Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 15

Jurnal Komunitas 7 (1) (2015): 118-132. DOI: 10.15294/komunitas.v7i1.

3620

JURNAL KOMUNITAS
Research & Learning in Sociology and Anthropology
http://journal.unnes.ac.id/nju/index.php/komunitas

Food Security and the Futures of Farmers in


Decentralisation Era: a Case Study From Sigi District
Central Sulawesi
Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alamsyah

Tadulako University, Indonesia

Permalink/DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15294/komunitas.v7i1.3620

Received : January 2015; Accepted: February 2015; Published: March 2015

Abstract
A progress of an area directly influences its society. Decentralization is a form of democratization of the area
for development. The formation of new autonomous regions (DOB) has created the land conversion and the
politicization of society. Food security policy as an instrument of regional distributive does not provide a meaningful
impact in the region, especially in building farmers’ work ethic and behavior. This situation has contributed to the
failure of the state to achieve food security as the constitutional rights of society, particularly farmers. Through
qualitative methods to bring together all the stakeholders (farmers, local authorities) by conducting focus group
discussions and in-depth interviews, it is known that the policy still is formalistic. There is no better information
dissemination, attitude and commitment to the policy, limited resources, and no standard work. The regional
council of food security is not optimalized and there are institutional barriers. In addition, there is no involvement
of the community in accessing programming and there is high politicization on agriculture which is all managed
by top down in the area.

Abstrak
Desentralisasi merupakan wujud demokratisasi daerah untuk pembangunan. Pembentukan daerah otonom
baru (DOB) melahirkan terjadinya alih fungsi lahan dan politisasi masyarakat seperti petani daripada
penguatan ketahanan pangan dan penguatan petani. Penelitian ini bertujuan meneliti kebijakan Kabupaten
Sigi dalam hal penguatan ketahanan pangan dan petani. Melalui metode kualitatif dengan mempertemukan
pemangku kepentingan (petani, pejabat daerah) melalui diskusi kelompok terfokus dan wawancara mendalam,
diketahui bahwa kebijakan masih bersifat formalistik. Tidak ada sosialisasi informasi secara baik, sikap dan
komitmen terhadap kebijakan kurang, keterbatasan sumber daya, tidak ada standar kerja. Dewan ketahanan
pangan daerah belum optimal, hambatan struktur dan kelembagaan, tidak ada keterlibatan masyarakat dalam
mengakses penyusunan program serta tingginya politisasi pada bidang pertanian yang semuanya dikelola
secara top down di daerah.

Keywords: policy; local government, food security; decentralization

How to Cite: Sayuti, Sultan, & Alamsyah, M. N. 2015. Food Security and the Futures of Farmers in Decentralisation
Era: a Case Study From Sigi District Central Sulawesi. Jurnal Komunitas, 7 (1): 118-132 doi: 10.15294/komunitas.
v7i1.3620

© 2015 Semarang State University. All rights reserved


Corresponding author : ISSN 2086-5465
Address: Jl. Soekarno - Hatta KM. 9, Palu, Sulawesi Tengah
UNNES JOURNALS
Jurnal Komunitas 7 (1) (2015): 118-132 119

INTRODUCTION 1996 on Food, Article 1 point 17. And the ef-


The decentralization after the reform, es- forts to achieve food supply is done by re-
pecially the region expansion, provides lying on the resources, institution, and local
functional and structural change in the so- culture as contained in Article 2 paragraph
cial and cultural dimensions. The policy (2) item a PP 68/2002.
influences the society including in the far- Food security in national commit-
ming culture. Indonesia as the agricultural ments is described as a condition in which
nation puts farmer on a high achievement each individual at all times has physical and
obsession in terms of production quality financial access to get sufficient, safe, and
and quantity. This obsession is part of the nutritious food according to their dietary
efforts to fulfill the community consumpti- needs and taste to be able to live healthy
on needs as well as a strategic investment for and active (Kemenristek, 2006). Agriculture
a sovereign nation. Because of this impor- which is dominated by traditional produc-
tant value, the effort of farmers must be able tion mechanisms puts it as a source of de-
to improve their household income in order pendence of life. This situation is threate-
to fulfill their basic needs. ned and potentially degraded, not only the
The capacities which include the kno- quantity but also the quality, if a shift in the
wledge, behavior, and skill aspects of farmer ethos or culture of farmers from rural com-
in recognizing the potential and business munities which characterized by existence
opportunity, farming management, and of farmers to a community which emphasi-
domestic economic activities have become zes the aspects of service of urban commu-
an important part for the sustainability of nity (rural), related to the development of
mode of production to be able to work to- city functions in the decentralization era.
gether effectively. Global reality, through a The government policy system should
capitalistic market, establishes a pressured be a major part which can take part on the
socio-cultural phenomenon. This pheno- role in the middle of imbalances in agricul-
menon encourages people to work partia- tural production when it is not getting ade-
lly so they cannot create an acceleration of quate production value in responding to the
social change and will eventually co-opt the needs of the economy as part of the prob-
community into a short-term practical need. lems of farmers’ life. In the era of decentra-
At this position, farmers often get lization, various cultural shocks attack the
caught up various dimensions helplessness farmers’ culture in the village. Village iden-
of social life which immediately needs to tity, as described by Herbert Spencer shows
be fulfilled as part of the current market the indicators which are still modest, unpre-
demand and life cycle. The existing poli- tentious, backward, and more identified as
cies mostly serve only as part of a suppor- “traditional”, while the urban is described as
ting pledge for food production cycle for the a level or a more complex situation that is
people who are not prepared as a model of labeled as a “modern” and “transitional”.
policies which can trigger work ethic. The development progress from the
Food in the context of nationality is a expansion area has created several deve-
dimension which must be well prepared by lopment challenges related to the following
the government. Therefore, based on the side effects. Through the expansion, such as
Government Regulation No. 68 2002, the In- the current condition of Sigi Regency after
donesian government has established a po- splitting in 2008, there is a development
licy foundation for their food security. Food of countryside with the rural development
security is defined as the fulfillment of the which eventually leads to the villages’ de-
conditions of food for households reflected pendence on the product of the city (Soejad-
in the food availability which is sufficient, moko in Mangunwijaya, 1993; 50).
(both in quantity and quality) safe, equitab-
le, and affordable as contained in the article This situation will also increase the stag-
1 point 1 and according to the Law No. 7 of nation (mandeg) in the village which in

UNNES JOURNALS
120 Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alamsyah, Food Security and the Futures of Farmers in Decentralisation

the establishment of new autonomous time. Even agricultural production is urged


region, should be stimulated on non-agri- to lands that are less or not suitable for ag-
cultural activities as part of self-fulfilling riculture. This marginal land management
program as the general characteristics of to conform to agriculture would require ad-
villages in Indonesia. This fact is contra-
ditional costs, such as for the development
dictory with the spirit of development,
where in reality, regional expansion is
of water management systems, fertilizing,
only meant as a physical change of the city and raising the pH (Buku Putih Ketahanan
solely as ‘red light’ and building a perma- pangan, 2006). It is mainly creating the land
nent office (alamsyah, 2012). degradation due to natural disasters such as
the case in Sigi Regency.
Traditional paradigm shift in Sigi Re-
gency communities who are culturally ac- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
customed to the traditional agriculture will Decentralization as the implementation of
be dragged into the crowded growth of new democracy in the region should place food
cities and ignore farming as an alternative security as an orientation into the upstream
livelihood after the division of Induk Dong- basic needs of society. Because of that, the
gala Regency. Regional expansion which re- food security in the form and type of policies
quires new land for offices and residential by Lowi in Parsons, (2006: 482) mentions
locations will inevitably erode agricultural several models to analyze a policy namely
land as well as affect the patterns of farming distributive, regulatory and redistributive
culture that has long existed into a more policies. At this early conception, the food
promising service sector. security policy in distributive policy is de-
According to (Darwanto, 2005; 164), fined as the direction of the various fields in
the sustainability of food security through order to achieve the objectives of common
increased availability of national food, es- interest and mutual needs in the context of
pecially rice and farmers’ welfare improve- the management of modern society which is
ment, requires long-term and short-term the government.
policies. For the short term, the protection Each policy requires an implementati-
policy with restrictions on imports of rice on policy to be managed in accordance with
farmers or incentive for local farmers is still the plan. This situation is indicated if the
needed, but it should be supported by poli- application considers several factors. These
cies that also encourage the increased pro- factors according to Edwards III in Winarno
duction through improving rice productivi- (2007) are:
ty, especially in traditional rice-producing 1) Communication is related to the process
areas. This must be an important part of the of delivering information and consisten-
government’s strategy in Sigi Regency which cy of the submitted information. Com-
has served as the center of agricultural deve- munication is important for the ongoing
lopment that sustains communities at three process of coordination and implemen-
(3) districts, Sigi, Palu and Donggala Regen- tation, which leads to the emergence of a
cies. thorough understanding of the program
And for the other polices, it is neces- importance and a comprehensive agree-
sary to improve productivity and harvested ment on the goals and objectives that will
area, both with expansion and increased be achieved.
cropping intensity per year to secure the 2) Resources are related to the four com-
availability of irrigation and agricultural ponents, namely, the fulfillment of the
inputs. The biggest obstacle in the auto- number of staff, the quality of necessary
nomous region is the development process information for the decision making,
that focuses more on the office infrastruc- sufficient authority to carry out its duties
ture and ignore the agricultural sector. This and responsibilities, and supporting fa-
situation creates resistance and the degra- cilities.
dation of the farmers’ spirit from time to 3) Disposition (tendencies) is the attitude

UNNES JOURNALS
Jurnal Komunitas 7 (1) (2015): 118-132 121

and commitment of the implementers of Mohammed Salmin), Head of the Food Se-
the program, especially from those who curity Office (Siti Sudarmi, SP., M.Si), Office
become implementers of the program, agriculture, fisheries and livestock (Ir. Agus
which in this case is bureaucratic official. Lamakarate, MM), BP4K Kab. Sigi (Tugi-
4) The bureaucratic structure is the exis- min, Spt, MM), the Department of Forestry
tence of a standard operating procedure and Plantation (Ir.Andi Aco), Perindagkop,
(SOP) which regulates the flow of work and Legislator Sigi (Rival).
and the implementation of the program. Besides the results of the in-depth in-
terview, this study was also supported with
The implementation of food security the record of focus group discussion (FGD)
policies which becomes the focus of this stu- with purposive sample of community in the
dy is a series of rules derived from the legal village of Jono Oge, disctrict of Biromaru
acts to the decision of the Mayor. It requires which is a surplus agricultural village and
analysis to be able to demonstrate its effecti- dominated by plural immigrant farmers and
veness in its field practice, especially inclu- the Bulu Bete village, Dolo Selatan District
des: which is minus agricultural village and con-
a) Policy Determination which is the anal- sists of homogenous local farmer of Kaili
ysis that is related to the way of policy- ethnic. This study involved the district go-
making, why, when, and for whom the vernment and village officials (village head
policy is made; and village secretary, village representative
b) The content of the policy is the analysis body/BPD, youth organization, farmer joint
that includes a description of specific groups/Gapoktan, farmer groups/Poktan,
policy, in this case food security, and how agricultural educators, religious leaders,
it is developed from the previous policy. traditional leaders, women leaders). The
This analysis can also be based on the data was also supported by secondary data
information provided by the theoretical from the above agencies and the media
framework which tries to provide a cri- (newspapers, websites, etc.). This data was
tique to the policy. recorded and then made transcripts for easy
verification and meaning.
The existence of the above points in
building the behavioral patterns of society is RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
very essential because the main object of the Sigi Regency officially became autonomous
success by this food security program is the regency since July 21, 2008 with the approval
community of farmers and not local govern- of Act No. 27 of 2008 on the establishment
ments. Stimulus to the community with the of Sigi Regency. This new region has an area
different level of acceptance and understan- of ​​5196.02 square kilometers consisting of
ding is an empirical reality that inevitably 15 districts with Kulawi District as the lar-
has to be accepted and understood on the gest district (1053.56 km2) and Dolo district
mechanisms of state management by the re- as the smallest district with an area of ​​36.05
gency administration. km2 (CBS, 2012).
Population growth in the period 2010-
METHODS 2012 (two) years ranges from 1.59%, in which
This research was conducted in Sigi Regency this period there were 3.93% of the popula-
as the new autonomous region and is a cen- tion suffered from malnutrition. And there
ter for the traditional farming cultivation were 15.62% of the population that are cate-
which provides supply for Palu and Dong- gorized as below prosperous and prosperous
gala cities. The qualitative research was I.
used with the field observation and in depth The situation becomes a challenge for
interview techniques through the use of a stable development considering the strong
questions list from the Regent (Ir. Aswadin farmer in Sigi Regency. The condition is very
Randalembah), chief of Bappeda (Alm. Drs. clear as compared to the number of food

UNNES JOURNALS
122 Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alamsyah, Food Security and the Futures of Farmers in Decentralisation

Table 1. The number of poor citizen in Sigi Regency


Popu- Num- Below Malnutri-
Prosperous I
No. Districts lation ber of prosper- tion and
family
(people) family ous family insufficient
1 Pipikoro 7,962 2195 644 531 665
Kulawi
2 8,630 2281 786 780 773
Selatan
3 Kulawi 14,434 4127 1326 1059 221
4 Lindu 4,777 1291 524 234 399
5 Nokilalaki 5,730 1467 238 636 410
6 Palolo 27,385 7756 2127 2336 409
7 Gumbasa 11,898 3207 609 872 661
8 Dolo Selatan 14,715 3944 2475 823 537
9 Dolo Barat 12,808 3623 1512 1470 664
10 Tanambulava 8,011 2252 657 428 536
11 Dolo 20,972 5255 1081 1427 932
12 Sigi Biromaru 43,649 10779 2151 3255 790
13 Marawola 21,379 7814 728 1276 482
Marawola
14 6,500 1809 1247 538 179
Barat
15 Kinovaro 9,649 2779 1587 768 932
Sigi Regency 2013 218,499 60579 17692 16433 8590
Source: the Data of SKPG, Food Security Department of Sigi Regency, 2013

Table 2. Number of food production in Sigi Regency in 2012


Paddy Pro- Corn Pro- Cassava Pro- Sweet Potatoes
No. District duction duction duction Production
(Ton) (Ton) Gross (Ton) Gross (Ton) Gross
1 Pipikoro 4003 545 186 162
2 Kulawi Selatan 6387 880 246 120
3 Kulawi 12205 447 288 117
4 Lindu 3123 11064 738 469
5 Nokilalaki 3089 429 266 106
6 Palolo 34060 1100 267 106
7 Gumbasa 4022 537 577 0
8 Dolo Selatan 12727 7640 1478 1353
9 Dolo Barat 10760 4775 658 553
10 Tanambulava 11877 440 185 96
11 Dolo 24353 545 6799 4095
12 Sigi Biromaru 38891 1108 430 0
13 Marawola 2577 448 847 297
Marawola
14 0 1418 861 437
Barat
15 Kinovaro 1907 925 981 530
Gross Production 169981 32301 14807 8441
Source: The Data of SKPG, Badan Ketahanan Pangan of Sigi Regency, 2013

UNNES JOURNALS
Jurnal Komunitas 7 (1) (2015): 118-132 123

production in each area of Sigi Regency, na- Group Association (Gapoktan) Recipi-
mely: ents Community Direct Assistance Fund
The portrayal of both data shows that (BLM) Rural Agribusiness Development
the development of community food pro- (PUAP) The second phase of Fiscal Year
duction is not associated with the changes 2010.
in the quality of life in Sigi Regency. The si- 3. Decree of the Regent of Sigi No. 520/0202
tuation is characterized by the existence of / B-SIGI / 2010 on the Establishment of
poor nutrition in the regency although they the Technical Committee of Rural Agri-
have a surplus of food in terms of quantity. business Development (PUAP) Sigi.
In this context, there is a big problem regar- 4. Sigi District Regulation No. 10 of 2010, on
ding on how malnutrition can happen whe- the Executive Agency of Agricultural Ex-
re the welfare figures are still high. The use tension, Fisheries and Forestry Sigi.
of data instruments in policy making will be 5. The Regent of Sigi decree No. 6 of 2011,
visible in the form of regional policies pro- the description of the main tasks and
gram in the form of funding and programs functions of the agricultural, fisheries
in each SKPD and cross-SKPD so it will be and forestry implementation agencies of
able to create a better situation of society. Sigi.
The continuity of the data was shown All rules of mutual synergy become
in the plus minus crops report of Sigi Regen- the main foundation of applying and deli-
cy in 2012 for January to August. For the ty- vering the realization of food security that
pes of plants –paddy- (Rice), there are some are expected to encourage a better lifestyle
surplus district namely Palolo, Tanambula- and mindset of farmers in Sigi Regency to
va and Nokilalaki districts while in districts be more modern.
Sigi Biromaru, the minus result occurred in The pillar of development in Sigi Re-
June 2012, the District Dolo had surplus re- gency is in the field of Agriculture, Tourism
sult in April, June, July and the remaining and Small-Medium Enterprises SMEs. This
were minus, South Dolo District experien- can be seen in the Government’s vision of
ced a surplus in April, June, July, August; Sigi in 2010-2015, namely “The Realization
Dolo West districts experienced a surplus in of Sigi Regency which is Cultured, Civilized,
April, June, July; Marawola district surplus and Excellent in Using the Potential Resour-
in February, June; while the West Marawola ces toward An Advanced Regency”. The ge-
district had minus throughout the months; neral policies of food security in Sigi Regen-
Gumbasa district was minus in January, cy includes (a) Improving food security for
June, July August, Kinovaro district was mi- the community; (b) Improving the welfare
nus in April, July, August (Sigi Food Security of farmers.
Office, 2013). During the period, there was Those general policies will be pursued
no effect of puso/failed harvest (DP3 Sigi, through these development programs:
2013). 1. Improvement of food security aimed at
Some national policies are made to increasing the sustainability of food secu-
encourage the institutionalization of food rity with the target of declining the ratio
security as an intervention attempt from the of the districts’ food insecurity in Sigi Re-
governments toward condition specificity gency.
faced by Indonesia, especially the Sigi Re- 2. Improvement Program of Farmers’ wel-
gency. Among them are: fare aimed at improving the welfare of
1. The Regulation of the Minister of Agri- farmers with the target of increasing the
culture No. 29 / Permentan / OT.140 / Value of Farmers’ Sales Index or the Value
3/2010 on Guidelines for Rural Agribusi- of Agricultural Production Selling Index.
ness Development (PUAP) For the government and all elements
2. The Decree of the Minister of Agriculture of society in Sigi Regency, agriculture sec-
Number: 3045 / kpts / OT.140 / 9/2010 tor has multi-functions from the function
on Stipulation of Village and Farmers of culture to the function of politics, which

UNNES JOURNALS
124 Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alamsyah, Food Security and the Futures of Farmers in Decentralisation

until now has not received adequate atten- 3. uneven and uncoordinated implemen-
tion from the public related to the quality tation of various policies and programs
of its management. Agriculture sector is the to reduce poverty.
identity and source of life for most people 4. non-optimal institutions that deal with
in Sigi Regency. The sector is a supplier of the problem of poverty.
clothing, food, and housing for the popula- Institutionally, the main institution
tion, as well as the preserver or conservation which becomes the foundation of food se-
of sustainable nature in Sigi Regency. curity policy is in the hand of institutional
Agricultural Sector in reality becomes food security department of Sigi Regency
a dominant sector in the establishment and as stated in the regional regulations of Sigi
economic activity in Sigi Regency. But in Regency No. 09 2010 on July 19, 2010 concer-
addition to agriculture, food security is also ning the organizations and functions of the
obtained by SKPD. This explanation can be Inspectorate, Bappeda and technical insti-
seen from the Sigi Regent who states that: tutes of Sigi Regency. Therefore, it becomes
the basis for the sustainability of food secu-
“... Coordination between some relevant rity in Sigi Regency. It is also seen in Sigi Re-
agencies related to food security issues in gent decree No. 521/106 / B.SIGI / 2012 on 24
Sigi Regency is conducted almost every April 2012 about the establishment of food
day, including in every Monday, we hold a security council of Sigi Regency where the
meeting to discuss all the sectors in which
chairman is regent and operational chair-
food security is part of it. The food securi-
ty issue is for example how sometime it is man is the Secretary of the District Chief
hampered by the industrial sector and so Executive (Sekkab) and the secretary is the
on. We do all those things in order to be Head of Food Security of Sigi Regency, this
inter-connected with each other. We hope model makes this institutionalization stag-
SKPD in Sigi Regency does not display any nant and not dynamic.
sectorial ego. Because I always convey to The circumstance becomes a strate-
SKPD that we work for the public, mea- gic indicator of food security office toward
ning that Sigi regency government exists another institution. The phenomenon of
because of the public. Therefore, the level bureaucratic life has structurally complica-
of social welfare is our priorities, which
ted the coordination considering all agency
among them is also about food security
... “(ARL, in Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alam, heads who become members of the working
2013) team working are the level of the leaders
with the higher echelon classification as
There are several important points in compared to the head of food security of-
the above statement, especially the need fice who has just a IIIa echelon. The other
for an official forum, institutionalization of policies that strengthen the functions of
food security, as well as the necessity for a food security is the number of Sigi Regen-
change of mindset of government bureauc- cy government policies through the Regent,
racy to go out from the old “tradition” that head of food security office and Sekkab as
sees the success from their only point of the operational chairman of food security
view. Sigi Regency empirical condition of of Sigi Regency and all related institutions
food security depends on the paddy rice ac- which put food security office as the main
companied by the condition of commodity leading sector.
production which in 2012 had 38.174 hecta- The main functions of the food secu-
res of production area (DP3 Sigi, 2013). rity office are as the technical policy makers
The main severe problem in Sigi Re- in the field of food security, the provision
gency is the problem of poverty, which in- of support on the regional administration
cludes: areas of food security, the development and
1. high number of poor people. execution of tasks in the field of food secu-
2. non-optimal planning and implementa- rity, and the implementation of other tasks
tion of poverty reduction programs. given by the Regent (Lakip Food Security of

UNNES JOURNALS
Jurnal Komunitas 7 (1) (2015): 118-132 125

Sigi Regency, 2012). One of the other efforts to the budget of Sigi regency, therefore, it
to boost the food security in the Sigi Regency becomes a challenge for more innovative
is by the stipulation of the existing indust- activities related to the policies that en-
rial core competence in Sigi Regency, in this courage farmers’ perspectives in terms of
case is the cocoa processing industry (Food their position as part of efforts to maintain
Security LAKIP Sigi, 2012). The existence of the stability of food as well as the creation
the action plan of the industrial develop- of a more balanced consumption patterns.
ment of core competence will be the opera- The construction that has always emerged
tional guideline of the government officers as a question is that where is the plus value
of Sigi Regency in directing and supporting of crop production which is carried out by
the implementation of core competence de- society toward national mechanisms. Once
velopment program of cocoa processing in- again, the support to the farmers is appre-
dustry complementarily and synergistically. ciated by the development strategy which
The existence of food security offi- is measured materialistically on the urban
ce budget with the support cost from the development and not the society welfare
provincial budget, regency budget, and the potential.
APBN/De-concentration with a total budget In detail, Sigi government policies
of 3.877.750.000 even in the realization of that include a direct security policy can be
performance measurement activities tab- seen in some of the important points in RP-
le (pengukuran kinerja kegiatan -PKK) of JMD Sigi Regency 2010-2015 (Bappeda Sigi,
food security depatment in 2012 to finance 2012) covering the policy orientation of local
the improvement of food security in the Sigi finance for:
Regency for the realization of 98% with a 1. Regency expenditure is prioritized for the
target of 2.601.820.000 and the realization improvement of the purchasing power
is 2,566,443,325 including office administra- on revitalization of agriculture, animal
tion services for 430,222.500 and the rest for farming, fishery, plantation and forest-
the improvement of resilience as much as ry, strengthening rural based economic
2,136,220,725 (LAKIP of Sigi Regency Food structure, empowerment of cooperatives
Security, 2012). This is obviously a very small and SMEs, Tourism, as well as support for
figure in the estimation of potential stimu- rural infrastructure.
lus for people in Sigi Regency. 2. Regency expenditure is intended to sup-
According to the previous explanation, port the reduction of unemployment
it is estimated that Sigi Regency is an area through ready-to-work employment
which relies on agriculture and food securi- preparation, increased investment in sev-
ty to be one of the main sectors because the eral sectors, improvement of facilities and
challenges and expectations of Sigi Regency infrastructure for employment training.
does not merely prepare food for themselves 3. Regency expenditure is intended to sup-
but the wider community in their surroun- port the development of economic activi-
ding such as Palu and Donggala Regencies, ties, maintenance, and development of
including some areas in Kalimantan. The infrastructure in the area of ​​production
budget is smaller than the budget allocati- centers in rural areas, and the accessibili-
on for the agricultural development sector ty of the raw water and electricity sources.
of Sigi Regency since the year 2009-2012 in 4. Regency expenditure is used to support
the amount of 4,334,768,916.31 (DP3 Sigi, the efforts to maintain the environmen-
2013). When we further compare to the 2012 tal capacity through programs and activi-
budget, this figure is only 0.72% of the total ties to reduce environmental pollution,
budget including direct and indirect expen- achievement of the target of protected
diture amounted to 537,245,541,000 (Bappe- areas, disaster mitigation, and control of
da Sigi, 2012). the land use and excessive exploitation of
Sigi local revenues in 2012, amounted natural resources.
to 4,900,950,000.00 or contributing 0.91% Sigi Regency financial expenditure

UNNES JOURNALS
126 Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alamsyah, Food Security and the Futures of Farmers in Decentralisation

policy is a four out of 13 (thirteen) proclai- expected that the M-P3MI program can
med policies which is intended as a regio- maximize the utilization of the waste
nal policy to support the achievement of in promoting agricultural productivity
the Vision-Mission of Regent and Vice Re- while reducing environmental impact.
gent 2010-2015, including also the target of 4. The institutional development can be
Human Development Index (HDI) and the done through a cultural approach so that
Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). the public will be regulated by customary
The regency expenditure policy year 2010- law.
2015 is done through regulation of regional One of the priorities which is expected
spending which embraces the principles of to trigger the farmers’ work performance in
proportionate, efficient and effective, eco- the region is through the preparation of va-
nomical and transparent (Bappeda Sigi, rious institutions such as the Counseling
2012). Other mechanism adopted by Sigi Center for Agriculture, Fisheries, and Fo-
government to strengthen the basis of food restry (BP3K) in Sigi Regency which have
security is to optimize the vertical presence been formed in some places to support
of national and provincial institutions. the assisting tasks for the community. The
As an effort to institutionalize the implementation of the tasks of this insti-
binding between Sigi government agencies tution is conducted through the institutio-
with the institutions, a joint agreement bet- nalization of farmers professionally by the
ween the Regent Sigi Ir. H. Aswadin Randa- formation of farmers’ combined group (ga-
lembah, the Head of BPTP Central Sulawesi poktan) in the village consisting of several
Province, and SKPD Chief of. Sigi Regency farmer groups (Poktan) with one of serious
(sulteng.litbang.deptan.go.id, 2013) is done. obstacles is not working in synergy in each
The approved agreement is related to chan- work unit (SKPD) to achieve the outcomes
ges in the behavior of farmers as follows: because of the sectoral ego on each agency
1. The improvement of agricultural produc- (SKPD). The number of Farmer Group As-
tivity is inseparable from the application sociation (union) is 146 Units, the number
of technological innovation, but techno- of farmer groups (Poktan) is 1,051 units,
logical innovation will not provide the Pokdakan (fisheries) as many as 108 units,
expected results without the support of and KTH (Forest) 71 units, so there are 1376
other sectors, especially with regard to units. Those are groups that have been for-
infrastructure, capital, marketing and med from the total population in Sigi 214
others. For those reasons, in order to in- 700 people.
crease the productivity of the agricultural One of the disadvantages of these
sector, Sigi Regency is required to make groups is that the Top Down characteristics
programs that can integrate various sec- so that it is not a pure public participation.
tors, so that development activities can The non-synchronization between institu-
be more focused, efficient and effective. tions that creates a dilemma towards the is-
2. The developmental model of Rural Ag- sue of agriculture escort headed towards the
riculture through Innovation which is realization of regional food security as one
abbreviated as M-P3MI is one of Agricul- informant put forward as the following:
ture Rural Development Model that inte-
grates not only by involving sub-sectors “... Indeed, it is sometimes a dilemma to
in agriculture, but the sector outside of be the educator in the field, for examp-
agriculture. M-P3MI success is largely le, educator who is in the village had di-
determined by the support of various vided the territory, such as, a village that
we have divided and formed groups. From
sectors, both financially and program
BP4K already sums up the whole potential
support. of existing farmer groups in Sigi. The edu-
3. Given the available organic material in cator has already had the data group, for
Sigi Regency which is not used optimally, example in a village there are 10 groups.
such as hay crops and cocoa wastes, it is But on one hand, there are certain people

UNNES JOURNALS
Jurnal Komunitas 7 (1) (2015): 118-132 127

go into that village for the group. Well, it income (GDP) of Sigi Regency lies in the
is usually chaotic. This includes the exis- agricultural sector, with the contribution of
ting groups assisted by the department of 52.85% (BPS Sigi, 2011) which is the highest
agriculture but not yet entered in the SK achievement earned although it is still far
of Regent that we manage and it will be
below the target given in RPJMD for the
put sort of revisers so the group can be as-
sisted... (TUG, in Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur
agricultural sector which is 54.73 % in the
Alam, 2013) third year (Bappeda Sigi, 2012). This achie-
vement can be considered that there are still
Further explained many things that have not been on the right
“... educator is only volunteer in the villa- track so that the optimum achievement of
ge, while if there is a program officers who the farm has not been reached. This can be
come to the region by bringing equip- just a natural reality that Sigi is a natural
ment, it will make the PPL workers un- area of agricultural
​​ management, and has
confident. The solutions that exist today not been optimized through the appropriate
are in a form of decree on strengthening program.
the group which explains that when the-
re are groups outside of their group, it is
not their responsibility, so that is the so-
The Future of Farmers
lution. For example, there are many cases Sigi community character appears on the
where assistance from the province come slogan which is used as a branding for local
into the area of Marawola districts by pro- government that is Mareso Masagena which
viding assistance directly to communities means Mareso (Reso) or hard work, tena-
goat without coordination and involve- cious, unflinching courage, enterprising,
ment in village or district extension, when resilient, patient, trustworthy, then Masa-
there is failure on the aid program, the gena (Sagena) which means complete, con-
PPL officers is questioned on why edu- venience, shared and prosperous. In other
cator does not accompany them?. While
words, the meaning and significance of the
initially, the program was not coordinated
with BP4K or BP3 in each district. So that
both words is to work hard to achieve suc-
the educator is not responsible ... “(TUG, cess together for the welfare (Bappeda Sigi,
in Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alam, 2013). 2012).
Until 2010, the Government of Sigi
Some of the above circumstances are claims that there is about 38.2 percent of the
part of food security problems especially in 217 874 inhabitants of Sigi who are still rela-
the field of food security that emphasizes tively poor. The factors causing a high rate
the implemented activities and are method of poverty is, in addition to the influence of
and pilot project involving the community education, the limited employment with a
directly and the implementation is not un- far below average salary, the isolation factor
derstood by the public such as; utilization of some areas also affects poverty in the re-
of the yard for the development of food that gion.
is contested, accelerating diversification of There is an error in the process of agri-
food and nutrition community conducted cultural production in creating a behavioral
simultaneously between socialization and pattern of with modern agriculture orienta-
competition, socialization of local food love tion. Mostly, the local farming communities
in a form of competition reserved menu 3 B still maintain traditional farming patterns
(LAKIP Sigi Food Security, 2013). While in on rice commodity which is managed mo-
the counseling sector, they provide guidan- notonously, although it is empirically not
ce to the achievement of the program whe- so strategic view of production but is very
re the agricultural sector is an intervention important for the food security. Various
program that is escorted by PPL although mistakes on the traditional agricultural pro-
sometimes the phenomenon of sectoral ego duction patterns are seen in the use and uti-
that is still visible there. lization of rice seeds to post-harvest proces-
The main reliance of gross domestic sing, farmers in this region often make small

UNNES JOURNALS
128 Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alamsyah, Food Security and the Futures of Farmers in Decentralisation

mistakes that subconsciously will bring big


economic losses. In this context, the general knowledge
The success in Sigi agriculture occurs possessed by farmers is not enough to take
because of the productive labor migration a rational decision, so that the necessary in-
patterns (urbanization) that creates an imi- tervention and government policies or best
tation pattern of production. The interacti- practice from outside knowledge is needed
on of Sigi local farmers who are culturally to trigger the action. The objectives will ne-
manage their agriculture with the outside ver be able to be achieved if the farmers do
farmers (bugis or Java) who are used to make not have supporting instruments and per-
innovation in agricultural business creates a haps this is also related to the strong culture
great desire for local communities to also of patron client/patronage in the communi-
be able to perform the same production ty. But this sign must be read as an impor-
mechanism for the better result. tant marker for the government for creating
The existence of a very traditional way a more creative and efficient program. It is
of thinking for the nature dependence is a further stated that the culture of Sigi people
cultural problem which still exists in the likes to imitate the success,
public mindset with assumption that nature
has presented everything to the communi- “... The rice paddies using Legowo row
ty. This condition creates apathetic society model shows good result. The PPL officers
like the one in the research object namely just provide information or story that if we
plant rice with the Legowo row system un-
petani angina (wind farmers-ARL, in Sayu-
til 6-7 tons / hectare will result in a good
ti, Sultan, M. Nur Alam, 2013). The transfer harvest. Obviously, people will not belie-
of knowledge to a peer system is another ve it, if we only we get the story. Surely,
example as expressed by the below farmers: the government should have to give a real
example. And after the result is successful
“... people in Bulu Bete, since 70s-80s un- and seen by the people, for instance, their
til 90s, just knew it all, Corn ..corn ...fai- production is usually only 2-3 tons and af-
led harvest, that’s it ‘. Later, I studied the ter the piloting project using Legowo row
emergence of this event through Javanese system, the result becomes 6-7 tons. And
migrants, Bugis migrants, and modern at this point, they will they follow us. So
farmers because we are just unprofessio- this is actually a thing to be started first,
nal farmers. They plant some crops, for which is from the top levels ... “(FGD in
example tomatoes, apples, watermelon, Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alam, 2013)
and cucumbers. From some hectares, if
only corn for example, say 1 hectare will The above statement embodies the
result in only about 2 million. If it’s Java- cultural construction of society that has not
nese or Bugis people use that 1 hectare,
been grown in a culture of modern, creati-
the harvest can worth until 12-15 million,
ve, innovative and independent agriculture.
so they have an evolved way of thinking.
Eventually, that’s what I see today evol- Their culture is still coopted with the old
ving in People of Bulu Bete because al- model which always thinks about derivati-
most everyone here works as farmers. It ve farming or even forced by economic de-
means not only that. After that, there are mands. Although there are government pro-
alternate planting such as tomatoes, cu- grams that have also imposed some piloting
cumbers, sweet potatoes. Because sweet projects such as national program of school
potato’s price is Rp.350.000 / sack, so it field, integrated land processing, and the
means our gratitude. We can imitate the management of agricultural, the programs
way our family from Java and South Su-
are still limited.
lawesi to do their farm who have already
Generally, people move to do somet-
established an advanced ways of thinking
because this is not just like images, this hing if there is a concrete/empirical eviden-
is a clear example in the field ... “(FGD, in ce that they can see and is not limited to just
Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alam, 2013) giving directions. Therefore, the existence

UNNES JOURNALS
Jurnal Komunitas 7 (1) (2015): 118-132 129

of the empowerment program fostering the with Private and production system tech-
food security in Sigi Regency is very impor- nology.
tant such as the program of Kaji Terap Rice 6. The Improvement Program of Industrial
and Corn and other agricultural activities Technology which is the mentoring of In-
(BP4K Sigi, 2013). dustrial Technology ability.
The same program is conducted by 7. The Arrangement of industrial structure
food security department (Food Securi- including policy for top and down busi-
ty Strategic Plan of Sigi, 2012) through the ness and facilities and infrastructure pro-
improvement of food security programs as vision for industrial clusters (Strategic
well as the acceleration of program diversi- Perindagkop & SMEs, 2010).
fication of food consumption and nutriti- Therefore, Sigi Regency should be able
on which is a stimulant effort to encourage to reorient the potential of that programs so
people to care about food security mainly they can be implemented effectively in each
with the utilization of local food potential phases in order to produce quality outcomes
and not merely relying on rice but also corn, for more prosperous and empowered so-
tubers, and various other nutritious food. ciety. However, it is unfortunate that there
For the Small and Medium Enterpri- has been no region institution in general
ses sector, the government of Sigi Regency which specifically prioritizes the food se-
through Perindagkop Agency and SMEs, curity as one of the strategic programs that
even during the visit of the minister of ag- can encourage the achievement of the other
riculture in the village of Jono Oge on the sectors.
usage of Sustainable Food House Region The main concern of development
(KRPL), have signed agreement related to undertaken by Sigi government seems to
the cooperation in the purchase and ma- be more oriented on the infrastructure de-
nagement of fried onions which until now velopment particularly office infrastructure
does not show a clear cooperation, although while the food security program just recei-
institutionally, Perindagkop also has a pro- ves a little concern and is generally limited
gram that is strongly associated with the se- to the formal program. This food security
curity such as,: program does not encourage the change of
1. The Creation Business a Conducive Cli- mindset and attitudes for the farmers. The
mate for SMEs through SME Develop- ceremonial activity with the presence of of-
ment Facilitation ficials is certainly an effort to show the con-
2. The Program of Entrepreneurship Devel- cern and achievement of food security in the
opment and Small-Medium Enterprises society.
Competitiveness, activities: Facilitation The coverage magnitude of achie-
of promotion infrastructure development vement exposed by the government has
on production results and Cooperative addressed the people who have begun to
Management Training. understand food security presence in agri-
3. The Program of business supporting de- cultural policies to be marginalized. This si-
velopment systems for small and medium tuation creates a reduction on their interest
micro enterprises that support the social- of farming. The farmers mistrust the system
ization of information on capital provi- of government programs. Therefore, the
sion for small and medium enterprises. agricultural program is merely a pragmatic
4. The program of Cooperative Institutional program using hit-and-run system which
Quality Improvement namely, Monitor- means that the farmers only take the finan-
ing, Cooperative Achievement Award, cial support from the program and do not
evaluation monitoring, and reporting give any serious innovation because they
5. The Development Program of Small and think that the farmers are just an object and
Medium enterprises related to the facili- not the subject of agricultural program by
tation for SMEs toward Resource Utiliza- the government.
tion; Facilitation of Partnership of SMEs The infrastructure problem in Sigi Re-

UNNES JOURNALS
130 Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alamsyah, Food Security and the Futures of Farmers in Decentralisation

gency to promote food security across the that have been carried out shows that the
region is conducted by SKPD, as stated Re- reality is not intercepted with the idea of go-
gent of Sigi that: vernment toward their needs of production
way.
“... .as a new area with a wide infrastructure Lack of infrastructure is one of the
and geographical condition, the main pri- conditions that makes agriculture and far-
ority is the improvement of infrastructure ming products of the people difficult to be
construction in Sigi Regency. But through marketed outside the region. Several studies
the development of other programs, we
show that the frequency of access to agricul-
expect the achievement of other areas,
particularly food security which really tural information has the greatest influen-
needs support of infrastructure to reach ce on the behavior of farmers in addition
out to the existing locations ...” (ARL in to education, farming experience, agricul-
Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alam, 2013) tural management understanding, and the
amount of family labor or the public interest
In line with the Regent, there are other to keep farming. As the complaint of some
informants who stated that. farmers in Jono oge, that:

“..... To realize a good agricultural develop- “... The current obstacles are water chan-
ment, we must no longer create barriers nels which are much improved, but only
between the educators and the commu- the primary and secondary channels. Most
nity. We have the same vision including of these tertiary channels is still much da-
food security; even the agriculture de- maged. The problems that existed at that
partment wants to realize agricultural de- irrigation is the mechanism of P3A which
velopment through Sigi Regency agricul- should come from the Department of
tural department has significantly needed agriculture, but so far has not operated.
the help from other agencies such as Pub- Another thing is that there is limitation
lic Works Department (PU). PU should in the area of ​​Jono Oge related to the tran-
help us in terms of irrigation because we sportation and roads in Food Barn which
need to take water from a big river which is still much less ... “(FGD in Sayuti, Sul-
must pass through non-farming land. Our tan, M. Nur Alam, 2013)
expertise does not go that far. We need
engineer who can help us to build irriga- So it can be concluded that the policy
tion networks. And after our successful orientation is still partial and does not have
farmers have cultivated the production, the short or long term indicator. As part of
then we urgently need the Department of the effort to encourage the farmers’ behavior
Perindakop to pack their crops and then
is conducted through Farmer Empowerment
make our own industry to be sold. Ma-
naging such area belongs to Perindakop, of Innovation and Information Technology
our main task is to lead farmers to gain (P3TIP / FEATI). One of the parts is to en-
successful production ... “(ALK in Sayuti, courage this program is the researcher and
Sultan, M. Nur Alam, 2013) educator. This strong point of Sigi govern-
ment policy is also acting as the obstacle in
It is seen in a various programs to imp- managing the food security policy particu-
rove the road quality from and to the centers larly related to finance, coordination, struc-
of agricultural production which is directed ture, and existing commitments.
to increase the current distribution of agri- The statement of farmer professional
cultural products in each of the centers of degradation is also sated b an informant:
production to markets of Sigi. The develop-
ment of the agricultural center (farm roads) “... If we want to see the condition in Sigi,
is mainly directed to some agricultural pro- most people who were once farmers now
duction centers in all regions of Sigi Regen- become only farm laborers due to the eco-
cy. The expectation of the people from the nomic needs so they were the owner of the
land but they sold to people who could af-
method of focus group discussions (FGD)
ford. Then they became farmers again in

UNNES JOURNALS
Jurnal Komunitas 7 (1) (2015): 118-132 131

their own fields. The vast majority of land country. The reality of local autonomy in a
owners are no longer people from Sigi decentralized environment should emerge
regency. Now, there are only few people as spirit to encourage the local potential op-
who originally come from here, like in the timization in triggering more people to sur-
Jono Oge village. Additionally, high level
vive, and not vice versa, as a formality in po-
of conversion of agricultural land is po-
tentially risky. The faring land with good
tential, agricultural, and regional character
irrigation has now become housing land. and culture of the community which does
Such factor makes the change in the pat- not have a strong historical value.
tern of the former farm. The commission The success in Sigi is a short-term
II of parliament is now preparing a local effect is seen through vigorous programs
regulation on the maintenance of eternal scattered in various local work unit prima-
agricultural land, for in the new Central rily on several related institutions, but there
Sulawesi in Sigi ... “(RIV in Sayuti, Sultan, has been no effort to build synergy between
M. Nur Alam, 2013) agricultural potential, farming capacity,
the culture of farmers and Sigi government
The problem has emerged as the rea-
policies. However, the regency parliament
lity which is faced by society and therefore
should be appreciated for its initiative ef-
it becomes people’s anxiety. And institu-
forts to present a draft regulation on the pro-
tionally, the Regency Parliament as part of
tection of agricultural areas.
the public expression agency makes a good
The existing policy model which in-
breakthrough. It is certainly expected to be a
cludes communication, resources, disposi-
policy in favor of the community which can
tion or commitment and structure is still not
generate something that can keep commu-
working properly. It can be seen on the sy-
nity identity of Sigi to be better. Therefore,
nergy between several departments to care
the involvement of professional guidance
about food security. The non-optimal food
and educator is essential in order to focus
security council and the distance between
on the agricultural production economy bu-
each SKPD in practice can be a beginning
siness mechanism and not only in the pro-
or ending problems of the sustainability of
gram.
food security policy that is the constructi-
on of the state in realizing the sovereignty
CONCLUSION
of the people. It takes the support of vario-
The political climate of democracy in the era
us political will of the political leadership in
of decentralization complicates the success
the region to be able to create a model that is
of food security programs. Institutionaliza-
able to accelerate the context, the structure
tion of agricultural policy which has been
of state policy, and culture of local commu-
done is the first step to be able to trigger
nities in generating food security policies
people to care about the farming profession
which are more relevant to the local context
which is regarded by young people as a “last
and could be an example for the same area.
alternative”. This mindset puts agricultural
This study of food security gets funding sup-
employment with less respected position
port from the directorate general of higher
and it is only a matter of traditional legacy
education, ministry of education and cultu-
from a village. The process of institutiona-
re of Indonesia through Tadulako University
lization of government policy interests in a
for the advanced decentralization in 2013.
village tends to be used as a mere mobilizati-
on strategy to support popularity. Therefore,
REFERENCES
the deviation happens when too many poli- Alamsyah, M.N. 2012. Prelimanary Report State Of
tical interests take part. Local Democracy (SoLD) Assesment In, Parigi
This dilemma becomes a challenge for Moutong Indonesia. JPP UGM & IDEA Inter-
the government, considering that this po- national.
Bappeda Sigi. 2011. Dokumen Rencana Pembangunan
licy aims at increasing the local Sigi’s wel- Jangka Menengah Daerah Kab. Sigi tahun 2010-
fare and food security in the context of the 2015. Sigi: Bappeda.

UNNES JOURNALS
132 Sayuti, Sultan, M. Nur Alamsyah, Food Security and the Futures of Farmers in Decentralisation

BP4K Sigi. 2013. Data Profil Badan Penyuluh Pertani- 2013, 09.23 Wita
an, perikanan, Peternakan dan Kehutanan Kab. Kantor Ketahanan Pangan Sigi. 2012. Laporan Surplus
Sigi. Biromaru: BP4K. Minus Tanaman Pangan Kabupaten Sigi.
BPS Sigi. 2012. Kabupaten Sigi Dalam angka Tahun Kantor Ketahanan Pangan Kab. Sigi. 2012. Laporan
2011. Biromaru: Bappeda-BPS. Akuntabilitas Kinerja Kantor Ketahanan Pan-
Darwanto, D.H. 2005. Ketahanan Pangan Berbasis gan Kab. Sigi (LAKIP) Tahun 2012. Biromaru.
Produksi Dan Kesejahteraan Petani. Jurnal Kantor Ketahanan Pangan Kab. Sigi. 2011. Data Ren-
Ilmu Pertanian, 12 (2): 152 - 164. stra Kantor Ketahanan Pangan 2010-2015. Kan-
Dewan Ketahanan Pangan. 2006. Revitalisasi Perta- tor Ketahanan Pangan Kab. Sigi. Biromaru.
nian, Perikanan, dan Kehutanan. Jakarta: Ke- Kementerian Negara Riset dan Teknologi Republik
mentan RI. Indonesia. 2006. Indonesia 2005 - 2025 Buku
Dinas Perindagkop dan UMKM Kab. Sigi. 2011. Ren- Putih Penelitian, Pengembangan dan Penera-
cana Strategis Satuan Kerja PerangkatDaerah pan Ilmu Pengetahuan dan Teknologi Bidang
(Renstra SKPD) dinas perindagkop dan UMKM Ketahanan Pangan. Jakarta.
Kab. Sigi tahun 2010-2015. Biromaru: Dinas Mangunwijaya, Y.B(ed). 1993. Teknologi dan dampak
perindagkop dan UMKM. kebudayaannya, (Teknologi, Pembangunan
Dinas Pertanian, Perikanan dan Peternakan (DP3K) dan Kebudayaan). Jakarta: Yayasan Obor In-
Kab. Sigi. 2013. Data Luas Tanam Menurut donesia.
Kecamatan, Dinas Pertanian, Perikanan Dan Parsons, W. 2006. Public Policy: Pengantar Teori dan
Peternakan Kab. Sigi 2013. Biromaru: Dinas Praktik Analisis Kebijakan, Cet. ke-2. Jakarta:
Pertanian, Perikanan Dan Peternakan (DP3K) Kencana.
Kab. Sigi. Sayuti, Sultan, & Alamsyah, M.N. 2013. Kebijakan Ke-
Dinas Pertanian, Perikanan dan Peternakan (DP3K) tahanan Pangan Dalam Mendorong Perilaku
Kab. Sigi., 2013. Data Luas Tanam, Luas Puso, Kerja Petani Di Kabupaten Sigi. Laporan pene-
Luas Panen, Produktifitas Dan Produksi Tana- litian. Program Hibah Penelitian Desentral-
man Pangan Bulan Januari-Maret 2013. Biro- isasi Unggulan Perguruan Tinggi, Lembaga
maru: Dinas Pertanian, Perikanan Dan Peter- Penelitian Untad.
nakan (DP3K) Kab. Sigi. Syahyuti. 2006. Konsep penting dalam pembangunan
http://sulteng.litbang.deptan.go.id/ind/index.php/ pedesaan dan pertanian. Jakarta: BRP.
berita/4-info-aktual/339-pertemuanpemk- Winarno, B. 2007. Kebijakan Publik: Teori dan Proses
ab-sigi-dan-bptp-sulawesi-tengah-hasilkan- cet. ke-1. Yogyakarta: Media Pressindo.
4-butir-kesepakatan downloaded on 2 August

UNNES JOURNALS

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi