Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Objective: To investigate the immediate effects of Kinesio TapingÕ (KT) on sit-to-stand (STS) movement, balance and
dynamic postural control in children with cerebral palsy (CP).
Methods: Four children diagnosed with left hemiplegic CP level I by the Gross Motor Function Classification System were
evaluated under conditions without taping as control condition (CC); and with KT as kinesio condition. A motion analysis
system was used to measure total duration of STS movement and angular movements of each joint. Clinical instruments
such as Pediatric Balance Scale (PBS) and Timed up and Go (TUG) were also applied.
Results: Compared to CC, decreased total duration of STS, lower peak ankle flexion, higher knee extension at the end of
STS, and decreased total time in TUG; but no differences were obtained on PBS score in KT.
For personal use only.
Conclusion: Neuromuscular taping seems to be beneficial on dynamic activities, but not have the same performance in
predominantly static activities studied.
Correspondence: C. S. N. da Costa, Department of Physiotherapy, Neuropediatric Research Unit, Federal University of São Carlos, Rodovia Washington
Luis, São Carlos 13565-010, Brazil. Tel: 55 313 4914489. Fax: (55) 33518647. E-mail: costa.csn@gmail.com
ISSN 1751–8423 print/ISSN 1751–8431 online/13/020121–8 ß 2013 Informa UK Ltd.
DOI: 10.3109/17518423.2012.727106
122 C. S. N. da Costa et al.
the better efficacy of the support for the muscle has boys and two girls) diagnosed with left hemiplegic
been explained in terms of KT effect on the skin, by CP level I by the GMFCS participated of the study.
means of moving and raising it in appropriate The age of participants was 9–11 years with mean
direction [14–16]. age of 10 years and 4 months (1 year and 3
Few studies have identified positive influences of months). Patients who were in physiotherapeutic
the KT in children with disabilities. S¸ims¸ek et al. treatment (mean ¼ 4 years; 2.6 years), and they did
[17] verified no direct effects of 12 weeks of KT not undergo surgery or have made application of
application on gross motor function and functional botulinum toxin for at least 6 months before assess-
independence; however, sitting posture seems to be ment date. Children also were able to understand the
affected positively. Furthermore, the authors examiner’s command. Children with shortening of
muscles of lower limbs, which were identified by the
For personal use only.
joints as close to 90 as possible [25]. The first two to test a client’s ability to maintain a position within
STS movement was allowed for the child to get used a decreasing base of support and to change positions.
to this position, and after that three first trials were The items are performed within a specified time
recorded for the analysis. The participants rose to frame, or the positions are held for a specified
stand at their preferred speed for three trials, while amount of time. The items are scored on a five-point
watching a standing eye level target. A quiet sitting ordinal scale from 0 to 4 [30]. A higher score
reference trial with arms by the side was recorded. indicates better balance abilities. Inter-rater reliabil-
Rising to stand commenced with arms by the side, ity using the PBS is reported to be extremely high,
however, arms were free to move during rising. with an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.98.
Start of movement was the time at which the Similarly, intra-rater reliability is high with a
horizontal velocity of the marker on the acromion reported correlation coefficient of 0.99. The intra-
was greater than or equal to 10 mm s1 [26] and the rater agreement was 92%. In this way, we divided
marker had not begun to move in a vertical direction. the PBS in PBS-static and PBS-dynamic. PBS-
Movement end was when knee extension was max- dynamic part presents eight dynamical activities,
Dev Neurorehabil Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Minnesota on 06/02/13
imal [27], and the vertical displacement of the allowing for a maximum score of 32 points, and
acromium marker was maximal [28]. Each trial PBS-static, which include six static balance
was time normalized with start in 0% and movement activities, allowing for a maximum score of 24
end 100%. points [30].
The whole experiment phase was recorded using
two-camera motion capture system. Two cameras
were positioned 45 from sagittal plane of child’s Timed up and go. The child sat in a height-
body, on the left side, shuttered (1/500 s), genlocked adjustable chair. The height of the seat was such
to synchronize their scans (60 fields per second), and that the subject’s knees and hips were flexed to 90
adequately calibrated to determine the 3-D scaling when sitting with the feet plantigrade on the floor.
factors. The average mean square error for the The child was informed that he would perform one
For personal use only.
calibration was 3.88 mm. practice trial and three recorded trials. The child was
Motion data were processed using Kwon 3-D given a signal ‘ready, 1, 2, 3, and go.’ On the go cue,
version 3.0 using a cut off frequency of 6 Hz (fourth- the child stood up, walked 3 m, turned around a
order zero phase shift Butterworth filter). mark on the floor, walked back, and sat down.
Although we believed there are compensatory Following one practice trial, each child performed
strategies in frontal and transversal planes, there is three recorded trials with a 30 s break between trials.
no other research in STS movement in children that The time in seconds was recorded from the ‘go’ cue
evaluated transverse and frontal plane for compar- to when the child sat down in the chair. In this sense,
isons. For that, this preliminary study focused on the the shorter the time of execution, better dynamic
sagittal plane, for being also considered the main balance control obtained by the child [31]. The
plane of movement. Therefore, we calculated: intra-rater agreement was 88%.
Children then rested for 3 min before taping the
(a) Time of execution: the total duration of STS quadriceps muscles and anterior tibial with elastic
motion, i.e., the difference between initial and tape. The elastic tape for these muscles was a 8–
final point in seconds [6, 29]. 20 cm piece of KT (Kinesio TexÕ , KT-X-050,
(b) Joint angles: The kinematic (ankle, knee, and Tokyo, Japan), cut into an Y shape (quadriceps)
trunk joint angles) were computed based on a and I shape (tibial anterior), and the elastic applied
3-D model including five segments (feet, shank, with minimal tension from origin to insertion mus-
thigh, pelvis, and trunk). Accordingly, cles according to muscle activation technique of
initial, maximal, and final values of these Kase et al. [15]. The tape was applied by an expert
joint angles were obtained for the trials analyzed. with technical course of KT in pediatrics. After the
[6, 29] taping application, the subject received the first or
After the STS task, assessments about dynamic second measurement of STS movement and func-
postural control and balance were done through PBS tional tests (PBS and TUG tests).
and TUG tests. We named the condition without taping as control
condition (CC) and the condition after the taping
application as KT condition. The order of
Pediatric Balance Scale. PBS has 14 items of conditions was randomized for each child excluding
increasing difficulty. These items are used to test the effect of practice.
functional skills relevant to everyday tasks, such as Data were analyzed in the SPSS statistical package
moving from sitting to standing, and reaching, (version 16.0). To view the differences between CC
beyond one’s base of support. Items were designed and KT conditions, the paired t-test test was used for
124 C. S. N. da Costa et al.
Results
A total of 24 attempts on the STS movement were
collected. The average time executed in STS move-
ment under CC was 2.41 (0.27) s and decreased
Dev Neurorehabil Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Minnesota on 06/02/13
Figure 2 Mean of time of execution for TUG for each child in CC and kinesio condition (KT).
For personal use only.
Table I. Score differences between kinesio control (KT) and CC of evaluated items of PBS for dynamic and static activities for each child.
Score KT–CC
taping in agility from sitting to standing and which was reflected by the decrease in time of
ambulation through the results obtained in the execution, reduction in ankle flexion peak and
STS, PBS-dynamic activities and TUG test. greater knee extension at the end of the movement.
However, there was no significant difference in The study by Park et al. [6] showed that children
balance and static postural control represented by with diplegia and spastic hemiplegia CP have
the PBS-static score. reduced knee extension at the end of the task and
The results of this study found that under the little ability to generate contraction of the hip and
condition with the taping application, there was a knee extensor muscles when compared to typical
significant improvement in the performance of STS, children. In addition, children with spastic CP have
126 C. S. N. da Costa et al.
difficulties in performing the STS due to inefficiency providing similar results of improved performance in
in the control of the neuronal selection process, to rising from chair. Neuromuscular taping also con-
imbalances between agonist and antagonist muscles tributed to proper muscle balance with less risk of
and to tonus alterations and ineffective balance causing future deformities. However, further studies
reactions [6, 29]. Thus, it is believed that the investigating the comparison between the long-term
neuromuscular taping was effective in improving use of AFO orthoses and neuromuscular taping
the performance of the STS, since it changed the should be conducted to confirm these inferences.
knee and ankle values, bringing them closer to values Initial assessment showed that children participat-
found for typical children. In addition, we believe ing in this study performed the TUG test in a longer
that KT improved children neuromuscular control, time than expected for the corresponding age group,
since that postural control is mainly the result of since the literature indicates that the average time
better postural orientation. For that the better body expected for children over 9 years of age must be
alignment, i.e., lower peak angle flexion, and more below 5.9 s [31]. Thus, these children performed the
extension at the final of STS, the easier the task with lower speed than the adequate speed (total
Dev Neurorehabil Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Minnesota on 06/02/13
stabilization of the center of mass, enabling better average time of 17.58 s).
equilibrium and more efficient movement. The longer time in the TUG test is associated with
Thus, methods such as therapy taping with KT high risk of falls [38], thus indicating that children
can help in the performance of STS activity, and assessed in this study have deficits in dynamic
contribute to be useful in the clinical practice. postural control; since that test requires a process
In the literature, there are studies that investigated of planning, initiation, and execution of complex
the effects of other contextual factors in STS activities such as rising from chair, walking, changing
movement, such as the use of the ankle–foot orthosis direction, and sitting [31, 38]. With the taping
(AFO) [32]. The study by Park et al. [33] on the application, it was found that children decreased the
applicability of AFO for children with diplegia time of TUG test and increased the speed. Thus, it is
showed a decrease in the execution time of the considered that the taping is effective in improving
For personal use only.
STS activity, increased knee flexion at the beginning the dynamic postural control, also improving the
of the movement and increased ankle dorsal flexion performance of dynamic activities such as STS
at the end of the STS. However, the outcome joint movement, TUG test.
angle strategies obtained from use of AFO and KT Few studies investigated the effect of KT on
on STS seems different; both methods are effective, dynamic activities in children. Although S¸ims¸ek
since those children executed the task successfully et al. [17] verified no effect of long-term physiother-
and more rapidly. apy associated with KT on gross motor function; the
However, the theoretical principles of the use of authors suggested that immediate effect also should
AFO are different from those of the use of taping. be investigated. The only study found in the liter-
The placement of AFO is based on the mechanism ature on the immediate effectiveness of the KT
of primary inhibition of hyperactive muscle, such as technique in dynamic activities for children showed
gastrocnemius and soleus muscles, by the applied significant improvements in upper extremities func-
elongation. According to Ross and Bowers [34], tion of children with risk for brain lesions [18].
AFO orthoses benefit the recruitment of evertor and Others studies in adults that verified immediate
dorsiflexor muscles, reducing muscle tonus, improv- effect of KT on joint amplitude, body alignment,
ing the performance of postural transfers, walking and muscles balance explained those improvements
and jumping. through increases the electrical activity of the mus-
On the other hand, the fixed positioning of this cles involved [20–22].
type of orthosis often generates changes in the tibia The literature shows other physiological and
alignment, preventing the recruitment of plantar biomechanical reasons that would explain the effec-
flexor muscles [35]. Thus, some authors consider tiveness of the KT technique on body structures on
that the long-term use of AFO limits the child’s the performance of dynamic activities as required in
sensorimotor experiences for motor learning, leads this study. Kase [14] reports that the application of
to deformities of feet and knees, such as the the KT technique provides a tactile–proprioceptive
plantar arch collapse associated with hyperextension stimulation, aligning muscular fascia and providing
or excessive flexion of knees [34, 36, 37]. sensory stimulation that would inhibit or facilitate
Neuromuscular taping has the principle of primarily the muscles involved in the movement. Callaghan
activating dominated or hypoactive muscles, which et al. [39] found that taping can modulate brain
would not change the foot-shank biomechanical activity in several areas of the brains, specially,
alignment, allowing free range of motion of ankle sensory motor cortex during a proprioception knee
and foot [14]. Thus, we believe that the application movement using patellar taping. For that, we
of the KT technique is as effective as the use of AFO, assumed that KT has positive effect on
Pilot study 127
mechanoreceptors which may be the cause of greater demand on postural control and greater
improvements in dynamic activities. The stimulus degree of difficulty shown by children with CP.
of cutaneous mechanoreceptors achieved thought In conclusion, we believe that KT is beneficial on
KT which applies pressure to the skin or even dynamic activities, as evidenced in the analyses of
stretches seem to result in physiological changes the STS movement, TUG test and PBS-dynamic
such as adequate firing and recruitment pattern of activities. However, the use of taping does not have
the quadriceps and tibial anterior muscles. Those the same performance in predominantly static activ-
physiological changes probably are related to ities, as shown by the results obtained in the PBS-
improvements in postural and neuromuscular con- static scores by children assessed in this study. A
trol reflected in our results. methodological limitation of this study is the use of a
Regarding the results on the PBS score, it was small sample size without using a placebo condition.
found that there was no change between CC and KC Although, it is important to note that this is a pioneer
conditions for PBS-static scores. On the other hand, study in evaluating the immediate effectiveness of
PBS-dynamic activities score was increased under the KT technique in children with CP in functional
Dev Neurorehabil Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Minnesota on 06/02/13
taping condition. Thus, based on the physiological, activities, which require dynamic and static postural
biomechanical, and elastic properties of the KT control.
method, it has been suggested that this technique is For being a cross-sectional study, further studies
effective for activities that require dynamic postural should be conducted for examining and relating the
control as compared to static postural control short and long-term effects of the KT technique in
activities which were performed in this study. In STS movement of children with CP, with more
this sense, studies previously [14–16] reported elas- accurate methods to prove the physiological changes
tic properties from KT which possibly would act assumed by KT in taped areas.
more effectively during the approach and retraction
of the body segments involved, which would explain
the higher number of studies proving the effective-
For personal use only.
ness of the neuromuscular taping preferably in Declaration of interest: The authors report no
dynamic activities, when compared with studies conflict of interest. The authors alone are respon-
focused on static activities, corroborating the sible for the content and writing of this article.
findings of this study.
A single study that evaluated the effectiveness of
the KT technique in the static postural control was References
found. In this study by Cortesi et al. [40], the
1. Rosenbaum P, Paneth N, Leviton A, Goldstein M, Bax M,
applicability of the KT technique in the calf of
Damiano D, Dan B, Jacobsson B. A report: The defini-
subjects with multiple sclerosis exhibited significant tion and classification of cerebral palsy April 2006.
reduction in oscillation and total displacement of the Developmental Medicine Child Neurology Supplements
center of pressure on the base of support. Although 2007;109:8–14.
the cited study seems to be in disagreement with the 2. Stackhouse SK, Binder-Macleod SA, Lee SCK. Voluntary
results of this study, it is important to note that the muscle activation, contractile properties, fatigability in chil-
dren with and without cerebral palsy. Muscle Nerve
methodology of the study by Cortesi et al. [40] 2005;31:594–601.
include a high-sensitivity instrument for assessing 3. Bigongiari A, Souza F, Franciulli P, Neto S, Araujo R,
postural control. Therefore, it could be inferred that Mochizuki L. Anticipatory and compensatory postural adjust-
the lack of difference found in PBS-static score may ment in sitting in children with cerebral palsy. Human
be due to the reduced accuracy provided by this Movement Science 2011;30:648–657.
4. Dehail P, Bestaven E, Muller F, Mallet A, Robert B, Bourdel-
instrument. However, further studies using force Marchasson I, Petit J. Kinematic and electromyographic
plate should be conducted to verify the effectiveness analysis of rising from a chair during a ‘‘Sit-to-Walk’’ task in
of the KT technique on static activities, standing or elderly subjects: Role of strength. Clinical Biomechanics
sitting balance control of children with CP. 2007;22:1096–1103.
The difference of results from PBS-dynamic 5. Lomaglio MJ, Eng JJ. Muscle strength and weight-bearing
symmetry relate to sit-to-stand performance in individuals with
activities to PBS-static activities under KT may be
stroke. Gait and Posture 2005;22:126–131.
explained for the fact that dynamic activities seem to 6. Park ES, Park C, Lee HJ, Kim D. The characteristics of sit-
be considered more complex than static activities. to-stand transfer in young children with cerebral palsy based
In dynamic activities, more demanding control of on kinematic and kinetic data. Gait and Posture
the center of gravity in different bases of support and 2003;17:43–49.
7. Damiano DL, Arnold AS, Steele KM, Delp SL. Can strength
high coordination of interdependent segments are
training predictably improve gait kinematics? A pilot study on
required. In this context, it could be inferred that the the effects of hip and knee extensor strengthening on lower-
KT technique is more effective in carrying out extremity alignment in cerebral palsy. Physical Therapy
dynamic activities, since these activities require 2010;90:269–279.
128 C. S. N. da Costa et al.
8. Liao HF, Gan SM, Lee HJ, Kim D. Effects of weight 24. Kadaba MP, Ramkrisnan K, Wootten ME, Gainey J,
resistance on the temporal parameters and electromyography Gorton G, Cochran GVB. Repeatability of kinematic, kinetic
of sit-to-stand movements in children with and without and a electromyografic data in normal adult gait. Journal of
cerebral palsy. American Journal of Physical Medicine and Orthopaedic Research 1989;7:849–860.
Rehabilitation 2010;89:99–106. 25. Pai YC, Rogers MW. Speed variation and resultant joint
9. Howle JM. Neuro-developmental treatment approach, torques during sit-to-stand. Archives of Physical Medicine
theoretical foundations and principles of clinical and Rehabilitation 1991;72:881–885.
practice. Canada: Neuro-developmental Treatment 26. Khemlani MM, Carr JH, Crosbie WJ. Muscle synergies and
Association; 2002. joint linkages in sit-to-stand under two initial foot positions.
10. Ketelaar M, Vermeer A, Hart H, van Petegem-van Beek E, Clinical Biomechanics 1999;14:236–246.
Helders PJM. Effects of a functional therapy program on 27. Kralj A, Jaeger RJ, Munih M. Analysis of standing up and
motor abilities of children with cerebral palsy. Physical sitting down in humans: Definitions and normative data
Therapy 2001;81:1534–1545. presentation. Journal of Biomechanics 1990;23:1123–1138.
11. Hamil D, Washington KA, White OR. The effect of 28. Crosbie J, Herbert RD, Bridson JT. Intersegment dynamics
hypotherapy on postural control in sitting for children with of standing up from sitting. Clinical Biomechanics
cerebral palsy. Physical and Occupational Therapy in 1997;12:227–235.
Pediatrics 2007;27:23–42. 29. Hennington G, Johnson M, Penrose J, Kory M,
Dev Neurorehabil Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by University of Minnesota on 06/02/13
12. Iosa M, Morelli D, Nanni M, Veredice C, Marro T, McMulkin ML, Vander Linden DW. Effect of bench height
Medici A, Paolucci S, Mazz C. Functional taping: A on sit-to-stand in children without disabilities and children
promising technique for children with cerebral palsy. with cerebral palsy. Archives of Physical Medicine and
Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology 2010; Rehabilitation 2004;85:70–76.
52:587–589. 30. Franjoine M, Gunther JS, Taylor MJ. Pediatric balance scale:
13. Footer CB. The effects of therapeutic taping on gross motor A modified version of the berg balance scale for the school-
function in children with cerebral palsy. Pediatric Physical age child with mild to moderate motor impairment. Journal
of Pediatric Psychology 2003;15:114–128.
Therapy 2006;18:245–252.
31. Williams E, Carrol S, Reddihough DS, Phillips BA,
14. Kase K. Until today from birth of Kinesio taping
Galea MP. Investigation of the timed ‘‘Up & Go’’ test in
method. Albuquerque, NM: KMS, LLC; 2001. pp 7–30.
children. Developmental Medicine Child Neurology 2005;
15. Kase K, Martin P, Yasukawa A. Kinesiotaping in pediatrics.
47:518–524.
Fundamentals and whole body taping. Albuquerque, NM:
32. da Costa CS, Savelsbergh G, Rocha NA. Sit-to-stand
For personal use only.