Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Ana Clemmer
IR 2/10-GT
4 June 2019
INTRODUCTION:
After years of college, medical school, and practice, healthcare professionals are well
educated and trained, and expected to perform faultlessly in each scenario they face in their
professional roles. But, when it comes to challenges that are still emerging and there is new
professionals still follow the best practices? Doctors are trained in appropriate prescription of
antimicrobials, but do they always follow those precepts? There are standard practices for
cleanliness within healthcare settings, but still microbes spread diseases within these facilities,
with antimicrobial resistance developing as one of the consequences. Handwashing and other
forms of hand hygiene are both well-known and widespread methods of preventing the spread of
disease. However, hand hygiene is not always implemented correctly by healthcare professionals
to prevent the spread of disease and the potential for the spread of antimicrobial resistance
persists. What about when it comes to the general public? Most people are not experts, and have
various levels of knowledge about antimicrobial resistance, some of it possibly being false. How
do their knowledge, attitudes and practices align with the correct ones, and what do they witness
resistance is very low, with attitudes not holding much concern, and a result of risky
BACKGROUND:
Though antimicrobial resistance has been known for decades, it is still a growing
problem. Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) was identified within 20 years after the development
hospital-acquired infection (Labricciosa, 2018). AMR increases mortality, medical costs, and
length of hospital stays (World Health Organization [WHO], 2018). Over 23,000 people die
annually as a direct result of antibiotic resistant infections (“The End of Antibiotics?” 2018).
Antimicrobial resistance develops through the effect of the antimicrobial being neutralized, and
thus the microbes avoid the lethal effect of the antimicrobial drug. The exposure to antibiotics
can create selective pressure, killing susceptible bacteria and allowing antibiotic resistant
bacteria to survive and multiply. Also, bacteria can mutate and transfer antimicrobial resistance
genes, contributing to the antimicrobial resistance gene pool (“Antibiotic resistance: questions
and answers”).
Incorrect prescription of antimicrobials is one the driving factors behind the emergence of
effective approach to decrease the emergence of antibiotic resistance (ABR) which is one for of
Clemmer 3
prescribing incorrect antibiotics or prescribing an antibiotic for the incorrect period of time. So,
resistance from developing (Pokrywka, 2016). Healthcare professionals are educated in the
antimicrobials does not always align with their training. Patients can have a significant effect
this can be quite detrimental as patients know the antibiotics which they want prescribed, and
often the patients will react negatively or even not return to a doctor if they do not receive the
drug prescriptions which they think they need (Sanchez, et al., 2014). Patients and healthcare
professionals disagree on the best process for antimicrobial selection and prescription in other
ways as well. Some patients believe a larger group of healthcare professionals should be
and inefficient this process would be in the prescription of antimicrobials (Holland, et al., 2016).
The majority of doctors responding to a research questionnaire in Lima, Peru agree that the
demand by patients for certain antibiotics contributes to the overuse of antibiotics in hospitals
(García, et al., 2011). Often, patients are not aware of the severe consequences of misusing
pathogens, and how antimicrobial resistance could affect them personally. Those patients who do
know about antimicrobial resistance may not care, assuming that new antimicrobial drugs will be
formulated, and thus combating the dire effects of antimicrobial resistance through innovation
(Sanchez, et al., 2014). Also, the attitudes of healthcare professionals toward antimicrobials
Clemmer 4
affect their practice. A dominant categorical gist for both patients and doctors is “why not take a
risk” (Broniatowski, et al., 2018). Clinicians who follow the “why not take a risk” approach
assume antimicrobial therapy is “essentially harmless” (Klein, et al., 2017). In fact, antimicrobial
therapy is not harmless, since reckless use can lead to antimicrobial resistance. Additionally,
physicians tend to be rigid and habits are hard to change (Sanchez, et al., 2014). Because medical
education related to the prescription of antimicrobials mainly revolves around what to prescribe
versus what not to prescribe, this sets a faulty foundation for practice and a tendency towards
rigidness of habits can be a barrier to correction of practice over time (Janet Robinson, personal
communication, 2019). In summary, though healthcare professionals are educated in the field of
indicates that their practice does not always reflect their knowledge.
Healthcare workers are aware of the necessity of cleanliness and general sanitation to
prevent the spread of infections, including those which are antimicrobial resistant. Both
disinfection and cleanliness are vital in the hospital, disinfection referring to reducing the number
of bacteria present, which in most cases means decreasing the presence of soils. Cleaning must
take place prior to disinfection, since it allows for disinfection to be optimized. Proper cleaning
is cost-effective and should be more of a major part of reducing the increase of antibiotic
resistance (Malavaud, 2016). However, it is one of the topics with the lowest levels of
consultations between patients and healthcare professionals (Smith, et al., 2017). It is almost like
a second thought, indicating its lack of priority for this precaution. Cleanliness can include
cleansing operating room garb, as well as various surfaces throughout the hospital setting.
Operating room nurses have a high amount of bacterial growth and recolonization on their glove
Clemmer 5
cuffs, which is often overlooked (Wistrand, et al., 2018). This lack of attention toward such areas
may lead to cross-infection. Cross infection is defined as the transfer of infection, which can
include antimicrobial resistant diseases. There are numerous areas which could contribute to the
spread of disease, and require proper cleaning. Areas such as surfaces near patients are often
properly cleaned, however there are more causes for concern in other areas that are not
prioritized for proper cleaning, such as in showers, sinks, toilets, and with the management of
human waste (Malavaud, 2016). In short, good cleanliness and sanitation help to prevent the
spread of disease, and thus prevent the spread of antimicrobial resistant disease. And, any
lacking in cleanliness and sanitation can contribute to the spread of antimicrobial resistance.
Hand hygiene prevents the spread of infections, thus preventing the spread of ABR
infections (HCAIs). Consistent with the timing of a program which successfully improved hand
hygiene (HH), the HCAI rate decreased by half in a hospital in Saudi Arabia (Al Kuwaiti, 2017).
Though the methods to prevent antimicrobial resistance are known, antimicrobial is still a
growing problem due to practices not always coming up to the stringent best practices needed in
healthcare settings. People, including healthcare workers and the general public, are aware that
they should wash their hands, however they do not implement this in their everyday life, as they
do not wash their hands appropriately. Handwashing has been proven to be a strong but
care units of a tertiary hospital, 86% of respondents were knowledgeable about the relation
between dirty hands and infection. However, only 28% practice correct handwashing techniques
Clemmer 6
(Adegboye, et al., 2018). This indicates that only approximately one third of knowledgeable
respondents practiced correctly. Additionally, healthcare workers may need a program to aid in
the adoption of hand hygiene guidelines, suggesting that they are not being followed
appropriately prior to said program (Creedon, 2005). There are numerous negative attitudes
contamination. Users of practices, such as the use of alcohol-based handrubs (ABHR), may have
low acceptability and tolerance. This was shown in a study on the hand hygiene of nurses, where
25% of the respondents had poor acceptability and tolerance. Due attention is not paid to
handwashing due to carelessness, and entire areas of the hand are often neglected during
sanitation. Namely, areas on the back of the fingers and on fingers are most often missed during
handwashing (Ataee, R., et al., 2017). Though respondent attitudes towards handwashing are
primarily positive in an Irish study conducted in 2007 and 2015, a large number of respondents
did not use proper hand washing techniques (Kingston, et al., 2017). Hand hygiene is
and the lack of appropriate hand hygiene practice shows that knowledge and practices are
disconnected. This is one of the practices used to combat antimicrobial resistance, and the
People, including healthcare workers and the general public, are aware that they should
wash their hands, however they do not practice proper handwashing at all of the critical times
consistently in their everyday life. Handwashing has been proven to be a strong but underused
(Pokrywka, 2016). In a Nigerian study conducted on healthcare workers in intensive care units of
a tertiary hospital, 86% of respondents were knowledgeable about the relation between dirty
hands and infection. However, only 28% practice correct handwashing techniques (Adegboye, et
al., 2018). This indicates that only a third of the respondents with the knowledge of the need for
good hand hygiene actually practiced this infection prevention measure. Healthcare workers may
need a promotion program to facilitate the adoption of hand hygiene guidelines (Creedon, 2005).
There are numerous attitudes, such as carelessness, which have a negative consequence in
handwashing practice and the resultant incomplete removal of the contamination source from
hands. Use of other hand hygiene practices such as the use of alcohol-based handrubs, also face
acceptability and tolerance challenges. This was shown in a study on the hand hygiene of nurses,
where 25% of the respondents reported a lack of acceptability and tolerance of ABHR. Due
attention is not paid to handwashing due to carelessness, and entire areas of the hand are often
neglected during sanitation. Namely, areas on the back of the fingers and on fingers are most
often missed during handwashing (Ataee, R., et al., 2017). Though respondent attitudes towards
handwashing are primarily positive in an Irish study conducted in 2007 and 2015, a large number
of respondents did not use proper hand washing techniques (Kingston, et al., 2017). Hand
setting, and a persistent lack of appropriate hand hygiene practice shows that knowledge and
practices are disconnected. Proper hand washing is one of the practices used to combat
antimicrobial resistance, and the disconnection between knowledge and practice is detrimental to
METHODS:
Survey 2: KAP survey of the general population of Maryland (observing Maryland physicians).
In this questionnaire, ‘antimicrobial resistance’ was referred to as ‘antibiotic resistance,’ and will
be referred to as such in the results and discussion to ensure accuracy and consistency.
P2 Does your doctor ever write an antibiotic prescription for you when they
seem unsure you need it?
Scale of 1-5, 1=Never, 5=Often
P3 During a visit to the doctor when you're sick, does your doctor address
hand-washing practices or use of a hand sanitizer?
Scale of 1-5, 1=Never, 5=Often
P4 If a doctor does not prescribe an antibiotic when you are sick, does your
doctor address why an antibiotic is not being given?
Scale of 1-5, 1=Never, 5=Often
Clemmer 9
P5 When your doctor prescribes an antibiotic to you, does your doctor instruct
you on proper use of the antibiotic?
Scale of 1-5, 1=Never, 5=Often
P6 Do you see the doctor washing their hands during your visit?
Scale of 1-5, 1=Never, 5=Often
P7 When you visit the doctor, do you ever have concerns about antibiotic
resistance and ask about it?
Scale of 1-5, 1=Never, 5=Often
RESULTS:
professionals in the United States, all 7 respondents answered correctly for knowledge questions,
and strongly agreed that AMR is a problem in the United States and in Maryland. Additionally,
none of the respondents receive reports on local AMR data. However, this survey is not
In the second Knowledge, Attitudes, and Practices survey, this one conducted on the
general population of Maryland, the majority of the 190 respondents, 69.5% answered correctly
(False) to the first and more tricky knowledge question: “Antibiotic resistance occurs when a
person becomes resistant to antibiotics. True or False?” For the next true or false question,
“Antibiotic resistance occurs when bacteria become resistant to antibiotics. True or False?,”
96.8% of respondents answered correctly (True). Granted, these questions were not very
difficult, but they did show that the general population of Maryland is knowledgeable about
antimicrobial resistance at least at a minimal level. However, the respondents’ opinion of their
own knowledge indicated 41.8% of respondents answered on the lower side (1-2) of the 1-5 scale
for the first question, “How much do you know about antibiotic resistance?” Answer 1
Clemmer 10
represented minimal knowledge, with 5 representing “I know a lot.” On the other hand, 29% of
respondents think their knowledge is on the upper side (4-5) of the scale, with 29.5% answering
number 3 in the middle of the scale. This indicates that the general population of Maryland
thinks that they have at least a relatively good understanding of antimicrobial resistance.
antimicrobial resistance is a large problem in the United States. 28.4% of respondents agree that
antimicrobial resistance is a large problem worldwide, with 32.6% strongly agreeing, resulting in
a majority 61% respondents agreeing that antimicrobial resistance is a large problem worldwide.
35.3% of respondents agree that antimicrobial resistance is a large problem in the United States,
with 37.4% strongly agreeing, resulting in a majority of 72.7% respondents agreeing that
antibiotic resistance is a large problem in the United States. This indicates that Marylanders tend
to think that antimicrobial resistance is more of a problem in the United States more than it is
worldwide.
The practices of Maryland physicians observed by the Maryland general public were
quite revealing. Only 43.6% of respondents often see their doctor wash their hands during their
visit. At less than half, this is a scarily low percentage of doctors to be performing one of the
most basic tasks in the prevention of both the spread of disease and antimicrobial resistance.
Similarly, only 48.9% of respondents reported their doctors often instructing them on proper use
of the antibiotic prescribed. This can be especially detrimental, especially for patients who are
less knowledgeable. Furthermore, 45.8% respondents reported their doctors never or almost
never address hand hygiene while counseling them during a visit. But, 35.8% of respondents said
Clemmer 11
that their doctors did address hand hygiene with them. For antibiotic counseling, 53.1%
respondents reported their doctors address why an antibiotic is not being prescribed when the
patient is sick. Doing this can help educate patients about antibiotics, thus preventing the patients
from taking actions that may encourage the spread and emergence of antimicrobial resistance or
64.2% of Marylander respondents never or almost never observe their doctors prescribing
antibiotics when the doctor seems unsure if it is needed or not, only 15.3% of respondents said
that their doctors often or occasionally prescribe antibiotics when the doctor seems unsure if they
DISCUSSION:
Though the amount of respondents was not statistically significant in the first KAP
survey, 100% of the U.S. healthcare professionals answered all of the knowledge questions
correctly, whereas in international studies, a smaller percentage of the respondents answered the
knowledge questions correctly. The U.S. healthcare professional respondents know more about
antimicrobial resistance than the general population of Maryland (as measured in the second
KAP survey, with 100% accuracy in healthcare professionals versus lower accuracy in the
general population. Also, U.S. healthcare professionals and the general population differ in their
worldwide, and only 32.6% of Maryland’s general population strongly agreeing that
antimicrobial resistance is a large problem worldwide. This is also the case in attitudes towards
Clemmer 12
antimicrobial resistance within the United States, with only 37.4% of Maryland’s general
population strongly agreeing that antimicrobial resistance is a large problem in the United States,
request an antibiotic prescription when it is not being offered. No respondents said they often
request an antibiotic prescription when it is not being offered, and only 5.3% do so occasionally.
Thus, the report by the general population is that they have a good practice towards antibiotic
prescriptions. However, the general population tends to not be very concerned about antibiotic
resistance, since 72.1% of respondents never or almost never have concerns about antibiotic
resistance and ask the doctor about it. Only 8.4% of respondents occasionally or often ask their
Marylanders overwhelmingly do not request an antimicrobial when it is not being given, whereas
in a Peruvian study, doctors claim that one of the major reasons for overuse of antimicrobials in
hospitals is due to patients’ demand for antimicrobials (García, et al., 2011). This would indicate
that patient requests for antimicrobials are less of a reason for antimicrobial resistance in
Maryland than Peru, though it should be noted that the Peru results are doctor reports of patients
while the Maryland results are patient reports of themselves, each with their own bias.
from a similar Canadian study. Primarily, 87.5% of Canadian physicians report addressing
hand-washing practices and 75% report addressing hand sanitizer during a consultation. In
contrast, only 14.2% of Maryland physicians address either of these things often, with 33.1%
Clemmer 13
addressing it occasionally, and 26.3% sometimes (as reported by patients). Overall, only 73.6%
of Maryland physicians are reported to address hand hygiene with patients at least semi
regularly, 13.9% less than Canadian physicians. Furthermore, 99% of Canadian physicians report
that they instruct patients in antibiotic use, while only 48.9% of Maryland patients report that
physicians often instruct them in the use of antibiotics being prescribed while the number is 91%
of Maryland physicians are reported to instruct antibiotic use ever, which is still low for another
key element of patient interaction. Moreover, 99% of Canadian physicians address why an
antibiotic is not being given, while only 53.1% of Maryland physicians often or occasionally do
this. This may lead to lack of patient trust in the doctor, and the patient seeking other ways to
receive an antibiotic, thus misusing antibiotics. Again, in the Maryland study, results are from
reported observations by the general population, who may not remember everything they
observed. In the Canadian study, responses are self reported by physicians, and there is likely
some bias towards reporting correct practices of oneself when answering these questions as a
healthcare professional.
CONCLUSION:
Data collected has proven that some practices of Maryland healthcare professionals
concerning antimicrobial resistance do not match knowledge, thus leading to the risk of an
increase in antimicrobial resistance. The difference between the practices of international and
counseling patients in handwashing and explaining why an antibiotic is not being prescribed.
Clemmer 14
However, Peru physicians reported being more affected by patients in writing prescription than
what was observed of Maryland physicians. The general population of Maryland seems to have a
relatively good knowledge of antimicrobial resistance, for lay people, and practice appropriate
behaviors for some of the practices which could prevent the risk of antimicrobial resistance.
Clemmer 15
Works Cited
Adegboye, M. B., Zakari, S., Ahmed, B. A., & Olufemi, G. H. (2018). Knowledge, awareness
and practice of infection control by health care workers in the intensive care units of a
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/antibiotic-resistance
Ataee, R. A., Ataee, M. H., Mehrabi Tavana, A., & Salesi, M. (2017). Bacteriological Aspects of
Hand Washing: A Key for Health Promotion and Infections Control. International
Broniatowski, D. A., Klein, E. Y., May, L., Martinez, E. M., Ware, C., & Reyna, V. F. (2018).
Infections in the Acute Care Setting. Medical Decision Making, 38(5), 547–561.
García, C., Llamocca, L. P., García, K., Jiménez, A., Samalvides, F., Gotuzzo, E., & Jacobs, J.
(2011). Knowledge, attitudes and practice survey about antimicrobial resistance and
Holland, T. L., Mikita, S., Bloom, D., Roberts, J., McCall, J., Collyar, D., Santiago, J., Tiernan,
Clemmer 16
R., … Toerner, J. (2016). Patient and physician attitudes regarding risk and benefit in
Kingston, L. M., Slevin, B. L., O’Connell, N. H., Dunne, C. P. (2017). Hand hygiene: Attitudes
and practices of nurses, a comparison between 2007 and 2015. American Journal of
Klein, E. Y., Martinez, E. M., May, L., Saheed, M., Reyna, V., Broniatowski, D. A. (2017).
Labricciosa, F. M., Sartelli, M., Correia, S., Abbo, L. M., Severo, M., Ansaloni, L., Coccolini, F.,
Alves, C., Melo, R. B., Baiocchi, G. L., Paiva, J. A., Catena, F., … Azevedo, A. (2018).
Malavaud, S. F. F., (2016) Hospital cleaning, a key element to prevent cross-transmission and
Pires, D., Tartari, E., Bellissimo-Rodrigues, F., & Pittet, D. (2017). Why language matters: a tour
through hand hygiene literature. Antimicrobial resistance and infection control, 6, 65.
Pokrywka, M., Buraczewski, M., Frank, D., Dixon, H., Ferrelli, J., Shutt, K., Yassin, M. (2017).
Can improving patient hand hygiene impact Clostridium difficile infection events at an
Sanchez, G. V., Roberts, R. M., Albert, A. P., Johnson, D. D., & Hicks, L. A. (2014). Effects of
Smith, C. R., Pogany, L., Foley, S., Wu, J., Timmerman, K., Gale-Rowe, M., & Demers, A.
(2017). Canadian physicians' knowledge and counseling practices related to antibiotic use
Ventola, C. L. (2015a). The antibiotic resistance crisis: part 1: causes and threats. P & T : a
Ventola, C. L. (2015b). The antibiotic resistance crisis: part 2: management strategies and new
agents. P & T : a peer-reviewed journal for formulary management, 40( 5), 344-52.
Wistrand, C., Söderquist, B., Falk-Brynhildsen, K., & Nilsson, U. (2018). Exploring bacterial
growth and recolonization after preoperative hand disinfection and surgery between
operating room nurses and non-health care workers: a pilot study. BMC infectious