Action on the commented MQP Rev 02 of Abir Infra

Cl No ABIR Comments TBEA Comments/ clarification

A. General comments
Contents to be revised in line with the revisions
1 Done in revised MQP Rev 02
done
We have modified the witness points
TBEA to submit the test procedures for all the as per our experience and request to
2
witness tests along with the QAP approve the same. Test procedure has
been enclosed.

For type/Model and details of the

accessorires the approved drawings
3 Include Type /Model/Size for all accessories
and documents needs to be refered
during inspection. Request to accept.

Format has been revised as per the

4 Format
request.

All reports which not for ECEPL/EICIPL witness Ok agreed. The same will be shown at
5
shall be submitted for ECEPL/EICIPL for review the time of final inspection/testing

B Comments with clause references

Material is imported. Electrical strength

in Oil not given for the imported
1.3.5 Add "Electrical strength in air & oil"
material by the supplier.Request to
accept.

Material is imported. Oil absorbtion test

1.3.9 Add "Oil absorption test" is not given by the supplier. Hence not
included.Request to accept.

1.3.10 Add "Moisture content" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

1.4 Add "and IS 3024" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

Test to be done at third party Lab

1.4 Add "One sample to be done at ERDA" NABL approved as ERDA has lot of
delays in testing. Request to accept.

1.4.3 Verification of records Included in revised MQP Rev 02

1.4.4 Add "Test" for Stacking factor Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.4.8 Include ductility test Included in revised MQP Rev 02

1.4.8 Add "Check for edge burr after deburring" The same already included in Cl 1.5.4

As the length of the sheets are large

1.5.5 Bow check removed the bow check has no real meaning
and hence deleted
1.6 Add "IS 1576 & 3513" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

Resistance to oil included in ageing

1.8 "Resistance in oil to be added"
test Cl 1.8.7

1.8 Add "IS 4253" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

1.9.2 Add "and creepage distance" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.10.2 Add "and creepage distance" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.11 Add "IS 2705" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.11.3 Add "Routine test" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

Power frequency on primary not

possible as this is bushing CT and as
such there is no primary (bushing
1.11.3 b Add "and Primary"
conductor forms the primary). The CT
is at earth potential and is tested
during final testing
 "Following tests to be added Continuity test &
1.12 Included in revised MQP Rev 02
Operation of contacts"
Add "Manual test: Operation of switches,
1.13 Included in revised MQP Rev 02
equipment and control"
1.14 Add Air cell "for conservator" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.14 Add "IS 3400" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.14.4 Add "Acceptance test" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
Add movement of rollers, positioning of sheet thru
1.15 Included in revised MQP Rev 02
90 degree
1.15 Add Class: "B" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.21 "Operation tests to be added" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.22 Add "colour of Silica gel" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.23 Add "Measurement of paint Already indicated in Cl 1.23.5
1.23 Class: "A" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.24 Add customer witness fior one job Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.24 Add "Neutralisation value" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.24.6 Add "Moisture content" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

Breakdown in oil included in revised

1.24.7 Electric strength in "air" & oil MQP Rev 02. Breakdown air has no
meaning for oil, hence not considered

1.25 Add "CBIP" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

1.26.1 Add "CBIP" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.26.8/9
Customer witness for one transformer Included in revised MQP Rev 02
/11
1.26.10 Add "CBIP" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.2.7 Delete RTCC as not applicable Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.29 Add "HV test and Insulation resistance" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.29.3 "List out the tests" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
1.32 "To be off Load Tap changer" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
Add" Visual check, free from damages and dust,
2.1 transpositions & crossovers, lead & coil Included in revised MQP Rev 02
identification & marking
2.1 Add " No of turns per disc" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

Add "Platform setting layout at first layer of

2.2 Included in revised MQP Rev 02
laminations"

2.2 Add "Thickness of steps" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

2.2 Add " Oil duct arrangement" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

2.2 Add " Check for Air gap" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
2.2 Add" Core diameter" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

2.2
Add " Winding dimension Included in revised MQP Rev 02
 2.2 Add " Distance of HV & LV Frames" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

2.2 Add " Overlapping of stampings" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

Reworded as Check of core tightness.

2.2.4 Removal of adhesive tape lashing
This is all encompassing

Reworded as "Diameter of the core

2.2.9 Removal of dimension
and distance between frames"

Why Check of CRGO sheet selection during core The same is included in Cl 1.5.2 and
2.2.1
building deleted Cl1.5.3 hence deleted
2.2.11 Add customer witness for one transformer Included in revised MQP Rev 02
2.2.12 Add customer witness for one transformer Included in revised MQP Rev 02
2.2.13 Add customer witness for one transformer Included in revised MQP Rev 02

3.1 Test procedures are to be given Test procedures are given separately

3.1 Add DGA Included in Cl 3.1.14 and Cl 3.2.1

3.1 Add PDA Included in Cl 3.1.12
3.1.5 Add " rated voltage" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
3.1.7 " Mention Voltage scale also" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

3.1.9 "Full wave Lightning impulse on all line terminals" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

3.1.14 Tests on OCTC" in place of OLTC Included in revised MQP Rev 02

3.1.15 Add "Temp rise test" Included in revised MQP Rev 02
3.1.17 Delete Magnetic balance test Included in revised MQP Rev 02

3.1.21 Add " as per CBIP" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

3.2 "Kindly specify the tests" Included in revised MQP Rev 02

Note: All other changes as requested by Abir Infra is incorporated in the revised MQP Rev 02
02 of Abir Infra

Remarks

Please refer to the comment. It is

mentioned as Resistance to Coil. Not
found in the referred clause 1.8.7
Resistance to oil is a part of the ageing
test in Oil
Not found in the MQP. Please mention the
clause no where it is being added or
where the same is covered.

Covered in Cl No 2.2.3

Not found in the MQP. Please mention the

clause no where it is being added or
where the same is covered.

Coverec in Claise No 2.2.4

Not found in the MQP. Please mention the

clause no where it is being added or
where the same is covered.

As such the oil duct arrangement is not

critical. More important is the Insulation
resistance between oil duct which is
included in Cl 2.2.5

Not found in the MQP. Please mention the

clause no where it is being added or
where the same is covered.

Included in Cl 2.1.8
 Not found in the MQP. Please mention the
clause no where it is being added or
where the same is covered.

Covered in Cl No 2.2.11

Not found in the MQP. Please mention the

clause no where it is being added or
where the same is covered.

As such the overlapping of the stampings

is not im portant This is replaced by Ci
2.2.6 "Check core joint and gaps"

Check for proviison of core & core frame

earthing- Commented on 2.3 is not added.
For all balance comments in 2.3 provide
compliance.
Core frame earthing included in Cl No
2.3.2

This test to be done afer FRA . The

comment is not incorporated.
Leakage test and FRA test are not
interlinked. Hence the sequence of test
has no bearing on each other

QP Rev 02