Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
The purpose of this dissertation is to document and explore the design language of Tropical
Modern residential architecture through its history and many built manifestations. Tropical, here,
refers loosely to architecture built in the climatic zones of the tropics and sub-tropics around the
world including other areas of the Pacific region. Modern refers to architecture designed with
methodologies that stem from the Modernist architectural idiom but are not limited to work built
in that era. In specific, precedents were researched from Tropical Modern architects such as
Vladimir Ossipoff from Hawai‘i, Paul Rudolph in Florida, Richard Neutra in California, Oscar
Niemeyer from Brazil, and Glenn Murcutt in Australia. Their work is analyzed by comparing it to
factors for regional design put forth by Henry Seckel in his book Hawaiian Residential
Architecture (1954). This body of work and analysis is then used as the foundation for a
discussion and cataloging of the design language of Tropical Modern residential architecture. The
design language is broken into three parts and an overview, including vocabulary, syntax, and
meaning. The argument is that by considering the factors for regional design in Modern
architecture for the tropics – isolation, materials, economic conditions, climate, setting, cultural
background, and environmental living – sensitive, personal and responsive architecture can be
designed. This concept of the Tropical Modern design language is then tested with two design
projects in O’ahu. Each design has unique clients and sites, meaning unique regional factors,
which resulted in two different designs built from the same design language methodology. This
process is documented and broken down into the same three parts
– vocabulary, syntax, and meaning. The end result is an understanding and documentation of the
Tropical Modern residential design language, and a methodology for how to perpetuate a type of
ii
Table of Contents
ABSTRACT................................................................................................................................... ii
Table of Figures
......................................................................................................................................................
vii
Introduction....................................................................................................................................1
Physical and Theoretical Context...............................................................................................1
Research Methodology...............................................................................................................2
Literature Review...........................................................................................................................5
Modernism.................................................................................................................................6
Modernism in the Tropics............................................................................................................10
Design in the Tropics...............................................................................................................10
Tropical Modernism.................................................................................................................12
Tropical Modernism vs. European Modernism........................................................................14
Types of Modernism in the Tropics..........................................................................................15
Seckel’s Regional Factors for Tropical Architecture:...................................................................17
Isolation...................................................................................................................................18
Materials..................................................................................................................................18
Economic Conditions...............................................................................................................19
Climate.....................................................................................................................................20
Setting......................................................................................................................................22
Cultural Background................................................................................................................23
Environmental Living..............................................................................................................26
Precedent Studies.........................................................................................................................28
Hawai’i.....................................................................................................................................28
Vladimir Ossipoff (1907-1998)............................................................................................30
Florida......................................................................................................................................43
Paul Rudolph (1918-1997)...................................................................................................46
California.................................................................................................................................62
Richard Neutra (1892–1970)................................................................................................65
Brazil........................................................................................................................................79
Oscar Niemeyer (1907-2012)...............................................................................................82
Australia...................................................................................................................................96
Glenn Murcutt (1936-present)..............................................................................................99
Design Language........................................................................................................................120
Design as Language................................................................................................................120
Language of the Tropics.........................................................................................................122
iii
Origins................................................................................................................................122
Meaning..............................................................................................................................123
Vocabulary..........................................................................................................................124
Syntax.................................................................................................................................125
Poetry.................................................................................................................................127
Vocabulary of Tropical Modernism............................................................................................129
Precedent Architects...............................................................................................................129
List of Architects by Region...............................................................................................130
Roofs......................................................................................................................................131
Double pitched...................................................................................................................131
Flat.....................................................................................................................................133
Curved ridge.......................................................................................................................134
Saddle.................................................................................................................................136
A-frame..............................................................................................................................137
Overhangs..........................................................................................................................137
Adjustable..........................................................................................................................140
Trellis.................................................................................................................................141
Thatch.................................................................................................................................142
Metal..................................................................................................................................143
Concrete.............................................................................................................................144
Tile.....................................................................................................................................144
Structure.................................................................................................................................145
Steel....................................................................................................................................145
Wood..................................................................................................................................147
Concrete.............................................................................................................................149
Composite..........................................................................................................................150
Walls.......................................................................................................................................151
Ventilated............................................................................................................................151
Vertical louvers...................................................................................................................152
Shading...............................................................................................................................154
Pivot walls..........................................................................................................................156
Wood..................................................................................................................................158
Metal..................................................................................................................................158
Stone...................................................................................................................................159
Windows.................................................................................................................................162
iv
Glass jalousies....................................................................................................................162
Louvers...............................................................................................................................163
Pivot...................................................................................................................................164
Transom..............................................................................................................................165
Hinged................................................................................................................................166
Sliding................................................................................................................................166
Sill vents.............................................................................................................................167
Doors......................................................................................................................................168
Sliding................................................................................................................................168
Ventilated............................................................................................................................169
Pivot...................................................................................................................................170
Folding...............................................................................................................................171
Floors.....................................................................................................................................172
Ventilated............................................................................................................................172
Elevated..............................................................................................................................172
Outdoor Rooms......................................................................................................................175
Wall-less Room..................................................................................................................175
Engawa...............................................................................................................................179
Balcony..............................................................................................................................180
Nature.....................................................................................................................................181
Pool....................................................................................................................................181
Pond...................................................................................................................................183
Garden................................................................................................................................185
Planters...............................................................................................................................185
Furniture.................................................................................................................................187
Lounge................................................................................................................................188
Seating................................................................................................................................189
Tables.................................................................................................................................191
The construction of Hawaiian hale was also very ritual, there were precise steps and orders for
which they were built. These steps are akin to the steps of a dance, ritualistically passed on from
generation to generation. The meaning imbedded into their architecture was also the same. Heiau
platforms were orientated to angles of the sun, corresponding to the sunrise and sunset of the
summer and winter equinoxes, representing the changing of the seasons. The nature of the place
came through in the material of the architecture, the type of structure built, and the functions for
the site which were associated with natural resources and nature. Lo‘i, wetland agriculture, was
placed by the mountain streams, fishponds were constructed were these streams met the ocean,
and hale halau were built to shelter canoes by the ocean used by fishermen. The history of a site
was represented in heiau construction and the place-names associated with ahupua’a. The
relations of the gods were seen in the very layout of the kauhale, or Hawaiian homestead. The
separation of men and women and eating and sleeping relate to stories of the relationships of
Hawaiian gods and the kapu system.198
Each culture has its own form of poetry, and through understanding its priorities and structure,
one can understand more about the poetics of their architecture.
The next portion of this paper is a dictionary of sorts, illustrating the vocabulary of Tropical
Modernism. It will be used as an introduction to the elements used in Tropical Modern residential
architecture and consists of illustrations and detail drawings of elements and either descriptions of
these elements in diagrammatic form or through short paragraph. Many of the elements have
several meanings to them as they are usually architectural solutions derived from certain areas in
the tropics so therefor have cultural meaning, climatic meaning, and can be rendered in different
materials. The organization of this dictionary is through the elements of a house, from the top
down, and from the inside out.
128
Vocabulary of Tropical Modernism
Precedent Architects
This set of vocabulary is primarily derived from architects previously studied in this paper, either
thoroughly as they represent the masters of Tropical Modernism in their region, or briefly, as they
are contemporary practitioners of Tropical Modernism and the breadth of their work is still on
going. In detail was mentioned architects from Hawai‘i, Florida, California, and Brazil, but other
Tropical Modernists of note are from India and Vietnam, as well as other regions. The architect
from India is Bijoy Jain of Studio Mumbai. His work is clean lined and contemporary, but poses
an amazing connection with the environment through its use of material, local craftsmanship and
central courtyards. There is an incredible attention to detail and craft in his work which adds
another layer of mastery to the architecture. A21 Studio, of Vietnam, are also inventive Tropical
Modernists in their immersion of user into nature. Whether through open air buildings or houses
that are more like animal habitats than traditional architecture, they converge nature and
architecture into one. Vo Trong Nghia, also of Vietnam, has work that is more in line with other
contemporary Tropical Modernists with his use of material and planters in his architecture. In
both architects’ work, nature is a major building element, planned out not as gardens or
landscape, but as vertical elements creating space, interest, and shade.
A21 Studio, Tent II. 2014, Nha Trang, Vietnam. Vo Trong Nghia, Binh Thanh House. 2013, Binh
Thanh District, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.
The architect’s work that was used for this vocabulary is listed below by region. It includes
previous researched architects in the precedent studies, as well as others whose work either
represents of influenced Tropical Modernism. Along with elements of Tropical Modernism, there
are also elements of regional vernacular architecture that when reimagined by these architects
becomes modern in character. The intention is to describe the element as a design solution that
has many meanings connected with its origin. Whether climatic, cultural, or contextual in their
origin, they now represent a part of the Tropical Modern vocabulary.
Flat
Concrete Flat
Organic Flat
Overhangs
Engawa-like
Solarium
Concrete checkerboard
Tile
Portuguese Tile
Concrete
Board-Formed Irregular
Composite Concrete
and Wood
Cobogós
Breeze Block
Wood Lattice
Metal Grille
157
Wood
Bleached Redwood
Metal
Corrugated Metal
Stone
PaPōhaku
Glass Jalousies
Hand crafted
Bijoy Jian, Ustav House.
Satirje, Maharashtra, India.
Most jalousies are factory
made, here they were hand
made with larger panes of glass
and custom wood hardware
and frames.
Louvers
Wood Louvers
Doors
Sliding
Double set
Folding
Bi-fold Doors
Mashrabiyas
Lattice Floor
Outdoor Rooms
Wall-less Room
Roofed Space
Wall-less Room
Engawa
Engawa
Rooftop Pool
Garden
Rooftop Garden
Planters
Semi-Enclosed Planter
Enclosed Planter
318
Galindo, Michelle. 2013. Tropical Houses: Living in Paradise. Berlin: Braun Publishing.
Goad, Philip, and Anoma Pieris. 2005. New Directions in Tropical Asian Architecture. North
Clarendon: Tuttle Publishing.
Halliday, William R. 1998. "History and Status of the Moiliili Karst, Hawaii." Journal of Cave
and Karst Studies 141-145.
Handy, E.S. Craighill, Elizabeth Green Handy, and Mary Kawena Pukui. 1991. Native Planters in
Old Hawaii: their Life, Lore and Environment. Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press.
Heath, Kingston WM. 2009. Vernacular Architecture and Regional Design: Cultural Process and
Environemental Response. Oxford: Elsevier Ltd.
Hess, Alan. 2006. Oscar Niemeyer Houses. New York: Rizzoli International Publications, Inc.
Hines, Thomas S. 1982. Richard Neutra and the Search for Modern Architecture. New York:
Oxford University Press.
Historic Hawaii Foundation. 2012. Hawaii Modern. Honolulu: Historic Hawaii Foundation.
Hochstim, Jan. 2004. Florida Modern. New York: Rizzoli International Publications, Inc.
Hyde, Richard. 2008. Bioclimatic Housing: Innovative Designs for Warm Climates. London:
Earthscan.
Island Expat. 2010. Hausten Pond at the Willows. September 12. Accessed February 23, 2015.
http://hawaiiantimemachine.blogspot.com/2010/09/hausten-pond-at-willows.html?
q=manoa.
Jackson, Neil. 2007. Pierre Koenig: Living with Steel. Koln: Taschen.
Jahn, Graham. 1994. Contemporary Australian Architecture. New South Wales: Craftsman House.
James, Van. 2010. Ancient Sites of O'ahu. Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press.
Jodidio, Philip. 2012. Oscar Niemeyer: The Once and Future Dawn. Koln: Taschen.
Kamakau, Samuel Manaiakalani. 1976. The works of the People of Old: Na Hana a ka Po'e
Kahiko. Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press.
Kirch, Patrick Vinton. 1985. Feathered Gods and Fishhooks: An Introduction to Hawaiian
Archaeology and Prehistory. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
Koenig, Gloria. 2005. Charles & Ray Eames: Pioneers of Mid-Centruy Modernism. Koln:
Taschen.
Lamprecht, Barbara. 2006. Richard Neutra: Survial Through Design. Koln: Taschen.
Mattoch McManus, Malia. 2007. The Hawaiian House Now. New York: Harry N. Abrams, Inc.
McCoy, Esther. 1977. Case Study Houses 1945-1962. Los Angles: Hennessey & Ingalls, Inc.
McKay, Ian and Others. 1971. Living & Partly Living. Melbourne: Nelson.
McLaughlin, George Wheeler A.I.A. 1968. South Seas Living. Honolulu: A & E Corp.
Morse, Edward S. 1961. Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings. New York: Dover
Publications, Inc.
Niemeyer, Oscar. 1985. Oscar Niemeyer. Sao Paulo: Editora Almed Ltda.
Pegrum, Roger. 1984. Details in Australian Architecture. Red Hill: RAIA Education Division.
Penick, Monica Michelle. 2007. The Pace Setter Houses: Livable Modernism in Postwar
America.
Austin: ProQuest.
Powers, Richard, and Phyllus Richardson. 2012. Living Modern Tropical: A Sourcebook of
Stylish
Interiors. New York: Thames & Hudson, Inc.
Pukui, Mary Kawena, and Samuel H. Elbert. 1964. Hawaiian Dictionary. Honolulu: University of
Hawaii Press.
Rhodes, Diane Lee, and Linda Wedel Greene. 1993. A Cultural History of Three Traditional
Hawaiian Sites on the West Coast of Hawai'i Island. Denver: U.S. Department of the
Interior.
319
Saini, Balwant Singh. 1970. Architecture in Tropical Australia. London: Lund Humphries
Publishers Limited.
Sakamoto, Dean. 2007. Hawaiian Modern: The Architecture of Vladimir Ossipoff. New Haven:
Honolulu Academy of Arts, Yale University Press.
Seckel, Harry W. 1954. Hawaiian Residential Architecture. Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press.
Spade, Rupert. 1971. Richard Neutra. Tokyo: Bijutsu Shuppan-sha.
Steele, James. 1994. Eames House: Charles and Ray Eames. London: Phaidon Press Limited.
Steele, James, and David Jenkins. 1998. Pierre Koenig. London: Phaidon Press Limited.
Street-Porter, Tim. 2008. L.A. Modern. New York: Rizzoli International Publications, Inc.
Taylor, Brian Brace. 1995. Geoffrey Bawa. New York: Thames & Hudson, Inc.
Tettoni, Luca Invernizzi. 2009. Ultimate Tropical. New York: Rizzoli International Publications,
Inc.
Tzonis, Alexander, Liane Lefaivre, and Bruno Stagno. 2001. Tropical Architecture: Critical
Regionalism in the Age of Globalization. London: Wiley Academy.
Yamagata, Saburo. 1979. The Japanses Home Stylebook: Architectural Details & Motifs.
Berkely:
Stone Bridge Press.
320