A.

Solution Number 1
Use Quantitave Strategic Planning Matrix to select the most attractive from feasible alternative
strategic. Because the material is CPO and categorized as crude oil, so the available option is the
ship that design to carry the crude oil such as Tanker Long Range, Aframax Tanker, Suezmax
Tanker, Very Large Crude Carrier (VLCC) and Ultra Large Crude Carrier(ULCC). But, VLCC and
ULCC just to big to can be handle by Belawan Liquid Docks.

Steps to use of QSPM are :

1. Use Analytical Hirarchi Process to determine the weight of each criterion that used to select
the best alternatives ship.
2. Determine the attractiveness score (AS)relatives to other strategic
3. Sum the Total Attractiveness score (TAS). TAS is sum product weight of criterion and
attractiveness score.

Step 1 : Use Analytical Hirarchi Process to determine the weight of each criterion that used to select the
best alternatives ship.

Maximum Maximum
Supply Quay Length
Capacity Depth
Supply 1 0.333333333 0.2 0.333333333
Maximum
3 1 0.333333333 0.333333333
Capacity
Maximum
5 3 1 3
Depth
Quay Length 3 3 0.333333333 1
Total 12 7.333333333 1.866666667 4.666666667

Maximum Maximum Eigen

Supply Quay Length Weight
Capacity Depth Factor
Supply 0.083333333 0.045454545 0.107142857 0.071428571 0.307359 0.07684
Maximum
0.25 0.136363636 0.178571429 0.071428571 0.636364 0.159091
Capacity
Maximum
0.416666667 0.409090909 0.535714286 0.642857143 2.004329 0.501082
Depth
Quay Length 0.25 0.409090909 0.178571429 0.214285714 1.051948 0.262987
Total 4 1
Consistency Test
Supply 4.135211268
Maximum
4.049886621
Capacity
Maximum
4.293736501
Depth
 Quay Length 4.326474623
lambda 4.201327253
CI 0.067109084
Faktor n 0.9
CR 0.074565649

Because CR<0.1, so the weight is consistent

Step 2 : Determine the attractiveness score and total attractiveness score.

QSPM Tanker Long Range Alframac Tanker Suezmax Tanker

Factor Weight AT ATS AT ATS AT ATS
Supply 0.076839827 2 0.153679654 3 0.230519481 4 0.307359307
Maximum
Capacity of 0.159090909 4 0.636363636 2 0.318181818 1 0.159090909
Liquid Docks
Maximum
0.501082251 4 2.004329004 2 1.002164502 1 0.501082251
Depth
Quay Length 0.262987013 3 0.788961039 2 0.525974026 1 0.262987013
Total 3.583333333 2.076839827 1.230519481

From the QSPM above, the most attractive ship to serve the need of CPO is Tanker Long Range 1.