Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 4

Surg Endosc (2001) 15: 663–666

DOI: 10.1007/s004640080146

© Springer-Verlag New York Inc. 2001

Risk factors and the prevalence of trocar site herniation after


laparoscopic fundoplication
D. J. Bowrey, D. Blom, P. F. Crookes, C. G. Bremner, J. L. M. Johansson, R. V. Lord, J. A. Hagen,
S. R. DeMeester, T. R. DeMeester, J. H. Peters
Department of Surgery, University of Southern California, HCC Suite 514, 1510 San Pablo St, Los Angeles, CA 90033-4612, USA

Received: 23 August 2000/Accepted in final form: 27 September 2000/Online publication: 11 May 2001

Abstract Key words: Fundoplication — Hernia — Laparoscopy —


Background: Although there have been case reports de- Postoperative complications
scribing trocar site herniation after laparoscopic fundopli-
cation, its overall prevalence and the risk factors for its
development are unclear.
Methods: The records of 320 patients undergoing primary
laparoscopic fundoplication as treatment for gastroesopha- Incisional herniation is a common sequela to open abdomi-
geal reflex disease (GERD) or hiatal hernia between 1991 nal surgery, affecting 5–15% of patients. The reported
and 1999 were reviewed retrospectively. Placement of the prevalence of this complication varies between studies, de-
initial supraumbilical trocar was by the open Hassan tech- pending upon the type of incision employed, the patient
nique in all patients. group studied, and the duration of follow-up [3, 4, 5, 8, 10,
Results: Nine patients (five male) with a mean age 54 years 11, 13, 16, 21, 23, 26, 29]. It is commonly held that the
(range, 37–75) developed trocar site herniation, for an over- frequency of incisional herniation has been reduced since
all prevalence of 3%. The mean interval between surgery the introduction of minimal access surgery.
and diagnosis was 12 months (range, 4–21). In all patients, Although there have been a number of case reports de
the hernia occurred at the supraumbilical camera port site. scribing herniation at laparoscopic trocar sites [6, 7, 9, 12, 14,
Patients with trocar hernias tended to have a higher body 19, 20, 22, 24, 27, 28, 30], there have been surprisingly few
mass index (BMI) than those without hernias (mean BMI, studies [1, 15, 17, 18, 23] examining the exact frequency of
29.4 kg/m2 vs 27.2 kg/m2, p ⳱ 0.13). None of the patients this complication after laparoscopic surgery and none that
developed intestinal obstruction as a consequence of her- have specifically addressed its frequency after laparoscopic
niation. To date, all but one of the hernias have been re- fundoplication. Therefore, we set out to ascertain the fre-
paired. Six of them required the insertion of a prosthetic quency of trocar site herniation in a cohort of patients who
mesh. had undergone laparoscopic fundoplication and second to
Conclusions: The prevalence of trocar site herniation after examine the characteristics of affected individuals so that
laparoscopic fundoplication was minimal at 3%. All hernias any putative risk factors for the development of trocar site
occurred at the midline supraumbilical port, the only site herniation could be identified.
where open trocar insertion was employed. As a conse-
quence of these observations, we have developed a new
method of open trocar placement. This method utilizes a Patients and methods
paramedian skin incision and separate fascial incisions
through anterior and posterior rectus sheathes, with retrac- Study population
tion of the rectus abdominis muscle laterally.
The study population was comprised of 320 patients undergoing primary
laparoscopic fundoplication as treatment for gastroesophageal reflux dis-
ease (GERD) (n ⳱ 292) or paraesophageal hiatal hernia (n ⳱ 28) between
the years 1991 and 1999. The case records were reviewed retrospectively
and those patients who developed incisional herniation identified. For all
Presented at the annual meeting of the Society of American Gastrointes- patients, the following information was extracted from the case records:
tinal Endoscopic Surgeons (SAGES), Atlanta, GA, USA, 29 March– age, sex, body mass index (BMI), past medical/surgical history, and smok-
1 April 2000 ing history. Standard office follow-up for all patients after laparoscopic
Correspondence to: J. H. Peters fundoplication was 6 weeks from hospital discharge. Subsequent follow-up
664

Table 1. Characteristics of patients developing trocar site hernias

BMI Preexisting Intervala


Age/sex (Kg/m2) Prior abdominal surgery Pulmonary comorbidity hernia (mo)

37/M 27.1 — Current smoker (26 pack-years) No 10


40/M 28.7 — — No 5
46/F 23.5 Hysterectomy, Caesarean section Ex-smoker (30 pack-years) No 19
50/M 34.3 — — No 19
52/M 26.1 — — No 4
53/F 45.2 Open cholecystectomy — No 6
61/M 25.9 Appendectomy Ex-smoker (25 pack-years) No 14
72/F 28.5 Open cholecystectomy, hysterectomy Ex-smoker (45 pack-years) Yes 7
75/F 25.5 Hysterectomy — No 21

M, male; F, female; BMI, body mass index


a
Denotes interval between antireflux surgery and diagnosis of trocar hernia

Results

At a mean follow-up time of 12 months (range, 6 weeks to


81 months), nine patients (five male) with a mean age of 54
years (range, 37–75) had developed trocar site herniation,
for an overall prevalence of 3% (nine of 320). Table 1
summarizes the characteristics of these nine patients. Seven
trocar hernias occurred after laparoscopic fundoplication for
gastroesophageal reflux (seven of 292, or 2%), and two
occurred after fundoplication coupled with paraesophageal
hernia repair (two of 28, or 7%). In all patients, herniation
affected the supraumbilical port site, the only location
where open trocar insertion was employed. There was a
trend for patients with trocar hernias to have a higher body
mass index than those without hernias (mean BMI, 29.4
Fig. 1. Positioning of the trocars for laparoscopic fundoplication. kg/m2 vs 27.2 kg/m2, p ⳱ 0.13). None of the patients de-
veloped intestinal obstruction as a consequence of hernia-
tion. On average, the hernia was detected 12 months fol-
was by the referring clinician. Patients who required conversion to open lowing surgery (range, 4–12). To date, all but one of the
fundoplication, those who underwent revisional antireflux surgery, and
those who failed to attend for postoperative follow-up were excluded from hernias have been repaired; six of them required the inser-
the analysis. tion of a prosthetic mesh. One patient declined further sur-
gery.
Trocar insertion and wound closure
The technique of laparoscopic fundoplication that we followed has been Discussion
detailed previously [2]. Five 10-mm ports were used (Fig. 1). Sharp cutting
disposable trocars (Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Cincinnati, OH, USA) were The current study identified a 3% minimum prevalence of
employed, with trocar positioning as follows:
trocar site herniation after laparoscopic fundoplication. This
1. The camera was placed above the umbilicus, one-third of the distance to figure is in close agreement with four previous studies ex-
the xiphoid process. In all patients, the camera port was the first trocar
introduced. The open (Hassan) method was always followed.
amining the frequency of incisional herniation after laparo-
2. The surgeon’s right and left-handed trocars were placed in the right and scopic abdominal surgery (1–2%) [1, 15, 17, 18, 23]. Thus,
left midclavicular lines, 2–3 in below the costal margin. the risk of incisional herniation is approximately three times
3. The right-sided liver retractor was placed in the right midabdomen in less after laparoscopic fundoplication than after open fun-
the midclavicular line at or slightly below the camera port. doplication.
4. A second retraction port was placed at the level of the umbilicus in the
left anterior axillary line. All hernias affected the supraumbilical port site, the
only place where open trocar insertion was employed. Other
At the end of the procedure, the two lower lateral port sites were closed
using the fascial closure device (Advanced Surgical). The rectus sheath of
investigators have reported a similar predilection for her-
the camera port site was closed with three interrupted 0 Vicryl sutures. No niation to affect the midline port [20]. Moreover, this ob-
fascial closure of the two upper port sites was performed. servation is in keeping with the findings of earlier studies of
open abdominal surgery that examined the risk of incisional
herniation after midline and paramedian incisions [5, 13].
Statistics Kendall [13] randomized 349 patients undergoing laparot-
Since the continuous data followed a normal distribution, parametric tests
omy to one of the following three groups: (a) paramedian
were employed. Comparison of proportions was by the chi-square test. incision with layered closure, (b) midline incision with mass
Significance was assumed at the 5% level. closure, or (c) midline incision with layered closure. After
665

18 months, incisional hernias were not detected in any of the References


patients who underwent laparotomy via paramedian inci-
sion, but they were found in 7% and 6%, respectively, of the 1. Ahmad SA, Schuricht AL, Azurin DJ, Arroyo LR, Paskin DL, Bar AH,
Kirkland ML (1997) Complications of laparoscopic cholecystectomy:
two groups undergoing laparotomy via a midline incision. the experience of a university-affiliated teaching hospital. J. Laparo-
As a consequence of our observations, we sought a new endosc Adv Surg Tech 7: 29–35
approach that would minimize the risk of trocar site hernia- 2. Bowrey DJ, Peters JH (1999) Current state, techniques, and results of
tion subsequently. To this end, a new method of initial laparoscopic antireflux surgery. Sem Laparosc Surg 6: 194–212
3. Bucknall TE, Cox PJ, Ellis H (1982) Burst abdomen and incisional
trocar insertion has been developed. This method utilizes a hernia: a prospective study of 1129 major laparotomies. Br Med J Clin
paramedian incision and separate fascial incisions through Res Ed 284: 931–933
anterior and posterior rectus sheathes, with retraction of the 4. Carlson MA, Condon RE (1995) Polyglyconate (Maxon) versus nylon
rectus abdominis muscle laterally. It is based on findings suture in midline abdominal incision closure: a prospective random-
ized trial. Am Surg 61: 980–983
from the studies cited above showing that paramedian inci- 5. Cox PJ, Ausobsky JR, Ellis H, Pollock AV (1986) Towards no inci-
sions are less susceptible to incisional herniation than mid- sional hernias: lateral paramedian versus midline incisions. J R Soc
line incisions [5, 13]. Med 79: 711–712
An alternative strategy to reduce the likelihood of inci- 6. De Giuli M, Festa V, Denoye GC, Morino M (1994) Large postop-
erative umbilical hernia following laparoscopic cholecystectomy: a
sional herniation is to achieve pneumoperitoneum using a case report. Surg Endosc 8: 904–905
Veress needle and to insert the initial midline trocar in an 7. Eltabbakh GH (1999) Small bowel obstruction secondary to herniation
oblique fashion. We speculate that the obliquity of trocar through a 5-mm laparoscopic trocar site following laparoscopic
cannula insertion into the lateral ports prevents the forma- lymphadenectomy. Eur J Gynaecol Oncol 20: 275–276
8. Guillou PJ, Hall TJ, Donaldson DR, Broughton AC, Brennan TG
tion of overlapping anterior and posterior rectus fascial de- (1980) Vertical abdominal incisions—a choice? Br J Surg 67: 395–399
fects. 9. Hass BE, Schrager RE (1993) Small bowel obstruction due to Rich-
One aspect of laparoscopic fundoplication that has re- ter’s hernia after laparoscopic procedures. J Laparoendosc Surg 3:
ceived scant attention is the design of the trocar. When a 421–423
10. Israelsson LA, Jonsson T, Knutsson A (1996) Suture technique and
Veress needle and blind trocar cannula insertion are used, wound healing in midline laparotomy incisions. Eur J Surg 162: 605–
trocar shape and contour are likely to influence the size of 609
the fascial defect created. In a recent animal study, Tarnay 11. Johnson B, Sharp R, Thursby P (1995) Incisional hernias: incidence
et al. [25] compared the area of the fascial defect created by following abdominal aortic aneurysm repair. J Cardiovasc Surg 36:
487–490
the insertion of six different laparoscopic trocar cannula 12. Jones DB, Callery MP, Soper NJ (1996) Strangulated incisional hernia
systems—two of pyramidal design, two of blunt conical at trocar site. Surg Laparosc Endosc 6: 152–154
design, and two of cutting–dilating design. The trocars were 13. Kendall SW, Brennan TG, Guillou PJ (1991) Suture length to wound
of equivalent diameter (12 mm), and all measurements were length ratio and the integrity of midline and lateral paramedian inci-
sions. Br J Surg 78: 705–707
made by a blinded observer. Despite having similar mean 14. Kurtz BR, Daniell JF, Spaw AT (1993) Incarcerated incisional hernia
incisional lengths, the blunt conical trocars resulted in after laparoscopy: a case report. J Reprod Med 38: 643–644
smaller fascial defects (10 and 12 mm2) than both the py- 15. Leibl BJ, Schmedt CG, Schwarz J, Kraft K, Bittner R (1999) Laparo-
ramidal (18 and 27 mm2) and the cutting–dilating trocars scopic surgery complications associated with trocar tip design: review
of literature and own results. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech 9: 135–
(29 and 31 mm2). The authors concluded that these differ- 140
ences could have important clinical implications—namely, 16. Lord RS, Crozier JA, Snell J, Meek AC (1994) Transverse abdominal
by reducing the risk of incisional herniation. These conclu- incisions compared with midline incisions for elective infrarenal aortic
sions are borne out by data from Leibl et al. [15], who found reconstruction: predisposition to incisional hernia in patients with in-
creased intraoperative blood loss. J Vasc Surg 20: 27–33
a reduction in the frequency of trocar site herniations from 17. Montz FJ, Holschneider CH, Munro MG (1994) Incisional hernia fol-
2% to 0.2% when a conical-shaped trocar was used in place lowing laparoscopy: a study of the American Association of Gyneco-
of a sharp cutting trocar. logic Laparoscopists. Obstet Gynecol 84: 881–884
It is noteworthy that the mean interval between antire- 18. Nezhat C, Nezhat F, Seidman DS, Nezhat C (1997) Incisional hernias
after operative laparoscopy. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech 7: 111–115
flux surgery and the diagnosis of an incisional hernia was 12 19. Patterson M, Walters D, Browder W (1993) Postoperative bowel ob-
months, ranging from 4 to 21 months. This finding under- struction following laparoscopic surgery. Am Surg 59: 656–657
scores the importance of medium-term follow-up of patients 20. Plaus WJ (1993) Laparoscopic trocar hernias. J Laparoendosc Surg 3:
after laparoscopic fundoplication. Although patients who 567–570
21. Regnard JF, Hay JM, Rea S, Fingerhut A, Flamant Y, Maillard JN
failed to attend for postoperative follow-up were excluded (1988) Ventral incisional hernias: incidence, date of recurrence, local-
from the analysis, it is possible that we have underestimated ization and risk. Ital J Surg Sci 18: 259–265
the prevalence of incisional hernia. In a study of >1200 22. Reissman P, Shiloni E, Gofrit O, Rivkind A, Durst A (1994) Incar-
patients undergoing open abdominal surgery over an 8-year cerated hernia in a lateral trocar site—an unusual early postoperative
period, Regnard et al. [21] found that 20% of incisional complication of laparoscopic surgery: case report. Eur J Surg 160:
191–192
hernias occurred late—i.e, after 24 months. 23. Sanz-Lopez R, Martinez-Ramos C, Nunez-Pena JR, Ruiz de Gopegui
In summary, we identified trocar site herniation after M, Pastor-Sirera L, Tamames-Escobar S (1999) Incisional hernias af-
laparoscopic fundoplication in 3% of patients. The midline ter laparoscopic vs open cholecystectomy. Surg Endosc 13: 922–924
supraumbilical port was the only site affected. As a conse- DOI: 10.1007/s004649901135
quence of these observations, a new method of open trocar 24. Storms P, Stuyven G, Vanhemelen G, Sebrechts R (1994) Incarcerated
trocar-wound hernia after laparoscopic hysterectomy: is closure of
placement has been developed that utilizes a paramedian large trocar fascia defects after laparoscopy necessary? Surg Endosc 8:
skin incision and separate fascial incisions through the an- 901–902
terior and posterior rectus sheathes. 25. Tarnay CM, Glass KB, Munro MG (1999) Incision characteristics
666

associated with six laparoscopic trocar–cannula systems: a random- 28. Wegener ME, Chung D, Crans C, Chung D (1993) Small bowel ob-
ized, observer-blinded comparison. Obstet Gynecol 94: 89–93 DOI: struction secondary to incarcerated Richter’s hernia from laparoscopic
10.1016/S0029-7844(99)00287-2 hernia repair. J Laparoendosc Surg 3: 173–176
26. Trimbos JB, Smit IB, Holm JP, Hermans J (1992) A randomized 29. Wissing J, van Vroonhoven TJ, Schattenkerk ME, Veen HF, Ponsen
clinical trial comparing two methods of fascia closure following mid- RJ, Jeekel J (1987) Fascia closure after midline laparotomy: results of
line laparotomy. Arch Surg 127: 1232–1234 a randomised trial. Br J Surg 74: 738–741
27. Waldhausen JH (1996) Incisional hernia in a 5-mm trocar site follow- 30. Yuen PM (1995) Early incisional hernia following laparoscopic sur-
ing pediatric laparoscopy. J Laparoendosc Surg 6: 1 S89–S90 gery. Austr N Z J Obstet Gynecol 35: 211–212