Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 81

Location from the left abutment (ft)

0
24
55
60
Analytical truck in situ (TRK)
origin 0 kip-f
MTRK+ (maximum positve moment location) 511 kip-f
MTRK- (negative sensors location) -156 kip-f
M-TRK_max_analytical (maximum negative moment location) -263 kip-f
Distance between center axle to max. neg. mom. loc. 36 f
Distance of the neg. sensor loc. to pier 5 f
Neg. mom. difference between sensor loc. and max. neg. mom. loc. 108 kip-f
Moment at negative sensor location -156 kip-f
STAT TRK 616 kip-ft

Analytical HS-20
origin 0 kip-f
MHS20+ (maximum positve moment location) 642 kip-f
MHS20- (negative sensors location) -229 kip-f
M-HS20_max_analytical (maximum negative moment location) -370 kip-f
Distance between center axle to max. neg. mom. loc. 36 f
Distance of the neg. sensor loc. to pier 5 f
Neg. mom. difference between sensor loc. and max. neg. mom. loc. 141 kip-f
Moment at negative sensor location -229 kip-f
STAT HS20 790 kip-ft
Analytical truck in situ (2 x TRK)
origin 0 kip-f
MTRK+ (maximum positve moment location) 1022 kip-f
MTRK- (negative sensors location) -311 kip-f
M-TRK_max_analytical (maximum negative moment location) -526 kip-f
Distance between center axle to max. neg. mom. loc. 36 f
Distance of the neg. sensor loc. to pier 5 f
Neg. mom. difference between sensor loc. and max. neg. mom. loc. 215 kip-f
Moment at negative sensor location -311 kip-f
STAT 2 x TRK 1232 kip-ft

Distribution factor
Spacing (S) 8.833 f
Span length (L) 60 f
slab thick. (ts) 8.5 in.
Modular ratio (n) 8.92 -
Girder depth 52.5 in.
Mom. of inertia (I) 16197.47 in.4
Area (A) 37.125 in.2
DF analytical used 0.805 -
I analytical 0.27 -
Analytical truck in situ (3 x TRK)
origin 0 kip-f
MTRK+ (maximum positve moment location) 1533 kip-f
MTRK- (negative sensors location) -467 kip-f
M-TRK_max_analytical (maximum negative moment location) -789 kip-f
Distance between center axle to max. neg. mom. loc. 36 f
Distance of the neg. sensor loc. to pier 5 f
Neg. mom. difference between sensor loc. and max. neg. mom. loc. 323 kip-f
Moment at negative sensor location -467 kip-f
STAT 3 x TRK 1849 kip-ft

Other parameters
MHS20+/MTRK analytical+ 1.26 -
LHS20 analytical = MHS20*DF analytical 516.81 kip-f
LHS20 analytical = MHS20*DF analytical*(1+I) 656.35 kip-f
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 1 -10.01 -0.32 0.00 -10.34 -0.34 -0.01 -0.49 -0.84

run 6 -0.36 -0.01 0.00 -0.37 18.88 0.71 27.74 47.33

∑ runs -10.37 -0.34 0.00 -10.70 18.54 0.70 27.24 46.49

DF ∑ runs -0.026 0.115

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
15.26 0.57 22.42 38.25 75.57 2.87 44.53 122.97 166.23 5.76 98.12
sum =
50.12 1.89 73.63 125.63 89.23 3.39 52.57 145.19 43.65 1.51 25.77
sum =

sum =
65.38 2.46 96.05 163.89 164.80 6.26 97.10 268.16 209.88 7.28 123.89
∑ runs =
0.405 0.663

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
808.88 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-189.87 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 263.69
-350.96 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 1.960
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 263.69
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 263.69
31 f
36 f
1159.83 kip-f
-350.96 kip-f
949.26 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
270.11 0.22 0.01 0.00 0.23 0.22 0.01 0.28 0.51 -2.03
420.15
70.94 -6.18 -0.16 0.00 -6.34 0.22 0.01 0.28 0.51 -18.85
388.72

0.00
341.04 -5.96 -0.15 0.00 -6.11 0.44 0.01 0.57 1.02 -20.88
808.88
0.843

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 949.26
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 331.90
kip-f MT (critical) 341.04
kip-f Mg (critical) 209.88
kip-f Ms (critical) 7.28
Nxa (critical) 123.89
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.843
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.06 -2.63 -4.72 -19.42 -0.59 -10.07 -30.08 -35.25 -1.22 -20.81
sum =
-0.56 -24.37 -43.78 -26.82 -0.81 -13.91 -41.55 -4.54 -0.16 -2.68
sum =

sum =
-0.63 -27.00 -48.50 -46.24 -1.40 -23.99 -71.63 -39.79 -1.38 -23.49
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-57.27
-91.34
-7.38
-98.53

0.00
-64.65
-189.87

0.973
1.298
1.590
1.022
0.955

1.960
girder 5
1.232
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 2 -8.17 -0.26 0.00 -8.44 3.07 0.12 4.51 7.70

run 7 2.80 0.09 0.00 2.89 24.93 0.94 36.63 62.51

∑ runs -5.37 -0.17 0.00 -5.55 28.01 1.05 41.15 70.21

DF ∑ runs -0.013 0.167

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
22.19 0.84 32.59 55.61 85.09 3.23 50.14 138.47 133.96 4.64 79.08
sum =
66.75 2.51 98.07 167.34 91.74 3.49 54.05 149.28 30.32 1.05 17.90
sum =

sum =
88.94 3.35 130.67 222.96 176.83 6.72 104.19 287.75 164.28 5.69 96.97
∑ runs =
0.529 0.683

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
842.31 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-196.61 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 222.17
-364.18 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 2.326
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 222.17
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 222.17
31 f
36 f
1206.49 kip-f
-364.18 kip-f
987.98 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
217.68 0.61 0.02 0.00 0.63 -0.26 -0.01 -0.34 -0.61 -4.58
411.03
49.26 1.18 0.03 0.00 1.21 -5.55 -0.17 -7.18 -12.89 -21.41
431.28

0.00
266.95 1.79 0.05 0.00 1.84 -5.81 -0.17 -7.51 -13.50 -25.99
842.31
0.634

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 987.98
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 279.89
kip-f MT (critical) 287.75
kip-f Mg (critical) 176.83
kip-f Ms (critical) 6.72
Nxa (critical) 104.19
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.683
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.14 -5.93 -10.65 -23.75 -0.72 -12.32 -36.79 -26.37 -0.91 -15.57
sum =
-0.64 -27.68 -49.73 -26.19 -0.79 -13.59 -40.57 -2.68 -0.09 -1.58
sum =

sum =
-0.78 -33.61 -60.38 -49.95 -1.51 -25.91 -77.36 -29.05 -1.01 -17.15
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-42.85
-90.27
-4.36
-106.34

0.00
-47.21
-196.61

0.973
1.247
1.589
1.024
1.178

2.326
girder 4
1.464
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 3 -6.53 -0.21 0.00 -6.74 5.92 0.22 8.70 14.84

run 8 9.43 0.31 0.00 9.73 35.62 1.34 52.34 89.30

∑ runs 2.90 0.09 0.00 2.99 41.54 1.56 61.04 104.14

DF ∑ runs 0.007 0.243

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
30.35 1.14 44.59 76.08 97.88 3.72 57.67 159.27 106.88 3.70 63.09
sum =
76.41 2.88 112.26 191.54 72.91 2.77 42.96 118.64 19.11 0.66 11.28
sum =

sum =
106.76 4.02 156.85 267.62 170.79 6.49 100.63 277.91 125.99 4.37 74.37
∑ runs =
0.624 0.648

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
857.39 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-205.49 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 214.57
-376.92 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 2.409
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 214.57
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 214.57
31 f
36 f
1234.30 kip-f
-376.92 kip-f
1008.15 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
173.67 0.88 0.02 0.00 0.90 -0.75 -0.02 -0.97 -1.75 -7.84
417.11
31.05 0.35 0.01 0.00 0.36 -9.32 -0.28 -12.05 -21.64 -23.95
440.27

0.00
204.72 1.23 0.03 0.00 1.26 -10.07 -0.30 -13.02 -23.39 -31.79
857.39
0.478

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1008.15
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 270.99
kip-f MT (critical) 277.91
kip-f Mg (critical) 170.79
kip-f Ms (critical) 6.49
Nxa (critical) 100.63
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.648
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.23 -10.13 -18.20 -28.22 -0.85 -14.64 -43.71 -19.20 -0.67 -11.33
sum =
-0.72 -30.97 -55.63 -21.57 -0.65 -11.19 -33.42 -0.74 -0.03 -0.44
sum =

sum =
-0.95 -41.10 -73.84 -49.79 -1.50 -25.83 -77.12 -19.94 -0.69 -11.77
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-31.20
-93.96
-1.20
-111.53

0.00
-32.40
-205.49

0.975
1.222
1.589
1.024
1.242

2.409
girder 4
1.516
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 4 -4.82 -0.16 0.00 -4.97 9.29 0.35 13.65 23.29

run 9 22.06 0.72 0.00 22.78 52.46 1.98 77.08 131.52

∑ runs 17.25 0.56 0.00 17.81 61.75 2.32 90.73 154.81

DF ∑ runs 0.040 0.352

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
40.11 1.51 58.93 100.55 107.00 4.07 63.05 174.11 85.02 2.95 50.19
sum =
78.47 2.95 115.28 196.70 51.22 1.95 30.18 83.35 9.03 0.31 5.33
sum =

sum =
118.57 4.46 174.21 297.25 158.22 6.01 93.23 257.46 94.06 3.26 55.52
∑ runs =
0.675 0.585

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
880.16 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-213.32 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 148.97
-389.68 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.469
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 148.97
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 148.97
31 f
36 f
1269.85 kip-f
-389.68 kip-f
1036.04 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
138.16 1.08 0.03 0.00 1.11 -1.48 -0.04 -1.91 -3.44 -12.27
431.13
14.68 -1.26 -0.03 0.00 -1.30 -14.41 -0.43 -18.63 -33.46 -24.36
449.03

0.00
152.84 -0.18 0.00 0.00 -0.19 -15.88 -0.48 -20.54 -36.90 -36.63
880.16
0.347

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1036.04
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 290.15
kip-f MT (critical) 297.25
kip-f Mg (critical) 118.57
kip-f Ms (critical) 4.46
Nxa (critical) 174.21
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.675
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.37 -15.86 -28.49 -30.53 -0.92 -15.83 -47.28 -14.31 -0.50 -8.44
sum =
-0.73 -31.50 -56.59 -13.85 -0.42 -7.19 -21.46 0.52 0.02 0.31
sum =

sum =
-1.10 -47.36 -85.09 -44.38 -1.34 -23.02 -68.74 -13.79 -0.48 -8.14
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-23.25
-101.35
0.84
-111.97

0.00
-22.40
-213.32

0.976
1.190
2.469
1.015
1.192

3.469
girder 3
1.405
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 5 -3.20 -0.10 0.00 -3.30 13.46 0.51 19.77 33.73

run 10 34.00 1.10 0.00 35.10 63.56 2.39 93.38 159.33

∑ runs 30.80 1.00 0.00 31.80 77.01 2.90 113.15 193.06

DF ∑ runs 0.071 0.432

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
48.10 1.81 70.67 120.59 106.63 4.05 62.83 173.51 66.68 2.31 39.36
sum =
75.34 2.84 110.68 188.86 41.99 1.60 24.74 68.32 5.24 0.18 3.09
sum =

sum =
123.44 4.65 181.36 309.45 148.61 5.65 87.57 241.83 71.92 2.49 42.45
∑ runs =
0.693 0.542

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
893.00 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-216.61 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 155.09
-395.58 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.332
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 155.09
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 155.09
31 f
36 f
1288.58 kip-f
-395.58 kip-f
1051.23 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
108.35 1.46 0.04 0.00 1.50 -2.23 -0.07 -2.89 -5.19 -16.10
432.88
8.51 -3.59 -0.09 0.00 -3.68 -16.97 -0.51 -21.94 -39.42 -23.19
460.12

0.00
116.86 -2.12 -0.05 0.00 -2.18 -19.21 -0.57 -24.83 -44.62 -39.29
893.00
0.262

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1051.23
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 302.09
kip-f MT (critical) 309.45
kip-f Mg (critical) 123.44
kip-f Ms (critical) 4.65
Nxa (critical) 181.36
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.693
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.48 -20.82 -37.41 -31.32 -0.95 -16.25 -48.52 -9.93 -0.34 -5.86
sum =
-0.69 -29.98 -53.87 -10.06 -0.30 -5.22 -15.58 1.04 0.04 0.61
sum =

sum =
-1.18 -50.80 -91.27 -41.38 -1.25 -21.47 -64.10 -8.89 -0.31 -5.25
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-16.14
-105.75
1.69
-110.86

0.00
-14.45
-216.61

0.976
1.172
2.469
1.015
1.162

3.332
girder 3
1.350
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 6 -0.43 -0.01 0.00 -0.44 19.07 0.72 28.02 47.80

run 11 46.92 1.52 0.00 48.44 69.93 2.63 102.74 175.30

∑ runs 46.49 1.51 0.00 47.99 89.00 3.35 130.76 223.11

DF ∑ runs 0.110 0.513

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
56.75 2.14 83.38 142.27 99.67 3.79 58.73 162.19 43.55 1.51 25.71
sum =
68.58 2.58 100.75 171.91 30.42 1.16 17.92 49.50 1.26 0.04 0.75
sum =

sum =
125.33 4.72 184.13 314.18 130.09 4.94 76.65 211.69 44.81 1.55 26.45
∑ runs =
0.722 0.487

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
869.79 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-213.86 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 157.46
-388.64 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.282
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 157.46
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 157.46
31 f
36 f
1258.43 kip-f
-388.64 kip-f
1025.25 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
70.77 1.48 0.04 0.00 1.52 -3.92 -0.12 -5.07 -9.10 -19.86
422.59
2.05 -7.02 -0.18 0.00 -7.20 -18.98 -0.57 -24.55 -44.10 -20.27
447.20

0.00
72.82 -5.54 -0.14 0.00 -5.68 -22.90 -0.69 -29.61 -53.20 -40.13
869.79
0.167

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1025.25
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 307.11
kip-f MT (critical) 314.18
kip-f Mg (critical) 125.33
kip-f Ms (critical) 4.72
Nxa (critical) 184.13
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.722
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.59 -25.67 -46.13 -28.60 -0.86 -14.84 -44.30 -5.41 -0.19 -3.19
sum =
-0.61 -26.21 -47.09 -6.74 -0.20 -3.49 -10.43 1.08 0.04 0.64
sum =

sum =
-1.20 -51.88 -93.21 -35.34 -1.07 -18.33 -54.74 -4.32 -0.15 -2.55
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-8.79
-106.80
1.76
-107.06

0.00
-7.03
-213.86

0.977
1.202
2.469
1.015
1.114

3.282
girder 3
1.329
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 7 2.80 0.09 0.00 2.89 24.93 0.94 36.63 62.51

run 12 71.83 2.33 0.00 74.16 78.71 2.96 115.64 197.31

∑ runs 74.63 2.42 0.00 77.05 103.64 3.90 152.27 259.81

DF ∑ runs 0.175 0.589

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
66.75 2.51 98.07 167.34 91.74 3.49 54.05 149.28 30.32 1.05 17.90
sum =
58.58 2.21 86.07 146.86 21.99 0.84 12.96 35.78 -1.93 -0.07 -1.14
sum =

sum =
125.34 4.72 184.14 314.20 113.72 4.32 67.01 185.06 28.38 0.98 16.75
∑ runs =
0.712 0.420

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
882.24 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-213.92 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 157.47
-390.72 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.282
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 157.47
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 157.47
31 f
36 f
1272.96 kip-f
-390.72 kip-f
1038.52 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
49.26 1.18 0.03 0.00 1.21 -5.55 -0.17 -7.18 -12.89 -21.41
431.28
-3.14 -13.25 -0.34 0.00 -13.59 -21.09 -0.63 -27.27 -49.00 -17.25
450.95

0.00
46.12 -12.07 -0.31 0.00 -12.38 -26.64 -0.80 -34.45 -61.89 -38.66
882.24
0.105

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1038.52
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 306.72
kip-f MT (critical) 314.20
kip-f Mg (critical) 125.34
kip-f Ms (critical) 4.72
Nxa (critical) 184.14
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.712
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.64 -27.68 -49.73 -26.19 -0.79 -13.59 -40.57 -2.68 -0.09 -1.58
sum =
-0.52 -22.30 -40.07 -4.34 -0.13 -2.25 -6.73 1.11 0.04 0.66
sum =

sum =
-1.16 -49.99 -89.80 -30.53 -0.92 -15.84 -47.29 -1.57 -0.05 -0.93
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-4.36
-106.34
1.81
-107.58

0.00
-2.55
-213.92

0.976
1.187
2.469
1.015
1.130

3.282
girder 3
1.329
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 8 10.17 0.33 0.00 10.50 36.88 1.39 54.18 92.44

run 13 107.43 3.48 0.00 110.91 83.72 3.15 123.00 209.87

∑ runs 117.59 3.81 0.00 121.41 120.60 4.54 177.18 302.31

DF ∑ runs 0.272 0.678

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
77.39 2.91 113.70 194.00 71.54 2.72 42.15 116.40 18.53 0.64 10.94
sum =
44.78 1.69 65.79 112.25 13.91 0.53 8.20 22.63 -4.28 -0.15 -2.53
sum =

sum =
122.17 4.60 179.49 306.25 85.44 3.25 50.35 139.04 14.25 0.49 8.41
∑ runs =
0.687 0.312

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
892.16 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-217.71 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 153.49
-396.72 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.367
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 153.49
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 153.49
31 f
36 f
1288.88 kip-f
-396.72 kip-f
1050.85 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
30.11 0.28 0.01 0.00 0.28 -9.66 -0.29 -12.49 -22.44 -24.19
443.46
-6.96 -24.13 -0.62 0.00 -24.75 -22.00 -0.66 -28.44 -51.10 -12.00
448.71

0.00
23.15 -23.85 -0.62 0.00 -24.47 -31.66 -0.95 -40.94 -73.54 -36.20
892.16
0.052

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1050.85
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 299.14
kip-f MT (critical) 306.25
kip-f Mg (critical) 122.17
kip-f Ms (critical) 4.60
Nxa (critical) 179.49
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.687
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.72 -31.28 -56.20 -21.46 -0.65 -11.13 -33.24 -0.77 -0.03 -0.45
sum =
-0.36 -15.52 -27.88 -1.91 -0.06 -0.99 -2.95 1.13 0.04 0.67
sum =

sum =
-1.08 -46.80 -84.08 -23.37 -0.71 -12.12 -36.20 0.36 0.01 0.21
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-1.25
-112.85
1.83
-104.86

0.00
0.58
-217.71

0.977
1.173
2.469
1.015
1.173

3.367
girder 3
1.364
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 9 21.41 0.69 0.00 22.10 50.36 1.90 73.99 126.25

run 14 140.79 4.57 0.00 145.35 77.03 2.90 113.16 193.09

∑ runs 162.20 5.26 0.00 167.46 127.39 4.80 187.16 319.34

DF ∑ runs 0.392 0.748

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
75.57 2.84 111.03 189.44 50.25 1.91 29.61 81.77 8.88 0.31 5.24
sum =
31.52 1.19 46.31 79.02 7.55 0.29 4.45 12.28 -5.98 -0.21 -3.53
sum =

sum =
107.09 4.03 157.34 268.46 57.80 2.20 34.06 94.05 2.90 0.10 1.71
∑ runs =
0.629 0.220

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
854.03 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-209.74 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 160.05
-381.31 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.229
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 160.05
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 160.05
31 f
36 f
1235.34 kip-f
-381.31 kip-f
1006.56 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
14.44 -1.34 -0.03 0.00 -1.37 -14.00 -0.42 -18.10 -32.52 -23.95
434.00
-9.72 -35.63 -0.92 0.00 -36.55 -20.09 -0.60 -25.98 -46.67 -7.41
420.03

0.00
4.72 -36.96 -0.95 0.00 -37.92 -34.09 -1.02 -44.08 -79.19 -31.36
854.03
0.011

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1006.56
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 312.12
kip-f MT (critical) 319.34
kip-f Mg (critical) 127.39
kip-f Ms (critical) 4.80
Nxa (critical) 187.16
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.748
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.72 -30.97 -55.64 -13.64 -0.41 -7.07 -21.13 0.52 0.02 0.31
sum =
-0.22 -9.58 -17.20 -0.61 -0.02 -0.32 -0.95 0.88 0.03 0.52
sum =

sum =
-0.94 -40.55 -72.84 -14.25 -0.43 -7.39 -22.07 1.40 0.05 0.83
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
0.84
-109.81
1.44
-99.93

0.00
2.28
-209.74

0.977
1.224
2.469
1.015
1.076

3.229
girder 2
1.308
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 10 33.14 1.07 0.00 34.21 63.31 2.38 93.01 158.70

run 15 192.78 6.25 0.00 199.03 69.38 2.61 101.93 173.92

∑ runs 225.92 7.33 0.00 233.24 132.68 5.00 194.94 332.61

DF ∑ runs 0.530 0.756

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
75.87 2.86 111.46 190.18 41.83 1.59 24.65 68.07 5.29 0.18 3.13
sum =
22.35 0.84 32.84 56.04 3.13 0.12 1.84 5.09 -8.75 -0.30 -5.17
sum =

sum =
98.22 3.70 144.30 246.22 44.96 1.71 26.49 73.16 -3.46 -0.12 -2.04
∑ runs =
0.560 0.166

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
879.61 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-213.28 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 166.70
-389.55 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.100
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 166.70
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 166.70
31 f
36 f
1269.17 kip-f
-389.55 kip-f
1035.43 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
8.60 -3.66 -0.09 0.00 -3.76 -17.03 -0.51 -22.01 -39.55 -23.35
459.77
-14.22 -49.70 -1.28 0.00 -50.99 -18.22 -0.55 -23.56 -42.32 -4.24
419.85

0.00
-5.62 -53.37 -1.38 0.00 -54.74 -35.25 -1.06 -45.57 -81.87 -27.59
879.61
-0.013

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1035.43
kip-f ∑STAT A 1232.40
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 324.69
kip-f MT (critical) 332.61
kip-f Mg (critical) 132.68
kip-f Ms (critical) 5.00
Nxa (critical) 194.94
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.756
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 1.00
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.70 -30.20 -54.25 -10.17 -0.31 -5.27 -15.75 1.08 0.04 0.64
sum =
-0.13 -5.48 -9.84 0.01 0.00 0.01 0.02 0.87 0.03 0.51
sum =

sum =
-0.83 -35.67 -64.09 -10.16 -0.31 -5.27 -15.73 1.94 0.07 1.15
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
1.75
-111.55
1.41
-101.72

0.00
3.16
-213.28

0.976
1.190
2.469
1.015
1.064

3.100
girder 2
1.256
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 1 -9.96 -0.32 0.00 -10.28 -0.31 -0.01 -0.46 -0.78

run 6 -0.43 -0.01 0.00 -0.44 19.07 0.72 28.02 47.80

run 11 46.92 1.52 0.00 48.44 69.93 2.63 102.74 175.30

∑ runs 36.53 1.18 0.00 37.71 88.69 3.34 130.30 222.32

DF ∑ runs 0.088 0.520

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
15.17 0.57 22.28 38.02 73.83 2.81 43.50 120.13 163.44 5.67 96.48
sum =
56.75 2.14 83.38 142.27 99.67 3.79 58.73 162.19 43.55 1.51 25.71
sum =
68.58 2.58 100.75 171.91 30.42 1.16 17.92 49.50 1.26 0.04 0.75
sum =
140.50 5.29 206.42 352.20 203.92 7.75 120.15 331.82 208.26 7.22 122.93
∑ runs =
0.824 0.776

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
1282.47 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-302.50 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 158.86
-558.13 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.253
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 158.86
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 158.86
31 f
36 f
1840.60 kip-f
-558.13 kip-f
1505.72 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
265.59 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.22 0.01 0.28 0.50 -1.90
412.67
70.77 1.48 0.04 0.00 1.52 -3.92 -0.12 -5.07 -9.10 -19.86
422.59
2.05 -7.02 -0.18 0.00 -7.20 -18.98 -0.57 -24.55 -44.10 -20.27
447.20
338.41 -5.54 -0.14 0.00 -5.68 -22.68 -0.68 -29.33 -52.69 -42.02
1282.47
0.792

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1505.72
kip-f ∑STAT A 1848.60
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 342.92
kip-f MT (critical) 352.20
kip-f Mg (critical) 140.50
kip-f Ms (critical) 5.29
Nxa (critical) 206.42
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.824
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 0.90
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.06 -2.45 -4.40 -18.68 -0.56 -9.69 -28.94 -34.34 -1.19 -20.27
sum =
-0.59 -25.67 -46.13 -28.60 -0.86 -14.84 -44.30 -5.41 -0.19 -3.19
sum =
-0.61 -26.21 -47.09 -6.74 -0.20 -3.49 -10.43 1.08 0.04 0.64
sum =
-1.26 -54.33 -97.62 -54.02 -1.63 -28.02 -83.68 -38.66 -1.34 -22.82
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-55.80
-88.64
-8.79
-106.80
1.76
-107.06
-62.83
-302.50

0.974
1.228
2.469
1.015
1.086

3.253
girder 3
1.318
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 2 -8.33 -0.27 0.00 -8.60 3.00 0.11 4.41 7.53

run 7 2.80 0.09 0.00 2.89 24.93 0.94 36.63 62.51

run 12 71.83 2.33 0.00 74.16 78.71 2.96 115.64 197.31

∑ runs 66.30 2.15 0.00 68.45 106.64 4.01 156.68 267.34

DF ∑ runs 0.158 0.617

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
22.17 0.83 32.58 55.59 86.52 3.29 50.98 140.78 136.54 4.73 80.60
sum =
66.75 2.51 98.07 167.34 91.74 3.49 54.05 149.28 30.32 1.05 17.90
sum =
58.58 2.21 86.07 146.86 21.99 0.84 12.96 35.78 -1.93 -0.07 -1.14
sum =
147.51 5.55 216.72 369.79 200.24 7.61 117.99 325.84 164.93 5.72 97.35
∑ runs =
0.854 0.752

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
1299.42 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-306.57 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 166.79
-565.60 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.098
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 166.79
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 166.79
31 f
36 f
1865.02 kip-f
-565.60 kip-f
1525.66 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
221.88 0.63 0.02 0.00 0.64 -0.25 -0.01 -0.32 -0.57 -4.70
417.18
49.26 1.18 0.03 0.00 1.21 -5.55 -0.17 -7.18 -12.89 -21.41
431.28
-3.14 -13.25 -0.34 0.00 -13.59 -21.09 -0.63 -27.27 -49.00 -17.25
450.95
268.00 -11.44 -0.30 0.00 -11.74 -26.89 -0.81 -34.77 -62.46 -43.37
1299.42
0.619

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1525.66
kip-f ∑STAT A 1848.60
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 360.05
kip-f MT (critical) 369.79
kip-f Mg (critical) 147.51
kip-f Ms (critical) 5.55
Nxa (critical) 216.72
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.854
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 0.90
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.14 -6.08 -10.93 -24.31 -0.73 -12.61 -37.65 -27.17 -0.94 -16.04
sum =
-0.64 -27.68 -49.73 -26.19 -0.79 -13.59 -40.57 -2.68 -0.09 -1.58
sum =
-0.52 -22.30 -40.07 -4.34 -0.13 -2.25 -6.73 1.11 0.04 0.66
sum =
-1.30 -56.07 -100.73 -54.84 -1.66 -28.45 -84.94 -28.74 -1.00 -16.96
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-44.14
-92.65
-4.36
-106.34
1.81
-107.58
-46.70
-306.57

0.974
1.212
2.469
1.015
1.048

3.098
girder 3
1.255
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 3 -6.47 -0.21 0.00 -6.68 5.79 0.22 8.51 14.52

run 8 9.43 0.31 0.00 9.73 35.62 1.34 52.34 89.30

run 13 108.86 3.53 0.00 112.39 84.38 3.18 123.98 211.53

∑ runs 111.82 3.63 0.00 115.44 125.80 4.74 184.82 315.36

DF ∑ runs 0.266 0.725

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
29.91 1.13 43.94 74.98 96.87 3.68 57.08 157.62 105.52 3.66 62.29
sum =
76.41 2.88 112.26 191.54 72.91 2.77 42.96 118.64 19.11 0.66 11.28
sum =
44.78 1.69 65.79 112.26 13.98 0.53 8.24 22.75 -4.27 -0.15 -2.52
sum =
151.10 5.69 222.00 378.78 183.76 6.98 108.27 299.01 120.35 4.17 71.04
∑ runs =
0.871 0.688

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
1304.16 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-311.37 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 170.85
-571.94 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.025
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 170.85
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 170.85
31 f
36 f
1876.10 kip-f
-571.94 kip-f
1532.94 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
171.46 0.86 0.02 0.00 0.89 -0.77 -0.02 -0.99 -1.78 -7.82
411.90
31.05 0.35 0.01 0.00 0.36 -9.32 -0.28 -12.05 -21.64 -23.95
440.27
-6.94 -24.90 -0.64 0.00 -25.54 -22.13 -0.66 -28.61 -51.40 -12.03
451.99
195.56 -23.68 -0.61 0.00 -24.29 -32.21 -0.96 -41.65 -74.82 -43.80
1304.16
0.450

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1532.94
kip-f ∑STAT A 1848.60
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 369.22
kip-f MT (critical) 378.78
kip-f Mg (critical) 151.10
kip-f Ms (critical) 5.69
Nxa (critical) 222.00
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.871
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 0.90
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.23 -10.11 -18.16 -27.97 -0.85 -14.51 -43.33 -19.24 -0.67 -11.36
sum =
-0.72 -30.97 -55.63 -21.57 -0.65 -11.19 -33.42 -0.74 -0.03 -0.44
sum =
-0.36 -15.56 -27.95 -2.01 -0.06 -1.04 -3.12 1.11 0.04 0.66
sum =
-1.31 -56.63 -101.74 -51.56 -1.56 -26.74 -79.86 -18.87 -0.65 -11.14
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-31.26
-93.64
-1.20
-111.53
1.81
-106.20
-30.65
-311.37

0.975
1.206
2.469
1.015
1.027

3.025
girder 3
1.225
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 4 -4.82 -0.16 0.00 -4.97 9.29 0.35 13.65 23.29

run 9 22.06 0.72 0.00 22.78 52.46 1.98 77.08 131.52

run 14 143.18 4.64 0.00 147.82 76.36 2.87 112.18 191.41

∑ runs 160.43 5.20 0.00 165.63 138.11 5.20 202.91 346.22

DF ∑ runs 0.382 0.799

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
40.11 1.51 58.93 100.55 107.00 4.07 63.05 174.11 85.02 2.95 50.19
sum =
78.47 2.95 115.28 196.70 51.22 1.95 30.18 83.35 9.03 0.31 5.33
sum =
31.48 1.19 46.25 78.91 7.55 0.29 4.45 12.29 -6.15 -0.21 -3.63
sum =
150.05 5.65 220.46 376.16 165.77 6.30 97.68 269.75 87.91 3.05 51.89
∑ runs =
0.868 0.622

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
1300.60 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-311.73 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 169.67
-571.78 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.046
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 169.67
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 169.67
31 f
36 f
1872.38 kip-f
-571.78 kip-f
1529.31 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
138.16 1.08 0.03 0.00 1.11 -1.48 -0.04 -1.91 -3.44 -12.27
431.13
14.68 -1.26 -0.03 0.00 -1.30 -14.41 -0.43 -18.63 -33.46 -24.36
449.03
-10.00 -35.37 -0.91 0.00 -36.28 -19.73 -0.59 -25.51 -45.83 -7.22
420.43
142.84 -35.55 -0.92 0.00 -36.47 -35.61 -1.07 -46.04 -82.72 -43.85
1300.60
0.329

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1529.31
kip-f ∑STAT A 1848.60
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 366.80
kip-f MT (critical) 376.16
kip-f Mg (critical) 150.05
kip-f Ms (critical) 5.65
Nxa (critical) 220.46
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.868
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 0.90
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.37 -15.86 -28.49 -30.53 -0.92 -15.83 -47.28 -14.31 -0.50 -8.44
sum =
-0.73 -31.50 -56.59 -13.85 -0.42 -7.19 -21.46 0.52 0.02 0.31
sum =
-0.22 -9.34 -16.78 -0.57 -0.02 -0.30 -0.88 0.84 0.03 0.49
sum =
-1.31 -56.70 -101.87 -44.95 -1.36 -23.32 -69.62 -12.95 -0.45 -7.64
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-23.25
-101.35
0.84
-111.97
1.36
-98.41
-21.04
-311.73

0.975
1.209
2.469
1.015
1.031

3.046
girder 3
1.234
Girder 1 Girder 2
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
run 5 -3.18 -0.10 0.00 -3.28 13.17 0.50 19.35 33.01

run 10 33.14 1.07 0.00 34.21 63.31 2.38 93.01 158.70

run 15 192.78 6.25 0.00 199.03 69.38 2.61 101.93 173.92

∑ runs 222.74 7.22 0.00 229.96 145.85 5.49 214.28 365.62

DF ∑ runs 0.528 0.840

Location from the left abutment (ft) Experimental ∑ runs


0 origin
33.6 ΣMT+ (maximum positve moment location)
76 ΣMT- (negative sensors location)
84 M-max_exp. (maximum negative moment location)
Distance of the maximum positive moment position to lef abutment
Distance of the negative sensor location to pier
Length of first span
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and negative sensor loc.
Distance between max positive mom. pos. and max negative mom. pos.
Difference between max. positive moment and max. negative moment
Max. negative moment
STAT E ∑ runs
Positive region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
46.71 1.76 68.63 117.10 105.30 4.00 62.05 171.35 66.41 2.30 39.20
sum =
75.87 2.86 111.46 190.18 41.83 1.59 24.65 68.07 5.29 0.18 3.13
sum =
22.35 0.84 32.84 56.04 3.13 0.12 1.84 5.09 -8.75 -0.30 -5.17
sum =
144.93 5.46 212.93 363.32 150.26 5.71 88.54 244.51 62.95 2.18 37.16
∑ runs =
0.835 0.562

Initial parameters
0 kip-f MHS20/MTRK analytical 1.26
1305.71 kip-f LHS20 analytical 516.81
-317.89 kip-f LHS20 experimental = MHS20/MTRK*Mg critical 164.92
-579.77 kip-f Experimental RF/Analytical RF 3.134
24 f LHS20 experimental double check formula (assume impact =1.0) 164.92
5 f MHS20 642.00
60 f LHS20 experimental another check 164.92
31 f
36 f
1885.48 kip-f
-579.77 kip-f
1537.62 kip-ft
Negative region
der 5 Girder 1 Girder 2 Girder 3
Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
107.91 1.29 0.03 0.00 1.32 -2.16 -0.06 -2.79 -5.01 -15.82
426.10
8.60 -3.66 -0.09 0.00 -3.76 -17.03 -0.51 -22.01 -39.55 -23.35
459.77
-14.22 -49.70 -1.28 0.00 -50.99 -18.22 -0.55 -23.56 -42.32 -4.24
419.85
102.29 -52.08 -1.34 0.00 -53.42 -37.40 -1.12 -48.36 -86.89 -43.41
1305.71
0.235

Other parameters
- ∑STAT E 1537.62
kip-f ∑STAT A 1848.60
kip-f MTRK+ 511.00
- MLE+ (critical) 357.06
kip-f MT (critical) 365.62
kip-f Mg (critical) 145.85
kip-f Ms (critical) 5.49
Nxa (critical) 214.28
DF analytical 0.805
DF experimental 0.840
Multi-presence coefficient (MPC) 0.90
Negative region
Girder 3 Girder 4 Girder 5
Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a Mt Mg Ms N*a
(kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f) (kip-f)
-0.47 -20.46 -36.75 -31.03 -0.94 -16.10 -48.07 -9.91 -0.34 -5.85
sum =
-0.70 -30.20 -54.25 -10.17 -0.31 -5.27 -15.75 1.08 0.04 0.64
sum =
-0.13 -5.48 -9.84 0.01 0.00 0.01 0.02 0.87 0.03 0.51
sum =
-1.30 -56.13 -100.84 -41.19 -1.24 -21.37 -63.80 -7.97 -0.28 -4.70
∑ runs =

Contribution factors
kip-f Long. distribution factor MLE/MT
kip-f Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings ∑STAT A/∑STAT E
kip-f Unintended composite action factor (Mg+N*a)/Mg
kip-f Deck flexure factor MT/(Mg+N*a)
kip-f Lateral distribution factor DF A/(DF E*MPC)
kip-f
kip-f
kip-f
- Load rating results
- Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating
- Critical girder
Experimental load rating/Analytical load rating - removing unin. composite action
der 5
Mt
(kip-f)
-16.11
-104.62
1.75
-111.55
1.41
-101.72
-12.95
-317.89

0.977
1.202
2.469
1.015
1.065

3.134
girder 2
1.269
Run combinations - 2 tr
Contribution factors runs 1+6 runs 2+7 runs 3+8 runs 4+9
Longitudinal distribution factor 0.973 0.973 0.975 0.976
Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings 1.298 1.247 1.222 1.190
Unintended composite action factor 1.590 1.589 1.589 2.469
Deck flexure factor 1.022 1.024 1.024 1.015
Lateral distribution factor 0.955 1.178 1.242 1.192
Experimental/Analytical load rating 1.960 2.326 2.409 3.469
Critical girder girder 5 girder 4 girder 4 girder 3
Exp./Analy. load rating - remove composite action 1.232 1.464 1.516 1.405

Run combinations - 3 trucks side by side


Contribution factors runs 1+6+11 runs 2+7+12 runs 3+8+13 runs 4+9+14
Longitudinal distribution factor 0.974 0.974 0.975 0.975
Add. stiffness factor - curbs and railings 1.228 1.212 1.206 1.209
Unintended composite action factor 2.469 2.469 2.469 2.469
Deck flexure factor 1.015 1.015 1.015 1.015
Lateral distribution factor 1.086 1.048 1.027 1.031
Experimental/Analytical load rating 3.253 3.098 3.025 3.046
Critical girder girder 3 girder 3 girder 3 girder 3
Exp./Analy. load rating - remove composite action 1.318 1.255 1.225 1.234
Run combinations - 2 trucks side by side
runs 5+10 runs 6+11 runs 7+12 runs 8+13 runs 9+14 runs 10+15
0.976 0.977 0.976 0.977 0.977 0.976
1.172 1.202 1.187 1.173 1.224 1.190
2.469 2.469 2.469 2.469 2.469 2.469
1.015 1.015 1.015 1.015 1.015 1.015
1.162 1.114 1.130 1.173 1.076 1.064
3.332 3.282 3.282 3.367 3.229 3.100
girder 3 girder 3 girder 3 girder 3 girder 2 girder 2
1.350 1.329 1.329 1.364 1.308 1.256

side by side
runs 5+10+15
0.977
1.202
2.469
1.015
1.065
3.134
girder 2
1.269

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi