Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
h i g h l i g h t s g r a p h i c a l a b s t r a c t
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Heating costs in the winter and cooling costs in the summer are very high. Building insulation reduces
Received 24 June 2013 heating costs in the winter and cooling costs in the summer. Although sunflower production in Turkey
Received in revised form 7 October 2013 is significant, after the production the sunflower stem is a serious problem for farmers. Sunflower stems
Accepted 19 October 2013
are cleaned, burned or used for temporary heating purposes. This type of use is causing serious problems
Available online 15 November 2013
to the environment. Sunflower stalks and cotton textile waste, such as stubble, cause serious environ-
mental problems. To circumvent this problem, the present study puts forth an advantageous use of those
Keywords:
waste materials for insulation of buildings. In Turkey there are a lot of both of the aforementioned mate-
Sunflower stalk
Stubble
rials. As the binder for those two materials epoxy was used. As samples, 30 40 2.5 cm rectangular
Textile waste blocks were prepared under different pressures. The samples were tested for their mechanical properties
Insulation material and the coefficients of thermal conductivity, as well. The results obtained satisfied the Turkish Standard
TS 805 EN 601. Thus, the method proposed in this study solves two industrial problems at the same time.
A useful construction material is produced while some waste materials causing environmental problems
are warded off.
Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
0950-0618/$ - see front matter Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2013.10.038
H. Binici et al. / Construction and Building Materials 51 (2014) 24–33 25
O O
H2 N NH2
+ H H
O O O
H2N NH + NH NH + NH N CH2 OH
Table 2
Chemical, physical and mechanical properties of the gypsum used.
Table 4
Mixing ratio by volume.
The addition of formaldehyde to urea occurs over the entire pH range. The reac- between two rooms [17]. Sound absorption coefficients of the samples were mea-
tion rate is dependent on the pH. The rate for the addition of formaldehyde to suc- sured under the same humidity conditions. The relative humidity was 40% and
cessively form one, two, and three methylol groups has been estimated to be at the the frequency of the sound was 800 Hz1/3 octave filters were used [13].
ratio of 9:3:1 [15]. The exact ratio, of course, is dependent on the reaction condi-
tions employed in the addition reaction. The second stage of urea–formaldehyde re-
2.2.2. Insulation materials made with epoxy binder
sin synthesis consists of the condensation of the methylolureas to low molecular
The fibre insulation material was produced with sunflower stalks, cotton waste,
weight polymers. The rate at which these condensation reactions occur is very
and textile waste fibre and epoxy as binder materials. Using these raw materials,
dependent on the pH and, for all practical purposes, occurs only at acidic pHs.
various samples were produced at different rates and under different pressures.
Moisture content of samples was 0.15% and the size of the samples was 20
20 cm. The samples produced are described by the volume mixing ratios and
2.1.6. Plaster by the weight of the samples in Table 4 in Table 5, respectively.
The chemical, physical and mechanical properties of the plaster used in the The reason for the trial was to determine the heat transfer coefficient, which re-
study are given in Table 2. quired a large amount of material in the mixture and a wide range of pressures.
Initially, A, B, C, . . . Z attempts were made. Then, the heat transfer coefficient
experiments focused on examples smaller than 0.1.
2.2. Method The insulation material used in the production of the raw materials, the sun-
flower stalk fibre, the sunflower stalks, the stubble, the cotton waste, and the textile
2.2.1. Insulation boards manufactured with plaster as a binder fibre waste, are given in Figs. 6 and 7.
The grinding machine was used for the agriculture and textile wastes, which The heat insulating blocks were 14 16 2 cm in size. The production scheme
were ground in a mixture of sunflower stalks. These materials were used with plas- of the insulation material is given in Fig. 8. Each layer of insulating material was
ter as a binder. The mixing ratio of the insulation material is given in Table 3. Insu- made separately and remained under pressure for optimum compaction (Fig. 9).
lation boards that were 30 40 2.5 cm in size were attached to the wall panels The difference between the pH profiles of the two stages of urea–formaldehyde
in Figs. 4 and 5. These tests were applied to walls only. The sound and thermal insu- resin synthesis is used to advantage in the production of urea–formaldehyde adhe-
lation values of the rooms were measured. These rooms were located next to iso- sive resins. In general, the commercial production of urea–formaldehyde adhesive
lated and untreated identical rooms, and other rooms were created with the resins is performed in two major steps. The first step consists of the formation of
same points. Acoustic measurements of sound insulation in industrial buildings methylolureas by the reaction of urea and formaldehyde under basic conditions
made with fibre reinforced mud bricks, concrete bricks and red bricks were per- with a pH of 8–9. This step is performed under basic conditions to allow the meth-
formed according to the EN TS 415 [16]. The foregoing standard specifies field ylolation reactions to proceed in the absence of reactions involving the condensa-
methods for measuring the airborne sound insulation properties of interier walls tion of the methylolureas. In the second step, the reaction mixture is brought to
28 H. Binici et al. / Construction and Building Materials 51 (2014) 24–33
Table 5
Mixing ratio by weight.
the acid side, with a pH of approximately 5, and the condensation reactions are methylolation step, in which the formaldehyde-to-urea (F/U) ratio is typically large
performed until a desired viscosity is reached. Then, the reaction mixture is cooled (1.6–2). Usually, the second addition of urea is made during the condensation
and neutralised. Water is removed by vacuum distillation to give a resin with the step. The second and any subsequent additions of urea lower the final F/U ratio
desired solids content (typically approximately 60–65%). Urea is often added in to the desired level. These procedures for the synthesis of urea–formaldehyde adhe-
two, or sometimes more, steps. The initial addition of urea is made during the sive resins offer a wide range of conditions, which make possible the synthesis of
H. Binici et al. / Construction and Building Materials 51 (2014) 24–33 29
resins with important properties such as tack, gel time, and spreadability for the un- 2.2.4. Ultrasonic sound penetration velocity coefficient
cured resin. The formaldehyde emissions and the durability of the cured resin can There is a specific relationship between the wave speed and the density of the
be controlled and specifically tailored for the final end use of the resin [18]. materials. When the amount of space inside the material increases, the ultrasonic
sound penetration velocity coefficient decreases.
The time it took for a sound wave at one surface of the material to reach the
2.2.3. Thermal conductivity coefficients other surface was measured and the wave speed was calculated as follows:
The thermal conductivity coefficients of the insulation material were measured
V ¼ ðS=tÞ 106 ð1Þ
with a QTM-500 according to ASTM C 1113-90.
30 H. Binici et al. / Construction and Building Materials 51 (2014) 24–33
Table 6
Heating–cooling temperatures and sound intensity measurements in offices with/without insulation panels.
Offices tested Sound intensity Heating temperature (°C) Cooling temperature (°C)
measurement values
Room Temp. after Total heating Room Temp. after Total cooling
(dB)
temp. 60 min of temp. temp. 60 min of temp. after
heating cooling 60 min
Offices with thermal insulation 45 15 76 51 72 61 11
Offices without thermal 56 15 54 39 70 37 33
insulation
to measure sound insulation [20,21]. In this study, the noise insula- generally causes serious health problems. Therefore, this section
tion of buildings was investigated. In small cities and districts in of the experimental study showed that using various ingredients
Turkey, many small office structures are made as a type project in insulation materials decreases the effect of noise on workers in
(Fig. 5). In these buildings, people work under different levels of this type of building (Table 6). According to Table 6, the office with
sound. The use of briquettes in the walls of these buildings insulation panels had a temperature increase of over 25% with
32 H. Binici et al. / Construction and Building Materials 51 (2014) 24–33
Table 7 Table 8
The unit weight and the water absorption values of the samples. Compressive and flexural strengths of some samples (MPa).
heating above that of the office without insulation. A loss of as little The insulation materials derived from waste materials showed
as one-third of the temperature change during the cool-down was low compressive strength due to their high porosity. Sample S
observed. These results are very important for energy consumption. gives the highest compressive strength. The compressive strength
of each material with a high flexural strength is not expected to
3.2. Insulation materials made with epoxy binder be likewise higher because the flexural strength values are very
close to each other.
3.2.1. Thermal conductivity coefficients
The thermal conductivity coefficients of the samples were ob- 3.2.3. Sound insulation properties
tained (Fig. 10). The thermal conductivity coefficient of sample A The insulation boards were found to improve the sound insula-
was the highest. The lowest thermal conductivity coefficient was tion performance of walls (Fig. 13). Moreover, the boards building
obtained for sample Z2 because of the content of the material has been found to be superior to the one made with gypsum, stub-
used, the pressure applied to the materials and the porosity. Gen- ble and textile wastes in this respect. This is most probably due to
erally, samples having sunflower stalk with cottony tissue had the high porosity of the stubble. Finally, it can be concluded that
low heat transfer coefficients. Examples of heat transmission the proposed insulation boards, with gypsum, stubble and textile
coefficients of less than 0.1 are the S, N, P, and Z samples. There- wastes as ingredients, can be used in industrial buildings for walls
fore, to study their structure, the compression ratio and the to improve sound insulation.
amount of binder was varied and a much smaller heat transfer
coefficient was obtained in these samples. As shown in Fig. 9, 4. Conclusions
the sample with the lowest coefficient of conductivity,
0.0728 W/mK, was the Z2 sample. To reduce the overall heat The results of the study are given below.
transfer coefficient of the foam handle portion, sunflower, and
cotton wastes were mixed in different proportions. The sunflower 1. In the houses, in which the panels made with gypsum, were
stem portion of the volume of the foam has a great amount of applied, the heating period was shorter and the cooling period
space, and empty volumes render a low coefficient of thermal was longer compared to those of the houses in which those
conductivity possible. Some insulating materials produced are panels were not used.
shown in cross-section views in Figs. 11 and 12. 2. Sunflower stem and gypsum blocks made with binder led to
Table 7 shows the high unit volume weight of sample S and better thermal insulation in homes. According to the reference,
sample Z has the lowest weight per unit volume. This situation the house heating temperatures of these houses was higher
is explained by the increase in weight per unit volume with than during the same period of cold, which is considered to
the amount of insulation material content. The low density of be important in terms of heating costs.
the samples led to lower heat transfer coefficients. A high pro- 3. When the pressure is increased, the heat transfer coefficients
portion of the materials used contain empty space. At the same and the unit weight increase also the thermal conductivity coef-
time, the material can absorb water due to the materials used ficients of the materials depended on the fibre state, the amount
to retain water, and thus the water absorption value is expected of epoxy and especially the pressure ratio. The optimum com-
to be higher. The vacancy rate in the most effective sample, the pression value was 7 bars.
unit weight and the heat transmission coefficient were naturally 4. Examples of low heat transfer coefficients were obtained in
higher in the Z2 sample, which had the lowest water absorption group Z. The reason is the presence of more air gaps in the sam-
rate. ples. TS 805 EN 60155 requires a thermal conductivity coeffi-
cient of lower than 0.1. In this case, N, S, P, and Z can be used
3.2.2. Compressive and flexural strength as insulating materials. When the press increased, a portion of
The compressive and flexural strengths of the samples with the linker escaped from the connector in the moulds and the
thermal insulation values lower than 0.1 are given in Table 8. ratio with the binder decreased. As described in the findings,
the research materials selected the sunflower stalks, the cotton [7] Binici H, Aksogan O, Bodur MN, Akca E, Kapur S. Thermal isolation and
mechanical properties of fibre reinforced mud bricks as wall materials.
waste, show that it is possible to produce insulation materials
Construct Build Mater 2007;21:901–6.
that are sufficient to mix with epoxy. [8] Cristel O, Nady PC, Fernando T, Silvio D, Ketty B, Marie-Ange A. Sugar cane
bagasse fibres reinforced cement composites thermal considerations. Comp
Finally, the most important result of this study is that waste Part A: Appl Sci Manuf 2010;41:549–556.
[9] Zhou X, Zheng F, Li H, Lu C. An environment-friendly thermal insulation
materials, which cause environmental pollution is prevented, and material from cotton stalk fibres. Energy Build 2010;42:1070–4.
a satisfactory insulation material is produced entirely of organic [10] Frydrych I, Dziworsko G, Bilska J. Comparative analysis of the thermal
origin. The product is a candidate to be commercialized in the insulation properties of fabrics made of natural and man-made cellulose
fibres. Fibres Textiles Eastern Eur 2002;3:40–4.
future. [11] Briga-Sá A, Paiva A, Boaventura-Cunha J, Lanzinha JC. Contribution of the
trombe wall to sustainable buildings: experimental work. In: 38th IAHS world
Acknowledgement congress on housing science. Istanbul, Turkey; 2012.
[12] Binici H, Gemci R, Aksogan O, Kaplan H. Insulation properties of bricks made
with cotton and textile ash wastes. Int J Mater Res 2010;101:894–9.
This study was supported by Kahramanmaras Sutcu Imam Uni- [13] Binici H, Gemci R, Kucukonder A. Investigating the sound insulation, thermal
versity Scientific Research Projects Department with the project conductivity and radioactivity of chipboards produced with cotton waste, fly
ash and barite. Constr Build Mater 2012;30:826–32.
number 2012/4-13 M. [14] Bolat M. Use of biomass sources for energy in Turkey and a view to biomass
potential. Biomass Bioenergy 2005;29:32–41.
References [15] Pizzi A. In wood adhesives: chemistry and technology. In: Pizzi A, editor.
Marcel Dekker: New York; 1983.
[16] EN TS ISO 140–4, EN TS 2382. Acoustics-measurement of sound insulation on
[1] Thorsnes P, Bishop T. The value of basic building code insulation. Energy
buildings and of building elements part 4: field measurements of air borne
Econom 2013;37:68–81.
sound insulation between rooms.
[2] de Wilde P, Voorden M. Providing computational support for the election of
[17] Binici H, Aksogan O, Bakbak D, Kaplan H, Isik B. Sound insulation of fibre
energy saving building components. Energy Build 2004;36:749–58.
reinforced mud brick walls. Constr Build Mater 2009;23:1035–41.
[3] Aksoy TU. Investigation of the effect on overall heat transition coefficient and
[18] Conner Anthony H. Urea-formaldehyde adhesive resins, forest products
heat loss of wall applications with sandwich and aerated concrete. Erciyes
laboratory. Poly Mater, Encyclopedia 1996;11:8496–501.
Univ J Sci 2008;24:277–90. _ Karakoç M. Relationship between ultrasonic velocity
[19] Demirboğa R, Türkmen I,
[4] Mengeloglu F, Alma MH. Wheat stems using composite panel production.
and compressive strength for high-volume mineral-admixtured concrete. Cem
Kahramanmaras Sutcu Imam Univ J Eng Sci 2002;5:37–48.
Concr Res 2004;34:2329–36.
[5] Monika M, Ramaniah K, Ratna Prasad AV, Mohana Rao K, Hema Chandra Reddy
[20] Binici H, Temiz H, Aksogan O, Ulusoy A. The engineering properties of fired
K. Thermal conductivity characterization of bamboo fibre reinforced polyester
brick incorporating textile waste ash and basaltic pumice. J Faculty Eng
composite. J Mater Environ Sci 2012;3:1109–16.
Architecture Gazi Univ 2009;24:485–98.
[6] Binici H, Yucegok F, Aksogan O, Kaplan H. Effect of corncob, wheat straw and
[21] Saarinen A. Reduction of external noise by building facades: tolerance of
plane leaf ashes as mineral admixtures on concrete durability. ASCE, Civ Eng
standard EN 12354–3. Appl Acoust 2002;63:529–45.
Mater 2008;20:478–83.