sure you ask
about expected clicks from each placement, to justify any higher
CPM’s. And, where you can, ask for CPC (click), CPL (lead) or
CPA (acquisition) advertising opportunities, which is always better
than CPM (impression) based placements, since the user has made a
known action on your site.
And, finally, the best thing about online display ads is the ease of
tracking the results therefrom. You should be using unique tracking
codes for each specific placement you buy, to track the
effectiveness of which sites/placements are performing better or
worse than others (from a small test campaign). And, then optimize
the bulk of your remaining budget/campaign into the best
performance vehicles from the initial test. And, where you can,
tracking should be implemented at the click, lead and transaction
level, to determine which clicks/vehicles do a better job of leading
to customer engagement and conversion.
Lesson #95: The Basics of Telemarketing
Depending on the nature of your business, telemarketing can be a
useful tool to cost-effectively drive targeted leads and sales for your
business. There are two types of telemarketing strategies, outbound
and inbound, that we will cover in this lesson.
OUTBOUND TELEMARKETING
In terms of the pitch, the more relevant it is to the listener, and the
more trusted you come across to the listener, the better it will be for
your efforts. So, for example, mentioning mutual colleagues or
references can go a long way to warming up the client to listen more
closely. Intros like “I was referred to your by John Doe, one of your
CFO colleagues” or “I am doing work next door for Mrs. Smith”
starts to build trust of you already doing business for people they
know and trust. The other key part of the pitch is getting it out as
quickly and sweetly as you can, in one sentence, not one paragraph.
Just as if you were pitching a VC, the listener has a very short
attention span and is trying to get you off the phone as quickly as
possible. So, an opening pitch like “we are an award-winning
insurance agency that can save you 80% on your healthcare costs
using your current providers” will get their attention.
As for the process, where you can, avoid wasting the time of your
best salespeople on cold calling. Use an administrative sales
assistant to carry the heavy workload of “dialing for dollars” in
mass, as an “appointment setter” for your key salesperson to swoop
in can close the hot lead. But, in many startups, for budgetary
constraints, you may have no other choice than having your
salesperson do their own cold calling. There are also many
professional appointment setting services you can use here, but I
find their costs are typically 2x-3x the cost of you hiring your own
admin and doing the calls yourself.
INBOUND TELEMARKETING
As for the process, most inbound call centers are organized around
key product specialties. So, for example, when you call Comcast,
dial one for cable TV, dial two for internet and dial three for phone,
is sending you to different product experts on the back end, most
qualified to answer those questions. Continuing with iExplore, we
organized our inbound sales team based on geographies of the world
(e.g., Africa sales to Marlyn, Europe sales to Rosemary). So, figure
out how to most-efficiently organize your inbound sales efforts and
make sure the team is highly trained in educating, closing and
upselling clients.
The cost of the marketing piece has six components: (a) the cost of
the list; (b) the cost of design; (c) the cost of printing; (d) the cost of
shipping; (e) the size of the mailing; and (f) the cost of the offer, if
any. If you are mailing your in-house mailing list, there is no cost of
mailing to your own names. But, if you are renting a mailing list
from the major services like Experian, or dropping to a targeted
media partner’s list like Forbes Magazine, there are typically fees of
$25-$50 per 1,000 names pulled to access such list (which can
certainly add up the more names you pull). The cost of design will
be cheaper by using your on-staff creative designer than using an
agency, which can cost 15% more for the hourly time invested in
the piece. Design costs can certainly add up depending on whether
you are dropping a one-side post card or a 100-page catalog.
Printing costs can wildly vary based on where you have the piece
printed and how big the piece is. One of the cheapest places for
printing is South Korea, even after including the overseas shipping
costs. So, depending on the size of your run, consider both domestic
and overseas options, via the assistance of printing management
companies. And, the per piece printing costs can vary from $0.10
per piece for simple postcards to $2.00 per piece for fancy catalogs
(understanding per unit prices will be lower for higher volume runs
than lower volume runs). A typical test run would not be less than
5,000-10,000 pieces, since the conversion rate on direct mail is only
like 0.2%, on average. Dropping any fewer pieces is unlikely to
deliver any conversions. And, on the high end, mailings can get into
the millions depending on your budget and the size of your target
market (e.g., marketing toothbrushes that appeal to 100% of market;
or Kenya safaris that appeal to 10% of market).
And, don’t forget, you are going to have to pay the U.S. Postal
Service to get these pieces to the homes of your target recipients.
Postage rates can vary significantly (from $0.15 to $2.00) based on
the size of the piece, and whether or not they are pre-sorted. So,
don’t forget to include the postage costs in your budgeting process,
and use a mailing service to assist you here with the pre-sorting
process to help lower your postage costs.
The quality of the offer is also important. And, what you think may
be exciting to consumers, may not be. So, do a few small tests with
variable offers to see which one performs best, before dropping to a
much broader list. But, in all cases, I am a huge fan of: (a) some
special offer; and (b) a deadline to redeem such offer, to create a
sense of urgency. So, at iExplore, we would not send a generic
“learn more about iExplore” mailing. We would send a specific and
meaningful offer like, “save $1,000 on any new booking made
within 30 days” (which can materially increase the cost of the
overall direct mailing including the other costs above, so make sure
you have enough margin to work with here to cover all costs,
including the offer).
Direct mail is a very big topic that deserves more space than
allocated in this short lesson. But, frankly, as a startup, your
marketing dollars may be more efficiently spent in other areas (e.g.,
search engine marketing, emails, social media). So, make sure you
have fully exhausted your higher ROI tactics before getting into the
expensive world of direct mail.
3 Human Resources
For example, don’t put a $1BN budget Proctor & Gamble CMO, in
charge of your $1MM start-up budget. The P&G guy most likely
only knows how to build brands with big teams and big budgets, not
how to organically and virally grow your business on the cheap in
new kinds of ways (e.g., social media, mobile, SEO), rolling up his
sleeves and doing it himself on a shoestring. So, past start-up
experience is a definite plus.
As we all know, startups are a 24/7 type of job. So, you are going to
be spending a lot of time with your co-workers. It is critical there is
a good personality fit between the team, as in those late night hours,
the last thing you need is someone getting on your nerves. Or,
having one member of your inner circle the pariah within the
company that nobody wants to work with. You don’t have time for
these types of issues while you are trying to win the start-up race.
And, when we talk about giving equity, there are many structural
considerations. Unless they are a co-founder at the time the
company is formed, giving an employee stock outright has two
problems: (i) the recipient and the company will both have
immediate tax implications, as stock grant would be treated like
immediate compensation; and (ii) if that employee quits tomorrow,
you don’t want them to walk away with the equity. So, to address
these issues, you would set up a stock option plan, or something
similar, where the employee: (i) has the right to purchase equity at
today’s fair market value; and (ii) the options have a vesting
schedule with the employee’s purchase rights being earned over
time (e.g., over four years, 25% of the grant is earned in each year).
That keeps the employee more committed for the long term, which
is what you want, and only rewards them for actual time invested
with the business. Also, be sure that the stock option plan provides
the company with a mechanism to easily repurchase any exercised
shares from the employee at any time, so you can easily recapture
ownership down the road (if things go awry with the employee, or if
there is an impending change of control that requires recapturing
100% of the outstanding shares).
If you don’t want to spread actual equity or options, you can easily
accomplish the same goal with a “phantom equity” plan, that
basically mimics equity ownership via a profit share plan or
otherwise. For example, employee could own 5% of all net income
created each year, instead of 5% of equity. Or, employee could own
5% of the company’s valuation at a mutually acceptable revenue,
EBITDA or net income multiple. These plans typically are paid in
cash, or accrue as interest bearing debt until paid out, so make sure
you anticipate having the cash resources to relieve these claims
before going down this road.
Now, you might be saying, you just gave away 10-20% for key
employees and 5%-20% for the key strategic partner, that totals
15%-40% of the company. First of all, you didn’t “give” it away,
the employees and the partner have to earn their upside before they
exercise their options or warrants (e.g., grow the company’s
business and valuation, bound by vesting rights that accrue over
time). But, more importantly, I would rather own 60-85% of a
wildly successful business, than 100% of a business where the staff
and partners are not invested in our mutual success.
It is hard to do this topic justice with one simple post, given all the
variations to a theme for motivating your team and partners, but
hopefully it gave you a good sense to the importance of this topic
and a few mechanics you can use to implement such.
You cannot have culture without people, and that is where it all
starts, right from your initial hiring decisions. To me, this comes
down to an individual’s smarts, internal startup DNA and
personality fit. It is critical you find the smartest people you can
find, to help you build your business. I would rather have a smart
person that is a quick study and no industry experience, than a
marginal industry veteran. If you don’t have the fire power in the
brain to think creatively out of the box, which is always required
with a startup, then your business will never succeed. And, don’t be
afraid to hire people that are smarter than yourself. Sometimes
managers are worried about being made to look stupid by their
subordinates. But, I say the smarter the better, to help raise
everyone’s skills around the table.
But, it is more than just having smart people around you. They must
also have the right startup DNA. Someone that is passionate about
the product that is getting built and is excited to come into work
each day, and put in the long hours required. Someone that is going
to motivate the rest of the team to do the same. Someone that is an
extrovert A-type personality that is going to cheerlead when
necessary and lead by example. Someone that has a great
personality fit with their peers, managers and subordinates.
Someone that is not easily rejected, and won’t bring a bad mood to
the office. I always say, “We are all paddling together in a
whitewater raft navigating the rushing rapids, and need all paddlers
rowing in unison and as fast as humanly possible to survive.”
As for management styles, the less hierarchical the better. Sure there
needs to be a clear chain of command, but it is critical an
employee’s voice is always heard and that they feel their smart
ideas are being listened to. There is no faster way to lose an
employee than to constantly shoot down their ideas, or by making
them feel stupid. And, when doing employee reviews, always do
360-degree reviews: manager reviews employee, employee reviews
manager, peers review eachother and employee reviews themself.
This way everybody participates in the process and both manager
and staff problems can get addressed.
When Google was getting started, they even went as far as letting
staff members take 20% of their time (one day a week) to work on
any personal pet projects they wanted, many of which lead to
amazing innovations and the next growth vehicles for the company.
And, don’t get mad if staff wants to blow of steam with a midday
video game or trip to the gym. As long as they are doing the work,
hitting their goals and putting in the effort, there is no need to micro
manage their hourly schedules.
The first two points really go hand in hand. In order to create the
clear vision, you need to have a good sense to what is going on in
the industry and with competition. That is really the first step to
building a winning business plan. It is not enough to say, “we are
building a great travel website”, as there are tons of travel websites
out there. You must shape the vision in a way it is more unique and
competitive than current solutions in the market. My previous
startup, iExplore, positioned itself as a niche killer for adventure
travel (compared to the general online travel agencies like Expedia).
And, within the adventure travel sector, iExplore marketed
“privately-guided, made to order” tours (compared to the traditional
packaged group tours with set itineraries) at a price point 25% less
than similar tours being offered (leveraging the cost efficiencies of
the internet, compared to brick and mortar agents). This vision for
the business created a unique product in the market place, which
consumers ultimately flocked to with over 1MM unique visitors per
month coming to the website.
But, the CEO’s job is not done setting the initial vision. He or she
must stay on top of those competitive trends to navigate the ship
over time. For example, after 9/11/01, iExplore needed to evolve
from a travel agent of other tour operators’ trips, into an iExplore
branded tour operator of its own in an effort to get more margin to
the bottom line during a difficult economic climate. And, at the
same time, iExplore opened up a whole new revenue stream from
online advertising, to get the company to profitability. It is the
CEO’s job to constantly watch these kinds of economic, industry or
competitive movements over time, and to respond accordingly to
keep the ship afloat.
Another job of the CEO is to make sure all employees are clear on
the vision, and that all staff are sailing in the same direction. In the
iExplore example for adventure travel, you can’t have your tech guy
building a cruise seller, your operating guy building a hotel seller
and your finance guy building an airfare seller. Everyone is building
an adventure travel seller, and the CEO’s job is to make sure all
staff have contributed in building that vision, so all players are on
the same page as to what they are building. Therefore, the CEO is
not only the communicator of the vision, the CEO is the consensus
builder for that vision. You will never be successful if your team
does not buy into the vision, or if they feel their good ideas for
improving the vision are not being listened to. Then once everyone
is firmly on board, keep them clearly focused on the goal.
Once the vision is set and being maintained over time, now comes
execution. And, one of the key execution requirements for any
startup CEO is to be its Chief Evangelist. This includes
cheerleading the staff, from top to bottom, and getting prospective
business clients and investors excited about getting involved with
the company. Everyone has been around that infectious personality
that lights up the room, and you can’t help but be excited by that
person. That is who you need to be. But, and this is a big but,
everyone has also been around that person who you feel is trying to
sell you the Brooklyn Bridge. So, it is important that your sales and
motivational skills are tempered with equally important business
judgment and intellect to come across as credible and backable to
all parties involved.
There is no single right answer for “who makes for the best startup
CEO?”, as everyone is different in terms of skills, style and
personality, and every business is different in terms of economic,
industry and competitive dynamics. But, the above is a good
summary of the types of people that have the best odds for success
in becoming a successful startup CEO.
This is particularly true when dealing with start-ups, where you are
in a race to win market share and client adoption as quickly as
possible. I always tell my team, I would rather you get it right 90%
of the time, and move at light speed on your own, than to get it right
100% of the time, and rely on me for input, which slows down my
own work efforts. Or, said another way, if you can deliver an A-
result in one week of effort, that is much better than an A+ result in
two weeks of effort, given the diminishing margin of return on that
extra 50% of work time.
That said, there are a few times when a hand-on style is required.
The first time while you are still learning the business. It is critical
you have a deep understanding of all aspects of your business, to
ensure that all input you are getting from your team makes sense
and is justified by your own experiences. For example, when I was a
first-time CEO, I had no experience in running different areas of a
business, like marketing, technology and operations. So, I hired
team members with deep experience in these areas, and relied on
them to make key business decisions in those areas. The problem
was, their experience only revolved around big companies, not
startups that required different skills. We made a lot of mistakes in
those early months, and we could have saved lots of money, had I
been more hands-on right from the start, until I had a firm grasp of
the key drivers of the business. You never want to be in a position
where you are getting advice from your team, and don’t know
whether or not what they are saying is the right advice, or at least
credible based on your own personal experiences with the business
or otherwise.
As for ease of recruitment, let’s face it, certain positions are easier
to fill than others. If you need a simple web designer, there is a large
and fertile pool of prospective employees in any major city. So, I
would try to fill that position locally for any permanent staff
positions, for better team building and communications with the rest
of the tech staff. But, if your office is located in Kalamazoo,
Michigan and there are very few hard core tech developers with
C++ or C# experience, you may have no choice by to hire a virtual
tech developer in Chicago or elsewhere, including India where labor
rates are a fraction of what they are in the U.S.
I try to prioritize all tasks (for myself and all team members) in a
way that will maximize revenues and increase the odds of hitting
our business goals. So, if ten projects are on the list, you have to
knock off #1 before you start wasting any time on #10, since your
prioritization efforts dictated a higher ROI from those efforts. And,
guess what, if you were right in your assumptions, revenues and
profits will be soon to follow, and then you will no longer feel you
have that “cash burn-out gun” constantly pointed at your head
(which is never healthy to any startup executive’s peace of mind).
To me, your personal life is the ying to your yang (work life). You
simply cannot have one without the other. How can you possible
focus on your work, if in the back of your head you know you are
missing your kid’s school play. Or, your marriage is suffering
because your spouse feels they never see you. Or, you just need a
change of scenery from a quick vacation to clear the head. You have
to make time for these kinds of things to recharge your batteries and
make your work time that much more efficient (the key word to all
of this). And, equally important, you have to encourage and permit
your staff do the same, offering flexible work hours or otherwise (in
this case, preaching what you practice).
So, long story short, keep your long-term overhead (e.g., employee
base) as low as possible, and structure your human resources in as
variable a way as you can. While at the same time, maximize your
selection of options and keep your costs low with crowdsources,
when complex work is not involved. Start researching crowdsources
on the web, there is most likely one for most any of your needs.
There are lots of different job posting sites out there, some are huge
(e.g., Monster, Career Builder, Craig’s List) and others are small
(e.g., job boards for trade magazine sites). Some offer national
candidates, and others local candidates. And, some are targeted to
senior executives (e.g., The Ladders, Netshare, Execunet) and
others for specific entry-level jobs. So, before randomly placing a
job posting, figure out which audience is most relevant for your
position.
And, let’s not forget the power of working your network and word
of mouth marketing via LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook or otherwise.
It is a lot better to find a “colleague of a colleague”, with firsthand
references in place, than to start blind with a random candidate,
where you can. Frankly, sites like LinkedIn are my favorite
recruiting sites, simply because I can learn a lot about the candidate,
above and beyond their simple resume data. How many connections
do they have? Who are those connections, and can they help me?
Do I have any overlapping connections that I can call as a
reference? Also, it provides really good insights to how socially
engaged the candidate is and the types of connections they can bring
to your business.
Once you have identified where you want to be recruiting, now you
need to figure out what your job posting should say to: (i) stand out
from the thousands of other job postings a candidate may be looking
at; and (ii) limit the clutter of resumes coming into your office, to
simplify the screening process. I would not be vague in your copy,
and disclose as much as you can to ensure the reader knows all the
plusses and minuses, so only the most interested will apply. That
means, disclose your company name (so they can research your
business on your website) and disclose the specific salary range (so
people desiring a salary above that range do not apply). The only
time you need to be more confidential in your posting, is when you
don’t want an existing staff member to know you are recruiting a
replacement for their position, or if you are worried about a
competitor learning you are hiring for certain skills. But, as a rule,
more disclosure is better than less for all involved.
The big picture point is: waste as little time as possible in the
minutia of recruitment, as that is time better spent on your business.
Put processes in place that allow for very efficient screening of
candidates (e.g., detailed posting, Q&A forms, video responses), so
only the most appropriate candidates apply, and they can easily be
screened from there. Then, once you find your favorite three
candidates, now is where you dig in and spend quality time learning
more about the candidate.
Finding the right team members for your startup are critical for its
success, so you have to invest the time here to get it right. But,
make sure that time is most efficiently spent (e.g., interviewing the
best candidates, and not on preliminary screening of all that apply).
You never want to rush a hiring decision or take a marginal
candidate just to fill a position, as long term, it will never work out
for either party’s long-term interests. And, it is a lot more expensive
and time consuming to remove a poor performer down the road,
than to get it right the first time.
For any candidate, I am trying to ensure: (i) they have the right
skills for the job: (ii) they have a proven track record of career or
educational success for the position; (iii) I can afford them; (iv) they
have the right personality fit with the company; (v) they have
references that will validate their claims; and (vi) they fit the
company on other tangential topics. I will tackle each of these
points below.
Making sure a candidate has the right skills for the job sounds
intuitive enough. For example, a candidate with 20 years of
marketing experience, should know something about marketing.
But, the devil is in the details. Was that marketing person in your
industry, as marketing tactics vary wildly by industry. Was that
marketing person a B2C marketer, when you need a B2B marketer?
Was that person spending huge budgets in mass media, when you
have small budgets needing viral social media? Did the person do
the marketing themselves, or were they relying on a big team they
managed? You get the point: drill down from the 30,000-foot view
to ground level, where the boots hit the ground.
As for a proven track record in their career, you need look for these
kinds of things. Was the candidate in big companies their entire
careers, or do they have real startup experience, which is more
important for startups. Has there been nice upward promotions
overtime, with titles increasing in importance from manager to
director to Vice President to Executive Vice President? Does the
candidate have longevity from position to position? I get really
nervous about candidates with 10 jobs in 10 years being poor
performers or simply bored easily, and am looking for a minimum
of 2-3 years per company, unless there are logical reasons for quick
job moves (like the company was sold). Was the candidate cut
during a layoff, as sometimes, but not always, companies typically
cut their underperformers when they tighten their belts. Are their
quantifiable successes they can point to that illustrates they have led
and managed rapid startup growth and success in a similar
environment to your own? Ask for examples.
There is no one right way to recruit for candidates, given the wide
variety of people, talents and personalities, but hopefully this will
point you in the right direction.
Lesson #42: Is Working With Family
Members a Good Idea?
My immediate reaction to this question is no, working with family
members is not a good idea, for the many potential issues I will
detail below. But, if structured correctly, a family-related team can
work.
The biggest reason I think the answer is no, is the normal work-life
balance can get completely thrown out of alignment. Normally, you
have your work life and relationships, you go home after work, and
enter your personal life and relationships. A nice balance of ying
and yang. When you work with the same people in your family,
there is a risk that balance is not achieved. You never get a break
from each other. And, frankly, it becomes too easy to bring work
home with you, and you never get a break from it. And, vice versa,
too easy to bring personal life back to work with you. So, for a
family working relationship to work, there has to be a clear
understanding: work issues stay at work, and personal issues stay at
home.
These are just a few things to think about before starting a working
relationship with your family members. If you can, I would avoid it.
God knows, my wife would kill me if she had to work with me, as
my “work personality and expectations as CEO” are very different
than my “home personality and expectations as husband.” And, I
would never want to worry about walking on eggshells in driving a
successful startup business, which is stressful enough as it is.
Back in Lesson #13, we talked about Creating the Right Culture for
Your Startup, including having an open-style of communication
between the CEO and the employees for the good, the bad and the
ugly. During difficult times, you need to learn how to communicate
any bad news to the team in a way that will keep them informed, but
motivated and confident at the same time. The last thing you want is
your staff to become demoralized, when they need to be energized,
putting an already struggling business into a death spiral.
What this typically means for a startup CEO is: no “public displays
of rejection.” A staff seeing their leader worried, depressed or losing
confidence is the equivalent of their swallowing a poison pill. When
a staff lives and breathes with each other, they know everybody’s
specific habits, personality and style. And, any change from the
norm from their CEO, can often set off red flags with the staff.
So, when communicating with the team, use the same tone,
personality and facial expressions you always would, in both good
times and bad times. This especially means keeping up your energy,
confidence and eye contact, regardless of the problems at hand.
And, do your best to maintain your normal routine: keep all normal
meetings with staff, do all the normal birthday celebrations,
continue to keep the door open to your office, keep a normal
presence in the office, don’t come across frantic in your daily
activities, etc.
And, it was largely due to the delivery of the message. Had I walked
into that room with my head down, crying with my tail between my
legs (how I really felt), it would have been game over. Instead, it
was business as usual, with an open and honest message of the fact
we were in a difficult position, but had a clearly communicated plan
on how we would get through it. And, the fact I acknowledged their
personal fears of them potentially losing their jobs if the business
went under, by allowing them time to interview for new jobs for
Plan B, deepened their trust in me and had them wanting to work
with me that much harder.
So, keep an even keel in both smooth and choppy waters, regardless
of how much pressure or stress you may be under during the bad
times. If you can avoid letting your stress or fears pass along to your
team, the odds of you successfully getting through those bad times
just increased ten-fold.
Lesson #55: Creating a Healthy Office
Environment
Back in Lesson #13, we talked about Creating The Right Culture
For Your Startup. In that lesson we talked about different
management styles, communications styles and maintaining the
proper work-life balance for your employees, to help build morale
amongst your team. Directly related to building morale is your
office environment itself. Nothing can dampen morale faster, than
working in an uninviting or dysfunctional workplace.
We have also all been inside workplaces that are better defined as a
“morgue”. These office spaces are typically not well-lit (or lacking
windows), where employees are buried in their private offices or
behind high cubicles and you can often hear a pin drop in the office.
No employee conversations, no music, no energy at all. This kind of
office space is a recipe for disaster for a startup, as employees will
only deal with that type of environment for so long, before they will
go stir crazy. Especially “A-type” personalities that want to get
involved with exciting startups.
Little things like this can really matter to employees, especially with
lots of other startups out there for them to choose from. And,
sometimes, your office environment can be the difference between
“high flying” and “six feet under.”
Lesson #58: How to Determine Employee
Compensation
At the end of the day, a couple key themes rule your employee
compensation strategies: (1) the market is the market, so you need
to pay competitively to attract talent; (2) you get what you pay for;
and (3) you can creatively lower cash salary with equity-based
compensation, to keep your cash burn rate at a low. I will tackle
each of these points below.
There is a “market rate” for each job within your company. And, the
market rates for any one position can wildly vary based on: (i) the
stage of your business; (ii) the industry/competitive skills you are
hiring for; and (iii) the city you work in. As an example, check out
Crains Chicago’s 2010 Wage and Salary Survey to get a good sense
to average wages and salaries by job position for employees in the
Chicago area. You should try to find something similar for your
home cities, or use the Chicago numbers as a rough ball park,
understanding bigger/more competitive cities, like New York and
San Francisco, have be pay more, and smaller cities can pay less
than what is paid in Chicago (given the lower cost of living in those
smaller markets). And, don’t forget the laws of supply and demand
for specific roles. As an example, if tech coders with expertise in C+
and Ruby are in high demand and short supply in your town, they
are going to be paid more than people with more readily available
HTML coding skills.
Sometimes you will see CFO’s being recruited in the $100K salary
range, and other times you see them being recruited in the $1MM
salary range. Why the huge discrepancy? Because proven Fortune
500 companies have to report to their public shareholders and need
proven CFO veterans with public company expertise and a track
record of successfully managing multi-billion dollar P&L’s. But, a
CFO of a startup does not need that level of expertise, and most
likely can get away with a less experienced CFO, who would
probably be more of a VP level executive within a bigger company.
But, the message “you get what you pay for” never holds more true
than in your recruiting efforts. So, you never want to be “cheap” in
your recruiting efforts. If you want a battle-tested startup CFO, as
an example, you are going to have to pay more than you would for a
first time CFO with limited startup experience and no track record.
But, that past startup experience is worth its weight in gold. In the
CFO example, knowing how to “stretch pennies into manhole
covers” and attract outside capital could be the key difference
between getting your company funded or successful. So, don’t
always go with the cheapest alternative. Go, for the best alternative
you can afford.
So, depending what mix of the above decisions you make, will have
a material impact on your overall healthcare benefit expenses. But,
cost of the plan is only part of your thinking, as you should also
make sure whatever plan you offer is “juicy” enough to have real
benefits for your employees (e.g., a plan from a less known insurer
where the employee’s doctor is not in-network will be meaningless
to them).
And, individual healthcare plans are easier to buy than ever from the
big insurers websites, and the costs of these plans can often be
comparable (or cheaper) than paying for the same coverage via a
company-sponsored group plan (especially for startups). As, an
example, my family coverage at iExplore was a $20,000 annual bill
to me, and my individually-sourced plan (also from Blue Cross) was
only a $12,000 bill to me, as I was able to customize it to exclude
maternity coverage, since we were done having kids. So, it can offer
be cheaper to give an employee an extra $5,000 in salary (for them
to cover their own healthcare expenses) than for the company to
carry the costs of funding their own healthcare plan for the
company.
Company operating policies deal with topics like travel, gifting, use
of company vehicles or assets, and no solicitation rules, to name a
few.
Leave of absence policies deal with topics like family and medical
leave, continuation of benefits, military leave, education leave,
public service leave, bereavement leave, jury duty and workers’
compensation, to name a few.
Employee benefit policies deal with topics like national holidays,
vacation days, sick days, personal days, voting days and other
company benefits, to name a few.
So, your lawyer should be able to help you with a good template
handbook. But, if you want to look at an example, I am happy to
send you one for your review. Long story short, clearly document
all company policies and expected “rules of engagement” to protect
yourself, and make sure all staff members execute an agreement
acknowledging their receipt, review and understanding of such
handbook. It will save a lot of unnecessary heartache down the road,
in case any employee issues develop over time. And, as your
employee policies change, which they may from time to time, make
sure to send out a revised handbook to all employees, and get them
to sign their acknowledgement of the amendments.
Cut early. As soon as you have a sense things are not working out, it
is in the company’s best interest to make any cuts sooner than later,
to preserve your limited remaining capital. Don’t wait until you run
out of cash, and have no other options. Not only, will early cuts help
your balance sheet and income statement faster, it will make the
company more attractive to new investors, with a lower burn rate.
And, cutting early, also leaves cash to pay for severance payments,
to calm cut staff.
Cut deep and once. It is absolutely critical you make the cuts deep
enough, that you do not need to go back and make secondary cuts
soon thereafter. You only have one chance to tell your remaining
employees, “We had to make one time cuts, the rest of you are safe,
now let’s get back to building greatness.” Which is a critical
message to deliver the remaining staff to keep them motivated and
not panicked looking for another job. You lose all that trust, the
minute secondary cuts are made.
Have witnesses. At the time of cuts, make sure you have a second
person in the room with you, to serve as a witness in case you are
ever sued by the cut staff member down the road. A witness can
verify what was said to the cut staff member, and verify that the
employee was not cut for any other discriminatory reasons (e.g.,
gender, age).
If you get them to start this transition process on their own, you
typically don’t have to pay any severance. As any salary you are
paying them in the transition period, is like paying them severance,
but you have the added benefit of them still doing their day-to-day
job during this period. And, make it easy for them to schedule time
out of the office, to schedule new job interviews. And, make sure
they know you will serve as a good reference for them, in case any
recruiters call. This ends up being best for all parties, not risking
embarrassment or reputation risk by the employee that comes from
a firing, and not exposing the company to a potential lawsuit for
wrongful termination, since the employee ended up quitting instead.
As you can see, I try to avoid terminating staff for many reasons: (i)
wrongful termination lawsuit risks; (ii) having to pay severance
payments; and (iii) giving the employee the chance to file
unemployment claims, which the company ultimately has to pay for
in its insurance premiums. So, where you can, creatively plant the
transition idea with the employee, so they feel the decision was
theirs, not yours, and you can creatively avoid many of these issues
that come from terminations.
And, don’t forget, any time an employee exits the company, make
sure you talk to your lawyer, and get all the appropriate employee
termination documents signed (e.g., non-disclosure, last day of
employment verification, agreement not to bring claims).
But, worth mentioning, getting an employee to meet your goals is a
two-way street: you as the manager need to be making an effort to
make sure you are mentoring and training all employees with the
right skillsets desired for the position. So, make sure you are doing
your best efforts here, before you start this process.
So, when you are pulling together your management team, make
sure you are hiring with this type of organization in mind (or
something similar, as this is not set in stone). And, make sure the
individuals for the job have the proper skills required to succeed in a
startup environment. Please re-read Lesson #34 and Lesson #35 for
more details on how best to recruit and screen candidates for your
startup. And, worth mentioning, it is equally important this team
gets along personally and shares the same long-term vision for the
business for the company to succeed.
Below are a few examples are employee rewards that have had
success with in my past:
1. Gift certificate to the sales team leader each month, to the store of
their choice
9. Free company-paid trip a year for each of the travel agents I had
at iExplore—they liked the trip, and I liked the fact they would
better sell the destination when they came home
This list could go on and on. The point here is: employees are not
simply cogs in the wheel of the day-to-day grind. They are people
with interests, emotions, and desires and they deserve the
appropriate respect and recognition for a job well done. And, the
more you invest in your team, the higher return they will invest
back into the company.
4 Technology
The second problem was the site was not easy to maintain, requiring
complicated builds to refresh the site for even the most simple of
changes and a staff of expensive, hard-to-find developers that were
proficient in the technologies we were using. So, the key lessons: (i)
never build a tech infrastructure in excess of reasonable growth
targets (to keep your costs at an absolute minimum); and (ii) build
your technologies in a scalable way where the site can easily be
developed and maintained over time, by easy to find developers.
Most lean startups with basic website needs today are building their
web-based businesses using the Ruby on Rails coding platform,
which is entirely based on inexpensive and freely available open-
source technologies. So, if you can, avoid more expensive, licensed
platforms based on Java, C#, PHP or VisualBasic.net. Ruby has
become the preferred language of choice since: (i) you can get your
product to market faster with less code to write; (ii) it is a flexible
language easily tied together with other systems; (iii) it is easy to
scale and iterate; and (iv) Linux based hosting providers are
numerous and inexpensive. Many successful startups like Groupon,
Living Social and Hulu, were all written with Ruby. The only real
negative of Ruby is that it is still a relatively new technology, and
experienced talent are in high demand (although many new
developers are learning the language in force).
I hope this helps get your development efforts off to a good start in
a “lean startup” kind of way: investing the minimum amount as
possible to take a viable technology to market as quickly and
cheaply as possible. Thanks again to the Obtiva team, for their help
here.
5 Fund Raising
Now, let’s assume you are one of the lucky 5-10 in 200 that has a
venture backable business. How do you typically phase in
investment? You can’t simply show up at a big Silicon Valley
venture firm with your piece of paper idea and say cut me a $10MM
check. Investors are typically segmented by life-cycle stage of the
business: angel investors or friends and family typically get a
business off the ground from a piece of paper to a working
prototype; Series A venture capitalists will put in $1-$5MM after
there has been a preliminary proof of concept, based on revenues,
pipeline, site traffic or some other metric; and Series B venture
capitalists will put in $10-$50MM to hit the accelerator after the
model is finely tuned and scaling. So, when you are approaching the
investment community, make sure you have thoroughly researched
not only their industry focus, but their stage of business focus as
well.
Once the term sheets start flowing in, how do you ultimately decide
who to move forward with? At the end of the day, you need to
follow your gut. Who is going to be the best partner for my
business, bringing a Rolodex of relationships to the table? Who is
going to be the most pleasant to work with around the board table,
especially when things start to go wrong (as they always do)? Who
has the deepest pockets to invest additional monies in follow-on
rounds? Who is giving me the best valuation? Whose term sheets
are more or less onerous than others in terms of liquidation
preferences and anti-dilution ratchets? So, hopefully, what you are
hearing is, not all venture capital is the same shade of green, and it
is important you do your homework upfront, to avoid misery down
the road. And, if you are not clear you are making a good decision
on your own, ask an advisor to help you.
But, overriding all of this, if you can figure out a way to fund your
business, with no outside capital, that is the preferred model. It
preserves the founder’s 100% control of the company’s equity,
board control and the timing of a sale (or not), at terms 100%
satisfactory to the founder. Don’t get romanced by the idea of
raising venture capital, because it certainly has its strings attached,
given the reasons above. But, if you think you have the next big
idea at the scale of a Google, Facebook or Groupon, the venture
community will be your best partners, having funded several of
those similar businesses and navigated the various pitfalls along the
way.
Friends and family investors have their distinct plusses and minuses.
The plusses are these people know you the best, so they are the
closest to you in determining whether or not you are backable, as
first-hand references. The minuses are pretty major: these are your
friends and family! It is very difficult to mix personal and
professional relationships. And, as we know, only one in 10 startups
is successful. So, there are very high odds you lose all the money
invested by your closest friends and family, which will make for
VERY awkward Thanksgiving dinners from that point on. So, if
you decide to ultimately go down this road (which for many startups
are their only option), make sure your friends and family know this
investment is HIGHLY risky, and they should not invest the funds
unless they are prepared to lose 100% of their investment (e.g., like
money they would gamble in a casino).
So, for example, if you think you have the next great video gaming
technology, I would research what similar video game technologies
have recently been sold (meaning the founder just got very cash
rich), and reach out to that founder to tap into their expertise as an
advisor, board member or investor. Notice I didn’t lead with
investor. You need to establish credibility with this individual
before jumping into the investment question. And, if he doesn’t
want to invest, he may know others in the industry that would, so
ask him for references. Venture capital firms are also aware of key
angels in their market, so reach out to them for guidance. There is a
great website called Angel List that makes finding angels for your
region/industry easier than ever, so check them out as a good place
to start.
Here in Chicago, the big three angel networks are Hyde Park
Angels, Cornerstone Angels and Heartland Angels. These angel
networks very much prefer to invest in their own backyard. So, if
you live in Chicago, reach out to these three. If you live in another
city, you will need to research who the angel networks are in or near
that city. I stumbled on this great list of angel networks by city
compiled by Andy Whitman, a Partner at 2x Partners, an early-stage
venture capital firm in Chicago with expertise in the CPG space.
This list applies to all industries, not just CPG, although Andy does
indicate what CPG deals these networks have invested in.
As for the desired format, I typically find that investors are very
busy, and are more receptive to getting an introduction via email
(which you can access via their website or calling their office).
Email gives them a chance to research you and your idea, before
committing to a phone call or an in person meeting. So, make sure
you keep a clean social networking trail on Facebook and Twitter,
as they will most certainly be Googling you. And, make sure your
LinkedIn profile is complete and compelling, as it is your online
resume.
The contents of that email are the most critical. Remember the short
attention span of investors: if they can’t understand your business in
30 seconds of reading, they are moving on to the next one. So, you
need a very short and sweetly written cover letter that summarizes
your story in a few sentences (not paragraphs!). Something that gets
them jazzed up.
Notice what that paragraph did: (i) described the business and its
leading market position; (ii) detailed industry size and growth; (iii)
highlighted a brand name strategic partner; (iv) showed the business
was driving revenues, and how quickly they were scaling; (v) and
wet their beak with the opportunity to make a big 10x return. That
was a lot to accomplish in two sentences. The paragraph also closes
(as it always should) with a clear call to action, which will be very
easy for the investor to hit reply and say “Friday looks fine at 9am.”
Now that the cover letter is solid, follow the above linked Lesson #7
to prepare a 1-2 page executive summary information (with the best
of the best from the bigger business plan, include management bios
and five year forecast). That is it. Do not send them any more than
this, as they will not read it at this time. They will certainly ask for
much more information during the due diligence process, which you
will already have prepared with your full plan sitting in reserve.
And, worth mentioning again, graphics and charts, go a lot further
than text to getting your message across as quickly and effectively
as you can.
You only have one chance to make a good first impression with a
prospective investor. Don’t blow it!
The third thing a VC looks for is passion and energy. Do you have
the fire in the belly to wake up every morning and bust your ass to
execute the business plan? I think it is safe to assume most good
entrepreneurs are not lacking in this area, but you would be
surprised how many startups come in with unenthusiastic or boring
presentations that doesn’t get anybody excited, regardless of how
great the idea may be. And, if you cannot get your VC’s excited, it
is unlikely you will get potential business customers excited in
driving revenues and hitting the VC’s ROI expectations.
The fourth thing VC’s look for are your listening and
communications skills. The biggest mistake an entrepreneur can
make is to assume they are the only smart person in the room, and
nobody else knows what they are talking about. Hence digging in an
entrenched viewpoint. Let’s not forget a good VC sees around 200
business plans a year, 2,000 plans a decade. And, most likely, many
very similar to your own, in one form or another. So, they bring a
ton of market intelligence to the table, to help you avoid known
pitfalls. It is critical they think you are flexible and will listen to
input as needed. And be prepared, at some point, a VC may make a
recommendation to put in a new CEO with more skills than
yourself. So, listen with open ears, as protecting your 65% equity
value is a lot more important than protecting your job title. But,
hopefully, you will never give them that opportunity by knocking
the cover off the ball the entire way up.
The days of the dot com boom in the 1990’s are long behind us. No
longer can a 21-year-old with a high-level idea on a piece of paper
(without even a revenue model) walk into Silicon Valley and collect
a $10MM check. You are much better served with at least 5-10
years of real life work experience, and the relevant lessons
therefrom. And, frankly, a second-time CEO, is a much better
venture bet than a first-time CEO, since that entrepreneur has
already learned how to avoid many startup pitfalls and can point to a
proven track record.
As I have said before, and it’s worth reiterating, VC’s would much
rather invest in an A+ team with a B+ idea, than an A+ idea with a
B+ team. So, keep that in mind.
Lesson #32: How to Value Your Startup
Business
One of the questions I get, more often than not, is what is the
appropriate valuation of my business. Typically related to an
upcoming financing or pending takeover offer. And, the answer is
quite simple: like for anything, your business is worth what
somebody is willing to pay for it. And, the methodologies applied
by one buyer in one industry, may be different from the
methodologies applied by another buyer in another industry. In
today’s post, I will give you some key drivers on how to value your
business, in a way that will make sense to you, and will be in line
with investor expectations.
To start, let’s not forget about the obvious: the natural economic
principles of supply and demand apply to valuing your business, as
well. The more scarce a supply (e.g., your equity in a hot new
patented technology business), the higher the demand (e.g., multiple
interested investors competing for the deal, and taking up valuation
in the process). And, if you cannot create “real demand” from
multiple investors, “perceived demand” can often work the same
when dealing with one investor. So, never have an investor think
they are the only investor pursuing your business, as that will hurt
your valuation. And, before you start soliciting investment, make
sure your business will be perceived as new and unique to maximize
your valuation. A competitive commodity business or “me too”
story, will be less demanded, and hence require a lower valuation to
close your financing.
If there are no earnings yet, with your business plowing profits into
long-term growth, then revenue multiples or some other metric
would be used. Revenue multiples for established businesses are
typically in the 0.5x-1x range, but in extreme scenarios, can get as
high as 10x for high flying dot commers with explosive growth
(e.g., Groupon). But, that is, by far, the exception to the rule. And, if
there are no revenues for your business, unless you are a biotech
business waiting for FDA approval or some new mobile app
grabbing immediate market share before others, as examples,
raising funds for your business, at any valuation, will be very
difficult. Investors need some initial proof of concept to get their
attention.
And, remember, at the end of the day, the investor will have a very
good sense to what a business is worth, and what they are willing to
pay for it. As they see deals all the time and typically have their
finger on the market pulse. So, collect a few term sheets from
multiple investors, and compare and contrast valuations and other
terms, and play them off each other to get the best deal. As a rule of
thumb, expect to give up 25-50% of your equity, in your first
financing round, depending on the size of the investment and the
type of investor (e.g., angel vs. venture capitalist).
If this describes you, and you prefer to raise debt instead of equity,
it is most likely going to come in the form of a convertible debt
instrument from a traditional angel investor, not a bank. So, go back
and read Lesson #5 on How to Find Angel Investors, and pitch
those angels a debt instrument, instead of equity, and you will most
likely negotiate towards some convertible debt instrument in the
middle. That said, if you are beyond seed stage, and are actually
driving profits that can service a loan, keep reading.
Now, there are a few exceptions to the rule. If you are trying to
finance hard assets (e.g., equipment, real estate), or bridge known
accounts receivable for working capital purposes, certain lenders or
factoring companies could be a little easier to work with, lending
50%-80% of the asset value depending on the nature of the assets
and risks associated with loan recovery. This includes financing any
equipment or other physical assets through capitalized leases, which
require minimal upfront payment for the assets, but over the life of
the lease, typically add up to 2x-3x the cost of the assets had you
purchased them for cash upfront. Just how mortgage payments add
up on your house over time (therefore helping near term cash, but
hurting long term cash). These asset-backed lenders will also
require personal guarantees, which are never fun if your business
goes under, as it can take you down personally, as well (adding
insult to injury).
And, if you are financing real estate, there are plenty of mortgage
companies to reach out to. But, you will need to have enough
personal or other income to insure that the mortgage costs
(combined with the costs of any other debts you have, like your
home mortgage or car loans) are not higher than 40%-45% of your
monthly income. Not to mention, having enough other cash on hand
to afford the 10-20% down payment. I don’t know many startups or
entrepreneurs that will successfully meet this criteria, so most
likely, this too will lead to a dead end.
And, worth mentioning, the same due diligence list that is being
asked of you, as a seller, can be used by you, as a buyer in any
acquisitions you are considering. So, keep this lesson handy to make
sure you are asking the right questions of any acquisition targets.
Lesson #97: Securing a Small Business Grant
Grants can often be an effective vehicle to finance your business,
just as venture capital can be. And, the upside of a grant is,
oftentimes, it does not need to be repaid or come with any long-term
hooks, like investors bring. That said, grants are not easy to secure.
So, if you can get one, more power to you. Today’s lesson will
summarize a few basics around securing a small business grant.
As I mentioned, grants are not easy to secure, given the high level
of competition looking for the same monies. But, if you: (i) know
where to look for available grants, (ii) engage the services of a
professional grant writer, and (iii) submit a proposal in the correct
format, you have as good a chance as anybody to secure such funds.
I wouldn’t invest a ton of time here, given the low odds of closure,
but it is definitely worth a little high level research to see if there are
any low-hanging-fruit opportunities that you can easily pursue.
You can also try to write the grant proposal yourself, to save some
money. The elements of a good grant proposal can be found on this
grant writing page on Wikipedia. So, follow the standard format,
and make sure you address all the detailed requirements that are
being asked for by the granting organization.
6 Finance
I don’t think you need anything fancy here. All you really need is
some basic and inexpensive small business accounting software,
like QuickBooks or Peachtree, to track all revenues and expenses of
the business, all balance sheet accounts (e.g., accounts payable,
accounts receivable) and related cash flow items. In addition, keep a
good paper trail in your files (e.g., invoices paid including check
numbers, invoices collected including deposit records), which backs
up all numbers entered into the accounting software system, in case
an auditor ever needs to see them.
Accounts payable are current liabilities less than one year old. And,
more practicably, they represent your normal monthly operating
expenses that get invoiced to you monthly. One way to stretch your
cash resources as a startup is to stretch out the timing on when you
actually pay your monthly bills. Most bills get invoiced with 30-day
due dates. But, stretching those payments to 45-60 days can give
you an extra 15-30 days of time to allow cash from revenues or
other sources (e.g., financing) to materialize before having to go
cash out of pocket.
That said, the longer you stretch out the timing on paying your bills,
the higher odds you piss off your vendors, where they may want to
drop you or implement prepayment terms to continue the
relationship. In addition, late payments by you also increase the
odds such late payments get reported to business services like Dun
& Bradstreet (D&B) or the Better Business Bureau (BBB). So, you
don’t want to use any long-term techniques that would impact your
public facing business credit ratings or corporate image. So, only
use these techniques when you have no other choice.
Accounts receivable are current assets less than one year old. And,
more practicably, they represent your normal monthly revenues
which you invoice monthly. So, the keys here are: (i) make sure you
are invoicing your customers on the first date of each month, to get
the collections clock started sooner than later; and (ii) make sure
you have a process each month to follow up with late paying
customers, to collect your cash sooner than later (e.g., monthly
aging reports, controller who tracks down late payments). The
longer you take to invoice clients and the longer you take to collect
late paying receivables, the more cash strains you are putting on
your business.
Don’t get so bogged down with the running of your startup, that you
forget to manage the timing of bills you need to pay and the timing
of receivables you need to collect. It can make a material difference
to your cash flow, and can more easily get you through the tough
times.
Interest. If you have any debt, you need to pay interest expense.
And, if you have a big cash balance, you will earn interest income.
Make sure you pick these up in your forecast, as well.
Taxes. If you are running a profitable company, you will also have
to budget for annual corporate income taxes at the levels appropriate
for your city and state. Understanding, you may have net operating
loss carry-forwards from prior years’ losses, to offset your early
profits.
Sanity check. At the end of the day, does your forecast pass the
“sniff test”. If you are only spending $500K in marketing, is it
reasonable to build a $100MM revenue business? Probably not. If
your industry is only $100MM in size, and you are building a
$50MM business, is it reasonable to achieve 50% market share in
your first year (or ever, for that matter)? Probably not. So, just make
sure your forecast is credible in light of your sales/marketing budget
and industry size.
Once you have taken into account all of the above, you should be in
a very good position to finish your budget and forecast the cash
needs of your business. So, make sure you raise enough capital to
cover at least 12-18 months of your going forward operations.
Otherwise, you will constantly be in fundraising mode, and not
focused on building out your business.
7 General Business
Market timing is basically being in the right place at the right time. I
will use MediaRecall, my past company, as an example.
MediaRecall had built the fastest, cheapest solution to digitize large
archives of film and video content, for publishing on the web. The
business was launched in 2006, well before online video started to
take off, so the big film archives had not yet began to think about
digitizing their archives. So, the company struggled to build a sales
pipeline until 2009, post the rapid success of sites like YouTube and
Hulu and all film archives scrambling to find a way to get their
archives monetizing online. Had MediaRecall launched in 2008, it
would have saved two years of burn rate. But, you are never that
smart to time the market. So, just make sure there is solid customer
interest for your product, before investing too heavily in your
business (e.g., the lean startup principle). But, launch early enough
to be the first to market, and beat any potential competitors to the
market.
And, on the sell side of your venture, it is important you know how
long to ride the wave. Don’t make the mistake of the riding the story
too long. Somethings may change to hurt the business (e.g., market
conditions, competition) that will result in a much lower sale price,
had you sold at an earlier time. And, equally important, the
prospective buyer of your business will want to see upside on their
investment. They will not want to buy a story that they perceive has
reached its full potential.
And, overriding all of this? Luck! So, carry your four leaf clovers
and rabbit feet in your pocket at all times!!
Lesson #8: Startups Require Flexibility to
Optimize Business Model
The #1 reason nine out of ten starts ups fail is the fact they did not
pivot fast enough, or stayed too focused or impassioned on their
original failing model. For most successful startups, their final
business model was the end product of numerous iterations and
evolutions from where they first started. It is critical you constantly
tinker with your model until you get it right.
I will use iExplore, the online adventure travel business I ran for 10
years, to further exemplify this point. iExplore’s original revenue
model was being an online travel agency of 5,000 adventure tours
from 200 third-party suppliers, earning a 15% commission on any
tours we booked through our call center. We learned there were a
few problems with that model: (1) 15% commissions are not a lot of
money to drive a very profitable business without tremendous scale;
(2) there were too many suppliers to drive enough volume to any
one to become important to them; and (3) the huge product selection
was too intimidating for the user; all the customer knew was they
wanted to go on a safari to Africa, and they could not easily
differentiate between the 100 safaris we offered on our site going to
unknown places like Kenya, Tanzania, South Africa, Botswana,
Namibia and Zimbabwe.
So, iExplore’s first pivot was to dramatically cut back the trip and
supplier offering, cutting to 2,000 trips and 20 key suppliers. That
made the customer experience more easy to navigate, while at the
same time, started pushing more volume to a select group of
preferred vendors. This latter point was critical to driving our
commissions up from 15% to 20%, the commissions paid by
suppliers to their highest-volume travel agencies.
But, those words of caution surely proved true in the days that
followed 9/11. The investors that were supposed to fund our last
round, got nervous and pulled their committed funding. And, sure
enough, travel sales fell off a cliff, at exactly the same time the
company was nearly out of cash (optimistic the venture funding deal
was only a couple days away). But, in the words of show business,
“It ain’t over until the fat lady sings”. And, iExplore found itself
with 45 employees, no cash, no prospects of cash, a ton of debt and
no revenues, staring over the edge of the abyss and at the precipice
of bankruptcy. In one fell swoop, a really exciting time in
iExplore’s history, became its worst nightmare and darkest moment.
So, when doing your budgeting and fund raising, always assume
you will need 2x the money you think you will need, 2x the
timeframe to achieve profitability and 2x the length of time required
to close any financing, and that should leave you with enough
cushion to get through the bad times or any delays. Building cash
reserves like this is not always easy for a startup, but it is critical if
you want to survive any and all scenarios. So, where you can, keep
your expenses razor thin until revenues or funding allow you to do
otherwise. And, do your best to “turn pennies into manhole covers”.
You’ll never know when you’ll need them!
To set the stage, here were the key datapoints for iExplore’s
business at 9/11/01. The company had about $5MM in debt
($3.5MM from venture capitalists and $1.5MM from creditors), a
cash burn rate of around $250K per month, no revenues coming in
(due to low demand post 9/11/01), a low margin business and no
cash in the bank (with our $4MM committed venture deal falling
apart post 9/11/01). To say the situation was bleak was an
understatement, and any normal business would have called it a day
and closed the business. But, I was passionate about the business
and our progress to date, and knew the markets would ultimately
recover. All I needed to do was to restructure our business to give it
a chance to succeed long term.
It terms of the $250K burn rate, that was net of any discretionary
spending like marketing that we had immediately cut. It was largely
the expenses related to our 45 person staff. With no cash in the
bank, and no cash in sight, I had no choice but to layoff 100% of
our staff, including myself. That got the burn down close to $50K
per month, a much more reasonable level to find a “white knight”. I
basically told nine of our employees, that if you are willing to
volunteer your time over the next couple months, they would be
rehired (and paid any unpaid back pay) if a new financing closes.
But, no promises, proceed at your own caution. Believe it or not,
those nine employees were as impassioned about iExplore as I was,
and agreed to stay on for no pay, on the hopes of having a job on the
back end. Those were some really terrific people!
Settling the $1.5MM of creditor debt was a lot trickier, as they were
not board members and did not have a vested equity stake. The
good news was, these creditors were not iExplore customers or
going forward vendors. They were 100 old vendors that we did not
plan on using going forward (e.g., old advertising agency, unneeded
software/hosting vendors post our reorganization). So, we hired
bankruptcy counsel who filled in a 75 page draft bankruptcy filing
and sent it to the 100 creditors with a cover letter that basically said,
“we all know what happened at 9/11/01, iExplore is illiquid and
needs to raise cash, new cash has been identified but only if you
settle your debts at $0.10 on the dollar, and if you don’t agree, you
are sitting behind $3.5MM of senior venture debt and will get zero
when this draft document gets filed”. It was basically a huge game
of “chicken” with what would become 100 hostile and pissed off
creditors. But, after lots of calls by myself and our CFO, we got
100% of the creditors to agree to the settlement, since $0.10 on the
dollar was better than zero. And, we turned $1.5MM of liabilities to
$150K of liabilities, a lot easier for a new investor to digest.
The final thing we had to do was raise the new capital, which was
torture in the wake of 9/11/01 when the whole financial market
basically went on pause. I had made 400 phone calls to my venture
capital colleagues looking for anyone to listen, and they were just
too worried about the long-term impact on the travel industry in a
world of increased terrorism. So, I had no choice but to call my
uncle, who was one of my advisors, that was willing to fund me
$50K per month, assuming he could see material progress in our
business. That was our lifeline, that gave me the time to ultimately
find $1MM of new venture capital that was willing to fund the
business in January 2002. These investors got more comfortable the
longer we got away from 9/11/01 and they could actually see
revenues starting to recover. Not to mention, buying into established
iExplore (with over 1MM visitors a month) at much reduced
valuations, could lead to juicy financial returns when the market
fully rebounded.
So, that was how iExplore survived 9/11/01 and lived to fight
another day. And, as we all know, it ultimately became the largest
website in the adventure travel space, and was sold in 2007 to TUI
Travel PLC, a $25BN company and largest seller of leisure travel in
the world. The investors who saved the business after 9/11/01 made
a good return on their investment. And, I now have a success story
on my resume and not a failure.
In determining where the pivot opportunity is, you need to study the
core assets of the business and how they may be applied in new
ways. In the Groupon example, it was the “tipping point”
technologies used in a new industry (e.g., consumer deals, instead of
fundraising). There are other examples, where the exact same
product wasn’t working for B2B clients, but was demanded by B2C
consumers. Or, the product doesn’t sell as a branded frontend
solution, but does as a white label back end solution. Or, maybe
your technology is too expensive on an installed license basis, but
sells better under a more cost effective SaaS solution. Maybe
corporations don’t need your solutions, but government or
university clients do?
Or, maybe there are dramatic changes that could lead to much better
financial returns on your investment. In one example, at
MediaRecall, a digital video services and technology company
serving the film studios and television networks, we learned that
instead of taking an upfront cash fee for services provided, we could
do the work for free and keep a 50%/50% revenue share on the
resulting professional entertainment content. These content royalties
would ultimately result in 10x the overall revenues than what we
would have received from the upfront for-fee services model, as the
resulting content gets distributed and monetizing on sites like
YouTube and Hulu. So, if we could fund the upfront work,
definitely worth the wait for revenues over time, instead of upfront.
So, when looking for your strongest assets, look enterprise wide.
Your asset can be a technology. Or,in distribution and logistics. Or,
in search engine marketing. Or, offshore product sourcing. Or, in
call center operations? Or, whatever. Just figure out what it is, and
leverage the hell out of it in new industries, sales channels or
applications.
First and foremost, for any negotiation to work, both parties need to
feel like they are getting a good deal. It can’t be lopsided in one way
or another, for the deal to have any reasonable chance for success.
So, structuring deals means working towards a win-win outcome for
both parties. Make sure the other party has clear responsibilities that
meet your goals, and vice versa. You know both parties have done a
good job negotiating, when they both feel “good” about the deal,
not one party feeling “great” and the other party feeling
“lukewarm.”
Secondly, most smart parties never lead with their best offer. They
always leave some wiggle room. So, as an example, when you are
buying a property listed for $1MM, it is not uncommon for your
first offer to be $900K and the parties agree to somewhere in the
middle near $950K. That 5% discount was already built into the
seller’s going in psychology, and they were prepared for that move.
But, had you started with a $500K offer for that $1MM listing, the
seller could be insulted by such a low offer, and the conversations
could end before they even got started. So, take advantage of
building in cushions, in both your asking price when selling, and bid
price when buying, so the other party feels like they have negotiated
a good deal too, through the process. But, don’t go overboard in
your starting positions, or risk a deal never happening.
Which takes us to the fourth point: in order to get the best terms, the
other party needs to feel you have a “hot product” and that they are
in competition with other bidders. If the other party thinks they are
the only bidder at the table: (i) they may get nervous about
proceeding, and that they may be missing something; and (ii) they
have no reason to move on terms, if they think you are desperate,
and need them, more than they need you. As an example, when
iExplore negotiated our strategic partnership with National
Geographic, in a subtle and non-threatening way, I was sure to let
them know I was having similar conversations with multiple other
parties, including Discovery Channel, their archenemy they would
not want to lose the opportunity.
The last point involves construction of the contract. Most often, the
parties negotiating the deal, are not the same parties executing the
deal. And, you do not want to leave any desired partnership points
“up for interpretation” or undocumented, including key deliverable
dates. In that same deal with National Geographic, we cut the deal
with their CEO and CFO, but then got handed off to 50 execution
people in the trenches: various publishers and editors at three
magazines, a cable channel, a website, a retail store and direct mail
list. All fiefdoms trying to grow their own businesses, with no clear
incentives to see iExplore succeed. I just assumed our senior level
contacts would be our internal champions company-wide. And, they
were to open up those doors, but it was ultimately up to the
execution people to fulfill any obligations. So, the devil is in the
details.
But, big picture, if you think it is important to make a deal, then get
the deal done without trying to carve every last penny out of it. As
an example, I thought the National Geographic strategic partnership
discussed above was worth 25% equity to them, but they dug in on
30%. I wasn’t going to quibble over that extra 5% equity stake, at
the risk of losing the deal altogether, when their brand association
and marketing support had to potential to double our business over
night. But, if you are far apart on important points to you, hold your
ground, and don’t flinch.
But, all I could think was the founder lacked focus. The skills
necessary to succeed vary wildly between services businesses and
technology businesses, or B2C marketing vs. B2B sales businesses.
And, clients in different industries have different end-product
requirements. And, they didn’t think of the channel conflicts of both
selling technology to advertising companies, while at the same time,
trying to compete with those companies with an advertising sales
model of their own. It was a mess indeed. And, when I
communicated that to the founder, all I got was a blank stare of
disbelief.
I, myself, was not immune to these mistakes while I was a first time
entrepreneur building iExplore in the adventure travel space. At the
same time during the early years of the business, I was trying to
build: (i) a leading internet portal website; (ii) an adventure travel
agency; (iii) an iExplore branded tour operator business; (iv) a
corporate events vendor; (v) a fund raising events management
company; and (vi) an advertising sales representation company. It
was simple too much, with each business having different
requirements, pulling the company in different directions. It wasn’t
until we laser focused our business around building the largest
website in the industry, supported by an advertising revenue base,
that the bottom line profits really started to take off.
So, I challenge you to all study your current businesses and make
sure it is designed as simply as it can be for long-term success and
focus. If you cannot simply describe your business in one sentence,
it is too complicated.
Lesson #47: The Importance of Networking
The old adage, “It is not what you know, it is who you know,”
resonates particularly well for startup entrepreneurs. And, it holds
true across most all areas of a startup’s business, including driving
sales, hiring employees, raising capital and securing key
partnerships. Therefore, establishing, nurturing and mining a deep
network of relationships can often make or break the success of a
startup. I know many of you may be uncomfortable with
networking, but hopefully this post will help you understand the
importance of networking and the need to break down any barriers
between you and your network. Let’s discuss the various types of
networking opportunities available to you.
We all know how busy you are as a startup executive. But, you
can’t bury yourself in your office, and you can’t be bashful when
building your business. Start building your network, and great
things (e.g., new clients, employees, investors, partners) are sure to
follow. And, don’t forget, networking is more than simply the
networking event itself: you are building long-term relationships
and need to follow up with these new colleagues after the event, and
over time. So, manage this network nurturing process accordingly.
And, had the iExplore team not had passion in the wake of 9/11/01
(remembering the company’s dire straits in Lesson #29), the
company would have never survived. Believe me, it would have
been a lot easier to close the business and move on from the
carnage. But, we were all passionate about what we were building,
knew this was a short-term hurdle and that we were committed to
living and fighting another day. A business only fails, when you
stop trying. And, passion was the lifeboat that carried us through
those dark days.
Fail fast simply means you want to learn whether or not your model
is working, and has a reasonable chance for profitability and long
term success, sooner than later. Too often an entrepreneur: (i) hasn’t
clearly identified the key success metrics for their startup; (ii)
doesn’t put the proper tracking and processes in place to ensure
such success metrics are met; and (iii) hangs on trying to keep a bad
idea on “life support” for too long, simply because they can’t walk
away from their “baby”. All that does is continue to invest “good
money” after “bad money”, and exacerbates your pain and capital
lost, when you ultimately have to shut the business down. So, make
sure you are clear on your ultimate success metrics and pull the plug
sooner than later, as soon as it becomes clear you are not heading
towards long-term success.
But, despite all of this excitement in the room, one of the highlights
to me was the introductory and inspirational speech by Joe Born, a
serial entrepreneur and Excelerate Labs mentor in Chicago. Joe is
currently the CEO of Neuros Technology and has had many
successful startups in his past. And, the summary of his speech was:
he could have never achieved the success that he did without a
robust supporting cast within the Chicago startup ecosystem.
Whenever he was knocked down, there was always someone there
to help pick him up and brush off the dust, giving him the additional
motivation to get back in the fight. The point being, us
entrepreneurs should never feel like we are trying to move
mountains by ourselves. There is always someone you can tap into
that has been in your shoes before, who can provide their guidance
to help you succeed and navigate any challenges you may be
experiencing.
And, for us in Chicago, this ecosystem has never been stronger than
it is today. I only wished I had an ecosystem like this to tap into
when I was starting up iExplore back in 1999, when Chicago was
the “flyover” city, compared to finding startups on the coasts in
Silicon Valley or New York. This includes all the tremendous
efforts of entrepreneurial groups like the Chicago Entrepreneurial
Center, Illinois Technology Association, TiE Midwest, Illinois
Venture Capital Association and Built in Chicago. And, the
entrepreneurial clubs within business schools and engineering
schools at Northwestern, U-Chicago, UIC, IIT, Depaul and Loyola.
And, all the venture investments by New World Ventures,
Lightbank, i2a Fund, OCA Ventures, MK Capital, Apex, Merrick,
Origin Ventures, Baird, Illinois Ventures and others. And, the angel
investor networks at Hyde Park Angels, Cornerstone Angels,
Heartland Angels and Wildcat Angels. And, the startup lawyers,
like Bart Loethen, Scott Glickson, Michael Gray, Bruce Zivian,
Frank Ballantine and Craig Bradley. And, startup advisors like Red
Rocket, Color Jar, Strongsuit, Venture Lab, AEGIS and
MidVentures. Incubators and accelerators like Sandbox, Excelerate
Labs, Tech Innovation Center, ScaleWell and Tech Nexus. And,
local events like Tech Week, Lean Startup Circle, BNC Tech Pitch,
Big Idea Forum, Founders Institute, Chicago Innovation Awards
and Funding Feeding Frenzy. And, startups like Groupon, Grub
Hub, Sitter City, Clever Safe, Braintree, Mu Sigma and others,
whose halo effect on the local market have put Chicago on the map
in a bigger way, attracting outside investment from the bigger
venture funds on the coasts.
I applaud you all, for doing your part to helping make Chicago one
of the best cities to start a new business and creating an amazing
startup ecosystem in the process. Us entrepreneurs couldn’t do it
without you.
I encourage all of you to tap into your local startup ecosystem, and
greatness will surely follow.
It is not fair that this happens, but the reality is, these “intangibles”
can often rule the day. And, lack of these “intangibles” can make it
an uphill battle for your startup to get off the ground. So, do your
best to make sure you have all your T’s crossed and all your I’s
dotted, from a perception basis, as well as a business basis, before
approaching prospective investors or partners/customers. And, if
you can’t fix perceptions, for whatever reason, figure out how to
turn your perceived weaknesses into communicated strengths,
tackling them head on.
Everyone initially wants to dance with the prettiest girl at the ball,
even though she may have an I.Q. of 75. But, people can’t assess
I.Q. based on a first glance from across the dance hall. So, make
sure you put on your best evening gown and ruby slippers, so you
too can get that first dance, and wow them from there.
Listen More Than You Talk. Often times, the biggest mistake an
entrepreneur has is having “diarrhea of the mouth”, sharing their
vision and rambling on about the features and functionalities of their
product or service. It is much better to go into a meeting with your
ears wide open, not your mouth. Ask probing questions that will
help you better learn the exact needs of your prospective client.
Then, once you know exactly what they are looking for, pound
home the key assets of your business, which directly address their
sweetspot.
Dress The Part. Always research the dress code of the other party
and dress equal to or better than they do. You never want to show
up in jeans to a company that works in business casual. The better
you dress, the more professional you will come across, increasing
the confidence of the other party in doing business with you. So,
hide the tattoos, take out the piercings and polish up your wingtips.
Remember, intangibles, like the way you present yourself, really
matter.
Strong Track Record. The more you can prove your historical
success, the better odds people will bet on your future success. Did
you graduate a name brand school? Did you get good grades there?
Did you work for name brand companies in your past? Did you
have a quantifiable level of success there? Have you done a startup
in the past, and if so, what was the outcome for its investors? Have
you won any relevant awards? The answers to these questions can
help build your credibility.
Clean Social Media Footprint. Make sure you clean up all your
public facing profiles in the social media world. You want to make
sure your persona is professional and trustable at all times. So, no
crazy party pictures, swearing or liking/publishing offensive
content. Potential partners will do their home work on you, and you
do not want to leave them with any excuse not to trust you.
Clean History. Having a free and clear criminal history and a good
credit score (personally and professionally) are a must for when a
prospective partner does their background checks on you and your
business. This should be pretty self-explanatory.
The Way You Carry Yourself. How you dress, how you talk, your
personality style, your listening skills, your professionalism, your
smarts all impact your personal brand. So, play the part required of
you in order to get the trusted attention of your prospective partners.
Most B2B companies are sales driven organizations, and most B2C
companies are marketing driven organizations, with numerous
examples of companies overlapping between the two. The reasons
most B2B companies are sales driven are three fold: (i) they are
usually dealing with a much smaller base of customers, more easily
reachable by a sales team; (ii) corporate customers are typically
relationship driven, and want the comfort of working with a
salesperson that best understands their needs; and (iii) the average
transaction size can get very large, often into the millions, which
needs the comfort provided from a face to face meeting to close a
sale (e.g., the trust factor).
The downsides of marketing are: (i) it can get expensive for any
budget, so you will need to have cash resources to spend; (ii) the
results are not always perfectly attributable to a specific marketing
piece, so you may not be able to know with 100% certainty which
tactics are working better or worse than others; and (iii) we are
living in a world where small budget startups are competiting with
big budget brands for the same marketing real estate.
The other key procedural point is the speed at which you respond to
a new lead. The faster you respond to a new lead, the higher your
odds you close that lead, before one of your competitors calls the
customer back. At iExplore, customers would reach out to three or
four tour operators while doing their research, and our sales
conversion rate was directly proportional to the response time of our
sales team (e.g., one hour response closed at 25% rate, 8 hour
response closed at 10% rate). And, if it was that dramatic for a four
week sales cycle product, imagine the implications for a “real time”
sales cycle product (e.g., I need business cards for a meeting
tomorrow).
You may be thinking that revenue targets are the most logical and
easy way to design your sales plan. And, often times they are. But,
if you simply give your team a sales target, they may not be paying
attention to other important metrics like the profit margin on their
sales, or the conversion rate as a percentage of leads they are being
given. When at iExplore, we actually were driving our sales team on
the latter, since if they were driving gross profit and converting a
high percentage of the leads we were sending them, the top line
revenues would naturally follow. So, figure out what key metrics
drive your business, and get your team religiously focused around
those metrics, which may or may not be revenues for your business.
There is a second piece to this, which is incentivizing the team
based on their individual performance vs. the company’s overall
performance. There could be scenarios where the company has a
bad month overall, but an individual does great, and vice versa. In
my opinion, it is important to reward good individual behavior, in
all scenarios. So, at iExplore we said that 50% of the incentive
would come from individual performance, regardless of company
performance, and 50% of their incentive would come from company
performance, regardless of their individual performance. That did a
good job of balancing the ebbs and flows of both the individual’s
and the company’s sales cycles.
But, the most critical overriding point is: in whatever sales incentive
plan you put in place, make sure it works for both the company and
the individual. Nothing will demotivate a sales team faster than an
individual working their ass off, and not seeing any fruits for their
labor. And, we all know how hard it is to recruit good sales people,
and keep them on staff. So, think long term, not short term, with
your sales team, even in the bad months.
You just never know what “evil” is lurking in the night, both by
disgruntled employees or competitors sniffing around for
information. So, better safe, than sorry.
First of all, it is important that any work done on your business prior
to formation, is legally documented as owned by the company at the
time of formation. So, collect key signatures from all founders,
employees, contractors, etc. with them agreeing that all work done
for the company was done on a “work for hire” basis and they
assign all inventions to the company. And, this document needs to
be in place for any and all employees and contractors going
forward, so no one can ever claim rights to the company’s
intellectual capital down the road. This is relevant to equity
discussions, so no previous founders or employees that are no
longer working with the business, come back looking for equity
value down the road after you hit it big.
So, as you can see, a good lawyer can help you think through all of
these issues upfront, before running into any unexpected snags or
ugly situations down the road. So, if you need any further help from
here, and you most certainly will, Bart Loethen at Synergy Law
Group has deep experience with startups and his hourly rates are a
lot more affordable than those charged by the bigger firms.
Lesson #62: Insurance Protection for
Startups
With startups, many things can go wrong. But, the last thing you
need is to be caught in a jam without the proper insurance
protections when an unexpected situation arises. Below are a few
policies to consider for your startup, some mandatory from the start
and some optional based on your specific situation or when budgets
can afford them.
The second case study was where our trademark helped us. There
was a company that was trying to “piggyback” on the iExplore
name, by launching travel websites like iexploreegypt.com,
iexploreturkey.com and iexploregreece.com, including a logo that
looked very similar to our own. Here too, customers were getting
confused, thinking they were buying from us, but were not. We sent
a cease and desist letter and threatened a lawsuit, and amicably
resolved the situation, making them change their logo, feature their
company name in the header (not iExplore), and clearly state they
were not affiliated with iExplore on their About Us page. So, make
sure you keep an eye out at all times, for potential competitors
trying to piggyback on your success.
Focus groups can also be done, immediately after a user first plays
with your website or product. To get their immediate reaction to
whether or not they liked it, and what they see as potential areas of
improvement. And, you would be surprised how much the answers
to the same questions can materially change from focus groups
completed prior to seeing the product, to after they see they product.
As an example, they may be willing to pay a lot more for it, once
they see the product in action, meeting their real life needs. And,
focus groups like this are also good for A/B testing, in case you are
not sure what direction to go. This allows you to show the user two
different options while they are using your website or product,
version A and version B, and letting them decide which version they
like better.
But, the problem with in-person focus groups is that they can be
time consuming and expensive. You typically have to pay
participants $50-$100 per session for their time, which certainly
adds up with the scores of participants needed to get a good data
sample, for each step of the design process. The good news is there
are many affordable technologies that can help you accomplish the
same usability testing goals.
I am not a pro on all the various tools in the marketplace, nor have I
used them all. So, I did a little research on the internet and
discovered this great list of 24 Usability Testing Tools from Craig
Tomlin’s usability testing blog. Craig is an expert in the usability
testing space and did a great job summarizing the pluses and
minuses of the various tools you have at your disposal. And many
other readers of Craig’s blog have posted additional valuable input,
in the comments section.
Hopefully this lesson gave you a good sense to why you need to do
consumer usability testing, and various ways to implement such,
both in-person and via technologies. If you need more help from
here, Craig looks like a good guy to know (although I have not met
him personally). And, if you are ever in a jam, your marketing firm
or development firm often have access to many good resources to
assist you here.
Let’s start with MediaRecall, the B2B digital video services and
technology business I ran. We were in discussions with NBC on
digitizing their entire news archive for the last decades, with
hundreds of thousands of hours of content that needed to be
serviced. It would be a $25MM contract over five years that would
“change our world”. Especially since the largest contract we had
ever closed prior to that was $500K. We were all jazzed up about
this project, for what it could do to stabilize our revenues as a
startup and cover our overhead costs for the foreseeable future.
But, once the revenue potential “euphoria” wore off, the impact of a
contract that large was actually quite sobering: (i) our technology
infrastructure would need to be materially improved and expanded
to support all the additional volume; (ii) we would need to build a
second services facility onsite in New York, with rare equipment
specifically needed for that one project only; (iii) the work would
require a lot of energy around fragile old film reels, when video
tapes are a lot easier to work with without risk of damaging the core
content (which we were indemnifying against damages); (iv) our
human resources efforts would need to accelerate to hire and train
all the additional staff overnight; (v) we would need to move to a
material larger home office to staff the new team, materially
increasing our going-forward overhead; (vi) this contract would
most certainly be all-time-consuming, for at least the first year,
putting at risk our efforts with other clients, slowing our new client
pipeline and putting all our eggs in one basket; and (vii) if one thing
goes wrong with this high profile project, that news could spread
through this very tight-knit industry and basically “black list” our
company. A lot was riding on the success of this project, and it
required religious focus to not drop the ball on any of these potential
pitfalls.
Then reality settled in with unexpected pitfalls along the way: (i) the
people we executed the partnership with handed us off to an
execution team, comprised of about 50 individuals in various
departments that had no real vested interest to help iExplore succeed
(pulling teeth to get anything done); (ii) the contract was not written
with enough clarity, leaving it up for debate what was really
intended in certain areas; (iii) the contract was written with the
assumption that iExplore would be flush with cash throughout the
five year period, and could afford buying 50% discounted ad space
in the magazines and direct mail (which wasn’t the case after
9/11/01, taking this marketing support off the table--BOOM!, there
goes 6MM magazine subcribers); (iv) the cable TV division could
never find a way to promote us cost effectively (BOOM!, there goes
80MM households); (v) although we found permanent placement on
their website, we were buried deep on their site with links that were
hard to find (BOOM!, there goes 5MM uniques, in exchange for
50K uniques); and (vi) it made cutting a strategic deal with
Discovery Channel (one of my goals), much more difficult, as they
are arch enemies with National Geographic. Did I already mention
we gave up 30% of the company for this relationship?? Lessons for
next time: the devil is in the details!!
So, as you can see, “whales” can be great for revenues, but they can
put a lot of strain on the business in other ways. Some you can
expect, and some you can’t. So, make sure you think through all of
the potential pitfalls well in advance of signing the contract, and
make sure you get any expected support in writing (and in
excrutiating detail, so there is no ambiguity on what you are
expecting).
The way we prioritized our tech list was to determine: (i) which
core features were “must haves” for launching a product that
consumers would be excited to use (and sufficiently differentiate
ourselves from our competition); and (ii) which features will do the
biggest job of moving the revenue needle or meeting our other
customer acquisition goals.
In terms of managing the project, it comes down to: (1) making sure
the entire team is clear on what they are building (and that they had
input in such vision); (2) making sure the team is entirely clear on
the date of delivery; and (3) having the team work in an agile
process of development.
If you told your team you were building a new car, you would be
surprised how many different interpretations your team may have,
in terms of what type of new car you were building. Some may
think red, others blue. Some may think van, others SUV. Some
make think luxury car, others may think more mainstream. So, you
need to pull your team together at the time of the project launch, and
through the process itself, to collaborate and collectively agree that
the new car we are trying to build is a yellow luxury sedan.
Hopefully, this open communication process will eliminate any
confusion amongst the group in terms what it is you are actually
building.
So, in today’s day and age, the iterative and incremental agile
development process is the way to go. The key components of the
agile manifesto are: (a) individuals and interactions, over processes
and tools; (b) working software, over comprehensive
documentation; (c) customer collaboration, over contract
negotiation; and (d) responding to change, over following a plan.
Or, said another way: (i) open communications and collaboration
with the entire cross-functional team from ideation through
completion; (ii) small bite-sized projects that need to get completed
every two weeks; and (iii) each person on the team responsible for
one specific piece of the puzzle (e.g., Joe tackling sign up form
functionality, Jimmy doing user design, and Susie doing database
integration).
But, how exactly did she do it? What lessons can we entrepreneurs
take from such a meteoric rise. To me, it comes down to the
following drivers of her success: (i) she took a page right out of a
proven playbook (e.g., Madonna); (ii) she always keeps her
followers guessing and wanting more; (ii) she produces a very high-
quality product; and (iv) she has a sincere personal relationship with
her customers/fans. Let’s study each of these points in more depth
below.
Lady Gaga was not the first female mega-popstar. She was clearly
preceded by many others, including one of her idols, Madonna.
Madonna was cutting edge for her day (the 1980’s and 1990’s). She
surrounded her music with controversial subject matter, videos
oozing with sexuality, and costumes that would make any mother
blush. And, she was the pro at staying relevant in an industry
littered with one-hit wonders. As she got older, she took bold
chances to keep her name at the forefront of her industry (e.g.,
leading role in Evita movie, music collaborations with hot stars of
the day, like Justin Timberlake). But, what Lady Gaga did, was take
that Madonna playbook, and put it on steroids. Lady Gaga became
more than simply another “over the top” music celebrity, she also
became a fearless fashion icon and a revered cheerleader/role model
for her fans. Time will tell if Lady Gaga will withstand the test of
time, like Madonna has. But, she is certainly off to a great start with
an already proven playbook.
But, perhaps, Lady Gaga’s biggest success is not her music or her
fashion sense. It is her uncanny ability to connect with her fans, at a
very personal level. She affectionately refers to her fans as her Little
Monsters (more marketing genius), and she has positioned herself as
their leader and champion, for those that cannot champion
themselves. She stands up for all who have been bullied or teased
for being different (almost as if she has personal experience of her
own in this regard). So, she is more than a musical artist to her fans.
She is their leader and role model, giving people a voice that
otherwise would not have a voice of their own. This is pretty
powerful stuff, resulting with Lady Gaga accumulating 56MM
fans/followers on Facebook/Twitter (a very large platform to
communicate her various messages).
Shuffle Your Letters. I can’t tell you how many times I will be
blankly staring at my rack of tiles, and can’t create any words. But,
when I start to randomly shuffle up the letters within the rack, my
brain starts to see potential words that it otherwise missed at first
glance. And, the business lesson here: when you are challenged by a
specific business problem, try to look at it from multiple
perspectives, and a solution may present itself that was not
immediately evident.
Use Your Highest Point Letters. Sounds pretty obvious, but I have
seen people play a six-letter word for six points (one point per
letter), and leave a ten-point Q sitting on their rack unused. And, the
business lesson here: always leverage your best assets in any
situation. As an example, would you walk into a big sales
opportunity leading with your stodgy controller, or your firecracker
salesperson. Or, as another example, don’t try to sell a toaster, when
your core competency is building blenders.
Play the Highest Point Space. With all other things being equal,
play open triple word spaces before open double word spaces, and
open triple letter spaces before open double letter spaces. You want
your tiles to accumulate as many points as possible, in that one turn.
And, the business lesson here: you always want to leverage your
fixed investment, by driving the highest ROI as possible. As an
example, try to close the $5,000 sale over the $2,500 sale, as the
fulfillment costs behind each are the same.
Play the Board, Not the Rack. Too often in Scrabble, people are
simply focused on the seven letter tiles on their rack and trying to
make a word as long as possible therefrom. But in Scrabble,
sometimes playing one letter can be much more valuable, like
playing a ten-point letter Z on a triple letter space on the board.
And, the business lesson here: don’t be so focused on the trees, that
you can’t see the forest. The point of business is to grow as quickly
as you can, and the easier you make it on yourself, the better.
Steve Jobs (Apple). One share of Apple stock back in 1996, when
Jobs regained the reigns as CEO of Apple (the company he co-
founded in 1976), was worth around $5. On the day that Jobs retired
as CEO in August 2011, that same share of stock was worth around
$366. Over that 15-year period, that was an average annual growth
rate of 33% per year, far exceeding the S&P 500’s 3% annual return
for that period. Jobs out-performed the market by 10x!! That makes
him, along with others below, one of the best CEO’s in history, as
long-term and consistent success like that is almost unheard of.
And, how did he do it: (i) intense focus on challenging the norm and
improving the consumer product experience (e.g., via iPod, iPhone,
iPad, iTunes, etc.); and (ii) a very hands-on, aggressive management
style (almost to a fault). And, we didn’t even talk about his early
success in taking the first commercially successful personal
computer to market in his first stint as Apple’s CEO, or his role in
helping turn Pixar into the undisputed leader in digital film
animation in between. One huge hit after another. I am not sure we
will ever see another Steve Jobs. So, religious attention to detail and
provocative innovations will surely lead you in the right direction.
Bill Gates (Microsoft). What Jobs was to Apple, Bill Gates was to
Microsoft. His run as co-founder and CEO of Microsoft from 1976
to 2006 produced an equally impressive 29% average annual growth
rate for its shareholders (which frankly slowed way down between
2000-2006 due to government monopoly discussions and
otherwise). The magic that drove Microsoft’s success was getting
their software products bundled into every piece of hardware
requiring such software, hence the monopoly problems that
eventually arose. But, in addition to being an equally passionate
innovator and product guy, what makes Gates so special is the way
he is giving back to the community via the Bill & Melinda Gates
Foundation, donating billions of dollars to those in need around the
world. It is not only what success you create from society, it is
equally important to give some of that back to society, for charitable
causes that are important to you.
Larry Page/Sergey Brin (Google). How can you argue with the
success of the Google Guys, driving a 22% compound annual return
for its public shareholders over the last seven years, when the
overall market has been dismal and Google’s valuation multiples
were completely off the charts at the time of their IPO in 2004.
What made the Google Guys so special were: (i) their spirit of true
innovation, coming up with a whole new way of driving search
results based on backlinks and algorithms; (ii) getting that spirit of
innovation infused into every employee in the company (e.g., giving
their engineers 20% time to build whatever innovations they want);
and (iii) their ability to see far enough ahead to make big bets (e.g.,
acquiring YouTube for $1.6BN seemed pretty foolish at the time for
a site with no revenue model, but not any more). Make sure your
employees never lose their spirit of innovation, as you never know
what next great idea they will come up with, to help your business
succeed.
Jeff Bezos (Amazon). There are very few sizable businesses that
survived the dot com boom and bust period of the late 1990’s. But,
Amazon is alive and well today, dominating the e-commerce space,
as the #1 internet retailer worldwide, largely to the credit of its CEO
and Founder, Jeff Bezos. What made Bezos so special was his
ability to bet big, in ways that were contrary to popular beliefs.
Bezos had a vision that e-commerce would take off, and even
though the markets were imploding around him, he was able to hold
strong to his vision, even though it may have confused his early
investors with atypical strategies, emphasizing long-term revenue
growth over near term quarterly earnings. It was a huge bet with a
lot of headwind, but Bezos executed it brilliantly. And, not only for
buying books, but for every other merchandise category, as well,
driving a whopping 42% annual return for Amazon’s public
shareholders since 1997 (the best returns of the group on this list).
And, did I mention contributing to the ultimate demise of retailers
like Borders, via electronic books read through a Kindle. So, hold
true to your core beliefs, despite what others are telling you, if your
“spider sense” is telling you it is the best way to go.
But, first, a little history about Netflix’s mounting woes over the last
few months: (i) they announced a separation of their DVD services
from their streaming services (which resulted in me paying 25%
more than before for both services); (ii) they lost their major content
deal with Starz, one of their only premium providers of high-quality
current movies in their offering; (iii) their forecasted users for this
year are 1MM less (5% less) than they estimated they would be at
the beginning of the year, based on these actions; (iv) their stock
price has cut in half (from around $300 per share to $150 per share),
as a result of the above; and (v) now, we have this splitting of the
business into two divisions, which is going to require users to
maintain activity, ratings and queues at two separate websites, one
for online streaming activity and the other for offline DVD rentals. I
just don’t think consumers will ultimately play that game, and
Qwikster (or Netflix’s DVD rental business) will most likely suffer
a “Qwik” death. This is probably Netflix’s long-term goal anyway,
but what a very strange business decision for Netflix to make given
the company still has the majority of its customers still using the
DVD rental services today.
So, what has Netflix done to its consumers in the last couple
months: (i) they are making them pay 25% more for bundled online
and offline services (or forcing them to pick one or the other); (ii)
they are losing current high-quality movie titles, which is
particularly evident on the streaming side of their business which
they desire to promote long term; and (iii) now, they are forcing
customers to maintain two different websites, instead of one, which
is a big ask of 12MM people (the 50% of their total business which
desires both online and offline services). Obviously, consumers are
not responding well to these actions, given the 1MM lower
members than estimated this year. And, the financial markets
haven’t responded well, with the 50% decline in Netflix’s stock
price in the last few months.
So, how did Reed Hastings get himself and Netflix into such a
mess? The answer is really quite simple: they put their business
goals in front of their customer goals. And, sometimes you need to
do that if your underlying business economics are flawed, like
Netflix’s were (e.g., the need for a price increase to cover the cost of
licensing the content—which would have been fine if
communicated that way as a better option than going out of
business). But, this most recent move may ultimately get the whole
house of cards to fall in on itself, when and if 50% of Netflix’s
customers decide to unsubscribe from all or part of the service. Let
me explain further.
At the end of the day, what are the challenges with Netflix’s
business: (i) it is much more expensive to fulfill mailing DVDs to
home, than simply streaming them over the internet; (ii) high-
quality current content is very expensive to license from the major
film studios, especially within the first 28 days of the home release;
(iii) the studios get a lot less revenues from DVD rentals, than they
do from cable on-demand or internet streaming (e.g., former simply
requires Netflix to buy DVDs, and the latter charges Netflix on a
per-subscriber basis for the service); and (iv) the markets are very
bearish on the DVD business long-term, and Netflix doesn’t want
that albatross around its neck in the financial markets (in business
practice or in name). So, when you look at Netflix’s business this
way, it is very easy to see how Netflix has ended up where it did.
I have been a huge fan of Reed Hastings, who has lead meteoric
growth at Netflix and a real change in the way consumers watch
movies (including the demise of former retail titans like
Blockbuster). And, I have been a loyal Netflix customer for years,
despite the ups and downs of their business. But, this most recent
move does not sit well with me, hence the post.
I sure hope they figure out a winning long-term business model, one
that puts the customer first with (i) high-quality current movies; (ii)
that I can watch within the first 28 days of home release; (iii) via
online streaming (or offline, if needed); and (iv) at a price that
makes sense to Netflix’s business (and is affordable to me).
Because, I am sure the major studios are trying to figure out how to
offer this service directly themselves (to cut Netflix as middleman
out of the way), or in partnership with the major cable companies
via on-demand services. But, the last thing I want to do is be forced
to re-rate 1,691 movies watched on a different service, so they know
what movies I have seen and which ones I haven’t seen, in order to
get their recommendation engines correctly working (where Netflix
is the pro and clear first mover).
So, the key lesson here: put your customers’ user experience first
when making key business decisions. You should always be
aspiring to give your customers more and more (and make your user
experience easier and easier) over time, not less and less (and harder
and harder).
11 Miscellaneous
“Our greatest glory consists not in never falling, but in rising every
time we fall.” –Confucius
“I am a great believer in luck, and I find the harder I work, the more
I have of it.” –Thomas Jefferson
“Do not hire a man who does your work for money, but him who
does it for love of it.” –Henry David Thoreau
“Many of life’s failures are people who did not realize how close
they were to success when the gave up.” –Thomas Edison
“You can’t build a reputation on what you are going to do.” –Henry
Ford
“Insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting
different results.” –Albert Einstein
“You can’t rest on your laurels. Your own body of work is yet to
come.” –Barack Obama
“Real success is finding your lifework in the work that you love.”
–David McCullough, Author
“The secret is to hire great people, don’t interfere too much and
when they’re great, take the credit. Works like a charm.” –Woody
Allen
Magazines/Blogs:
Entrepreneur Magazine
Inc. Magazine
Fast Company
Blogs Only:
Mashable
Tech Crunch
Silicon Alley Insider
The Next Web
All Things Digital
GigaOM
Venture Beat
Venture Hacks
Startup Report
Startup Digest
Startup Weekly
On Startups
Startup Meme
Media Post
eMarketer
THE PLUSSES
Being Your Own Boss. Once you get the taste of being your own
boss, it is very difficult to ever go back to being a “cog in the
wheel” within a big corporate environment. Nowhere else can you
get the thrill of making senior level decisions across a wide range of
business topics (e.g., strategy, finance, marketing, technology,
operations). The buck stops with you (literally!), and the success or
failure of your business falls squarely on your shoulders, based on
the decisions made by you and your team. That may sound a little
daunting, at first. But, trust me, it is very exciting.
THE MINUSES
Living Like a Pauper. Let’s face it, it is not easy plowing all your
hard-earned savings into a risky startup, not getting paid in the early
months of getting the business off the ground and not being sure
where your next paycheck is coming from. Unfortunately, unless
you are wealthy from other means, launching a startup with hopes
of a long-term payback often comes with the strings of living very
frugally until the business gets its “sea legs” beneath it. If you need
the comfort and security of bi-weekly paychecks to cover your bills
or lifestyle, don’t get involved in the early stages of a startup.
High Stress Level. Obviously, with weak cash flow and other
business constraints, comes constant worry and stress. Launching a
startup was a big gamble: (i) you quit your comfortable job; (ii) you
put all your savings (and those of your friends and family) at risk;
and (iii) you will end up with nothing but life lessons learned and a
“black eye” with your investors if the business goes under. That is a
big burden to carry around each day. So, if you are not good when
dealing with stressful situations, a startup is not right for you.
Impact on Your Resume. Before being an entrepreneur, I was a big-
bracket investment banker to Fortune 500 executives. Nobody told
me after 12 years of being an entrepreneur, that big company
recruiters would label me an “early stage guy”, making it very
difficult to break into any business generating in-excess of $100MM
of revenues. Don’t get me wrong, I love being involved in startups.
But, I would at least like to control my own career destiny, if I ever
desire to try my hand at being a CEO of a bigger business. The
longer you are involved with startups, the more difficult it will be at
turning back from a lifelong career in early stage companies.
Being an entrepreneur is not right for everyone. Make sure you have
a real appetite for the risks at hand, a real passion for your product
and an unbridled confidence in your ability of building a great
business, before jumping in. But, once you do make the leap, hang
on for one of the wildest rides of your life!! As starting and growing
your own business really is one of the most-rewarding life
experiences you can have.
It has been a real pleasure having you share this editorial adventure
with me.
About George Deeb
Managing Partner,
Red Rocket Ventures
Prior to launching Red Rocket, George was the founder and CEO of
two venture-capital backed digital tech startups: iExplore (which
became the #1 adventure travel website) and MediaRecall (a B2B
digital video services and technology company). Both of these
startups were sold to billion dollar companies. George was named
an Ernst & Young “Entrepreneur of the Year” in 2001, for his
efforts at iExplore. George began his career as an investment banker
with Credit Suisse First Boston, doing mergers and acquisitions and
corporate finance in the retailing/consumer industry group. George
received his BBA in finance from the University of Michigan in
1991. He is also a founding mentor of the Chicago chapters of
Techstars and Founder Institute.
Follow George:
Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/georgedeeb
LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/georgedeeb
Google+: https://plus.google.com/u/0/+GeorgeDeeb
Klout: http://www.klout.com/#/georgedeeb
AngelList: http://www.angel.co/georgedeeb
Contact George via the contact from on the Red Rocket Ventures
website.
About Red Rocket Ventures
Red Rocket is a high-energy, growth-oriented, results-driven
strategic consulting, executive coaching, shared executive staffing
and financial advisory firm whose partners bring a unique
combination of growth strategy, execution and fund raising
experience. Consider us a one-stop resource for companies desiring
high growth in both the B2C and B2B space. We are particularly
deep around digital strategy, digital marketing, digital media, social
media, mobile marketing, e-commerce, digital video and web
technologies, but can easily assist in other industries, as well.
Growth Consulting
Follow Us
To stay up to date with the newest startup lessons from Red Rocket,
please follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn, Google+, Facebook, Vimeo,
SlideShare, Meetup and RSS Feed.
Contact Us
For your immediate needs, feel free to contact us via the contact
form on the Red Rocket Ventures website, to see if we can help.