Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
5. The dam at the “Canal Isabel II” Canal and the boveda plana.
From the theoretical standpoint, there is a strong analogy
between the dam and the boveda plana, in terms of structural
performances and behaviour.
The boveda plana is a particular solution for covering a
quadrangular area, and in spite of its planar configuration, it is
more similar to a spatial vault in which the curvature tends to
zero. The static behaviour is then significantly based on the
three-dimensional interlocking of the blocks, that establishes a
three-dimensional lattice distributing the load on the supports.
In this system, the horizontal thrusts over the supporting
elements is very strong, and the stiffness and solidity of the
whole masonry is guaranteed only if every horizontal
displacement is prevented. If the masonry panels are rigid enough Fig. 12-15: Details of the boveda plana. Photo by
and well scarfed to form the masonry box, the floor is very stiff. the authors (May 2002).
Otherwise, the collapse of the structure is sudden and
unexpected, showing all the features of brittle ruptures: no
warning signs nor large deformations arise, and a snapping
collapse takes place. Once the sliding over the contact surfaces
of the blocks are activated and the hooping action of the walls
is no more able to contrast them, the structure cannot find an
equilibrated configuration. It is evident that in these cases very
high safety factors are required.
The principle governing the structural behaviour of the dam
wall is quite similar. The structure is composed by different
layers: the inner part is a conventional gravity wall, with a
sloping earth bank on the water side (Fig. 16-17-18). The outer
layer is made up by blocks cut in a dovetail shape guaranteeing
the inner connection both in the vertical and in the horizontal
direction. The conveyance of the water pressure to the
abutments is so achieved through the combination of two
mechanisms: the classical gravity reaction and the frictional
interlocking among the blocks establishing a spatial platband-
behaviour similar to that of the boveda plana.
Indeed, the structural problem to solve is the same: the loads
act in the direction perpendicular to the “plate” (out of plane
actions), and have to be absorbed - and then conveyed to the
restraints - by means of a plane structure made up by no-
tension materials and relying only, if conventional solutions are
adopted, on the development of the friction reactions.
Now, instead, the static behaviour is essentially based upon the
connection among the different ashlars in the space, that form
a three-dimensional lattice distributing the load in both the
directions.
In both cases, the stiffness and strength of the apparatus is
Fig. 16: Stone Masonry Arch Dam at guaranteed only if displacements on the boundary are
Zola, France (1847-1854) prevented, that in the dam is quite natural, since the abutments
Fig. 17: Stone Masonry Gravity Dam at are usually well robust and rigid.
Pontòn de la Oliva, Spain (1851 –
1858)
Fig. 18: Comparison of Sections and 6. The role of stone blocks’ shape in the structural performance
basin plans in the case of the stone The closeness of the two structures seems to be validated by
masonry dams at Zola and at the Pontòn the presence of the little space, intended for containing the
de la Oliva.
technical equipment, located nearby the dam wall and covered
with a boveda plana .
Maybe, it was a divertissement of the designers who wanted to
apply the theoretical solutions described in the treatise, and the
presence of a yard specialized in stone cutting made it possible
the implementation of extremely complex geometric
configurations. Certainly, they had to solve a tricky problem
for the dam construction, and used all the tools and knowledge
available at that time.
The little and fascinating boveda plana witnesses the high level
reached in the building techniques, and the care for details in Fig. 18: Structural mechanism of the
order to guarantee a well-done construction. boveda plana.
For the boveda plana, the mechanism of the work can be 8 A comparative analysis of the
schematised throughout the simple system shown in Figure 19, different flat-vault solutions, and on
in which each of the four beams has one perfect constraint on their respective structural behaviour
in the light of their updating was
one side and is elastically constrained on the other by the developed by the authors within the
following one, and is then loaded by the previous. Research Unit of the Politecnico di
Bari of the MIUR ex-40% funded
It is so possible to span a fixed length using shorter elements, research The typological and constructive
reform of the Mediterranean house 1999-
but uniformly distributing the weights on the restraints as well. 2001, (national and local
A sort of circular diffusion of the load is generated, where each coordinator: Prof. C. D’Amato
element is loaded and loads the other to the same extent. This Guerrieri, Dipartimento ICAR,
distribution, involves both vertical and horizontal actions, Politecnico di Bari). The 3D
determining the overturning thrusts on the supports8. elaboration of the original model
ideated by Abeille (1669?-1752?,
The solution adopted at the Pontòn de la Oliva does not solution edited in Machines et
present the pyramidal holes at the extrados of the Abeille’s inventions approuvées par l’Academie
solution indicated in Figure 19. Here the engineer restored the Royale des Sciences, Tom. 1 pp. 159,
continuity of the extrados, and improved the engagement 1735), and of its successive variants
could be regarded not only as a
among ashlars in both directions, offering a better resistance to geometrical game but mainly as an
the collapse. attempt to improve the static
In the Dam of Pontòn de la Oliva the use of the dovetail joint performances of the system.
improves the interlocking of the blocks, enhancing the
strength to the mutual sliding and to the rotation induced
by the overturning pressure. In the boveda plana the presence of
monolithic L – shaped blocks at each corner of the system
provides the necessary contrast to the horizontal actions.
REFERENCES: