Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00216-002-1263-5
O R I G I N A L PA P E R
Received: 16 July 2001 / Revised: 29 January 2002 / Accepted: 13 February 2002 / Published online: 4 April 2002
© Springer-Verlag 2002
Abstract A simple and rapid procedure, utilising con- lected trace elements and special additives [1]. A typical
stant-current stripping analysis (CCSA) at a carbon-paste example is iodine, because this bioessential element often
electrode containing tricresyl phosphate as a pasting liq- occurs in natural salt (rock and sea salts, brine from salt
uid (TCP-CPE), has been developed for the determination springs) at a very low concentrations. In commercial salt
of iodide in table salt. Because of a synergistic accumula- used for human and animal nutrition, iodine is usually
tion mechanism based on ion-pairing and extraction of io- present as added iodide or iodate. For example, while the
dide in combination with electrolytic pretreatment of the recommended minimum iodide content of iodised salts is
TCP-CPE, the method is selective for iodide and enables 5 mg KI kg–1 salt [1], the regulation for commercial prod-
direct determination of iodide in samples of table salt con- ucts in many countries requires an average KI content of
taining anticaking agents such as K4[Fe(CN)6] (food addi- 25 mg kg–1 (min. 20 and max. 30 mg kg–1). Potassium
tive “E 536”) or MgO. The iodide content (calculated hexacyanoferrate(II), labeled as food additive “E 536” is
as KI) can be determined in a concentration range of 2 to a special additive allowed to be added to table salt (max.
100 mg kg–1 salt, with a detection limit (S/N=3) of 1 mg kg–1, 10 mg kg–1) as a drying agent to prevent undesirable cak-
and a recovery from 90 to 115%. The proposed method ing and aggregation of the salt during its storage. Similar
has been used to determine iodide in several types of arti- effects can be achieved by adding other compounds such
ficially iodised table salt and in one sample of natural sea as MgO and MgCO3 [1, 2]. The additive content of salt,
salt. The results obtained agreed well with those obtained including iodide, is strictly regulated and thus must be
by use of three independent reference methods (titration, controlled at both production and public health institution
spectrophotometry, and ICP–MS) used to validate the sites. This is particularly important, because of the poten-
CCSA method, indicating that the developed method is tial harm to health and the environment caused by high
applicable as a routine procedure for rapid testing in salt concentrations of these minor constituents. Reliable, sim-
production process control and in the analysis of marketed ple, and rapid methods are therefore needed for routine
table salts. monitoring of regulated additives, including iodide, in salt.
Several methods are used for determination of (total)
Keywords Constant-current stripping analysis · iodine and iodide or iodate in table salt, e.g. classical titra-
Carbon-paste electrode · Iodide · Table salts tion (still the official method) [3, 4], traditional [5] and
modern spectrophotometry [6], flow injection [7], ion
chromatography [8], and ICP–MS [9]. These methods do,
Introduction however, have disadvantages – either they are not suffi-
ciently sensitive and/or are time-consuming (e.g. classical
Table (food grade), feeding and industrial salts are often titrimetric and spectrophotometric methods) or they re-
artificially enriched with minor constituents such as se- quire specialised and expensive equipment (ICP–MS, ion
chromatography).
Electrochemical stripping methods have been shown to
B. Ogorevc · M. Nović be a promising alternative for the measurement of iodide
Analytical Chemistry Laboratory, National Institute of Chemistry, [10, 11, 12, 13, 14]. These methods are based on:
P.O. Box 3430, 1001 Ljubljana, Slovenia
1. accumulation of iodide (or chemically pre-reduced io-
I. Švancara (✉) · K. Vytřas date) at a working electrode modified with suitable
Department of Analytical Chemistry,
Faculty of Chemical Technology, University of Pardubice,
ion-pairing agents, e.g. protonated organic esters [15]
nám. Čs. legií 565, 532 10 Pardubice, Czech Republic or cationic surfactants of the tetraalkylammonium salt
e-mail: Ivan.Svancara@upce.cz type [13], as a first step; then
796
Chemicals and solutions This official standard analytical method [3, 4] is based on chemi-
cal oxidation of iodide in the sample by use of bromine water and
All chemicals were of analytical reagent grade, except for sodium subsequent titration of the released iodine with thiosulfate stan-
chloride, which was of Suprapur quality (Merck). Stock solutions dardised against dichromate.
of NaCl (2 mol L–1, supporting electrolyte) and 0.01 mol L–1 stan-
dard solutions of KI, K4[Fe(CN)6] and K3[Fe(CN)6] were diluted
ICP–MS
as needed, daily. Testing reagent containing magnesium oxide was
an approximately 10% (m/v) suspension of MgO in water. Before
The aqueous stock solutions of samples of different table salt were
potentiometric stripping measurements all solutions were purged
prepared by dissolving approximately 100 mg salt in 100 mL de-
with pure nitrogen. De-ionised and additionally purified (Milli-Q,
ionised water. Quantification was performed by use of a standard
Millipore) water was used throughout this work.
addition method employing a standard solution containing 1.01 g L–1
iodide. The measurements were performed with a Hewlett–Packard
(Waldbronn, Germany) HP4500 element-selective inductively-
Working electrode (TCP-CPE)
coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP–MS) equipped with a
Babington nebuliser and operated under normal plasma conditions
Carbon paste was made by thorough hand-mixing of 0.5 g RW-B
(RF power 1350 W, reflected power <2 W; gas flows (L min–1):
spectroscopic graphite powder (Ringsdorff Werke, Germany) with
plasma 14.8, auxiliary 0.93, carrier 1.30; cooling temperature
0.2 mL tricresyl phosphate (mixture of isomers, Fluka). The ho-
2 °C).
mogenised carbon paste was packed into a laboratory-made elec-
trode body driven with a piston for extrusion of the paste through
a hole in the end (diameter 2 mm). Spectrophotometry
Fig. 2 Comparison of the behaviour of [Fe(CN)6]4– and Table 1 Results from analysis of some commercial table salts
[Fe(CN)6]3– with that of iodide at the TCP-CPE. A. (a) blank me- (group A samples) for iodide (CCSA) and total iodine (titrimetry
dium, (b) a+1.5×10–6 mol L–1 [Fe(CN)6]4–, (c) a+1.5×10–5 mol L–1 and ICP–MS); CCSA: constant-current stripping analysis with
[Fe(CN)6]4–; B. (a) blank, (b) a+1.5×10–6 mol L–1 [Fe(CN)6]3–, (c) TCP-CPE (the proposed method); Titration: standard method [3,
a+1.5×10–5 mol L–1 [Fe(CN)6]3–, (d) a+4×10–6 mol L–1 I-; other 4]; ICP–MS: for details, see Experimental. All results and label-
conditions as for Fig. 1 declared data are given in mg KI kg–1 salt; results are given as
means from three replicate analyses. Sample specifications are
given in the text
of 4×10–6 mol L–1 I– was found to be satisfactory; the rela-
Sample Declared content Found
tive standard deviation (r.s.d.) was approximately 5%
(n=7). KI K4[Fe(CN)6] CCSA Titration ICP–MS
Hexacyanoferrate(II) as a possible component of table
or feeding salt might be a potentially concurrent ion-pair- A1 20–30 – 25.7±3.1 20.6a 24.1b
A2 “Added”c “Added” 12.6±3.3 22.1 25.4
ing species in the CCSA determination of iodide. Because
A3 – – 2.6±1.9 0.8 1.2
hexacyanoferrate(II) is readily converted into hexacyano-
A4a 22 “Added” 34.2±5.1 – –
ferrate(III), and vice versa [24], both anions were consid-
A4b 22 “Added” 18.0±2.1 – –
ered as potential interferents in this work. Figure 2 dis-
A4c 22 “Added” 8.1±2.3 – –
plays the CCSA behaviour at the TCP-CPE in the pres- A4d 22 “Added” 25.1±3.9 18.1d 25.6
ence of different concentrations of either [FeII(CN)6]4– or
[FeIII(CN)6]3– ions (A, B; curves b, c) compared with that ar.s.d. ca 5% at 20 mg kg–1, 25% at 1 mg kg–1 (the limit of the
in the presence of iodide ions (curve d). The concentra- method)
br.s.d. ca 5% over the whole concentration range
tions of both species in model solutions were chosen to cotherwise unspecified
correspond to the maximum admissible potassium hexa- dan unclear solution was obtained after dissolution of the table salt
i.e. each time employing a new TCP-CPE, because the tion, Youths, and Sports of the Czech Republic (Kontakt ME 241).
lifetime of this type of electrode is 3 weeks, maximum The authors wish to thank Dr I. Grabec Svegl and Dr B. Divjak
(NIC) for conducting standard titrimetric and ICP–MS analysis.
[15].
Conclusions References
A novel rapid and simple method based on CCSA at the 1. Belitz HD, Grosch W (1994) Food Chemistry. Springer, Berlin,
pp 718–719
TCP-CPE is presented for the determination of iodide in 2. EC Directive No. 95/2/EC on food additives other than colours
table salt in the presence of some anticaking agents. Be- and sweeteners (OJ L 061, 18.03.95, p 1; amended, OJ L 086,
cause of the excellent selectivity of the TCP-CPE for io- 28.03.97, p 4; OJ L 295, 04.11.98, p 18)
dide, the procedure proposed enables direct analysis of 3. Cunniff P (1995) (ed) Official Methods of Analysis, 16th edn.
AOAC International, AOAC Official Method 925.56, Arling-
table and related salts without sample pretreatment. The ton (USA), Vol. I, p 31
method utilises a unique accumulation mechanism at the 4. Ettel W, et al. (1997) (eds) Schweiz Lebensmittelbuch Kapitel
TCP-CPE based on both ion-pairing and extraction, in ef- 37, Section B 5–5.1, 5.2, 5.3
fective combination with computer-controlled constant- 5. Sandell EB, Kolthoff IM (1937) Mikrochim Acta I:9
6. Fischer PW, L’Abbe MR, Giroux A (1986) J Assoc Off Anal
current stripping analysis [16, 27]. In addition, the CCSA Chem 69:687
procedure combined with pre-reduction is fully applicable 7. Sun JY, Chen XG, Hu ZD (1997) Fresenius J Anal Chem
for analysis of table salts containing iodate [26]. 357:1002
The iodide determination is rapid, and easy to perform, 8. Hu W, Haddad PR, Hasebe K, Tanaka K, Tong P, Khoo C
because quite simple measurement operations and elec- (1999) Anal Chem 71:1617
9. Larsen EH, Ludwigsen MB (1997) J Anal At Spectrom 12:435
trode pretreatment and regeneration steps are involved. 10. Lu GH, Yang M, Zheng QF, Wang AL, Jin ZX (1995) Electro-
The method combining CCSA with the TCP-CPE seems analysis 7:591
to be an interesting alternative to the classical (official) 11. Kwak MK, Park DS, Won MS, Shim YB (1996) Electroanaly-
titration and spectrophotometric procedures. Compared sis 8:680
12. Svancara I, Konvalina J, Schachl K, Kalcher K, Vytras K (1998)
with these the CCSA method is simpler, analyses can be Electroanalysis 10:435
performed much more rapidly, and the whole procedure 13. Svancara I, Cermakova I, Goessler W, Kalcher K, Vytras K (1999)
seems to be attractive economically because of the spar- Sci Pap Univ Pardubice, Ser A 5:95
ing use of chemicals and reagents. Compared with ICP– 14. Walcarius A, Lefevre G, Rapin JP, Renaudin G, Francois M
(2001) Electroanalysis 13:313
MS this method requires significantly less expensive 15. Svancara I, Vytras K (1993) Anal Chim Acta 273:195
equipment and levels of accuracy and reliability are com- 16. Vytras K, Konvalina J (1998) Electroanalysis 10:787
parable. 17. Ostapczuk P (1993) Anal Chim Acta 273:35
Analyses of real salt samples validated by three inde- 18. Dean RB, Dixon WJ (1951) Anal Chem 23:636
pendent reference methods have demonstrated that the 19. Jagner D (1982) Analyst 107:593
20. Svancara I, Schachl K (1999) Chem Listy 93:490
method based on CCSA and the TCP-CPE is particularly 21. Rice M, Galus Z, Adams RN (1983) J Electroanal Chem 143:
suitable for rapid testing (screening) of the iodide level 89
and its uniform distribution in iodised marketed table salt, 22. Ravinchandran K, Baldwin RP (1984) Anal Chem 56:1744
in public health control service, in salt mixtures (after 23. Wang J, Desmukh BK, Bonakdar M (1985) J Electroanal Chem
194:339
component additions and homogenisation), or in the con- 24. Kalcher K (1986) Analyst 111:625
trol of salt-production processes. 25. Konvalina J, Svancara I, Vytras K, Kalcher K (1997) Sci Pap
Univ Pardubice, Ser A, 3:153
Acknowledgements This work was supported by the Ministry of 26. Konvalina J (2001) PhD Thesis, University of Pardubice, Par-
Education, Science, and Sport of the Republic of Slovenia dubice
(P1–0509–0104, 3311–01–838008) and by the Ministry of Educa- 27. Konvalina J, Vytras K (2001) Chem Listy 95: 344