Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
TABLE OF CONTENTS
COMMIT
10 How I Revise
CHANEL CLEETON
WORKING THROUGH IT
26
That Doesn’t Mean What You Think It Means
ROSS PETRAS & KATHRYN PETRAS
Illustration, NATHAN GELGUD
Give the same plot to ten dif- never be compelled by your ing a moment’s thought to your
ferent writers and you will get voice. With luck, others will fall voice. But just as knowing and
ten very different stories. No in love with it. understanding your core story
two will sound alike. Why? can be extremely useful at vari-
Because every author brings a Voice is hard to define because ous points in your career, so, too,
unique voice to the craft of writ- it’s a mix of so many things — is having a clear sense of your
ing. Voice is everything when it your core values, your world voice. If you comprehend its
comes to telling a story. view, your personality, your strengths and weaknesses you
sense of optimism or cynicism will be able to figure out how
It isn’t clever plot twists or deep or despair or anger or bitterness to sharpen it and make it more
character insights or detailed or hope — all those things are powerful.
descriptions that draw a reader bound up in your storytelling
back again and again to a par- voice. How do you identify your writ-
ticular writer — it’s the writer’s ing voice? Here’s a simple exer-
voice. Just to make things even And then there’s the craft as- cise: Write a scene from start to
more complicated, the truth is pect. finish. It should be a scene that
that no two people respond to is infused with the emotions,
a writer’s voice in exactly the You can write successfully for themes, or conflicts that compel
same way. Some readers will your entire career without giv- you as a writer.
It is helpful to think of scenes as Did you scare your reader? Did Listen to your writing voice. It
short stories. They have a begin- you make that reader want to will tell you what kinds of sto-
ning that engages the reader, a know what happens next? Your ries you will write with the most
middle in which emotional and goal is to identify the single power. Once you have figured
often physical action takes place, strongest emotion that the reader out your voice, do everything
and an endpoint that either re- experienced while reading your you can to strengthen it and
solves the narrative or provides scene. That response will help make it more compelling.
a cliffhanger that leads into the you analyze the strengths and
next scene. weaknesses of your voice. The Voice is your superpower.
worst possible reaction from Discover it.
Give your scene to a couple of a reader is no emotional reac-
people to read. These should be tion at all. There is nothing that
people you trust. Make it clear will kill a writing career faster
JAYNE ANN KRENTZ is the
that you do not want a writing than storytelling that bores the author of Promise Not to Tell.
critique. You are not interested reader.
in their opinion of your charac-
ters or your plot. You want one Put the most engaging elements
response, and one only, to the of your voice on display in the
following question: “What is very first sentence of your book.
your emotional takeaway from Readers will not give you a few
that scene?” pages or a couple of chapters to
get the story going. You must
Did you make your reader’s draw the reader into your world
pulse kick up? Did you arouse from the very first sentence, and
LEARN MORE
curiosity? Anger? Sympathy? you do that with your voice.
I frequently say that the most always start with a revision pull out my red pen. For me, this
predictable part of my writing pass on my computer. Since I is where the magic happens.
process is how unpredictable it often take months to write the There’s something about editing
is. As a writer, I’m a “pantser” initial draft, I read through your work in print that really
— someone who drafts without the entire manuscript with the helps you polish your writing. I
plotting a great deal. Instead of aim of getting a holistic view spend a lot of time at this stage
utilizing an outline as I write, I of the book. I’ll frequently dis- working on sentence structure,
favor following where the story cover that something I wrote word choice, and adding layers
takes me with a general idea of when I started the book needs and depth to the story.
the book’s conclusion. The jour- to be tweaked to fall in line with
When I’ve finished this second
ney is different for each book I where the story took me later on.
pass, I email the updated manu-
write, and I frequently find sur- This revision pass helps me gain
script to my e-reader. I’ve found
prises along the way. However, a better sense of how the overall
that I am much more likely to
as unpredictable as penning the story is working and whether
catch typos, mistakes, and awk-
first draft of my novel is, my re- any plot holes exist or character
ward phrasing when I change
vision process never varies, and development is needed. I’m also
the medium with which I view
that reliable system is a source fixing obvious flaws that jump
my book. If I’m used to look-
of great comfort as I hone my out at me.
ing at it a certain way, it’s easy
novel.
After I’ve reacquainted myself to skip over things, but with va-
Once I’ve finished the first draft with the book and tweaked the riety, it feels fresh each time I
of my manuscript, I implement plot and characters as neces- revise. At this level, I’m mainly
my tried-and-true system. I sary, I print out a hard copy and doing the never-ending typo
search as well as cleaning up (and then we start the editorial work across different mediums.
any awkward phrasing. I’ll also process); others need nine or It offers a fresh perspective —
look for any formatting issues more revision passes. The goal and you’ll be surprised what you
that jump out at me that make is to reach the point where I’m find!
the manuscript less readable in not making significant changes
a digital format, like unwieldy at the e-reader stage.
paragraphs. CHANEL CLEETON is the
Because I often start writing a author of Next Year in Havana.
Following these three revision book with a skeleton of an idea
passes, I usually take a step and I love the freedom of being
back and decide if I’m happy able to explore the direction in
with the book, or if it needs more which my characters and plot
tweaking. The digital pass really take me, the structure of my
informs that decision, because revision process really works
it’s the draft when I truly read as a safety net. Whenever I feel
the book as a reader would. If stuck in the drafting process or
there are still things that are realize something isn’t working
pulling me out of the story, or in the book, I push through with
L E A R N M OR E
something isn’t working for me, the knowledge that the revision
I’ll restart the revision process process will provide an oppor-
and go through each step again. tunity to make the book shine.
Some books only need three re- Whether you’re a plotter or a
vision passes before I’m comfort- pantser like me, I recommend
able sending them to my editor taking the time to revise your
“Write what you know.” perspective of three drastically other things — implicit bias and
different characters. racism, especially in the con-
It’s a quote often attributed to
text of modern day American
Mark Twain, and familiar ad- There’s Camille Gray, wife of
education.
vice amongst writers. So famil- a corporate executive, stay-at-
iar, in fact, it could be considered home mother of three, perpetual
Camille Gray is a white woman
cliché. I have nothing against volunteer and longtime PTA
who’s never given much thought
Mr. Twain, I just prefer to take chairwoman; Jen Covington, a
to how white her world is, or
those four words and raise them career nurse adjusting to life as a
how that whiteness has shaped
to six: transracial family thanks to her
her. Jen Covington is also
recently adopted seven-year- old
white, but her daughter is black.
Write what you want to know. daughter; and Anaya Jones, a
Because of this, Jen is increas-
first-year teacher at an affluent
Or better yet, write what you ingly aware of (and uncomfort-
school district that is nothing at
want to explore. able with) how segregated we
all like her alma mater.
are as a society. Anaya Jones is
This is exactly what I did in my The characters are fiction, but black, and has lived her life with
latest novel, No One Ever Asked the story was inspired by true a set of experiences I have never
— a story written from the events, and explores — among and will never have as a white
I never wanted to write a book ripped from their parents’ arms, explore questions of belonging
about refugees. And yet that is the whole lot of them thrown and identity — national and
exactly what my debut novel, into prison. individual — how these things
The Boat People, is about. are constructed and ever-chang-
From the opposite end of the ing, perhaps false. To write about
In August 2010 a rusty cargo country, four time zones and the divide between immigrant
ship arrived on Vancouver 4,600 miles away, I watched parents and their western-born
Island, off Canada’s west coast. the drama unfold, feeling both children, a chasm that wid-
On board were nearly 500 Tamil distant from, and connected ens with time and succeeding
men, women, and children, to, the newcomers. My family generations.
survivors of Sri Lanka’s brutal is also from Sri Lanka and it is
civil war. Today, when anyone only good luck that brought us I planned to set the novel in
thinks of Canada and refugees, to Canada in the 1980s as im- Toronto, in the land-locked
what they imagine is the Prime migrants instead of two decades center of the country, and use
Minister welcoming Syrian later as refugees. I wasn’t a the arrival of a refugee ship far
families at the airport with a writer in 2010, not yet. But three away on the west coast as a news
big smile and winter coats. But years later, when I sat down to item, off-stage action that would
eight years ago, there was a dif- draft my first novel, that ship provoke debate and discus-
ferent government in power, one and its passengers still haunted sion at the dinner table. A plot
that wanted nothing to do with me. device to reveal character and
asylum-seekers, especially ones the culture gap. This was not go-
who showed up en masse and by Write what you know. That was ing to be a novel about boats and
boat. The Tamils were labeled the plan: to tell a story about refugees. It would not be a story
illegals and terrorists, husbands a sprawling, multi-genera- of war and sorrow. None of it
separated from wives, children tional Sri Lankan family. To would take place in Sri Lanka, a
I learned
good.
mentum. Writers can draw up
easily. elaborate plots and timelines Here is what I’ve learned: Write
what you know is incomplete ad-
We fought, but if a character saunters on
stage with a compelling story, vice. Start with what you know.
my book the enterprise is fated. Better to Then leave your comfort zone.
and I, set aside the master plan and Explore what you don’t know,
the things that frighten you.
every
follow your character, let him
take the lead. But this was not Walk toward the darkness and
step a lesson I learned easily. We write from deep inside that ter-
In 1992, Dr. Maria P. P. Root think of myself as Persian at all. Granted, this plan would have
wrote a “Bill of Rights for worked a lot better if my name
Racially Mixed People,” which I was raised in Kansas City, weren’t Adib and I didn’t have
was later included in several of Missouri, in a predominantly to constantly explain where my
her books, including 1996’s The white suburb, and it was easier name came from.
Multiracial Experience.
As I got older,
As I got older, I became a lot
I wish I could say I had grown more comfortable with my
up with this document, or even I became Iranian heritage, and there were
been aware of it before research-
a lot more even times I leaned into it, like
comfortable
ing this piece, but Dr. Root in college when being Iranian
manages to encapsulate in made me stand out in an other-
twelve sentences what I spent an with my wise crowded field. (It helped
entire novel trying to express.
Iranian that there was a very good
Iranian restaurant in town that
In Darius the Great Is Not Okay, heritage, I got my classmates hooked on.)
Darius Kellner frequently
and there
were even
refers to himself and his sister Even now, though, I don’t
as “Fractional Persians,” as op- know that I’ve gotten myself all
posed to the “True Persians” times I figured out. Some days I feel
his mother’s family in Iran
represent. Growing up Iranian-
leaned into it. white; some days I feel Iranian.
Some days I feel both, and some
American myself, I didn’t ever days I feel neither.
think of myself as “Fractional to pretend I was 100 percent
Persian.” In fact, I tried not to white like all my classmates.
I was nearly finished writing of the existing border’s creation. age book more valuable than the
my reported memoir about my I grew up traveling through the average news story is its longer
quest to understand my father, country’s busiest port of entry lifespan; it speaks to something
a Mexican immigrant who in San Diego as the body of the unchanging in the species. The
crosses borders both real and border materialized; now, that great ones, like Isabel Allende’s
illusory — between countries, body was about to transform. Paula, are timeless. In her mem-
between madness and sanity, Did I want to go back through oir, Allende explores her fam-
between substance abuse and the manuscript and weave in ily history as it unfolds amid
sobriety — when Donald J. the plot of the new president’s political upheaval in Chile, but
Trump was elected president of plans? what motivates her is a desire
the United States. not to make a relevant political
One of the biggest challenges of
statement but to save her dying
Trump had campaigned on writing memoir is making our
daughter: “Listen, Paula. I am
promises to build a bigger personal stories relevant to the
going to tell you a story, so that
wall at the border — a wall he world around us without letting
when you wake up you will not
started building spring 2018. them be overtaken by the head-
feel so lost.”
This made him, theoretically, a lines. Current events are always
perfect nemesis for my father: a changing. As a journalist who Current events are rarely
man whose story is defined by covers immigration, I have a as interesting as the forces
crossing man-made lines. My front-row seat to the rapid-fire propelling them. The more per-
book, CRUX: A Cross-Border metamorphosis of the border sonal the motive for writing the
Memoir, unfolds in the context region. What makes the aver- memoir, the more likely it is to
cross
tate a life or that it shouldn’t be
Why are some of us tempted to
included in a memoir. But cur-
borders, rent events are symptoms of the
cross borders, while some seek
to strengthen them? Is one way
while some past. The recurring patterns that
fuel them can inform a diagno-
better than the other? Memoirs
seek to sis. Those patterns lie inside of
allow us to arrive at more com-
strengthen ourselves.
plex answers to the issues that
tend to polarize us; they show
them? The border and I have an in- that reality is rarely as simple
better than
nothing to do with President terror of the unknown leads to
Trump. It has to do with my the same place as an unchecked
the other? father, who instilled in me my obsession with it: a world where
journalistic curiosity before he fact and fiction are mixed up.
ran away to flee alleged CIA
It is easy for memoirists to get
persecutors. In what I believe is
lost in the dark and digress-
my first memory, Papi is mak-
ing corridors of our minds. But
ing me hallucinate. I am sitting
memory has orienting features:
on his lap in an airplane and he
rhymes. They function as rungs
reaches through the window to
in our recollections. These
touch a cloud. Inspired, I plunge
parallels lead us from our most
my own fingers into the cloud. I
intimate wounds to the wounds
know this is impossible, but for
of our ancestors and, eventually,
years I recalled this with such
to the maladies of humankind.
clarity that I thought airplane
regulations in the late 1980s al-
lowed for open windows. Now I
JEAN GUERRERO is the author
know that, surely, the memory
of Crux.
was a product of suggestion.
An illusion. Papi probably pre-
tended to stroke the cloud from
behind the window, prompting
my mind to dissolve the plexi-
glass.
I’m the daughter of Chinese WRITING ACROSS RACE, fear not! Your imagination and
immigrants, and I’ve been writ- GENDER, CLASS, AND empathy can fill in the rest.
ing about Asia and the diaspora ETHNICITY
for two decades. I have a passion If you’re writing outside of your BEWARE OF
direct experience, start hum- HAGIOGRAPHY
for writing about immigrants
bly, not with assumption and Whether writing about your
and their children, about their
arrogance. Ask questions and family or beloved members of
histories, ambitions, traditions
do research to avoid trite, ste- a community, don’t turn them
that they bring to this coun-
reotypical descriptions. Ask into saints. As hard-working as
try, and about the complicated
yourself, is your character fully your grandfather might have
relationships they have with
realized, or is he or she a sym- been, as self-sacrificing as your
their homelands, ancestral and
bol? mother is, portray them — or
adopted.
the characters based upon them
I’ve always strived to shine a WRITING WHAT YOU — in all their flawed complexity.
light onto untold stories that DON’T KNOW
reflect the world we live in, To describe a time, place, or INTERVIEWS
stories that might inspire a event that you didn’t witness Seek out guides who can make
change in thinking, and a firsthand, search through introductions for you, such as
change in action. Often, I’m Flickr, YouTube, and Google activists, religious leaders, and
asked about how to tell those Street View for photos and reporters from ethnic press.
stories with truth and authen- videos of other worlds. Read Be aware that they may have
ticity. For me, trying to do so fiction and nonfiction from that an agenda and that you’ll have
remains a work in progress, but country and time period, as to corroborate their assertions
you might find the following well as travel guides. If you dis- with independent reporting.
guidelines helpful too: cover gaps in the official record, Entice them with something
You will need: ONE OR MORE might include, but are not
A SETTING WITH A PROTAGONISTS limited to, fawning opportun-
CLOSED SOCIAL SYSTEM These are your primary ingre- ists, vindictive ex-spouses,
Think of this as your stovetop dients. They should be char- predatory teachers, sociopathic
burner and pot, both the source acters who possess universal schemers, alcoholic best friends,
of heat and the container for qualities, desires, and fears, who and autocratic executive chefs.
your novel. It could be an army struggle to do the right thing and
battalion stationed in a war sometimes fail, but nonetheless AN INCITING INCIDENT
zone, an ethnically or racially rise to meet challenges much as This is the yeast, the leaven-
segregated neighborhood in a we all would, neither heroically ing, the element that causes
gentrifying city, a group of old nor cynically, but with an in- the chemical reaction to set the
college friends with secrets stinctive effort to hold on to the storytelling alchemy in motion.
and ancient rivalries in a Fire things and people they love. In As the energy and reaction it
Island summer house, a board- other words — solid, complex, generates propels the story for-
ing school on an island in Maine, interesting human beings. ward, it will also cause the cracks
a family farm in Pennsylvania… in the social system to show
or an old cruise ship on the A NUMBER OF MINOR and widen as the story goes on.
Pacific Ocean. The best systems CHARACTERS Examples of inciting incidents:
are the ones that seem hardy at These act like spices to make The enemy attacks the bar-
first, but over the course of the things exciting: They create racks, a shady outsider moves
story, as they are exposed to conflicts and intrigues, add in across the street, a teacher is
friction, heat, and tension, they dimension to the story by accused of sexually abusing a
soften and break down, reveal- eliciting, challenging, and student, a gas company offers a
ing themselves to be fragile and complementing our protago- lot of money to frack on the dairy
corruptible. nists’ fears and desires. They farm, or the old and creaky ship
24 2018 Ultimate Writing Guide
sets sail from Long Beach to Ha- holding their breath for the last out of its framework, don’t lose
waii. ten pages. heart, stick to your point of view,
and don’t be afraid to shake the
A SERIES OF UPHEAVALS bowl with it. As Julia Child
Directions: said, “When you flip anything,
OR CALAMITIES
1. One by one, add the protago- you just have to have the cour-
These actions — comparable to
nists and minor characters into age of your conviction.” If it falls
braising, flash-frying, and/or
the closed social system in its on the floor, pick it up and put
shocking in an ice bath — can
setting, stirring steadily. it back.
gradually build on each other to
amp up the drama by intensify- 2. Throw in the inciting incident 7. And now it’s time for the
ing and complicating the char- all at once. surprise finish, like a flambé or
acters’ collective and individual
a hit of a blowtorch that sears
struggles, ideally in a way that 3. As the story reacts and bub-
the top. This can and should
pits them against one another bles and begins to foment, keep
surprise or shock your reader,
and forces all of them to grapple your focus solid and consistency
but ideally in a way that makes
with their consciences and the smooth by making sure all the
the rest of the novel suddenly
limitations of their integrity and characters’ reactions and points
appear to be something other
courage—such as, in the case of of view stay clear and evenly
than what they thought it was all
the old and creaky ship: an en- distributed. Stir your narrative
along. This could cause them to
gine room fire, a crew walkout, a lightly but confidently, pushing
be initially angry or dismayed,
norovirus epidemic, and, finally, and pulling with your narrative
but, the more they think about it,
a cataclysmic gale-force storm. spoon to give it a proportional,
the more sense it should make.
organic shape as it achieves its
A POINT OF VIEW own swirling momentum. 8. Serve hot.
This is the heart and soul of your
4. Working quickly but deftly,
dish, your own personal imprint
throw in the first calamity and
on the recipe. What do you most KATE CHRISTENSEN is the
keep all the characters’ reac- author of The Last Cruise.
deeply believe? What do you
tions front and center.
think about what’s happening to
your characters, how do you feel
5. Before the novel can sub-
about it? Let your ingredients/
side back into calm, add your
characters speak for your own
second piece of trouble. Stand
deepest convictions.
back in case of minor explosion,
but don’t lose your grip on your
AN ENDING characters.
A dramatic finish is the literary
equivalent of setting a Baked 6. As things heat up, toss in
Alaska on fire. This should a third calamity. Then, if you
LEARN MORE
make the reader say “wow!” have it and the story can with-
or “what?” or just exhale be- stand it, a fourth. If the novel
cause they realize they’ve been threatens to come apart or fall
L E A R N M O RE
In my new book, What You Don’t beaches and heat and flowers of loneliness. All these opposites
Know About Charlie Outlaw, I astonishing size and bright- are inextricably linked. Free-
wrote about a man who travels ness, and sometimes resorts and dom and exploration can so eas-
to an island and ends up in dan- high-end shopping and cocktails ily become horror and death. All
ger. In doing so I joined a long bright as the flowers. Civiliza- it takes is a slip of the foot on a
tradition. From Robinson Crusoe tion at its most pleasurable, or cliff’s edge, a fin in the water.
to Lord of the Flies to “Castaway” no civilization at all. Islands can You feel free precisely because
to “Lost,” we keep going back
to islands in stories. Like other
settings we return to again and We want to know what it
again — the wilderness, space,
the open ocean — islands can would mean to be ourselves
offer adventure or terror. We without the trappings of our
seem to crave these things in
equal measure, in our stories at
lives.
least.
be a prison, as in the TV show you’re abandoning caution.
Islands have other kinds of “Arrow”; a sanctuary, as in There is no adventure without
doubleness as well: escape “Wonder Woman”; or a place danger, no connection without
or abandonment, luxury or of rebirth, as in “How Stella isolation.
deprivation. The flipside of the Got Her Groove Back.” When
deserted island — that cartoon we send characters to islands, We dream of escaping to
place of one palm tree, one co- we can set them on paths to islands; we fear abandonment on
conut, a man in raggedy shorts discovery or despair, a new un- them. Maybe the dream and the
— is the tropical paradise, derstanding of love or profound nightmare are not so different;
Everyone makes grammar so, shouldn’t they be in the ob- lunch.” But sometimes “me” is
mistakes. But we make them at ject form: him? Obviously not. “I correct. In “Thanks for taking
different levels. Someone with know him works hard” is clearly the time to visit Stephanie and
no interest in words or writing an error. Yet the same error isn’t me,” the noun phrase “Stepha-
might be more prone to confuse as clear when we’re dealing with nie and me” is the object of the
“you’re” and “your” or “its” and “who” and “whom.” Look at this verb “visit.” The pronoun “I” is a
“it’s.” At the other end of the example: “The manager wanted subject. The pronoun “me” is an
spectrum, serious wordsmiths to hire Yale alumni whom he object. So for the object of a verb
are more inclined to commit er- knew would fit in well at the like “visit,” you need “me.” Idi-
rors involving “whom” or coor- company.” That’s a mistake. It omatically, it’s acceptable to use
dinate subjects like “John and should be “who.” The object of “I” here. But people who know
I.” Here are five errors even the the verb “knew” is not a single the rules will think you were
most literate people make. pronoun, “whom.” It’s a whole trying to be grammatically cor-
clause: “who would fit in well.” rect and failed. When in doubt,
“Whom” between clauses. To
That verb phrase “would fit in try omitting the other person.
understand the most common
well” needs a subject, so it needs Then you get “Thanks for tak-
“whom” errors, first compare
the subject pronoun “who” and ing the time to visit I” versus
two sentences that do not con-
not the object pronoun “whom.” “Thanks for taking the time to
tain the pronoun “whom”: “I
visit me.”
know him.” “I know he works “Joe and I” used as an object.
hard.” Why does the first use We’re taught that “I” is more Faulty parallels. What’s wrong
an object pronoun, “him,” while proper than “me.” That’s of- with the following sentence?
the second uses the subject pro- ten true. “Joe and me are hav- “Carrie says Brian plans to study
noun “he”? Aren’t they both the ing lunch” is grammatically biology, math, French, econom-
object of the verb “know,” and if inferior to “Joe and I are having ics and is considering joining