Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: Natural disaster such as earthquake can cause destruction to structural buildings and human casualties. To mitigate
this natural disaster, one aspect of construction design that needs to be considered is material selection. Most of existing
concrete structures are designed to have strengths of about 30 MPa. Concretes of this strength range are normally associated
with poor durability. Lowering the water/binder ratio and incorporating supplementary cementitious material (SCM) such as
silica fume, fly ash and rice husk ash (RHA), which are industrial and agricultural wastes respectively, can improve
compressive strength and durability of concrete. Furthermore, use of SCM can help save the environment, with respect to using
less cement, utilization of waste and sustainable construction. This paper reports the development of sustainable high
performance concrete (HPC) of 100 MPa incorporating RHA. The results showed that the fresh and mechanical properties of
sustainable high performance RHA concrete presented significant improvements over ordinary portland cement (OPC) or silica
fume concrete. Applications of this type of concrete may include natural disaster mitigation or resistance to blast in building
structures.
Keywords: Sustainable concrete, high performance concrete, rice husk ash, workability, mechanical properties
1
Proceeding of the 4th ASEAN Civil Engineering Conference Yogyakarta, 22-23 November 2011
alloy industry and its particle size is 100 times Table 2. Physical properties of cement and SCM
smaller than the cement grains. It could work either
Properties OPC RHA CSF
as a pozzolan or filler. Even as an industrial waste by
Avg. particle size (µm) 22.1 11.5 0.5
product, its price is expensive. As an alternative, Specific surface area (m2/g) 359 16900 26250
SCM from the agricultural industry such as rice husk Specific gravity (g/cm3) 3.14 2.06 2.31
can be used (Mehta, 1977 ; Mahmud, 1997). It is a
waste derived from milling of paddy. Generally rice
husks are dumped in landfill or burnt in open area
causing environment pollution. Through controlled
combustion with temperature between 500 oC and 700
°C, non crystalline silica ash is formed (Hamad, 1981
; Nair, 2008). Combustion lower than 500 °C
produces ash which contain high carbon content and
high loss on ignition and combustion with temperature
greater than 700 °C produces crystalline silica (Nair,
2008), which is less reactive. In amorphous form Si02
content in RHA is about 90 % and normally Figure 1. Particle size distribution of RHA and cement.
categorized as reactive pozzolan. RHA should be
pulverized to get the appropriate particle size because In this research the material used to develop
the particle size of RHA influences the workability sustainable high performance RHA concrete grade
and the strength of concrete (Habeeb, 2010). RHA is 100 are locally available. The cementious material
capable to be used as partial cement replacement used was ordinary Portland cement (OPC), classified
material and reduced the use of natural resources as ASTM type I and the supplementary cementious
(Habeeb, 2010 ; Kartini, 2010). Then, RHA concrete materials used were rice husk ash (RHA) and
should be categorized as sustainable concrete. condensed silica fume (CSF). Their chemical
Although high performance concrete (HPC) was composition and physical properties are given in
developed very rapidly and used worldwide, most of Tables 1 and 2, respectively. The surface area of
these are associated with silica fume concrete. There cement and CSF was tested by the Blaine test
are increasing researches related to use of RHA in according to ASTM C 204-94a and that of RHA was
concrete up to 80 MPa (Raman, 2011 ; Mahmud, tested by nitrogen absorption method. For the
2009). There is still much work remains to be done to purpose of this research, the average particle size of
relate the mechanical properties of high performance RHA used was 11.5μm, which is less than the average
RHA concrete of 100 MPa. This paper evaluates the particle size of cement of 22.1 µm. Particle size
effect of inclusion of RHA on the strength of high distribution of RHA and cement are shown in Fig. 1.
performance concrete compared to OPC and CSF
concrete.
2
Proceeding of the 4th ASEAN Civil Engineering Conference Yogyakarta, 22-23 November 2011
3 TEST PROCEDURE
Figure 3. Bulk density of combination of fine and coarse
aggregates. To get the required workability for concrete with low
W/B ratio, addition of appropriate dosage of
Table 3. Mix proportion of High Performance Concrete superplasticizer is important during mixing. Prior to
mixing, cement and SCM were premixed. The
Constituent OPC RHA10 RHA15 CSF10
W/b 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 objective of concrete mixing is to coat the surface of
Sp (%) 0.45 1.1 1.2 0.95 all aggregate particles with cement paste, and to blend
Water (kg/m3) 137.5 137.5 137.5 137.5 all the gradients of concrete into a uniform mass.
Cement (kg/m3) 550 495 467.5 495 Mixing method adopted to produce HPC in this
RHA (kg/m3) 0 55 82.5 0 research was a two step mixing method; firstly
CSF (kg/m3) 0 0 0 55 advance preparation of a grout which is then blended
FA (kg/m3) 651.9 623.3 611.3 626.6 with aggregate to produce concrete (Rejeb, 1996).
CA (kg/m3) 1050 1050 1050 1050 The type of mixer used was a pan mixer with 100 L
capacity. The workability of concrete was measured in
The fine aggregate used was mining sand passing 4.75 terms of slump flow, performed immediately after
mm sieve with specific gravity of 2.61, fineness mixing the concrete. The slump flow test was carried
modulus of 3.1 and absorption of 0.76 %. The coarse out in accordance with BS 1881–102.
aggregate was crushed granite with size of 19.0-4.75
mm with specific gravity of 2.65, fineness modulus of For each mix, the following specimens were made: 42
6.76 and water absorption of 0.5 %. The coarse nos. of 100 mm cubes for compressive strength; six
aggregate met the grading requirements of ASTM C nos. of 150x300 (diameter x length) mm cylinders for
33 for 19.0–4.75 mm size aggregates as shown in Fig. modulus of elasticity and tensile strength; six nos. of
2. The key in HPC mix design is the optimization of 100x100x500 mm beams for flexure strength. After
the granular mixture. It was achieved by finding the demolding at the age of one day, 21 nos. of 100 mm
optimum density of combination of fine and coarse cubes, cylinder and beam were cured in a water tank
aggregates as shown Fig. 3. Domone et al. (Domone at 23± 1°C until the day of test and the other 21 nos.
and Soutsos, 1994) suggested the use of sand content of 100 mm cubes were air dried in laboratory room at
somewhat lower than that giving minimum voids in temperature of 28-30 °C and relative humidity of 70-
the aggregate combination required. In order to 80%.
achieve more flowability, the ratio of fine aggregate to
total aggregate used was 40:60 by mass, a little bit The compressive strength was determined according
lower than 48:52 as shown in Fig 3. All concrete to BS 1881: Part 116:1983 at 1, 3, 7, 28, 56, 91 and
mixtures had cementitious materials content of 550 180 days but samples of modulus of elasticity, tensile
kg/m3. A constant water to binder (W/b) ratio of 0.25 strength and flexure strength were tested at 7, 28 and
was used for all concrete mixtures and a 91 days. The standards followed for the modulus of
superplasticizer was employed in order to maintain elasticity, tensile strength and flexure strength were
the slump flow of fresh concrete of between 450 and BS 1881: Part 121: 1983 (equivalent MS 26: Part 2:
500 mm. The percentage of cement replacement by 1991), BS 1881: Part 117: 1983 (equivalent MS 7.1:
mass weight of RHA was 0 %, 10 % and 15 % and Part 4: 1971), BS 1881: Part 118: 1983 (equivalent
with that of CSF was 10 %, which are symbolized as MS 7.1: Part 4: 1971) respectively. For flexural test,
OPC, RHA10, RHA15 and CSF10, respectively. The the sample dimensions were conducted over a simply
dosage of superplasticer was adjusted to provide supported span length of 300 mm with two center -
similar slump flow. In calculating water to binder point loads. All tests were conducted using a testing
ratio the water present in the super-plasticizer was machine of 3000 kN capacity.
excluded. A commercially available modified
3
Proceeding of the 4th ASEAN Civil Engineering Conference Yogyakarta, 22-23 November 2011
4
Proceeding of the 4th ASEAN Civil Engineering Conference Yogyakarta, 22-23 November 2011
constant. This is attributed to the slow consumption of drying, except for RHA10 mix, concrete incorporating
the SiO2 of RHA and CSF at later ages and the rapid RHA and CSF have compressive strength lower than
formation of an inhibiting layer of reaction product that of OPC at 28 days and beyond. This information
that prevent further reaction of RHA or CSF with is beneficial for concrete contractors to better
calcium hydroxide (Mazloom, 2004). understanding the performance of concrete containing
these materials when deprived of water curing.
Figure 6. Percentage of compressive strength with respect Age OPC RHA10 RHA15 CSF10
to 28 days compressive strength of OPC under air drying. (Days) (MPa) (MPa) (MPa) (MPa)
7 4.69 4.37 4.67 4.6
Figures 5 and 6 show the rate of compressive strength 28 5.75 6.05 4.94 5.4
development with respect to 28 days compressive 91 6.95 7.03 6.08 6.3
strength of OPC concrete under both curing regimes.
The results of the splitting tensile strength tests for all
For water cured samples at 1 day, the results of
of the mixtures are presented in Table 7. The increase
samples containing RHA and CSF show 50% strength
in splitting tensile strengths of the OPC, RHA10, and
with respect to 28 days of that of OPC. After 3 days
CSF10 between 28-and 91-day is 20%, 16% and 16%
the strength increment is significant, indicating
respectively. The splitting tensile strengths of the
pozzolanic activity. At 28 days onwards RHA10 and
OPC, RHA10 and CSF10 water cured concretes
RHA15 mixes showed 10 % and 4.5 % higher
increased from 5.75 to 6.95 MPa, 6.05 to 7.03 MPa
strengths than that of OPC. These results suggest that
and from 5.4 to 6.3 MPa respectively. The splitting
RHA used in the research is reactive and pozzolanic
tensile strengths of RHA10 consistently exceeded
reaction starts at the age of 3 days onwards. CSF10
those of the corresponding OPC and CSF10. This
shows similar strength to that of RHA10 after 180
result is similar to that from previous research
days, implying that pozzolanic reaction of RHA is
(Mahmud et al., 2005 ; Mahmud, 2009). In general,
similar to that of CSF. It is interesting to compare the
the splitting tensile strengths of RHA concretes were
compressive strength of air dried concrete with that of
substantially higher than those of OPC and CSF
water cured. It can be seen that water curing
concretes, again probably due to stronger bonding
improved the compressive strength of CSF concrete at
between the cement paste and aggregate. However,
180 days by about 10% but in air drying the
the splitting tensile strengths of RHA15 and CSF10
compressive strength is decreased. According to the
were consistently lower than those of the
Concrete Society report (ACI Committee 363-1992,
corresponding OPC.
1992) concrete containing silica fume should be moist
cured for at least 7 days. It is obvious that curing is
sensitive for concrete containing SCM. Under air
5
Proceeding of the 4th ASEAN Civil Engineering Conference Yogyakarta, 22-23 November 2011
4.4. Effect of RHA on Static Modulus of Elasticity of 2. The results of splitting tensile and flexural tests
Concrete showed higher strength for RHA concrete
compared to OPC concrete due to filler and
Table 8. Static modulus of elasticity development of pozzolanic effects.
concrete specimens under water curing 3. The optimum 28-day compressive strength was
Age OPC RHA10 RHA15 CSF10 obtained with 10 % RHA replacement of cement.
(Days) (GPa) (GPa) (GPa) (GPa) 4. Both the splitting and flexural strengths follow
7 36 37.5 40.9 41.2 similar strength development to that of
28 39.6 43.8 42.9 42.3 compressive strength.
91 46.5 47.6 46.2 47.2 5. 100 MPa concrete can be obtained by incorporating
RHA. Since RHA is much cheaper than CSF, it is
The modulus of elasticity of HPC is shown in Table 8. the better alternative material than CSF to produce
The values of modulus of elasticity at 28 days for concrete of this magnitude.
RHA10, RHA15 and CSF10 concretes were 43.8,
42.9 and 42.3 GPa respectively, while that of the OPC ACKNOWLEDGMENT:
concrete was 39.6 GPa. This result indicated that the
use of SCM caused increase in modulus of elasticity The authors would like to thank the University of
of concrete; similar to that of previously reported Malaya for awarding the research grant PS113/2008B
(Mahmud et al., 2005 ; Mahmud, 2009). Higher to conduct the present research.
modulus of elasticity values implies better resistance
to deformation. REFERENCES
4.5 Effect of RHA on Flexural Strength of Concrete ACI Committee 363-1992, (1992). ACI Committee
363-1992, State-of-the-art report on high-strength
Table 9. Flexural strength development of concrete
concrete. ACI 363-1992. Detroit: American Concrete
specimens under water curing
Institute.
Age OPC RHA10 RHA15 CSF10
(Days) (MPa) (MPa) (MPa) (MPa) De Sensale, G. R. (2006). "Strength development of
7 7.11 7.97 8.18 6.64 concrete with rice-husk ash". Cement and Concrete
28 8.57 9.31 8.2 8.39 Composites. 28 (2), 158-160
91 9.52 10.1 9.06 9.74
Domone, P. L. J. and Soutsos, M. N. (1994).
Table 9 shows the variation of flexural strength for "Approach to the proportioning of high-strength
HPC. RHA10 seems to have a more pronounced concrete mixes." Concrete International 16 (10), 26-
effect on the flexural strength than the splitting tensile 31.
strength. At 28 and 91 days, inclusion of 15% RHA
did not improve the flexural strength of concrete Giaccio, G., De Sensale, G. R., Zerbino, R. (2007).
significantly. The average gain in flexural strength of "Failure mechanism of normal and high-strength
RHA10 concrete with respect to OPC at 7, 28 and 91 concrete with rice-husk ash." Cement & Concrete
days is 12.10%, 8.63%, and 6.09%, respectively. The Composites 29, 566-574.
flexural strengths development is similar to that of
Habeeb, G. A., Mahmud, H.B. (2010). "Studies on
compressive strength. The results of the present
properties of rice husk ash and its use as cement
investigation indicate that the optimum RHA
replacement material." Material Research. 13 (2),
inclusion for 28-day flexural strength is 10%.
185-190.
6
Proceeding of the 4th ASEAN Civil Engineering Conference Yogyakarta, 22-23 November 2011
3rd ACF International Conference- ACF/VCA 2008. sand." Construction and Building Materials. 25 (7),
Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. 3123-3130
Kartini, K., Mahmud, H.B., Hamidah, M.S. (2010). Ramezanianpour, A. A., Khani, M. M., Ahmadibeni,
"Absorption and permeability performance of G. (2009). "The effect of rice husk ash on mechanical
Selangor rice husk ash blended Grade 30 concrete." properties and durability of sustainable concretes."
Journal of Engineering Science & Technology. 5 (1), International Journal of Civil Engineerng. 7 (2), 83-
1-16 91.
Lepech, M. and Li, V. C. (2005). "Water permeability Rejeb, S. K. (1996). "Improving compressive strength
of cracked cementious composite."In: Proceedings of of concrete by a two-step mixing method." Cement
Eleventh International Conference on Fracture, Paper and Concrete Research. 26 (4), 585-592.
4539, March 20-25 2005 Turin, Italy. (CD-ROM).
Safiuddin, M., West, J.S., Soudki, K.A. (2011).
Mahmud, H. B., Chia, B.S., Hamid. N.B.A.A. (1997). "Flowing ability of the mortars formulated from self-
"Rice husk ash - an alternative material in producing compacting concretes incorporating rice husk ash."
high strength concrete." In: AL-MANASEER, S. N., Construction and Building Materials 25, 973-978.
R.C.JOSHI, ed. Proceedings of International
Conference on Engineering Materials, 1997 Ottawa, Sarkar, S. L., Aimin, Xu., Jana., D. (2001). Scanning
Canada., 275-284 Electron Microscopy, X-Ray Microanalysis of
Concretes. In: RAMACHANDRAN, V. S.,
Mahmud, H. B., Majuar, E., Zain, M. F. M. and BEAUDOIN, J.J (ed.) Handbook of analytical
Hamid, N. B. A. A. (2005). "Strength durability and techniques in concrete science and technology New
shrinkage of high strength rice husk ash concrete." York, USA: William Andrew Publishing.
American Concrete Institute Special Publication
SP228 Utilization on High Strength/High Sata, V., Jaturapitakkul, C., Kiattikomol, K. (2007).
Performance Concrete.,189-201. "Influence of pozzolan from various by-product
materials on mechanical properties of high-strength
Mahmud, H. B., Malik, M.F.B.A., Kahar., R.A, concrete." Construction and Building Materials 21
Rahman, S.N. (2009). "Mechanical properties and (7), 1589-1598.
durability of normal and water reduced high strength
grade 60 concrete containing rice husk ash." Journal Shao_Dong, W. (1999). "From 40 MPa to 100 MPa:
of Advanced Concrete Technology, Japan Concrete Materials Appreciation for Concrete." Journal of
Institute. 7 (1), 21-30. Chongqing Jianzhu University. (5), 1999-2005.
Mazloom, M., Ramezanianpour, A.A., Brooks J.J. Thomas, J., Jennings, H. 2008. "The science of
(2004). "Effect of silica fume on mechanical concrete" [Online]. Available:
properties of high-strength concrete." Cement & http://iti.northwestern.edu/cement/monograph/Monogr
Concrete Composites. 26, 347-357. aph5_4_3.html [Accessed 9/7 2011].