Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A Thesis
Presented to
the Faculty of the School of Education
University of Southern California
In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree
Master of Science in Education
by
Robert Kenneth Burley
June 1947
UMI Number; EP55381
In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript
and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed,
a note will indicate the deletion.
Dissffllalien Rublish»ng
UMI EP55381
Published by ProQuest LLC (2014). Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author.
Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC.
All rights reserved. This work is protected against
unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code
ProQuest LLC.
789 East Eisenhower Parkway
P.O. Box 1346
Ann Arbor, Ml 48106- 1346
est 47 fin
f
T h is thesis, w r it t e n u n d e r th e d ir e c t io n o f the
C h a ir m a n o f the candidate's G u id a n c e C o m m itte e
a n d a p p r o v e d by a l l m em b ers o f the C o m m itte e ,
has been p resen ted to a n d accep ted by the F a c u lt y
o f the S c h o o l o f E d u c a t io n o f T h e U n iv e r s it y o f
S o u th e rn C a li f o r n i a in p a r t i a l f u l f i l l m e n t o f the
re q u ire m e n ts f o r the degree o f M a s t e r o f Science
in E d u c a tio n .
^ 'Ch
aiiman
hair
TAEÜUE C)]? CCWTTEBrrS
CHAPTER PAGE
I. THE PROBimi.............. 1
Statement of the problem . • ............. 1
Purpose of the s t u d y ....................... 1
lifhat are the problems of the students re
presenting the entire student body?. . . . Z
Vihat problems are common to boys of
all four grades? ................. Z
What problems are common to girls of
all four grades?................... .. 3
What problems do freshmen face?........... 4
What problems do sophomores face?. • • . 5
What problems dojuniors face? . .5
What problems doseniors face? . . . . . .. 6
II. PROCEDURE.......... 7
The preliminary survey ..................... 7
The main survey............................. 8
III. RESULTS. ................................. 11
Guidance problems among all classes...... . 1 1
Academic problems among all classes. .. . . .13
Non-academic school problems of all classes. . 15
Boy and girl problems of all classes.......17
Family problems ofstudents from all classes . 18
Social problems ofstudents from all classes . £1
li
CHAPTER
CHAPTER PAGE
Distribution of family problems among
jupiors.....................................79
Distribution of social problems among
juniors.......... * ...........81
Distribution of guidance problems among
seniors....................................81
Distribution of academic problems among
seniors.................................... 85
Distribution of non-academic school
problemsamong seniors...................... 87
Distribution of boy and girl problems
among seniors............................. 89
Distribution of family problems among
seniors.................................... 89
Distribution of social problems among
seniors....................................93
IV. CONCLUSION .... ........... 95
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE PAGE
I. Distribution of Guidance Problems among
all Glasses.............................. 12
II. Distribution of Academic Problems- among
all Classes ........................... 14
III. Non-academic School Problems of all Classes . . 16
IV. Boy and Girl Problems of all Classes........ 19
V. Family Problems of Students from all Classes. . 20
VI. Social Problems of all Students......... . . 23
VII. Guidance Problems among Boys of all Four
Classes ...................................24
VIII. Academic Problems among Boys of all Four
Classes.................................. 26
IX. Non-academic School Problems among Boys
of all Four Grades....................... 29
X. Girl Problens among Boys of all Four Grades . . 31
XI. Family Problems among Boys from all Four
Grades. . ............................. . 32
XII. Social Problems among Boys from all Four
Grades................ ‘ 34
XIII. Guidance Problems among Girls of all Four
Grades.................................... 36
XXV. Academic Problems among Girls of all Four
Grades............................... 38
Vi
TABLE PAGE
XV. Non-Academic School Problems among Girls of
all Pouf Grades . . . ................. 40
XVI. Boy Problems among Girls of all Four Grades 42
XVII. Family Problems among Girls from all Grades 44
XVIII. Social Problems among Girls from all Grades 46
XIX. Guidance Problems among Freshmen. ........ 48
XX. Academic Problems among Freshmen ........ 50
XXI. Non-academic School Problems among Freshmen 52
XXII. Boy and Girl Problems among Freshmen. . . . 54
XXIII. Family.Problems among Freshmen. . . . . . . 56
XXIV. Social Problems among Freshmen............ 58
XXV. Guidance Problems among Sophomores........ 60
XXVI. Academic Problems among Sophomores. . . .,. 62
XXVII. Non-academic School Problems among Sophomores 64
XXVIII. Boy and Girl Problems among Sophomores. . . 66
^XXIX. Family Problems among Sophomores.......... 68
XXX. Social Problems among Sophomores.......... 70
XXXI. Guidance Problems among Juniors .......... 72
XXXII. Academic Problems among Juniors . . . . . . 74
XXXIII. Non-academic School Problems among Juniors. 76
XXXÏV. Boy and Girl Problems among Juniors ...... 78
XXXV. Family Problems among Juniors......... . 80
XXXVI. Social Problems among Juniors ............ 82
v il
TABLE PAGE
XXXVII. Guidance Problems among Seniors.......... . 84
XXXVIII. Academic Problems among Seniors.......... , 86
XXXIX. Non-academic School Problems among Seniors . 88
xxxx. Boy and Girl Problems among Seniors. . . .
XXXXI. Family Problems among Seniors. . . . . . . . 92
XXXXII. Social Problems among Seniors............ . 94
CHAPTER I
THE PROBLm
PROCEDURE
RESULTS
TABLE I
Problems Frequency io
Total 254 99 »
TABLE II
Problems Frequency %
TABLE III
Problems Frequency
Total 263 99
17
to the academic program. Students feel a great need for more
entertainment of a professional nature. Their greatest interest
is in musical talent from outside school. This reaction in
dicates a tendency for students to want entertainment on a
higher level than the local talent is able to produce. They
want to be taken away from the names and faces they see in the
classroom and on the campus every day. They want to listen
to entertainers who are good, and who can take them away from
the problems of the classroom. The complaint about over-crowd
ed conditions at school and the use of antiquated buildings
and equipment shows that the students are acutely aware of the
need for great improvement in the physical equipment provide.
The need for greater social activity in the form of
school dances was brought out by the many requests for more
dances. Some students want more formal occassions, while others
prefer the less formal sport dances. Dancing, whether formal
or not, seems to be very popular. In order to satisfy students
there must be more of them.
TABLE IV
Problems Frequency io
Total 65 99
20
TABLE V
Problems Frequency io
Total 3^ 101
21
that several students feel that they don’t have a fair chance
to study at home because there is too much and disturbance
from other members of the family. It is very easy to under
stand that attitude when you realize that many of them live
in trailer houses, where it is impossible to getaway from
noise and confusion. Others live in small home, with two or
three families in the same house. Little thought is given
to anyone in the crowd who might want a little peace and quiet
so that he might do some studying. Much unhappiness and
mental anguish born by high school students arises from the
fact that parents don’t get along with each other. When par
ents fight at home the unhappy mood Instilled in the unfortu
nate boy or,girl goes right along to school and definitely
affects his every activity throughout the day. These people
need much more understanding than they usually get from teachers.
One student says,"my folks fight a lot and when they fight, I
can’t work very well at school. How are my teachers to know
about this trouble?” Sometimes the fight is between the student
and one or both of his parents. This clash is a serious set
back for many students, because it sets up a resentment to
adult guidance that is hard to overcome. As a result of this
resistance, often it is impossible for anyone to help that un
fortunate individual..
TABLE VI
SOCIAL FROBLEMS OF ALL STUDENTS
Problems Frequency %
Total 106 99
24
TABLE VII
GUIDANCE PROBLEMS AMONG BOYS OF
ALL FOUR GRADES
Problems Frequency %
Total 116 99
25
a counselor. They have problems that need solution, questions
that need answering, and often suggestions that are good. The
number of such responses is not abnormal. Several boys felt
that new students need a lot more individual help than they
get at the present time. This is an important problem, especial
ly for^ the people who come into the school after the first
quarter is started. They get lost in the confusion of enroll
ing, finding the right buildings and rooms for classes. All
the details of office forms and school rules and regulations
are very confusing to the new students.
A surprising response, for boys, shoves several who
want to know what to do to make better grades. They feel that
they are capable of doing better work, but don’t know how to
go about doing it. Many boys need help, in choosing a vocation.
They want to talk to someone who can give them some suggestions
and good advice about the vocation that will best fit the
qualities they have.
Problems Frequency io
TABLE IX
Problems Frequency %
TABLE X
Problems Frequency Io
Total 6 99
32
TABLE XI
Problems Frequency %
Total 13 99
55
must he know how to drive, but he must develop some right
attitudes about safety and consideration for others while
driving. It is an important and critical stage of develop
ment, and needs some careful guidance.
At this time some boys feel that parents fail to un
derstand them when little differences come up. They want to
go out at night instead of doing the homework that needs do
ing for the next day at school. The importance of doing the
school work and earning good grades fades into the background
when there is a car to tinker with or some place to go in that
car, where he can have fun with other boys and girls. Guidance
in proper decisions about this is very important and must be
done by teachers or counselors if it is not done by the parents
at home.
TABLE XII
Problems Frequency %
Total 41 100
35
only a few do everything, and thereby to keep only those few
before the public eye at all times. This feeling of neglect
ultimately brings on a reaction that makes trouble for students
and school officials. It would be easy enough to provide an
outlet for the middle and lower group to exercise this interest
in the extra-curricular activities, through an organized pro
gram. No doubt the students who write stories for the school
paper need to be good in English, but there must be many jobs
in connection with editing a paper that the average students
could do just as well as the so-called "brain".
Guidance problems among girls from all four classes.
.Among the girls of all four grades in high school there are
many who want to see a counselor about a personal problem.
Table XIII shows a large percentage of the total want to have
a talk with a counselor in private. One girl said she would
like to talk to a counselor about something that was too embar
rassing to discuss with her folks. That response sounds rather
odd until you think about some case histories of family relations.
In some situations there is no feeling of confidence between
1
student and parent. Under those circumstances it becomes a
problem for the student to find someone to confide in. The
counselor at school could very well be that person to whom boys
and girls could go for help with a personal problem.
The high school girls need help in making a vocational
choice. Several asked about where to get help in choosing a
36
TABLE XIII
Problems Frequency
Total 136 99
37
vocation, and after having made a choice they want to know
how to .go about getting the right training to prepare for their
lifes work. Students in general are quite concerned about
how they will earn their living after finishing high school
or college. Most of them have a very realistic attitude to
ward this problem and feel that they must do something about
it.
New students feel that they should get more personal
help than they do. Students who come from the smaller schools
have a difficult time adjusting themselves to the complex
procedure in getting started in a school where there is a
large student body, and large campus. A better plan for help
ing these students through these first few days of school is
definitely needed.
TABLE XIV
TABLE XV
Problems Frequency %
TABLE XVI
Problems Frequency io
Total 34 100
43
TABLE XVII
Total 21 99
45
it. Several girls struggle under pressure from parents who
want them to go to colleges. The girl wants to take commercial
subjects and do secretarial work, but parents insist that she
take all the subjects necessary for college entrance. This
insistence on the part of parents usually continues until the
girl has failed several subjects, then a change is made when it
is too late. The student has lost credit that must be made up,
/
and has not had a chanpe to take the type of work that vfill
prepare her best for the vocation that she wants to follow.
Counselors should play an important part in solving this pro
blem for students as soon as possible.
TABLE XVIII
Problems Frequency %
Total 63 100
47
out the school paper, but the school paper is edited through
the journalism classes, and before a student can enroll for
journalism he must have a very good grade in English. A large
number of students don’t get good grades in English, so they
are automatically eliminated from having anything to do with
the school paper. Several special programs are put on before
the entire student body during the year, but most of them are
cast from members of some special group. For example, the
annual Pan-American program is a colorful affair that many
girls would like to take part in, but it is put on by members
of the Spanish and French classes. A large number of girls
do not take either Spanish or French, so they are automatically
eliminated from taking part in any such activities.
TABLE XIX
GUIDANCE PROBLEMS AMONG FRESHMEN
Problems Frequency
Total 48 99
49
TABLE XX
ACADEMIC PROBLEMS AMONG FRESHMEN
Problems Frequency %
Total 72 100
51
This idea is based on the premise that those who understand
the quick discussion are the only ones who should try to go
on to higher education, while the slow ones will always be
too slow to gain by going after a higher education. The idea
that only those who are quick to comprehend should be given the
opportunity to go to the universities is archaic, and those
who hold it need to have that fact pointed out to them.
TABLE XXI
Problems Frequency %
Total 54 100
53
recognition by other students, and one of the best means of
securing recognition is by becoming a member of an athletic
team. Freshmen need to have this feeling of belonging to some
group. Self-confidence is so important at this time in the
life of boys and girls, and there is nothing that will bolster
a students assurance more than participation in athletics.
TABLE XXII
Problems Frequency %
Total 13 100
55
A cheerful greeting to a lonesome little freshman might
brighten the day for him or her a great deal. Teachers could
arrange informal groups, as a part of classroom procedure,
in which boys and girls could get acquainted and be more con
genial. There would be a carryover from the classroom to
other activities through the day, so that boys and girls
would recognize and greet each other wherever they might meet.
.TABLE XXIII
FAMILY PROBLEMS AMONG FRESHMEN
Problems Frequency %
Total 18 100
57
A thorough job of counseling at school will help students
with this problem.
TABLE XXIV
Problems Frequency %
Total 10 100
59
Distribution of guidance problems among sophomores.
Several sophomores want to see a counselor for help v/ith a
personal problem. Table XXV shows this request exceeding,
by far, any of the other responses under the guidance cat-
egory. These students in their secohd year of high school
are beginning to think more seriously about a vocation, so
they want to talk to a counselor about planning for the future.
This interest in planning is important and worth giving each
student time for a conference. Often the discussion of prob
lems related to finishing school, and preparing for a vocation
serves as a means of settling other problems. The boy who
wanted to be a doctor when he entered high school can see,
after having finished the first year, that it is necessary to
work very hard to master subject matter well, in order to
achieve that goal. During this conference it is easy to point
out the close connection between vocational success and serious
attention to school work. An indication of this desire for
success -in school work is shovm by the several responses ask
ing, "what can I do to make better grades". Although many
students, especially boys, are reluctant to let others know
that they want to get good grades, they usually show a true
interest in just that, when in private conference with a
counselor. The private conference has an advantage over class
room discussion in that students will speak more freely about
personal matters.
60
TABLE XXV
Problems Frequency %
Total 56 100
61
TABLE XXVI
Problems Frequency %
Total 66 100
63
Starting with the second year in high school, social activi
ties assume a position of great importance to students. Table
XXVII shovfs that the sophomores want to have more dances spon
sored by their own class. These school dances afford one of
the best mediums for teaching many of the social graces that
students need to learn in high school. Some students want to
have formal as well as informal dances, so they can dress up
for an oceassion. That is an important part of the training
processs that must start in high school, or before, and con
tinue through the formative years. It is important that
students learn how to dress properly for social affairs, as
well as to learn hovf to act while attending such an event*
For many students the only way he or she can learn these things
- is to observe others and follow a good example. In order to
do that it is necessary to attend school dances sponsored by
reliable people.
Among the sophomores there are many who are deeply
interested in athletics. Several of them feel that there
should be more opportunity for all students to take part in
athletics. The boys feel that they don’t have a very good
chance to get on an athletic team. Problably the best answer
to this problem is an intramural program of athletics that
vfould reach everyone who has any desire whatever to compete.
TABLE XXVII
Problems. Frequency io
Total 74 100
65
Distribution of boy and girl problems among sophomores.
Most students are reluctant to talk about things that envolve
members of the opposite sex. Most boys would rather do any
thing than talk to a counselor about his girl, therefore, the
system of having each student write down on pieces of paper,
his comment about this problem, gave each one a chance to
express himself without embarrassment. Under this plan re
sults were quite good. The fact that some students want to
know how to get acquainted with a member of the opposite sex.
Table XXVIII shows that they are not as sophisticated as they
would appear to be at first glance. When these boys and girls
are observed in a group, you would think that they are as
bold and forward as anyone could be, but when it becomes a
matter of a boy asking a girl for a date or asking for a dance,
the situation is entirely different. These same forward people
often become tongue-tied with embarrassment. They are not at
all sure of themselves, and sometimes are so reluctant that
it becomes a real problem for them to get acquainted with
members of the opposite sex. A few students are concerned
about this shyness around other boys and girls, and want to
do something to help themselves. Sophomore girls want to know
if it is proper to let a boy kiss them goodnight, the first
night they ahve a date. Apparently there isn’t very much
guidance about these matters in some homes, so it falls upon
the school counselor to give advice about them.
66
TABLE XXVIII
Problems Frequency %
Total 15 99
67
Distribution of family problems among sophomores.
Sophomores have the same trouble at home as the freshmen do.
Table XXIX shows that the most difficult problem these students
have at home, is to get enough peace and quiet from little
brotheres and sisters so that the homework can be done. This
difficulty is really a great handicap for several students,
and parents would be doing them a wonderful service if they
would provide some way for their sons and daughters to have a
quiet"and well lighted room for study. Many parents refuse
to allow their children to go out at night with a boy or girl
friend. This kind of treatment is resented by some and accept
ed by others. In general, sophomores feel that it’s all right
to be restricted, from going out on week nights, except on very
special occassions, but object streniously to the same treat
ment on Friday and Saturday night.
Other problems that originate with the family, cause
a few students a lot of trouble. Family bickering usually
results in some type of maladjustment of a boy or girl at
school. The arguement at home usually leaves a student in
such a mental uproar that he or she has a very difficult time
regaining control of good judgement before going to school.
Sometimes a disastrous explosion is the result of this con
dition.
The family is sometimes responsible for driving students
into a program that doesn’t fit the unfortunate victim at all.
68
TABLE XXIX
Problems Frequency
Total 14 99
69
TABLE XXX
SOCIAL PROBLEMS AMONG SOPHOMORES
Problems Frequency 1o
Total 20 100
71
isn’t enough opportunity for them to write for the paper, con
sequently, the same few people get all the publicity every
issue. This is a logical criticism, since a school paper is
published for the purpose of informing the entire student body
about 'What goes on at school, it should carry information and
news about as many;people, and subjects as possible.
TABLE XXXI
Problems Frequency
Total 72 99
73
It is indicated in Table JJXl that the upper-class-
men are more concerned about the new students when they enter
school, than the lower grades are. There is enough of this
criticism to indicate that there really needs to be something
done about this problem of new students, and their adjustment
to this school. I believe that it would be very worthwhile
to work out some kind of system whereby new students would
have a student escort help them to find buildings and rooms,
and to help them with anything else that is a part of the
adjustment.period in school.
TABLE XXXII
Problems Frequency %
Total 48 100
75
to the curriculum. This is typical of each student, to want
something that is especially interesting to himself. How
ever, some of the suggestions are good and v/ould apply to
a large number of students. Several want automobile driving
instruction, and certainly there could be nothing more
practical than teaching boys and girls how to drive properly.
Even more important than how to drive is the building of
proper attitudes toward safety in driving. High schools could
do a great service to mankind by spending some time in the
school program in teaching traffic safety.
TABLE XXXIII
Problems Frequency %
Total 67 100
77
the juniors than either the freshmen or the sophomores.
The third year in high school without any participation in
athletics, means that a boy or girl is very apt to miss that
experience entirely. The best answer to this problem is the
inaugeration of an extensive intramural program in athletics.
In such a program all students would have a chance to take
part in some athletic contest.
TABLE XXXIV
Problems Frequency fo
Total 8 97
79
does not take part would be more conspicuous than those who
do. In this way a shy person can’t stay out of the fun, and
soon loses herself in the enjoyment of being a part of the
group.
TABLE XXXV
Problems Frequency %
Total 4 100
81
that some of the Juniors failed to tell about some of the
family problems that do exist.
TABLE XXXVI
Problems Frequency
Total 30 100
83
from responsibility varies a great deal with the individual
student, but in general, the high school graduate has had a
pretty easy time while going to school. By this time, most
students have decided what vocation to follow, and start work
ing toward that end. That means that some will be going on
to higher education, while others will start apprenticeship
jobs. With graduation from high school comes the acceptance
of a new responsibility. Those students who go on to a higher
education, usually have to carry at least a part of the burden
of expenses, and many have to carry the entire load themselves.
Either way, it means holding a job, and saving some money.
For most high school seniors, that is a new responsibility.
Those students who go to a school for special training, and
those who go into an apprenticeship training program, have
many questions to ask a counselor. As shovm in Table XXX7II,
the greatest number of responses by seniors, is for an appoint
ment to see a counselor about a personal problem. Those
students who will go to work immediately after leaving high
school, have many important decisions to make, so they re
quest appointments with a counselor. The seniors are more
concerned, than any other class, about new students. They
feel that new students in our school should be given more
individual help than they are now getting. This is a just
criticism, and should result in some action to correct the
situation.
84
TABLE XXXVII
Problems Frequency %
Total 76 100
85
Distribution of academic problems among seniors,
it is significant that among seniors, there are very few students
who are concerned about teachers assigning too much home v^ork,
while among the freshmen, there was great concern about the
matter. Table XKXVIII indicates that the greatest interest
shown by seniors in the academic problems, is that the students
be given a chance to have more voice in the making of rules
and regulations that govern their actions. If things have to
be done in a certain way, they want to know the reason for
doing them that way. The student point of view is an excellent
one to consider when making plans to control their actions,
because they have to follow the rules, and therefore will know
if there is anything unreasonable about them. Administrators
can well afford to listen to the opinions expressed by members
of the student body. The next most numerous response was the
expression by students of a need for the addition of many new
courses to the curriculum. They have emphasized, through these
responses, serious weaknesses in our curriculum offerings, just
as expertly, or perhaps even more expertly, than a curriculum
specialist. This shows again, the value of taking a problem to
the students for a reaction, when you want an opinion that is
functional. Even as late as the senior year students still
complain that teachers don’t explain subject matter so that
students can understand it. The fact that this response is so
frequent, and universal among all classes indicates that it is
86
TABLE XXXVIII
Problems Frequency fo
Total 56 100
87
serious and needs correction.
TABLE XXXIX
Problems Frequency fo
TABLE XXZX
Problems Frequency fo
Total 6 96
91
extent of the response by seniors to family problems shows
that this classification is one where there is very little
trouble. Table XXXXI shows that only two seniors expressed
any feeling at all concerning family problems, as compared
with eighteen such responses among the freshmen. Both re
sponses of the seniors were concerned with the inability of
students to get along v/ith parents, and trouble between the
father and mother. These problems are the ones that are the
most difficult to remedy. There isn’t very much that can be
done to correct the situation at home, where parents are con
stantly fighting, but there is something that can be done at
school for the student who comes from such a home. A counselor
can be sympathetic enough toward those students to make the
way a little easier for them. He can do this by giving the
boy or girl an opportunity to come in and talk about the
trouble at home, and offer advice and friendship. A counselor
can help this student by letting all of the teachers know
what to expect from such a student, when he is carrying this
burden. On the days when there has been a battle at home,
the carry over with the student at school is very apt to
cause him some trouble, unless teachers are sympathetic to
ward his attitude. Although few seniors responded to this
main topic of family problems, the ones who did react, brought
out some very important facts. It is hard to realize just
how much strife there is in the home environment of many
students until you hear from the students themselfs, the
sordid details.
92
TABLE XXXXI
Problems Frequency %
Total 100
93
Distribution of social problems among seniors. The
seniors are the social lions of the entire high school. They
responded in great numbers to this general topic, and Table
XDOCII show that among the social problems, the most important
one, as far as number of reactions is concerned, is the one
requesting more parties and class activities for after school
hours. The senior year is one in which a climax is reached in
the social calendar. The senior play, senior banquet, and
graduation exercises, make the last year in high school a period
during which impressions that last a lifetime, are formed. It
is only natural that during this year students are more socially
minded, and therefore want to have just as much social activity
as possible. During this senior year many students want to have
a part in editing the school paper.
94
TABLE XXXXII
Problems Frequency %
Total 47 99
CHAPTER IV
CONCLUSION