Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract - The application of bus transfer schemes in M-T-M bus transfer schemes. Thus, Main-Tie-Main bus
industrial and utility facilities, such as paper mills, transfer schemes can be:
petrochemical facilities, and utility power plants is Accomplished by reduced amount of devices/IEDs (i.e.
significant in both its number and criticality. This paper “lean” applications)
will review the basics of main-tie-main bus transfer Implemented using protective relay inputs and outputs
schemes, highlight the technical challenges associated Implemented using protective relay-to-relay control
with implementing such schemes, and examine how logic via IEC61850 GOOSE messaging
modern technology can provide solutions that enhance Simplified as a result of the protection and logic being
efficiency, engineering, and operations. programmed in modern microprocessor based
Among the issues to be discussed in this paper are: (a) protection & control IEDs, such as protection, transfer
enhancing panel design by reducing the number of logic, interlocking, timing and sequencing functions
devices necessary for implementation; (b) achieving The application of new technology is rooted in an
savings in wiring by utilizing IEC61850 peer-to-peer understanding of tried and true concepts. This paper will first
communication methods; (c) how modern technology discuss the common types of bus transfer schemes that have
enhances the ability to test and troubleshoot the scheme been deployed for many years in industrial and utility facilities.
and; (d) examination of the advantages and Secondly, this paper will discuss several efficient methods of
disadvantages of different types of bus transfer schemes. using protective relay IEDs to perform M-T-M bus transfer.
These first generation microprocessor-based relays were Similarly, the blown fuse of the measured voltage
superior in providing control and protection elements in inputs could cause the initiation of the bus transfer
comparison to their ancestral electromechanical relays. scheme and needs to be blocked.
However, they still lacked a custom built automatic bus While transferring the motor-bus to another healthy
transfer scheme, due to their limited hardware and software incoming source, there is need to select control
capabilities. Due to the various onsite practices, the mediums (based on the measured analog inputs) to
implementation of the residual voltage dependent bus transfer decide the completion of the transfer. For example,
scheme also varies from one site to another and requires a monitoring an overloading condition on the incoming
great flexibility in its implementation. Here are the few transformer and its required load shedding.
examples of onsite flexibility requirements. Need for more inputs and outputs from the relay to
On the return of the lost power supply, it is the practice implement electrical interlocks (such as picking up
of using various restoration methods such as: manual master trip relay 86 for a fault on the bus side) which
and automatic; close transition and open transition. also creates undervoltage condition on the incoming
Generally the line side Potential Transformer (PT) input feeder, and to avoid paralleling of the incoming
detecting undervoltage on the incomer supply is phase- sources.
phase or phase-ground. This arrangement cannot
detect a blown fuse condition on the unmonitored
phase-ground voltage of the primary side of the
incoming transformer.
IV. PEER-TO-PEER COMMUNICATIONS USING IEC61850 Interlocking (bus protection) with downstream relays
GOOSE MESSAGING can be accomplished with IEC61850 GOOSE
messaging
Technological advancements in relay hardware design and Scheme alarms when either protective relay is off-line
the development of high-speed peer-to-peer communication or not communicating.
protocols have resulted in a new generation of intelligent Reconfiguration of scheme without time and expense
electronics devices (IEDs). These protective and control of additional wiring.
relays have the capability to accept multiple levels of current .
and voltage inputs and to analyze these values at significantly
increased speeds. The main advantages of using these
numerical IEDs are simplification of the automatic bus transfer
system, component cost reduction, increased system
reliability, and the availability of events for transfer analysis.
An efficient way to apply these IEDs and obtain a custom-
built automatic bus transfer scheme is to use high-speed
peer-to-peer IEC61850 GOOSE messaging between two
protective relays. IEC61850 uses an Ethernet connection as
the medium of communication between the protective relays.
Logical I/O via Ethernet communications is used in place of
traditional hard wire to exchange the information between the
two protective relays. The information sent over the network
might include main and tie breaker status, voltage detector
status, current detector status and transfer scheme status.
Modern IEC61850 implementations are able to send
messages between relays at speeds of around 2-4 ms. Also,
IEC61850 has recently added the capability of exchanging Fig. 3. Data Exchanged Between Two Protective Relays with
analog data between relays so actual values of currents and IEC61850 Peer-to-Peer Communications
voltages are now also able to be sent over the high speed
network. Figure 3 illustrates some of the data that can be
exchanged between the two relays via the high-speed When applying main-tie-main automatic bus transfer using
network. two protective relays and IEC61850 GOOSE messaging,
When using IEC61850 GOOSE messaging, one can limit protective relay 1 will be the master and implement automatic
the wiring to the protective relay to the following: bus transfer logic and provide protection for Main 1 circuit
breaker. Protective relay 1 controls Main 1 circuit breaker and
3 phase & ground currents Tie circuit breaker. Protective relay 1 provides overcurrent
3 phase bus voltages protection for Main 1 circuit breaker. Protective Relay 2
1-3 phase line voltages provides overcurrent protection and transfer control for Main 2
52a contact circuit breaker. Figure 4 shows the typical configuration.
TOC contact (is breaker racked in?)
Trip output
Close output
B3a
S1 S1 TIE TIE S2 S2
+Power CLS TRIP CLS TRIP CLS TRIP
+ + + + + +
S1 S1 TIE TIE S2 S2
-Power
CLOSE TRIP CLOSE TRIP CLOSE TRIP
Fig. 5. Automatic Bus Transfer with Single IED Fig. 6 Discrete Inputs and Outputs for a Single Protective
Relay Transfer Scheme
The protective relay performs the logic necessary for the
transfer scheme internally via programmable logic. Figure 5
shows this type of configuration. The relay used in a single IED transfer scheme must have
Using a single IED for automatic bus transfer has the expanded capabilities to perform the transfer function. First,
following: the relay must have three phase voltage inputs for both mains
Position and status indications for each circuit breaker. and if residual voltage transfer is desired a voltage input for
Phase and neutral/ground overcurrent protection for each bus. Three phase voltage inputs are necessary to
Main 1 and Main 2 circuit breakers. transfer on negative sequence overvoltage as well as loss of
Undervoltage supervision for Main 1, Main 2, and Tie source. This allows the bus to be transferred before
circuit breakers. equipment is damaged or motors are tripped on negative
Synchronism check for closing Main 1 & Main 2 circuit sequence voltage. The relay must also have sufficient
breakers undervoltage elements and negative sequence voltage
Transfer auto/manual selection via front pushbuttons or elements to implement the scheme. Lastly, the relay must
external control switch have sufficient logic capabilities to perform the transfer for all
Transfer scheme lockout and block via internal three breakers.
programmable logic A single protective relay IED that performs all of the transfer
Trip selector via front pushbuttons or external control needs of the switchgear simplifies design of the transfer
switch. scheme because information is no longer needed to be
Oscillography & sequence of events capture entire passed from one relay to another. As an additional benefit,
scheme operation and timing. with one relay, the programmable logic settings to provide the
Ability to custom the transfer scheme to any transfer functions can more easily be tested in simulation
application. conditions before the switchgear is installed reducing
commissioning time. This highlights an additional benefit of
single relay transfer schemes; the relay logic can be
configured such that, with limited modifications, one logic
setting can provide transfer for any bus architecture or
transfer option. The same logic settings can use pushbutton open/close breakers, rack in/out breakers, change
or discrete inputs to provide several options of transfer operating selector switch positions, etc.
including: If using IEC61850 peer-to-peer GOOSE messaging,
• Main-Tie-Main or Main-Main architectures by make sure all devices are on-line and communicating
treating the Main-Main as a Main-Tie-Main where with each other and that relevant breaker and transfer
the tie is always closed. status are being recognized across the network.
• Open or closed transition modes upon return from If the synchrocheck is being used, make sure that the
transfer. incoming breakers do not close when the phases are
• A preferred main bus arrangement, that swapped or are out of predetermined phase angle
determines which main is closed in main-main boundary.
architectures or which combination of two breakers Ensuring that all output contacts operate per the logic
are closed in main-tie-main architectures. and schemes; e.g., the close output contact is asserted
• Auto return or manual return when a signal to close is received from the control
switch, or perhaps via a serial or Ethernet
Discrete inputs, necessary to accomplish the options listed communications link.
above are shown in Figure 6. Ensuring that an open transition scheme does close
the tie breaker or alternate healthy breaker if the main
breaker fails to open.
VI. TESTING
Making sure that a transfer does not get initiated when
Unlike conventional transfer schemes using traditional control power is lost to any one of the protective relays
electromechanical relays, testing microprocessor-based and that the bus is experiencing a short circuit fault.
automatic transfer schemes requires additional steps and There are both advantages and disadvantages when testing
better understanding of the different logic used within the microprocessor-based relays and associated transfer scheme
protective relay(s). Knowledge regarding the software and logic.
firmware revision is required before programming these Among the disadvantages are that the programmable logic
microprocessor-based relays. Microprocessor-based relays is more complex and may require additional testing time and
generally have numerous pages of settings to be entered into software tools. Additional training may be required of both
the protective relay to ensure the proper functionality. engineers and technicians to properly program and test these
Moreover, it is necessary to determine which settings protective relays. Also, the programming and configuration of
specifically affect the transfer scheme. We also need to bear the protective relays is a complex process that not only
in mind that some manufacturers have factory default settings requires knowledge of the application but knowledge of how to
values already installed on these protective relays and only by integrate the relay into any possible automation systems via
understanding these values one can accomplish the desired Ethernet or serial communications.
functions. Here are the basic requirements for the on-site A key advantage is that a programming standard can be
starting and testing of the transfer scheme: developed and implemented at numerous locations with
Understanding the method for programming the decreasing engineering development costs after the standard
protective relay by downloading the settings using a is developed. Microprocessor-based relays also offer
personal computer via front port or Ethernet port. numerous tools in terms of event recording, oscillography, and
Verifying the firmware revisions on the protective the ability to send information to different places via serial or
relays and ensuring they are the most recent or at Ethernet communications networks. Software tools allow the
least the same on all protective relays. real-time graphical representation of the programmable logic
Ensuring the date and time synchronization (time and aid in the transfer scheme testing and troubleshooting.
stamping) on the protective relays is correct (in order The process of document control can also be streamlined as
to facilitate troubleshooting). settings can be stored in files apart from the actual protective
Understanding the different means by which the relay and any changes can be done off-line before sending to
protective relays communicate with each other; e.g. the protective relay.
contact inputs/outputs, serial port communications,
analog inputs, virtual inputs/outputs, Ethernet
networking, etc. VII. CONCLUSIONS
Once the protective relay has been properly programmed,
one can proceed in applying voltages and currents to the The bus transfer scheme in industrial and utility facilities is
protective relay (s). Applying an undervoltage on one of the a critical application that requires careful thought in how it is
sources and watching the source breaker trip (open) and the implemented. While electromechanical relays have provided
alternate source or tie breaker close does not complete the a reliable solution for a number of years, it is imperative that
true testing. On microprocessor-based protective relays, it is modern organizations seek to utilize new technology to
very important to work through all the different scenarios optimize resources and improve efficiency. Proven installed
applicable to the design and to ensure all criteria are met. solutions exist today using single IED or multiple IED
Some additional checks while testing an automatic transfer configurations and IEC61850 based peer-to-peer messaging.
scheme are: Engineers, designers, and technicians in the field need to be
Verifying that all contact and analog inputs are adequately trained on the full capabilities of the new
registered by the protective relay(s). For example, technology so that the different parts of the organization can
fully utilize the technology. From there, the organization can
reap the benefits of streamlined design and system operations
that maximize reliability and overall efficiency.
VIII. BIOGRAPHIES
Craig Wester is the southeast US regional sales manager
for GE Digital Energy Multilin in Norcross, Georgia. He was
born in Belgium, Wisconsin, and received a B.S. in Electrical
Engineering with a strong emphasis on power systems from
the University of Wisconsin-Madison in 1989. Craig joined
General Electric in 1989 as a utility transmission & distribution
application engineer. He is a member of the IEEE.