Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Luigi Villa
Rev. Luigi Villa Th. D.
Vatican II
awaits them, as the sinner who cried in
front of the empty tomb: “Where hast
thou put Him?”»
ABOUT FACE!
(From: “Pius XII Before History”)
$ 20.00
The Apostolate of Our Lady of Good Success
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 2
Copyright ® 2011
The Apostolate of Our Lady of Good Success
ISBN: .....
Library of Congress Control Number: ...
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 3
Vatican II
ABOUT
FACE!
The Apostolate of Our Lady of Good Success
1288 Summit Ave Suite 107
Oconomowoc, WI. 53066 USA
Phone 262-567-0920
Website: www.ourladyofgoodsuccess.com
Email: ladyofgoodsuccess@sbcglobal.net
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 4
Index
Preface 9
Introduction 13
Chapter I
So, why a “New Council”? 25
Chapter II
Theological Qualification of Vatican II 35
Chapter III
“Sacrosantum Concilium” Constitution
– A “New Liturgy” – 49
Chapter IV
“Unitatis redintegratio” Decree
– Ecumenism – 91
Chapter V
“Gaudium et spes” Constitution
– The Church and the World – 115
4
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 5
Chapter VI
“Dignitatis Humanae” Constitution
– Religious Freedom – 131
Chapter VII
“Nostra Aetate” Constitution
– Non-Christian Religions – 159
Chapter VIII
“Lumen gentium” Constitution
– The Church – 171
Chapter IX
– Collegiality – 183
Conclusion 193
Appendix
If the Pope falls into heresy or schism... 199
5
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 6
6
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 7
7
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 8
8
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 9
PREFACE
9
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 10
10
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 11
12
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 13
INTRODUCTION
13
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 14
14
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 15
15
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 16
Perhaps the Popes (John XXIII and Paul VI) executors and
directors of this “pastoral and non-dogmatic council” would
not say the same about Vatican II? So, his “pastoral” consists,
ultimately, in the Church’s relationship with the world, and this
makes it different from other councils precisely because it
lacks a “defining” doctrinal character. Strange, then, that the
absence of intent contradicts the “dogmatic” qualifications of
the two constitutions: “Lumen Gentium” and “Dei Verbum”,
which were reproposed in the” Dogmatic Constitution, because
they had been proposed as truths of the faith and dogmas de-
fined in previous councils (pp. 50-51). However, it remains
clear that the other documents of Vatican II do have not a dog-
matic character, whereby their doctrines do not point to previ-
ous definitions, are neither infallible nor irreformable, and thus
non-binding; those who deny them, are not automatically con-
sidered heretical Whoever then would impose it as infallible
and irreformable, would go against the Council itself.
So one might accept Vatican II as only markedly dogmat-
ic only when the Vatican II proposes truths of the faith and
dogmas defined in previous councils.
“The doctrines that originated at the Council, however ab-
solutely cannot be considered dogmatic, for the inescapable
reason that they are devoid of ‘unavoidable formalities of de-
finition and, therefore, of its “voluntas definiendi” (p. 51).
Therefore, the texts that have a certain ambiguity can be sub-
ject to historical and theological criticism.
An example is the “Pastoral Constitution”, “Gaudium
et Spes” on the Church in the Modern World, where the term
“pastoral” becomes a humanistic term of empathy, openness,
of understanding toward Man, his history and “aspects of
modern life and human society”, with particular attention to
“problems that seem more urgent today.”
Therefore, “Gaudium et Spes” is a document full of cul-
ture and institutions (GS 53), economic and social progress
(GS 66), technological advances (GS 23), and human progress
(GS 37.39.53.72). It is obvious that it is a “new Christianity”
that extends its boundaries to Karl Rahner and Schille-
16
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 17
17
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 18
18
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 19
19
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 20
20
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 21
21
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 22
Paul VI.
22
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 23
Benedict XVI.
23
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 24
24
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 25
Chapter 1
HOWEVER, WHY
A “NEW COUNCIL”?
25
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 26
26
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 27
27
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 28
2. A “New Religion”
There is an “error” marked by Pentecostal Enlighten-
ment and included in John XXIII’s speech at Basilica of
Saint Paul Outside the Walls on January 25, 1959, where he
speaks of an “inspiration” confirmed by a “splendor of ce-
lestial lights” and the Pope did not hesitate to compare Vati-
can II with “a second Last Supper,” insinuating that the
“first” Last Supper had been on the day of Pentecost,
whereas the “second” one would be the “Ecumenical Coun-
cil” in Rome. However, John XXIII’s Enlightenment is
“charismatic” because the Pope stated that the heretics and
separatists’ prayers, as well as their abundant and wholesome
fruits, are of supernatural value, even if they are “outside the
Bosom of the Church.” Although no one can assert this, if we
can say that they have saved their souls and converted, then we
should say that Vatican II has founded a “new religion”!
28
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 29
the heart, the return to the true Faith and Christ and the true
Church, whereas John XXIII’s “prophets of joy” do not
want debilitating joy that does not lead for certain to Happi-
ness and is not true God’s inspiration.
The disdain, irony and sarcasm in John XXIII’s speech
can be explained this way: in 1960, everyone expected the
publication of the “Third Secret” of Fatima, but John XIII
did not want to know it, demonstrating his easy-going and
good natured personality and saying that he did not want to
hear about sad things!
It is true that the Pope did not speak “ex cathedra” and
did not make use of his Papal authority, but this did not pre-
vent his condemnation against the “prophets of doom” from
becoming a ticket to the Devil of sorts who then turned against
him [the pope] and his supporters!
5. “Modernism”
This Satanic “heresy” named Modernism triumphed in
the Second Vatican Council, covered by the principle set
forth by John XXIII: “men are always more convinced that
the dignity and perfection of the human being are very im-
29
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 30
6. “Religious freedom”
This new break with the Catholic Faith is the one we de-
scribed in the previous chapter, by Pope John XXIII: “Men
are always more convinced that the dignity and perfection
of the human being are very important values that de-
mand hard efforts.”
Here, the Declaration “Dignitatis Humanae” specified
this statement made by John XXIII, and the Pastoral Con-
stitution “Gaudium et Spes” drew all the consequences that
can be inferred as follows: the dignity and perfection of the
human person are such that do not allow the use of violence
or conflicts, but rather demand that we recognize everyone’s
freedom, complete responsibility of their thoughts, their
choices and their social and political commitments.
30
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 31
7. Ecumenism
Here the heresy lies in attributing to Jesus Christ a desire
of unity that He never had, because His true idea of union will
be put in place by Him - gathering all people under one fold,
His own! Since Pentecost, in fact, there has been no other
church than the Church of Christ and outside of Her, there is
no other religion, and therefore no one can be saved “out-
side of It.” The error here is the will to break with the dogma:
“There is no salvation outside the Church.”
31
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 32
32
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 33
33
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 34
34
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 35
Chapter II
THEOLOGICAL QUALIFICATION
OF THE SECOND
VATICAN COUNCIL
35
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 36
36
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 37
37
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 38
38
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 39
39
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 40
40
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 41
41
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 42
42
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 43
43
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 44
44
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 45
45
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 46
Yves-Marie-Joseph Congar.
46
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 47
47
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 48
***
48
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 49
Chapter III
“SACROSANTUM CONCILIUM”
CONSTITUTION
– A “New Liturgy”
49
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 50
50
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 51
51
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 52
52
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 53
53
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 54
54
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 55
55
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 56
56
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 57
57
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 58
58
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 59
59
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 60
useless, but also all those side altars, suggesting with this
that no worship should be given to the Saints, not even
“dulia” and also challenging, even here, the condemnation
of heresy made by the Council of Trent!
What was the fate of the tabernacle?
In his Speech of September 22, 1956, Pius XII wrote:
60
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 61
61
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 62
62
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 63
LATIN LANGUAGE
63
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 64
64
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 65
65
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 66
66
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 67
67
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 68
***
68
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 69
69
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 70
70
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 71
71
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 72
72
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 73
To which it adds:
73
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 74
74
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 75
75
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 76
76
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 77
77
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 78
78
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 79
4 The edited text is as follows: “In the Mass, or Sunday supper, God’s peo-
ple gather to celebrate with the presence of a priest, who acts “on behalf
of Christ”, the remembrance or Eucharistic sacrifice. This local assembly
is immediately founded in Christ’s promise: “Where two or three people
are gathered in my name, I am among them.”
79
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 80
80
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 81
in recent years.5»
81
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 82
82
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 83
***
83
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 84
84
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 85
85
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 86
86
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 87
87
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 88
88
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 89
89
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 90
***
***
90
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 91
Chapter IV
DECREE:
“UNITATIS REDINTEGRATIO”
– Ecumenism –
91
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 92
92
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 93
93
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 94
94
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 95
95
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 96
96
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 97
97
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 98
98
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 99
99
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 100
100
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 101
101
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 102
***
102
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 103
103
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 104
104
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 105
***
105
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 106
106
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 107
107
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 108
108
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 109
109
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 110
110
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 111
History of Ecumenism,
from Its Origins until Vatican II
1910 World Missionary Conference to discuss the prob-
lems of missionary work in the non-Christian world,
held in Hamburg.
111
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 112
112
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 113
Hans Urs von Balthasar, the “Father of the New Ecumenical Apostasy”.
113
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 114
***
114
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 115
Chapter V
“GAUDIUM ET SPES”
CONSTITUTION
– The Church and the World –
115
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 116
God”. The famous principles mask the true intent, which was
successfully confused with lies.
Now, in the Constitution: “The Church in the Modern
World”, it states: “The Church, therefore, by virtue of the
Gospel (?) committed to Her, proclaims the “rights of
man”; She acknowledges and greatly esteems the dynamic
movements of today by which these rights are everywhere
fostered.”
If so, then one cannot be surprised by Paul VI’s declara-
tion in Manila: “I feel the need to profess, here more than
anywhere, the “rights of man” for you and all the poor of
the world.” (Nov. 27, 1970)
We would expect that a Pope would feel the need to pro-
fess the Gospel, but instead, reading the writings of Pope
Paul VI, it is clear that, for him, being a messenger of the
Gospel and “the Declaration of the Rights of Man”, are one
and the same thing.
And again: “The Church strongly believes that the pro-
motion of “human rights” is a requirement of the Gospel
and as such it must occupy a central position in Her min-
istry” (Nov. 17, 1974).
He insists: “Wishing to convert fully to the Lord and
better fulfil Her ministry, the Church intends to show re-
spect and diligence for the “rights of man,” within Herself
as well.” (Message to the Synod, Oct. 23, 1974)
And continues: “In light of what we perceive to be our
duty to evangelize, and with the force that comes from our
duty to proclaim the Good News, we affirm our determi-
nation to promote human rights and reconciliation every-
where, in the Church and in the contemporary world.”
Therefore, this was the opinion of Paul VI. In his eyes,
the “Declaration on the Rights of Man” was a sort of mod-
ern version of the Gospel, whereas it was the complete oppo-
site!
The Gospel, in fact, does not teach human rights, but
rather teaches the duties that we have towards God, al-
though while respecting those duties to GOD, the rights of our
116
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 117
117
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 118
118
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 119
119
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 120
120
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 121
121
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 122
122
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 123
123
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 124
124
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 125
125
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 126
126
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 127
127
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 128
128
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 129
129
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 130
***
130
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 131
Chapter VI
“DIGNITATIS HUMANAE”
CONSTITUTION
– Religious Freedom –
131
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 132
132
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 133
133
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 134
134
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 135
“RELIGIOUS FREEDOM”
ON THE THEOLOGICAL PLANE
This expression of “religious freedom” became popular
after Vatican II issued “Dignitatis Humanae,” which was
precisely on “religious freedom.”
It is a fact that the contradiction between Vatican II and
the previous traditional teaching is more than evident. It is
enough to compare two official texts: “Dignitatis Humanae”
and “Quanta Cura” by Pius IX.
The discussion that occurred in the Council meetings be-
tween the two factions was a true dialogue that fell on deaf
ears. Everyone, even though using the same text, gave it a dif-
ferent interpretation. I will limit myself here to mention the
“heterodoxy” of the teaching of “Dignitatis Humanae,” in
its form and application, and, for example, in Spain.
In my opinion, the rift with Vatican II was on the issue
of “Religious Freedom.”
Let us immediately consider its application in Spain.
135
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 136
and in paragraph 2:
136
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 137
137
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 138
138
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 139
139
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 140
140
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 141
***
141
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 142
142
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 143
143
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 144
144
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 145
145
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 146
146
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 147
147
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 148
And also:
148
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 149
149
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 150
And yet, the golden calf was not a representation – also il-
legal! – of the God of Israel!
150
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 151
In conclusion:
Professing and evangelizing false religions, even if pro-
tected by civil authorities, is not at all the “freedom” re-
ferred to by the positive law nor the natural one; on the
contrary, it would be licentious and, therefore, an inherently
immoral “freedom”!
Therefore, the Pope is not allowed to remain silent in or-
der not to disturb the good faith of the people, but rather, he is
obliged to speak, to preach, to spread the Gospel, to call peo-
ple back to the “true faith” and, thereby, to the Church, at
least as an implicit desire to include faith and supernatural
charity.
Wasn’t it, perhaps, the Lord Himself who gave to Peter
and the Apostles the command to go and preach His faith,
the only true faith, in order to win over all souls of good
faith to the Gospel? And this, because – according to the
“doctrine” of the Church since the beginning – those who
belong to the Church only “in voto”, or rather, with an im-
plicit or explicit wish, do not have the assurance of their eter-
nal salvation, nor of the ordinary means (doctrine and Sacra-
ments) to attain it.
Thus, all the Apostles did so. They became “martyrs”,
precisely because those who refused the true faith, - there-
fore, in bad faith! - killed them!
Certainly, the “truth”, because it is uncompromising, al-
ways upsets and offends those who do not want the light and
perform evil works [John 3,19: “... the light is come into the
world, and men loved darkness rather than the light: for their
works were evil”]. But those that, like the Apostles, remain
151
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 152
152
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 153
QUANTA CURA
The proposition Pope Pius IX condemned is:
153
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 154
“RELIGIOUS FREEDOM”
ACCORDING TO SOME COUNCIL FATHERS
154
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 155
155
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 156
Hans Küng.
156
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 157
157
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 158
158
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 159
Chapter VII
“NOSTRA AETATE”
CONSTITUTION
– Non-Christian Religions –
159
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 160
160
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 161
161
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 162
162
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 163
163
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 164
164
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 165
165
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 166
166
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 167
167
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 168
Luise Rinser ex wife of musician Karl Orff and mistress of Karl Rah-
ner, who wrote her 1.800 letters always most ardent and passionate.
168
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 169
169
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 170
170
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 171
Chapter VIII
“LUMEN GENTIUM”
CONSTITUTION
– The Church –
171
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 172
As we can see, it does not refer to the text: “You are Pe-
ter and on this rock I will build My Church”, so that the
phrases “put Peter at its head,” and “their chief,” or
“head,” have the meaning of a simple “primacy of honor.”
At N° 20, the misunderstanding remains; in fact, it says:
172
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 173
173
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 174
174
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 175
175
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 176
176
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 177
177
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 178
178
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 179
179
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 180
THE “SUBSISTIT”
IN “LUMEN GENTIUM”
Pius XII, in his encyclical “Mystici Corporis” dated June
20, 1943, expresses himself with inequivocable clarity, with
his teaching up until Vatican II. Speaking about the unity and
the uniqueness of the Church, Pius XII uses the word “est”,
whereas the Constitution of Council “Lumen Gentium”
uses the word “subsistit in.”
It says:
180
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 181
She realized the way to exist, but which, however, can also be
found elsewhere.
It is a “change of direction,” if we know the revealed
truth, namely Catholic doctrine.
It is still evident that this substitution of “est” with
“subsistit in” also betrayed the precise directive of John
XXIII to the Council and repeated, then, by Paul VI: “It is
necessary - affirmed John XXIII – first of all, that the
Church does not stray from the sacred patrimony of the
truth” (…) and later: «this concerns the renewed, serene
and calm adherence to the whole teaching of the Church in
its entirety and precision, that still shines in Conciliar acts
from Trent until Vatican I.»
But it was easy to foresee the abuses that neo-modernists
and liberals of all kinds would have made of the ecumenical
formula “subsistit in.” For example, H. Küng, basing him-
self on this phrase “subsistit in,” affirmed that after such a
Constitution, the Catholic Church “does not identify simply
as the Church of Christ.” The Catholic doctrine, since then,
has been enlightened by Vatican II.
After the Council, there were various attempts to again
propose the idea of the “only” Church, even if it is current-
ly divided among different Christian churches, as if they were
different «branches. (pan-Christian, worked up by Protestant
ecumenism and condemned by Pius XII in “Mortalium Ani-
mos”).2»
2 Cfr. Bouyer, “La Chiesa di Dio, corpo di Cristo e tempio dello Spiri-
to”; Cittadella, Assisi p. 603.
181
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 182
182
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 183
Chapter IX
COLLEGIALITY
183
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 184
184
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 185
185
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 186
186
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 187
5 In this passage, the Council Fathers cite: Jn. 1,42; Mt. 16, 16-1; Jn. 21,
15-17.
187
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 188
188
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 189
189
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 190
Karl Rahner and Joseph Ratzinger: the “mind” and the “arm”.
190
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 191
191
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 192
«Wreaking havoc
on the opinions of a people
is a diabolical game of one year;
putting them back in order
takes centuries.»
192
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 193
CONCLUSION
193
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 194
194
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 195
195
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 196
196
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 197
Benedict XVI.
197
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 198
198
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 199
APPENDIX
If the Pope
falls into heresy or schism...
Today, could one also say that the Hierarchy of the Ro-
man Church is destroying the Catholic doctrine, to give us
a “new religion”? But, how is this possible? How is it possi-
ble that whoever follows the new doctrinal guidelines, which
are often in contradiction with Catholic doctrine, is outside
the Faith of pre-Vatican II?
One could point to all of the documentation of the Coun-
cil and all of the acts of Paul VI and John Paul Il, if the
limited space of this text were sufficient to show “facts” and
“words” that would prove the contrast to the doctrine and
practice of the traditional Church1.
One can obviously not believe that Paul VI and John
Paul II did not know Catholic doctrine, holding degrees in
199
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 200
200
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 201
201
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 202
202
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:33 Pagina 203
203
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:34 Pagina 204
204
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:34 Pagina 205
205
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:34 Pagina 206
Cop Vat. II dietro-elena:Cop Vat. II dietro front en 29/11/11 12:00 Pagina 1
Luigi Villa
Rev. Luigi Villa Th. D.
Vatican II
awaits them, as the sinner who cried in
front of the empty tomb: “Where hast
thou put Him?”»
ABOUT FACE!
(From: “Pius XII Before History”)
$ 20.00
The Apostolate of Our Lady of Good Success
Vat. II dietro front en-ELENA:Vat. II dietro front en 30/11/11 10:34 Pagina 207