Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Volume 1 Issue 1
Abstract
Introduction: Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) is the most important lifesaving
technique in several emergency situations such as cardiac arrest. In future, being part of
health care professionals, pharmacy students are deemed to possess basic skills and expertise
which are required to perform CPR. Objective: To access the knowledge of cardiopulmonary
among pharmacy students of Mirpur Azad Jammu & Kashmir. Methods: It was a
questionnaire-based, descriptive cross-sectional study, conducted among 4th and 5th year
students of two Pharmacy institutes of Mirpur AJ&K from November 2018 to January 2019.
A pre-tested questionnaire from previous study was used to collect data. It comprised of 13
dichotomous questions with “Yes/No” options, regarding knowledge of CPR. Descriptive
statistics was used to unfold the demographic characteristics. Inferential statistics (Kruskal
Wallis and Man Whitney) tests were used for evaluating difference between dependent
continuous variables and independent variables and Chi-square was applied to determine
difference between grouped variables. P-value of less than 0.05 is considered significant. The
data was analyzed using SPSS version 20. Result: Overall, 131 out of 150(response rate=
92%) students participated in current study. Gender distribution among the participants was
almost equal with 66 males (50.4%) males and 65 (49.6%) females took part in current study.
Participants of the age group 21-23 years (n=88, 67.2%) were dominant. Only few students
(n=23, 17.6%) reported to have taken training in CPR previously. Eighty-eight (66.7%) had
average knowledge of CPR. No significant differences among male and female, 4th and 5th
year students of both the institutes were found. Conclusion: The study revealed that
knowledge level of CPR is adequate in most of the students of pharmacy. However, further
improvements are required to perform CPR in an efficient manner. Thus, training in CPR
should be mandatory in the pharmacy curriculum.
CPR techniques have been upgrading, that Several reasons that account for the
now it has been referred to be basic life pharmacy students to acquire CPR training
support (BLS) which also have other include participation in advanced training
techniques but can be interchangeably used opportunities in the immunization practice,
with CPR. To normalize blood circulation complying experimental site requirements,
in brain and vital organs, chest and participation in professional CPR
compressions and mouth to mouth learning opportunities that may include
ventilation are given to regain respiration. Advanced Cardiac Life Support (ACLS).
Respiratory and cardiac arrest situations Nevertheless, the majority of pharmacy
can rise in any age in adults or neonates [4]. colleges obtain CPR training from some
other entity [5]. Pharmacist is an essential
In the latest guidelines quality of CPR is part of the healthcare profession.
highlighted. Correct chest compressions, Therefore, it is essential for the pharmacy
rate, depth and minimal pauses in students to have sufficient knowledge
compression are the main elements of regarding CPR. A very little data is
CPR. Pauses are important in chest available in Pakistan regarding CPR
compression as interruptions lead to worst among medical professionals including
outcomes resulting in decreased coronary doctors, students & paramedical staff.
perfusion. Depth of compression is often Moreover, the awareness of this life-
too shallow. Better perfusion is correlated sustaining technique should be confined
to better survival. In clinical settings only to the medical personnel but also
quality of CPR performed by professionals should be given to the general population
is poor, although it improves definitive [6]. Literature suggests, very little research
survival rate. Rate of compression is not has been performed regarding CPR among
optimal during CPR however, higher rate pharmacy students.
is associated with improved hemodynamic
and primary survival [1]. The main objective of this study is to
access the knowledge of CPR among the
Regardless of any health care provider, pharmacy students. In addition to that, it is
any person can learn skills of CPR, now expected to emphasize the replenishment
available in modified simple forms. This of knowledge on CPR among the
life saving treatment is immediately pharmacy students with modern changes in
initiated in hospitals by the skilled staff CPR guidelines.
members. Approximately 2 per 1000
admissions in a report of cardiac arrest METHODOLOGY
receiving CPR by the trained staff in the Study Design
hospital resulted in more improvement in It was a questionnaire-based, descriptive
the cardiac arrest. In developing countries cross-sectional study.
outcomes of such incidences are rarely
reported unfortunately. According to world Study Population and Settings
recommendations, at least every 2 years Fourth and fifth-year students of two
CPR course should be revised by the pharmacy institutes namely Akson College
health care providers [2]. of Pharmacy, Mirpur University of
Science & Technology, Mirpur AJ&K and
For all health care professionals, CPR Mohi-ul-din Islamic Institute of
training has been recommended. Since, the Pharmaceutical Sciences, Mirpur AJ&K.
establishment of CPR guidelines about 40
years ago, most of the pharmacy institutes Duration of Study
had CPR certification of the Pharm-D The present study had been conducted
students during study of their curriculum. from November 2018 to January 2019.
Table 2 represents the basic knowledge about the location of chest compression
among population about CPR. A large while only half of the participants were
number (n=125, 94%) of pharmacy students successful in answering about the rate and
considered that they knew about CPR but depth of chest compression in a correct
only 81(61.8%) students correctly answered manner. Most of the pharmacy
questions about the correct concept of CPR. undergraduates (71.8%) reported to have
Majority of the students knew about basic received information about basic CPR.
life support while only 89 (67.9%) students Therefore, majority (n=107, 81.7%) of the
were able to identify the conditions where students were willing to check breathing
there is a need to perform CPR. Three responsiveness in an unconscious person and
questions were addressed regarding chest most of the students (n=86, 65.6%) agreed to
compressions such as location, depth and check blood circulation in early critical
rate of compressions and 77% of minute after cardiac and respiratory arrest.
respondents reported to know correctly
Table 3 shows the comparison between difference in the awareness of CPR among
demographic variables and overall the students of Akson College of Pharmacy
knowledge level about CPR. Comparative and Mohi-u-Din Islamic Medical College.
analysis using Chi-square test shows that However, a significant difference was
there are no statistically significant obtained in the CPR knowledge of the
differences between males and females, students who had taken former training in
students of different age groups or 4th and CPR and the students who had not taken any
final year students about the CPR training in CPR which is evident by the p-
knowledge. There was also no significant value of 0.002 (<0.05).
Table 4 presents the descriptive results been involved in former CPR training. In
(frequency, mean, standard deviation). P- the study performed by Hassan Zaheer et
value shows that there was no significant al in Karachi, a large proportion of
difference in terms of gender, age and year participants (79%) insisted the inclusion of
of study except between the students of BLS (CPR) training in the undergraduate
both institutes and training in CPR with p- curriculum [4]. Effect of training in CPR
value 0.002. Students of Akson College of on the knowledge level of sample is also
Pharmacy were found to have higher supported by another research in which
knowledge. basic elementary questions about BLS
(CPR) were responded correctly by most
DISCUSSION of the participants (70%). This was
The present study population showed a because of the fact that participants were
mean knowledge score of 9.08 and practically familiar with BLS. It has
majority had average knowledge score already been recommended in the
which is almost equal to the knowledge of developing countries to provide training in
medical students reported in a study [8]. CPR to the students of high schools about
Dr. Abdul Rehman et al performed a study 10 years ago [14]. However, in Pakistan,
and revealed that 60-69%pharmacists’ no such initiative has been taken even for
knowledge was adequate [9]. Meena medical and pharmacy students. Need for
Kumari et al reported >47% of the training and refresher courses for all
population to have excellent grades [10]. healthcare professionals are also confirmed
In another study the knowledge and by the study performed on cardiologists
experience regarding CPR were less than [6]. A recent study in Pakistan performed
score of 50% in medical and dental by Abbas et al compared knowledge level
intern’s students, despite that all of them among trained and untrained medical
were aware of its importance [11]. In a students in first aid. Correct responses of
study, knowledge score was found to be untrained students were significantly less
less among medical and nursing interns than trained ones regarding CPR, recovery
however it was statistically non- position, asthma and bleeding [15].
significant. Medical students of Pakistan Another study draws attention towards the
and Switzerland have been reported to lack permanent training programs on BLS and
adequate knowledge of CPR 12]. This ALS because the two fundamental
study showed that the mean knowledge elements that determine the success rate of
score was 9.08 and majority of the cardiopulmonary resuscitation are
students scored between 40% and 80% knowledge and practical skills. Other
indicating the adequate knowledge level closed studies confirmed this too [2, 16,
among the pharmacy students about CPR. 17].
and breathing of victims was about 80%. pharmacy students stated to have correct
And the nearly identical results were knowledge about the chest compressions
obtained in the present study (60-80%). A in CPR compared with 39% in a
small proportion of students (32%) of the Malaysian study [17]. A comparable
previous study were willing to sustain percentage of correct answers about the
breathing of victim by giving mouth to chest compressions was found in another
mouth CPR. On the contrary, number of study and about one third of the population
students were almost twice in the present answered correctly about the location of
study (61%) [19]. chest compressions [13]. Likewise, 25% of
healthcare providers in a study responded
In comparison with another study positively about the chest compression [2].
performed on dentists to check the On the contrary, about three fourth of the
knowledge level of CPR it was found that population correctly answered the
there was no significant difference questions about the chest compressions
between the response rate regarding [20]. When the results of present study
correct concept of CPR among the were compared with an old study, a similar
populations of both the studies. In that number of students gave incorrect answers
study about 75.9% participants had about BLS. But opposing results were
received information about basics of CPR obtained related to location and depth of
and similar percentage (71%) was found in chest compression[9]. Compared to the
this study. Participants of both the studies sample responses of questions about
reported to have received training in CPR location (93%) and depth (93%) of chest
at the percentage of 17% and 12% [7]. compression in a study by Mittal R.
68% of the healthcare providers in a study Savaliya, response rate in present study
stated to have prior knowledge on CPR was nearly equal 77% for location while
[2]. lower (50%) for depth of chest
compression [21].
Knowledge score of the students of both
institutes was found to be almost equal. About 74% of the population of current
According to a previous study, CPR study would make an attempt to sustain
knowledge was found to be inadequate life in early critical minutes after cardiac
among medical students inhabiting and respiratory shock which is two folds
Switzerland and Pakistan [12]. There were higher than medical students (32%)
no concrete differences in the knowledge involved in a study [22].
level and frequency of male and female
population which is similar to the results There was no statistically significant
of study performed by Javaid Arif Khan difference (P-value=0.369) between final
and Zafar Haleem Baloch on cardiologists year students and 4th year students in the
in Pakistan. (P-value>0.05) [6]. present study which is opposed by a study
Insignificant effect of male and female conducted in which final year students had
population on knowledge of CPR is also better knowledge than 4th year
supported by another study [8]. In a study, undergraduates [8].
gender differences pointed out that females
had slightly lower awareness about BLS According to a former study, age of the
which was attributed to the differences in person may affect knowledge level which
between pulmonary capacities of females is shown in the results where students of
and males. age group 24-29 had adequate knowledge
and so in the present study. This is
Comparing the present data with the probably due to more exposure and
literature, it was observed that 48% of the experience. However, there is no