Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
www.jtln.org
KEYWORDS: Abstract
Large group simulation; A growing disconnect exists between what students learn in the classroom and how they use nursing
Unfolding case studies; concepts to provide safe and effective care in a clinical setting. The purpose of this article is to share a
Low-fidelity simulation; large group simulation teaching and learning strategy that combines unfolding case studies, low-fidelity
PowerPoint®; simulation, and PowerPoint® to facilitate active learning and the integration of classroom and clinical
Active learning; learning in an associate degree nursing program.
Teaching and © 2015 Organization for Associate Degree Nursing. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
learning strategy
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.teln.2016.01.002
1557-3087/© 2015 Organization for Associate Degree Nursing. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
2 S.M. Moyer
Despite the evidence that students learn better when they are as a valid teaching and learning strategy. Simulation
engaged in the learning process, nursing education continues to experiences can be low-fidelity to high-fidelity based on the
focus on content where faculty rely on traditional lecture and technology involved and degree they match reality (Cant &
PowerPoint® methods to implement content-loaded, time- Cooper, 2010). Literature reveals that simulation has a positive
constrained curricula (Day, 2011; Della Ratta, 2015). This impact on student learning and assists students to integrate
results in passive student learning, and students have few, if any, classroom theory and clinical application (Lasater, Johnson,
classroom opportunities to practice applying nursing concepts Ravert, & Rink, 2014; Yuan, Williams, & Fang, 2012).
learned to situations they will encounter in clinical practice. Simulation provides real-life interactive experiences, al-
though, it can be time intensive and expensive to implement and
utilize in nursing programs. Barriers to simulation include cost,
3. Background faculty and facility resources, and fear of technology (Howard,
Ross, Mitchell, & Nelson, 2010; Kisner & Johnson-Anderson,
A review of student course evaluations from a small urban 2010); however, not all simulation modalities require the same
community college nursing program revealed student requests resources. Low-fidelity simulation is an example of a
for increased interactive classroom learning experiences to cost-effective, low-resource type of simulation that can be
practice the application of nursing knowledge in simulated effective in promoting student learning (Sharpnack & Madigan,
clinical situations. In an effort to meet the needs of the students 2012). This simulation modality uses common, inexpensive
in the nursing program and incorporate recommendations from static mannequins. It lacks the interactive capability found in
the Carnegie report (Benner et al., 2010), I developed and high-fidelity human patient simulators; yet, this modality does
implemented a large group classroom simulation active provide students with opportunities to practice skills and
learning strategy to teach freshman nursing students in an transfer learning to practice (Lasater et al., 2014; Sharpnack &
associate degree nursing program. The strategy is practical and Madigan, 2012; Yuan et al., 2012). The literature reveals that
combines common teaching and learning modalities: unfolding students are satisfied learning from simulation that involves any
case studies, low-fidelity simulation, and PowerPoint®. degree of fidelity (Tosterud, Hedelin, & Hall-Lord, 2013)
Various studies have detailed the effectiveness of the use of which that supports the use of low-fidelity simulation in nursing
these strategies independently or paired; however, information programs where resources may be limited.
regarding the concurrent use of all three of these methods to
organize a large group simulation is not evident in the literature. 4.3. PowerPoint®
PowerPoint® is an example of presentation software that
4. Teaching and Learning Strategies uses projected slides to present visual and auditory content.
Students evaluate the use of PowerPoint® positively, and
4.1. Unfolding Case Studies research suggests that this technology increases attention
span and interest; engages listening, thinking, and participa-
The use of unfolding case studies is a popular interactive tion; promotes learning; and enhances comprehension of
teaching and learning strategy. Unfolding case studies course material (Hill, Arford, Lubitow, & Smollin, 2012).
present a clinical scenario of a patient whose condition or The literature cites many benefits of using PowerPoint®;
disposition changes over time. Utilization of this strategy yet, educators continue to be challenged to use this
assists students to develop critical thinking and problem- technology in ways that stimulate students to respond and
solving skills because data on the patient is limited and participate actively in classroom learning. By incorporating
revealed only as the case unfolds (Day, 2011; Reese, 2011; PowerPoint® with alternative active learning strategies,
Shellenbarger & Robb, 2015). This provides a sense of educators use this technology most efficiently to improve
unpredictability and challenges students to use learned classroom learning experiences (Hill et al., 2012).
classroom theory to prioritize care and make decisions The use of unfolding case studies, low-fidelity simulation,
based on limited patient information, similar to the reality of and PowerPoint® as instructional strategies is not new; yet,
actual nursing practice (Shellenbarger & Robb, 2015). combining these modalities increases student engagement and
Unfolding case studies are flexible and can be individualized provides opportunities for teaching to a variety of learning
to highlight specific concepts or areas of nursing, and they can styles. Combining strategies encourages active learning in the
be designed to accommodate large groups of students within classroom and is one way to assist large groups of students in
various types and levels of nursing courses (Day, 2011). connecting learned nursing concepts to clinical application.
degree nursing students. This combined teaching strategy the case study (Table 1). I focused the group roles on aspects
was used in a freshman nursing course where the course of key nursing concepts, and I planned to discuss each role
objectives focused on fundamental nursing concepts and with the class prior to beginning the case study.
skills. This course consisted of 49 first semester freshman In addition to using group work to unfold the case, I also
nursing students who were completing long-term care utilized a low-fidelity mannequin and PowerPoint® to
clinical rotations. Upon admission to this course, students supplement various aspects of the case study. I incorporated
were required to complete general education courses these instructional strategies to assist in simulating a more
including anatomy and physiology. realistic clinical scenario and to capture diverse learning
I used a template by Page, Kowlowitz, and Alden (2010) styles. The mannequin was designed to resemble the acute
to develop the unfolding case studies, which started with care patient in the case study and was present on a litter in the
topic selection. I chose to focus the unfolding case study on front of the classroom. This enabled students to connect the
the care of an acute care patient because students were patient in the case study to the mannequin in the classroom and
preparing to begin acute care clinical and many of them were provided students with an opportunity to perform assessments
inexperienced in caring for hospitalized patients. and skills required in the case study. Laboratory faculty
Next, I identified learning objectives and determined key assisted in outfitting the mannequin in necessary equipment
nursing concepts that would be incorporated into the case and provided additional supplies required in the case such as a
study (Page et al., 2010). Learning objectives for the case stocked medication cart and nasal cannula. I created a patient
focused on the use of active learning strategies to facilitate chart using templates from the National League for Nursing
the care and management of an acute care patient. The key Web site (ACES, n.d.), and this chart was distributed to all
concepts focused on fundamental nursing knowledge and student groups. It contained pertinent health care provider
skills such as application of the nursing process, communi- (HCP) notes, orders, medical and surgical history, laboratory
cation, and documentation. and diagnostic results, and a medication record.
When I began outline development, I remained cognizant I incorporated PowerPoint® into the unfolding case study
of the time frame for case study implementation (Page et al., to assist in providing visual and auditory aspects of the
2010). I had 2 hours to complete the strategy, which included scenario. I designed the slides to display Internet images of
precase study instructions and group work, implementation an elderly patient that were embedded with prerecorded,
of the unfolding case study, and postcase study debriefing. self-made audio clips. The audio clips included the patient
I created the story and characters utilizing a combination of talking or making requests, of family members who were
unfolding case study templates from the National League for concerned about their loved one, and of nursing staff
Nursing Web site (“Advancing Care Excellence for Seniors providing shift reports. I forwarded the slides and cued the
(ACES),” n.d.), Internet resources, and past clinical experiences audio to play at specified times throughout the case study.
for the development of the story (Page et al., 2010). Characters The addition of audio provided students with the opportunity
present in the case study included an elderly patient, a family to hear the case study unfold and also required students to
member, and registered nursing staff. I selected these characters pay attention and listen for details throughout the scenario.
because the students were completing long-term care clinical After the case study was written and the group roles were
rotations and were most familiar with the care of elderly clients. prepared, I developed an instructor guide to accompany the
In addition, the interaction with a patient and a family member unfolding case study. The instructor guide included audio scripts,
required utilization of learned therapeutic communication skills. assessment results, and prompts for advancing slides, presenting
I began writing the case to depict an acute care patient new orders, and facilitating group participation. It also included
experiencing a change in condition. I designed the case study reminders to highlight key points and priority concerns throughout
to represent a newly admitted elderly patient who came from the case study. I used this guide to assist me in keeping the case
home after experiencing confusion and a fall. As the case study on track and moving forward methodically. An example of
unfolds, the patient becomes more confused and experiences part of the instructor guide is displayed in Table 2.
respiratory issues. Students need to think critically and apply Lastly, I reviewed the unfolding case study to ensure that it was
nursing process skills, prioritize, and communicate effectively complete, logical, realistic, and included the necessary informa-
to implement a plan that will improve the patient outcomes. tion needed to make clinical decisions (Page et al., 2010). I
A variation to this teaching and learning strategy, as reexamined the case study to be sure that it included relevant
compared to other modalities, is that I divided the class into clinical and contextual information, that activities to meet the
student groups who were each responsible for different learning objectives were available, and that the level of content
aspects of the case study. This created a large group was appropriate for the freshman students (Page et al., 2010).
simulation experience that encouraged synchronous active
learning among all students in the class and enabled the case
study to unfold as each student group performed or discussed 6. Case Implementation
their assigned parts. To accomplish this, I wrote the case
study from start to finish and then developed group roles and I implemented this large group simulation experience
activities that were performed at varying points throughout with a freshman nursing class (N = 49). I determined the
4 S.M. Moyer
Table 1 Group roles and associated activities for each role within the unfolding case study
Group role Associated group activities
1. Observer group • “Taking it all in”: Observing peer activities
• Assisting in critical thinking as needed
• Providing peer review and reflection at conclusion of case
2. Assessment group • Complete organized head to toe assessments. Review orders to determine frequency of assessments
• Perform actual skills on patient/mannequin. Use the preparation time to familiarize group with the
mannequin and equipment
• Use cue cards to report assessment findings
• Use therapeutic communication with patient and family
• Act on all new orders received
3. Lab analysis group • Analyze available laboratory studies. Prepare to explain analysis of abnormal studies to peers
• Consider how the laboratories correlate with the HCP orders
4. Medication group • Research all medications and consider correlations between medical history, present illness, and
laboratory studies.
• Prepare to administer medications at assigned times. Review safe medication administration.
• Review intravenous infusion rate calculations.
5. Nursing diagnosis group • Review the definition, defining characteristics, etiology, and interventions for the following diagnostic
labels. You will share applicable nursing diagnoses as needed throughout case study
○ Risk for falls
○ Acute confusion
○ Ineffective breathing pattern
○ Impaired gas exchange
○ Impaired urinary elimination
○ Nutrition: less than body requirements
6. Safety and client • Consider interventions for confused patients at risk for falls
education group • Review hospital safety measures
• Review the following client education topics:
○ Pain medicine and antibiotic use
○ Pneumonia
○ Hypertension
○ Influenza vaccination
7. Documentation group • Draw flowsheets on board: Need nursing assessments, vital signs, intake and output record
• Chart all assessments, vital signs, and intake and output on white board throughout case study
8. Reporting group • Review SBAR reporting.
• Record activities throughout the case study so that you are prepared to contact the HCP as needed in the
case
• Review shift reporting. Be prepared to share an end of shift report at the conclusion of the case study.
group role sizes based on enrolled students and the amount of PowerPoint® slides embedded with self-recorded audio of
preparation required in each role. Students were randomly the patient, staff, or family talking, which I cued to play at
assigned to one of the eight groups, and each group consisted varying times throughout the scenario. The slides pictured
of approximately five to seven students. the patient in 2-hour increments throughout the 0700–1900
I described the simulation experience and provided an day shift and also included other visual elements like a lunch
overview of the case study to the class (Table 3). All groups tray that assessed accuracy of intake measurement. The case
also received a patient chart and an index card that explained study unfolded depicting a decompensating patient
the roles and activities for each group as described in Table 2. experiencing respiratory distress. Student groups had to
Students had 20–30 minutes to prepare their respective parts, perform assessments, analyze data, communicate with the
and I provided each group individualized instruction to aid in HCP, initiate new orders, and prioritize care. I forwarded the
their role preparation. Students were encouraged to observe slides and prompted various groups to either perform skills
and assess the mannequin and use textbooks and group or share information on the area they were assigned when it
collaboration to prepare parts. was relevant in the scenario. As the case unfolded, I assisted
Once the group preparation was complete, I began the students to perform ongoing analysis of assessment data and
unfolding case study. Generally, the case study consisted of to think critically about how to connect nursing knowledge to
LARGE GROUP SIMULATION 5
Table 2 Example of part of the instructor guide for the large group simulation experience
0800 Morning report completed; assessment group comes to front of class and prepares to care for mannequin/patient on litter
(FORWARD SLIDE): Slide pictures an elderly patient sitting in a hospital bed
Upon entering room, students should do the following:
• Wash hands, ID self and patient (play slide audio after students ID him)
• Audio Script: “Hi there, my name is J. Kirk and my date of birth is Sept. 24, 1938.
My daughter dropped me off here and I am not sure where I am…at the clinic or something?
Is it 2013? I feel okay but my daughter said I only ate a quarter of my breakfast.
She had to go to work or something. I think I need my pills…
I don’t know what they are but you can ask my daughter to look for them on the kitchen counter.
Where is Deena anyway? She never comes to see me.”
Assessment group should reveal:
• Assessment findings: All normal except client confused and lungs decreased bilaterally,
not taking deep breaths; has not voided since 0400
• Vital signs: 99°F-92-18-162/88; 96% on room air
Documentation group should do the following:
• Ask class: Any initial concerns about intake? Any concerns about assessment data?
• Students should also want to review medications and laboratory results.
Laboratory analysis group presents:
• Explains abnormal results and correlation of results to medications and patient data
Medication group participates:
• Reviews 0800 medications at cart and provides explanations as to why the patient is receiving the medications.
• Reviews current health provider orders
• Facilitator may also question if any medications are missing.
• Group proceeds to administer medications
Diagnosis group participates:
• Provides class with relevant nursing diagnoses based on current data and explains why these diagnoses are pertinent.
• Facilitator assists class in initial care plan development
Table 3 Overview of unfolding case study provided to students education were not emphasized to the same degree as other
Instructor reviews at start: areas in the case study. In future application of this strategy, I
Mr. J. Kirk, 76 years old, has been admitted to the medical–surgical recommend providing written examples of shift and SBAR
unit for evaluation after a fall. No fractures have been identified. reports, increased emphasis on the national patient safety
Mr. Kirk's family notes that he has been experiencing increasing goals, and increased performance time for patient education.
difficulty with his memory and he has not taken medications
properly in the days prior to admission.
You are assigned to Mr. Kirk during the 0700–1900 day shift.
9. Summary
8. Lessons Learned
Implementing a large group simulation using unfolding
Implementing a large group simulation experience for the case studies, low-fidelity simulation, and PowerPoint®
first time required a considerable amount of preparation on concurrently is a unique approach to engage students and
my part. Developing a detailed unfolding case study and provide active learning in the classroom. Combining these
incorporating PowerPoint® embedded with self-recorded three instructional modalities provides opportunities for an
audio clips was time consuming. Developing group roles and entire class to integrate nursing concepts and clinical
activities and inserting them into the case study required practice. This strategy can be used to address a variety of
additional thought and creativity. Managing the simulation learning styles and can be used with various student
was most challenging as I operated the PowerPoint® and populations, group sizes, concepts, and courses.
audio while facilitating the application of the nursing process Initial results of this large group simulation experience are
and integration of nursing concepts and clinical practice. If encouraging; yet, further evaluation of this teaching strategy
possible, the assistance of one or more faculty facilitators is recommended to determine its continued effectiveness as a
may be helpful. learning tool and its impact on student learning outcomes.
The survey results revealed reporting; situation, back- The use of unfolding case studies, low-fidelity simulation,
ground, assessment, recommendation (SBAR); patient and PowerPoint® concurrently promotes active learning,
safety; and patient education as weak areas. It is plausible collaboration, problem solving, and the integration of
that students felt inexperienced at applying reporting and classroom and clinical learning. In doing so, students have
SBAR communication skills, especially in the freshman increased opportunities in the classroom setting to prepare
year, as the skill is taught, but its application is limited. It is for the demands of the nursing profession that exist in the
also conceivable that the areas of patient safety and patient clinical setting.