Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Original research
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Purpose: Hoffa fracture fixed by only using a single plate or lag screws might be not strong enough to
Received 25 January 2015 achieve direct stability. The goal of this study is to determine the functional outcome of the surgical
Received in revised form treatment and rehabilitation of medial Hoffa fracture by a locking plate combined with cannulated or lag
6 May 2015
screws.
Accepted 15 May 2015
Available online 26 May 2015
Methods: A total of 13 patients suffering isolated medical Hoffa fractures were identified during the
study period (2005.February-2013.February) and retrospectively analyzed. All the fractures were treated
by open reduction via the medial approach, and internal fixation by a locking plate combined with
Keywords:
Medial Hoffa
cannulated or lag screws. Early active rehabilitation including tele-rehabilitation for rural patients with
Rehabilitation restricted weight bearing was instituted after the surgical treatment. The radiological and functional
Locking plate outcome analysis was performed by using Knee Society Score (KSS), the range of movement (ROM), and
Screw the stability of fixation of the patients during 24 month follow-up.
Results: The bone union of medial Hoffa fractures was achieved in all patients. The articular surface of
medial femoral condyle was anatomically reduced. There was no loss of reduction and fixation. All pa-
tients achieved satisfactory knee joint function and regained their walking ability with good clinical
results through early postsurgical rehabilitation. Ten patients (77%) had 0 e130 range of motion with
full extension; two patients (15%) had 0 e115 range of motion; one patient (8%) had 0 e110 range of
motion. The KSS of all the patients were more than 80, and the scores of seven patients (54%) were more
than 85.
Conclusion: Fixation with a locking plate and cannulated or lag screws for medial Hoffa fracture seemed
to be effective and reliable for achieving anatomical reduction, and gave satisfactory functional results
when coupled with aggressive rehabilitation.
© 2015 IJS Publishing Group Limited. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsu.2015.05.027
1743-9191/© 2015 IJS Publishing Group Limited. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
96 M. Gao et al. / International Journal of Surgery 19 (2015) 95e102
involves the lateral condyle [2]. Isolated coronal fracture of medial modified the medial distal-femur approach as a “medial to medial-
Hoffa fracture is extremely rare, and little is described in literatures posterior distal femur approach”, and it was easy to explore the
about the surgical approach, fixation methods and rehabilitation in vastus medialis muscle, sartorius muscle and sapheneus nerve,
such fractures [3e5]. which was retracted forward to the anterior to explore the gracilis,
The purpose of the treatment of this kind of articular fracture is semimembranosus and semitendinosus muscles. After that, the
to achieve anatomical reduction of the articular surface. Early open semimembranosus and semitendinosus were retraced to the pos-
reduction and internal fixation are mandatory for good long-term terior and we could go through the interval space between the
recovery in patients with such fractures. But there are many diffi- gracilis muscle and caput medial of the gastrocnemius to expose
culties associated with internal fixation in treating Hoffa fracture, the fragment, and then the origin of the medial collateral ligament
especially the medial Hoffa fracture. It was shown that the internal could be clearly exposed and protected. The intact fragment of
fixation by only using a single plate or lag screws was not enough to Hoffa fracture was reduced and fixed with one or two cannulated or
achieve enough stability of Hoffa fracture, and as a result, fragment lag screws from the medial-posterior to the lateral-anterior
displacement, non-union, and even bone absorption could happen condyle, and meanwhile a locking plate (Synthes) was anatomi-
[6,7]. cally contoured and used for fixing with angular stability and also
Except for the steady fixation on medial Hoffa fracture, early preventing from the vertical gliding of the fragment. No external
effective rehabilitation is also essential to achieve the satisfactory fixation was used after operation.
functional recovery of knee. A review of available data suggests that Several pitfalls should be alerted and avoided during operation.
a combination of both two exercises is helpful when appropriate Firstly, the operation should be carried out gently to protect the
precautions are taken to protect the healing fragments and avoid nutrient artery and soft tissue, including the insertion of medial
excessive stress to the patellofemoral joint [8,9]. However, there collateral ligament, especially in the Type II Hoffa fracture; Sec-
were few researches concerning the rehabilitation on this kind of ondly, the procedure of fixation should be avoided operating
fracture. repeatedly, in order to prevent surgical failure, if the fracture
In this study, we reported our experience of surgical treatment fragment is small; The third, the plate and cannulated or lag screws
and rehabilitation of medial Hoffa fracture in patients fixed by a should be placed correctly. The locking plate (Synthes) was placed
locking plate and cannulated or lag screws through the medial on the medial-posterior side of the femur condyle and the cannu-
approach, which could provide rigid stability and earlier active lated or lag screws were placed by the side of the locking plate in
rehabilitation. our research.
Fig. 1. a) The incision passed over the surface of vastus medialis muscle and sartorius muscle,and the medial femoral condyle was exposed by being mobilized and retracted. b)-c)
Full exposure of the fragment of the medial condyle of the left femur by a modified approach was achieved and a locking plate and cannulated screw was placed.
2.5. Six weeks to 10 weeks postoperatively CT scanning every month in the first 3 months, every 3 months in
the following 9 months, and then at the 12th and 24th months.
In 6e8 weeks after surgery, the patients began practicing non-
weight-bearing walking with the help of crutches. The patients 3. Results
were allowed partial weight-bearing at around 10 weeks post-
operatively. For the discharged patients, they gradually increased All the patients were compliant and the data were collected
the bearing weight under the guidance of the clinician via tele- without missing. To evaluate the healing of the fracture, the X-ray
rehabilitation [11]. or CT scanning were used. We found that the bone union in 10
patients (77%) were seen at 3 months, bone union of 2 patients
2.6. Fourteen weeks to 28 weeks postoperatively (15%) were seen at 5 months, and 1 patient (8%) got bone union at 6
months. At the end of 24-month follow-up, all the fractures were
When the sign of bone union was showed in radiographs and united.
the patients were allowed for full weight-bearing from 14 weeks to Following open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF), gradual
28 weeks postoperatively. range of motion exercises of knee were initiated. At four weeks
postoperatively, 9 patients (69%) had 0 -130 range of motion with
2.7. Follow up full extension, 3 patients (23%) had 0 -115 range of motion, 1 pa-
tient (8%) had 0 e110 range of motion, and there was no varus-
The patients after discharge were followed up by taking X-ray or valgus instability. Functional outcome of knee measurements
98 M. Gao et al. / International Journal of Surgery 19 (2015) 95e102
Table 2
Follow-up and outcomes.
Patient Diagnostic modality Knee ROM (degrees) Knee Society score (points) Bone union time(month) Follow-up (months) Non-union Stability
(ROM of knee, KSS, stability of fixation) were performed during the 0 e130 range of motion was obtained in the patient (Fig. 5). Six
24 months’ follow up (Table 2). Additionally, there was no limb- months after the operation, the fracture line was obscure at the 3D-
length discrepancy, postoperative infection, un-union, secondary CT, and there was no secondary displacement (Fig. 6).The patient
displacement, or bone resorption, and the distal femoral physis had was allowed to have full weight-bearing at home 9 months post-
started to fuse on both sides. All the patients were pain free and operatively. A stable and functional knee was achieved after 13
ambulatory without walking aids. months, and the patient was fully recovered, loaded, and back to
In this study, the patient of case 3 (a 58-year-old male) got the work as a physical worker after 24 months follow-up.
left medial Hoffa fracture (type IIb) from a motor vehicle accident
(Fig. 2a and b). A locking plate and one cannulated screw were 4. Discussion
placed at the medial-posterior distal femoral condyle (Fig. 3). The
patient could acquire nearly 90 range of motion through active In 1904, the coronal plane fractures of the distal femoral condyle
rehabilitation at the tenth day (Fig. 4). 3 months after the operation, were officially described for the first time by Hoffa [1]. Hoffa
Fig. 2. a)-b) AP/Lateral radiograph of right knee showed a type IIc medial Hoffa fracture. c)-d) 3D-CT of right knee showed a type IIc medial Hoffa fracture.
M. Gao et al. / International Journal of Surgery 19 (2015) 95e102 99
Fig. 3. AP/Lateral radiograph of right knee showed that the fracture was reduced and fixed with a locking plate and one cannulated screw.
fracture refers to the single or double femoral condyle fracture on medial Hoffa fracture were shown in the literature [3,14,15].
the coronal plane. Since the patients with Hoffa fracture usually Hoffa fracture was classified into three types by Letenneur [16].
suffer from high-energy injury, many cases are missed unfortu- Type I is a vertical fracture involving the entire condyle parallel to
nately at the first assessment [12]. Unicondylar Hoffa fracture has the posterior cortex of the femur; Type II is a fracture of variable
been reported in several studies [2,13]. However, few reports about size, horizontal to the base of the condyle; Type III is a fracture
Fig. 4. The patient could acquire nearly 90 range of motion through active rehabilitation at the tenth day.
Fig. 5. The patient obtained 0 e130 range of motion in 3 months after the operation.
100 M. Gao et al. / International Journal of Surgery 19 (2015) 95e102
Fig. 6. 3D-CT of the left knee showed that there was no secondary displacement and the fracture line was obscure ten months after the operation.
oblique to the femur, originally described for lateral Hoffa fractures medial genicular artery and arteriae genu descendens, and a few
(Fig. 7). Compared to type I and type III fractures, the type II Hoffa blood supply was from the soft tissue, medial collateral ligament
fracture fragment was relatively small and most likely to nonunion attachment sites. Compared to type I and type III fractures, the
for the lack of soft tissue attachment. Type II Hoffa fracture has fragment in type II Hoffa fracture was relatively small and most
worse blood supply bone union than the other two types. Most of likely to induce nonunion due to the lack of soft tissue attachment.
the nutrient arteries for medial condyle were provided by superior Accordingly, injury of these nutrient artery and soft tissues should
be prevented during the operation. have difficulty with transportation to rehabilitation center [11]. The
Hoffa fractures are usually caused by motor vehicular accidents. advantages of rehabilitation could reduce the rate of the post-
Until now, the injury mechanisms of this fracture pattern have not operative complications, which include lowering the odds of
been clearly described. To detect the coronal fractures more accu- acquiring Deep Vein Thrombosis (DVT), joint loosening and post-
rately, CT scanning is necessary to these fractures that might be operative infection [28]. The rehabilitation of patients after surgery
easily overlooked on plain radiographs. On the other hand, CT refers to start to train based on the preoperative instructions from
scanning or MRI examination is essential to find out a potential the third day of post-operation, and keeps on physical therapy post-
fracture and other accompanying structure injuries [17]. Ozturk discharge by tele-rehabilitation. In our study, all the patients were
[18] recorded a case of neglected medial Hoffa fracture that was compliant and received positive rehabilitation according to our
initially missed because of seemingly normal anteroposterior (AP) personalized and professional instructions during the follow-up
radiographs of the knee. period. The plan of rehabilitation excise in this study was on the
The medial Hoffa fracture is a kind of intra-articular fracture, basis of previous researches and combined with the internal fixa-
and most of these cases need operation [3,13]. Conservative man- tion methods we did here, which allowed the patients with Hoffa
agement often leads to nonunion or loss of knee function [18]. The fracture to carry out earlier, more active and safer post-operative
surgical approaches are usually parapatellar approaches (ante- rehabilitation excise, and our results were satisfactory. Up to now,
romedial), or combined with posterior approaches, depending on the rehabilitation program should be considered on a case-by-case
the fracture classification and fixation methods. basis, and its implementation and coordination should be executed
As far as we know, there was no clinical comparison of different by professional physician and surgeon.
fixation methods on Hoffa fracture in the literatures. Most of Hoffa In this retrospective cohort study, the lack of controls and the
fractures were treated with cannulated screws or cancellous screws limited number of patients was due to that the medial Hoffa frac-
from anterior to posterior or the opposite direction, and the clinical ture is extremely rare. The managements of medial Hoffa fracture
outcomes were different [2,15,18e20]. It is generally accepted that applied in our study need to be evaluated deeply in further study.
the screw heads are recessed beneath the articular surface. Some- In summary, it suggests that cannulated or lag screws combined
times, internal fixation assisted with arthroscopy could be helpful with a locking plate provided an adequate stability and earlier
to restore the article surface [21]. A biomechanical study showed active rehabilitation for the patients with medial Hoffa fracture to
that cannulated screws placed from posterior to anterior provided estore knee function. Our surgical treatment of the medial Hoffa
more stable fixation of Hoffa fractures in embalmed femurs than fracture seems to present good clinic results while combined with
anteroposteriorly placed cannulated screws [22]. However, there early active rehabilitation.
was also a report of screw fixation failure in osteoporotic Hoffa
fracture [15]. Conflict of interest
The key factors for Hoffa fracture healing contain blood supply
and fixation stability. Therefore, the firmness of fixation is partic- The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
ularly important. Favorable biomechanical and clinical results had
shown that the locking plate with a fixed-angle design could pro- References
vide angular stability of the fracture if applied appropriately
[23,24]. It was shown that two screws with cross direction were [1] A. Hoffa, Lehrbuch der Frakturen und Luxationen, fourth ed., Ferdinand Enke-
sufficient for the fixation of Hoffa fractures [6,25]. Shi [26] reported Verlag, Stuttgart, 1904, p. 453.
[2] S.M. Holmes, D. Bomback, M.R. Baumgaertner, Coronal fractures of the femoral
12 cases of lateral Hoffa fractures treated with a locking plate and condyle: a brief report of five cases, J. Orthop. Trauma 18 (2004) 316e319.
cannulatedor lag screws. According to Knee Society Score, 6 pa- [3] M.S. Dhillon, A.K. Mootha, K. Bali, S. Prabhakar, S.S. Dhatt, V. Kumar, Coronal
tients got an excellent result, and 6 got good. Bone Unions were fractures of the medial femoral condyle: a series of 6 cases and review of
literature, Musculoskeletal Surg. 96 (2012) 49e54.
achieved in all patients. No loss of reduction and fixation appeared.
[4] A. Karim, N. Rossiter, Isolated medial unicondylar hoffa fracture following
There was no evidence of deep infection after 3 years follow-up. traumatic knee dislocation, Inj. Extr. 37 (2006) 12e14.
In this study, we used additional locking plate device to fix the [5] A. Ocguder, M. Bozkurt, T. Kalkan, Hoffa fracture, eminentia fracture and
posterior cruciate ligament damage: an unusual knee injury, Inj. Extr. 39
fragment providing stronger support after compression with one or
(2008) 88e91.
two cannulated screws. On the other hand, the locking plate was [6] S.L. Lewis, J.L. Pozo, W.F. Muirhead-Allwood, Coronal fractures of the lateral
used as an anti-sliding plate to avoid secondary displacement, femoral condyle, J. Bone Jt. Surg. Br. 71 (1989) 118e120.
especially at vertical displacement. As a result, instantly biome- [7] A.P. Singh, I.K. Dhammi, R. Vaishya, A.K. Jain, A.P. Singh, P. Modi, Nonunion of
coronal shear fracture of femoral condyle, Chin. J. Traumatol. 14 (2011)
chanical stability was achieved, patients were allowed active knee 143e146. Zhonghua chuang shang za zhi Chinese Medical Association.
movement immediately after the operation without any external [8] R. Glass, J. Waddell, B. Hoogenboom, The effects of open versus closed kinetic
brace or cast. Meanwhile, bone union was all found three to six chain exercises on patients with ACL deficient or reconstructed knees: a
systematic review, North Am. J. Sports Phys. Ther. NAJSPT 5 (2010) 74e84.
months after the fixation and earlier good knee function was [9] C. Mikkelsen, S. Werner, E. Eriksson, Closed kinetic chain alone compared to
achieved. combined open and closed kinetic chain exercises for quadriceps strength-
For correcting knee flexion and extension deficits, the rehabili- ening after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with respect to return to
sports: a prospective matched follow-up study, Knee Surg., Sports Traumatol.,
tation protocol is necessary. The therapeutic goals such as con- Arthrosc. 8 (2000) 337e342 official journal of the ESSKA.
trolling pain and edema, preserving quadriceps function, achieving [10] E. von Elm, D.G. Altman, M. Egger, S.J. Pocock, P.C. Gotzsche,
more than 90 of knee flexion and functional knee, and returning to J.P. Vandenbroucke, The strengthening the reporting of observational studies
in epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational
activity and sports, often need to be addressed by rehabilitation studies, Int. J. Surg. 12 (2014) 1495e1499.
methods [27]. During the period of hospitalization, the rehabilita- [11] M. Piqueras, E. Marco, M. Coll, F. Escalada, A. Ballester, C. Cinca, R. Belmonte,
tion program of patients was implemented with the help of phy- J.M. Muniesa, Effectiveness of an interactive virtual telerehabilitation system
in patients after total knee arthoplasty: a randomized controlled trial,
sicians, but due to the special conditions in China, like economic
J. Rehabil. Med. 45 (2013) 392e396.
condition, health care system, bed conversion and farmer-workers’ [12] C. Thakar, The Hoffa fractureea fracture not to miss, Emerg. Med. J. EMJ 27
migration, it is hard for the Chinese patients to take rehabilitation (2010) 391e392.
exercise in hospital. Tele-rehabilitation is a promising alternative to [13] P.A. Ostermann, K. Neumann, A. Ekkernkamp, G. Muhr, Long term results of
unicondylar fractures of the femur, J. Orthop. Trauma 8 (1994) 142e146.
traditional face-to-face therapies after discharge from open [14] K. Bali, A.K. Mootha, S. Prabhakar, M.S. Dhillon, Isolated Hoffa fracture of the
reduction and internal fixation, especially for those patients who medial femoral condyle in a skeletally immature patient, Bull. NYU Hosp. Jt.
102 M. Gao et al. / International Journal of Surgery 19 (2015) 95e102