#G F D F7D 3 75 e A@#3 @9 Bbda35:8ad) GBB 7de) 7 75F A@: @F7D@3F A@3 A@87d7@57a@#a67 @9 ? L3F A@3@6a?bgf @9#%

Available online at www.sciencedirect.
com
Procedia Engineering 38 (2012) 2312 – 2328
@F7D@3F;A@3>A@87D7@57A@#A67>;@9%BF;?;L3F;A@3@6A?BGF;@9#%

#G>F;D;F7D;3 75;E;A@#3=;@9 BBDA35:8AD)GBB>;7DE

)7>75F;A@
D&&3DF:;43@346G>0G43D4:;@F3?3@;&3D975
!
00)1!,1/-&%00-/ %.!/1+%,1-&/-$2#1)-,,'),%%/),'!1)-,!*,01)121%-&%#(,-*-'5)/2#()/!..!**)!+)*!$2 6

,$)!
"
%0%!/#(#(-*!/%.!/1+%,1-&/-$2#1)-,,'),%%/),'!1)-,!*,01)121%-&%#(,-*-'5)/2#()/!..!**)!+)*!$2 6

,$)!
#
-01/!$2!1%012$%,1%.!/1+%,1-&/-$2#1)-,,'),%%/),'!1)-,!*,01)121%-&%#(,-*-'5)/2#()/!..!**)!+)*!$2 6

,$)!
$231#%3
*:7EFG6K673>EI;F:F:7835FADE38875F;@9F:7EGBB>;7DE7>75F;A@BDA57EEFAEFG6K F:7 ;@F7D35F;A@47FI77@

F:7?3@6F:GE7?B;D;53>>K3EE7EEI:;5:835FADE3D7?AEF;@8>G7@5;@9A@7;@EGBB>K5:3;@AB7D3F;A@EI:;5:
?GEF 47 9;H7@ 53D78G> 3FF7@F;A@ AD EFG6K;@9 F:7 ;@F7D35F;A@ 47FI77@ F:7 835FADE 3@6 BD;AD;F;L;@9 F:7
835FADE I7:3H7GE76)#@F7DBD7F;H7)FDG5FGD3>#A67>;@9F75:@;CG74KI:;5:I7 9AFF:7I7;9:FE8AD
F:7B7D8AD?3@57835FADE I:;5:3D77J3?;@763@6D3@=76 &@3>KF;53>;7D3D5:K&DA57EE;EGE76FA
D3@=F:7EGBB>;7D3@68AG@6AGFF:747EFEGBB>;7D8DA?F:7 9DAGB A8EGBB>;7D*:;E?7F:A6;E3BB>;76FA3@
3GFA?AF;H7 5A?BA@7@F ?3@G835FGD;@9 ;@6GEFDK ;@ F:7 EAGF:7D@ B3DF A8 @6;3 'G3>;8;53F;A@ 3@6 8;@3>
E7>75F;A@ A8 F:7 EGBB>;7D 3D7 6A@7 43E76 A@ F:7 ?7F:A6 BDABAE76 -7 :3H7 5A>>75F76 F:7 63F3 8DA? F:7
?7@F;A@76;@6GEFDK3@6F:7D7EG>FE3D7;?B>7?7@F764KF:7;@6GEFDK
M
&G4>;E:764K>E7H;7D"F6)7>75F;A@3@6 ADB77DD7H;7IG@67DD7EBA@E;4;>;FKA8$AADG>E>3?
7@FD78AD;9:7D6G53F;A@ Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
!7KIAD6E)GBB>;7D)7>75F;A@)GBB>;7D(3@=;@9 @3>KF;53>;7D3D5:K&DA57EE&

2..*)%/0
@KA@7 I:A EGBB>;7E BDA6G5FE ;@FA F:7 ?3D=7F ;E B3DF A8 F:7 EGBB>K 5:3;@
;@5>G6;@9 ?3@G835FGD7DE ;?BADF7DE I:A>7E3>7DE D7F3;>7DE 3@6 :;D7 5A?B3@;7E 7I BDA6G5FE AD E7DH;57E
7J;EFF:3FEA@AFD7CG;D7EA?7EGBB>K5:3;@?3@397?7@F*:7?AD7EGBB>;7DEF:3F3D7;@HA>H76F:7EGBB>K
5:3;@?3@397?7@F475A?7E?AD75A?B>7J*:7D7:3H7477@3@G?47DA8B:;>AEAB:;7E34AGF:AIFA673>
I;F:F:7EGBB>K5:3;@?3@397?7@F 35=I3D6;@F79D3F;A@67H7>AB3E?3@KEGBB>;7DE3EBAEE;4>7FA?3=7
1877-7058 © 2012 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
doi:10.1016/j.proeng.2012.06.277
P. Parthiban et al. / Procedia Engineering 38 (2012) 2312 – 2328 2313
F:7EGBB>K;F7?35A??A6;FK5A?B7F;F;H74;66;@9E;@9>7 EAGD57EGBB>;7DB3DF@7DE:;BEFA@3?7387I@
97@7D3>F:75>AE7D3BDA6G5FADE7DH;57;EFA35A??A6;FK;F7?4K678;@;F;A@F:7?AD7BAF7@F;3>EGBB>;7DE
3D73H3;>34>7*:;E53@?3=7F:7EGBB>K5:3;@?3@397?7@F7JFD7?7>K5A?B>7J #3;@F3;@;@9FD35734;>;FK
475A?7E?G5:?AD74GD67@EA?7
-:;>7E7>75F;@9F:7EGBB>;7DE35A?B3@KE:AG>65A@57@FD3F7A@53B34;>;F;7E3@65A?B7F7@57E@AF
D7EAGD57E-:7@7H3>G3F;@9EGBB>;7DE5>;7@FEF7@6FA8A5GEA@F:7EGBB>;7DVED7EAGD57E4753GE7F:7E73D7
:;9:>K H;E;4>7 A@ E;F7 FAGDE 43>3@57 E:77FE 3@6 D7EG?7E GF F:7K E:AG>6 47 ?AD7 ;@F7D7EF76 ;@ F:7
EGBB>;7DVE 34;>;FK FA FGD@ F:7E7 D7EAGD57E T ;FE B:KE;53> 3@6 :G?3@ 3EE7FE EG5: 3E B:KE;53> 835;>;F;7E
F75:@A>A9;7EFAA>E3@6 IAD=8AD57 T ;@FA53B34;>;F;7EF:3F;@FGD@53@47 5A?4;@76FA5D73F7:;9:>7H7>
5GEFA?7D835;@95A?B7F7@5;7E
$776A8E7>75F;@9F:747EFEGBB>;7D;E4753GE7;F;EG@I;E7FAB3KFAA?G5:4GF;F;EG@I;E7FA
B3KFAA>;FF>7-:7@KAGB3KFAA?G5:KAG>AE73>;FF>7?A@7KF:3F;E3>>-:7@KAGB3KFAA>;FF>7KAG
EA?7F;?7E>AE77H7DKF:;@94753GE7F:7F:;@9KAG4AG9:FI3E;@53B34>7A86A;@9F:7F:;@9KAG4AG9:F;F
FA6A
*A63K AD93@;L3F;A@E F:3F I;E: FA 53DDK A@ F:7 EGEF3;@34>7 9DAI;@9 @776 3 DA4GEF EFD3F79;5
B7D8AD?3@57 ?73EGD7?7@F 3@6 7H3>G3F;A@ EKEF7? 4753GE7 A8 5:3@9;@9 67?3@6E A8 5A@EG?7DE D76G576
BDA6G5F>;875K5>75A?B7F;F;H73@69>A43>;E76?3D=7FE
7EF BD35F;57 8AD EGBB>K 5:3;@ 6;5F3F7E F:3F ?3@397DE E:AG>6 >AA= FA 8AD? 5>AE7D >A@97D F7D?
D7>3F;A@E:;BE F:3F 67>;H7D >A@9 F7D? H3>G7 FA 4AF: B3DF;7E )FDA@9 D7>3F;A@E:;BE :7>B 6D;H7 5A>>34AD3F;A@
FDGEF 3@6 H3>G7 F:DAG9:AGF KAGD EGBB>K 5:3;@ *AB >7H7> AD93@;E3F;A@E D75A9@;E7 F:7 ;?BADF3@57 A8
67H7>AB;@93@6?3;@F3;@;@9IAD>65>3EEEGBB>K5:3;@EF:3F9;H7F:7?5A?B7F;F;H736H3@F397E8DA?AF:7DE
;@F:7;D?3D=7F*D3@EB3D7@5K3@6B7D8AD?3@57:3H73>I3KE477@;?BADF3@F8ADAD93@;E3F;A@E>AA=;@9FA
47 3 ?3D=7F >7367D *:7D78AD7 ?3@K A8 F:7? 3D7 EF3DF;@9 FA D75A9@;E7 F:7 H3>G7 ;@ )&# 8AD @GDFGD;@9
EGBB>;7DD7>3F;A@E:;BEF:DAG9:3B7D8AD?3@575G>FGD7
*:7 5A@57BFA8@F7DBD7F;H7)FDG5FGD3>#A67>>;@9)#I3EBD;?3DK;@FDA6G5764K -3D8;7>6
-3D8;7>6BDABAE76)#6G7FA7H3>G3F7F:75A?B>7JEA5;A75A@A?;5EKEF7?E7EF3F76F:3F)#
3BBDA35: 835;>;F3F7E FA 5A?B7> 5>3EE;8;53F;A@ 3@6 6;D75F;A@ A@ F:7 5A?B>7J D7>3F;A@E:;BE 3?A@9
5A?BA@7@FE A8 3 5A?B>7J;FK A8 D7>3F;A@E:;BE 3?A@9 7>7?7@FE A8 3 EA5;A75A@A?;5 EKEF7? )# ;E
;@F7DBD7F;H7 3E 43E76 A@ 3 9DAGBVE <G69?7@F 3@6 675;E;A@ I:7F:7D 3@6 :AI F:7 EKEF7?VE 7>7?7@FE 3D7
>;@=76F;EEFDG5FGD3>3E5A@EFDG5F76A@F:7D7>3F;A@E:;BVE8AG@63F;A@3@68;@3>EFDG5FGD7;E7JB>A;F768DA?
F:7 5A?B>7J E7F A8 EKEF7?VE H3D;34>7E F ;E 3>EA 3 ?A67>>;@9 3E F:7 8;@3> D7>3F;A@E:;B ;E ;>>GEFD3F76 ;@ 3
6;D75F769D3B:;53>?A67>
2314 P. Parthiban et al. / Procedia Engineering 38 (2012) 2312 – 2328
*:7@3>KF;5;7D3D5:K&DA57EE&:3E477@ 67H7>AB764K*)33FK

3@6
3@6;EA@7A8F:747EF=@AI@3@6?AEFI;67>KGE76#3BBDA35:7EF3>>AIEGE7DEFA3EE7EEF:7
D7>3F;H7 I7;9:F A8 ?G>F;B>7 5D;F7D;3 AD ?G>F;B>7 ABF;A@E 393;@EF 9;H7@ 5D;F7D;3 ;@ 3@ ;@FG;F;H7 ?3@@7D @
53E7 CG3@F;F3F;H7 D3F;@9E 3D7 @AF 3H3;>34>7 BA>;5K ?3=7DE AD 3EE7EEADE 53@ EF;>> D75A9@;L7 I:7F:7D A@7
5D;F7D;A@;E?AD7;?BADF3@FF:3@3@AF:7D*:7D78AD7B3;DI;E75A?B3D;EA@E3D73BB73>;@9FAGE7DE)33FK
7EF34>;E:7635A@E;EF7@FI3KA85A@H7DF;@9EG5:B3;DI;E75A?B3D;EA@E.;E?AD7;?BADF3@FF:3@/;@FA
3E7FA8@G?47DED7BD7E7@F;@9F:7D7>3F;H7BD;AD;FKA8735:A8F:75D;F7D;3
*:7 & 3E 3 5A?B7@E3FADK ?7F:A6 3EEG?7E 5A?B>7F7 399D793F;A@ 3?A@9 5D;F7D;3 3@6
67H7>ABE3>;@73D366;F;H7?A67>*:7I7;9:FE3@6E5AD7E3D735:;7H7643E;53>>K4KB3;DI;E75A?B3D;EA@E
47FI77@3>>ABF;A@EI;F:735:AF:7D
@675;E;A@?3=;@9F:7I7;9:FE3EE;9@76FAF:7675;E;A@5D;F7D;33FF7?BFFAD7BD7E7@FF:797@G;@7
;?BADF3@57A8F:75D;F7D;3-:7@5D;F7D;353@@AF477JBD7EE76;@CG3@F;F3F;H7F7D?EF:7@;F;E6;88;5G>FFA
355GD3F7>KD7BD7E7@FF:7;?BADF3@57A8F:7E75D;F7D;3@3E;FG3F;A@>;=7F:;EF:7675;E;A@?3=;@9BDA57EE
53@ 47 ;?BDAH76 5A@E;67D34>K 4K ;67@F;8K;@9 F:7 5D;F;53> 5D;F7D;3 3@6 F:7@ 53@ 47 D77H3>G3F76 ?AD7
355GD3F7>KF:7I7;9:FEA8F:7E75D;F7D;3*:7;@FG;F;H747>;7H7;EF:3FF:75D;F7D;A@I;F:F:7:;9:7EFI7;9:F;E
F:7 ?AEF 5D;F;53> A@7 *:;E ?3K @AF 3>I3KE 47 FDG7 3@6 ;@ EA?7 ;@EF3@57E F:7 5D;F7D;A@ I;F: F:7 >AI7EF
I7;9:F?3K47F:7?AEF5D;F;53>A@7
!

)GBB>;7DE7>75F;A@3FF3;@76F:7EF3F7A8:;9:7EFE;9@;8;53@578AD5A?B3@;7E;@F:75GDD7@FE57@3D;A
4753GE7 A8 ;@5D73E;@9 5A?B7F;F;A@ ?BDAB7D E7>75F;A@ A8 EGBB>;7DE I;>> :3H7 3@ BAAD ;?B35F A@ F:7
AH7D3>>B7D8AD?3@57A8F:7 ?3@G835FGD7D *:7@7I3BBDA35:BDABAE764K#;F:3F07K63@R@7KFNA>B3@
7?3>NA43@A9>G

5A@E;67D4AF:CG3>;F3F;H73@6CG3@F;F3F;H7H3D;34>7E;@7H3>G3F;@9B7D8AD?3@57
8ADE7>75F;A@A8EGBB>;7DE43E76A@788;5;7@5K3@678875F;H7@7EE;@A@7A8F:74;997EF53D ?3@G835FGD;@9
835FADK ;@ *GD=7K *:;E @7I ?7F:A6A>A9K ;E D73>;L76 ;@ FIA EF7BE @ F:7 8;DEF EF397 CG3>;F3F;H7
B7D8AD?3@57 7H3>G3F;A@ ;E B7D8AD?76 4K GE;@9 8GLLK & ;@ 8;@6;@9 5D;F7D;3 I7;9:FE 3@6 F:7@ 8GLLK
*%&));EGF;>;L76;@8;@6;@9F:7D3@=;@9A8EGBB>;7DEI7;9:F76?3JT?;@8GLLK?A67>;E67H7>AB76FA
:3@6>7F:7H39G7@7EEA8;@BGF63F378875F;H7>K3@66;887D7@FI7;9:FEA85D;F7D;3;@F:7B3B7DEG4?;FF764K
?;6 3@ ):A6EKBAGD 4 %VD;7@ #3K

*:7K :3H7 GE76 F:7 & FA 67F7D?;@7 F:7
I7;9:FEA8F:75D;F7D;3)3DA<!3G>(3=7E:,3D?3BDABAE7E36K@3?;5?A67>I;F:G@57DF3;@FK43E76A@
GLLK&8AD>A@9F7D?EFD3F79;5H7@6ADE7>75F;A@BDA4>7?E
@ 3FF7?BF :3E 477@ ?367 4K # &G@@;K3?AADF:K & #3F:;K3>393@ & &3DF:;43@
FA
67H7>AB3@7I5A?BAE;F7?A67>GE;@9EFDG5FGD3>7CG3F;A@?A67>;@93@68GLLK3@3>KF;5:;7D3D5:KBDA57EE
F75:@;CG743E76A@F:7D7EG>FEA83EGDH7KA8D7EBA@67@FE*:7B3B7D4K7E:7@93E:-G3/;6A@9
0:3@9 7J;3@9 -G6 3H;6 " %>EA@ 74DG3DK
BDABAE7E 3 8GLLK ?G>F;A4<75F;H7 BDA9D3??;@9

?A67>FA675;67A@EGBB>;7DE7>75F;A@F3=;@9D;E=835FADE;@FA5A@E;67D3F;A@G3@ K:):KGD3EG):;:
):;:4BD;>
&DABAE763:K4D;6?A67>8ADEGBBADF;@9F:7H7@6ADE7>75F;A@BDA57EE;@F:7@7IF3E=
E;FG3F;A@E *:7 B3B7D EG4?;FF76 4K )3?G7> G3@9 3DE:3> !7E=3D G>K
BD7E7@F76 3@
;@F79D3F;A@ ?75:3@;E? ;@ F7D?E A8 3 E7F A8 5A?BD7:7@E;H7 3@6 5A@8;9GD34>7 ?7FD;5E 3DD3@976
:;7D3D5:;53>>KF:3FF3=7E;@FA355AG@FBDA6G5FFKB7EGBB>;7DFKB73@6%# EGBB>;7D;@F79D3F;A@>7H7>*:7
EFG6K 4K E:GFAE: )3D=3D &D3F3B ! #A:3B3FD3
3EEG?7 FIA ;?BADF3@F 6;?7@E;A@E A8

EGBB>;7DEUB7D8AD?3@573@653B34;>;FK
;3@@ ";3@9 /3@9 G3@ $7@9 :;G IAE:;G@9 *L7@9 (G7K G7; /7: G@7

BDABAE76;@F79D3F768GLLK?G>F;B>75D;F7D;3675;E;A@?3=;@9##?7F:A6366D7EE7EF:;E;EEG7I;F:;@
F:75A@F7JFA8F:7H7@6ADE7>75F;A@BDA4>7?*:7KGE76;@F7DBD7F;H7EFDG5FGD3>?A67>>;@9)#FA?3BAGF
F:7 D7>3F;A@E:;BE 3?A@9 F:7 EG45D;F7D;3 *:7@ F:7K :3H7 GE76 F:7 8GLLK 3@3>KF;53> :;7D3D5:K BDA57EE
& ?7F:A6 FA 5A?BGF7 F:7 D7>3F;H7 I7;9:FE 8AD 735: 5D;F7D;A@ +@67DEF3@6;@9 3@6 CG3@F;8K;@9 F:7
;@F7DD7>3F;A@E:;BE47FI77@;@6;H;6G3>D;E=7>7?7@FE;E3E;9@;8;53@F>K;?BADF3@F4GF5A?B>7J5:3>>7@978
I7H;7I3>>F:7D;E=E;@38;D?3E3@;@F79D3F76EKEF7?I753@3BB>K35A?BGF7D3EE;EF76>73D@;@9BDA57EE
53>>76 @F7DBD7F;H7 )FDG5FGD3> #A67>;@9 )# FA 5A@EFDG5F 3 EFDG5FGD3> 9D3B: 3@6 ;>>GEFD3F7 F:AE7 D;E=
;@F7DD7>3F;A@E:;BE(;5=ADH7FF)#(#(# &:$;@9I7;";G&:
:3EGE76
)#5A@57BFE3@6F75:@;CG7EFAG@67DEF3@635A?B3@KVEAH7D3>>D;E=BDA8;>7;@347FF7DI3K*:7EGBB>;7D
675;E;A@?3=;@9BDA4>7?;E5A?B>;53F764KE7H7D3>5D;F7D;33@6EG45D;F7D;3*:75D;F7D;33@6EG45D;F7D;3
GE76?3KH3DK35DAEE6;887D7@FBDA6G5F53F79AD;7E3@6E;FG3F;A@E*:73;?A8F:7B3B7DEG4?;FF764K
!3@@3@ 3@6 $AADG> 3C 74DG3DK
;E FA 3@3>KE7 F:7 ;@F7D35F;A@ A8 5D;F7D;3 3@6 EG45D;F7D;3
*:7E7 5D;F7D;3 3D7 GE76 FA E7>75F F:7 EGBB>;7D 8AD F:7 4G;>F;@AD67D EGBB>K 5:3;@ 7@H;DA@?7@F ;@ F:7
AD;9;@3>7CG;B?7@F?3@G835FGD;@95A?B3@K
>8A@EA )P@5:7L H3@97>AE *D;3@F3B:K>>AG BD7E7@FE 3 ?7F:A6A>A9K 8AD B7D8AD?;@9 3
E7@E;F;H;FK3@3>KE;EA@F:7I7;9:FEA8F:7675;E;A@5D;F7D;33@6F:7B7D8AD?3@57H3>G7EA8F:73>F7D@3F;H7E
7JBD7EE76;@F7D?EA8F:7675;E;A@5D;F7D;3*:7EFG6K4K:7-7;:3@9:7@9(G-G:;@*E3;";@
G3@9:G :7@ 6;E5GEE7E 3@6 67H7>ABE 3 ?3@G835FGD;@9 CG3>;FK K;7>6 ?A67> 8AD 8AD753EF;@9 ;@
E;>;5A@ I387D E>;5;@9 43E76 A@ F:7 @3>KF;5 ;7D3D5:K &DA57EE & 8D3?7IAD= ;@3>>K E7@E;F;H;FK
3@3>KE;E;EB7D8AD?76FAF7EFF:7EF34;>;FKA8F:7BD;AD;FKD3@=;@9@F:7B3B7D4K>7EE;AE:;L3=3E:D38
"34;4F:73GF:ADED7H;7IF:767H7>AB?7@FEA8F:73@3>KF;5:;7D3D5:KBDA57EE&E;@57;FE;@57BF;A@@
B3DF;5G>3DF:7K6;E5GEEBDA4>7??A67>>;@9B3;DI;E75A?B3D;EA@E<G697?7@FE53>7E67D;H3F;A@?7F:A6E
5A@E;EF7@5K;@6;57E;@5A?B>7F7?3FD;JEK@F:7E;EA8F:7I7;9:FEE7@E;F;H;FK3@3>KE;E3@69DAGB675;E;A@E
>>:3H7477@;?BADF3@F3D73EA8D7E73D5:;@&

/-"*%+%&),)1)-,
?A@9 F:7 CG7EF;A@E F:3F 3D;E7 3D7 I:3F 3D7 F:7 5D;F7D;3 F:3F ;@8>G7@57E F:7 B7D8AD?3@57 A8
EGBB>;7DE8DA?F:75A?B3@K B7DEB75F;H7 I:3F;@F7D35F;A@E3D7F:7D747FI77@F:75D;F7D;3F:3F:3H7477@
;67@F;8;76 I:;5: 3D7 F:7 5D;F7D;3 ?AEF>K ;@8>G7@5;@9 F:7 EGBB>;7D E7>75F;A@ 675;E;A@ 5:AAE;@9 F:7 47EF
EGBB>;7DE 8DA? F:7 4G@5: A8 EGBB>;7DE ;67@F;8K;@9 F:7 I73= EGBB>;7DE 3@6 BDABAE;@9 B7D8AD?3@57
;?BDAH7?7@F?7F:A6EFAD3;E7F:7 CG3>;FK-7:3H7FA5:AAE7F:75D;F7D;34K5A@6G5F;@9F:7EGDH7K*:7@
I7:3H7FA8;@6F:7;@F7D35F;A@47FI77@F:75D;F7D;33@667H7>AB363F3E:77FI;F:F:7>;@9G;EF;5H3D;34>7E
3F3:3E477@5A>>75F768DA?F:75A?B3@K
;9 &DA4>7?7E5D;BF;A@
-$%*&-/+2*!1)-,
A>>AI;@9 EF7BE :3H7 477@ 8A>>AI76 FA EA>H7 F:7 BDA4>7? 3@6 8>AI 5:3DF A8 F:7 BDA4>7?
67E5D;BF;A@;E3EE:AI@;@;9
;67@F;8K;@9 F:7 5D;F7D;3 3@6 D7EB75F;H7 I7;9:FE A8 >;@9G;EF;5 H3D;34>7E A8 F:7 5D;F7D;3 4K F3=;@9
AB;@;A@E 8DA?;@6GEFDK7JB7DF
67H7>AB;@9F:7;@F7DD7>3F;A@E:;B47FI77@F:75D;F7D;3
BD;AD;F;L;@9F:75D;F7D;33@6D3@=;@9F:7?
53>5G>3F;A@A8F:7I7;9:FE8ADF:75D;F7D;3
67F7D?;@;@9F:7BD;AD;FKI7;9:FEA8F:75D;F7D;38AD@AA8EGBB>;7DE3@6D3@=;@9F:7EGBB>;7DE
;67@F;8K;@9F:79DAGBA847EFEGBB>;7DE
B7D8AD?;@9 F:7 E7@E;F;H;FK 3@3>KE;E FA EFG6K F:7 78875F 5D;F7D;A@ 3@6 3>F7D@3F;H7 A@ F:7
B7D8AD?3@57A8F:7EGBB>;7DE
#7F:A6A>A9KI73D79A;@9FAGE78ADF:734AH7BGDBAE7;E3E8A>>AI;@93@6F:7?A67>;EE:AI@
;@;9
-7 :3H7 GE76 #)# #A6;8;76 @F7DBD7F;H7 )FDG5FGD3> #A67>>;@9 F75:@;CG7 8AD EFG6K;@9 F:7
;@F7D35F;A@ 47FI77@ F:7 5D;F7D;3 3@6 BD;AD;F;L;@9 F:7 5D;F7D;3 -7 9AF F:7 I7;9:FE 8AD F:7
B7D8AD?3@575D;F7D;33@67EF34>;E:7635A@F7JFG3>D7>3F;A@E:;B47FI77@7>7?7@FEI;F:D7EB75FFA
I:;5:B3;DEA87>7?7@FEI:;5:3D77J3?;@763@6D3@=76
&@3>KF;53>;7D3D5:K&DA57EE;EGE76FAD3@=F:7EGBB>;7D3@68AG@6AGFF:747EFEGBB>;7D
8DA?F:74G@5:A8EGBB>;7D
"

$%,1)&)#!1)-,& (%%/&-/+!,#%/)1%/)-,
*:7B7D8AD?3@575D;F7D;3I:;5:3D7D7>7H3@F8DA?F:7EGBB>;7DVEBA;@FA8H;7I3D7;67@F;8;764KF3=;@9
AB;@;A@E8DA?F:7;@6GEFDK7JB7DFE3@6F:7>;F7D3FGD7D7H;7I768F7D6;E5GEE;@9I;F:F:7;@6GEFDK7JB7DF
F:7835FADEI:;5:3D78;@3>;L768ADF:7EFG6K3D73E8A>>AIE
'G3>;FK'
7>;H7DK
&DA6G5F;H;FK&
AEFE
BB>;53F;A@A85A@57BFG3>#3@G835FGD;@9
*75:@A>A9;53>3B34;>;F;7E*
@H;DA@?7@F3>#3@397?7@F
G?3@(7EAGD57#3@397?7@F
#3@G835FGD;@9:3>>7@97#
)7DH;57)
*A ?77F EF3@63D6 D7CG;D7?7@F 3@6 5A@F;@GAGE ;?BDAH7?7@F ;@ 4GE;@7EE 5A?B3@;7E @776 FA
?A@;FADF:7;DEGBB>;7DB7D8AD?3@577>;H7DK3@6CG3>;FK3D7FIAA8F:7?AEF;?BADF3@F;@6;53FADEA8
EGBB>;7D7H3>G3F;A@
;9 #A67>AD?G>3F;A@
-$)&)%$1/2#12/!*%*&,1%/!#1)-,!1/)4
-7 :3H7 ?A6;8;76 F:7 F75:@;CG7 4K 366;@9 FIA ?AD7 5A@EFD3;@FE ;@ F:7 )FDG5FGD3> )7>8
@F7D35F;A@#3FD;JI:;5:I;>>5>73D>K6;E5D;?;@3F73?A@9F:7835FADEI:;5:I;>>9;H735>73D7D;67334AGF
I:;5:835FADE3D7F:76D;H;@9835FADE3@6I:;5:3D7F:767B7@676835FADE*:GEI753@BD;AD;F;L7F:7?3E
I7>>3ED3@=F:7?78875F;H7>K*:;EI;>>3>EA:7>BGEFA9;H7I7;9:FEFAF:75D;F7D;3I:;5:;@FGD@I;>>:7>B
FAD3@=F:7EGBB>;7DE78875F;H7>K
AD3@3>KL;@9F:7B7D8AD?3@575D;F7D;3;@67H7>AB;@9))#F:78A>>AI;@9E;JEK?4A>E:3H7477@
GE76FA67@AF7F:76;D75F;A@A8D7>3F;A@E:;B47FI77@835FADE;3@6<
, 35FAD;I;>>38875F835FAD<?3<AD>K
35FAD<I;>>38875F835FAD<?3<AD>K
% 35FADE;3@6< I;>>:7>BFA35:;7H7735:AF:7D
. T 35FADE;3@6<3D7G@D7>3F76
35FAD;I;>>38875F835FAD<
+ T 35FAD<I;>>38875F835FAD;
%!#(!")*)15!1/)4
*:7))#:3E477@5A@H7DF76;@FA3?3FD;J53>>76F:7;@;F;3>D735:34;>;FK?3FD;J4KEG4EF;FGF;@9,%
.3@6+4K 3@6
3EB7D9;H7@53E7
;8F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7))#;E,F:7@F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7D735:34;>;FK?3FD;J475A?7E3@6
F:7<;7@FDK475A?7E

;8F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7))#;EF:7@F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7D735:34;>;FK?3FD;J475A?7E
3@6
F:7<;7@FDK475A?7E
;8F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7))#;E%F:7@F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7D735:34;>;FK?3FD;J475A?7E3@6
F:7<;7@FDK3>EA475A?7E
;8F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7))#;E.F:7@F:7;< 7@FDK;@F:7D735:34;>;FK?3FD;J475A?7E
3@6
F:7<;7@FDK3>EA475A?7E

;8F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7))#;EF:7@F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7D735:34;>;FK?3FD;J475A?7E 3@6
F:7<;7@FDK3>EA475A?7E
;8F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7))#;E+F:7@F:7;<7@FDK;@F:7D735:34;>;FK?3FD;J475A?7E3@6
F:7<;7@FDK3>EA475A?7E
%3%*!/1)1)-,
*:7 D735:34;>;FK 3@6 3@F75767@F E7F -3D8;7>6 8AD 735: 835FAD ;E 8AG@6 8DA? F:7
D735:34;>;FK ?3FD;J *:7 D735:34;>;FK E7F 8AD 3 B3DF;5G>3D H3D;34>7 5A@E;EFE A8 F:7 H3D;34>7 ;FE7>8 3@6 F:7
AF:7D H3D;34>7E I:;5: ;F ?3K :7>B FA 35:;7H7 *:7 3@F75767@F E7F 5A@E;EFE A8 F:7 H3D;34>7 ;FE7>8 3@6 F:7
AF:7DH3D;34>7EI:;5:?3K:7>B;@35:;7H;@9F:7?)G4E7CG7@F>KF:7;@F7DE75F;A@A8F:7E7E7FE;E 67D;H76
8AD3>>H3D;34>7E*:7H3D;34>78ADI:;5:F:7D735:34;>;FK3@6F:7;@F7DE75F;A@E7FE3D7F:7E3?7;E9;H7@F:7
FAB>7H7>H3D;34>7;@F:7)#:;7D3D5:KI:;5:IAG>6@AF:7>B35:;7H73@KAF:7DH3D;34>734AH7F:7;DAI@
>7H7>8F7DF:7;67@F;8;53F;A@ A8F:7FAB>7H7>835FADE;F;E6;E53D6768DA?F:7AF:7DD7?3;@;@9H3D;34>7E
*:;E ;F7D3F;A@ ;E 5A@F;@G76 G@F;> F:7 >7H7>E A8 735: H3D;34>7 3D7 8AG@6 AGF *:7 ;67@F;8;76 >7H7>E 3;6E ;@
4G;>6;@9F:76;9D3B:3@6F:78;@3>?A67>A8)#
,!*50)0
*:7A4<75F;H7A8F:7##3@3>KE;E;EFA3@3>KE7F:76D;H7DBAI7D3@6F:767B7@67@57BAI7D
A8 F:7 H3D;34>7E *:7 H3D;34>7E 3D7 5>3EE;8;76 ;@FA 8AGD 5>GEF7DE 3E E:AI@ ;@ 8;9GD7 *:7 8;DEF 5>GEF7D
5A@E;EFEA8F:73GFA@A?AGE5D;F7D;3F:3F:3H7I73=6D;H7DBAI7D3@6I73=67B7@67@57*:7E75D;F7D;33D7
D7>3F;H7>K 6;E5A@@75F76 8DA? F:7 EKEF7? I;F: I:;5: F:7K :3H7 A@>K 87I >;@=E I:;5: ?3K 47 EFDA@9
)75A@65>GEF7D5A@E;EFEA8F:767B7@67@F5D;F7D;3F:3F:3H7I73=6D;H7DBAI7D4GFEFDA@967B7@67@57*:7
F:;D65>GEF7D:3EF:7>;@=3975D;F7D;3F:3F:3H7EFDA@96D;H;@9BAI7D3>EAEFDA@967B7@67@57*:7E75D;F7D;3
3D7G@EF34>7;@F:7835FF:3F3@K35F;A@A@F:7E75D;F7D;3I;>>:3H73@78875FA@AF:7DE3>EA38776435=A@
F:7?E7>H7E *:7 8AGDF: 5>GEF7D ;@5>G67E F:7 ;@67B7@67@F 5D;F7D;3 :3H;@9 EFDA@9 6D;H;@9 BAI7D 4GF I73=
67B7@67@57F;EA4E7DH76F:3F3H3D;34>7I;F:3H7DKEFDA@96D;H;@9BAI7D53>>76F:7=7KH3D;34>7E83>>E
;@FAF:753F79ADKA8;@67B7@67@FAD>;@=3975D;F7D;3
,!*51)#!*)%/!/#(5/-#%00
*:7@ @3>KF;53> ;7D3D5:K &DA57EE ;E GE76 FA 8AD 7H3>G3F;@9 F:7 EGBB>;7DE -7 :3H7 GE76 F:7
>;@9G;EF;5H3D;34>7E53>75A@E;EF;@9A8D3F;@9EFAD3F7F:76;887D7@FEGBB>;7DE*:7@@AD?3>;L76I7;9:FE8AD
735:EGBB>;7DI;F:D7EB75FFAF:7H3D;AGE835FADE:3H7477@ 53>5G>3F76*:7BD;AD;FKI7;9:FEA8EGBB>;7DE
I;F:D7EB75FFAF:7735:835FAD3D79;H7@4K366;@9F:7I7;9:FEB7DEGBB>;7D?G>F;B>;764KI7;9:FEA8F:7
5ADD7EBA@6;@9B7D8AD?3@57835FAD

*:7A4<75F;H7A8F:;EE75F;A@;EFA8;@6;@F7D35F;A@47FI77@F:7B7D8AD?3@575D;F7D;3FA8;@6F:7
5D;F7D;3 I7;9:FE 3@6 FA 6;E5D;?;@3F7 F:7 47EF EGBB>;7DE 8DA? F:7 AF:7D 3>EA FA H3>;63F7 F:7 ?A67> 4K
53DDK;@9 AGF F:7 E7@E;F;H;FK 3@3>KE;E *:7 ?A67> :3E 477@ 3BB>;76 FA F:7 3GFA?AF;H7 5A?BA@7@F
?3@G835FGD;@9 5A?B3@K ;@ F:7 EAGF:7D@ B3DF A8 @6;3 *:7 D7CG;D76 63F3 :3H7 477@ 5A>>75F76 8DA? F:7
E3?7;@6GEFDK3@6?A67>:3E477@IAD=76AGF8ADF:7;@6GEFDK
@F:;ED7E73D5:8AD;67@F;8K;@9F:75A@F7JFG3>D7>3F;A@E:;B3?A@9F:7B7D8AD?3@57835FADE8ADF:7
EGBB>;7DE7>75F;A@5DAEE8G@5F;A@3>F73?8DA?F:7;@6GEFDKI7D75A@EG>F768ADF:734AH7IAD=

%)'(10&-/1(%%/&-/+!,#%/)1%/)!
*:7:;7D3D5:K>7H7>EA4F3;@768DA?F:7#A6;8;76)#?7F:A63D7GE76FAA4F3;@F:7I7;9:FE8AD
735: 835FAD *:7 #A6;8;76 )FDG5FGD3> )7>8 @F7D35F;A@ #3FD;J #)# ;E E:AI@ ;@ F34>7 F:7
(735:34;>;FK#3FD;J;E53>5G>3F763@6E:AI@;@F34>7*:7AH7D3>>"7H7>B3DF;F;A@;EE:AI@;@F34>7
*:7@G?47DA8>7H7>E;@F:7)#BDA57EE8ADF:75D;F7D;3 ;E)AF:7?3J;?G?D3F;@9A8F:75D;F7D;3;7
;E6;H;6764KFAA4F3;@F:7I7;9:FA8F:7>AI7EF>7H7>;7
*:7?G>F;B>7EA8F:;EH3>G73D7GE76
8AD 3EE;9@;@9 F:7 I7;9:FE FA F:7 :;9:7D H3>G7E *:7 @AD?3>;L76 I7;9:FE A8 F:7 B7D8AD?3@57 835FADE 3D7
53>5G>3F76;@F34>7*:7835FADEI;F:F:7:;9:7EF>7H7>3D79;H7@3I7;9:FA8*:75D;F7D;3F:3F:3H7
F:7E3?7>7H7>3D73EE;9@76E3?7H3>G7E#A6;8;76)#43E76:;7D3D5:K?A67>8ADF:75D;F7D;A@;EE:AI@
;@8;9
;9 #A6;8;76 )# 43E76:;7D3D5:K?A67>8ADF:75D;F7D;A@
;9 6D;H;@9BAI7D3@667B7@67@576;39D3?8AD5D;F7D;A@ 8DA?#A6;8;76)#

-7 :3H7 3>EA GE76 )# F75:@;CG7 FA ;67@F;8K F:7 ;@F7DD7>3F;A@E:;B 47FI77@ F:7 B7D8AD?3@57
?73EGD7E*:7D7EG>FEA8F:7)#3D73EE:AI@ 47>AI;@8;9 I;F:F:76;9D3B:E:AI;@9:;7D3D5:K>7H7>E
A8 F:7 B7D8AD?3@57 835FADE DA? F:7 6;9D3B: 47>AI E7DH;57 ;E 3F F:7 :;9:7EF >7H7> 8A>>AI76 4K CG3>;FK
5AEF 3@6 BDA6G5F;H;FK 3@6 EA A@ *:7 ## 3@3>KE;E 8;9 3>EA E:AIE ?AEF A8 F:7 5D;F7D;3 3D7
5A@57@FD3F76;@F:;D65>GEF7DI:;5:E:AIE>;@=3975D;F7D;3
-7 :3H7 GE76 #A6;8;76 )# F75:@;CG7 FA 97F F:7 5>73D7D ;673 34AGF I:;5: 835FADE 3D7 6D;H;@9
835FADE I:;5: 3D7 67B7@67@F 3@6 FA BD;AD;F;L7 F:7? ?AD7 78875F;H7>K ;@FA F:7 8AGD 9DAGBE ;@ ##
3@3>KE;E3@63>EAFA97FF:7BDAB7D:;7D3D5:KEFDG5FGD74K366;@9FIA?AD75A@EFD3;@FE*:DAG9:#A6;8;76
@F7DBD7F;H7 )FDG5FGD3> #A67>>;@9 I7 9AF ?AD7 BD35F;53> D7EG>FE )# F75:@;CG7 ;E GE76 FA H7D;8K F:7
#A6;8;76)#F75:@;CG78F7D5A?B3D;@9F:7)# #A6;8;76)#3@65A@EG>F;@9F:75DAEE8G@5F;A@3>
F73?8DA?;@6GEFDKI78AG@6AGFF:3F#)#;E9;H;@947FF7DD7EG>FEE3F;E8K;@9F:7;@6GEFDKD7CG;D7?7@F
;9 )#43E76:;7D3D5:K?A67>8ADF:75D;F7D;A@
;9 6D;H;@9BAI7D3@667B7@67@576;39D3?8AD5D;F7D;A@ 8DA?)#

*34>7 #A6;8;76 )FDG5FGD3>)7>8@F7D35F;A@#3FD;J#)#E:AI;@9>;@9G;EF;5H3D;34>7E8ADF:7

B7D8AD?3@575D;F7D;A@
00,+%#3+/. /(
-#.4(#%341+.)
'%*./,/)+%#
.5+1/.-'.3
#.#)'-'.3
#.4(#%341+
1/&4%3+5+37
,#0#$+,+37
*#,,'.)'2
/.%'034#,
#%3/12
',+5'17
4#,+37
'15+%'
'2%1+03+/.

/232
.)
4#,+37 % . % , , . + ,
',+5'17 % % . + , . +
1/&4%3+5+37 % , % . % % .
/232 % % . % %
00,+%#3+/. /(
/.%'034#, % % . . , .
#.4(#%341+.)
'%*./,/)+%#,
% . . % +
#0#$+,+37
.5+1/.-'.3#,
% + % .
#.#)'-'.3
% + %
#.4(#%341+.)
% %
*#,,'.)'2
'15+%'2 %
*34>7 (735:34;>;FK#3FD;JE:AI;@96D;H;@9BAI7DE3@667B7@67@57BAI7D8AD735:5D;F7D;A@
#.4(#%341+.)
-#.4(#%341+.)
1+5+.)/6'1
00,+%#3+/. /(
'%*./,/)+%#,
.5+1/.-'.3
#.#)'-'.3
1/&4%3+5+37
/.%'034#,
#%3/12
*#,,'.)'2
#0#$+,+37
',+5'17
'2%1+03+/.
4#,+37
'15+%'

/232
4#,+37

',+5'17

1/&4%3+5+37

/232

00,+%#3+/. /(
/.%'034#,

#.4(#%341+.)
'%*./,/)+%#,

#0#$+,+37
.5+1/.-'.3#,

#.#)'-'.3

#.4(#%341+.)

*#,,'.)'2
'15+%'2

'0'.&'.%'

/6'1
*34>7 %H7D3>>"7H7>B3DF;F;A@A8835FADE
35FADE (735:34;>;FK)7F @F75767@F)7F @F7DE75F;A@ "7H7>
' '&*# '&#) '&# "7H7>
& &*) &*) &*) "7H7>
'&*# '&*# '&*# "7H7>
&*#) '*#) *#) "7H7>
'*# '&* '* "7H7>
* &*#) '&*#) &*#) "7H7>
# # # "7H7>
'&#) '&#) '&#) "7H7>
# '&*#) '&*#) '&*#) "7H7>
) '*#) *#) *#) "7H7>
*34>7$AD?3>;L76I7;9:FEA8F:7B7D8AD?3@575D;F7D;A@
$AD?3>;L76
&7D8AD?3@575D;F7D;3; "7H7>EB -7;9:FEI;
-7;9:FE@I;
'G3>;FK "7H7>

&DA6G5F;H;FK "7H7>

7>;H7DK "7H7>

AEFE "7H7>

BB>;53F;A@ A8A@57BFG3>#3@G835FGD;@9 "7H7>

*75:@A>A9;53>3B34;>;FK "7H7>

@H;DA@?7@F3>#3@397?7@F "7H7>

(# "7H7>

#3@G835FGD;@9:3>>7@97E "7H7>

)7DH;57E "7H7>

*:7@ @AD?3>;L76 I7;9:FE 8AD 735: EGBB>;7D I;F: D7EB75F FA F:7 H3D;AGE 835FADE :3H7 477@
53>5G>3F76 *:7 BD;AD;FK I7;9:FE A8 EGBB>;7DE I;F: D7EB75F FA F:7 735: 835FAD 3D7 9;H7@ 4K 366;@9 F:7
I7;9:FEB7DEGBB>;7D?G>F;B>;764KI7;9:FEA8F:75ADD7EBA@6;@9B7D8AD?3@57835FAD ;@3>>KF:7BD;AD;FK
I7;9:FE A8 735: EGBB>;7D 53@ 47 53>5G>3F76 4K I7;9:FE B7D EGBB>;7D ?G>F;B>;76 4K I7;9:FE A8 F:7
5ADD7EBA@6;@95D;F7D;A@*:7:;9:7EFE5AD7A8F:7EGBB>;7D9;H7EF:7;67334AGFF:747EF9>A43>EGBB>;7D8AD
EGBB>KA8F:7B3DFE
-:;>7 GE;@9 & I7 :3H7 FA 5:75= F:7 5A@E;EF7@5K A8 F:7 ?3FD;J 4GF I7 3D7 GE;@9 :K4D;6
F75:@;CG7 GE;@9 #)# 3@6 & ;@ I:;5: I7 3D7 @AF GE;@9 F:7 B3;D I;E7 5A?B3D;EA@ A8 F:7 5D;F7D;3
7>7?7@FEFA53>5G>3F7F:7BD;AD;FKI7;9:FE@EF736I73D7GE;@9F:7#)#F75:@;CG7EAI7@776@AF:3H7
FA5:75=F:75A@E;EF7@5KA8F:7?3FD;J
*34>7 )G??3DK5A?4;@3F;A@A8F:7BD;AD;FKI7;9:FEB7D8AD?3@575D;F7D;3A8F:7AH7D3>>A4<75F;H7
I;F:F:73>F7D@3F;H7E;7
)GBB>;7DE
A8 A@57BFG3>
*75:@A>A9;53>
#3@G835FGD;@
?3@G835FGD;@
@H;DA@?7@F
#3@397?7@F
9:3>>7@97E
&DA6G5F;H;FK
,3'1.#3+5'
BB>;53F;A@
3B34;>;FK
7>;H7DK
01+/1+37
6'+)*32
)7DH;57
'G3>;FK
(#
AEFE
-7;9:FE

)GBB>;7DE
2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

/3#,
$AI8DA?F:734AH7F34>73@643D9D3B:;@8;9GD7 I753@5>73D>K8;@6F:3F)GBB>;7DE

3D7F:747EFEGBB>;7DE8ADF:7?7@F;A@76E57@3D;A
;9 )GBB>;7DED3F;@9

-7:3H7F3=7@F:78AGD?AEF;?BADF3@F5D;F7D;38DA?F:7EGBB>;7DE7>75F;A@BA;@FA8H;7II:;5:
I7 9AF 8DA? F:7 #)# F75:@;CG7 3@6 F:7 8;H7 47EF EGBB>;7DE I:;5: I7 9AF 8DA? F:7 & FA 53DDK F:7
E7@E;F;H;FK3@3>KE;EFA8;@6AGFF:7?AEF5D;F;53>5D;F7D;33@6F:7?AEF5D;F;53>3>F7D@3F;H7;7EGBB>;7D*:7
8AGD5D;F7D;33D7'G3>;FK7>;H7DKAEF3@6&DA6G5F;H;FK3@6F:7EGBB>;7DE3D7))
)
)3@6)

@ F:7 5GDD7@F E57@3D;A A8 9>A43> AB7D3F;@9 5A@6;F;A@E 3@6 5A?B7F;F;H7 7@H;DA@?7@F ;F :3E
475A?7:;9:>K@757EE3DK8ADAD93@;L3F;A@EFAE7>75FF:747EFEGBB>;7D@K;@355GD3F7E7>75F;A@A8 EGBB>;7D
I;>> >736 FA @G?7DAGE BDA4>7?E I:;5: 38875F F:7 5A?B3@KVE AH7D3>> B7D8AD?3@57 *:;E E:AIE F:3F
EGBB>;7D E7>75F;A@ BDA576GD7 ;E 3 :;9:>K 7EE7@F;3> 5A@57D@ 8AD 5A?B3@;7E *:7 E7>75F;A@ A8 F:7 D;9:F
EGBB>;7D8DA?F:79DAI;@9@G?47DA83>F7D@3F;H7E;@F:7?3D=7F;E5A?B>;53F76>AFA8EGBB>;7DE7>75F;A@
?A67>E3D73H3;>34>7;@F:7>;F7D3FGD7;@F:;EEFG6K3E6;E5GEE76;@F:773D>;7D5:3BF7DEF:;EBDA<75F;E3@
3FF7?BFFA3DD;H73F3@;@F79D3F76?7F:A68ADEGBB>;7DE7>75F;A@GE;@9#)#3@6&?7F:A6-7:3H7
?A6;8;76 F:7 AD;9;@3> )# F75:@;CG7 4K 366;@9 FIA ?AD7 5A@EFD3;@FE ;@ F:7 )FDG5FGD3> )7>8 @F7D35F;A@
#3FD;J I:;5: I;>>5>73D>K6;E5D;?;@3F73?A@9F:7 835FADE3@6F:7;D;@F7D35F;A@E I:;5: I;>>9;H75>73D7D
;673 34AGF I:;5: 835FADE 3D7 F:7 6D;H;@9 835FADE 3@6 I:;5: 3D7 F:7 67B7@676 835FADE *:GE I7 53@
BD;AD;F;L7F:7?3EI7>>3ED3@=F:7?78875F;H7>K@6I;>>:7>BGEFA9;H7I7;9:FEFAF:75D;F7D;3I:;5:;@
FGD@ I;>> :7>B FA D3@= F:7 EGBB>;7DE 78875F;H7>K *:;E EFG6K 8A5GE7E A@ F:7 B7D8AD?3@57 835FADE F:3F
;@8>G7@57 EGBB>;7D E7>75F;A@ 3@6 F:7 ?A67> :3E 477@ 4G;>F 43E76 A@ F:AE7 835FADE 3@6 F:7@ )7@E;F;H;FK
@3>KE;E ;E 6A@7 FA 8;@6 AGF :AI E7@E;F;H7 F:7E7 835FADE 3@6 F:7 EGBB>;7DE 3D7 FA F:7 5:3@97 ;@ AF:7D
835FADE
*:;E ?7F:A6 ;E 3BB>;76 FA 3@ 3GFA?AF;H7 5A?BA@7@FE ?3@G835FGD;@9 ;@6GEFDK 3@6 3 B3DF;5G>3D
5A?BA@7@F:3E
EGBB>;7DE'G3>;8;53F;A@3@68;@3>E7>75F;A@A8F:7EGBB>;7D;E6A@743E76A@F:75D;F7D;3
675;6764KF:77JB7DFE#A6;8;76)#F75:@;CG7;EGE76FA8;@6F:7;@F7DD7>3F;A@E:;B 47FI77@F:75D;F7D;3
3@6I7;9:FE8ADF:7735:5D;F7D;A@-;F:F:7:7>BA8F:7EGBB>;7DI7;9:FEI:;5:I7:3H75A>>75F768DA?F:7
;@6GEFDK3@65D;F7D;3I7;9:FE8DA?#)#&;EGE768ADA4F3;@;@9F:7I7;9:FE8ADF:7735:EGBB>;7D8AD
F:7 735: B7D8AD?3@57 ?73EGD7 3@6 A4F3;@;@9 ABF;?3> EA>GF;A@E 8DA?
EGBB>;7DE @3?7>K ) )

)
))

*:7 :K4D;6 F75:@;CG7 A8 #A6;8;76 @F7DBD7F;H7 )FDG5FGD3> #A67>>;@9 3@6 @3>KF;53> ;7D3D5:K
&DA57EE I;F: )7@E;F;H;FK @3>KE;E 9;H7E F:7 ?AD7 BD35F;53> D7EG>FE F:3@ F:7 FD36;F;A@3> F75:@;CG7E *:7
;@F7D35F;A@I;F:F:7;@6GEFDK7JB7DFE?3=7EF:;E?A67>?AD7873E;4>73@6BD35F;53>>EAF:7?A6;8;76)#
F75:@;CG7 9;H7E ?AD7 BD35F;53> D7EG>FE 3@6 5>73D7D ;673 34AGF F:7 ;@F7DD7>3F;A@E:;B A8 F:7 B7D8AD?3@57
835FADE*:7?A67>:3E477@IAD=76AGF8ADF:73GFA?AF;H7;@6GEFDK;@EAGF:7D@B3DFA8@6;33@6D7EG>FE
I7D7;?B>7?7@F76;@F:7;@6GEFDK

12 ?;6):A6EKBAGD%VD;7@
I7;9:F76?3JT?;@?A67>8AD8GLLK?G>F;A4<75F;H7
EGBB>;7DE7>75F;A@;@3EGBB>K5:3;@@F &DA6G5F;A@5A@A?;5E
T
12 >7EE;A E:;L3=3 E:D38 "34;4
(7H;7I A8 F:7 ?3;@ 67H7>AB?7@FE ;@ F:7 3@3>KF;5 :;7D3D5:K
BDA57EEJB7DF)KEF7?EI;F:BB>;53F;A@E
T
1 2 @<3>; I3EF:; )3FK3H77D):3G:3@ )!AK3>

8GLLK ?G>F;5D;F7D;3 3BBDA35: 8AD
7H3>G3F;@97@H;DA@?7@F3>B7D8AD?3@57A8EGBB>;7DE@F &DA6G5F;A@5A@A?;5E

T
12 E:GFAE:)3D=3D&D3F3B! #A:3B3FD3
H3>G3F;A@A8EGBB>;7D53B34;>;FK3@6B7D8AD?3@57
?7F:A68ADEGBB>K43E7D76G5F;A@ AGD@3>A8&GD5:3E;@9)GBB>K#3@397?7@F
T
12 3DA> &D3:;@E=; - 7@FA@
)GBB>;7D 7H3>G3F;A@E 5A??G@;53F;A@ EFD3F79;7E FA ;?BDAH7

EGBB>;7DB7D8AD?3@57 AGD@3> A8%B7D3F;A@E#3@397?7@F
T
12 :7@/ /G!):3:43L3@6.7H;
)3E76)7@E;F;H;FK@3>KE;EA8#G>F;D;F7D;3
-7;9:FEF:-AD>6#) #%)#A@9D7EE3;D@EGEFD3>;3 G>K

12 :7-7;:3@93:7@9(G-G4:;@*E3;";@5G3@9:G:7@
@3BB>;53F;A@A8
&3@6E7@E;F;H;FK3@3>KE;E8ADE7>75F;@9F:747EFE>;5;@9?35:;@7A?BGF7DE@6GEFD;3>@9;@77D;@9

T

12 7E:7@9 3E: -G /;6A@9 0:3@9 7J;3@9 -G 3H;6 " %>EA@

GLLK ?G>F;A4<75F;H7
BDA9D3??;@9 8AD EGBB>;7D E7>75F;A@ 3@6 D;E= ?A67>;@9 BAEE;4;>;FK 3BBDA35: GDAB73@ AGD@3> A8
%B7D3F;A@3>(7E73D5:

T
12 H3@97>AE *D;3@F3B:K>>AG >8A@EA )P@5:7L E7@E;F;H;FK 3@3>KE;E 3BBDA35: 8AD EA?7 67F7D?;@;EF;5
?G>F;5D;F7D;3675;E;A@?3=;@9?7F:A6E75;E;A@)5;7@57E,A>$ABB-;@F7D
1
2 7>;J *) :3@ $;D3< !G?3D
>A43> EGBB>;7D 67H7>AB?7@F 5A@E;67D;@9 D;E= 835FADE GE;@9

8GLLK7JF7@676&43E763BBDA35:%?793
T
12 !3@@3@ @6 $AADG>3C
@3>KE;EA8;@F7D35F;A@EA85D;F7D;33@6EG45D;F7D;38ADF:7
E7>75F;A@A8EGBB>;7D;@F:74G;>F;@AD67DEGBB>K5:3;@7@H;DA@?7@F@F7D@3F;A@3> AGD@3>A8&DA6G5F;A@
(7E73D5:,A>$A )7BF7?47D
T
12 36; ):;DAGK7:L36 3?;6D7L3 &3@<7:8AG>3693D3@ (7L3 347EF3@; #AEF383 363=:E:;3@

,7@6AD &7D8AD?3@57 #73EGD7?7@F +E;@9 GLLK "A9;5 A@FDA>>7D *:7 AGD@3> A8 #3F:7?3F;5E 3@6
A?BGF7D)5;7@57,A>$A

1 2 G3@ K: ):KGD3 EG):;: ):;:
:K4D;6 ## ?A67> 8AD EFD3F79;5 H7@6AD E7>75F;A@

#3F:7?3F;53>3@6A?BGF7D#A67>>;@9
T
12 ;3@@";3@9/3@9G3@$7@9:;GIAE:;G@9*L7@9(G7KG7;/7:
,7@6ADE7>75F;A@
4K ;@F79D3F768GLLK##F75:@;CG7E I;F:;@67B7@67@F3@6;@F7D67B7@67@F@8AD?3F;A@)5;7@57E

T
12 #);@9:(!3@F
!@AI>7697?3@397?7@F43DD;7DE@;@F7DBD7F;H7EFDG5FGD3>?A67>>;@9
3BBDA35:@F7D@3F;A@3> AGD@3>A8#3@397?7@F)5;7@573@6@9;@77D;@9#3@397?7@F,A>
$A
BB
12 # &G@@;K3?AADF:K & #3F:;K3>393@ & &3DF:;43@

EFD3F79;5 ?A67> GE;@9 EFDG5FGD3>
7CG3F;A@ ?A67>;@9 3@6 8GLLK >A9;5 ;@ EGBB>;7D E7>75F;A@ JB7DF )KEF7?E I;F: BB>;53F;A@E

T
12 (3<3F :39I3F #;>;@6 !G?3D ):3D?3
&7D8AD?3@57 ?73EGD7?7@F A8 EGBB>K 5:3;@

?3@397?7@F43>3@576E5AD753D63BBDA35:A?BGF7DE@6GEFD;3>@9;@77D;@9
T
12 (;5=ADH7FF)#(#(#&:$;@9I7;";G&:
@F7DBD7F;H7)FDG5FGD3>
#A67>;@9A8@F7D35F;H7(;E=E@F7DBD;E7(;E=#3@397?7@F)K?BAE;G?:;539A"
12 )35:;@#A6;,;@57@F#347DF
)GBB>;7D67H7>AB?7@F?BDAH;@9EGBB>;7DB7D8AD?3@57
F:DAG9:=@AI>7697FD3@E87D AGD@3>A8%B7D3F;A@E#3@397?7@F
T
1
2 )3?G7> G3@9 3DE:3> !7E=3D
A?BD7:7@E;H7 3@6 5A@8;9GD34>7 ?7FD;5E 8AD EGBB>;7D

E7>75F;A@@F &DA6G5F;A@5A@A?;5E

T

#G F D F7D 3 75 e A@#3 @9 Bbda35:8ad) GBB 7de) 7 75F A@: @F7D@3F A@3 A@87d7@57a@#a67 @9 ? L3F A@3@6a?bgf @9#%

Transféré par

Informations du document

Titre original

Copyright

Formats disponibles

Partager ce document

Partager ou intégrer le document

Options de partage

Avez-vous trouvé ce document utile ?

Ce contenu est-il inapproprié ?

Droits d'auteur :

Formats disponibles

#G F D F7D 3 75 e A@#3 @9 Bbda35:8ad) GBB 7de) 7 75F A@: @F7D@3F A@3 A@87d7@57a@#a67 @9 ? L3F A@3@6a?bgf @9#%

Transféré par

Droits d'auteur :

Formats disponibles

Available online at www.sciencedirect.

Procedia Engineering 38 (2012) 2312 – 2328