Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Volume I
Pages: 1-30
Exhibits: 0
COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
APPEARANCES:
For the Plaintiff:
Law Office of Glenn F. Russell, Jr.
38 Rock Street
Fall River, Massachusetts 02720
By: Glenn F. Russell, Esq.
Worcester, Massachusetts
June 19, 2018
Recording produced by digital audio recording system. Transcript
produced by Approved Court Transcriber, Donna Holmes Dominguez
Page | 2
Appearances Continued:
I N D E X
None - Hearing
Page | 4
1 P R O C E E D I N G S
6 please.
9 Nims.
15 York?
23 Have a seat and we’ll -- and we’ll wait for him because
25 place, as a matter of fact the deed into the bank was recorded
Page | 6
11 statute did not bar the foreclosure. There was a petition for
16 relatively easy case for the Court to decide for -- for three
17 reasons.
23 mortgage statute.
9 that matter.
21 five years after the maturity date, which would push us out to
1 can say all right well the mortgage had to be discharged, it’s
14 One, that the date of the 4th, and the -- and the loan
22 of limitations running.
24 in 2010, but as the cases have held the note and the mortgage
1 remedies, which is why despite the fact that the Nims family
6 starts at the date of the default of the note, and Judge Campo
14 no case law that has held that, then if the trigger event is
7 cases that Judge Campo relied upon, the Hayden case, from the
18 which say that the obsolete mortgage statute simply does not
21 Honor.
4 so that -- the case wasn’t filed until after June 1st of 2017.
6 demand letter. While they claim that a demand letter was sent
22 this and not that every and all third-party loan servicers in
2 master servicer under the PSA has any relevance to the -- the
4 party beneficiaries of the PSA and by its terms, the PSA says
17 remember.
6 agreed with me, how the underlining merits would not foreclose
15 Your Honor would indulge me I have a few hand ups I’d like to
16 present as well if --
11 Contrast that with the SJC case and they -- they talk
12 about -- they talk about in 2006 the statute was amended; the
19 And at page 253 of the Fitchburg case it says, “We answer the
22 undertake.
9 are reliant upon the Hayden matter, again, who never undertook
19 you that it’s not going to be a cake walk and if -- and I’m
9 remedy, I’m not seeking any benefit from that, all I’m asking
11 enforce the note and mortgage they have to show they have
19 time on it then.
24 SJC. There’s been two cases that have gone to the SJC, one of
3 SJC, “We aren’t certain with the term nominee means within the
9 appeal did they say that they were an agent and the SJC again
12 reason why I tell you that, Your Honor, is one of the cases I
14 case. I’ve put the order from Judge Young, it’s right on the
20 but note ten of Eaton talks about the fact that a mortgage
23 way the law stands now, because MERS admits it does not own
1 282 at page two eighty-seven. They talk about the same thing,
2 they’re like MERS does not own notes. The SJC in Eaton said
7 dismiss today.
3 it just says that the Bank of New York Mellon is the holder of
18 and it’s cited to in U.S. Bank v. Ibanez 458 Mass 637, a case
5 And the thing I want to talk about, Your Honor, is all these
6 cases talk about are, like, cases that are saying, oh, we’re
10 client, that doesn’t mean they get a free house, they could do
17 ruling under Rule 65. Now obviously Your Honor knows well
21 legally cogent. I’m not just making stuff up, I’m not just
22 saying oh, this is the way it should be, I’m citing case law,
24 plausible.
10 waiting for someone to come in and throw them out of the house
14 come in here and it’s just everybody makes the same argument,
15 it’s all the same, it’s not the same. How could my client’s
18 They can’t be, and all I ask is to look at the pleadings and
22 those pleadings and line them up next to mine and say geez,
5 my brother quoted it, that the note was -- or the loan was
10 was, denied, see Hayden, that was basically the ruling on the
19 these other cases and those other cases are all reliant on
20 Hayden.
9 have one from 2011. I have one with me, Your Honor, from 2012
12 That means that the date when the debt fall due -- fell due,
16 can be accelerated, and the SJC was clear that the statute
23 to do was file for an extension and the SJC talked about that
2 and you get another five years. That wasn’t done in this
3 case.
5 can show you that in fact not only in 2011 but in 2012 the --
12 taking up Your Honor’s -- this much time and thank you very
22 Your Honor has probably read his decision, will read it again,
24 Deutsche Bank.
21 reconsideration denied.
25 Your Honor.
P a g e | 29
6 roped in because they were the master servicer under the PSA
8 Your Honor.
15 surprise.
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25 (Adjourned)
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
OFFICE OF COURT MANAGEMENT, Transcription Services
For court transcribers: Complete this assessment form for each volume of transcript
produced, and include it at the back of every original and copy transcript with the certificate
page, word index, and CD PDF transcript.
low audio
____________________ _____________________________________
____________________ _____________________________________
____________________ _____________________________________
COMMENTS:_
P a g e | 30
Certificate of Accuracy
(781) 575-8000___________________
donna@dhreporting.com
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
4 [2] 8:14 28:13 affirmative [1] 19:21 5,9,10,11,13,15 23:13,14,
1 458 [1] 22:18 afternoon [7] 4:7,10,11 5: 18,20,23 24:5,14 25:8 26:
1 [3] 12:3,4 26:5 5,6 11:23 29:10 15,20,24
106-3-118a [1] 16:19 6 agency [1] 19:5 arguments [7] 8:13 20:11
10c [1] 27:9 637 [1] 22:18 agent [6] 19:8,9 20:4,9,9 21:3 23:20 24:6,19 25:18
118a [1] 16:22 65 [1] 23:17 21:23 around [1] 5:3
12(b)(6 [2] 23:15 25:13
122 [1] 12:10
7 agree [1] 20:12 aside [1] 10:24
agreed [2] 14:6,8 assert [1] 13:9
123 [1] 12:9 7 [1] 28:3
agreement [3] 5:15 13:9 assign [2] 10:13 19:16
14 [1] 22:12 708 [1] 19:25
18:13 assignment [2] 21:14 24:
18.21a [1] 12:16 9 ahead [1] 6:13 16
18.21a2c [4] 21:16 22:6, al [2] 4:4,4 association [1] 19:1
93a [1] 11:25
21 29:3 alienation [1] 15:2 assume [1] 12:24
1992 [1] 17:2 “ allegation [1] 12:12 attorney [1] 4:10
2 “as [1] 16:5 alleged [3] 5:17 6:2 15:7 auction [1] 24:9
“ibanez [1] 14:24 alleges [1] 11:24 august [3] 10:8 26:5 28:3
2005 [4] 7:17 8:7 26:5 28:
“in [1] 14:11 allowed [2] 17:14 22:23 aurora [1] 19:25
12
“maturity [1] 26:17 allows [1] 9:3 authority [2] 10:25 27:8
2006 [1] 15:12
“memorandum” [1] 25: alone [1] 20:9 authorized [3] 20:4,9 22:
2007 [1] 10:8
15 alternative [1] 27:1 21
2010 [3] 8:15,21,24
“obsolete [1] 14:25 amazing [1] 24:23 autonomous [1] 19:21
2011 [3] 25:8 26:9 27:5
“we [2] 15:19 19:3 ambiguous [1] 16:3
2012 [5] 8:15 26:9,11,13
“when [1] 15:23 amended [1] 15:12
B
27:5 back [4] 6:7 8:21 17:22 20:
A america [9] 4:12,14 5:10
2013 [1] 12:3 14
12:9,17,19 13:1 21:17 29:4
2015 9:9,15,22 25:6 28: abandoned [1] 20:12
[5]
backed [2] 20:14 21:11
america’s [3] 11:24 12:2
16 above [3] 16:4,6,6 background [1] 7:22
13:5
2017 [5] 8:5 9:15 10:9 12:4 absolute [1] 6:22 baldinelli [1] 19:13
ample [1] 10:25
28:4 accelerated [11] 9:9,22, bank [24] 4:4,12,14,14,18 5:
analysis [1] 24:3
2017-1677 4:4 [1]
22 16:16,23,25 25:6,8 26: 7,9,10,25 11:23 12:2,8,17,
animated [1] 25:1
2018 [1] 28:6 16,19 28:12 18 13:1,5 14:14 21:17,23
another [5] 10:10 13:23
2020 [1] 9:16 acceleration [10] 9:10 14: 22:3,18 25:14 27:24 29:4
18:21 19:13 27:2
2035 [1] 7:18 11 16:20 17:4,15 26:7,7,11 bankruptcy [4] 8:16,19 9:
answer [2] 8:5 15:19
2040 [3] 7:22 8:6 11:20 28:15,16 3,3
apologize [5] 18:20 21:2,
209 [4] 12:16 21:16 22:21 accordance [1] 16:2 banks [4] 7:23 22:23 23:1
20 25:1 27:11
29:3 act [1] 19:21 28:10
appeal [2] 19:9 20:20
244 [2] 22:12,21 acting [1] 21:23 bar [2] 6:11 18:7
appended [1] 27:8
253 [1] 15:19 active [2] 17:4 24:11 barred [4] 6:4,22 8:4 12:1
applying [1] 15:20
255 [1] 16:4 acts [1] 12:16 based [3] 11:16 16:15 26:
appreciate [1] 24:25
260 [5] 14:21 16:13,21 23: actually [2] 17:20 22:13 14
april [1] 11:5
20 26:22 addition [2] 7:3 12:9 baseless [1] 12:20
aren’t [2] 19:3 21:6
282 20:1
[1]
additional [1] 27:14 basically [2] 22:4 25:10
arg [1] 20:11
2c [1] 12:16 adjourned [1] 29:25 basis [2] 12:20 20:25
argue [7] 8:20 9:8 10:6,9
3 admits [1] 19:23 13:22,24 22:12 bearing [2] 10:20 19:4
admitted [1] 19:7 argued [2] 13:22 22:19 became [1] 27:9
3 [1] 16:22
advances [1] 17:4 argues [1] 27:21 become [1] 8:2
33 [5] 14:21 16:14,21 23:20
advancing [1] 14:7 argument [39] 5:12 6:8 8: becomes [3] 8:10,10 9:11
26:22
advisement [1] 29:14 8 13:24 14:1,4,7 16:15 17: beer [1] 10:16
35g [1] 22:22
affect [1] 11:19 6,23,24,25 18:7,14,22 19: began [1] 26:21
4 affected [1] 14:24 19 20:6,14,15,15,15,16 21: begin [3] 5:11 12:1 15:23
Sheet 1 1 - begin
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
behalf [7] 4:8,12,14,14 21: category [1] 26:1 comes [1] 18:1
23 24:6,19 caused [1] 12:14 coming [1] 9:12
D
behind [2] 15:5 20:21 cenlar [2] 11:5 28:5 common [1] 16:10 damages [1] 12:14
believe [7] 9:8 10:2 13:25 certain [1] 19:3 commonwealth [1] 19: date [25] 7:21 8:9,10,10,11,
19:15 21:17 25:7 26:2 certificate [1] 13:6 16 14 9:6 15:15,17,18 16:8,9,
believes [1] 24:1 certification [4] 22:1,2,20 company [1] 23:19 13,14,16,23,25,25 17:4 25:
bench 7:8[1] 29:3 complaint [9] 6:2 12:10 24 26:4,12,15,19,20
beneficiaries [2] 13:4,8 certifications [1] 12:25 20:7 21:16 23:8 24:8 25:6 date” [1] 26:17
benefit [1] 18:9 certified [1] 22:8 26:2 27:8 day 24:9
[1]
borrowers 23:4 [1] challenge [2] 18:5 19:8 compromised [1] 24:7 decide 6:16 [1]
both [2] 15:13 19:1 challenging [1] 24:11 conclusion [2] 11:6,15 decided [7] 6:7 10:13 11:3,
briefing [2] 17:20 28:11 chance [1] 24:1 conclusive.” [1] 16:3 4 28:3,3,6
briefly 7:16
[1] chap [1] 11:25 conduct 12:13
[1] decision [24] 6:6,24 7:3 9:
bring [1] 17:20 chapter [1] 11:25 conflict [1] 10:12 21 10:3,4,10,13,14,15,18,
brother [12] 6:6 8:13 17:7, circuit [14] 10:8,10,13 11:4 confusing [1] 12:25 24 11:1,2,3,5,9,16 13:24
8,17,22 18:2 21:17 22:20 13:25 14:5,10 15:9,21 17: considering [1] 16:8 18:1 20:16 27:22,23 28:4
23:16 25:5,21 18,21 19:13 28:3,4 construction [5] 14:14 decisions [1] 10:23
brothers [1] 14:19 circuit’s [1] 10:24 15:6,9,24 17:10 declaratory [2] 15:8 23:8
brought [1] 27:15 circumstances [1] 24:17 construction,” [1] 15:21 declaring [1] 9:11
buy [1] 10:15 citation [1] 23:14 contemplates [1] 12:21 declined [1] 20:19
cite [1] 28:6 context [2] 12:16 19:4 deed [2] 5:25 6:13
C cited [2] 10:4 22:18 continues [1] 19:15 default [7] 8:10,11,15,21,
cake [2] 17:18,19 citing [2] 23:22,23 contract [4] 18:2,3,4,8 23 9:6 11:12
call 8:11
[1]
civil [1] 27:9 contractual [1] 18:12 defaults [1] 28:17
called [1] 4:2 claim [10] 6:20 7:1,2 11:13 contrast [1] 15:11 defendant [1] 5:7
campo [13] 6:5,24 9:6,16 12:6,10,18,20 16:21 29:7 controls [2] 15:18 17:1 defendants [2] 12:7 20:
10:7,25 13:20 23:16 25:23 claims [4] 6:2 12:1,15 13:3 convoluted [1] 19:19 18
27:21 28:11,13,19 clarify [1] 29:2 copy [3] 14:19 22:4,8 definitely [4] 17:15,16 18:
campo’s 10:4 11:16 16: clause [1] 26:22
[4]
correct [5] 5:21 7:5 10:1 4 27:6
17 25:2 clear [4] 16:3 22:8 23:3 26: 21:18,21 demand [4] 12:6,6,8,10
can’t 23:9,12 24:18 29: 16
[4]
couldn’t [1] 24:7 denied 6:12 25:10 28:
[3]
5 clearly 22:2 23:20
[2] counsel 4:5,18 13:12
[4] 21
cannot [4] 7:20 9:2 19:16, clerk [1] 4:3 20:10 denying [1] 28:19
21 client [3] 18:12 23:10 24: count [2] 11:24 12:8 depositor [1] 13:6
canon [1] 15:24 19 court [54] 4:2,5,10,13,17, despite [1] 9:1
case [39] 5:16,18 6:15,16 9: client’s [2] 24:6,15 20,22 5:2,5,8,14,21,23 6: determined [4] 7:1 10:11
5,7,14 10:7,10 11:16 12:4 clients [1] 15:7 15,16 7:4,10,13 8:8 10:22 17:3 28:13
13:23,23 14:9 15:11,16,18, clip [1] 19:15 11:1,2,3,5,9,10,15,17,22 deutsche [2] 14:14 27:24
19 17:1,3,8 18:25 19:2,5,7, closest [1] 4:24 13:12,14 14:2,3,17 17:3,13 devoted 14:9
[1]
14 22:18 23:22 24:17,24 18:13,16,18 19:2 20:10,24 didn’t 14:20 15:9 20:14
[6]
cloud [1] 7:24
25:21,22,23,23 26:18 27:3, cmr [4] 12:16 21:16 22:21 21:1,1,3,12 27:14,18 28:1, 25:17 28:20 29:2
14 28:5,24 29:3 2,2,6 29:9,14 difference [1] 23:12
cases [16] 7:4 8:24 10:7 cogent [5] 17:6 23:21,23 cullhane [1] 19:25 different 10:18 14:7 21:
[4]
11:17 17:7 18:24 19:1,12 24:5 26:15 curious 23:1
[1] 13 23:18
23:6,6,13,15 24:12 25:19, come [5] 10:18 11:6 24:3, currently [1] 20:8 disagree [1] 16:17
19 27:25 10,14 discharge [1] 7:24
Sheet 2 behalf - discharge
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
discharged [4] 8:1,16,17 establish [1] 7:4 filings [1] 10:22 got [3] 14:21 27:4,6
9:3 et [2] 4:4,4 financial [2] 18:7,8 grouped [1] 23:13
discuss [2] 21:19 25:17 eve [1] 20:23 find [1] 23:1 guard [1] 17:23
discussion [2] 16:5 17:21 even [8] 6:19 10:23 14:5 finding [1] 16:17 guess [1] 11:13
dismiss [12] 4:13 5:9,17 6: 23:25 24:7 25:11,17 28:17 findings [1] 24:20 gun [1] 5:2
14,14 11:15,24 21:4,7 27: event [4] 8:7 9:14,21 12:15 first [17] 10:8,10,13,24 11:4, guys [1] 4:24
10 28:8,15 everybody [2] 4:25 24:14 4 13:25 14:5,10,12 15:8,21
dismissed [3] 13:11 24:8 everyone [1] 23:14 17:18,21 19:13 28:3,4
H
28:24 everything [2] 9:11,12 fit [1] 15:14 hand [1] 14:15
dispute 6:18
[1] exact [1] 24:2 fitchburg [5] 14:14 15:4, handed [6] 17:1,7,8 19:13
distinguished [1] 27:23 exactly [1] 24:23 19 26:14,24 27:25 28:5
district [4] 11:1,2 28:1,2 examination [3] 14:10 15: five [4] 7:21 9:23 27:2,20 handicapped [1] 25:16
divest [1] 25:16 6 17:11 five-year [1] 15:14 happened [2] 9:18 10:9
division 22:23 23:1 28: examine [1] 15:8
[3] flush [1] 22:24 harrington [2] 11:5 28:5
9 excuse [3] 5:1 10:8 11:4 follow [1] 22:9 hasn’t [2] 12:17 13:16
docket [1] 4:4 exhibit [4] 21:16 22:6 26:1 followed [1] 11:2 haven’t [1] 23:11
document 27:7 [1] 28:13 ford [1] 23:19 hayden [19] 10:7,10,24 11:
documents [1] 27:4 existing [1] 6:20 fore [1] 6:13 1,2,4 13:21,21,21 14:9 17:
doesn’t [5] 6:20 9:13 11:7 extension [2] 26:23 27:1 foreclose [7] 6:3,9 8:6 11: 9 25:10,20 27:21 28:1,1,3,
12:23 23:10 extent [1] 12:18 20 14:6 19:18 26:10 6,20
don’t 7:13 12:7,11 18:
[4] foreclosed [3] 7:20 8:5 he’s [4] 4:19 10:2,2,9
18
F 12:17 hear [2] 5:11,12
done [2] 7:10 27:2 f3d [1] 19:25 foreclosing [2] 5:16 21: heard [2] 13:19 28:18
doubtful [1] 24:2 face [2] 14:22 15:15 24 hearing [1] 6:5
due [8] 9:11,12 14:23 16: fact [15] 5:25 9:1 12:12 14: foreclosure [20] 5:17,19, held [3] 6:5 8:24 9:14
14 17:5 26:12,12,13 23 16:15 17:8,17 19:6,8,20 22,24 6:4,11,22 8:4,9,9,19 holder [2] 19:21 22:3
21:15 22:10 24:2 26:18 27: 11:12,14 12:17 22:11 26:7, holders [1] 13:7
E 5 8 27:6,7 29:5 holding [1] 6:6
easily [1] 27:1 facts [4] 6:18,19 7:16 24: forth [2] 15:13 16:22 home [2] 24:9 25:16
easy [1] 6:16 17 forward [3] 5:23 16:4 24:8 homeowner [1] 24:13
eaton 18:25 19:2,17,20, fail [1] 12:15
[6]
found [1] 19:25 honor [38] 4:3,7,11,16 5:1,
24 20:2 failed [3] 12:19 13:16 19:7 four [4] 10:23 12:3 27:25 13,24 7:6,15 8:3,13 11:21,
edward [1] 17:2 failure [2] 22:9,15 28:12 23 13:13,15,18 14:1,15 15:
effect [3] 8:20 9:7,19 fair [1] 7:10 fourth [1] 28:5 7 17:2 18:3,20 19:12 21:2,
effort [1] 5:18 fall [1] 26:12 framework [1] 8:2 9,21 23:5,9,17 26:9 27:4,
eight 11:11,12
[2] falls [2] 16:14 17:5 free [2] 7:13 23:10 17,22 28:25 29:1,8,11,13
eighteen [1] 28:8 familiar [1] 7:6 friday [1] 14:2 honor’s [2] 24:25 27:12
eighty-seven [1] 20:1 family [2] 6:20 9:1 fully [1] 22:24 honorable [1] 13:19
either [1] 19:17 far [1] 19:5 funny [1] 26:5 house [2] 23:10 24:10
electronic [1] 18:22 favorable [1] 6:19 however [3] 14:12,12 19:4
else’s [1] 24:16 federal [2] 17:13 19:1 G
encumbrances [1] 15:2 feel [1] 7:13 galiastro [4] 18:25 19:5,7,
I
ended 12:2
[1] feeling 25:15
[1] 17 i’d [2] 13:18 14:15
enforce [4] 18:2,8,11 20:5 fell [1] 26:12 geez [1] 24:22 i’ll [5] 5:11,13,13 10:15 20:
engaged [1] 5:4 fernandes [1] 17:2 generally [1] 13:7 25
entire [1] 14:9 ferreira [1] 17:2 getting [2] 7:11 25:1 i’m [19] 4:22 5:1 7:11 10:1
entitled 26:6
[1] few 14:15
[1] give [1] 27:18 17:19 18:2,8,9,9 21:3,3,8,
entity [1] 18:5 file [2] 26:23 27:1 given [1] 14:19 18 23:21,21,22,23 24:5 27:
especially [1] 23:15 filed [4] 5:18 8:16 12:4 20: glc [3] 16:19 22:12,21 11
essentially [3] 6:7 7:1,20 20 glen [1] 4:7 i’ve [7] 7:10,10 10:16,22 14:
Sheet 3 discharged - i’ve
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
19 19:14 27:4 jr [1] 4:8 litigation [1] 24:11 21:4,11,13 28:7,9
iannacchino [2] 23:19,25 judge [22] 6:5,10,24 9:6,16 little [2] 5:3 7:7 met [1] 23:11
ibanez [1] 22:18 10:4,7,24 11:16 13:20 16: live [1] 20:16 might [1] 7:4
identified [1] 25:3 17 19:14 20:16,21 23:16, loan [7] 12:14,21,22 19:25 mine [3] 18:3,25 24:22
identify 4:5[1] 25 25:2,23 27:21 28:11,12, 23:4 25:5 28:12 minimum [1] 26:11
immediately [1] 26:13 18 long [1] 16:5 missing [1] 4:24
impact 22:16
[1] judgement 23:8 [1] look 10:9 24:18 25:18
[3] miss-quoting [1] 21:20
implausibility [1] 25:17 judges [1] 10:11 looked [4] 15:10 17:3,10 mistake [1] 25:4
importance [1] 22:17 judgment [1] 15:8 28:7 moment [3] 22:21 29:3,4
important 15:7 [1] jumped 5:2 [1] looking 14:13 16:24
[2] month [1] 6:1
importantly [1] 22:9 jumping [1] 5:3 lot [2] 14:23 24:12 mortgage [52] 6:5,10,23 7:
inapposite 25:23 [1] june 12:3,4
[2] 2,6,16,17,19,19,20,25 8:1,4,
including [1] 27:10 junior [2] 11:2 28:1
M 7,18,24 9:4,5,9,11,13,18,22
incorporate 28:14 [1] jurisdictional 12:5 [1] made [7] 8:9 15:5 16:20 17:
11:8,18 14:12 15:16,17 16:
incorrect [2] 11:15 25:6 11 23:16 24:19 25:4 6,10,11 18:4,11,22 19:1,4,
indication [1] 23:3
K maintain [1] 17:25 20 21:14,22 22:1,5 23:7 24:
indisputably [1] 26:10 kicking [1] 11:8 mandatory [1] 22:13 16 25:12,24,25 26:1,6,21
individual [1] 25:17 knows [1] 23:17 mass [2] 22:18 27:8 27:7 28:16,23
massachusetts [3] 11:1
indulge 13:18 14:15
[2]
L 17:13 19:11
mortgage,” [1] 15:1
indulgence [2] 24:25 27: mortgagee [3] 5:16 19:22
lack [1] 13:8 master [3] 13:2,5 29:6
13 20:3
land [4] 11:3,5 28:2,6 math [1] 9:15
informed [1] 23:4 mortgages [1] 19:16
language [8] 15:25 16:1,2,
matter [18] 4:3 5:25 7:9 9:
injunction [3] 13:19 16:18 most [1] 6:19
13,24 21:21 24:3 26:17 15 10:19,20 11:7,19 12:2
28:14 motion [10] 5:17 6:14 11:
last [6] 5:18 6:1 9:21 17:12
13:10,21 17:8,9 18:23 19:
insight [1] 15:25 24 20:22 25:2 27:10 28:8,
25:1 28:18 13 20:17,18,20
instrument 16:20 20:5
[2] 14,19,20
later [1] 19:6 matters [2] 19:18 21:1
intended [1] 14:7 motions [4] 4:13 5:9 21:4,
law [15] 6:20 7:8,25 9:5,7, mature [1] 7:18
intent [1] 15:25 6
14 16:10 17:13 19:11,23 maturity [17] 7:21 8:10,11 motor [1] 23:19
interest [1] 10:12
20:19,22 23:22 26:18 27: 15:15,17,18 16:8,9,13,16,
interject [1] 4:16 move [1] 24:8
15 23,25,25 25:24 26:3,15,19
interpret 16:1 [1] moved [1] 27:6
least [1] 19:22
mccann [8] 4:11,11,16,18,
interpreted [2] 6:19 16:1 much [2] 27:12,13
leave [1] 5:10 21 11:23 13:13 29:11
involved 12:23 13:25
[2] must [1] 17:25
left [1] 9:4
mean [2] 16:14 23:10
involvement [1] 12:2
issue [10] 6:21 8:3 9:25 10:
legal [4] 17:6 23:23 24:5 meaning [3] 15:23 16:2 N
26:15 22:24 n.a 4:12
[1]
3,4 17:14,15,16 18:3 19:17
legally [2] 23:21 24:5
means [5] 7:18 9:11 19:3, national [1] 19:1
issued [4] 6:5,24 10:8 15:
legislature [4] 14:23 15:3, 10 26:12 nebraska [1] 19:25
23
25 22:23 mellon [10] 4:4,18 5:7,10, necessarily [1] 16:7
issues [2] 25:3 28:10
lender [1] 18:6
16 6:3,9 21:24 22:3 25:14 need [3] 18:18 20:3 22:7
it’s [31] 5:21 7:7,7,24,24 8:
let’s [1] 11:11 memory [1] 13:16 neglect [1] 7:23
1,2 9:24,24 13:16 17:2,18,
letter [5] 12:6,6,8,11 28:15 mendillo [15] 5:1,4,6,6,13, negotiable [1] 16:20
19 19:14 20:6,21,23 21:5
liability [2] 8:17 9:2 15,22,24 7:12,15 8:12 11: neither [1] 13:3
22:18 23:18 24:14,15,15
light [1] 6:19 11 27:17,19 29:12 never [3] 17:9 19:17 24:12
25:7 26:2,4,4,6,18,19 27:
likelihood [1] 7:2 mention 28:9,9 [2] new [11] 4:4,14,18 5:10 10:
23
limitation [2] 12:3 15:4
mentioned [1] 6:12 14 14:8 17:20 20:23 21:24
itself [4] 7:3 15:16 19:21
limitations [6] 8:22 9:23 merely [2] 23:8 24:20 22:3 25:14
27:7
14:22,25 15:13,14 merits [1] 14:6 next [2] 4:3 24:22
J line [1] 24:22 mers [17] 18:25 19:7,16,18, nims [5] 4:4,8,9 6:20 9:1
john 4:11
[1] listed [1] 25:24
22,23 20:2,7,13,14,15,22 nominee [2] 19:3,10
Sheet 4 i’ve - nominee
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
none [1] 17:7 opined [1] 17:16 placed [1] 25:25 pronouncing [1] 9:17
nonetheless [2] 9:3 10: opposition [2] 28:8,13 plain 11:19 16:2,24 21: properties [1] 14:24
[4]
21 order [6] 4:2 15:14 18:10 21 prove [1] 18:1
nor [1] 13:3 19:14 20:3,21 plaintiff [2] 20:17 25:14 provide [5] 7:4 12:21 21:
note [35] 8:17,18,23,23,24 original 18:6
[1] plaintiff’s 12:13 24:1
[4] 24 22:7,15
9:6,9,19,21 11:7 15:17,18 other [12] 7:4 9:8 10:3 11: 25:18 27:9 provided [1] 10:23
16:6,16,24 18:11 19:2,20, 17 12:7 14:20 18:25 23:14 plaintiffs [11] 4:8 12:18 psa [4] 13:2,4,4 29:6
24 20:3,4,8 21:20,25 22:2, 24:21 25:19,19,21 13:7 16:19,20,22 17:6 20:6 pun [1] 14:7
4,5,8,15 23:7 25:5 26:3,4, otherwise [2] 6:8 18:1 22:1,12 26:8 purposes [3] 8:11 18:14
15 28:16 out 7:17,21 10:18,25 15: plaintiffs’ 13:1,3 16:15 27:10
[7] [4]
note.” [1] 16:11 3 22:24 24:10 18:4 pursued [1] 9:2
noted [3] 14:8 16:4,6 outcome 24:1 [1] plausible 6:19 17:25
[6] pursuing [1] 6:8
notes [2] 19:24 20:2 outside [1] 21:14 23:20,24 24:4 26:20 push [1] 7:21
nothing [2] 14:11 21:10 over 23:11
[1] pleading 24:21
[1] put [4] 10:24 16:22 19:14
notice [6] 22:11,13,16,17 own [2] 19:23 20:2 pleadings [4] 20:7 24:18, 25:14
23:3 27:7 owner [5] 20:3,4,8 22:4 23: 22 27:10
notices [1] 26:8 4 please [1] 4:6
Q
november [3] 5:20,23 6: ownership [1] 12:19 plenty [1] 9:24 question [4] 15:20 19:5,
13 point [2] 11:13 28:18 11 28:23
nowhere [1] 25:18
P points [2] 6:6 27:20 questions [3] 20:18,22,23
9:19,20 10:16 27:20 packet [1] 17:1 post-eaton 19:22 [1] quoted [1] 25:5
page [6] 6:24 9:20 15:19
numerous [1] 26:8
16:4 20:1 25:15
postulate [1] 17:14 R
potentially [1] 12:25
O pages [1] 28:8 practicality [1] 10:19
raise [1] 29:7
oath [1] 22:8 paid [1] 24:13 raised [1] 19:17
practicing [1] 7:8
obligation [2] 16:8,9 panel [4] 10:11,14,18 14:8 predict [1] 10:15 rather [1] 5:20
obligations [1] 13:5 paper [1] 19:15 reach [1] 16:7
predicts [1] 17:17
obscure [1] 7:7 paperclip [1] 15:5 reaching [1] 10:18
prejudice [1] 13:11
obsolete [16] 6:4,10,22 7: papers [2] 5:12 7:11 read [4] 5:11 7:10 27:22,22
preliminary [3] 13:19 16:
2,6,19 8:2,4 9:5,12,18 11:8, paragraph [8] 12:9,9,10 real [1] 12:12
18 28:14
18 25:12 26:21 28:23 14:9 25:7 26:2,4,5 re-argument [1] 10:14
prerequisite [1] 12:5
obsolute [1] 9:17 paragraphs [1] 9:21 reason [5] 15:1,7 16:22 19:
present [2] 14:5,16
obviously [1] 23:17 part [3] 13:24 22:13 27:9 12 20:9
presented [1] 15:20
occasion [1] 10:16 particular [4] 21:15 22:16, presumably [1] 10:14 reasonable [2] 12:24 21:
occur [1] 15:3 25 25:25 19
prevent [1] 5:19
occurred [2] 11:13 28:16 parties [2] 13:3,8 reasoning [1] 11:16
previously [2] 28:17,22
october [2] 5:18,20 party [1] 13:4 reasons 6:17 13:10 28:
[4]
primary [2] 15:24 22:17
okay [6] 5:13 7:12 18:16 pass [1] 9:4 22,22
privity [1] 18:12
20:24 21:12 29:10 past [1] 11:12 rec [1] 10:21
probably [1] 27:22
old [1] 7:25 payable [1] 26:13 received [1] 26:8
problem,” [1] 14:24
one [23] 6:2,6,18 8:14 9:19, pending [1] 20:23 recent [1] 10:21
procedure [1] 27:9
21 10:6,11 12:7 13:22,22 people [4] 7:25 24:7,9 26: proceed [2] 5:13 8:19 recently [2] 7:8 10:9
14:19,19,20 18:24 19:12 11 recite [1] 7:16
proceedings [1] 8:19
22:25,25 24:13 25:1 26:9,9 people’s [1] 24:21 reconsideration [6] 25:3,
promise [2] 17:18 24:23
27:20 personal [2] 8:17 9:2 9,11,22 28:19,21
promissory [1] 8:18
only [6] 10:4 17:14 18:3 19: pertaining [1] 21:6 record [1] 7:24
pronouncement [1] 17:
8 21:10 27:5 petition [1] 6:11 recorded [2] 5:25 6:13
13
open [1] 19:11 physically [1] 24:7 rectify [1] 14:20
pronouncement.” [1] 19:
operation [1] 7:25 place [3] 5:21,22,25 redundant [1] 12:24
5
Sheet 5 none - redundant
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
reference [3] 15:15,17 23: roll [1] 4:22 set [1] 15:3 start [1] 13:18
2 roped [1] 29:6 sets [1] 15:13 starts [2] 9:6,23
references [1] 26:3 rule [3] 23:17 27:8,9 setting [1] 22:23 state [6] 6:20 16:12 17:13
refers [1] 26:17 ruled [6] 6:9,10 9:7,16,20 settled [1] 15:20 18:10 26:15,20
regard 12:12 17:24 18: 23:9
[6] seven [1] 11:11 stated [6] 14:10 16:18 17:
17,21,22 25:12 rules [1] 15:20 seventy-for [1] 25:7 4 19:2 20:17 28:22
regarding 12:13 17:15 ruling [10] 13:20,21 16:18
[4] seventy-two [1] 25:7 states [11] 17:22 18:2 20:7
20:22 22:2 20:19 23:15,17 25:2,10,13 shoes [1] 18:6 21:22,22 22:7,20,22 23:8,
regards [1] 20:13 26:14 short [1] 8:5 25 25:4
registration [1] 18:22 run 9:13 13:6
[2] shorten [1] 14:25 statues [1] 15:13
regulation [5] 12:20,24 running [2] 8:22 9:23 show [3] 16:23 18:11 27:5statute [43] 6:5,11,23 7:7,
21:22 22:9,10 russell [25] 4:7,7,10 6:7 8: showing [1] 13:25 19,22 8:4,21 9:5,13,18,19,
regulations [3] 12:1 22: 20 10:1,6,16,23 13:14,15 shows [1] 26:10 23,24 10:5 11:8,18,20 12:3
24,25 14:4,18 18:15,17,20 20:13, simple [2] 7:14 28:23 14:10,11,13,21,22,25 15:5,
regulatory [1] 12:15 25 21:2,8,13 27:20 28:18 simply [2] 11:18 27:23 8,12,13,14,23 16:1,24 17:
rehearing [1] 6:12 29:1,13 since [1] 20:23 11 22:14,17,25 23:9,12 25:
reit [1] 21:9 russell’s 28:7
[1] single [2] 24:9,17 12 26:16,21 28:24
reiterate [1] 21:9 sit [1] 24:9 statutes [1] 15:4
reiterated [2] 19:6,10
S situational [1] 14:10 statutory [12] 11:25 14:13
related [2] 20:15 21:10 sale [5] 5:19 6:12 9:15 11: six [2] 6:24 9:20 15:6,9,21,24 16:13 17:10
relates [1] 12:16 12,14 sixty [2] 27:17,18 22:11 23:3,11 26:18
relatively [1] 6:16 same [9] 10:18 14:13 20:1 sjc [18] 14:12 15:4,11 16: stayed [1] 17:11
relevance [1] 13:2 23:14 24:14,15,15,17,23 12 17:11,12 18:24,24 19:3, step [2] 6:7 18:5
relevant [1] 21:6 savings [1] 26:22 9 20:2,19,22 22:19 26:14, stephen [2] 4:3,8
reliant [2] 17:9 25:19 saying [3] 23:6,22 26:25 16,23,25 stepped [1] 17:22
says [11] 7:19 9:5 13:4 15:
relied [4] 10:7,25 13:20 27: sjc’s 27:23
[1] still [2] 8:19 17:24
21 19 16:24 21:25 22:3,4 25: skipped [1] 12:5 stone [5] 11:3,3 25:21,22
rely [1] 27:25 18 26:5,6 skipping [1] 16:4 28:2
relying 16:19,21
[2] scheduled [1] 5:19
so-called 6:4 [1] strawbridge [1] 10:3
remain [2] 8:16,20 scope [1] 16:6 sole [3] 6:21 8:3 9:4 street [1] 1:38
remains [1] 17:17 seat [1] 4:23 someone 21:19 24:6, stuff [1] 23:21
[5]
remedies [2] 9:1 26:6 second [2] 12:5 19:15 10,20 25:16 subjectively [1] 24:1
remedy [3] 9:4 18:9 26:7 seconds [3] 27:17,18 29:2 sometimes 7:23 [1] submission [1] 14:1
remember [1] 13:17 section [3] 16:14,22 22:22 sorry [3] 4:21 5:1,2 submit [4] 6:15 11:6,14 17:
remove [1] 15:2 security [1] 20:5 sought [1] 14:25 20
replicate [1] 24:20 see [3] 11:11 25:10 28:19 source 15:24
[1] submitted [5] 13:20 14:1
required [2] 22:14 29:3 seeking [4] 17:20 18:2,8,9 speaking [1] 13:7 17:12 20:21 25:4
requirements [1] 23:12 seeks [1] 18:5 speaks 14:11 24:13
[2] subsection [1] 22:22
requires [1] 12:24 seem [2] 12:23 21:18 specific [1] 25:17 success [1] 7:2
respectfully [5] 11:14 13: sense [1] 24:4 specifically 9:20 16: suffices [1] 12:10
[8]
20 16:17 17:12 25:4 sent [6] 12:6 14:2 22:10 23: 21 17:23 22:7 23:2 24:19 sufficient [1] 25:15
responded [1] 26:25 2 25:2,22 25:3 26:2 suggested [1] 20:20
response [3] 10:21 25:9 sentence [1] 16:5 speculation 24:4 [1] supplied [1] 22:1
27:16 separate [3] 8:25 14:22 speed [1] 11:7 surprise [1] 29:15
restroom [1] 4:19 15:3 spend 18:18
[1] systems [1] 18:23
result [1] 8:18 separately [1] 8:25
stagnant [1] 15:2
rights [1] 13:9 servicer 12:21 13:2,6
[6]
standing [14] 6:3,7,9 10:3
T
21:23 29:5,6 13:9 17:23 18:5,14 20:11, talked 23:16 25:12,21,
[5]
road 2:15
[1]
robert [1] 5:6 servicers [1] 12:22
13 21:6,9 28:10 29:7 22 26:23
rock [1] 1:38 services 19:25[1]
stands [1] 19:23 talks [5] 16:19 19:20 22:10
Sheet 6 reference - talks
DH Reporting Services, Inc. (781) 575-8000
25:7 26:3 trying [6] 18:8 19:18 21:9 vickie [1] 4:8 24 22:3 25:14
ten [1] 19:20 23:7,7 26:10 violation [1] 11:25 you’re [3] 5:11 18:7 21:4
tender [2] 10:22 11:9 twelve [1] 20:23 violations [1] 11:25 young [3] 19:14 20:16,21
tendered [1] 11:17 twenty [1] 26:5 void [3] 11:14 23:7,7 yourself [1] 4:5
term [4] 16:8,9,12 19:3 twenty-nine [1] 19:2
terms [2] 11:19 13:4 twenty-seven [1] 19:24
W
text [2] 15:10 17:10 twists [1] 18:7 wait [2] 4:23 24:7
text,” [1] 14:11 two [18] 6:2,3,6,10,24 8:13, waiting [1] 24:10
25 9:20 11:24,25 14:22 15: waived 10:2 28:10,11,
[4]
thankfully [1] 13:15
thanks [1] 27:14 3 18:24 20:1 21:4 25:15 26: 11
that’s [28] 5:2,5 7:22 8:2,2, 6 27:25 walk [2] 17:18,19