Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Solids melted
globalisation - complex social processes that are changing our current social condition based on the
modern system of independent nation-states
– unprecedented compression of time and space
– range of processes nesting under one rather unwieldy epithet
Freemen
1. uniqueness and morphological sophistication
absorb and rearrange ideas from conventional ideologies
no other focused on shrinking time and space
market as conceptual core
1. context-bound responsiveness to political issues
2. ability to produce effective conceptual decontestation chains
decontestation - specifies the meanings of the core concepts by arranging in a pattern/configuration
simple semantic chains whose conceptual links convey authoritative meanings that facilitate collective
decision-making
Claims:
A. Globalisation is about the liberalisation and global integration of markets
– markets are driving force of governments: free-market capitalism
B. inevitable and irreversible
C. Nobody is in charge of globalism
D. Benefits everyone in the long run
E. furthers the spread of democracy
F. Requires global war on terror
Modernity
beyond industrialisation: multidimensional
process, discourse
condition and outcome generated by the interaction of deeply structured processes of change taking
place over long periods
modernisation
set of social processes that transition from a pre-modern to a modern society
globality
condition characterised by tight economic, political, cultural and environmental interconnections and
flows making borders and boundaries irrelevant
globalisation
set of social process that transform weakening nationality to globality
human lives played out in a single space
redefining landscape of sociopolitical processes and social sciences
redefining landscape of sociopolitical processes and social sciences
global imaginary
people’s awareness of belonging to a global community
destabilises and unsettles conventional parameters of undestranding which people imagine their shared
existence
political
secular forms of power
legitimacy and sovereignty
defined territorial boundaries
economic
monetarized exchange economy
large scale production and consumption of commodities
extensive ownership of private property
accumulation of capital on a systematic and long term basis
social
no fixed social hierarchies
dynamic social and sexual division of labor
new class formations and distinctive patriarchal relations (modern capitalist)
culture
secular, materialist culture
individualistic, rationalistic and instrumental impulses
new intellectual, cognitive world
cultural and social identities
sense of belonging “imagined community”
symbolic boundaries
Marx
capitalist economy - mass production and consumption
alienation
Weber
rationality (efficiency)
immense bureaucratisation
Durkheim
extensive specialisation/division of labor
mechanical to organic solidarity
anomie
modernisation theory
tech and cultural differences = global inequality
tradition - barrier to econ development
progressively linear process (Rostov)
affluent nations = catalysts
dependency theory
historical exploitation = global inequality
colonisation
wallerstein’s capitalist world economy
affluent nations = perpetrators of impoverishment
Giddens
Giddens
modernity = juggernaut, unavoidable force
reflexive, aware= choices, flexibility of law and public opinion
disembodiment from time and space
Beck
risk society= preoccupied with future
uncertainties and generate hazards and insecurities
Appadurai
alternatives to nation-state: media, migrants
diasporic public spheres - transnational cultural groups
Bauman
trade-off
forego freedom for benefits of increased individual security
“stranger”
socsci
enlightenment was the creation of a new framework of ideas about man, society and nature that
challenged existing concepcionts rooted in the traditional view dominated by christianity
cultural innovations in writing, printing, painting, music, sculpture and the art; technological innovations
framed social theories
universalised human knowledge bc specialised disciplines
first to last quarter of 18th century
france, european states
philosophes - man of letters who is a freethinker, cosmopolitans, citizens of an enlightened intellectual
world
a general process of society awakening from the dark slumbers of superstition and ignorance
science was the supreme form of knowledge, based on experiment and observation
encyclopedie - man realising his potential through the use of his mind
instructive and grand
universalistic
refusal to accept anything uncritically
moral science/socio - human conditions as prelude to emancipation of man from ties of superstition,
ignorance ideology and feudal social relationships
Communication
– new secular intelligentsia and give role of the intellectual a social and cultural base independent of trad
institutions, represented change in the way in which ideas were created, disseminated and was a truly
modern intellectual movement; propagation depended upon the creation of secular and cross-cultural
forms of communication
– academy, journal, conference
19th and 20th centuries - gulf emerged between natural and social sciences
naturalism - notion that cause and effect sequences in the natural world fully explain social phenomena
control of prejudice
Enlightenment
new framework of ideas
confidence in intellectual powers
mathematical and scientific laws
cultural movement
18th century, France, freethinkers/philosophes, cosmopolitanism=eurocentrism
Elements
1. Anti-clericalism
Christianity: control of knowledge production, dissemination, ideological legitimation for exercise of
absolute power
absolute power
SOCIAL SCIENCE
newton: knowledge and practices-science
moral sciences - moral phil from theo
naturalism - cause and effect explain social phenomena
control of prejudice - preventing value judgments
characteristics
1. scientific methods - human institutions
2. cultural relativism - human is uniform, varied in response to local conditions
– impersonal and privileged legal or constitutional order with the capability of administering and
controlling a given territory; distinct for of public power, separate from ruler and ruled forming the
supreme political authority within certain defined boundaries
– civil society - private/voluntary arrangements between individuals and groups outside the direct control
of the state
city-state/polis- east, Mesopotamia
europe- creation of many complex processes at the intersection of internal, external forces and relations
absolutism
– infrastructural strengths vs despotism
– created urself a momentum toward the development of new forms and limits of soft power: reciprocity
between governors and governed, influencing rulers; surveillance and social relations
– international law = westphalian model
– separate and discrete political orders with no common authority
modern state
– from absolutism and interstate system
– nation-states - political apparatuses distinct from ruler and ruled, with supreme jurisdiction over a
demarcated territorial area backed by a claim to a monopoly of coercive power and enjoying a minimum
level of support or loyalty from citizens
1. territoriality
2. control of the means of violence - pacification of people
3. impersonal structure of power
4. legitimacy - not divine right, active citizens of a new order
Forms
1. Constitutionalism/constitutional state - limits on decision-making; procedural(specifying
decisions)/substansive (blocking changes); safeguard rights and liberties of citizens
2. liberal state - private sphere independent of state, civil society from interference and delimiting state’s
authority; constitutionalism, private property, competitive market economy, patriarchal family
3. liberal or representative democracy - elected officers representing interests of citizens within rule of law,
sub-group of representatives
4. one-party or single party polity
– the more costly and demanding war became, rulers had to bargain for and win support of subjects
– more people were drawn into war preps, aware of membership in a political community and rights and
obligations
– nationalism was a force in the development of democratic nation-states; administrative unification of
state
– national identies = struggle for membership in the new political communities, struggle by elites and
governments to create new identity to legitimise state actions; gain state power
CAPITALISM
world-system
world-empires - political units, imperial bureaucracies, armies
world-ecoomies - economic unit that transcended the boundaries of political structures
SOVEREIGNTY
16th century
sovereignty-theory of legitimate power/authority
state sovereignty - state with ultimate authority to define public right
popular socereighty - people’s will, direct determination by the public
Hobbes
– all-powerful sovereign capable of securing the conditions of peaceful and commodious living
– self-perpetuating, undivided and absolute
– safety of the people
– where sovereign authority lay?
– proper form and limits?
Rosseau
– people
– enactment of law according to standards and requirements of the common good
– public discourse and agreement
– citizens-> general will- common good
Locke
– government - defence of life, liberty and estate
– individual rights as gained down by God’s will and law
– constitutional state in which public power is legally circumscribed and divided
– people = final judges
– wherever law ends, tyranny behind
– governmental supremacy = delegated on trust
Mill
– governors must be accountable to the governed through political mechanisms which alone can give
citizens the satisfactory means for choosing, authorising and controlling political decisions
Weber
– critic of Marxsm
– territoriality and violence
– monolozying the legitimate use of violence within a given territory
– legitimacy - commitment to a code of legal regulations
– administrative apparatuses
SUMMARY
– intersection of national nd international
– subjects, citizens; states system and international economy
– supreme = waging war, economic resources and claims to legitimacy
– went to war to enhance economic activity for legitimation
– system of organisations and relations which can make ands have socio, political and economic changes
– system of power in its own rights
MODERN STATE
Absolutism
capacity for surveillance extended admin power
dependence on cooperative forms of social relations; reciprocity
inter-state integration
sovereignty and inter-state integration
westpahlia: sovereign , equal, national interest, non-interference
impersonal structure: supreme jurisdiction over territory, political rights, obligations and duties are not
tied to property, religion, nobility
capitalism
war for capitalist expansion and legitimation
diffusion of power through sea-going military and commercial endeavours
weber
feared that pol life would be ensured by a rationalised, bureaucracy
Role of absolutism
instrumental in forging the modern states
expansion of the capacity for surveillance (i.e. collection and storing of info and the supervision of
populations) extended the administrative power of the state
dependence on cooperative forms of social relations; reciprocity between governors and governed;
more opportunities to influence leaders
for it to succeed, it has to be seen as legitimate; authority has to be constantly won
inter-state integration mutual recognition of sovereignty (i.e. state should have equal rights to self-
determination)
key innovations
1. territoriality - exact borders
2. control of the means of violence - legitimate use of force, necessitated the “pacification of peoples”or
the breaking down of rival centres of power and authority in the nation-state
3. impersonal structure of power - a legally circumscribed structure of power with supreme jurisdiction
over a territory; challenges the notion that political rights, obligations and duties are tied to property
What makes the nation integral to the nation-state is not the existence of sentiments of nationalism (i.e.
sharing a strong linguistic, religious and symbolic identity) but the unification of an administrative apparatus
over precisely defined territorial boundaries”
not just sentiments of nationalism
Notions of sovereignty?
– whole small-scale and piecemeal; industry was labour intensive and skill intensive, work-unit of
household
– wool, leather, building, cotton
– end of 18th, commerce
– nascent consumerism, pre-modern industries
– pre-industrial
19th century- flexibility and technological innovation
20th
– service sector
– tech innovation
– post-industrial society
MODERN ECONOMY
Adam Smith
– high priest of capitalism
– invisible hand - economic activities of profit-seeking individuals result in the greatest economic good for
society
– fundamental harmony of interests between the activities of profit-seeking individuals and general good
of society
Self-interest
– need to save and increase the stock of capital so that production can be expanded
– better condition
– vanity not ease/pleasure that interests us
– positional goods - can’t be owned by a large number of people without losing something of their appeal
David Ricardo
– income between 3 classes: landlord, capitalist, labourers; rent, profits, wages
Karl Marx
– wealth of nations- ideological defence of capitalism
– irreconcilable conflict of interest between capital and labor (capitalism)
– exploitation of working class and revolutionary to overthrow capitalist system
conclusion
– theory of invisible hand as an account of capitalist market mechanism
– division of labor as explanation of the sources of increased productiveness
– pervasiveness and strength of motive to better one’s condition as a spur to individual profit-seeking
behaviour
natural liberty
– economic agents would choose how to use economic property, would best promote country’s opulence
– agriculture first then domestic manufactures, foreign trade
summary
– wealth of nations- signpost for emerging liberal capitalist oder
– but writings do not unambiguously lend support to the interpretation; system of natural liberty based on
natural progress of opulence fro agriculture to manufactures to commerce
– works can be understood in terms of discourses of the enlightenment period
main features
1. population increased and urban areas grew
1. population increased and urban areas grew
2. improvement of canals and roads whichh reduced travel time
3. improved communications
4. development of retailing and advertising
5. emphasis of politeness, refined way of life
Division of Labor
made possible an enormous increase in the productivity of labor in opulent countries
rationalisation of processes geared toward the promotion of efficiency, productivity, calculability,
uniformity and control
creation of bureaucratic insitutiotns
Self-interest
need to save and increase the stock of capital so that production can be expanded
ambition is based on a person’s desire to be approved by others (vanity)
not the pursuit of riches and luxuries for own sake, but the effect which the possession of these items
will have on other people
David Ricardo
distribution of income in 3 main classes of society
theory of comparative advantage: industry specialisation and free trade]
marx
smith=defense of capitalism
conflict of interest between capital and labor
asymmetrical and exploitative econ relation during industrialisation
natural liberty
natural order of economic progression - preference of people, econ agents choose how they use
property
agriculture, domestic manufavures, foreign trade
The interpretation of social meanings that support, challenge or change the definitions, perspectives and
identities of social actors to the advantage of some and the disadvantage of others across state and society
culture industry not so much adapts to the reactions of its customers as it counterfeits them
I. Popular culture
– focuses on issues of race, ethnicity, class, gender, sexuality, cultural imperialism and censorship as
shaped by and redlgected in various mass media
– difference and hierarchy
Spivak's Subaltern
Wester academic thinking is produced in order to support western economical results
knowledge is like any other commodity that is exported from th west to the third world for financial and
other types of gain
data or raw material is harvested in the third world country and taken back to the west to be produced
and sold for the benefit of the western readers and especially the western writer
(domination=power, resistance=subordinate)
(domination=power, resistance=subordinate)
resistance- purview of the marginalised to challenge those in power
mounting, coordinating and sustaining this interaction
known repertoires of contention
EDSA
– prior to “peaceful revolution”, what led to EDSA was a violent atmosphere
– conditions are generated by
the power and the continued dominance of western ways of intellectual inquiry and the production of
knowledge in the academic, intellectual and cultural spheres of the de-colonized country
Globalisation
contemporary? irreversible, inevitable?
multidimensional, contested. need to problematic
increasing economic interdependence, accelerating flows
political economy: world-capitalist system
kimura
– asia is an object of globalisation
– asia is also a subject/agent - spurred the globalisation process
– PRE
– asia dominated the spice trade, trade routes, science and medicine
– the west only rose after they extracted silver form colonies and pried their way to asian markets
– japanese development pre-world war shaped globalised key parts of the world economy
– COLONIAL
– colonies are ‘laboraties of modernity’
– innovations in political form and social imaginary and in what defined the modern itself were not
european exports rather other way
– ex PH, colonial policing in the colony transformed both philippine polity and us national security
state
– Dutch East Indies: realm of intimate and personal influenced sexuality and social reform
– reemergence = restoration of traditional dominant position
– TODAy: china (money lending), india (textile), foreign workers and remittance, regional free trade
agreements and open regionalism
secularisation
– religion/tradition was undermined by rationality (Weber)
– religion in th private sphere
– not all states have undergone secularisation like PH, Shariah laws
–
– Religion is now a transnational force
– in a modern society, people can get disenchanted easily. we need mechanisms to ensure that that
social and moral fabric stays intact.
– Religion= collective effervescence (Durkheim)
– no post-secular society because religion has always been public ?? discourse
PERSPECTIVES ON GLOBALIZTION
Compression
– shrinking of the world
– not equated with universalism but interpenetration of universalism and particularism
Space-time & globalization
– global that supersedes the modern age - goes afte, as if modernity gave rice globalisation
– giddens and beck suggest specific historical trajectory that we can point to as global age or
globalisation
– but the problem is when we assign a specific trajectory, we lose sight that even before we label a point
modernization, maybe before it already has happened
– ongoing process that may have breached a certainn time period
– dialectic of deterritorialization and deterritorialization
theorizing religion
Globalization of religion
Globalization of religion
– spread of religions and specific genres
– mega churches
globalization and religion
– religion is a dynamic entity - it adapts, reshapes their institutional practices and mentalites
– atoned to the times
– church protects itself, but also church’s attempt to discourse on modernity
religion as transnational
– transnational transcendence
– religion becomes the central reference of immigrant communities
– exchange of practices, flows of narratives/ideas
interface between religion and culture
– ability of religion to mold into the fabric of different communities in ways that connect it intimately with
communal and local relations
– shedding of universal uniformity in favor of blending with locality
media acts as a conduit that disseminates and diffuses the practices beyond place of origin
nations are the result of imagined communities - media helps perpetuate this
while we are consumers of media, we have the capacity to interpret, recreate this globalisation of media
human agency - producers, through media we can also disseminate at varying degrees
mcluhan — global village - media helps facilitate
mumford - media as the influence to maintain status quo, playing field that reinforces power, not an
equal playing field to begin with