Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Fuel
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/fuel
A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T
Keywords: The inevitable rise in the usage of plastic poses a serious threat to the environment owing to their non-biode-
Waste plastic gradable nature. The lack of proper infrastructure for treating and recycling plastic wastes give rise to the
CRDI engine disposal problem. However, the oil synthesized from these waste plastics can be used as an alternative fuel for C.I
EGR engines which not only helps to tackle the disposal problem but also aids in recovering precious energy from
Combustion
these wastes. This experimental investigation aims to study the effects of plastic-diesel blend(P30) fuel on the
Performance
performance, emission and combustion characteristics of a twin cylinder CRDI engine operating at different EGR
Emission
rates (0%, 10% & 20%). The experimental results showed a slight drop in the engine performance while oper-
ating with plastic blend, mainly overall due to its higher viscosity and lower heating value. The vast upsurge of
NOX emissions with plastic blend was mitigated by the aid of EGR methodology. Marginal increase in the dis-
charge of regulated emissions like HC, CO and soot were noticed for both plastic blend as well as EGR operations.
The experiments were carried out for five different loading conditions varying from 0% to 80% in steps of 20%
each and found out that waste plastic-diesel blend can be successfully used as an alternative fuel in diesel
vehicles without any prior modifications in the engine.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: archit_9325@yahoo.com (A.S. Ayodhya), gnkumar33@gmail.com (G.N. Kumar).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fuel.2018.04.128
Received 27 February 2017; Received in revised form 25 January 2018; Accepted 25 April 2018
0016-2361/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
A.S. Ayodhya et al. Fuel 227 (2018) 394–400
Nomenclature HC hydrocarbon
BHC unburned hydrocarbon
C.I compression ignition DF diesel fuel
CRDI common rail direct injection WPO waste plastic oil
EGR exhaust gas recirculation P30 30% waste plastic oil + 70% diesel fuel
NOX nitrogen oxides ECU electronic control unit
NO nitric oxide BTDC before top dead center
NO2 nitrogen dioxide CA Crank angle
H2O water BTE brake thermal efficiency
CO carbon monoxide HRR heat release rate
CO2 carbon dioxide EGT exhaust gas temperature
EGR is usually accompanied by aggravated engine performance and 2.1. Fuel properties and extraction
marginal rise in the regulated emissions [14], hence the percentage of
exhaust gases to be re-circulated is necessary to optimize. The conversion of waste plastic into useful fuel occurs through the
After going through the literature it has been found that no research pyrolysis process. This process involves anaerobic thermal degradation
work has been carried out related to high pressure (100 MPa) plastic of waste plastics into three products: solid, liquid and gaseous. The exit
fuel injection. Therefore, this work attempts to improve the perfor- gas from the reactor is condensed using a series of condensers and this
mance, combustion& emission characteristics by incorporating waste condensed liquid is used as a fuel for experimental investigations. The
plastic oil blend in a high injection pressure diesel engine under EGR properties of the pyrolysis products depend on the type of plastic feed to
operation. the reactor and process parameters such as temperature, catalyst and
residence time [15,16].
The various fuel properties as presented in Table 2 were in-
2. Experimental setup and methodology vestigated using standard instruments as per ASTM standards.
The instruments were calibrated as per the manufacturer’s manual. 2.2. Error analysis
The schematic description of the experimental setup is shown in Fig. 1.
A dual cylinder, 4-stroke CRDI diesel engine coupled with an open ECU Estimation of uncertainties and error is essential while conducting
(NIRA) was used for the experimental investigation which was loaded any experimental investigation. Uncertainties may appear because of
by eddy current type dynamometer; specifications of the engine are several factors like: environmental conditions, calibration, observation,
given in Table 1. Measurement of combustion pressure at each crank instrument selection and incorrect reading. Error analysis quantifies the
angle was made by M108A02 PCB piezotronics make pressure trans- accuracy of the experiments being performed. The uncertainties of
ducer which utilized the average values of 100 completed cycles as dependent parameters like brake power, fuel consumption and brake
pressure data for the calculation of combustion parameters. The engine thermal efficiency were computed by partial differentiation method
speed was determined by a rotary encoder which displayed the mea- using the uncertainty percentages of various instruments as shown in
sured value in rpm on a digital indicator. Fuel flow consumption was Table 3. The uncertainties for independent parameters were found by
recorded on volume basis with the help of a burette and a stop-watch. calculating the mean, standard deviation & standard error for the re-
K-type thermocouples were installed for the purpose of exhaust gas peated set of 20 readings.
temperature measurement. Suitable manometers and rotameters were The total uncertainty of the experimental investigation is,
mounted for interfacing airflow and cooling water flow rate. A Labview
based software package “Enginesoft” is also provided for online per- = Square root of {(uncertainty of CO)2 + (uncertainty of
formance evaluation. HC)2 + (uncertainty of NO)2 + (uncertainty of
The exhaust gas recirculation unit is managed by an arrangement soot)2 + (uncertainty of load)2 + (uncertainty of
consisting of ECU, vacuum pump and a solenoid valve. The ECU as per speed)2 + (uncertainty of time)2 + (uncertainty of brake
the input given by the user sends signals to the vacuum pump which power)2 + (uncertainty of fuel consumption)2 + (uncertainty of
operates the solenoid valve. The solenoid valve regulates the flow of brake thermal efficiency)2}
exhaust gases to be recirculated in proportion to the signals fed by the = Square root of {(0.1)2 + (0.8)2 + (0.1)2 + (1.7)2 + (0.1)2
ECU to the vacuum pump. It also uses an electrical actuator for precise + (0.1)2 + (0.9)2 + (0.1)2 + (1)2 + (1.1)2}
valve control. = ± 2.5%.
AVL DI Gas 444 gas analyser with recommended filters was made
use of to measure the concentrations of unburned hydrocarbons (HC),
2.3. FT-IR of waste plastic oil
carbon monoxide (CO) and nitric oxide (NO) in the exhaust line. It
measures CO in percentage volumes whereas HC & NO in ppm. Smoke
FTIR analysis gives a brief idea about the presence of various func-
opacity was measured using an AVL 437 smoke meter.
tional groups in the fuel sample. This method categorizes the chemical
The engine performance, combustion and emission data were noted
bonds in a molecule by generating an infrared absorption spectrum results
for different loads varying from 0% to 80% in steps of 20% at a constant
for several functional groups present in the waste plastic oil. It has ab-
speed of 2000 rpm. Waste plastic oil was selected for blending with
sorption bands in the region of 4000–400 cm−1 with several peaks. When
diesel on volume basis where P30 denotes a blend consisting of 70%
subjected to infrared radiation, chemical bonds contract, stretch and ab-
diesel and 30% waste plastic oil. P30 blend ratio was selected in par-
sorb these radiations in a particular range of wavelength independent of
ticular as it had similar properties in comparison to diesel. EGR rates of
the structure of the rest of the molecules. The FTIR spectra of plastic fuel as
0%, 10% and 20% were employed as an intention to reduce NOX
shown in Fig. 2 was recorded by Bruker series FTIR spectroscopy. Table 4
emissions. Three trial readings were noted after the engine had very
gives the information about the different functional groups present in the
nearly achieved steady state conditions, and the average of these trials
oil sample which were detected by matching the peak wave numbers with
was taken for calculation purposes.
standard data given by Coates [18].
395
A.S. Ayodhya et al. Fuel 227 (2018) 394–400
Table 2
Properties of diesel and waste plastic oil.
Fuel properties Test method Diesel Waste Plastic oil
3
Density (kg/m ) ASTM D4052 832 915
Lower calorific value (MJ/kg) ASTM D240 41.6 37.8
Kinematic viscosity (cSt) ASTM D445 2.3 3.52
Colour – Yellow Brown
Flash Point (°C) ASTM D93 50 42
Fire Point (°C) ASTM D93 56 44
Cetane Number* ASTM D 613 05 54 50
Table 3
List of uncertainties of different parameters.
Measurement % Uncertainty
CO 0.1
HC 0.8
NO 0.1
Soot 1.7
Load 0.1
Speed 0.1
Fig. 1. Schematic layout of an experimental setup. Time 0.9
BP 0.2
Fuel Consumption 1.0
Table 1 BTE 0.9
Specifications of the engine.
Parameter Details
for P30 blend in delayed compared to DF; and also a slightly higher
Engine make and model Mahindra, Maxximo (900 cc) peak pressure is achieved. The maximum in-cylinder pressure for P30 is
Type Dual Cylinder, four stroke, CRDI
81.86 bar whereas for DF it is 81.18 bar. In diesel engines the peak in-
Stroke × bore 83 × 84 mm
Power Rating 18.4 kW at 3600 rpm cylinder pressure is dependent on the amount of fuel taking part in the
Compression ratio 18.5 initial stages of uncontrolled combustion which is governed by the
Injection timing 12 °BTDC delay period [20]. Higher viscosity of P30 extends this delay period
Injection pressure 1000 bar leading to greater amount of fuel concentration to be combusted in the
Aspiration Natural aspiration
pre-mixed combustion phase. Longer ignition delay of waste plastic oil
Cooling system Water cooled
Dynamometer Eddy current, water cooled blends is the cause for higher in-cylinder pressure [21,22].
There is a minor drop in maximum in-cylinder pressure to 80.61 bar
and 79.17 bar with the application of 10% and 20% EGR rates re-
3. Results and discussions spectively. The re-circulated air substitutes substantial amounts of
oxygen by CO2 + H2O which act as heat absorbing agents and thereby
3.1. Brake thermal efficiency suppress the combustion process. This suppression of the combustion
process results into lowering of the in-cylinder pressure by 1.5% for
Brake thermal efficiency is the measure of how efficiently an engine 10% EGR and by 3.3% for 20% EGR rates respectively. Sathiyamoorthi
converts the thermal energy of fuel to mechanical output. The im- et al. [23] also reported similar observations while operating with EGR.
provement in BTE with load is due to reduced heat losses. It is observed
from Fig. 3 that BTE increases from 21.01% at 20% load to 39.2% at
80% load for DF and from 21.34% at 20% load to 40.14% at 80% load 3.3. Net heat release rate
for P30 blend. The minute rise in BTE of 1.52%, 3.4%, 2.3% & 2.4% for
20%, 40, 60% & 80% load respectively may be credited to lower ca- The heat release rate for DF and different blend cases is illustrated in
lorific value and longer ignition delay of plastic blend fuel. This ignition Fig. 5. It is observed that DF exhibits a lower heat release of 101.22 J/
delay is a result of lower cetane number of P30 fuel; as a result of which °CA as compared to P30 which has a maximum heat release rate of
greater quantity of fuel is combusted in the pre-mixed phase which 112.23 J/°CA. Also, the combustion for P30 blends is delayed by nearly
improves the combustion process. Also combustion of P30 releases less 3–4 °CA because of its higher viscosity. The longer ignition delay for
heat due to its lower calorific value, hence reducing heat losses and P30 blends makes possible better fuel-air mixing by allowing added
improving BTE. mixing time, which being the major reason for higher HRR. Another
The reduction in BTE with EGR application at all loads is due to the factor which may contribute to higher HRR in waste plastic oil blends is
deficiency of oxygen concentration inside the combustion chamber and the presence of additional 1.5%–3.3% oxygen by weight [6,21].
large replacement of air by exhaust gases [19]. Furthermore, EGR in- The application of EGR had an outcome of reduced peak heat re-
creases CO2 concentration inside the combustion chamber which in- lease rate to 104.44 J/°CA for 10% EGR and to101.98 J/°CA for 20%
creases the heat capacity of the mixture and brings down the BTE as the EGR rates respectively. This is due to the reduction in oxygen con-
working mixture now absorbs more heat energy. centration within the combustion chamber which is been replaced by
CO2 + H2O, thereby reducing the intensity of pre-mixed combustion
3.2. Cylinder pressure vs crank angle [24]. Mani et al. [25] also reported similar results in their experimental
work.
Fig. 4 shows the in-cylinder pressure readings recorded at different
crank angles for 80% load condition. It is noticed that the combustion
396
A.S. Ayodhya et al. Fuel 227 (2018) 394–400
3.5. Hydrocarbon CO emission is mainly due to poor mixture preparation, air en-
trainment, lack of sufficient oxygen and incomplete combustion [31].
Unburned hydrocarbons consist of fuel that is partially burned, and CO is a toxic intermediate product formed during the combustion of a
is an important parameter to measure the combustion inefficiency. hydrocarbon fuel; therefore its emissions should be controlled. The
Higher concentration of HC at lower loads is noticed because of poor reduction in ignition delay at higher loads result in less quantity of fuel
fuel distribution and lower in-cylinder temperature as observed in being present in the delay period and hence CO emissions are lesser
previous investigations [6,28]. From Fig. 7 it is evident that P30 blend [21].
has slightly higher concentration of UBHC decreasing from 26 ppm at Moreover, Carbon monoxide requires a temperature of 1200 °C to
20% load to 7 ppm at 80% load compared to DF whose concentration oxidize into CO2. Low loads will have lower combustion temperature
varies from 24 ppm at 20% load to 44 ppm at 80% load. P30 blend and therefore, higher CO emissions. It can be seen from Fig. 7 that CO
emits more HC emissions due to the following reasons: firstly, the concentration for P30 decreased from 0.3% at no load to 0.04% at 80%
higher viscosity of the blend limits proper mixing of the fuel resulting load condition. For the same load variations, CO concentration for DF
into several local spots of rich and lean mixtures [29]. Lean mixture decreased from 0.16% to 0.02%. Higher CO emissions from P30 blends
zones are too lean to burn whereas the fuel-rich zones do not have may be attributed to poor mixture preparation (due to higher viscosity
enough oxygen to burn the entire fuel. Secondly, unsaturated aromatic of P30) and the presence of local rich regions which invariably produce
compounds present in the P30 blend were indestructible during the CO.
combustion process [30]. Another reason might be the inability of the As seen from Fig. 8, it is clear that CO emission further increases
fuel spray to penetrate deeper into the combustion chamber leaving marginally with the application of EGR and in proportion with the %
100
964.79
95
1154.14
1652.13 1268.67
90
Transmittance (%)
748.56
85 1378.82
887.25
2859.62 699.60
80 1460.40
2957.53
75
70
2920.81
397
A.S. Ayodhya et al. Fuel 227 (2018) 394–400
Fig. 4. Variation of in-cylinder pressure with load and EGR. Fig. 7. Variation of unburned hydrocarbon with load and EGR.
Fig. 5. Variation of heat release rate with load and EGR. Fig. 8. Variation of carbon monoxide with load and EGR.
398
A.S. Ayodhya et al. Fuel 227 (2018) 394–400
4. Conclusions
• The engine was able to operate successfully with waste plastic oil
blend of 30% without any modifications being done.
• Improvement in brake thermal efficiency of 2–3% was attained with
P30 blend.
• Higher peak pressure & heat release rate for P30 blend were ob-
served because of its longer ignition delay and higher viscosity.
• NO emissions increased for P30 blend because of higher adiabatic
X
flame temperature and higher heat release rate.
Fig. 10. Variation of exhaust gas temperature with load and EGR. • Other measured emissions like CO, HC and soot marginally in-
creased because of poor mixture preparation.
399
A.S. Ayodhya et al. Fuel 227 (2018) 394–400
[7] Ananthakumar S, Jayabal S, Thirumal P. Investigation on performance, emission [21] Mani M, Nagarajan G, Sampath S. Characterisation and effect of using waste plastic
and combustion characteristics of variable compression engine fuelled with diesel, oil and diesel fuel blends in compression ignition engine. Energy 2011;36(1):212–9.
waste plastics oil blends. J Braz Soc Mech Sci Eng 2017;39(1):19–28. [22] Kaimal VK, Vijayabalan P. A detailed study of combustion characteristics of a DI
[8] Damodharan D, Sathiyagnanam AP, Rana D, Kumar BR, Saravanan S. Extraction diesel engine using waste plastic oil and its blends. Energy Convers Manage
and characterization of waste plastic oil (WPO) with the effect of n-butanol addition 2015;105:951–6.
on the performance and emissions of a DI diesel engine fueled with WPO/diesel [23] Sathiyamoorthi R, Sankaranarayanan G, Pitchandi K. Combined effect of nanoe-
blends. Energy Convers Manage 2017;131:117–26. mulsion and EGR on combustion and emission characteristics of neat lemongrass oil
[9] Devaraj J, Robinson Y, Ganapathi P. Experimental investigation of performance, (LGO)-DEE-diesel blend fuelled diesel engine. Appl Therm Eng 2017;112:1421–32.
emission and combustion characteristics of waste plastic pyrolysis oil blended with [24] Ladommatos N, Balian R, Horrocks R, Cooper L. The effect of exhaust gas re-
diethyl ether used as fuel for diesel engine. Energy 2015;85:304–9. circulation on combustion and NOx emissions in a high-speed direct-injection diesel
[10] Sane H, Purandare N, Barve O, Todakar A. Emission reduction of ic engines by using engine (No. 960840): SAE technical paper. 1996.
water-in-diesel emulsion and catalytic converter. Int J Res Eng Technol [25] Mani M, Nagarajan G, Sampath S. An experimental investigation on a DI diesel
2014;3:378–83. engine using waste plastic oil with exhaust gas recirculation. Fuel
[11] Kökkülünk G, Gonca G, Ayhan V, Cesur I, Parlak A. Theoretical and experimental 2010;89(8):1826–32.
investigation of diesel engine with steam injection system on performance and [26] Teng H, Regner G. Fuel injection strategy for reducing NOx emissions from heavy-
emission parameters. Appl Therm Eng 2013;54(1):161–70. duty diesel engines fueled with DME (No. 2006-01-3324): SAE technical paper.
[12] Hussain J, Palaniradja K, Alagumurthi N, Manimaran R. Effect of exhaust gas re- 2006.
circulation (EGR) on performance and emission characteristics of a three cylinder [27] Kidoguchi Y, Yang C, Kato R, Miwa K. Effects of fuel cetane number and aromatics
direct injection compression ignition engine. Alexandria Eng J 2012;51(4):241–7. on combustion process and emissions of a direct-injection diesel engine. JSAE Rev
[13] Ganapathy T, Gakkhar RP, Murugesan K. Influence of injection timing on perfor- 2000;21(4):469–75.
mance, combustion and emission characteristics of Jatropha biodiesel engine. Appl [28] Gnanasekaran S, Saravanan N, Ilangkumaran M. Influence of injection timing on
Energy 2011;88(12):4376–86. performance, emission and combustion characteristics of a DI diesel engine running
[14] Brijesh P, Sreedhara S. Exhaust emissions and its control methods in compression on fish oil biodiesel. Energy 2016;116:1218–29.
ignition engines: a review. Int J Automot Technol 2013;14(2):195–206. [29] Celıkten I. An experimental investigation of the effect of the injection pressure on
[15] Panda AK, Singh RK. Catalytic performances of kaoline and silica alumina in the engine performance and exhaust emission in indirect injection diesel engines. Appl
thermal degradation of polypropylene. J Fuel Chem Technol 2011;39(3):198–202. Therm Eng 2003;23(16):2051–60.
[16] Wallis MD, Bhatia SK. Thermal degradation of high density polyethylene in a re- [30] Panda AK, Murugan S, Singh RK. Performance and emission characteristics of diesel
active extruder. Polym Degrad Stab 2007;92(9):1721–9. fuel produced from waste plastic oil obtained by catalytic pyrolysis of waste
[17] Kaimal VK, Vijayabalan P. A detailed investigation of the combustion character- polypropylene. Energy Sources Part A 2016;38(4):568–76.
istics of a DI diesel engine fuelled with plastic oil and rice bran methyl ester. J [31] Murugan S, Ramaswamy MC, Nagarajan G. Tyre pyrolysis oil as an alternate fuel for
Energy Inst 2015. diesel engines (No. 2005-01-2190): SAE technical paper. 2005.
[18] Coates J. Interpretation of infrared spectra, a practical approach. Encyclopedia of [32] Kaimal VK, Vijayabalan P. An investigation on the effects of using DEE additive in a
analytical chemistry. 2000. DI diesel engine fuelled with waste plastic oil. Fuel 2016;180:90–6.
[19] Park Y, Bae C. Experimental study on the effects of high/low pressure EGR pro- [33] Wang HW, Huang ZH, Zhou LB, Jiang DM, Yang ZL. Technical note: investigation
portion in a passenger car diesel engine. Appl Energy 2014;133:308–16. on emission characteristics of a compression ignition engine with oxygenated fuels
[20] Murugan S, Ramaswamy MC, Nagarajan G. A comparative study on the perfor- and exhaust gas recirculation. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part D J Automobile Eng
mance, emission and combustion studies of a DI diesel engine using distilled tyre 2000;214(5):503–8.
pyrolysis oil–diesel blends. Fuel 2008;87(10):2111–21.
400