Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
04452019 1585
article
a case study in the Comunidade Terapêutica Clínica do Outeiro –
Portugal
Considering the amount of raw data, it is nec- itive information analysis, since the data were
essary to synthesize the information to facilitate synthesized, easy to read and interpret.
its understanding, interpretation and inference18.
In this perspective, the data processing consub- Presentation and Discussion of Results
stantiated in the content analysis (CA), defined
by Bardin19 as a set of communication analysis After categorizing the data obtained through
techniques, which uses systematic procedures the aforementioned instruments and their re-
and objectives to describe the content of messag- spective coding in context and registration units,
es, reaching an understanding of their meanings three categories emerged that were more relevant
at a level that goes beyond a common reading. to the study (Chart 1).
In the present study, the contents of the state- The occurrence count by category is assumed
ments were appreciated in their entirety with the by several authors as a way of determining the
exploration of their implicit and explicit mean- main apprehensions / opinions of the partic-
ings (qualitative induction). Adopting the per- ipants, because the repeated words / ideas /
spective of Bardin19, the CA proceeded in three thoughts are those that reflect primordial con-
stages: pre-analysis, in which the organization cerns. Although quantifying the speech can be a
of the material that was intended to be used in starting point, it cannot be a binding for infer-
the investigation occurred, categorizing the data; ences on important subjects22, so the findings are
and finally, the treatment of results, inference quantified and described below, being appro-
and interpretation, which established a relation- priately confronted with studies addressing the
ship between the data obtained by performing same theme.
a comparative analysis of the categories created
in the previous stage. In this process, the CA re- Functional deficits
lied on three indexes for the organization of the
analysis: clipping, aggregation and enumera- The use of substances has a negative impact
tion. In the clipping, the units of analysis based on the performance of the individuals, being
on thematic cutouts were defined that illustrate referred by the OT, Activities of Daily Living
the experiences of the clients and the character- (ADL), Instrumental Activities of Daily Living
istics attributed to the Occupational Therapy. IADL), leisure, work and social participation, as
It followed the aggregation that determined the the most most-loss occupation areas also identi-
conjunction and specification of units that were fied in the Bazzani23 review in 2013.
clustered around distinct categories. Finally, the Table 1 presents references, according to the
enumeration allowed to gauge the gradient and Occupational Therapy Practice Framework20,
the quantification applied to the referents of the contained in the statements of the different par-
material analysed. ticipants regarding functional deficits that inter-
Some of the categories and subcategories fere with the occupational performance of indi-
used were predetermined based on the Portu- viduals with substance abuse disorders.
guese version of the 2nd edition of the Occupa- From the analysis of the data, there are fre-
tional Therapy Practice Framework: Domain and quent and significant references to the subcate-
Process20, and others emerged from the data. In gory “Routines / Habits”, identified as the estab-
the structuring of the categories it is emphasized lished sequences of occupations and activities
the obedience of the principles: a) exclusivity that give structure to daily life. Four sources (GF,
between categories; b) homogeneity within cat- TO1, TO2 and C1) emphasise that the routine
egories; c) completeness of the codified text; d) disruption and lack of client habits are reflected
objectivity among coders; and, e) suitability and in negligence in the ADL, especially in hygiene
relevance to contents and objectives19. and personal care, where it is assumed as primor-
In order to facilitate this process, webQDA dial “to show the importance and to facilitate the
software was used to support qualitative data involvement of the individual in the care of the
analysis21 in which the collected information was own body”6.
first transcribed in its totality and later intro- One of the OT (TO1) also reports, in concor-
duced into the program, categorised and coded dance with Bazzani23, the loss of abilities in the
by three researchers simultaneously in order to IADL, namely, in the cleaning and maintenance
achieve the Intercoder reliability. This tool per- of spaces.
mitted the selection and manipulation of the Individuals with substance use disorders have
most relevant categories, allowing a more intu- very restricted leisure activities, according to the
1589
allusions found in the discourse of two sources The OT and the rest of the team also point
(TO1 and C2) and when given the opportunity out that these individuals often have associated
to experience new activities “show difficulties memory deficits, executive functions, insight, de-
in exploring them” (TO1), as Ricou and Teixei- creased concentration and judgment, planning,
ra6 corroborate when affirming that one of the conflict management and problem solving, also
first areas of occupation where there is a consid- described by Ricou and Teixeira6.
erable decrease in performance is leisure. These Irritability, stress, anxiety and impulsivity are
individuals direct their interests to the search for, characteristics referenced five times in the sub-
acquisition and consumption of the substance, category “Emotional Regulation Skills” by three
repercussions in difficulties, when in abstinence, sources (TO1, TO2 and GF). These are men-
in the identification of leisure activities differ- tioned as factors that result from the emotional
ent from those associated with consumption6. lability that clients present, and they point out
According to C2, the lack of motivation is also the lack of motivation for occupational perfor-
a factor that contributes to the reduced range of mance, being “easily discouraged by what they
interests and involvement in the activities. An OT are doing and are eternally dissatisfied” (GF).
(TO1) states that before joining the community, As already mentioned, the enumeration of
this population is usually unemployed or disabil- references by subcategory contributes to the in-
ity pensioner or, on the other hand, do not have terpretation of the data, highlighting the “prima-
work skills because they have never experienced ry concerns”22. Thus, Table 1 arises to synthesize
or performed this type of activity, meeting the the references found in the subcategories anal-
findings of Ricou and Teixeira6. ysed.
The American Society of Addiction Medi-
cine24 in 2011 highlighted the problem of inter- Scope of Occupational Therapy
personal relationships. CTCO clients also find it intervention
difficult to establish and maintain interpersonal
relationships, both within their family and in the As evidenced in Amorelli’s study25, also in
community, as mentioned by one of the sources CTCO, Occupational Therapy stands out at first,
(TO1) of the two references obtained in the sub- concentrating its interventions on functional
category “Social Participation”, denoting deficits independence through the use of significant oc-
in social and communication skills, such as “dif- cupations thus increasing the, also referred to by
ficulty in listening to others”, “they cannot have a Ricou and Teixeira6, levels volition and motiva-
dialogue”, “they do not come with correct com- tion of the individual to remain abstinent and
munication, they are rude to people”, mentioned resorting to these activities to intervene in the
by three sources (TO1, TO2 and GF) in a total of necessary competences through the performance
seven references in the subcategory “Communi- of truly transforming occupations for each sub-
cation and social skills”. ject23. In this direction, the setting of the Occupa-
1590
Ribeiro J et al.
tional Therapy that sustains the triadic relation- ity of life of the clients, through the acquisition
ship is a promoter of activities. These, in turn, as of new performance standards, new occupational
a therapeutic tool, have several objectives, among roles and the development of new habits6. In this
them: observation, analysis, education, treat- proposal, the central nucleus is the triadic rela-
ment, story composition and social insertion26. tionship, constituted by patient, OT and activi-
As mentioned previously, clients present ties, characterized by enabling and maintaining
functional deficits in several areas, and Occupa- a particular dynamic of functioning, in which
tional Therapy intervention is directed at mini- movements of action and reaction are determi-
mizing and empowering clients’ autonomy, seek- nants of the relational dynamics between the
ing to generalize the tools acquired in the com- three terms that the constitute it26.
munity to society. This intervention encompasses Taking as some examples of more individu-
the treatment of physical, mental and emotional alized activities, Occupational Therapists refer to
factors, identification of stress factors and coping support in maintaining daily tasks: ADL training
skills equally highlighted by Bhatia et al.3. as “hygiene and personal care training” (TO1 and
Firstly, the intervention is focused on the (re) TO2) and IADL training, such as such as “folding
structuring of a healthy routine and on the qual- clothes, tidying up the closet and cleaning their
1591
occupational right for all32. At the same time, OT sional areas in the CTCO.The TO is considered
assumes the role of daily routines builder, because the professional that deals more directly with
“it helps to get the message of how important it is the clients, having a level of proximity to them,
to have this well-structured routine” (GF) foster- superior to the other professionals, concretizing
ing performance in the various areas of occupa- their work in the very contexts of these individ-
tion. In this context, the identification, adaptation, uals (GF, TO1 and TO2): “we are there for them,
implementation and development of habits, ritu- in the room to sort things out with them, in cog-
als and routines, addressing barriers and taking nitive stimulation to see their difficulties”(TO2).
advantage of existing competences, often arise as Therefore, this fact “is extremely important be-
objectives of intervention of Occupational Thera- cause they come to certain situations that we do
py with these individuals. Indeed, it is highlighted not reach” (GF),presenting an increased capacity
in many publications related to mental health and for observation, “a careful and trained look, in
the rehabilitation of individuals with substance order to signal situations” (GF) that are often
use disorders33-35. This concern with the neces- not detectable by the rest of the technical team
sary structuring of routines is consistent with the (GF and TO2). Bonsaksen et al.39 have identified
AOTA indications36,37, looking at the individual’s a large number of publications that point to a
functionality and well-being and, consequently, generalized understanding within the profession
their adaptation in the contexts of life. that success in promoting client participation in
The occupation, the foundation of OT’s prac- occupations depends in part on the quality of
tice, provides structure and routine to our day, client-therapist relationship, particularly close
contributes to our dynamic sense of identity and contact with the client’s contexts. Proximity in
keeps us connected to others and to the world the relationship between health professionals
around us. These additional aspects have also and clients allows to know the client and his/her
proved to be essential for health and well-being38. needs, promoting the humanization of care and
Continuing the analysis of the above table, it meeting the clients’ needs40,41.
is verified that the proximity to the client is the Lopes and Leão28 highlight another differen-
subcategory most referenced by the five sourc- tial that specifies the practice of Occupational
es (GF, TO1, TO2, C1 and C2), showing a more Therapy, such as the prioritization of the action,
differentiating characteristic of the other profes- the process of ‘doing’, to the detriment of the fi-
Table 2. Category “Difference between Occupational Therapy and other areas of practice”
Category Subcategory References Sources
Difference Proximity 17 5
between References to the greater propinquity of the therapist-client.
Occupational Mortivation 16 5
Therapy and other References to investment to promote motivation and
areas of practice development of volition.
Clientintegration in the community 8 1
References to Occupational Therapy intervention aiming at the
inclusion of the individual in the different contexts of his life.
Creativity / Flexibility 7 4
References to the adoption of diversified strategies in the
intervention of Occupational Therapy.
Ability to observe 7 2
References to the identification of clients needs arising from the
specific spectrum of Occupational Therapy competencies.
Habits and routines References to Occupational Therapy 5 1
intervention for the development of behavioral patterns that
influence the performance of ADL.
1593
Collaborations
Acknowledgments
1. World Health Organization (WHO). Substance abuse. 17. Gondim S. Grupos focais como técnica de investigação
2016. [acessado 2017 Jul 15]. Disponível em: http:// qualitativa: desafios metodológicos. Paidéia 2003;
www.who.int/topics/substance_abuse/en/ 12(24):154.
2. American Occupational Therapy Association (AOTA). 18. Moraes R. Análise de conteúdo. Revista Educação 1999;
Overcoming Drug and Alcohol Abuse. 2002. [acessado 22(37):7-32.
2017 Jul 15]. Disponível em: https://www.aota.org/~/ 19. Bardin L. Análise de conteúdo. Lisboa: Edições 70; 2013.
media/Corporate/Files/AboutOT/consumers/Mental- 20. Marques A, Trigueiro MJ. Enquadramento da prática da
Health/Drugs/SubAbuse.pdf Terapia Ocupacional: domínio & processo. Porto: Livp-
3. Bhatia M, Garnawat D, Kaur J. Rehabilitation for Sub- sic; 2011.
stance Abuse Disorders. Delhi Psychiatry Journal, 2013; 21. Chaves M, Larocca L, Mafra M. Pesquisa qualitativa
16(2):400. com apoio de software: Um relato de experiência. In-
4. Departamento de Tratamento e Reinserção. Linhas vestigação Qualitativa em Saúde 2015; 1:187-188.
Orientadoras para o Tratamento e Reabilitação em Co- 22. Stemler S. An overview of content analysis. Practical
munidades Terapêuticas. Lisboa: Instituto da Droga e da Assessment, Research & Evaluation 2001; 7(17).
Toxicodependência Obtido de Serviço de Intervenção 23. Bazzani L. La Terapia Ocupacional en el abordaje de las
nos Comportamentos Aditivos e nas Dependências adicciones: una revisión actualizada. Revista Chilena de
(SICAD); 2011. Terapia Ocupacional 2013; 13(2):57-64.
5. Decreto Lei nº74/2016. Diário da República 2016; 8 nov. 24. American Society of Addiction Medicine. Public Policy
6. Ricou M, Teixeira C. Volição em Toxicodependentes Statement: Short Definition of Addiction. 2011. [aces-
que frequentam a Unidade de Desabituação do Norte sado 2017 Jul 15]. Disponível em: http://www.asam.
pela primeira vez e em indivíduos reincidentes. Revista org/docs/default-source/public-policy-statements/
Toxicodependências 2008; 14(2):25-35. 1definition_of_addiction_short_4-11.pdf?sfvrsn=0
7. Cáceres A, Mesias B. Atención a población sin hogar: 25. Amorelli C. Psychosocial Occupational Therapy In-
Experiencia del Instituto de Adicciones de la Ciudad terventions for Substance-Use Disorders: A narrative
de Madrid. In: Bobes J, Casas M, Gutiérrez M, editores. review. Occupational Therapy in Mental Health 2016;
Manual de Trastornos Adictivos. Madrid: Enfoque Edi- 32(2):167-184.
torial; 2011. p. 226-234. 26. Benetton J, Marcolino T. As atividades no Método Ter-
8. Petrova T, Punanova N. Behavioral Approach to Re- apia Ocupacional Dinâmica/Activities in the Dynamic
habilitation of Patients with Substance-Use Disorders. Occupational Therapy Method. Cadernos de Terapia
In: Söderback I, editor. International Handbook of Oc- Ocupacional da UFSCar 2013; 21(3):645-652.
cupational Therapy Interventions. Estocolmo: Springer; 27. Màngia EF. Contribuições da abordagem canadense
2009. p. 277-284. “Prática de Terapia Ocupacional Centrada no Cliente”
9. Steiner A. Occupational therapy for addiction? Experts e dos autores da desinstitucionalização italiana para a
say it’s back. [acessado 2017 Jul 15]. Disponível em: Terapia Ocupacional em Saúde Mental. Rev. Ter. Ocup.
https://www.minnpost.com/mental-health-addic- Univ. São Paulo 2002; 13(3):15-21.
tion/2017/03/occupational-therapy-addiction-ex- 28. Lopes RE, Leão A. Terapeutas ocupacionais e os Cen-
perts-say-it-s-back tros de Convivência e Cooperativa: novas ações de
10. Crouch R, Alers V, editors. Occupational therapy in saúde. Rev. Ter. Ocup. Univ. São Paulo 2002; 13(2):56-
psychiatry and mental health. Hoboken: John Wiley & 63
Sons; 2014. 29. Polia AA, Castro DH. A lesão medular e suas seqüelas
11. Davies R. According to the models of care for the treat- de acordo com o modelo de ocupação humana. Cader-
ment of drug misusers, does occupational therapy have nos Brasileiros de Terapia Ocupacional 2010; 15(1):19-
a role in the treatment of drug misuse? British Journal 29.
of Occupational Therapy 2006; 69(12):575-577. 30. Ribeiro M, Oliveira L. Terapia Ocupacional e saúde
12. Stoffel V, Moyers PA. Terapia ocupacional e distúrbios mental: construindo lugares de inclusão social. Inter-
do uso de substâncias. In: Cara E. MacRae A, editors. face (Botucatu) 2005; 9(17):425-431.
Terapia Ocupacional Psicossocial: Uma Prática Clínica. 31. Dowling H, Hutchinson A. Occupational therapy-its
2ª ed. Albany: Do Mar; 2005. p. 446-473 contribution to social inclusion and recovery. A Life in
13. Ribeiro J, Brandão C, Costa A. Metodologia de Estudo the Day 2008; 12(3):11-14.
de Caso em Saúde: Contributos para a sua Qualidade. 32. Le Boutillier C, Croucher A. Social inclusion and men-
In: Oliveira E, Barros N, Silva R, organizadores. Inves- tal health. British Journal of Occupational Therapy 2010;
tigação Qualitativa em Saúde conhecimento e aplicabi- 73(3):136-139.
lidade. Oliveira de Azeméis: Ludomedia; 2016. p. 143- 33. Garnham M, Morley M, Forsyth K, Lee S, Taylor R,
160 Kielhofner G. Occupational therapy care packages in
14. Coutinho C. Metodologias de Investigação em Ciências mental health: preparing for payment by results. Lon-
Humanas. Coimbra: Almedina; 2011. don: British Association of Occupational Therapists
15. Alves Z, Silva M. Análise Qualitativa de dados de en- and College of Occupational Therapists; 2010.
trevista: uma proposta. Paidéia 1992; (2):61-69. 34. Bryant W, Fieldhouse J, Bannigan K, editors. Creek’s
16. Backes D, Colomé J, Erdmann R, Lunardi V. Grupo focal Occupational Therapy and Mental Health E-Book. Am-
como técnica de coleta e análise de dados em pesquisas sterdam: Elsevier Health Sciences; 2014.
qualitativas. O Mundo da Saúde 2011; 35(4):438-442.
1596
Ribeiro J et al.
CC BY This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License