Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1- Division of Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility, Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Johns Hopkins University
School of Medicine, Baltimore, USA
2- Zanvyl Krieger School of Arts and Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, USA
Abstract
The number of couples seeking consultation for infertility problems has steadily in-
creased over the past decade, affecting 10%−15% of the sexually active population.
* Corresponding Author:
Paul R. Brezina, Division Abnormal semen production, a male factor infertility (MFI), is thought to be the
of Reproductive cause of up to 50% of all infertilities in developed countries. There are potentially
Endocrinology and many different causes of male infertility, including hormonal, anatomical, and sec-
Infertility, Department of ondary to exposure to exogenous substances. In many cases of MFI, a definitive
Gynecology and
Obstetrics, Johns Hopkins
cause for abnormalities is never identified. Recently, the research community has
University School of given greater attention to identifying causes of MFI ranging from genetic Y chromo-
Medicine, Baltimore, USA some microdeletions to mechanisms of environmental damage on sperm production.
E-mail: Still evolving, is a clear understanding of how many pharmaceutical medications
pbrezin1@jhmi.edu may cause MFI, which is often treatable and reversible. In this review we will out-
Received: Oct. 5, 2011 line the data regarding various pharmaceutical medications that have been investi-
Accepted: Dec. 31, 2011 gated as possible causes of MFI.
Introduction
auses of male infertility: The number of motility are estimated to be as high as 44% and
couples seeking consultation for infertility 15% respectively (8).
problems has steadily increased over the The causes of oligospermia or azoospermia can
past decade, affecting 10%−15% of the sexually be divided into three distinct stages: Pre-Tes-
active population (1, 2). MFI contributes to ticular, Testicular, and Post-Testicular, depending
approximately 50% of all infertility (2−4). MFI on the stage of spermatogenesis which is altered
may is generally diagnosed through an abnormal or impaired (9). Pre-testicular stage azoospermia
semen analysis (SA). While the SA has multiple results from the pituitary gland, part of the hypo-
measured parameters, the most important are ab- thalamic-pituitary-gonadal (HPG) axis, not pro-
normalities in sperm count, ranging from fewer ducing proper hormones to stimulate the testes to
than normal sperm (oligospermia) to undetectable produce sperm and is often due to an underlying
sperm (azoospermia), sperm motility, a condition endocrinologic abnormality (9).
known as asthenospermia, and sperm morphology Testicular stage azoospermia is a failure of tes-
(5, 6). The relative importance of each of these ticular function and Post-Testicular azoospermia
parameters, among other measures of semen qual- is due to physical causes such as obstruction (9).
ity, are constantly a subject of debate within the In the majority of MFI cases, a definitive cause
fertility community (5, 7). A further complicating for abnormalities is never identified (4). Pharma-
matter is the poor reproducibility of SA as an as- ceutical medications as well as recreational drugs
sessment tool for sperm quality and quantity. In- have been documented to impact semen produc-
deed, data has shown that interjaculate coeffi- ticular stages (2, 10, 11). In addition, some medi-
cients of variation for sperm concentration and cations impair ejaculation and erectile function, as
well as the ability to decrease libido (12). This Another retrospective trial has demonstrated an
review article will focus on the effects of certain association between SSRI use and decreased
pharmaceutical medications that may be associ- sperm motility (23). Evidence also shows that
ated with male infertility. SSRIs have a spermicidal effect in vitro (24). One
Anti-depressants: Depression is a common dis- group has actually described SSRIs as an acutely
order with a lifetime prevalence of approximately helpful therapy to improve increased ejaculate
16% (13). Rising levels of depressive disorders volume in men taking Sildenafil (25). While there
have in turn led to an increase in the use of pre- have been several small trials that link SSRIs to
scription antidepressants, with more than 253 mil- semen abnormalities, the authors could not iden-
lion prescriptions on record for 2010, the second tify a large trial that definitively link SSRIs to
most among all medications in the United States MFI as defined by in ability to achieve pregnancy.
(14). The underlying cause of depression is still As such, the data linking SSRIs to MFI are, at the
being investigated but is thought to include an present time, suggestive but not conclusive. A
over-activity of the emotion processing regions of summary of the current evidence is offered in
ventral limbic and underactivity of the dorsal pre- Table 1.
frontal cortex (15). Antidepressent medications, Calcium channel blockers: Calcium Channel
specifically selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors Blockers (CCBs) are calcium ion antagonists.
(SSRIs), are currently the treatment of choice for They block the movement of free calcium ions,
individuals suffering from depression (16). SSRIs which serve as important secondary messengers,
have been implicated as a source of MFI. How- between ion channels and ionophores. CCBs can
ever, as the use of SSRIs has increased in recent have an effect on cardiac muscle, smooth muscle
years, few studies have evaluated the effect of of blood vessels, and neurons (26, 27). CCBs are
SSRIs on MFI. Further complicating the picture is indicated as a therapy for various medical condi-
the fact that some studies have linked depression tions including hypertension and heart failure (26,
alone, without the use of medications, to altered 27).
testosterone levels, which could conceivably con- Since 1988, calcium antagonists have been
tribute to MFI (17, 18). However, several other shown to produce a dose-dependent reduction in
studies have failed to demonstrate such a correl- sperm motility and viability in vitro (28). In one
ation (17, 19, 20). particular in vitro assay, the dose-dependent effect
In 2006, researchers at Weill Cornell Medical of Nifedipine, a CCB, was examined with regards
College in New York published a case report that to sperm morphology, motility, and phospholipid
proposed a possible link between SSRIs and MFI composition. The addition of the CCB resulted in
(21). In 2010, the same group performed a retro- significant inhibition of calcium ion uptake. The
spective study on thirty-five healthy male volun- researchers also elucidated a clear dose-dependent
teers (22). The men were asked to provide semen and time-dependent effect of the calcium antagon-
samples at baseline and were then administered ist on sperm motility for different durations. Add-
the drug paroxetine, an SSRI, for a period of five itionally, this study showed that exposure to the
weeks. Results indicated that the key sperm par- CCB resulted in structural changes in both the
ameters of volume, concentration, motility or head and tail regions of sperm when evaluated by
morphology were not adversely affected during scanning electron microscope (29). Others have
the trial period. However, sperm integrity DNA shown that CCB may inhibit the ability of sperm
analysis showed that mean sperm DNA fragmen- to bind to an egg by altering the lipid bilayer of
tation was significantly greater (30.3%) in men the sperm plasma membrane (27).
after continued use of paroxetine when compared Interestingly, researchers have also shown that
to the baseline (13.8%). Furthermore, self-reports calcium ions exert a paradoxical effect on human
from the subjects showed that 35% cited consider- sperm motility, depending on the developmental
able changes in erectile function while 47% noted stage of the sperm (30). Earlier in vitro experi-
difficulties with ejaculation while taking paroxe- ments in non-human mammalian species had
tine. Limitations of the study included a small shown an increase in sperm motility with the add-
sample size of healthy volunteers without baseline ition of calcium ions, likely through the binding of
depression, a lack of placebo pill use in the con- calcium to a calmodulin-like protein. However,
trol group, and the fact that fertility was not evalu- other experiments demonstrated that calcium
ated. chelators (EGTA and EDTA) as well as calcium
antagonists increased motility in human semen. plasia (BPH) (33). These drugs have a high affin-
One possible hypothesis for this effect was the ity for alpha-adrenergic receptors in the smooth
triggering of a premature acrosome reaction in muscle cells of the lower urinary tract and blood
sperms before they underwent full capacitation vessels (33). AABs also have a high binding affin-
and maturation (31). ity for various other receptors including dopamine
In addition to the in vitro studies outlined above, and serotonin (33).
there are also clinical trials that point to a link The use of AABs has been shown to be associ-
between CCBs and MFI. One small trial evalu- ated with significant rates of antegrade ejaculation
ating sperm from men taking CCB did not show or even anejaculation (33, 34). As the process of
decreased rates of oocyte fertilization when under- male ejaculation encompasses a complex coordin-
going in vitro fertilization (IVF) without intracy- ation of actions, this affect of AABs is thought to
toplasmic sperm injection (32). However, the be secondary to the effect on dopamine and sero-
pregnancy rate per transfer in embryos derived tonin, among other mechanisms (34). The degree
from men taking CCBs was only 17.4% (32). to which AABs may compromise the ejaculatory
While significant data exists to suggest that CCBs efficiency is substantial. One trial using a 5-day
may contribute to MFI, the authors could not treatment with tamsulosin (an AAB) demonstrated
identify a large prospective trial evaluating fertil- that a measurable decrease in ejaculate volume
ity outcomes among men taking CCBs. A sum- may be seen in 90% of subjects following AABs
mary of the current evidence is offered in Table 1. use (33). Furthermore, the rate of anejaculation
Alpha-Adrenergic Blockers: Alpha-adrenergic following AAB administration was as high as
blockers (AAB) are a class of medication most 30% (33). Additionally, AABs have been shown
commonly used to treat Lower Urinary Tract Syn- to also negatively impact semen parameters such
drome associated with Benign Prostatic Hyper- as sperm concentration and motility (34).
However, other trials using AABs other than that the majority of studies have failed to elimin-
tamsulosin, such as alfuzosin, have not demon- ate. A summary of the current evidence is offered
strated deleterious effects on ejaculatory effi- in table 1.
ciency or altered semen parameters (35). While Anti-retrovirals: The treatment of human im-
significant data exists to suggest that AABs, spe- munodeficiency virus (HIV) has transformed a
cifically tamsulosin, may contribute to MFI, the once quickly lethal disease into a condition that,
authors could not identify a large prospective trial with proper treatment, may be compatible with a
evaluating fertility outcomes among men taking long lifespan (43, 44). As such, many individuals
AABs. A summary of the current evidence is with well controlled HIV are increasingly inter-
offered in Table 1. ested in the possibility of pursuing parenthood.
Anti-epilepsy: Epilepsy is known to be associated Therefore, an understanding of how medications
with MFI. Epileptic males have been shown, in used to treat HIV may impact MFI is warranted.
large studies, to have significantly lower fertility The ability of HIV positive men to father children
rates and greater risks of hyposexuality than the even with HIV seronegative women is now a
general population (36). Studies on anti-epileptic reasonable proposition through IVF risk reduction
medications including carbamazepine, phenytoin programs that involve sperm washing to signifi-
and valproate have suggested specific drug-de- cantly reduce the risk of HIV transmission (45).
pendent side effects, including abnormal sperm Early HIV infection is not thought to significant-
morphology, reduced motility, lower sperm count, ly impair semen parameters (46−48). However,
and reduced testicular volume. The most likely some have evaluated if medications used to treat
mechanism for these side effects is thought by HIV infection could affect MFI. Highly active
some to be the interaction between anti-epileptic antiretroviral therapy (HAART) is provided to
medications and sex hormones, interfering with patients with HIV and, despite its tremendous
normal HPG pathway functioning (37). However, reduction in HIV mortality, has been associated
many studies have been inconclusive whether with a number of serious adverse side effects in-
these effects are symptoms of epilepsy itself or cluding neuropathy and lipodystrophy (49).
side effects of long-term administration of anti- Numerous studies have evaluated the effect of
epileptic medications (38, 39). HAART on sperm quality. One study showed that
One case report published in 2005 described a saquinavir, commonly used in HAART regimens,
patient suffering from infertility taking 400mg/day results in decreased sperm motility in vitro and
of carbamazepine with a semen analysis showing negatively affects mechanisms that are essential to
a normal sperm concentration but no motile fertilization of an oocyte such as the acrosome
sperm. One month after discontinuing his carba- reaction (50). A clinical study prospectively fol-
mazepine and starting phenytoin monotherapy, his lowed men starting HAART and demonstrated a
semen parameters were found to be normal and 60% reduction in sperm motility over a period of
his wife became pregnant within 6 months (40, 48 weeks (48). Other studies have shown similar
41). In a 2003 selective cohort study, researchers results with reductions in ejaculate volume, in-
from Norway investigated the effect of carbamaz- creased rates of abnormal sperm morphology, and
epine and valproate on semen quality in a treat- decreased sperm motility (51). However, despite
ment arm for each medication and a control group these HAART associated semen abnormalities,
receiving no medication. The study did show an centers following men undergoing HAART show
increased rate of abnormalities in the tails of high rates of ultimately achieving pregnancy (45).
sperm in men taking valproate. These changes Regardless of the possible adverse effects of
were not seen in men taking carbamazepine. Of HAART on sperm quality, the health benefits of
note, there was no difference in fertility in any of the treatment far outweigh any possible fertility
the men, as defined by pregnancy, compared with benefit that could be associated with medication
the controls (42). While significant data exists to discontinuation. However, these studies may be
suggest that various antiepileptic medications may helpful in counseling HIV positive men who wish
contribute to MFI, current data is inconsistent and to pursue parenthood. A summary of the current
precludes specific recommendations regarding in- evidence is offered in table 1.
dividual medications. Furthermore, the well- Miscellaneous medications: Data evaluating the
described association between epilepsy and infer- effects of most medications on semen is lacking.
tility presents a significant confounding variable However, the body of data available addressing
normal WHO criteria for healthy males. Even 3. Thonneau P, Marchand S, Tallec A, Ferial ML, Du-
though the WHO criteria likely serves as a fair cot B, Lansac J, et al. Incidence and main causes of
representation for normal male characteristics, the infertility in a resident population (1,850,000) of
absence of a control group increases the likely- three French regions (1988-1989). Hum Reprod.
1991;6(6):811-6.
hood of ignoring an important confounding vari-
able in a certain trial. As such, to eliminate any 4. Wong EW, Cheng CY. Impacts of environmental
chance of bias and provide more certainty to the toxicants on male reproductive dysfunction. Trends
results, researchers should seek to limit confound- Pharmacol Sci. 2011;32(5):290-9.
ing variables to the best of their capabilities. 5. Natali A, Turek PJ. An assessment of new sperm
Despite these design limitations, the literature tests for male infertility. Urology. 2011;77(5):1027-
does suggest that certain medications may, in fact, 34.
prove detrimental to male reproductive potential. 6. Baker HW. Male infertility. Endocrinol Metab Clin
Specifically, there is good data that SSRIs, CCBs, North Am. 1994;23(4):783-93.
certain AABs, and HAART medications certainly 7. World Health Organization. WHO Laboratory Man-
could contribute to MFI. However, many men still ual for Examination and Processing of Human
father healthy children even while taking medica- Semen. 5th ed. Geneva: World Health Organization.
tions. Therefore, as the detrimental effects of 2010. 287 p.
these medications were never universally ob- 8. Aitken RJ. Sperm function tests and fertility. Int J
served, counseling men taking these medications Androl. 2006;29(1):69-75.
should include discussing the risk that the medi-
9. Lee Hee Y. Expenence with 3,520 infertile male pa-
cations may, but also may not, pose to their repro-
tients and a clinical perspective. Seoul J Med. 1986;
ductive health. In many instances, the detrimental 27(1):1-18.
aspects of these drugs on semen parameters is
likely outweighed by the significant medical bene- 10. Thompson ST. Prevention of male infertility: an
update. Urol Clin North Am. 1994;21(3):365-76.
fit conferred to one taking the medications, es-
pecially in life-extending treatments such as 11. Pasqualotto FF, Lucon AM, Sobreiro BP, Pasqu-
HAART. alotto EB, Arap S. Effects of medical therapy, al-
The classes of pharmaceutical medications dis- cohol, smoking, and endocrine disruptors on male
infertility. Rev Hosp Clin Fac Med Sao Paulo.
cussed in this paper are limited, largely due to the
2004;59(6):375-82.
relative lack of research that has been done in this
field. The association between MFI and exposure 12. Pollack MH, Reiter S, Hammerness P. Genitourin-
to pharmaceutical compounds has only recently ary and sexual adverse effects of psychotropic
been explored and is a subject sure to generate medication. Int J Psychiatry Med. 1992;22(4):305-
27.
more research and discussion in the years to
come. Indeed, SA certainly does not evaluate 13. Soleimani L, Lapidus KA, Iosifescu DV. Diagnosis
many of the parameters of sperm that may impact and treatment of major depressive disorder. Neurol
MFI such as an intact acrosome reaction [8]. Fu- Clin. 2011;29(1):177-93.
ture exploration into this field must relate the 14. IMS: Institute of Healthcare Informatics [Internet].
affects that medications may or may not have, not USA: IMS Health Incorporated; 2011. The Use of
only on semen parameters, but also on the ability Medicines in the United States: Review of 2010;
to actually father a child. 2011 Apr [cited 2011 Jul 5]; [36 pages]. Available
from: http://www.imshealth.com/deployedfiles/ims
Acknowledgement health/Global/Content/IMS%20Institute/Static%20
File/IHII_UseOfMed_report.pdf
Pertinent disclosures and conflicts of interest are
as follows: None was present for the authors. 15. Murrough JW, Iacoviello B, Neumeister A, Char-
ney DS, Iosifescu DV. Cognitive dysfunction in
References depression: Neurocircuitry and new therapeutic
1. Rabin DS, Qadeer U, Steir VE. A cost and outcome strategies. Neurobiol Learn Mem. 2011;96(4):553-
model of fertility treatment in a managed care envir- 63.
onment. Fertil Steril. 1996;66(6):896-903. 16. Ali MK, Lam RW. Comparative efficacy of esci-
2. Singh K, Jaiswal D. Human male infertility: a com- talopram in the treatment of major depressive dis-
plex multifactorial phenotype. Reprod Sci. 2011;18 order. Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat. 2011;7:39-49.
(5):418-25.
43. Chu C, Selwyn PA. Complications of HIV infec- productive toxicity in male rats: effects of vitamin
tion: a systems-based approach. Am Fam Phys- C and N-acetylcysteine. Exp Toxicol Pathol. 2008;
ician. 2011;83(4):395-406. 60(1):77-85.
44. Leone S, Gregis G, Quinzan G, Velenti D, Cologni 56. Drumond AL, Weng CC, Wang G, Chiarini-Garcia
G, Soavi L, et al. Causes of death and risk factors H, Eras-Garcia L, Meistrich ML. Effects of mul-
among HIV-infected persons in the HAART era: tiple doses of cyclophosphamide on mouse testes:
analysis of a large urban cohort. Infection. 2011;39 Accessing the germ cells lost, and the functional
(1):13-20. damage of stem cells. Reprod Toxicol. 2011;32(4):
45. Nicopoullos JD, Almeida P, Vourliotis M, Gould- 395-406.
ing R, Gilling-Smith C. A decade of sperm wash- 57. Levine J. Fertility preservation in children and ado-
ing: clinical correlates of successful insemination lescents with cancer. Minerva Pediatr. 2011;63(1):
outcome. Hum Reprod. 2010;25(8):1869-76. 49-59.
46. Crittenden JA, Handelsman DJ, Stewart GJ. Semen 58. Marquis A, Kuehni CE, Strippoli MP, Kühne T,
analysis in human immunodeficiency virus infec- Brazzola P; Swiss Pediatric Oncology Group.
tion. Fertil Steril. 1992;57(6):1294-9. Sperm analysis of patients after successful treat-
47. van Leeuwen E, Wit FW, Prins JM, Reiss P, van ment of childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia
der Veen F, Repping S. Semen quality remains with chemotherapy. Pediatr Blood Cancer. 2010;55
stable during 96 weeks of untreated human im- (1):208-10.
munodeficiency virus-1 infection. Fertil Steril. 59. Attia SM, Badary OA, Hamada FM, Hrabé de An-
2008;90(3):636-41. gelis M, Adler ID. The chemotherapeutic agents
48. van Leeuwen E, Wit FW, Repping S, Eeftinck nocodazole and amsacrine cause meiotic delay and
Schattenkerk JK, Reiss P, van der Veen F, et al. non-disjunction in spermatocytes of mice. Mutat
Effects of antiretroviral therapy on semen quality. Res. 2008;651(1-2):105-13.
AIDS. 2008;22(5):637-42. 60. Rajender S, Monica MG, Walter L, Agarwal A.
49. Carr A, Samaras K, Burton S, Law M, Freund J, Thyroid, spermatogenesis, and male infertility.
Chisholm DJ, et al. A syndrome of peripheral lipo- Front Biosci (Elite Ed). 2011;3:843-55.
dystrophy, hyperlipidaemia and insulin resistance 61. Tan RS, Scally MC. Anabolic steroid-induced
in patients receiving HIV protease inhibitors. hypogonadism--towards a unified hypothesis of
AIDS. 1998;12(7):F51-8. anabolic steroid action. Med Hypotheses. 2009;72
50. Ahmad G, Moinard N, Jouanolou V, Daudin M, (6):723-8.
Gandia P, Bujan L. In vitro assessment of the ad- 62. Bonetti A, Tirelli F, Catapano A, Dazzi D, Dei Cas
verse effects of antiretroviral drugs on the human A, Solito F, et al. Side effects of anabolic andro-
male gamete. Toxicol In Vitro. 2011;25(2):485-91. genic steroids abuse. Int J Sports Med. 2008;29(8):
51. Kehl S, Weigel M, Müller D, Gentili M, Horne- 679-87.
mann A, Sütterlin M. HIV-infection and modern 63. Lombardo F, Sgrò P, Salacone P, Gilio B, Gandini
antiretroviral therapy impair sperm quality. Arch L, Dondero F, et al. Androgens and fertility. J
Gynecol Obstet. 2011;284(1):229-33. Endocrinol Invest. 2005;28(3 Suppl):51-5.
52. Haidl G, Allam JP, Schuppe HC. Chronic epididy- 64. Pomara G, Morelli G, Canale D, Turchi P, Cag-
mitis: impact on semen parameters and therapeutic lieresi C, Moschini C, et al. Alterations in sperm
options. Andrologia. 2008;40(2):92-6. motility after acute oral administration of sildenafil
or tadalafil in young, infertile men. Fertil Steril.
53. Cai T, Wagenlehner FM, Mazzoli S, Meacci F,
2007;88(4):860-5.
Mondaini N, Nesi G, et al. Semen Quality in Pa-
tients with Chlamydia Trachomatis Genital Infec- 65. Dimitriadis F, Tsambalas S, Tsounapi P, Kawam-
tion Treated Concurrently with Prulifoxacin and a ura H, Vlachopoulou E, Haliasos N, et al. Effects
Phytotherapeutic Agent. J Androl. 2011 Oct 6. of phosphodiesterase-5 inhibitors on Leydig cell
[Epub ahead of print]. secretory function in oligoasthenospermic infertile
men: a randomized trial. BJU Int. 2010;106(8):
54. Yániz JL, Marco-Aguado MA, Mateos JA, Santo-
1181-5.
laria P. Bacterial contamination of ram semen,
antibiotic sensitivities, and effects on sperm quality 66. Safarinejad MR. Effect of pentoxifylline on semen
during storage at 15°C. Anim Reprod Sci. 2010; parameters, reproductive hormones, and seminal
122(1-2):142-9. plasma antioxidant capacity in men with idiopathic
infertility: a randomized double-blind placebo-con-
55. Farombi EO, Ugwuezunmba MC, Ezenwadu TT,
trolled study. Int Urol Nephrol. 2011;43(2):315-28.
Oyeyemi MO, Ekor M. Tetracycline-induced re-