Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Citation: Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data 31, 387 (2002); doi: 10.1063/1.1461829
View online: http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.1461829
View Table of Contents: http://aip.scitation.org/toc/jpr/31/2
Published by the American Institute of Physics
International Equations for the Saturation Properties of Ordinary Water Substance. Revised According to the
International Temperature Scale of 1990. Addendum to J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 16, 893 (1987)
Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data 22, 783 (2009); 10.1063/1.555926
A New Equation of State for Carbon Dioxide Covering the Fluid Region from the Triple-Point Temperature to
1100 K at Pressures up to 800 MPa
Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data 25, 1509 (2009); 10.1063/1.555991
共Received 20 September 2001; revised manuscript received 20 December 2001; published 7 June 2002兲
In 1995, the International Association for the Properties of Water and Steam 共IAPWS兲
adopted a new formulation called ‘‘The IAPWS Formulation 1995 for the Thermody-
namic Properties of Ordinary Water Substance for General and Scientific Use’’, which we
abbreviate to IAPWS-95 formulation or IAPWS-95 for short. This IAPWS-95 formula-
tion replaces the previous formulation adopted in 1984. This work provides information
on the selected experimental data of the thermodynamic properties of water used to
develop the new formulation, but information is also given on newer data. The article
presents all details of the IAPWS-95 formulation, which is in the form of a fundamental
equation explicit in the Helmholtz free energy. The function for the residual part of the
Helmholtz free energy was fitted to selected data for the following properties: 共a兲 thermal
properties of the single-phase region (p T) and of the vapor–liquid phase boundary
( p ⬘ ⬙ T), including the phase-equilibrium condition 共Maxwell criterion兲, and 共b兲 the
caloric properties specific isochoric heat capacity, specific isobaric heat capacity, speed of
sound, differences in the specific enthalpy and in the specific internal energy, Joule–
Thomson coefficient, and isothermal throttling coefficient. By applying modern strategies
for optimizing the functional form of the equation of state and for the simultaneous
nonlinear fitting to the data of all mentioned properties, the resulting IAPWS-95 formu-
lation covers a validity range for temperatures from the melting line 共lowest temperature
251.2 K at 209.9 MPa兲 to 1273 K and pressures up to 1000 MPa. In this entire range of
validity, IAPWS-95 represents even the most accurate data to within their experimental
uncertainty. In the most important part of the liquid region, the estimated uncertainty of
IAPWS-95 ranges from ⫾0.001% to ⫾0.02% in density, ⫾0.03% to ⫾0.2% in speed of
sound, and ⫾0.1% in isobaric heat capacity. In the liquid region at ambient pressure,
IAPWS-95 is extremely accurate in density 共uncertainty ⭐⫾0.0001%兲 and in speed of
sound 共⫾0.005%兲. In a large part of the gas region the estimated uncertainty in density
ranges from ⫾0.03% to ⫾0.05%, in speed of sound it amounts to ⫾0.15% and in isobaric
heat capacity it is ⫾0.2%. In the critical region, IAPWS-95 represents not only the
thermal properties very well but also the caloric properties in a reasonable way. Special
interest has been focused on the extrapolation behavior of the new formulation. At least
for the basic properties such as pressure and enthalpy, IAPWS-95 can be extrapolated up
to extremely high pressures and temperatures. In addition to the IAPWS-95 formulation,
independent equations for vapor pressure, the densities, and the most important caloric
properties along the vapor–liquid phase boundary, and for the pressure on the melting
and sublimation curve, are given. Moreover, a so-called gas equation for densities up to
55 kg m⫺3 is also included. Tables of the thermodynamic properties calculated from the
IAPWS-95 formulation are listed in the Appendix. © 2002 American Institute of Phys-
ics.
Key words: critical region, data evaluation, equation of state, extrapolation, fundamental equation,
H2O , IAPWS-95 formulation, melting curve, property tables, sublimation curve, thermal and caloric
properties, vapor–liquid phase boundary, water substance.
0047-2689Õ2002Õ31„2…Õ387Õ149Õ$35.00 387 J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, Vol. 31, No. 2, 2002
388 W. WAGNER AND A. PRUß
2.1. The Triple Point. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 398 5.4. Functional Forms for r and the Bank of
2.2. The Critical Point. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 398 Terms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 423
2.3. The Vapor–Liquid Phase Boundary. . . . . . . . . 398 5.4.1. Polynomial Terms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 423
2.3.1. Experimental Data and Equations for 5.4.2. Polynomial Terms in Combination
the Vapor Pressure and the Densities with Exponential Functions. . . . . . . . . . 423
of the Saturated Liquid and Vapor. . . . 398 5.4.3. Modified Gaussian Bell-Shaped
2.3.2. Experimental Data for the Caloric Terms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
Difference Property ⌬␣ and Equations 5.4.4. Nonanalytical Terms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
for the Enthalpy and Entropy of 5.4.5. Bank of Terms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 425
the Saturated Liquid and Saturated 5.5. Determination of the Final Form of the
Vapor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 400 IAPWS-95 Formulation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 426
2.4. The Solid–Liquid and Solid–Vapor Phase 5.5.1. Summarizing Information on the
Boundaries. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 401 Sorts of Data Used. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 426
2.4.1. The Melting–Pressure Equations. . . . . . 401 5.5.2. Iterative Process of the Development
2.4.2. The Sublimation–Pressure Equation. . . 401 of the IAPWS-95 Formulation. . . . . . . . 426
3. The Gas Equation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 401 6. The IAPWS-95 Formulation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 427
3.1. Density Range and Input Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . 402 6.1. Reference Constants. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 428
3.2. Details of the Gas Equation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 402 6.2. Numerical Description of the IAPWS-95
3.3. Comparison of the Gas Equation with Formulation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 429
Experimental Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 403 6.3. Basic Information on the Application of the
4. The Selected Experimental Data and Other Data IAPWS-95 Formulation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 432
Used to Develop IAPWS-95 and Further 6.3.1. Range of Validity. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 432
Experimental Data for Comparison. . . . . . . . . . . . . 403 6.3.2. Estimates of Uncertainty. . . . . . . . . . . . 432
4.1. Vapor–Liquid Phase Boundary. . . . . . . . . . . . . 405 6.3.3. Computer-Program Verification. . . . . . . 435
4.1.1. Thermal Properties in the Saturation 6.4. Features of the Nonanalytical Terms Used
State. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 405 for IAPWS-95. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 435
4.1.2. Caloric Properties in the Saturation 6.4.1. Positive Features of the Nonanalytical
State. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 405 Terms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 435
4.2. Single-Phase Region. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 406 6.4.2. Weaknesses of the Nonanalytical
4.2.1. p T Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 407 Terms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 437
4.2.2. Second Virial Coefficients. . . . . . . . . . . 410 6.4.3. Nonanalytical Terms Proposed by
4.3. Speeds of Sound. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 410 Kiselev and Friend. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 441
4.4. Isochoric Heat Capacities. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 412 6.4.4. Summary of the Advantages and
4.5. Isobaric Heat Capacities. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 413 Weaknesses of the Nonanalytical
4.5.1. Data of the Specific Isobaric Heat Terms in IAPWS-95. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 441
Capacity in the Ideal-Gas State. . . . . . . 413 7. Comparison of the IAPWS-95 Formulation with
4.5.2. Experimental Data of the Specific Experimental Data and Values from Other
Isobaric Heat Capacity. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 414 Equations of State. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 442
4.6. Enthalpy Differences. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 416 7.1. The Vapor–Liquid Phase Boundary. . . . . . . . . 443
4.7. Joule–Thomson Coefficient. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 416 7.1.1. Thermal Properties at Saturation. . . . . . 443
4.8. Isothermal Throttling Coefficient. . . . . . . . . . . 416 7.1.2. Speeds of Sound at Saturation. . . . . . . . 444
4.9. Hugoniot-Curve Data and Derived p T 7.1.3. Isochoric Heat Capacities at
Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 417 Saturation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 445
4.10. Calculated Data for the Gas Region. . . . . . . 418 7.1.4. Isobaric Heat Capacities at
4.11. Data for Special Applications. . . . . . . . . . . . 418 Saturation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 445
5. Details of the Development of the IAPWS-95 7.1.5. The Caloric Difference Property ⌬␣
Formulation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 419 and the Enthalpies at Saturation. . . . . . 446
5.1. Basic Structure of an Equation of State 7.2. The Representation of Properties in the
Explicit in the Helmholtz Free Energy. . . . . . 419 Single-Phase Region. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 446
5.2. The Equation for the Helmholtz Free 7.2.1. p T Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 446
Energy of the Ideal Gas. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 419 7.2.1.1. Temperature Range T
5.3. Basic Statements for Fitting and Optimizing ⬍273.16 K. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 446
the Structure of an Equation for the 7.2.1.2. Temperature Range 273.16 K
Residual Part of the Helmholtz Free Energy.. 420 ⭐T⬍643.15 K. . . . . . . . . . . . . 447
5.3.1. Fitting an Equation for r to Data. . . . 420 7.2.1.3. Critical Region 643.15 K⭐T
5.3.2. Basic Statements for Optimizing the ⬍663.15 K. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 449
Mathematical Form of r. . . . . . . . . . . 422 7.2.1.4. Temperature Range 663.15 K
⭐T⬍1273.15 K. . . . . . . . . . . . 450
J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, Vol. 31, No. 2, 2002
THERMODYNAMIC PROPERTIES OF ORDINARY WATER 389
7.2.1.5. Comparison with the IAPS 4.4. Information on the selected p T data. . . . . . . . . 406
Skeleton Table Values at 4.5. Information on the selected data for the speed
High Pressures and of sound w. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 411
High Temperatures. . . . . . . . . . 450 4.6. Information on the selected data for the
7.2.2. Second and Third Virial Coefficients. . 451 specific isochoric heat capacity. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 413
7.2.3. Speed of Sound. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 452 4.7. Information on data sets for the isobaric heat
7.2.4. Isochoric Heat Capacity. . . . . . . . . . . . . 455 capacity of water in the ideal-gas state. . . . . . . . 413
7.2.5. Isobaric Heat Capacity. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 459 4.8. Information on the selected data for the
7.2.6. Enthalpy Differences. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 464 specific isobaric heat capacity c p . . . . . . . . . . . . . 414
7.2.7. Joule–Thomson and Isothermal
4.9. Information on the selected data of the caloric
Throttling Coefficient. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 465
properties enthalpy difference ⌬h, Joule–
7.2.8. Isentropic Temperature–Pressure
Thomson coefficient , and isothermal throttling
Coefficient. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 468
7.3. Selected Attributes of the IAPWS-95 coefficient ␦ T . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 416
Formulation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 468 5.1. Contribution of the several linear, nonlinear,
7.3.1. Derivatives of the Thermal Properties and linearized data to the weighted sum of
in the Liquid Phase. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 468 squares for the fitting and optimization process.. 421
7.3.2. Representation of Thermodynamic 5.2. Parameters of the modified Gaussian bell-shaped
Properties in Metastable Regions. . . . . 472 terms according to Eq. 共5.37兲 which are
7.3.2.1. Subcooled Liquid. . . . . . . . . . . 472 contained in the bank of terms, Eq. 共5.41兲. . . . . . 425
7.3.2.2. Superheated Liquid. . . . . . . . . . 473 5.3. Parameters of the nonanalytical terms according
7.3.2.3. Subcooled Vapor. . . . . . . . . . . . 474 to Eq. 共5.40兲 which are contained in the bank
7.3.3. Extrapolation Behavior. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 475 of terms, Eq. 共5.41兲. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 426
7.3.3.1. Hugoniot Curve and p T 5.4. Summarizing information on the selected data
Behavior at Extreme used in the linear optimization procedure and
Pressures and Temperatures. . . 475 in the nonlinear fitting process when
7.3.3.2. Ideal Curves. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 476 developing the IAPWS-95 formulation. . . . . . . . 427
8. Uncertainty of the IAPWS-95 Formulation. . . . . . 478 6.1. Coefficients of Eq. 共6.5兲. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 429
9. Recommendations for Improving the Basis of 6.2. Coefficients and exponents of Eq. 共6.6兲. . . . . . . . 430
the Experimental Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 479 6.3. Relations of thermodynamic properties to the
10. Conclusions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 480 ideal-gas part °, Eq. 共6.5兲, and the residual
11. Acknowledgments. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 480 part r, Eq. 共6.6兲, of the dimensionless
12. References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 481
Helmholtz free energy and their derivatives. . . . 431
13. Appendix: Tables of Thermodynamic Properties
6.4. The ideal-gas part °, Eq. 共6.5兲, of the
of Water. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 485
dimensionless Helmholtz free energy and
its derivatives. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 432
List of Tables 6.5. The residual part r, Eq. 共6.6兲, of the
1.1. Information on selected equations of state for dimensionless Helmholtz free energy and its
water. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 396 derivatives. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 433
2.1. Information on the selected measuring runs for 6.6. Values for the ideal-gas part °, Eq. 共6.5兲, and
the vapor pressure p , the saturated liquid for the residual part r, Eq. 共6.6兲, of the
density ⬘, and the saturated vapor density ⬙... 399 dimensionless Helmholtz free energy together
2.2. Information on the selected data for the caloric
with the corresponding derivatives for two
difference quantity ⌬␣. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 400
combinations of temperature and density. . . . . . . 436
3.1. Coefficients and exponents of the residual part
7.1. The zeroth and first order ideal curves for the
r of the dimensionless Helmholtz free energy,
compression factor Z and their definitions in
Eq. 共3.3兲. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 402
4.1. Information on the selected values of the terms of the compression factor Z( ,T) and of
thermal saturation properties used to develop the residual part of the reduced Helmholtz
the IAPWS-95 formulation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 405 free energy r( ,T) and the condition for the
4.2. Information on the selected values for the second virial coefficient B at the temperature
specific internal energy on the vapor–liquid T end . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 477
phase boundary. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 405 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the
4.3. Information on the selected data for the caloric vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on
properties speed of sound w and specific temperature. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 486
isobaric heat capacity c p of the saturated liquid 13.2. Thermodynamic properties of water in the
and vapor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 406 single-phase region. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 495
6.13. Isochoric heat capacity along several 7.7. Percentage deviations of the experimental data
near-critical isochores ⬍ c 共gas region兲 of the isobaric heat capacity of the saturated
calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, in a small liquid c ⬘p and the isobaric heat capacity of the
temperature range above the saturation saturated vapor c ⬙p from the corresponding
temperature.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 440 values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . 445
6.14. Speed of sound along several near-critical 7.8. The caloric difference quantity ⌬␣ related to
isochores ⬎ c 共liquid region兲 calculated ⌬T 共with ⌬T⫽1 K兲 as a function of temperature
from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, in a small calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲,
temperature range above the saturation IAPS-84, and the equation of Hill 共1990兲.. . . . . . 446
temperature.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 440 7.9. Percentage deviations of the experimental data
6.15. Isochoric heat capacity along the vapor–liquid of the caloric difference quantity ⌬␣ and
values of the Skeleton Tables IST-85 with their
phase boundary as a function of density
tolerances 关IAPWS 共1994兲兴 of the enthalpy
calculated from IAPWS-95, an IAPWS-95-like
of the saturated liquid h ⬘ and the enthalpy of the
equation without nonanalytical terms, and
saturated vapor h ⬙ from the corresponding
the crossover equation of Kostrowicka
values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . 446
Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 440
7.10. Percentage density deviations between
6.16. Speed of sound along the vapor–liquid phase experimental p T data and values calculated
boundary as a function of density calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 447
from IAPWS-95, an IAPWS-95-like equation 7.11. Percentage density deviations between
without nonanalytical terms, and the experimental p T data and values calculated
crossover equation of Kostrowicka from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 448
Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 441 7.12. Percentage density deviations between very
7.1. Percentage deviations of the experimental data accurate experimental p T data and values
of the vapor pressure p , the saturated liquid calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . 449
density ⬘, and the saturated vapor density 7.13. Percentage density deviations 100 ⌬ /
⬙ from the corresponding values calculated ⫽100( exp⫺calc)/ exp between highly
from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 442 accurate experimental p T data along the
7.2. Percentage deviations 100 ⌬ ⬘ / ⬘ ⫽100( exp ⬘ isobar p⫽0.101 325 MPa and values calculated
⬘ )/ exp
⫺calc ⬘ between experimental data of the from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 449
saturated liquid density ⬘ and values 7.14. Parts-per-million density deviations 106 ⌬ /
calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . 443 ⫽106 ( exp⫺calc)/ exp between highly accurate
7.3. Percentage deviations of the experimental data experimental p T data along the isobar p
of the vapor pressure p , the saturated liquid ⫽0.101 325 MPa and values calculated from
density ⬘, and the saturated vapor density IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 449
⬙ from the corresponding values calculated 7.15. Percentage density deviations 100⌬ /
from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, for the temperature ⫽100( exp⫺calc)/ exp between the p T
range from 10 K below the critical data of Wiryana et al. 共1998兲 for temperatures
temperature up to T c .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 443 from 353.15 to 473.15 K and values
7.4. The vapor–liquid phase boundary in the calculated with IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . 450
7.16. Percentage pressure deviations between
critical region of the p – diagram calculated
experimental p T data in the critical region
from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, the
and values calculated from IAPWS-95,
equation of Hill 共1990兲, and the crossover
Eq. 共6.4兲; the density range of the diagrams
equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al.
clearly exceeds the critical region.. . . . . . . . . . . . 450
共2000兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 444
7.17. Percentage density deviations between
7.5. Percentage deviations of the experimental data
experimental p T data and values calculated
of the speed of sound of the saturated liquid from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 451
w ⬘ and the speed of sound of the saturated vapor 7.18. Percentage density deviations of experimental
w ⬙ from the corresponding values calculated p T data and values of the Skeleton Tables
from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 444 IST-85 关IAPWS 共1994兲兴 together with
7.6. Percentage deviations 100 ⌬c ⬘v /c ⬘v ⫽100(c ⬘v ,exp their tolerances from values calculated with
⫺c⬘v,calc)/c ⬘v ,exp between experimental data of IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 452
the isochoric heat capacity of the saturated 7.19. Second virial coefficient B as a function of
liquid c ⬘v and values calculated from IAPWS-95, temperature as calculated from IAPWS-95,
Eq. 共6.4兲. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 445 Eq. 共6.4兲; the experimental data are plotted for
7.46. Percentage density deviations 100⌬ / 7.58. The ideal curves in a double logarithmic p/p c
⫽100( exp⫺calc)/ exp between accurate vs T/T c diagram as calculated from IAPS-84
experimental p T data for the isotherm T and the equation of Hill 共1990兲; the curves
⫽273.15 K and values calculated from calculated from IAPWS-95 are plotted
IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 469 for comparison.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 478
7.47. Percentage differences of values of the 7.59. Second virial coefficient at very high
derivatives ( / p) T and ( / T) p for the four temperatures as calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq.
pressures 0.1, 1, 10, and 100 MPa calculated 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, the equation of Hill 共1990兲,
with IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 and the virial equation of Hill and MacMillan
from values calculated with IAPWS-95, Eq. 共1988兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 478
共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 470 7.60. The ideal curves in a / c vs log (T/T c)
7.48. Values of the derivatives ( 2 / p 2 ) T , diagram as calculated from IAPWS-95,
( 2 / T 2 ) p , and ( 2 / p T) as a function of Eq. 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, and the equation of Hill
pressure for the temperatures 273.15 and 共1990兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 478
298.15 K and ( 2 / T 2 ) p as a function of
temperature for p⫽0.101 325 MPa as calculated Nomenclature
from IAPWS-95, IAPS-84, and the equation
Latin symbols
of Hill 共1990兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 471
7.49. Percentage density deviations 100⌬ / a,b,c,d,
⫽100( exp⫺calc)/ exp between experimental A,B,C,D Adjustable parameters
p T data in the subcooled liquid along B Second virial coefficient
the isobar p⫽0.101 325 MPa and values c Density exponent
calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . 472 cp Specific isobaric heat capacity
7.50. Percentage deviations 100⌬w/w⫽100(w exp cv Specific isochoric heat capacity
⫺wcalc)/w exp between experimental data of the c Specific heat capacity along the
speed of sound w in the subcooled liquid saturated-liquid line
along the isobar p⫽0.101 325 MPa and values C Third virial coefficient
calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . 472 d Density exponent
7.51. Comparison between experimental data of the d Derivative
isobaric heat capacity c p in the subcooled D Fourth virial coefficient
liquid for the isobar p⫽0.101 325 MPa and E Fifth virial coefficient
values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, f Specific Helmholtz free energy
IAPS-84, and the equation of Hill 共1990兲.. . . . . . 472 g Specific Gibbs free energy
7.52. Percentage density deviations between h Specific enthalpy
experimental p T data in the superheated liquid i, j,k,l,m Serial numbers
共left of the phase-boundary line兲 and values I,J,K,L,M Maximum values of the serial numbers
calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . 473 i, j,k,l,m
7.53. Percentage deviations between experimental M Molar mass, number of data
data of the speed of sound w in the superheated n Adjustable coefficient
liquid 共left of the phase-boundary line兲 and p Pressure
values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . 474 R Specific gas constant
7.54. The liquid spinodal of the vapor–liquid Rm Molar gas constant
two-phase region as calculated from s Specific entropy
IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, and the t Temperature exponent
equation of Hill 共1990兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 474 T Thermodynamic temperature, ITS-90
7.55. Comparison of the Hugoniot curve as calculated u Specific internal energy
from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, the v Specific volume
equation of Saul and Wagner 共1989兲, and the w Speed of sound
equation of Hill 共1990兲 with the corresponding x,y Independent variables
experimental data.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 475 z Any thermodynamic property
7.56. Plot of three p T isotherms in the pressure– Z Compression factor 关 Z⫽ p/( RT) 兴
density diagram at extremely high pressures as
calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, Greek symbols
IAPS-84, and the equation of Hill 共1990兲.. . . . . . 475 ␣,,␥,⌬,⑀, Adjustable parameters
7.57. The so-called ideal curves in a double ␣,,␥,␦ Critical exponents
logarithmic p/p c vs T/T c diagram as calculated ␣ Special caloric property, Eq. 共2.9兲
from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 477  Special caloric property, Eq. 共2.3兲
冎
Critical point
Temperature T c⫽647.096 K see Sec. 2.2
Pressure p c⫽22.064 MPa
Density c⫽322 kg m⫺3
Triple point
冎
Temperature T t⫽273.16 K see Sec. 2.1
Pressure p t⫽611.655 Pa Eq. 共6.4兲c
Density 共liquid兲 t⬘ ⫽999.793 kg m⫺3
Density 共vapor兲 t⬙ ⫽0.004 854 58 kg m⫺3
Normal boiling point
Temperature T b⫽373.124 K Eq. 共6.4兲c
p b⫽0.101 325 MPa
冎
Pressure
Density 共liquid兲 ⬘b ⫽958.367 kg m⫺3 Eq. 共6.4兲c
Density 共vapor兲 ⬙b ⫽0.597 657 kg m⫺3
Reference state
共liquid state at the
triple point兲
Specific internal energy
Specific entropy
Specific enthalpy
u ⬘t ⫽0
s ⬘t ⫽0
h ⬘t ⫽0.611 872 J kg⫺1
冎 see Sec. 6.2
Eq. 共6.4兲c
c
Calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, by solving the phase-equilibrium condition, Eqs. 共6.9a兲–共6.9c兲.
1. Introduction quality, their different nature and the extremely large number
of data 共about 20 000 values兲, water cannot be compared
1.1. Background with any other substance. However, a continuous description
Of all pure fluid substances, water and steam, or ‘‘ordinary of the thermodynamic properties of water over the entire
water substance’’ as it is sometimes called, or simply H2 O, is thermodynamic surface can only be achieved with a suitable
equation of state that is able to represent all the data consid-
without doubt the most important substance in existence. It is
ered to be reliable to within their experimental uncertainty.
used as a working fluid in power cycles which supply elec-
Since 1970, international research regarding the thermo-
tricity in huge amounts to power the industrialized world and
physical properties of water and steam has been coordinated
for numerous other technical applications. In addition to its
by the International Association for the Properties of Steam
use in energy engineering, in chemical engineering and 共IAPS兲, which later changed its name to the International
chemistry, water is the most common solvent. Not only is Association for the Properties of Water and Steam 共IAPWS兲.
H2 O an extremely important substance in classical technical IAPWS members come from most of the important industrial
applications, but also in very modern technical fields such as countries. IAPWS is responsible for the international stan-
supercritical water oxidation. Supercritical water has been dards for several thermophysical properties. These standards
examined as a very convenient medium for special chemical and recommendations are given in the form of releases and
reactions to destroy hazardous waste. No less important than guidelines. One of the most important standards in this sense
these technical applications is the fact that water plays an is the equation of state for the thermodynamic properties of
essential part in the variation of weather and climate, and its ordinary water substance for general and scientific use.
properties under extreme pressure and temperature are essen-
tial in the field of geology. Finally, water covers more than
two thirds of the earth’s surface, not to mention its seminal
role in living organisms.
1.2. Previous Equations of State
In view of this multitude of applications and the basic
importance of water, a huge number of measurements in a Numerous correlations for the thermodynamic properties
great variety of its properties have been carried out from the of water can be found in the literature, but most of them
beginning of the 20th century until today. Considering their cover only small parts of the fluid region and do not meet
International 1968 IFC-68 273–1073 0–100 Separate equations of 240 p v T,p v ⬘ v ⬙ T,h
Formulation the Gibbs and Helmholtz
Committee free energy for 7
subregions
Keenan et al. 1969 273–1673 0–100 Helmholtz free energy 50 p v T,p v ⬘ v ⬙ T,h ⬘ ,h ⬙
Pollak 1974a 273–1200 0–300 Helmholtz free energy 40 p T,p ⬘ ⬙ T,
Maxwell, h ⬘ ,h ⬙
Haar et al. 1982b IAPS-84c 273–1273 0–1000 Helmholtz free energy 48 p T,p ⬘ ⬙ T,
Maxwell
Saul & Wagner 1989 273–1273 0–25 000 Helmholtz free energy, 58 p T,p ⬘ ⬙ T,
optimized structure Maxwell, c v ,w,w ⬘ ,
c p ,⌬h, , ␦ T ,u ⬙ ⫺u ⬘
Hill 1990 273–1273 0–1000 Helmholtz free energy, 80 p v T,p , v ⬘ , Maxwell, h ⬘ ,h ⬙
optimized structure,
combined with a scaled
equation
a
See also Pollak 共1975兲.
b
See also Haar et al. 共1984兲.
c
Published as IAPS-84 formulation by Kestin and Sengers 共1986兲.
present demands on accuracy. Thus, Table 1.1 summarizes rivative’’ properties such as the isothermal compressibility兲
only the characteristic features of the best equations of state and when extrapolating this equation beyond its range of
that have been published since 1968. validity. The fundamental equation developed by Saul and
The first international standard for the thermodynamic Wagner 共1989兲 was the first equation of state for water that
properties of water and steam for scientific and general use was optimized regarding its functional structure and that was
was the equation package of the IFC-68 关IFC 共1968兲兴. This fitted simultaneously to the experimental data of many dif-
formulation was a further development of the international ferent properties 共so-called multiproperty fitting, see Table
standard for the thermodynamic properties of water and 1.1兲. In 1990, Hill 共1990兲 published a so-called unified fun-
steam for industrial use, the IFC-67 formulation 关IFC damental equation for the thermodynamic properties of H2 O
共1967兲兴; the improvement related essentially to a better rep- that includes the revised and extended scaled equation of
resentation of the critical region. IFC-68 used seven separate Levelt Sengers et al. 共1983兲. It was the first time that an
equations to cover its entire range of validity. However, due analytical wide-range equation was combined with a scaled
to these separate equations, there are clear consistency prob- equation without problems in the transition range; this equa-
lems for some properties. The first wide-ranging single equa- tion provides a smooth transition from the singular scaled
tion of state for water was developed by Keenan et al. equation to the nonsingular wide-range function. The price
共1969兲, which was one of the first fundamental equations in however, for realizing this behavior is the great number of 80
the form of the Helmholtz free energy. This equation, how- fitted coefficients, and more importantly, a rather complex
ever, did not satisfy the phase-equilibrium condition 共Max- functional structure of the entire equation plus, due to the
well criterion兲. A very good equation for water was the fun- incorporation of a scaled equation, the necessity of a recur-
damental equation of Pollak 共1974, 1975兲, which has a range sive calculation of internal variables in the scaled part. Due
of validity in pressure up to 300 MPa. This equation meets to the use of the original scaled equation of 1983 关Levelt
the phase-equilibrium condition so that the saturation prop- Sengers et al. 共1983兲兴 the critical point of Hill’s equation is
erties along the vapor–liquid phase boundary can be calcu- slightly different from the critical point of H2 O as agreed by
lated from this equation without using a separate vapor– IAPWS 共1992兲.
pressure equation. In 1984, the Helmholtz-free-energy It should be pointed out that none of these wide-range
equation developed by Haar et al. 共1982, 1984兲 was adopted equations is based on the current International Temperature
by IAPS as a new international standard. We will refer to this Scale of 1990 共ITS-90兲, see Preston-Thomas 共1990兲, as they
formulation as IAPS-84; for the corresponding publication were all developed before 1990.
see Kestin and Sengers 共1986兲. This equation was the first to Besides the wide-range equations of state mentioned
cover a pressure range up to 1000 MPa, and over wide above, there are also special equations for the critical region
ranges of pressure and temperature IAPS-84 represents the of H2 O. One of these equations is the revised and extended
thermodynamic properties of water very well. However, in scaled equation of Levelt-Sengers et al. 共1983兲 which is a
the years following 1984 it became clear that IAPS-84 mani- part of the unified fundamental equation of Hill 共1990兲. The
fested some substantial weaknesses near the critical point most recent equation of this kind is the crossover equation
共particularly regarding the phase boundary and in its ‘‘de- developed by Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲. This
equation has been included in the corresponding compari- Thermodynamic Properties of Water and Steam’’ abbreviated
sons with experimental data of the critical region, see Sec. 7. to IAPWS-IF97 was adopted. IAPWS-IF97, which is de-
signed for the special needs of the steam power industry, was
1.3. Need for the Development of a New developed based on input data calculated from the new sci-
Scientific Formulation and Adoption of the entific formulation IAPWS-95 described in this article. In
IAPWS-95 Formulation this way, the industrial standard for the thermodynamic prop-
erties of water and steam is coupled to the corresponding
It becomes apparent from the summary of previous scien- scientific standard, the IAPWS-95 formulation. Full informa-
tific equations of state that they all have several smaller or tion on the industrial standard IAPWS-IF97 can be found in
greater deficiencies, and that a new equation of state for H2 O the article by Wagner et al. 共2000兲.
was needed.
At the IAPWS meeting in Buenos Aires in 1990, it was
agreed that a new scientific standard equation should be de- 1.5. Note on the Values of Temperature Used
veloped in order to replace IAPS-84. The task group of Throughout this Article
IAPWS for dealing with this development consisted of Pro-
fessor J. V. Sengers 共USA兲 as chairman and Professors P. G. With regard to the numerical values used for the thermo-
Hill 共Canada兲 and W. Wagner 共Germany兲. The new scientific dynamic temperature throughout this article the following
formulation was required to meet the following three main information is given:
requirements: 共i兲 No distinction is made between the thermodynamic
temperature T and the temperature T 90 of the currently valid
共i兲 based on ITS-90; International Temperature Scale of 1990 共ITS-90兲, see
共ii兲 based on an updated data set; and Preston-Thomas 共1990兲. This is because the ITS-90 is the
共iii兲 improved behavior in the critical region, in metastable best approximation of the thermodynamic temperature
regions, of the first and second derivatives in the liq- within the present experimental uncertainties.
uid region at low temperatures and pressures, and 共ii兲 All correlation equations for the thermodynamic prop-
when extrapolating to very high pressures and high erties along the several phase boundaries, the so-called gas
temperatures. equation, and the IAPWS-95 formulation refer to the ITS-90.
共iii兲 The temperature values of the available experimental
Taking these requirements into account, new equations of data, based on older temperature scales and referred to in this
state were developed in two groups, namely in Professor article, were converted to ITS-90. The conversion from the
Hill’s group at the University of British Columbia in Vancou- IPTS-68 temperature scale to ITS-90 temperatures was car-
ver 共Canada兲 and in Professor Wagner’s group at the Ruhr- ried out based on conversion equations given by Rusby
Universität Bochum in Bochum 共Germany兲. After having 共1991兲 for T⬍903.15 K and by Rusby et al. 共1994兲 for
finished these developments, the two candidate equations 903.15 K⭐T⭐1337.15 K. Data corresponding to the
were comprehensively tested by the IAPWS Task Group IPTS-48 temperature scale were converted to IPTS-68 ac-
‘‘New Scientific Formulation—Evaluation,’’ which was cording to the procedure given by Bedford and Kirby 共1969兲.
chaired by J. Gallagher 共USA兲. Both equations gave very 共iv兲 Values calculated from literature equations that are
good results with small advantages and disadvantages for used in the corresponding figures for comparison purposes,
each. In 1995, after careful consideration, IAPWS at its were, if necessary, converted from their original temperature
meeting in Paris adopted the equation of state developed by scale to ITS-90 values.
Pruß and Wagner 共1995a,1995b兲 as the new scientific stan-
dard under the name ‘‘The IAPWS Formulation 1995 for the
Thermodynamic Properties of Ordinary Water Substance for 2. Phase Equilibria of Water
General and Scientific Use,’’ which we shall refer to in the
following as the IAPWS-95 formulation or IAPWS-95 for
Figure 2.1 shows several phase–boundary curves for wa-
short. The final form of the IAPWS release that describes
ter in a p – T diagram. In this section information on the
IAPWS-95 in detail was adopted at the IAPWS meeting in
following data and equations is given:
Fredericia 共Denmark兲 in 1996 关IAPWS 共1996兲兴; the essential
information from this release can be found in Sec. 6. The 共i兲 The internationally accepted values for the parameters
IAPWS-95 formulation replaces the previous scientific for- of the triple point and critical point.
mulation IAPS-84. 共ii兲 The selected experimental data for the vapor pressure,
the saturated liquid density, the saturated vapor den-
1.4. Existence of the New Industrial Formulation sity, and the differences of the internal energy on the
IAPWS-IF97 vapor–liquid phase boundary.
共iii兲 Correlation equations for the properties vapor pres-
The reader should be informed that in 1997 at the IAPWS sure, saturation densities, specific enthalpy, specific
meeting in Erlangen 共Germany兲 a new formulation for indus- internal energy, and specific entropy along the vapor–
trial use called ‘‘IAPWS Industrial Formulation 1997 for the liquid phase boundary.
冉 冊
T c⫽ 共 647.096⫾ ⑀ 兲 K with ⑀ ⫽0.01, 共2.2a兲
p Tc
ln ⫽ 共 a 1 ⫹a 2 1.5⫹a 3 3
p c⫽ 共 22.064⫾0.27⑀ ⫾0.005兲 MPa, 共2.2b兲 pc T
c⫽ 共 322⫾3 兲 kg m⫺3 . 共2.2c兲 ⫹a 4 3.5⫹a 5 4 ⫹a 6 7.5兲 , 共2.5兲
TABLE 2.1. Information on the selected measuring runs for the vapor pressure p , the saturated liquid density
⬘, and the saturated vapor density ⬙
dp
dT
⫽⫺
p
T
ln
p
pc冋冉 冊
⫹a 1 ⫹1.5a 2 0.5⫹3a 3 2
ln 冉 冊
⬙
c
⫽c 1 2/6⫹c 2 4/6⫹c 3 8/6
TABLE 2.2. Information on the selected data for the caloric difference
quantity ⌬␣
Number of data
Temperature Uncertainty
Authors range/K ⌬共⌬␣兲 Total Selected
computer-program verification of Eqs. 共2.5兲–共2.7兲 can be FIG. 2.3. Percentage deviations 100⌬(⌬ ␣ )/⌬ ␣ ⫽100(⌬ ␣ exp⫺⌬␣calc)/
found in the article of Wagner and Pruss 共1993兲. ⌬ ␣ exp between experimental data of the caloric difference quantity ⌬␣ and
values calculated from Eq. 共2.9兲.
It should be pointed out that Eqs. 共2.5兲–共2.7兲 are only
auxiliary equations for calculating properties along the
vapor–liquid phase boundary. Although the differences be-
tween the results from these equations and the corresponding 19 9
results from the IAPWS-95 formulation, Eq. 共6.4兲, are ex- ⫽d ⫹ d 1 ⫺20⫹d 2 ln ⫹ d 3 3.5
0 20 7
tremely small, these equations are not thermodynamically
consistent with IAPWS-95. Nevertheless, the application of 5 109
these auxiliary equations might be useful for simple calcula- ⫹ d 4 4⫹ d 53.5, 共2.9a兲
4 107 5
tions of these saturation properties or for the determination
of starting values when iteratively calculating the saturation where ␣ 0 ⫽1 kJ kg⫺1 , 0 ⫽ ␣ 0 /T c , ⫽T/T c , T c⫽647.096
properties from IAPWS-95 according to the phase- K, and the coefficients are d ␣ ⫽⫺1135.905 627 715, d
equilibrium condition. ⫽2319.5246, d 1 ⫽⫺5.651 349 98⫻10⫺8 , d 2 ⫽2690.666 31,
d 3 ⫽127.287 297, d 4 ⫽⫺135.003 439, and d5
⫽0.981 825 814. The values of the coefficients d ␣ and d
were determined according to the international agreement so
2.3.2. Experimental Data for the Caloric Difference Property ⌬␣
and Equations for the Enthalpy and Entropy of the
that the zero points of the specific internal energy and the
Saturated Liquid and Saturated Vapor specific entropy are met for the saturated liquid at the triple
point 关namely u ⬘t ⫽0, s t⬘ ⫽0, see also Eq. 共6.7兲兴. Figure 2.3
Up to now it has not been possible to measure directly shows the comparison between the experimental ⌬␣ values
values of the enthalpy and internal energy along the vapor– and the values calculated from Eq. 共2.9兲. 共In all such devia-
liquid phase boundary of H2 O. Thus, for a system consisting tion plots, points shown at the top or bottom edge have de-
of a gas and liquid phase, 关in addition to the quantities  and viations larger than the scale of the plot.兲
␥, see Eqs. 共2.3兲 and 共2.4兲兴, Osborne measured the caloric The equations for calculating the specific values of the
difference quantity ⌬␣, which basically corresponds to the enthalpy h, the internal energy u, and the entropy s for the
difference of the internal energy between two temperatures saturated liquid and the saturated vapor are summarized as
in the two-phase region. For this quantity the following re- follows:
lation exists:
Specific enthalpy
⌬ ␣ ⫽h ⬘ ⫺⌬ vh
v⬘
v ⬙⫺ v ⬘
, 共2.8兲
h⬘ ␣
⫽ ⫹103
kJ kg⫺1 ␣ 0
T/K dp
⬘ / 共 kg m⫺3 兲 dT 冉 冊冒冉 冊 MPa
K
,
共2.10兲
where ⌬␣ depends only on temperature. Table 2.2 summa-
rizes the information on these selected measuring runs of the
caloric difference quantity ⌬␣.
h⬙ ␣
⫽ ⫹103
kJ kg⫺1 ␣ 0
T/K dp
⬙ / 共 kg m⫺3 兲 dT 冉 冊冒冉 冊 MPa
K
.
共2.11兲
A correlation equation for ␣ ⫽ ␣ (T) allows the calculation
of the enthalpy, internal energy, and entropy along the phase
boundary, for details see Saul and Wagner 共1987兲. On the Specific internal energy
basis of this article, Wagner and Pruss 共1993兲 made the co-
efficients of the equation for ␣ and its integrated form
consistent with the ITS-90 temperature scale. The equations
u⬘ ␣
⫽ ⫹103
T dp
K dT 冉 冊冒冉 冊
MPa
K
⫺
p
MPa
, 共2.12兲
and the converted coefficients read: kJ kg⫺1 ␣ 0 ⬘ / 共 kg m⫺3 兲
␣
⫽d ␣ ⫹d 1 ⫺19⫹d 2 ⫹d 3 4.5⫹d 4 5 ⫹d 5 54.5, 共2.9兲
u⬙ ␣
⫽ ⫹103
T dp
K dT 冉 冊冒冉 冊
MPa
K
⫺
p
MPa
. 共2.13兲
␣0 kJ kg⫺1 ␣ 0 ⬙ / 共 kg m⫺3 兲
冉 冊冒冉 冊
⫽1⫺0.295 252共 1⫺ 60兲 , 共2.17兲
dp MPa pn
s⬘ dT K with ⫽T/T n , T n⫽251.165 K, and p n⫽209.9 MPa.
⫽ ⫹10
3
,
kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 ⫺3
⬘ / 共 kg m 兲 Melting–pressure equation for ice V (temperature range
共2.14兲 from 256.164 to 273.31 K):
s⬙
⫽
⫹10 3
冉 冊冒冉 冊
dp
dT
MPa
K
.
p m,ice
pn
V
⫽1⫺1.187 21共 1⫺ 8 兲 , 共2.18兲
kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 ⫺3
⬙ / 共 kg m 兲
共2.15兲 with ⫽T/T n , T n⫽256.164 K, and p n⫽350.1 MPa.
Melting–pressure equation for ice VI (temperature range
In order to evaluate Eqs. 共2.10兲–共2.15兲 the quantities ␣ / ␣ 0 , from 273.31 to 355 K):
, ⬘, ⬙, p , and dp /dT are calculated from Eqs. 共2.9兲,
共2.9a兲, 共2.6兲, 共2.7兲, 共2.5兲, and 共2.5a兲. Values for computer- p m,ice VI
program verification of these equations are given by Wagner ⫽1⫺1.074 76共 1⫺ 4.6兲 , 共2.19兲
and Pruss 共1993兲. pn
For remarks regarding the usefulness of Eqs. 共2.10兲– with ⫽T/T n , T n⫽273.31 K, and p n⫽632.4 MPa.
共2.15兲 and their consistency related to IAPWS-95, see the Melting–pressure equation for ice VII (temperature range
end of Sec. 2.3.1. from 355 to 715 K):
the above mentioned article. Although these equations were ⫹34.707 823 8共 1⫺ ⫺1.25兲 , 共2.21兲
not directly used for the development of the IAPWS-95 for- with ⫽T/T n , T n⫽273.16 K, and p n⫽0.000 611 657 MPa.
mulation, the equations are presented here because they mark For further details and values for computer-program verifi-
the boundaries between the fluid phase 共for which cation see Wagner et al. 共1994兲.
IAPWS-95 is valid兲 and the solid phase.
TABLE 3.1. Coefficients and exponents of the residual part r of the dimen- heat capacity c p , Joule–Thomson coefficient , and isother-
sionless Helmholtz free energy, Eq. 共3.3兲
mal throttling coefficient ␦ T . Due to the density range con-
i di ti ni sidered here, only data with ⭐55 kg m⫺3 were used. Infor-
mation on all data selected for the development of the
1 1 0.25 0.474 865 925 9
IAPWS-95 formulation is summarized in Sec. 4; for the data
2 1 1.25 ⫺0.112 437 055 3⫻101
3 1 3.5 ⫺0.811 862 740 1 considered in connection with the gas equation see Secs. 4.2,
4 1 12 ⫺0.621 301 850 1⫻10⫺3 4.3, 4.5, 4.7, and 4.8. Figures 4.1, 4.5, 4.8, and 4.9, which
5 2 1.5 0.192 443 099 3 show the data distribution in corresponding p – T diagrams,
6 2 13.5 ⫺0.832 286 766 2⫻10⫺1 contain the isochoric line ⫽55 kg m⫺3 to illustrate which
7 4 8.75 0.139 105 223 0⫻101
part of the gas region and which data sets were involved. In
total, 604 p T data, 112 w data, 90 c p data, 234 data, and
180 ␦ T data were used to develop the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲.
steam region, the establishment of this gas equation is of These data had to be represented by the gas equation to
primary importance and is therefore described in this section. within their experimental uncertainty.
For ‘‘normal’’ substances, a simple virial equation, 3.2. Details of the Gas Equation
p Like the IAPWS-95 formulation, Eq. 共6.4兲, the gas equa-
⫽1⫹B 共 T 兲 • ⫹C 共 T 兲 • 2 ⫹D 共 T 兲 • 3 ⫹E 共 T 兲 • 4
RT tion is a fundamental equation for the specific Helmholtz free
energy f. This equation is expressed in dimensionless form,
⫹... , 共3.1兲 ⫽ f /(RT), and is separated into two parts, an ideal-gas part
truncated after the term with the third virial coefficient C(T) ° and a residual part r, so that:
is able to cover the fluid region up to densities of 0.5 c f 共 ,T 兲
within the experimental uncertainty of the data. For the ‘‘dif- ⫽ 共 ␦ , 兲 ⫽ ° 共 ␦ , 兲 ⫹ r共 ␦ , 兲 , 共3.2兲
ficult’’ substance water, such a truncated virial equation can RT
only cover the gas region very accurately for densities up to where ␦ ⫽ / c and ⫽T c /T with c⫽322 kg m⫺3 , T c
about 0.1 c . It was, however, our aim that the gas equation ⫽647.096 K, and R⫽0.461 518 05 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 . The ideal-
should cover a region up to densities of ⫽55 kg m⫺3 gas part ° of Eq. 共3.2兲 is identical to the ideal-gas part of
⬇0.17 c . In this region, the gas equation should represent IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.5兲.
all thermodynamic properties with the best possible accu- The form of the residual part r of the dimensionless
racy. Helmholtz free energy is:
In order to achieve this aim, the equation was developed 7
by using selected experimental data of the thermal properties ⫽ 兺 n i␦ di ti,
r
共3.3兲
(p T) and the properties speed of sound w, specific isobaric i⫽1
FIG. 3.1. Percentage density deviations between experimental p T data and values calculated from the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲.
FIG. 3.3. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the isobaric heat capacity c p and values calculated from the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲.
the best experimentally investigated fluids. As a basis for the In our comprehensive study to establish such a selected
development of the new equation of state, a comprehensive data set, we took into account all information given in sev-
and consistent data set had to be assembled from a total of eral articles. The article of Sato et al. 共1988兲, which de-
about 20 000 experimental data. scribes the basis of the IAPWS Skeleton Tables of 1985
共IST-85兲, represents a comprehensive investigation regarding
the p T data of the single-phase region; the IST-85 Skeleton
Tables converted to ITS-90 temperatures are given in the
corresponding revised IAPWS release 关IAPWS 共1994兲兴.
Moreover, for our own assessment we considered the analy-
ses of the data used to establish the equations of state of Saul
and Wagner 共1989兲 and of Hill 共1990兲. In addition to this,
there is also the data collection of Sato et al. 共1991兲 that was
initiated by IAPWS and forms the most comprehensive data
collection presently available, consisting of more than 16 000
experimental data for several thermodynamic properties of
H2 O. We examined this data set and the data judged to be of
high quality were incorporated into our selected data set.
It should be clearly pointed out that we critically re-
examined the data used by Saul and Wagner 共1989兲 and by
Hill 共1990兲 for their equations of state. All data were again
checked with regard to their internal consistency and their
basic applicability for the development of an equation of
state to form the new scientific standard. These selected data
sets took into account experimental data which were avail-
able by the middle of 1994.
The experimental data published between May 1991 关the
time up to which Sato et al. 共1991兲 included data for their
collection兴 and the middle of 1994 共the time at which we
took into account data for the development of IAPWS-95兲
did not contain significant new experimental information; for
a comprehensive view of the experimental data of H2 O,
please refer to the study of Sato et al. 共1991兲. Thus, in this
FIG. 3.4. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the Joule-
Thomson coefficient and values calculated from the gas equation, article the information on experimental data is limited to
Eq. 共3.2兲. those data used for the development of the IAPWS-95 for-
TABLE 4.1. Information on the selected values of the thermal saturation properties used to develop the
IAPWS-95 formulation
mulation and to comparisons with data published between 4.1.2. Caloric Properties in the Saturation State
the middle of 1994 and the middle of 2001.
This section presents not only information on the experi- The difference property ⌬␣ 共see Sec. 2.3.2兲 is the only
mental data 共Secs. 4.2– 4.9兲 used to develop IAPWS-95, but caloric property whose measurements cover the entire tem-
also presents information on calculated values 共Secs. 4.1, perature range from the triple point to the critical point with
4.10, and 4.11兲 used as additional input data for the high accuracy, see Table 2.2 and Fig. 2.3. The enthalpies h ⬘
IAPWS-95 formulation. and h ⬙ of the saturated liquid and vapor, respectively, are
directly based on the ␣ values from Eq. 共2.9兲, which repre-
sents the experimental ⌬␣ data. Since the previous scientific
standard IAPS-84 could only represent the h ⬘ values of the
4.1. Vapor–Liquid Phase Boundary IST-85 Skeleton Tables 关IAPWS 共1994兲兴 with systematic de-
viations that are partly outside the IST-85 tolerances, it was
In the course of developing the IAPWS-95 formulation,
desired that the IAPWS-95 formulation behaves clearly bet-
the new equation of state was fitted to values defining the
ter in this respect. Thus, it was decided to incorporate values
vapor–liquid phase boundary. These values are thermal and
of one of the key quantities for a good representation of ␣,
caloric properties calculated from the corresponding auxil-
namely enthalpies or internal energies, into the selected data
iary equations summarized in Sec. 2. Since these auxiliary
set. Since h is distinguishable from u by the product p v ,
equations had resulted from a statistically founded fitting
which consists of purely thermal properties, the internal en-
process to experimental data and since the step size of the
ergy u is the decisive caloric quantity in the saturation state
calculated points is given, the corresponding input values for
and its inclusion in the selected data set is a precondition for
IAPWS-95 can be clearly identified.
a good representation of the ␣ values by IAPWS-95. Besides
(u 2⬘ ⫺u 1⬘ ) values, specific internal energies of vaporization,
4.1.1. Thermal Properties in the Saturation State (u ⬙ ⫺u ⬘ ), were included in the selected data set for devel-
oping IAPWS-95. Table 4.2 gives information on the design
All thermal properties on the vapor–liquid phase bound- of these data sets, including the data distribution on the
ary, i.e., p ⬘ ⬙ T data, which were used to develop the vapor–liquid phase boundary. For given values of tempera-
IAPWS-95 formulation, were calculated from the corre- ture, the u ⬘ and u ⬙ values were calculated from Eqs. 共2.12兲
sponding auxiliary equations given in Sec. 2.3.1 for prese-
lected values of temperature. The exact data set is defined by
Table 4.1. There, it can be seen that in actual fact two data TABLE 4.2. Information on the selected values for the specific internal en-
sets distributed along the phase boundary were used. The ergy on the vapor–liquid phase boundary
p ⬘ ⬙ T data were used in the linear fitting of IAPWS-95 to
Number
p T data points at saturation and to the phase-equilibrium Property of data Temperature range Step size
condition. The data set containing separate p (T), ⬘ (T),
and ⬙ (T) data were used to fit IAPWS-95 nonlinearly to (u 2⬘ ⫺u 1⬘ ), 2⬘ , 1⬙ , T 1 , T 2 74 273.16 K⬍T 1 ⭐638 K ⌬T 1 ⫽5 K
(T 2 ⫺T 1 )⫽5 K
these single p – T, ⬘ – T, and ⬙ – T values, for further de-
(u ⬙ ⫺u ⬘ ), ⬙, ⬘, T 75 273.16 K⬍T 1 ⭐638 K ⌬T⫽5 K
tails see Sec. 5.5.2.
TABLE 4.3. Information on the selected data for the caloric properties speed of sound w and specific isobaric
heat capacity c p of the saturated liquid and vapor
Number of data
Temperature Uncertainty
Authors Property range/K ⌬y a Total Selected
and 共2.13兲 and the corresponding ⬘ and ⬙ values were de- consistent with each other 共see the discussion in Sec. 7.2.4
termined from Eqs. 共2.6兲 and 共2.7兲, respectively. on the c v data in the single-phase region兲. Therefore, these
Experimental data for other caloric properties on the data were not used to develop IAPWS-95, but a comparison
vapor–liquid phase boundary of H2 O are rather limited re- with c ⬘v data is carried out in Fig. 7.6.
garding their number and quality. Information on the best
data sets is given in Table 4.3; these data were used to de- 4.2. Single-Phase Region
velop IAPWS-95. There are also experimental data of the
The International Skeleton Tables of 1985 关共IST-85兲, see
isochoric heat capacity at saturation 共saturated liquid and
saturated vapor from both the single-phase and two-phase Sato et al. 共1988兲兴 in its revision for the ITS-90 temperature
region兲, which were measured by Kerimov 共1964兲, Amirkha- scale 关IAPWS 共1994兲兴 contain a comprehensive set of p T
nov et al. 共1969兲, and Abdulagatov et al. 共1998兲. Unfortu- and enthalpy values. These values were chosen using mea-
nately, however, these data sets from the Dagestan Scientific surements in combination with several equations of state of
Center of the Russian Academy of Sciences are not very that time. Since these values are not direct measurements and
FIG. 4.1. Distribution of the selected p T data used to develop the residual part of IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.6兲, in a p – T diagram. The isochore ⫽55 kg m⫺3 shows
the upper density limit for the p T data used to develop the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲.
are partly based on experimental data that were not consid- Table 4.4 summarizes the information on the selected p T
ered accurate enough to be included in the selected data set data set where the measuring runs, published through 1990,
for IAPWS-95, the IST-85 values 关IAPWS 共1994兲兴 were also were used to develop the IAPWS-95 formulation. In addition
not used for the development of the IAPWS-95 formulation. to the temperature and pressure range covered by each data
For an investigation of the corresponding p T data at high set, the experimental uncertainties of the individual mea-
temperatures and high pressures, see Sec. 7.2.1.5. sured quantities T, p, and are listed. These uncertainties
The tables in the following subsections contain informa- were used in Eq. 共5.8兲 to calculate the weighting factor when
tion on experimental data used to develop the IAPWS-95 the coefficients of the residual part r of IAPWS-95, Eq.
formulation and also on data that are considered to be accu- 共6.6兲, were fitted to the data.
rate enough but were not yet available when IAPWS-95 was Except for converting the original temperature values to
developed. Information on other experimental data, which ITS-90, all p T values of this data set were used as origi-
are only used in comparisons with IAPWS-95 in Sec. 7, is nally given by the original authors with the exception of the
only given in the text. p T data measured by Grindley and Lind 共1971兲; the reason
for correcting the data of Grindley and Lind 共1971兲 is as
4.2.1. p T Data follows. For temperatures up to 423 K and pressures up to
100 MPa, the liquid region is covered by the very accurate
Based on a comprehensive examination of the very great data of Kell and Whalley 共1975兲, see Fig. 4.1. For these
number of existing p T data, 2773 data points were finally temperatures and higher pressures, the liquid region is
selected. Figure 4.1 shows how these selected p T data mainly covered by the p T data of Grindley and Lind
cover the p – T surface of water. 共1971兲. Unfortunately, these two data sets do not fit smoothly
data of Maier and Franck 共1966兲 and of Köster and Franck data at a pressure of 0.101 325 MPa measured in the three
共1969兲 reach up to ⫾1.5% in density, which underlines the studies mentioned above, namely Takenaka and Masui
assessment of these data. As a consequence of these factors, 共1990兲, Patterson and Morris 共1994兲, Masui et al. 共1995/96兲,
the data of Maier and Franck 共1966兲 and of Köster and and in addition the data of Watanabe 共1991兲. As a result, this
Franck 共1969兲 were not included in the selected p T data set Task Group 关Tanaka et al. 共2001兲兴 presented a new formula
and IAPWS-95 was not fitted to these data. In contrast, these for the density–temperature relationship of VSMOW at
less accurate p T data were considered in establishing the 0.101 325 MPa in the temperature range from 273.15 to
Skeleton Tables IST-85 关IAPWS 共1994兲兴, for the conse- 313.15 K. 关In the article of Tanaka et al. 共2001兲, it is said that
quences see Sec. 7.2.1.5. the density–temperature relationship and the corresponding
The last four data sets listed in Table 4.4 cover high- density tables refer to SMOW 共Standard Mean Ocean Wa-
precision measurements of the liquid density at a pressure of ter兲. However, from a note in this article it can be seen that
p⫽0.101 325 MPa. At the Japanese National Research Labo- VSMOW is meant; all the density measurements used to
ratory of Metrology 共NRLM兲, Takenaka and Masui 共1990兲 derive the density–temperature relationship given in this ar-
measured dilatometrically the thermal expansion of purified ticle are based on VSMOW.兴 Using this formula, they calcu-
Japanese tap water 共JTW兲 at temperatures from 273.15 to lated a recommended table for the density of water in this
358.15 K. To obtain absolute density values, they related range, which also contains the uncertainty estimation for
their thermal expansion measurements to the maximum den- each density value 共tabulated every 1 K兲; the uncertainty was
sity max on this isobar near 4 °C in the following way. Pro- estimated to be between 0.84 and 0.87 ppm. The maximum
ceeding from the commonly accepted max value for Vienna density on this isobar was given as ( max⫽999.974 950
Standard Mean Ocean Water 共VSMOW兲 at that time, given ⫾0.000 84) kg m⫺3 at a temperature of 共3.983 035
by the BIPM 共Bureau International des Poids et Mesures, ⫾0.000 67兲 °C. All these more recent VSMOW densities
France兲, and the known isotopic compositions of VSMOW have been included in the comparisons with those values
and the JTW used, Takenaka and Masui transferred the max calculated from IAPWS-95, see Sec. 7.2.1.2.
value of VSMOW to their JTW. 关VSMOW’s isotopic com-
In the last few years, a relatively large number of measure-
position is documented by Gonfiantini 共1978兲 and which is
ments on mixtures have been carried out where one of the
available from the International Atomic Energy Agency in
components is water. Besides the experimental data of the
Vienna.兴 In this way Takenaka and Masui 共1990兲 obtained 79
corresponding mixture, in most of the investigations mea-
density values of JTW in the temperature range mentioned
surements of pure water have also been made, mainly for
above. Moreover, they fitted an (T)/ max equation to their
calibration purposes. One typical example is the article by
data and give for this equation an uncertainty of about 1
Abdulagatov et al. 共1993兲. Those authors measured p T data
ppm. We used this equation, however, not with their max
of water–methane mixtures for temperatures between 523
value of JTW but with the one of VSMOW given by the
and 653 K at pressures from 2 to 64 MPa. However, these
BIPM as max⫽999.975 kg m⫺3 关Menaché and Girard
data are of lower quality than those of other authors who
共1973兲兴. In this way we determined VSMOW densities for
measured only pure water in this region; for example, the
every 5 K between 273.15 and 358.15 K and IAPWS-95 was
fitted to these 18 VSMOW densities, see Table 4.4. scatter of Abdulagatov et al.’s data amounts to ⫾0.4% in
After the development process of IAPWS-95 had been density. Other similar cases of measurements on water,
completed, additional density measurements of VSMOW at where the predominant portion of data has been taken in
p⫽0.101 325 MPa were published. The liquid density mea- connection with measurements of mixtures, were also not
surements of Patterson and Morris 共1994兲 were carried out at taken into account for the selected p T data set; examples of
the CSIRO National Measurement Laboratory 共Australia兲. such measurements are Kubota et al. 共1987兲 and Yokoyama
By hydrostatic weighing they measured absolute densities at and Takahashi 共1989兲.
temperatures from 274.15 to 313.15 K. They give an uncer- Wiryana et al. 共1998兲 reported p T data for temperatures
tainty for their densities ranging from 0.6 ppm at 288.15 K to from 353.15 to 473.15 K at pressures up to 3500 MPa. Al-
1.4 ppm at 313.15 K. At NRLM, Masui et al. 共1995兲 mea- though these data are not direct density measurements but
sured the absolute density of VSMOW at 289.15 K by hy- were derived from their speed-of-sound measurements 共see
drostatic weighing. Separately, they measured dilatometri- the second to the last paragraph of Sec. 4.3兲, these p T data
cally the thermal expansion of their VSMOW samples for can be used for extrapolation tests of IAPWS-95, see Sec.
temperatures from 273.15 to 358.15 K. Using the results of 7.2.1.2.
these measurements, they developed a (T) equation for the There are also p T data in the two metastable regions:
temperature range of their measurements; the measured ab- subcooled liquid 共metastable with respect to the solid兲 and
solute density at 289.15 K is given in the article by Masui superheated liquid 共metastable with respect to the vapor兲. In
et al. 共1995/96兲. For this (T) equation, an uncertainty be- the subcooled liquid there are two accurate p T data sets
tween 0.9 ppm at 273.15 K and 1.3 ppm at 358.15 K is along the isobar p⫽0.101 325 MPa. The data of Kell 共1975兲,
claimed by the authors. Very recently, a Task Group, formed to which IAPWS-95 was fitted for T⬍273.15 K, cover tem-
by the Working Group on Density of the Consultative Com- peratures from 236 to 268 K, see Table 4.4, and the data of
mittee for Mass and Related Quantities, analyzed the density Hare and Sorensen 共1987兲 are in the temperature range from
240 to 268 K. In Sec. 7.3.2.1 these data are compared with low temperatures, Kell et al. 共1989兲 limited their B values to
the p T values calculated from IAPWS-95. References of 423 K, where their B value at 423 K is clearly more uncer-
further p T data on this isobar of the subcooled liquid can tain than for temperatures above 423 K, see Sec. 7.2.2. The
be taken from Fig. 7.49; these data show systematic devia- p T data of Eubank et al. 共1988兲 are clearly more uncertain
tions from the two data sets mentioned above. In the super- than those of Kell et al. 共1989兲 and are, therefore, also
heated liquid, there are two data sets to which IAPWS-95 clearly outside the uncertainty of IAPWS-95 regarding the
was not fitted. The p T data of Chukanov et al. 共1971兲 cover p T data in this range. However, due to their corrections for
temperatures from 413 to 504 K at pressures from 0.06 to 4 adsorption effects, the B values of Eubank et al. 共1988兲 are
MPa, while the data of Evstefeev et al. 共1977兲 range from the best second virial coefficients at 373, 403, and 423 K.
508 to 571 K at pressures from 0.1 to 9.4 MPa; some of these The most recent B values of Hendl et al. 共1997兲 are esti-
data are in the stable liquid range of H2 O. Comparisons of mated to be less accurate than the data mentioned before for
these data with values from IAPWS-95 can be found in Sec. this temperature range. The high temperature region up to
7.3.2.2. 1173 K is covered by the second virial coefficients of
Vukalovich et al. 共1967兲. The article of Le Fevre et al.
共1975兲 contains tabulated B values which are not measure-
4.2.2. Second Virial Coefficients
ments 共although often quoted as being such兲, but they were
The information on the second and third virial coefficients, calculated from an equation for the second virial coefficient.
B and C, of water vapor 共steam兲 determined through 1989 For temperatures from 293 to 413 K this equation was fitted
was summarized by Sato et al. 共1991兲. More recent experi- to 关 B⫺T(dB/dT) 兴 values derived from isothermal throttling
mental B values were determined by Hendl et al. 共1997兲. experiments 关mainly ␦ T,0 data of Wormald 共1964兲 which are
However, the IAPWS-95 formulation was not fitted to any of identical to that of McGlashan and Wormald 共2000兲兴 and for
these B and C data for reasons described in the following temperatures from 423 to 1173 K it was fitted to B values
paragraphs. References regarding the experimental data of derived from p T data. This equation is less accurate for
the second and third virial coefficient are given in Figs. 7.19 temperatures below 450 K and particularly below 348 K; in
and 7.20. this low temperature region, based on our assessment, this
Virial coefficients cannot be measured directly. In most equation yields B values that are systematically too high.
cases they are determined from p T measurements and, Based on all the facts discussed above, the IAPWS-95
more seldom, from measurements of the properties speed of formulation was not fitted to any second virial coefficients
sound, Joule–Thomson coefficient 共isenthalpic throttling co- with the exception of a few very high-temperature B values
efficient兲, and isothermal throttling coefficient. However, all calculated from the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲, for details see
experimental data sets on B and C mentioned above are Sec. 4.10. Nevertheless, in Sec. 7.2.2 second and third virial
based on p T measurements. Such values of the virial coef- coefficients calculated from IAPWS-95 will be compared
ficients contain absolutely no additional information beyond with the experimental B and C values described above.
the original p T data, and they are clearly more uncertain
than the p T data themselves for the following reason. The 4.3. Speeds of Sound
B and C values considered here were obtained from correla-
tion equations for the isothermal p T data by extrapolating Due to the relatively high accuracy of the experimental
to the density ⫽0; in this way, uncertainties of the p T data data of the 共isentropic兲 speed of sound w of H2 O, this prop-
result in increased uncertainties of the second virial coeffi- erty provides a very sensitive test of derivatives in the course
cients, so that the B values are more uncertain than the origi- of developing an equation of state. Table 4.5 lists information
nal p T data. This problem is even more pronounced for low on the selected speed of sound data used to fit the IAPWS-95
temperatures, because in this range the isotherms are very formulation. Figure 4.5 shows the distribution of these se-
short due to their upper pressure limit at the phase boundary lected w data in a p – T diagram. From Figs. 4.1 and 4.5, it
共vapor pressure兲, see Fig. 4.1. In addition, at these low pres- can be seen that in the gas region there are two data sets, the
sures and temperatures there are adsorption effects that tend p T data of Kell et al. 共1989兲 and the w data of Novikov and
to dominate over the nonideality effects. Therefore, virial Avdonin 共1968兲. The doubts regarding Kell et al.’s data on
coefficients derived from p T data at low temperatures and the isotherms 423 and 448 K, mentioned in Sec. 4.2.1, are
pressures have rather large uncertainties, and a fit of an equa- confirmed by the speed of sound data in this region.
tion of state to such B and C data may do more harm than Of special importance are the measurements of the speed
good. of sound in the liquid phase at ambient pressure. These data
The most accurate p T data in the gas region of H2 O are were measured with very good agreement by two groups of
without a doubt the data of Kell et al. 共1989兲. Thus, the B experimenters, namely by Del Grosso and Mader 共1972兲 and
data derived by Kell et al. 共1989兲 from their p T data are the by Fujii and Masui 共1993兲. These high-precision speed-of-
most accurate values of the second virial coefficient for the sound data, which have absolute uncertainties of only
temperature range from 448 to 773 K, the upper temperature ⫾0.015 m s⫺1 corresponding to relative uncertainties of
limit of Kell et al.’s p T data, see Table 4.4. Taking into about ⫾10 ppm, serve as calibration points for many pieces
account the difficulties in determining virial coefficients at of equipment to measure the speed of sound of liquid water.
TABLE 4.5. Information on the selected data for the speed of sound w
Unfortunately, there are no accurate speed-of-sound data point. The w data closest to the critical point of water were
for the critical region. The decrease of the speed of sound to measured by Erokhin and Kal’yanov 共1979兲, 共1980兲. How-
very small values when approaching the critical point is ever, for reasons mentioned above, these data do not ap-
nearly impossible to measure because frequency-dependent proach the critical point very closely, and consequently the
dispersion effects become significant close to the critical smallest values of these speed-of-sound data are on the order
FIG. 4.5. Distribution of the selected data of the speed of sound used to develop the residual part of IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.6兲, in a p – T diagram. The isochore
⫽55 kg m⫺3 shows the upper density limit for the w data used to develop the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲.
of 300 m s⫺1. Thus, equations of state for water are, with 4.4. Isochoric Heat Capacities
respect to the critical region, experimentally more deter-
mined by p T data than by speed-of-sound data. Therefore, Between 1962 and 2001, a great number of data of the
the w data of Erokhin and Kal’yanov 共1979兲, 共1980兲 were isochoric heat capacity c v for H2 O were measured at the
only used for comparison purposes 共see Sec. 7.2.3兲 and not Dagestan Scientific Center of the Russian Academy of Sci-
for the development of the IAPWS-95 formulation. ences. Information on the c v data published through 1975
Wiryana et al. 共1998兲 reported speed-of-sound data for can be found in the article by Sato et al. 共1991兲; in this
H2 O at temperatures between 353.15 and 473.15 K at pres- period of time, the only data set not measured at the Dag-
sures up to 3500 MPa measured with a diamond-anvil high- estan Scientific Center is that of Baehr and Schomäcker
pressure cell. For their temperature range, these w data fill 共1975兲. The more recent c v data sets are those of Abdulaga-
the gap in the selected data for pressures between 100 and tov et al. 共1995兲, Abdulagatov et al. 共1998兲, Magee et al.
1000 MPa, see Fig. 4.5; for their estimated uncertainty see 共1998兲, Abdulagatov et al. 共2000兲, and Polikhronidi et al.
Table 4.5. Moreover, since these data extend to pressures 共2001兲. Figure 4.6 illustrates that these c v data cover the
which are 3.5 times as high as IAPWS-95’s range of validity entire density region from about 20 to 1000 kg m⫺3 for tem-
for pressure 共1000 MPa兲, these data are useful for extrapola- peratures up to about 70–100 K above the saturation tem-
tion tests of IAPWS-95, see Sec. 7.2.3. perature, and for densities up to 200 kg m⫺3 also to tempera-
As with the p T data, there are speed-of-sound data in the tures up to about 1000 K 共not shown in Fig. 4.6兲.
metastable regions of subcooled liquid and superheated liq- The positive feature of the Dagestan data is that they in-
uid. The w data in the subcooled liquid are only on the isobar clude the immediate vicinity of the critical point and illus-
p⫽0.101 325 MPa and seem to be inconsistent with the ac- trate experimentally the strong increase of c v in the critical
curate p T data in this metastable region. The references to region. Unfortunately, these data are clearly more uncertain
these data can be taken from Fig. 7.50; IAPWS-95 was not than estimated by the authors. There are considerable incon-
fitted to these data. In the superheated liquid there are the sistencies of up to 20% between the c v data sets of the dif-
data of Evstefeev et al. 共1979兲, which cover a temperature ferent papers, but inconsistencies of up to 5% and more can
range from 423 to 573 K at pressures from 0.1 to 9.9 MPa. also be observed within the same data set; for details see Sec.
The comparison with these data, to which IAPWS-95 was 7.2.4. Such inconsistencies are visible in the older data and
not fitted, is given in Sec. 7.3.2.2. also in the more recent data. Therefore, we decided not to fit
TABLE 4.6. Information on the selected data for the specific isochoric heat capacity
Baehr & Schomäcker 共1975兲 649– 691 213–396 ¯ ⫾0.3% ⫾5% 414 113b
Magee et al. 共1998兲 304.5– 413.5 935–996 ¯ ¯ ⫾0.3% 278 ¯c
a
The uncertainties in ⌬T are taken into account in the uncertainty in isochoric heat capacity.
b
Only data from the single-phase region were selected.
c
These data were only available after the development of IAPWS-95 had been finished.
the IAPWS-95 formulation to any of the Dagestan data. to 20 000 K. The c ⴰp data set based on the most recent statis-
Thus, IAPWS-95 was only fitted to those c v data of Baehr tical mechanical model is that of Vidler and Tennyson
and Schomäcker 共1975兲 which cover the single-phase region; 共2000兲.
data from the two-phase region were not taken into account. The lower part of Table 4.7 contains information on a
Information on these c v data and the most recent c v measure- well-known correlation equation for the c ⴰp values of H2 O
ments of Magee et al. 共1998兲 is summarized in Table 4.6. and on c ⴰp values published in the most recent editions of two
Section 7.2.4 presents examples of comparisons between the well-known tables for caloric data in the ideal-gas state, the
experimental c v data mentioned above and the corresponding TRC Tables 共1988兲 and the NIST-JANAF Tables 关Chase
values calculated from IAPWS-95. 共1998兲兴. The c ⴰp equation developed by Cooper 共1982兲 was
In the last few years, the group at the Dagestan Scientific fitted to Woolley’s data of 1980 for temperatures from 130 to
Center has also published c v data for mixtures where H2 O is 2000 K. Cooper’s equation, given as Eq. 共5.5兲, represents the
one of the components, e.g., Abdulagatov and Dvoryan- c ⴰp data of Woolley 共1980兲 very well. This c ⴰp equation was
chikov 共1993兲 and Abdulagatov et al. 共1997兲. These papers adopted for the ideal-gas part of IAPWS-95, see Sec. 5.2.
also contain a few c v data for pure water, which are, how- The c ⴰp values given in the TRC Tables 共1988兲 are based on
ever, sometimes republications of older measurements. The the c ⴰp data ‘‘1984 version’’ of Woolley 共1987兲, where, for
article of Abdulagatov and Dvoryanchikov 共1993兲, for ex- T⬎1000 K, the c ⴰp values are not only printed at every 1000
ample, contains c v data for H2 O which were previously pub- K as in Woolley’s article but also intermediate values are
lished by Amirkhanov et al. 共1969兲. listed. In contrast to the TRC Tables, the c ⴰp values given in
the NIST-JANAF Tables 关Chase 共1998兲兴 are based again on
4.5. Isobaric Heat Capacities the c ⴰp data of Woolley 共1980兲.
In Fig. 4.7 the seven c ⴰp data sets defined in Table 4.7 are
This section describes both the situation regarding the data plotted as percentage deviations in comparison with the c ⴰp
of the specific isobaric heat capacity in the ideal-gas state c ⴰp values from the ideal-gas part of IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.5兲,
and regarding the experimental data of the specific isobaric which corresponds to the c ⴰp equation of Cooper 共1982兲, Eq.
heat capacity c p of H2 O 共in the real-fluid state兲. The knowl- 共5.5兲. The upper deviation diagram covers temperatures up to
edge of the c ⴰp behavior is necessary for the development of 3000 K, while the temperature range of the lower diagram
any equation of state that covers caloric properties. extends to 1273 K corresponding to the range of validity of
4.5.1. Data of the Specific Isobaric Heat Capacity IAPWS-95. From the upper diagram, it can be seen that the
in the Ideal-Gas State three c ⴰp data sets of Woolley are not consistent with each
other; even the ‘‘1982 version’’ and the ‘‘1984 version’’ c ⴰp
According to Eq. 共5.4兲, knowledge of the specific isobaric data of Woolley 共1987兲 are not in agreement. Unfortunately,
heat capacity in the ideal-gas state, c ⴰp , forms the basis for
the description of the ideal-gas part of the Helmholtz free TABLE 4.7. Information on data sets for the isobaric heat capacity of water in
energy. Such c ⴰp data are usually calculated from statistical the ideal-gas state
mechanical models with the aid of spectroscopic data.
Table 4.7 lists in its upper part information on those c ⴰp Temperature
Source Number of data range T/K
data sets obtained within 共about兲 the last 20 yr from such
statistical mechanical models. The c ⴰp data set that is most c ⴰp data calculated from statistical mechanical models
widely used is that of Woolley 共1980兲, which covers tem- Woolley 共1980兲 259 10– 4000
peratures up to 4000 K. In order to extend the c ⴰp data of H2 O Woolley 共1987兲, 1982 version 18 200–10 000
up to 10 000 K, Woolley modified his statistical mechanical Woolley 共1987兲, 1984 version 18 200–10 000
Gurvich et al. 共1989兲 101 100–20 000
model 共e.g., inclusion of centrifugal effects, modifications of
Vidler & Tennyson 共2000兲 38 100– 6 000
rotational and vibrational cutoff effects兲. Depending on the
c ⴰp values represented by a correlation equation and by well-known tables
kind of modification, Woolley 共1987兲 published two different
c ⴰp data sets called ‘‘1982 version’’ and ‘‘1984 version.’’ The Equation of Cooper 共1982兲 130–2 000
TRC Tables 共1988兲
fourth c ⴰp data set based on a statistical mechanical model 30 0–5 000
NIST-JANAF Tables 关Chase 共1998兲兴 62 0– 6 000
was reported by Gurvich et al. 共1989兲; these data extend up
FIG. 4.7. Percentage deviations between the data of the isobaric heat capac- Nearly all the data for the isobaric heat capacity c p for
ity in the ideal-gas state c ⴰp from statistical mechanical models and from
water are based on measurements of Sirota’s group in the
property tables, respectively, and values calculated from the ° equation of
IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.5兲. former Soviet Union in the period from 1956 to 1970. Since
then, only two further c p data sets have been published that
were used for fitting the IAPWS-95 formulation. These are
he does not give any uncertainty values for his c ⴰp data, nei- the measurements of Angell et al. 共1982兲, who investigated
ther for the data published in 1980 nor in 1987, nor does he subcooled liquid water at ambient pressure, and the high-
make any statement as to which of the two data sets of 1987 pressure c p data measured by Czarnota 共1984兲. The data of
might be the more accurate. The c ⴰp data of Gurvich 共1989兲 Czarnota 共1984兲 have not yet been confirmed by other ex-
also differ considerably from the other data sets. The exact perimenters. Recently, Archer and Carter 共2000兲 published
agreement of the values from the TRC Tables 共1988兲 with c p measurements for subcooled liquid water, which cover
the ‘‘1984 version’’ data of Woolley 共1987兲 and, for tempera- almost the same region as the data of Angell et al. 共1982兲.
tures to 2000 K, of the values from the NIST-JANAF Tables Table 4.8 gives details on the selected experimental c p data
关Chase 共1998兲兴 with the data of Woolley 共1980兲 show that sets, and Fig. 4.8 presents in a p – T diagram the distribution
TABLE 4.8. Information on the selected data for the specific isobaric heat capacity c p
FIG. 4.8. Distribution of the selected data of the isobaric heat capacity used to develop the residual part of IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.6兲, in a p – T diagram. The
isochore ⫽55 kg m⫺3 shows the upper density limit for the c p data used to develop the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲.
of the c p data used to develop IAPWS-95. In the following, 共1982兲. Archer and Carter 共2000兲 give experimental uncer-
additional information on the selected data sets is given and tainties for their c p data of ⫾0.3% at 285 K increasing to
further data sets are discussed. about ⫾1% at 236 K. The comparisons between these two
Levelt Sengers et al. 共1983兲 carried out investigations re- data sets, carried out in Sec. 7.3.2.1, show that there are
garding the behavior of several properties in the critical re- systematic differences between them. Except for the lowest
gion of H2 O. They concluded that the values of the isobaric temperature, where the difference amounts to about 5%, the
heat capacity measured by Sirota and Mal’tsev 共1962a兲 are maximum difference between the two data sets is about
not sufficiently consistent with the p T data in the critical 3.2%. Archer and Carter 共2000兲 suggest that the calibration
region. To overcome these inconsistencies, Levelt Sengers of Angell et al.’s 共1982兲 differential scanning calorimeter
et al. 共1983兲 proposed to reduce the temperature values of was in error.
the c p data of the four near-critical isobars 共p In their review article, Sato et al. 共1991兲 list information
⫽22.561 MPa, p⫽23.536 MPa, p⫽24.517 MPa, and p on isobaric heat capacity data measured by Philippi 共1987兲
⫽26.968 MPa兲 by 0.05 K. Our own investigations supported and classify these data into the best category 共category A兲.
this procedure, so we have included these c p data corrected However, in addition to the c p data, which were derived 共as
in the way proposed by Levelt Sengers et al. 共1983兲. is always done兲 from the originally measured ⌬h – ⌬T data,
Angell et al. 共1982兲 did not report experimental uncertain- Philippi 共1987兲 also gave the corresponding information on
ties for their c p data in the subcooled liquid at p these directly measured data, see Table 4.9. Thus, we used
⫽0.101 325 MPa, but gave a value of ⫾1% for the reproduc- his measurements not as c p but as ⌬h data, see Sec. 4.6.
ibility of their data. Based on the scatter of their data and the Since the corresponding paper published in English by Ernst
description of the measurements, we estimated the experi- and Philippi 共1990兲 presents only the c p data and offers no
mental uncertainty to be less than ⫾3% in c p , see Table 4.8. information to determine the corresponding enthalpy differ-
This table also shows that the more recent c p data of Archer ences, we only refer to Philippi 共1987兲 with regard to the
and Carter 共2000兲 for p⫽0.101 325 MPa cover practically ⌬h data. Although the c p data given in both publications
the same temperature range as the data of Angell et al. 关共Philippi 共1987兲 and Ernst and Philippi 共1990兲兴 were not
TABLE 4.9. Information on the selected data of the caloric properties enthalpy difference ⌬h, Joule–Thomson coefficient , and isothermal throttling
coefficient ␦ T
used to develop IAPWS-95, a comparison between these can be seen that the ⌬h data of Castro-Gomez et al. 共1990兲
data and IAPWS-95 is shown in Sec. 7.2.5. are in that part of the liquid region where only the p T data
Wiryana et al. 共1998兲 reported c p data for temperatures of Kell and Whalley 共1975兲 exist.
from 353.15 to 473.15 K and pressures up to 3500 MPa.
However, these data are not direct measurements of the iso-
4.7. Joule–Thomson Coefficient
baric heat capacity, but were derived from their speed-of-
sound measurements 共see the second to the last paragraph of Measurements of the Joule–Thomson coefficient 关
Sec. 4.3兲. For this derivation, they used not only the equation ⫽( T/ p) h 兴 , which is also called the isenthalpic throttling
of state of Saul and Wagner 共1989兲 and IAPS-84 but also the coefficient, are inherently less accurate than other caloric
experimental p T data of Maier and Franck 共1966兲 and Kö- properties. In particular, experimental data of the Joule–
ster and Franck 共1969兲 共which we have not included in the Thomson coefficient do not yield any relevant additional in-
selected p T data set, see the discussion in Sec. 4.2.1兲. On formation if measurements of other caloric properties 共e.g.,
this basis, it is very difficult to estimate the uncertainty of c p and w兲 exist. For this reason, only the data of the gas
Wiryana et al.’s c p data. Nevertheless, in Sec. 7.2.5 these c p region measured by Ertle 共1979兲 were used for fitting
data are compared with values extrapolated from IAPWS-95. IAPWS-95. Information on this measuring run is given in
Table 4.9, and the distribution of these data on the p – T
surface is shown in Fig. 4.9.
4.6. Enthalpy Differences In this range of state, Ertle’s data border on the range of
In contrast to the experimental data for the isobaric heat the p T data of Kell et al. 共1989兲. Based on the relation
capacity, there are only a few measuring runs of enthalpy
differences ⌬h. One characteristic feature of such measure-
ments is that the data of several authors cannot be compared
lim ⫽ T
→0
冉 dB
dT
⫺B
1
cp
,冊 共4.1兲
with each other since the authors normally measure different the data of the gas region also influence an equation of
enthalpy differences; such measurements can only be com- state regarding its second virial coefficient behavior in such
pared with values calculated from an equation of state. This regions where no p T data exist.
problem is commonly overcome by dividing the measured
共small兲 enthalpy difference by the corresponding temperature 4.8. Isothermal Throttling Coefficient
difference and leads then to the known method of determin-
ing isobaric heat capacities. The transition from the differ- In principle, the statement made on the quality of experi-
ence quotient (⌬h/⌬T) p 共which corresponds to the quantity mental data of the Joule–Thomson coefficient 共see Sec. 4.7兲
measured兲 to the differential quotient c p ⫽( h/ T) p is not a is also valid for the data of the isothermal throttling coeffi-
problem as long as the temperature differences are not too cient 关 ␦ T ⫽( h/ p) T 兴 . Due to the relation
large and as long as the c p behavior is sufficiently linear in
␦ T ⫽⫺ c p , 共4.2兲
the temperature range considered. If these preconditions are
not sufficiently well met, then the fitting of the equation of measurements of the isothermal throttling coefficient have a
state directly to the measured enthalpy differences proves to similar influence on the behavior of an equation of state re-
be the more correct procedure. garding the second virial coefficient B as the data. Only
Since the older measurements of enthalpy differences do the ␦ T data of Ertle 共1979兲 were used to fit IAPWS-95. Table
not exhibit the required quality, only the data of Philippi 4.9 lists information on the used ␦ T data measured by Ertle
共1987兲 were used to fit IAPWS-95, see also the remarks in 共1979兲 and Fig. 4.9 shows the distribution of these data in a
Sec. 4.5, and the data of Castro-Gomez et al. 共1990兲; from p – T diagram; the ␦ T data are located at almost the same
Philippi’s data only those taken with the ‘‘second’’ calorim- p – T points as the data for temperatures above 550 K.
eter were selected. Table 4.9 gives information on these two Both data sets, the and ␦ T data, were not used to optimize
measuring runs of the enthalpy differences. Figure 4.9 illus- the structure of IAPWS-95 but only to fit its coefficients after
trates the distribution of these ⌬h data in a p – T diagram. It the structure had been found, for details see Sec. 5.5.2.
FIG. 4.9. Distribution of the selected data of the three properties enthalpy difference, Joule–Thomson coefficient, and isothermal throttling coefficient used to
develop the residual part of IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.6兲, in a p – T diagram. The isochore ⫽55 kg m⫺3 shows the upper density limit for the and ␦ T data used
to develop the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲.
Very recently, McGlashan and Wormald 共2000兲 reported vation relations for mass, momentum, and energy across the
measurements of the isothermal throttling coefficient. These shock wave, such measurements result in the Hugoniot rela-
data, which are the same as given in the Ph. D. thesis of tion
Wormald 共1964兲, cover a temperature range from 313 to
413.19 K at very low pressures up to 82 kPa. By extrapolat-
ing these isothermal ␦ T data to zero pressure, the authors also
h⫺h 0H⫽0.5共 p⫺ p 0H兲 冋 1
⫹
1
0H
.册 共4.3兲
obtained data for the quantity ␦ T,0⫽B⫺T(dB/dT), the iso-
thermal throttling coefficient at zero pressure. For these ␦ T,0 The evaluation of this relation yields data for the enthalpy h
data, estimates of their uncertainties are given by McGlashan as a function of pressure p and density at shock-wave pres-
and Wormald 共2000兲. For the main measuring range from sures up to tens of GPa and temperatures of several thousand
333 to 413 K, these uncertainties extend from 0.8% to 1.4% Kelvins; the index 0H corresponds to the initial state prior to
with increasing temperature. In contrast to the ␦ T,0 data, no the release of the shock wave. Although it is not yet clear
uncertainties are given for the directly measured ␦ T data. whether these measurements describe equilibrium states at
However, one can assume that the uncertainties of the ␦ T all, comparisons with such p h data are the only experimen-
data must be smaller than those of the extrapolated ␦ T,0 data. tal information to test the extrapolation capability of an equa-
Comparisons with the ␦ T and ␦ T,0 data of McGlashan and tion of state to these extreme conditions of pressure and tem-
Wormald 共2000兲 are presented in Sec. 7.2.7. perature.
For water, such shock-wave measurements meeting the
Hugoniot relation, Eq. 共4.3兲, were carried out by Walsh and
4.9. Hugoniot-Curve Data and Derived p T Data Rice 共1957兲, Lyzenga et al. 共1982兲, and Mitchell and Nellis
共1982兲. The corresponding p h data extend to pressures be-
One method used to demonstrate the extrapolation behav- yond 80 000 MPa. These data were not taken into account for
ior of an equation of state at extreme pressures and tempera- the development of the IAPWS-95 formulation, because
tures is examination of how well it represents shock-wave their use would have resulted in nonlinear relations which
measurements of the Hugoniot curve. Based on the conser- require iterative solutions of temperature. However, such an
approach implies the risk of distorting the experimental in- 4.11. Data for Special Applications
formation given by the Hugoniot data because the deter-
mined temperature belonging to the p h data cannot be In this section, three further synthetic data sets used to
checked due to the absence of other p T data under these develop IAPWS-95 are described. Two of these data sets
extreme conditions. Nevertheless, based on the relation cover thermal properties 共p T data兲 and were ‘‘produced’’ to
influence the extrapolation behavior of IAPWS-95. The third
dT⫽
1
cp 冋 冉 冉 冊冊 册
dh⫺ v ⫺T
v
T p
dp 共4.4兲
data set consists of data for the isochoric heat capacity in the
critical region, and was intended to support the development
of IAPWS-95 regarding this difficult region.
The entire development process of IAPWS-95 was started
and estimates for c p and the derivative ( v / T) p , Rice and
by establishing preliminary wide-range equations of state in
Walsh 共1957兲 determined the temperature T for their
Hugoniot–p h data 关Walsh and Rice 共1957兲兴. We strongly the following way. The equations were fitted only to p T
recommend against use of these p T data. Based on our data of the gas region 关determined from the gas equation, Eq.
experience, the fit of an equation of state to these p T data 共3.2兲兴 and to the selected experimental p T data of the entire
yields a totally incorrect plot of the Hugoniot curve, for fur- fluid region including the p ⬘ ⬙ T data in the saturation
ther details see Sec. 7.3.3.1. As mentioned above, IAPWS-95 state 共see Tables 4.4 and 4.1兲. In this way, in the ‘‘difficult’’
was not directly fitted to the Hugoniot–p h data, but the parts of the entire thermodynamic surface 共e.g., critical re-
high-pressure high-temperature behavior defined by these gion, subcooled liquid兲 the preliminary equations of state
data was indirectly taken into account, see Sec. 4.11. In Sec. were not 共negatively兲 influenced by data of properties other
7.3.3.1, IAPWS-95 is compared with the Hugoniot-curve than the very accurate p T data. The aim of establishing
data. such an equation was to achieve a reasonable description of
the high-pressure and high-temperature range, where few if
any reliable experimental data exist.
In this way we succeeded in determining preliminary
4.10. Calculated Data for the Gas Region equations that showed a physically meaningful behavior
As mentioned at the beginning of Sec. 3, to support the when we calculated simultaneously the Hugoniot curve and
development of a wide-range equation it has been necessary the p T behavior in the high-pressure high-temperature
to include input data of several properties calculated from a range, for further details see Sec. 7.3.3.1. In order to ensure
specially developed gas equation, particularly if such data that the positive behavior that had been achieved at this stage
are not available from direct measurements. Thus, such of development could be retained in the following genera-
‘‘synthetic’’ data were calculated from Eq. 共3.2兲, namely 75 tions of equations, 50 p T data were calculated from the
data points for each of the properties density 共p T data兲, respective preliminary equations in the temperature range
specific isochoric heat capacity, and speed of sound. These from 555 to 5300 K at densities from 1500 to 2500 kg m⫺3 to
data cover the temperature range from 273 to 1073 K at support the behavior of the Hugoniot curve. Further, 120
pressures up to 5 MPa. Based on the existing data situation p T data were calculated from these preliminary equations
for H2 O, the use of these data helped to prevent a wide-range for temperatures between 448 and 1273 K and densities from
equation of state consisting of numerous complex functional 1000 to 2500 kg m⫺3 to ensure that IAPWS-95 did not pro-
forms from behaving unphysically for various properties in duce any crossing of isotherms or even a bending of iso-
certain parts of the gas region; for example, the heat capacity therms in the extrapolation range at pressures up to 100 000
of the saturated vapor and the second and third virial coeffi- MPa. In the final stage of the equation development leading
cient at low temperatures. to IAPWS-95, any of the preliminary equations could be
In addition, when using the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲, to used to calculate the 170 synthetic p T data, because all
calculate synthetic p T data for the range of state in which these equations yielded basically the same reasonable p T
experimental data for the Joule–Thomson coefficient and surface in this high-pressure high-temperature region. Thus,
isothermal throttling coefficient exist 关Eq. 共3.2兲 was fitted to the 170 synthetic p T data can also be calculated from the
these and ␦ T data兴, the experimental information based on final equation, the IAPWS-95 formulation itself.
the and ␦ T data could be incorporated in the linear fitting The behavior of caloric properties in the critical region of
procedure as part of optimizing the structure of IAPWS-95, water is covered insufficiently by existing experimental data.
not just in the nonlinear fitting of the coefficients, see Sec. On the one hand, the experimental data near the critical point
5.5.2. were not free of systematic errors so that these data had to be
In order to improve the behavior of IAPWS-95 regarding adjusted using the ‘‘revised and extending scaled equation’’
the representation of the so-called ‘‘ideal curves’’ 共see Sec. of Levelt Sengers et al. 共1983兲, and therefore considerable
7.3.3.2兲, ten values of the second virial coefficient B(T) in corrections in the temperature values given by the experi-
the temperature range from 6000 to 15 000 K were calculated menters for their data were made. This is the case for the
from Eq. 共3.2兲. These high-temperature virial coefficients isochoric heat capacity data of Amirkhanov et al. 共1969兲 and
formed the only data for the second virial coefficient used to the speed of sound data of Erokhin and Kal’yanov 共1979兲,
develop IAPWS-95. 共1980兲. Thus, the real information content of these data is
questionable, see also Secs. 4.3 and 4.4. On the other hand, 5.1. Basic Structure of an Equation of State
the measurements of reliable caloric data end far before the Explicit in the Helmholtz Free Energy
range of interest in the critical region; this is the case for the
c v data of Baehr and Schomäcker 共1975兲. The equation of state described in this article is a funda-
Nevertheless, in order to achieve a consistent description mental equation explicit in the Helmholtz free energy f with
of the critical region it was necessary to calculate synthetic the independent variables density and temperature T. The
c v values in the near-critical region using suitable equations function f ( ,T) is commonly split into a part f ° that repre-
from the literature. When IAPWS-95 was being developed, sents the properties of the ideal gas at given T and and a
the scaled equation developed by Luettmer-Strathmann part f r that takes into account the residual fluid behavior.
共1992兲 was the obvious choice for this procedure; this equa- This convention can be written as
tion corresponds to a parametric crossover model. For the f 共 ,T 兲 ⫽ f ° 共 ,T 兲 ⫹ f r共 ,T 兲 . 共5.1兲
critical region and a greater range outside the critical region,
namely for temperatures from 628 to 800 K (T c Usually, the Helmholtz free energy is used in its dimension-
⫽647.096 K) and densities from 115 to 635 kg m⫺3 ( c less form ⫽ f /(RT) so that Eq. 共5.1兲 becomes
⫽322 kg m⫺3 ), Luettmer-Strathmann fitted the coefficients
共 ␦ , 兲 ⫽ ° 共 ␦ , 兲 ⫹ r共 ␦ , 兲 , 共5.2兲
of her equation to p T, c v , c p , and p ⬘ ⬙ T data calcu-
lated from the equation of state of Saul and Wagner 共1989兲, where ␦ ⫽ / c is the reduced density and ⫽T c /T is the
taking into account the temperature conversion to ITS-90 inverse reduced temperature with c and T c the critical den-
temperatures. sity and the critical temperature, respectively.
Besides the crossover equation of Luettmer-Strathmann Since the Helmholtz free energy as a function of density
共1992兲, c v values were also calculated from the equation of and temperature is one of the four fundamental forms of an
state of Hill 共1990兲. This was done because Hill’s equation equation of state, all thermodynamic properties of a pure
yields better results for the extended critical region than substance can be obtained by combining derivatives of Eq.
Luettmer-Strathmann’s equation. The reason for this is that, 共5.2兲. For the relations between Eq. 共5.2兲 and its derivatives
in the transition region between the critical and extended and the thermodynamic properties considered in this paper,
critical region, Hill’s equation is better than that of Saul and see Table 6.3.
Wagner 共1989兲 on which Luettmer-Strathmann’s equation
was based.
After careful investigation of Hill’s and Luettmer-
Strathmann’s equations in the critical and extended critical 5.2. The Equation for the Helmholtz Free Energy
region, the following input data for the development of of the Ideal Gas
IAPWS-95 were used: 176 c v values along seven isochores The Helmholtz free energy of the ideal gas is given by
in the critical region for temperatures between 646.24 and
654.92 K and densities from 267 to 400 kg m⫺3 calculated as f ° 共 ,T 兲 ⫽h° 共 T 兲 ⫺RT⫺Ts° 共 ,T 兲 . 共5.3兲
follows: The equation of Luettmer-Strathmann 共1992兲 was
For the ideal gas, the enthalpy h° is a function of tempera-
used to calculate the c v values for T⭐648 K, while for T
ture only, and the entropy s° depends on temperature and
⬎648 K the values were determined from the equation of
density. Both properties can be derived from an equation for
Hill 共1990兲. When calculating these synthetic c v data, we
made allowance for the fact that the two equations and the ideal-gas heat capacity c ⴰp (T). When c ⴰp is inserted into
IAPWS-95 are based on different critical parameters and dif- the expression for h°(T) and s°( ,T) in Eq. 共5.3兲, one ob-
ferent temperature scales. tains
f ° 共 ,T 兲 ⫽ 冉冕T0
T
冊
c ⴰp dT⫹h ⴰ0 ⫺RT
冋冕 冉 冊 册
5. Details of the Development 共5.4兲
T c ⴰp ⫺R
of the IAPWS-95 Formulation ⫺T dT⫺R ln ⴰ ⫹s ⴰ0 ,
T0 T 0
The new equation of state for ordinary water substance is where all variables with the subscript ‘‘0’’ refer to an arbi-
an empirical description of the Helmholtz free energy. For trary reference state.
the development of such empirical formulations, the applica- In order to obtain the equation for f °( ,T) and °共␦,兲,
tion of linear optimization procedures and nonlinear multi- the well-established equation of Cooper 共1982兲 was used for
property fitting algorithms is state-of-the-art. Although this the isobaric heat capacity in the ideal-gas state, c ⴰp (T). This
strategy has already been presented in the literature 关e.g., equation, which is a sum of so-called ‘‘Planck–Einstein’’
Setzmann and Wagner 共1989兲, 共1991兲, Wagner and de Reuck functions, is:
共1996兲, and Span 共2000兲兴, this section summarizes the basic
c ⴰp 共  i /T 兲 2 e ⫺  i /T
5
elements of this strategy along with the special features nec-
essary when developing the new equation of state for H2 O. R
⫽b 0 ⫹ 兺
i⫽1
bi
关 1⫺e ⫺  i /T 兴 2
. 共5.5兲
Cooper determined the coefficients b 0 , b i , and the expo- speed of sound w, ...兲 can be used to determine the unknown
nents  i by nonlinear least-squares fitting to the c ⴰp values of coefficients n i 共expressed as the vector n̄兲 by minimizing the
Woolley 共1980兲, where he took into account only the data for following sum of squares:
temperatures between 130 and 2000 K. After rearranging the
J J Mj
coefficients and exponents, namely n ⴰ3 ⫽b 0 ⫺1, and for
i⫽1 to 5 n i⫹3ⴰ
⫽b i and ␥ i⫹3ⴰ
⫽  i /T c , one obtains from 2⫽ 兺
j⫽1
2j ⫽ 兺 兺
j⫽1 m⫽1
关关 z exp⫺z calc共 x exp ,y exp ,n̄ 兲兴 2 兴 j,m
Eq. 共5.5兲
ⴰ • tot,m , 共5.7兲
c ⴰp 共 ␥ ⴰi 兲 2 e ⫺ ␥ i
8
R
⫽1⫹n ⴰ3 ⫹ 兺 n ⴰi 关 1⫺e ⫺ ␥ 兴 2
i⫽4
ⴰ
i
共5.6兲 where M j is the number of data points used for the jth prop-
erty, z exp is the experimental value for any property z, and
with ⫽T c /T. Equations 共5.5兲 and 共5.6兲 represent the c ⴰp z calc is the value for the property calculated from the equation
values of Woolley 共1980兲 very accurately. The values of the for with the parameter vector n̄ at x exp and y exp . The
coefficients of Eq. 共5.6兲 are given in Table 6.1. In the tem- measured independent variables x and y may vary for the
perature range from 250 to 2000 K, the deviations in c ⴰp /R different properties of z, but usually one of them corresponds
between the values of Woolley 共1980兲 and the values from to temperature T, while the other corresponds to density or
Eqs. 共5.5兲 and 共5.6兲 are less than 0.0005%, and from 140 to pressure p 关e.g., p(T, ) or w(T, )兴. When data sets of dif-
240 K they do not exceed 0.001%. ferent properties are used for the development of a correla-
After inserting c ⴰp (T) according to Eq. 共5.6兲 in Eq. 共5.4兲, tion equation, then the residuum ⌬z⫽(z exp⫺zcalc) of Eq.
working out the integrations and proceeding to the dimen- 共5.7兲 is reduced with a suitable measure for the uncertainty
sionless form of the Helmholtz free energy in the ideal-gas of the data point considered. According to the Gaussian error
state ° 关see Eq. 共5.2兲兴, one obtains the final ° equation, propagation formula, the uncertainty of a measured data
given as Eq. 共6.5兲. point is given by
y,z
2x ⫹ 冋 册
⌬z
y
2
x,z
2y ⫹ 冋 册
⌬z
z
2
x,y
z2 , 共5.8兲
the Structure of an Equation for the
Residual Part of the Helmholtz Free Energy where x , y , and z are the isolated uncertainties of the
single variables x, y, and z, respectively. The partial deriva-
While statistical thermodynamics can predict the behavior
tives of ⌬z have to be calculated from a preliminary equation
of fluids in the ideal-gas state with high accuracy, no physi-
of state.
cally founded equation is known which accurately describes
In order to have an additional influence on the data set, a
the real thermodynamic behavior of fluids in the whole fluid
weighting factor f wt is introduced. The total variance tot
2
of
region. Thus, for this purpose an equation for the residual
a data point used in Eq. 共5.7兲 is defined as
fluid behavior, in this case for the residual part of the Helm-
holtz free energy r, must be determined in an empirical tot
2
⫽ exp
2 2
/ f wt . 共5.9兲
way where, as a matter of course, as much physical under-
standing as possible is taken into account. Since the Helm- In this way, weighting factors f wt⬎1 increase the influence
holtz free energy itself is not accessible to direct measure- of a data point with respect to the sum of squares and
ments, it is necessary to determine the unknown weighting factors f wt⬍1 reduce it. Usually f wt is equal to
mathematical structure and the unknown coefficients of the one and tot
2
is equal to exp
2
. However, in some cases differ-
residual part of the dimensionless Helmholtz free energy ent weighting factors are used to compensate for effects
from properties for which experimental data are available. caused by the structure of the data set.
In this context, the following steps for the development of The determination of n̄ by minimizing 2 for data of more
the final form of an equation for r must be performed: than one property is called ‘‘multiproperty fitting.’’ This
共1兲 selection of the final data set, see Secs. 2– 4; problem leads to a linear system of normal equations if each
共2兲 weighting of the data; of the properties z depends on the same independent vari-
共3兲 precorrelation of auxiliary quantities; ables as the function used 共for example, T and for the
共4兲 linear least squares fitting in connection with the struc- Helmholtz free energy兲 and if the relations between z and the
ture optimization method; and function or its derivatives is linear for all properties consid-
共5兲 nonlinear least squares fitting. ered. Data for such properties are called ‘‘linear data.’’ For
functions in terms of the Helmholtz free energy, examples of
In this section, basic statements on items 共2兲–共5兲 are made. such properties are p(T, ) and c v (T, ), see Table 5.1. If
one or both of these conditions is not fulfilled 关for instance,
5.3.1. Fitting an Equation for r to Data for h(T,p), w(T,p), c p (T,p),..., see also Sec. 5.3.2兴, those
data are called ‘‘nonlinear data’’ and more complicated and
If a certain functional form has been selected for time-consuming nonlinear algorithms must be used to mini-
r( ␦ , ,n̄), data for J different properties z j 共e.g., pressure p, mize the sum of squares, Eq. 共5.7兲. Table 5.1 lists all sums of
TABLE 5.1. Contribution of the several linear, nonlinear, and linearized data to the weighted sum of squares for the fitting and optimization process
Linear data
兺 冋 RT ⫺ 册
M
p⫺RT 2
1 p( ,T) 21⫽ 2
⫺1 r
c ␦ • m⫺2 共5.10兲
m⫽1 m
兺 冋 R ⫹ 共 ⫹ 册
M 2
cv
2 c v ( ,T) 22⫽ 2 ⴰ
兲
r
• m⫺2 共5.11兲
m⫽1 m
冋 册
M 2
3 B(T) 23⫽ 兺
m⫽1
B•c⫺ lim r␦
→0
• m⫺2 共5.12兲
m
Nonlinear data
兺 冋RT⫺1⫺2␦ ⫺ ␦ 册
M
w2 共 1⫹ ␦ r␦ ⫺ ␦ ␦r 兲 2 2
4 w(p,T) 24⫽ r
␦
2
␦␦ ⫹
r
ⴰ • m⫺2 共5.13兲
m⫽1 2
共 ⫹
r
兲 m
兺 冋 R ⫹ 共 ⫹ 册
M
cp ⴰ
共 1⫹ ␦ r␦ ⫺ ␦ ␦r 兲 2 2
5 c p (p,T) 25⫽ 2
兲 ⫺
r
• m⫺2 共5.14兲
m⫽1 1⫹2 ␦ ␦ ⫹ ␦ ␦␦ r 2 r
m
兺 冋RT ⫺ RT ⫺关共 ⫺ 兲 ⫹ ␦ 兴
M
h2 h1 ⴰ
26⫽
r
r
␦ 2
m⫽1 2 1
6 h 2 (p 2 ,T 2 )⫺h 1 (p 1 ,T 1 ) 共5.15兲
⫹ 关 共 ⴰ ⫺ r 兲 ⫹ ␦ r␦ 兴 1 册 2
m
• m⫺2
兺 冋R⫹ 共 1⫹ ␦ ⫺ ␦ 册
M
共␦r␦⫹ ␦ 2 r␦␦ ⫹ ␦ ␦r 兲 2
7 (p,T) 27⫽ ⴰ • ⫺2 共5.16兲
m⫽1
r
␦ ␦ 兲
r 2
⫺ 2
共 ⫹ 兲共 1⫹2 ␦ ␦ ⫹ ␦ ␦␦ 兲 m m
r r 2 r
兺 冋␦ ⫺1⫹ 1⫹2 ␦ ⫹ ␦ 册
M
1⫹␦r␦⫺ ␦ ␦r 2
8 ␦ T (p,T) 28⫽ T r 2 r • m⫺2 共5.17兲
m⫽1 ␦ ␦␦ m
兺 冋 RT 册
M
p,m⫺p 2
9 p (T) 29⫽ • m⫺2 共5.18兲
m⫽1 c c m
兺冋 册
M
m⬘ ⫺ ⬘ 2
10 ⬘ (T) 210⫽ • m⫺2 共5.19兲
m⫽1 c m
兺冋 册
M
m⬙ ⫺ ⬙ 2
11 ⬙ (T) 211⫽ • m⫺2 共5.20兲
m⫽1 c m
兺 冋 RT ⫺ RT ⫺ 关 共 ⫹ 兲兴 ⫹ 关 共 ⫹ 兲兴 册
M
u 2⬘ u ⬘1 2
12 u 2⬘ (T 2 )⫺u 1⬘ (T 1 ) 212⫽ ⴰ
r
2
ⴰ
r
1 • m⫺2 共5.21兲
m⫽1 2 1 m
兺冋 冋 册册
M
u ⬙ ⫺u ⬘ ␦⬙ 2
13 u ⬙ (T)⫺u ⬘ (T) 213⫽ ⫺ ln ⫹r 共 ␦ ⬙ , 兲 ⫺ r 共 ␦ ⬘ , 兲 • m⫺2 共5.22兲
m⫽1 RT ␦⬘ m
Linearized data
兺 冋RT⫺␥ • 共 1⫹2 ␦ ⫹ ␦ 册
M 2 2
w
4* w( p,T) 4*⫽
2 p r
␦
2
␦␦ 兲
r
• m⫺2 共5.23兲
m⫽1 m
兺 冋 R ⫹ 共 ⫹ 册
M 2
cp
5* c p ( p,T) 2
5*⫽ 2 ⴰ
兲 ⫺ ⑀
r p
• m⫺2 共5.24兲
m⫽1 m
兺 冋RT ⫺ RT ⫺关共 ⫺ 兲 ⫹ ␦ 兴 ⫹ 关 共 ⫺ 兲 ⫹ ␦ 兴 册
M 2
h2 h1
6* h 2 ( p2 ,T 2 )⫺h 1 ( p1 ,T 1 ) 2
6* ⫽ ⴰ
r
r
␦ 2
ⴰ
r
r
␦ 1 • m⫺2 共5.25兲
m⫽1 2 1 m
TABLE 5.1. Contribution of the several linear, nonlinear, and linearized data to the weighted sum of squares for the fitting and optimization process—Continued
兺 冋 RT ⫺ RT ⫺ 关 共 ⫹ 兲兴 ⫹ 关 共 ⫹ 兲兴 册
M
u 2⬘ u 1⬘ 2
12* u 2⬘ ( 2⬘ p ,T 2 )⫺u 1⬘ ( 1⬘ p ,T 1 ) 2
12* ⫽ ⴰ
r
2
ⴰ
r
1 • m⫺2 共5.26兲
m⫽1 2 1 m
兺冋 冋 册册
M
u ⬙ ⫺u ⬘ ␦⬙ 2
13* u ⬙ ( ⬙ p,T)⫺u ⬘ ( ⬘ p,T) 2
13* ⫽ ⫺ ln ⫹r 共 ␦ ⬙ , 兲 ⫺ r 共 ␦ ⬘ , 兲 • m⫺2 共5.27兲
m⫽1 RT ␦⬘ m
兺 冋 共 ⬘ 兲 RT ⫺ 册
M
p ⫺ ⬘ RT 2
14 p( ⬘ p,T) 214⫽ 2
⫺1 r
c ␦共 ␦ ⬘, 兲 • m⫺2 共5.28a兲
m⫽1 m
兺 冋 共 ⬙ 兲 RT ⫺ 册
M
p ⫺ ⬙ RT 2
15 p( ⬙ p,T) 215⫽ 2
⫺1 r
c ␦共 ␦ ⬙, 兲 • m⫺2 共5.28b兲
m⫽1 m
兺 冋 RT • 冋 ⬙⫺ ⬘ 册 ⫺ln冋⬙册⫺关 共 ␦ ⬘, 兲 ⫺ 共 ␦ ⬙, 兲兴 册
M
Maxwell p 1 1 ⬘ 2
16 216⫽ r r
• m⫺2 共5.28c兲
criterion
m⫽1 m
Explanations
For the relations between the several properties and ° and r and their derivatives see Table 6.3.
For the weighted sum of squares the following abbreviations and definitions are used:
共1兲 r␦⫽ 冋 册
r
␦
, r␦␦ ⫽
␦ 2冋 册
2 r
, r ⫽
r
␦
,
r
⫽ 冋 册
2 r
␦
2 冋 册
, ␦r ⫽ 冋 册 冋 册
2 r
␦
, ⴰ ⫽
°
␦
ⴰ
, ⫽ 冋 册 2 °
2 ␦
. 共5.29兲
共2兲 The weight m corresponds to the quantity tot according to Eq. 共5.9兲.
共3兲 The subscript p means precorrelated. The precorrelation factors ␥ p and ⑀ p are defined by the relations:
c p 共 p,T 兲
␥ p⫽ 共5.30兲
c v 共 p,T 兲
⑀ p⫽c p ⫺c v ⫽ 冋 共 1⫹ ␦ r␦ ⫺ ␦ ␦r 兲 2
1⫹2 ␦ r␦ ⫹ ␦ 2 r␦␦
册 ,␦p
共5.31兲
squares of the linear and nonlinear data used for the devel- 共2兲 From this bank of terms, the structure-optimization
opment of IAPWS-95. The total sum of squares is obtained method determines with mathematical statistical and sto-
as given by Eq. 共5.7兲. chastic methods the best combination of a certain num-
ber of terms.
5.3.2. Basic Statements for Optimizing the Mathematical Form
of r For developing IAPWS-95, a modified form of the structure-
optimization method developed by Setzmann and Wagner
Since the functional form of an equation for the residual 共1989兲 was used. This method only works with linear data,
part of the Helmholtz free energy is not initially known, a see Sec. 5.3.1. Thus, to take into account the optimization
suitable mathematical structure must be established before
process, at least partly, the experimental information of the
any coefficients n i can be fitted to the data. In the past, the
nonlinear data, the nonlinear relations between these proper-
structure of most correlation equations was determined sub-
jectively, based on the experience of the correlator or by trial ties, and the derivatives of ° and r were linearized. The
and error. To improve this situation, we developed different results of this linearization for the sums of squares of those
optimization strategies 关Wagner 共1974兲, Ewers and Wagner nonlinear properties considered to be important for the de-
共1982兲, Setzmann and Wagner 共1989兲, and Tegeler et al. velopment of IAPWS-95 are given by Eqs. 共5.23兲–共5.28兲
共1999兲兴 that introduce objective criteria for the selection of listed in Table 5.1. In the following an example of such a
the mathematical structure of such equations of state. linearization is shown for the property speed of sound w.
The entire strategy of the structure optimization of an According to the relation between the property z⫽w and
equation of state consists of two basic steps: the derivatives of ° and r given in Table 6.3 the sum of
共1兲 Formulation of a comprehensive set of mathematical squares 关see Eq. 共5.7兲兴 for fitting an equation for r to M
functions of the reduced density and inverse reduced experimental data of w 共w is the jth property considered in
temperature which is used as a ‘‘bank of terms.’’ the entire multiproperty fitting process兲 reads:
冋
M is of great importance. The starting point for the investigated
w2
2j ⫽ 兺
m⫽1 RT
⫺1⫺2 ␦ ␦r ⫺ ␦ 2 ␦␦
r
functional forms was our experience with the development
of wide-range equations of state of reference quality for oxy-
⫹
共 1⫹ ␦ r␦ ⫺ ␦ ␦r 兲 2
ⴰ
2 共 ⫹
r
兲
册 2
m
⫺2
• tot,m . 共5.32兲
gen, water, methane, and carbon dioxide 关Schmidt and Wag-
ner 共1985兲, Saul and Wagner 共1989兲, Setzmann and Wagner
共1991兲, and Span and Wagner 共1996兲兴. A great number of
This type of sum of squares leads to a nonlinear system of investigations were necessary in order to find out the appli-
normal equations when determining the coefficients n̄ in the cability of the several functional forms in view of the re-
equation for r( ␦ , ,n̄). However, the structure optimization quirements for establishing the new equation of state for wa-
method used here cannot cope with such a nonlinear system. ter. Finally, the bank of terms was composed of four different
A further difficulty arises because the speed of sound is mea- functional forms.
sured as a function of pressure and temperature, and not
density and temperature, which are the variables of the equa- 5.4.1. Polynomial Terms
tion for r. Thus, the sum of squares according to Eq. 共5.32兲
is implicitly nonlinear. As shown by Schmidt and Wagner Polynomial terms have been part of all previous wide-
共1985兲, this implicitly nonlinear relation can be linearized by range equations of state. They are a part of our bank of terms
using the following sum of least squares: in the following form:
冋 册
M
w2 2
ri ⫽n i ␦ d i t i 共5.34兲
2j ⫽ 兺 RT
⫺ ␥ p• 共 1⫹2 ␦ r␦ ⫹ ␦ 2 ␦␦
r
兲 ⫺2
• tot,m
m⫽1 m with ␦ ⫽ / c and ⫽T c /T. In order for the new equation of
共5.33兲 state to achieve good extrapolation, the values of the density
with the so-called precorrelation factor ␥ p according to exponents d i were limited to the range from 1 to 5 with
c p 共 p,T 兲 integral step sizes. This limitation is particularly important
␥ p⫽ . 共5.33a兲 when extrapolating to high densities. For the same reason,
c v 共 p,T 兲
the values of the temperature exponents t i were limited to a
The density p and the precorrelation factor ␥ p have to be small range as well. Moreover, the temperature exponent t i
precalculated by a preliminary equation of state. of the polynomial term with the highest density exponent d i
Because the linearizations of the nonlinear sums of 共the leading term when extrapolating the equation to high
squares require precalculations with preliminary equations of densities兲 should be between 0⬍t i ⭐1; for further details
state, the entire process of optimizing the structure of the r and discussion of these considerations see Span and Wagner
equation is a recursive process, see Sec. 5.5. 共1997兲. Based on these considerations, the entire range for
In this work, a modified form of the structure-optimization the temperature exponents of the polynomial terms was se-
method developed by Setzmann and Wagner 共1989兲 was lected to be from ⫺0.5 to 1 with a step size of 0.125. With
used to determine a suitable mathematical structure of this small step size, which was used for the first time in this
IAPWS-95. The modifications relate to both the stochastic work, a sufficiently large selection of these functional terms
and the deterministic part of the original algorithm. More was available despite the small range for t i .
importantly, however, are the changes mentioned in the next
paragraph with regard to the handling of different functional
forms in the bank of terms. 5.4.2. Polynomial Terms in Combination
with Exponential Functions
A sophisticated correlation equation for the residual part
of the Helmholtz free energy consists of an extensive sum of
The mathematical structure of polynomial terms in
terms. Hence, the mathematical form of a single term can be
combination with exponential functions is illustrated by the
associated with different functional groups ranging from
equation
simple polynomials in the reduced density ␦ and the inverse
reduced temperature to complicated exponential expres- ri ⫽n i ␦ d i t i e ⫺ ␦ i .
c
共5.35兲
sions 关see the bank of terms, Eq. 共5.41兲兴. During our work on
the reference equation of state for carbon dioxide 关Span and Terms of this type with c i ⫽2 are known as Benedict, Webb,
Wagner 共1996兲兴 additional limitations with respect to the and Rubin 共BWR兲-type terms, see Benedict et al. 共1940兲. In
number of terms belonging to certain functional groups an extended form, namely with density exponents up to c i
turned out to be useful and the optimization algorithm was ⫽6, these terms are nowadays considered to be the standard
modified to allow such limitations; for further details see functional forms of modern wide-range equations of state.
Span 共2000兲. Shortly after starting the development of the new equation of
state, we recognized that those terms of Eq. 共5.35兲 with c i
5.4. Functional Forms for r and the Bank ⫽5 were hardly ever selected by the structure-optimization
of Terms procedure if at the same time corresponding terms with the
density exponent c i ⫽6 had been contained in the set of func-
For the development of a suitable form of the equation for tions. Thus, during the development of the r equation these
the residual part r of IAPWS-95, the composition of the terms were omitted from the bank of terms.
comprehensive set of functional forms for the bank of terms
J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, Vol. 31, No. 2, 2002
424 W. WAGNER AND A. PRUß
not just one term in the equation. 共Meanwhile this as- TABLE 5.2. Parameters of the modified Gaussian bell-shaped terms accord-
ing to Eq. 共5.37兲 which are contained in the bank of terms, Eq. 共5.41兲
sumption has proved to be erroneous, see the discussion
in Sec. 6.4.2.兲 i di ti ␣i i ␥i ⑀i
共3兲 Within the ␦, surface of the critical region, the maxi-
mum of r
should follow the course of the saturated 1 1 0 10 150 1.21 1
2 1 1 10 150 1.21 1
vapor and saturated liquid curves in order to avoid un- 3 1 2 10 150 1.21 1
reasonable c v maxima in the single-phase region near the 4 1 3 10 150 1.21 1
phase boundary. 5 1 4 10 150 1.21 1
6 2 0 15 150 1.21 1
Taking these conditions into account, the nonanalytical terms 7 2 1 15 150 1.21 1
8 2 2 15 150 1.21 1
to be included into the bank of terms use the following form:
9 2 3 15 150 1.21 1
ri ⫽n i ⌬ b i ␦ , 共5.40兲 10 2 4 15 150 1.21 1
11 3 0 20 150 1.21 1
with 12 3 1 20 150 1.21 1
13 3 2 20 150 1.21 1
⌬⫽ 2 ⫹B i 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 a i , 14 3 3 20 150 1.21 1
15 3 4 20 150 1.21 1
⫽ 共 1⫺ 兲 ⫹A i 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 1/ 共 2  i 兲 , 16 1 0 10 200 1.23 1
17 1 1 10 200 1.23 1
⫽e ⫺C i 共 ␦ ⫺1 兲
2 ⫺D 2
i 共 ⫺1 兲 . 18 1 2 10 200 1.23 1
19 1 3 10 200 1.23 1
The exponential function damps the influence of this ex- 20 1 4 10 200 1.23 1
21 2 0 15 200 1.23 1
pression outside the critical region. The distance function ⌬
22 2 1 15 200 1.23 1
raised to the noninteger power b i introduces the nonanalyti- 23 2 2 15 200 1.23 1
cal behavior and should ensure that the maximum in c v fol- 24 2 3 15 200 1.23 1
lows the phase boundary. Finally, the reduced density in the 25 2 4 15 200 1.23 1
product of r guarantees a physically correct behavior in the 26 3 0 20 200 1.23 1
27 3 1 20 200 1.23 1
low-density limit.
28 3 2 20 200 1.23 1
Besides the coefficients n i , Eq. 共5.40兲 introduces seven 29 3 3 20 200 1.23 1
‘‘internal’’ parameters (A i ,B i ,C i ,D i ,a i ,b i ,  i ) for each of 30 3 4 20 200 1.23 1
the terms i; in principle, these parameters can be included 31 1 0 10 250 1.25 1
into a nonlinear fit of the entire equation. However, because 32 1 1 10 250 1.25 1
33 1 2 10 250 1.25 1
these parameters are highly correlated, a simultaneous non-
34 1 3 10 250 1.25 1
linear fit turned out to be very difficult. Thus, except for A i 35 1 4 10 250 1.25 1
and  i , the values of these parameters were determined by a 36 2 0 15 250 1.25 1
method similar to the one used for the exponents of the 37 2 1 15 250 1.25 1
Gaussian bell-shaped terms, see Sec. 5.4.3. The parameters 38 2 2 15 250 1.25 1
A i and  i of the function were determined at the very 39 2 3 15 250 1.25 1
40 2 4 15 250 1.25 1
beginning in the following way: the value for  i was prese- 41 3 0 20 250 1.25 1
lected so that it had a value near that of the critical exponent 42 3 1 20 250 1.25 1
corresponding to the renormalization group theory and 43 3 2 20 250 1.25 1
obeyed certain relationships with the parameters a i and b i , 44 3 3 20 250 1.25 1
45 3 4 20 250 1.25 1
for details see Span and Wagner 共1996兲. Then, A i was deter-
mined so that the function of Eq. 共5.40兲 represents the
phase boundary defined by the experimental p ⬘ ⬙ T data in
the critical region as well as possible. The effectiveness of
this form of terms was already increased by preinvestigations residual part r of the dimensionless Helmholtz free energy
with different combinations of values for the parameters equation consisted of 745 terms and was of the following
within the structure-optimization process so that we could form:
avoid refitting the parameters nonlinearly in the final stages
of the development of the new equation of state. 5 8 15 16
r⫽ 兺 兺 n i j ␦ i j/8⫹e ⫺ ␦ 兺兺 n i j␦ i j
i⫽1 j⫽⫺4 i⫽1 j⫽1
⫹e ⫺ ␦ 兺兺 n i j ␦ i j ⫹e ⫺ ␦ 兺 兺
2 3
n i j␦ i j
Based on the general functional forms discussed in Secs. i⫽1 j⫽1 i⫽1 j⫽10
5.4.1–5.4.4, and as a result of comprehensive preinvestiga- 9 20 7 25
tions regarding the ranges of exponents and other param- ⫹e ⫺ ␦ 兺 兺 n i j ␦ 2i j ⫹e ⫺ ␦ 兺 兺
4 6
n i j␦ i 2 j
eters, the general expression for the bank of terms for the i⫽1 j⫽10 i⫽3 j⫽12
⫹ 兺兺兺兺 兺
i⫽1 j⫽1 k⫽1 l⫽1 m⫽1
n i jklm ⌬ b j ␦ , 共5.41兲 1
2
3.5 0.8
0.85
24
28
0.2 700
800
0.32 0.3
3 0.9 32 900
with 4 0.95
⌬⫽ 2 ⫹B k 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 a i ,
⫽ 共 1⫺ 兲 ⫹A 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 1/ 共 2  兲 , 共1兲 The selected data 共experimental and synthetic data,
⫺C l 共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 ⫺D m 共 ⫺1 兲 2 see Secs. 2 and 4兲 for the single-phase region and the vapor–
⫽e . liquid phase boundary formed the starting point of the cycle
The parameters d i , t i , ␣ i ,  i , ␥ i , and ⑀ i of the 45 Gaussian of development.
bell-shaped terms according to Eq. 共5.37兲 are listed in Table 共2兲 Using a preliminary equation of state, or, for the ther-
5.2. The parameters a i , b i , B k , C l , D m , A, and  of the 36 mal properties on the vapor–liquid phase boundary, the aux-
nonanalytical terms corresponding to Eq. 共5.41兲 are given in iliary equations 共2.5兲–共2.7兲, the nonlinear data are linearized
Table 5.3. The bank of terms given by Eq. 共5.41兲 contains all by calculating the density p and the precorrelation factors
terms from which the final equation of state for H2 O, the ␥ p and ⑀ p.
IAPWS-95 formulation, has been determined by the 共3兲 Then all data, the original and the precorrelated data,
structure-optimization procedure, see Secs. 5.3.2 and 5.5. are weighted 共calculation of m 2
for the sums of squares
given in Table 5.1兲 with a preliminary equation of state.
共4兲 Based on the linear and linearized data 共see the pen-
5.5. Determination of the Final Form
ultimate column of Table 5.4兲, the modified structure-
of the IAPWS-95 Formulation
optimization procedure of Setzmann and Wagner 共1989兲, see
After the following three main tasks had been completed, also Sec. 5.3.2, yields an interim equation of state with an
the final form of IAPWS-95 could be developed: optimized functional structure containing, for example, 56
terms. The structure-optimization procedure works on the ba-
共i兲 setting up the selected set of experimental data; sis of the bank of terms, Eq. 共5.41兲, consisting of 745 terms.
共ii兲 description of several auxiliary equations for calculat- By modifying the original Setzmann and Wagner method,
ing further data; and see Sec. 5.3.2, it was possible to limit the number of terms
共iii兲 considerations of functional forms and setting up the belonging to certain functional groups of the bank of terms.
bank of terms for the structure-optimization procedure In the case of IAPWS-95, the following limitations were
共see Sec. 5.3.2兲 preselected: In order to assist the extrapolation capability, the
maximum number of polynomial terms was limited to 12.
5.5.1. Summarizing Information on the Sorts of Data Used
The number of Gaussian bell-shaped terms and nonanalytical
Information on the data used to develop the IAPWS-95 terms were limited to six and two, respectively, in order to
formulation is summarized in Table 5.4. Details are given for avoid intercorrelations in the near-critical region. The maxi-
the individual types of data with their independent variables. mum total number of terms to be selected by the structure-
The majority of the data are directly based on measurements, optimization procedure was set to 58, for further details see
but there are also so-called synthetic data calculated from Pruß and Wagner 共1995b兲. The interim equation of state with
corresponding auxiliary equations or from preliminary equa- the functional structure found in this way is then nonlinearly
tions of state obtained during the process of developing fitted to all original data, linear and nonlinear 共but not to the
IAPWS-95. The values of some independent variables had to linearized data兲, see the last column of Table 5.4.
be precorrelated from preliminary equations of state in order 共5兲 The optimized interim equation of state obtained in
to be able to use these data in the linear structure optimiza- step 4 is then used to recalculate the precorrelated densities
tion to determine the optimum functional structure of p and the precorrelation factors ␥ p and ⑀ p, and for all data
IAPWS-95, for details see Secs. 5.3.2 and 5.5.2. Those vari- the weight m 2
as well.
ables for which the values were precorrelated are marked by 共6兲 Without any changes in the data set, this iteration
the superscript p. cycle is repeated until the linearly optimized equation cannot
be further improved by fitting this equation nonlinearly to the
selected data set 共consisting of linear and nonlinear data兲.
5.5.2. Iterative Process of the Development
of the IAPWS-95 Formulation Usually, 2– 4 iteration cycles are needed to obtain such a
result. However, if the data set is changed 共e.g., change in
Based on the data set of which certain details are summa- weighting factors or in the data set itself兲, then the iteration
rized in Table 5.4, the development of IAPWS-95 occurred process starts again from the beginning. More than 100 such
using an iterative process. As illustrated in Fig. 5.1, this it- iteration cycles were performed before the final form of
erative process can be summarized as follows: IAPWS-95 was determined.
TABLE 5.4. Summarizing information on the selected data used in the linear optimization procedure and in the
nonlinear fitting process when developing the IAPWS-95 formulation
Number of data
Figure 5.1 is specially designed for the development of 6. The IAPWS-95 Formulation
IAPWS-95 based on the data set described in Table 5.4. If,
for example, for other substances, other types of data should
be taken into account, such data can easily be included in This section presents the new international standard equa-
this scheme of development; examples for such data might tion of state for H2 O, the ‘‘IAPWS Formulation 1995 for the
be third virial coefficients, internal energies of the single- Thermodynamic Properties of Ordinary Water Substance for
phase region, linearized data of the Joule–Thomson coeffi- General and Scientific Use’’ referred to in the following as
cient, etc. the IAPWS-95 formulation or IAPWS-95 for short. All nu-
By carrying out steps 1– 6 mentioned above, the final merical details needed for the use of IAPWS-95 are given,
equation of state for H2 O, the IAPWS-95 formulation, was and statements on the range of validity and estimates of un-
determined. All the numerical information on IAPWS-95 certainty are made. In this respect, this section essentially
necessary to use this new standard equation is summarized in corresponds to the content of the IAPWS release on this
Sec. 6.
formulation 关IAPWS 共1996兲兴 and gives some further infor- The values for the critical temperature T c and the critical
mation. Details of the development of the IAPWS-95 formu- density c are identical to those given in Eqs. 共2.2a兲 and
lation are summarized in Sec. 5. 共2.2c兲. The value of the specific gas constant R is derived
from values of the molar gas constant R m 关Taylor et al.
共1969兲兴 and the molar mass M 关Kell 共1977兲兴, which differ
slightly from the accepted values of these quantities at the
6.1. Reference Constants
time when the IAPWS-95 formulation was developed and
The so-called reference constants needed for evaluating from the current values R m⫽8.314 472 J mol⫺1 K⫺1 关Mohr
the IAPWS-95 formulation are: and Taylor 共1999兲兴 and M ⫽18.015 268 g mol⫺1 . This value
for M results from the molar masses of the stable isotopes of
T c⫽647.096 K, 共6.1兲 hydrogen and oxygen given by Audi and Wapstra 共1993兲 and
c⫽322 kg m⫺3 , 共6.2兲 the isotopic composition of VSMOW. 共As a result of a recent
investigation carried out by Harvey 共1998兲, IAPWS recom-
R⫽0.461 518 05 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 . 共6.3兲 mends that VSMOW be used as the standard definition of
‘‘ordinary water substance’’ 关IAPWS 共2001兲兴. The isotopic TABLE 6.1. Coefficients of Eq. 共6.5兲a
composition of VSMOW is documented by Gonfiantini
i n ⴰi ␥ ⴰi i n ⴰi ␥ ⴰi
共1978兲 and is also given in the IAPWS guideline 关IAPWS
共2001兲兴; samples of VSMOW are available from the Interna- 1 ⫺8.320 446 482 01 ¯ 5 0.973 15 3.537 342 22
tional Atomic Energy Agency 共IAEA兲 in Vienna, Austria. 2 6.683 210 526 8 ¯ 6 1.279 50 7.740 737 08
3 3.006 32 ¯ 7 0.969 56 9.244 377 96
Although IAPWS-95 is not based on the current M value for 4 0.012 436 1.287 289 67 8 0.248 73 27.507 510 5
VSMOW, one may say that IAPWS-95 is not in conflict with
this value. The only property which is measured so accu-
a
The values of the coefficients n ⴰ3 to n ⴰ8 and ␥ iⴰ are also valid for Eq. 共5.6兲.
rately that the value of the molar mass is indeed of impor-
tance is the liquid density at atmospheric pressure. The
7 51
highly accurate measurements of this quantity are repre-
r⫽ 兺 n i ␦ d i t i ⫹ 兺 n i ␦ d i t i e ⫺ ␦
ci
sented by IAPWS-95 to within their experimental uncertain- i⫽1 i⫽8
ties, see Sec. 7.2.1.2.兲 The use of the current values for R m
54 56
and M would yield a specific gas constant which is greater
兺 n i ␦ d i t ie ⫺ ␣ i共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲 兺
2⫺ 2
⫹ i共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲 ⫹ n i⌬ bi␦
than the value given in Eq. 共6.3兲 by 5.6 i⫽52 i⫽55
⫻10⫺6 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 . Density in the ideal-gas limit calcu-
lated from Eq. 共6.4兲 is therefore off by 6 ppm. However, 共6.6兲
since the value of R in Eq. 共6.3兲 has been used in determin- with
ing the coefficients in the residual part r, Eq. 共6.6兲, then this
⌬⫽ 2 ⫹B i 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 a i ,
value of R must be used in obtaining property values from
the IAPWS-95 formulation, Eq. 共6.4兲. ⫽ 共 1⫺ 兲 ⫹A i 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 1/共2 i 兲 ,
By using the specific gas constant, Eq. 共6.4兲 corresponds
⫽e ⫺C i 共 ␦ ⫺1 兲
2 ⫺D 2
to a mass-based formulation. In order to convert values of i 共 ⫺1 兲 ,
specific properties to molar properties, the most recent value for the definition of ␦ and see Eq. 共6.4兲. The coefficients
for the molar mass of VSMOW must be used; at present it is and exponents of Eq. 共6.6兲 are listed in Table 6.2; for the
the M value given above. determination of these values see Sec. 5.5.
All thermodynamic properties can be derived from Eq.
共6.4兲 by using the appropriate combinations of the ideal-gas
6.2. Numerical Description of the IAPWS-95 part °, Eq. 共6.5兲, and the residual part r, Eq. 共6.6兲, of the
Formulation dimensionless Helmholtz free energy, and the derivatives of
° and r. Relations between thermodynamic properties and
The IAPWS-95 formulation is a fundamental equation for ° and r and their derivatives are summarized in Table 6.3.
the specific Helmholtz free energy f. This equation is ex- All required derivatives of the ideal-gas part and of the re-
pressed in dimensionless form, ⫽ f /(RT), and is separated sidual part of the dimensionless Helmholtz free energy are
into two parts, an ideal-gas part ° and a residual part r, so explicitly given in Tables 6.4 and 6.5, respectively.
that: Since the 5th International Conference on the Properties of
Steam in London in 1956, the specific internal energy and
f 共 ,T 兲 the specific entropy of the saturated liquid at the triple point
⫽ 共 ␦ , 兲 ⫽ ° 共 ␦ , 兲 ⫹ r共 ␦ , 兲 , 共6.4兲
RT have been arbitrarily set equal to zero. Thus, at the triple-
point temperature T t⫽273.16 K:
where ␦ ⫽ / c and ⫽T c /T with T c , c , and R given by
Eqs. 共6.1兲–共6.3兲. u t⬘ ⫽0, s t⬘ ⫽0. 共6.7兲
The equation for the ideal-gas part ° of the dimensionless The coefficients and n ⴰ1 n ⴰ2
in Eq. 共6.5兲 have been adjusted to
Helmholtz free energy has been obtained from the equation meet this condition. Consequently, after calculating for T t the
for the specific isobaric heat capacity in the ideal-gas state saturated liquid density ⬘t via the phase-equilibrium condi-
c ⴰp , Eq. 共5.6兲, which was developed by Cooper 共1982兲; for tion 关see Eqs. 共6.9a兲–共6.9c兲兴, Eq. 共6.4兲 yields for the specific
details see Sec. 5.2. The corresponding equation for ° enthalpy of the saturated liquid at the triple point:
reads:
h t⬘ ⫽0.611 872 J kg⫺1 . 共6.8兲
8
In the liquid–water region, small changes in density along an
°⫽ln ␦ ⫹n ⴰ1 ⫹n ⴰ2 ⫹n ⴰ3 ln ⫹ 兺 n ⴰi ln关 1⫺e ⫺ ␥ i 兴 ,
ⴰ
i ci di ti ni
i ci di ti ni ␣i i ␥i ⑀i
i ai bi Bi ni Ci Di Ai i
55 3.5 0.85 0.2 ⫺0.148 746 408 567 24 28 700 0.32 0.3
56 3.5 0.95 0.2 0.318 061 108 784 44 32 800 0.32 0.3
TABLE 6.3. Relations of thermodynamic properties to the ideal-gas part °, Eq. 共6.5兲, and the residual part r, Eq. 共6.6兲, of the dimensionless Helmholtz free
energy and their derivativesa
Property Relation
Pressure p共␦,兲
p⫽ 2 ( f / ) T ⫽1⫹␦r␦
RT
Entropy s共␦,兲
s⫽⫺( f / T) ⫽共ⴰ ⫹r 兲 ⫺ °⫺ r
R
Enthalpy h共␦,兲
h⫽u⫹p v ⫽1⫹共ⴰ ⫹r 兲 ⫹ ␦ r␦
RT
c 共 兲 ⴰ
1⫹ ␦ ⬘ r␦ ⫺ ␦ ⬘ ␦r
Saturated liquid heat capacity ⫽⫺ 2 共 ⫹
r
兲⫹
R 1⫹2 ␦ ⬘ r␦ ⫹ ␦ ⬘ 2 r␦␦
c 共 T 兲 ⫽ 共 h/ T 兲 p ⫹T 共 p/ T 兲
• 共 dp /dT 兲 / 共 ⫺ 2 共 p/ 兲 T 兲 兩 ⫽ ⬘
冋
• 共 1⫹ ␦ ⬘ r␦ ⫺ ␦ ⬘ ␦r 兲 ⫺
c dp
R ␦ ⬘ dT 册 b
a
r␦⫽ 冋 册
r
␦
, r␦␦ ⫽ 冋 册
2 r
␦ 2 , r ⫽
r
␦
,
r
⫽ 冋 册
2 r
␦
2 冋 册
, ␦r ⫽
2 r
␦
, ⴰ ⫽
°
冋 册 冋 册 ␦
ⴰ
, ⫽ 冋 册 2 °
2 ␦
.
冋冉 冊 册
b
dp ⬙ • ⬘ ⬙
⫽ R ln ⫹ r共 , ␦ ⬙ 兲 ⫺ r共 , ␦ ⬘ 兲 ⫺ 共 r 共 , ␦ ⬙ 兲 ⫺ r 共 , ␦ ⬘ 兲兲 .
dT ⬙ ⫺ ⬘ ⬘
TABLE 6.4. The ideal-gas part °, Eq. 共6.5兲, of the dimensionless Helmholtz 共6.4兲 is also in satisfactory agreement with the experimental
free energy and its derivativesa data in the critical region, the equation has some unsatisfac-
8 tory features in the immediate vicinity of the critical point.
兺 n ln共1⫺e
ⴰ
°⫽ln ␦⫹nⴰ1⫹nⴰ2⫹nⴰ3 ln ⫹ ⴰ
i
⫺␥i
兲 These features involve second order and higher derivatives
i⫽4
of the dimensionless Helmholtz free energy and properties
ⴰ␦⫽1/␦ ⫹0⫹0⫹0⫹0 obtained from them. Specifically, the isothermal compress-
ⴰ␦␦ ⫽⫺1/␦ 2 ⫹0⫹0⫹0⫹0 ibility 关 T ⫽ ⫺1 ( / p) T 兴 , and the specific isobaric heat ca-
8 pacity c p exhibit unphysical behavior 共indentations兲 which
兺 n ␥ 关共 1⫺e
ⴰ
ⴰ ⫽0⫹0⫹n ⴰ2 ⫹n ⴰ3 / ⫹ ⴰ
i
ⴰ
i
⫺ ␥ i ⫺1
兲 ⫺1 兴 occurs in a region from T c to 5 K above T c for densities
i⫽4
8 ⫾0.5% from c . 共The value of 5 K is given in the release on
兺 n 共␥ 兲 e ⴰ 2 ⫺ ␥ iⴰ IAPWS-95 关IAPWS 共1996兲兴. However, comprehensive in-
ⴰ
ⴰ
⫽0⫹0⫹0⫺n ⴰ3 / 2 ⫺ ⴰ
i i 共 1⫺e ⫺ ␥ i 兲 ⫺2
i⫽4 vestigations carried out after 1996 showed that the tempera-
␦ⴰ ⫽0⫹0⫹0⫹0⫹0 ture range where this weakness occurs noticeably extends
only from T c to 2 K above T c 关see Figs. 6.11 and 6.12兴.兲 In
a
ⴰ␦⫽ 冋 册
°
␦
, ⴰ␦␦⫽冋 册
2°
␦2
, ⴰ ⫽ 冋 册
°
␦
ⴰ
, ⫽
2°
2 ␦
, ␦ⴰ ⫽ 冋 册
2°
␦
. 冋 册 addition, within a temperature range from 20 mK below T c
up to T c , the isochoric heat capacity c v exhibits a maximum
and the speed of sound w exhibits a minimum not at the
saturation temperature T of the corresponding isochore 共as
These equations represent the equality of pressure, tempera- it should be兲 but in the single-phase region up to 2.5 mK
ture, and specific Gibbs free energy 共Maxwell criterion兲 in above T . Details of this behavior, which is of no relevance
the coexisting vapor and liquid phases; for an explanation of for the vast majority of applications of IAPWS-95, are given
the quantities ␦r see the footnote of Table 6.5. For a given in Sec. 6.4.
saturation temperature, after iterative solution of Eqs. 共2兲 In the stable fluid region, the IAPWS-95 formulation
共6.9a兲–共6.9c兲, Eq. 共6.4兲 yields the thermal saturation proper- can also be extrapolated beyond the limits given under item
ties p , ⬘, and ⬙. Then, all the other saturation properties 共1兲. Tests showed that Eq. 共6.4兲 behaves reasonably when
can be derived from Eq. 共6.4兲. In this way, the properties extrapolated to pressures up to about 100 GPa and tempera-
calculated on the vapor–liquid phase boundary are thermo- tures up to about 5000 K. This holds at least for the density
dynamically consistent with the properties of the single- and enthalpy of undissociated H2 O. In the gas region at pres-
phase region. sures below the triple-point pressure, Eq. 共6.4兲 behaves rea-
Moreover, Eq. 共6.4兲 meets the conditions at the critical sonably when extrapolated to the sublimation curve 关see Eq.
point, i.e., it reproduces the critical parameters T c , p c , and 共2.21兲兴 for temperatures down to 200 K. Due to the ex-
c according to Eqs. 共2.2a兲–共2.2c兲 and yields zero for the tremely low densities in this region which go down to about
first and second partial derivative of pressure with respect to 10⫺6 kg m⫺3 , attention must be paid to numerical problems.
density at the critical point. 共3兲 As far as can be tested with experimental data, the
formulation behaves reasonably when extrapolated into the
6.3. Basic Information on the Application metastable regions. Equation 共6.4兲 represents the currently
of the IAPWS-95 Formulation available experimental data for the subcooled liquid and for
the superheated liquid to within the experimental uncertainty.
In this subsection brief statements on the range of validity, In the case of the subcooled vapor, no experimental data are
estimates of uncertainty, and computer-program verification available. In this region, for pressures below 10 MPa, Eq.
of IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, are made. Comprehensive compari- 共6.4兲 produces reasonable values close to the saturated vapor
sons of IAPWS-95 with experimental data and other equa- line. For calculations further away from the saturated vapor
tions of state are shown in Sec. 7. line, the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲, should be used instead of
Eq. 共6.4兲. For further details, see Sec. 7.3.2.
6.3.1. Range of Validity
TABLE 6.5. The residual part r, Eq. 共6.6兲, of the dimensionless Helmholtz free energy and its derivativesa
7 51 54 56
r⫽ 兺 i⫽1
n i␦ di ti⫹ 兺
i⫽8
n i ␦ d i t ie ⫺ ␦ i⫹
c
兺
i⫽52
n i ␦ d i t ie ⫺ ␣ i共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲
2⫺
i共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲
2
⫹ 兺 n⌬
i⫽55
i
bi
␦
with ⌬⫽ 2 ⫹B i 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 a i
⫽ 共 1⫺ 兲 ⫹A i 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 1/共2 i 兲
⫽e ⫺C i 共 ␦ ⫺1 兲
2 ⫺D 2
i 共 ⫺1 兲
7 51
r␦ ⫽ 兺 nd␦
i⫽1
i i
d i ⫺1 t i
⫹ 兺 ne
i⫽8
i
⫺␦ci
关 ␦ d i ⫺1 t i 共 d i ⫺c i ␦ c i 兲兴
冋 册
54
兺 n␦ d i t i ⫺ ␣ i共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲2⫺  i共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲2
di
⫹ e ⫺2 ␣ i 共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲
i⫽52
i
␦
兺 n 冋⌬ 冉 冊 册
56
⌬ bi
⫹ bi
⫹␦ ⫹ ␦
i⫽55
i
␦ ␦
7 51
r␦␦ ⫽ 兺
i⫽1
n i d i 共 d i ⫺1 兲 ␦ d i ⫺2 t i ⫹ 兺 ne
i⫽8
i
⫺␦ci
关 ␦ d i ⫺2 t i 共共 d i ⫺c i ␦ c i 兲共 d i ⫺1⫺c i ␦ c i 兲 ⫺c 2i ␦ c i 兲兴
54
⫹ 兺 n e
i⫽52
i
t i ⫺ ␣ i共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲2⫺  i共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲2
• 关 ⫺2 ␣ i ␦ d i ⫹4 ␣ 2i ␦ d i 共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲 2 ⫺4d i ␣ i ␦ d i ⫺1 共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲 ⫹d i 共 d i ⫺1 兲 ␦ d i ⫺2 兴
兺 n 冋⌬ 冉 冊 冉 冊 册
56
2 ⌬ bi 2⌬ bi
⫹ bi
2 ⫹ ␦ 2 ⫹2 ⫹␦ ⫹ ␦
i⫽55
i
␦ ␦ ␦ ␦ ␦2
冋 册
7 51 54
兺 兺 兺 n␦
ti
n i t i ␦ d i t i ⫺1 e ⫺ ␦ i ⫹ d i t i ⫺ ␣ i共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲2⫺  i共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲2
c
r ⫽ n i t i ␦ d i t i ⫺1 ⫹ e ⫺2  i 共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲
i⫽1 i⫽8 i⫽52
i
兺 n ␦冋 册
56
⌬ bi
⫹ ⫹⌬ b i
i⫽55
i
7 51
r
⫽ 兺
i⫽1
n i t i 共 t i ⫺1 兲 ␦ d i t i ⫺2 ⫹ 兺 n t 共 t ⫺1 兲 ␦
i⫽8
i i i
d i t i ⫺2 ⫺ ␦ c i
e
冋冉 冊 册
54 2
兺 n␦ d i t i ⫺ ␣ i共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲2⫺  i共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲2
ti ti
⫹ e ⫺2  i 共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲 ⫺ ⫺2  i
i⫽52
i
2
兺 n ␦冋 册
56
2⌬ bi ⌬ bi 2
⫹ ⫹2 ⫹⌬ b i 2
i⫽55
i 2
7 51
␦r ⫽ 兺
i⫽1
n i d i t i ␦ d i ⫺1 t i ⫺1 ⫹ 兺 nt␦
i⫽8
i i
d i ⫺1 t i ⫺1
共d i ⫺c i ␦
ci
兲e ⫺␦
ci
冋 册冋 册
54
兺 n␦ d i t i ⫺ ␣ i共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲2⫺  i共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲2
di ti
⫹ e ⫺2 ␣ i 共 ␦ ⫺ ⑀ i 兲 ⫺2  i 共 ⫺ ␥ i 兲
i⫽52
i
␦
兺 n 冋⌬ 冉 冊 冉 冊 册
56
2 ⌬ bi ⌬ bi 2⌬ bi
⫹ bi
⫹␦ ⫹␦ ⫹ ⫹␦ ⫹ ␦
i⫽55
i
␦ ␦ ␦ ␦
⌬bi
⌬
⫽bi⌬bi⫺1 ⫽⫺2Ci共␦⫺1兲
␦ ␦ ␦
2⌬bi
␦ 再
2 ⫽bi ⌬
bi⫺1
2⌬
␦2
⫹共bi⫺1兲⌬bi⫺2
⌬
␦ 冉 冊冎 2
2
␦2
⫽兵2Ci共␦⫺1兲2⫺1其2Ci
⌬bi
⫽⫺2bi⌬bi⫺1 ⫽⫺2Di共⫺1兲
TABLE 6.5. The residual part r, Eq. 共6.6兲, of the dimensionless Helmholtz free energy and its derivativesa—Continued
2⌬bi 2
⫽2bi⌬bi⫺1⫹42bi共bi⫺1兲⌬bi⫺2 ⫽兵2Di共⫺1兲2⫺1其2Di
2 2
2⌬bi 2 ⌬ 2
⫽⫺Aibi ⌬bi⫺1共␦⫺1兲关共␦⫺1兲2兴1/共2i兲⫺1⫺2bi共bi⫺1兲⌬bi⫺2 ⫽4CiDi共␦⫺1兲共⫺1兲
␦ i ␦ ␦
with
⌬
␦ 再2
⫽ 共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 A i 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 1/ 共 2  i 兲 ⫺1 ⫹2B i a i 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 a i ⫺1
i 冎
2⌬
⫽
1 ⌬
␦ 2 共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 ␦ 再
⫹ 共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 4B i a i 共 a i ⫺1 兲关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 a i ⫺2 ⫹2A 2i
1
i 冉 冊兵 2
关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 1/ 共 2  i 兲 ⫺1 其 2
⫹A i
4
冉1
i 2i 冊
⫺1 关共 ␦ ⫺1 兲 2 兴 1/ 共 2  i 兲 ⫺2 冎
a
r␦⫽ 冋 册
r
␦
, r␦␦ ⫽ 冋 册
2 r
␦2
, r ⫽
r
␦ 冋 册
,
r
⫽
2 r
2 ␦ 冋 册
, ␦r ⫽
2 r
␦
. 冋 册
possible values as judged by IAPWS, and no statistical sig- due to the very accurate p T data and speeds of sound on
nificance can be attached to it. With regard to the uncertainty which IAPWS-95 is based.兲 The statement ‘‘no definitive
for the speed of sound and the specific isobaric heat capacity uncertainty estimates possible’’ for the high-pressure region
共see Figs. 6.2 and 6.3兲, it should be noted that the uncertain- in Figs. 6.2 and 6.3 is based on the lack of experimental data
ties for these properties increase drastically when approach- in this region. 共After the adoption of the release on the
ing the critical point. 共Over wide ranges of state, the uncer- IAPWS-95 formulation 关IAPWS 共1996兲兴, Wiryana et al.
tainty of IAPWS-95 in the isobaric heat capacity is 共1998兲 reported speed-of-sound data for temperatures be-
considered to be smaller than the uncertainty of the experi- tween 351 and 473 K at pressures up to 3500 MPa. In the
mental c p data, see Sec. 7.2.5. This attribute of IAPWS-95 is pressure range up to 1000 MPa, which is in the region with
the statement ‘‘no definitive uncertainty estimates possible’’
FIG. 6.3. Percentage uncertainties in specific isobaric heat capacity esti- figures for their computer-program verification should refer
mated for IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. For the uncertainty in the immediate vicin-
ity of the critical point, see the text; for the definition of the triangle around directly to the release on IAPWS-95 关IAPWS 共1996兲兴. Infor-
the critical point, see Fig. 6.1. The positions of the lines separating the mation about available computer codes based on IAPWS-95
uncertainty regions are approximate. is given on the IAPWS website http://www.iapws.org/
newform.htm
To assist the user in computer-program verification of 6.4.1. Positive Features of the Nonanalytical Terms
IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, Table 6.6 contains values of the ideal-
gas part ° and the residual part r of the dimensionless For a very near-critical isochore, Fig. 7.29 illustrates that
Helmholtz free energy together with the corresponding de- IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, is basically able to follow the steep
rivatives. These values were calculated for two combinations increase of the data of the isochoric heat capacity when ap-
of temperature and density; one T – point is in the ‘‘nor- proaching the saturation temperature 共phase boundary兲 ex-
mal’’ fluid region and the other one is in the critical region. tremely close to the critical temperature. With the help of
Moreover, values for the most relevant thermodynamic prop- Fig. 6.5, it is shown that this positive feature of IAPWS-95 is
erties can be compared with the corresponding values listed produced by the new nonanalytical terms. For the critical
in the thermodynamic property tables, Tables 13.1 and 13.2, isochore, the figure presents the isochoric heat capacity cal-
given in the Appendix. The values for the saturated vapor culated from three equations of state which differ clearly
and saturated liquid along the vapor–liquid phase boundary regarding their functional structure. The equation of Saul and
given in Table 13.1 have been calculated from Eq. 共6.4兲 by Wagner 共1989兲 does not contain modified Gaussian bell-
applying the phase-equilibrium condition 关see the corre- shaped terms, the interim equation of state contains such
sponding comment in context with Eqs. 共6.9a兲–共6.9c兲兴 and terms but no nonanalytical terms and the IAPWS-95 formu-
not by using the auxiliary equations for the saturation prop- lation contains, in addition to Gaussian bell-shaped terms,
erties given in Sec. 2.3. Users who require more significant special nonanalytical terms according to Eq. 共5.40兲. It can be
TABLE 6.6. Values for the ideal-gas part °, Eq. 共6.5兲, and for the residual part r, Eq. 共6.6兲, of the dimension-
less Helmholtz free energy together with the corresponding derivativesa for two combinations of temperature
and density
a
For the abbreviated notation of the derivatives of ° and r see the footnotes of Tables 6.4 and 6.5,
respectively.
seen that wide-range equations of state without the modified In order to demonstrate the capability of IAPWS-95 to
Gaussian bell-shaped terms 共here, the Saul and Wagner equa- represent a very steep increase of the isochoric heat capacity
tion of state兲 are not able to follow the increase of the c v data in the temperature range (T⫺T c) of a few hundredths of a
for temperatures (T⫺T c)⬍⬇5.5 K, or expressed more gen- Kelvin, Fig. 6.6 shows, as a function of density, c v values
erally in reduced temperatures, for T/T c⬍⬇1.01. The calculated from two other equations of state at the critical
IAPWS-95-like equation with Gaussian bell-shaped terms temperature T c and for a temperature T⫽T c⫹0.05 K. Both
but without nonanalytical terms only fails for (T⫺T c) the IAPWS-95 formulation and the crossover equation of
⬍⬇2.2 K corresponding to T/T c⬍⬇1.003. However, with Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲 yield a completely
the nonanalytical terms IAPWS-95 is indeed able to yield the
required steep increase of the isochoric heat capacity in the
near-critical region. Thus, Fig. 6.5 illustrates very clearly the
improvement achieved by the Gaussian bell-shaped terms
and in particular by the nonanalytical terms.
FIG. 6.5. Isochoric heat capacity in the critical region as a function of tem-
perature 共on the critical isochore of the single-phase region兲 calculated from FIG. 6.6. Isochoric heat capacity in the critical region as a function of den-
IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, an IAPWS-95-like equation but without nonanalytical sity on two isotherms calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, and
terms, and the equation of Saul and Wagner 共1989兲. the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲.
FIG. 6.8. Isochoric heat capacity along the critical isochore of the single-
phase region in a double logarithmic diagram calculated from IAPWS-95,
Eq. 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, and the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wycza-
lkowska et al. 共2000兲. Experimental data from the isochore ⫽316.84
kg m⫺3 are plotted for comparison.
FIG. 6.7. Speed of sound in the critical region as a function of density on
two isotherms calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, and the
crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲. , the reduced density and inverse reduced temperature, like
all the other terms of IAPWS-95. Compared to scaled equa-
tions like that of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲 or
different course for the two isotherms T⫽T c⫹0.05 K and that of Levelt Sengers et al. 共1983兲 used in the equation of
T⫽T c 共both equations yield an infinite c v value for T⫽T c at Hill 共1990兲, this feature drastically simplifies the evaluation
⫽ c兲, whereas IAPS-84 does not show any difference be- of IAPWS-95.
tween the isotherms T⫽T c⫹0.05 K and T⫽T c . However, it
can also be seen that IAPWS-95 and the crossover equation 6.4.2. Weaknesses of the Nonanalytical Terms
yield a rather different kind of increase of c v for the critical
temperature when approaching the critical density. Besides the significant improvement of the capability of
Figure 6.7 shows the speed of sound w plotted as a func- IAPWS-95 for representing caloric properties in the critical
tion of density for two isotherms, namely for the critical region, such terms also have some basic weaknesses which
temperature T⫽T c and the temperature T⫽T c⫹0.05 K. The are discussed in this section.
corresponding plots of w have been calculated from IAPWS- Limiting behavior. Equations of state containing the kind
95, IAPS-84, and the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wy- of nonanalytical terms presented in Sec. 5.4.4 still have cer-
czalkowska et al. 共2000兲. IAPS-84 yields practically the tain weaknesses in the limiting behavior when approaching
same values for the isotherm T⫽T c⫹0.05 K and for the criti- the critical point. As an example, Fig. 6.8 shows c v in a
cal isotherm, where the smallest speed-of-sound value double logarithmic plot versus 关 (T⫺T c)/T c兴 for ⫽ c
amounts to about w⫽250 m s⫺1 . In contrast, the IAPWS-95 ⫽322 kg m⫺3 as calculated from IAPWS-95, the crossover
formulation and the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wy- equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲, and
czalkowska et al. 共2000兲 yield very small values of w for T IAPS-84. For comparison, the experimental data along the
⫽T c when approaching the critical density c 共with w⫽0 at isochore ⫽316.84 kg m⫺3 are also plotted. In this diagram,
the critical point兲. Thus, IAPWS-95 yields the required the density difference between the calculated c v values and
strong decrease in the speed of sound when approaching the the experimental data does not matter, because the difference
critical point, even though its critical isotherm in the w – between the critical temperature T c⫽647.096 K and the satu-
diagram shows a certain oscillation for ⬎ c . ration temperature T ( ⫽316.84 kg m⫺3 )⫽647.095 K is
An important advantage for practical applications of this only 1 mK. It can be seen that IAPWS-95 does not yield a
kind of nonanalytical terms in a wide-range equation of state straight line in this diagram 共as it should for ⫽ c兲, but sags
is that, in contrast to crossover and other scaled equations, no below the line beginning at about (T⫺T c)⫽0.5 K. Although
transformation of the independent variables has to be made: the c v data are represented within their experimental uncer-
the distance function ⌬, see Eq. 共6.6兲, directly contains ␦ and tainties, the results from IAPWS-95 are for (T⫺T c)⫽0.5 K
FIG. 6.9. Partial derivative of pressure with respect to density at constant FIG. 6.10. Partial derivative of density with respect to pressure at constant
temperature as a function of density calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, temperature as a function of density calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲,
along the isotherm T⫽T c⫹10 mK. The enlarged section shows a small along the isotherm T⫽T c⫹10 mK. The enlarged section shows a small
range around the critical density. range around the critical density.
FIG. 6.11. Isobaric heat capacity as a function of density calculated from FIG. 6.12. Isobaric heat capacity as a function of density calculated from
IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, along the isotherm T⫽T c⫹10 mK. The enlarged sec- IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, along the two isotherms T⫽T c⫹1 K and T⫽T c
tion shows a small region around the critical density.
⫹2 K. The arrows mark the locations where the indentations occur, see text.
FIG. 6.13. Isochoric heat capacity along several near-critical isochores FIG. 6.14. Speed of sound along several near-critical isochores ⬎ c 共liquid
⬍ c 共gas region兲 calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, in a small tempera- region兲 calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, in a small temperature range
ture range above the saturation temperature. above the saturation temperature.
共ii兲 due to the implicit nature of the kernel term, the cal-
culation of thermodynamic properties becomes rather
complicated; and
共iii兲 the kernel term in Kiselev and Friend’s modified ver-
sion of Eq. 共6.4兲 contributes to all derivatives of the
dimensionless Helmholtz free energy.
FIG. 7.1. Percentage deviations of the experimental data of the vapor pressure p , the saturated liquid density ⬘, and the saturated vapor density ⬙ from the
corresponding values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison:
⬘ ⫺calc
100⌬p /p ⫽100(p ,exp⫺p,calc)/p ,exp , 100⌬ ⬘ / ⬘ ⫽100( exp ⬘ )/ exp
⬘ , 100⌬ ⬙ / ⬙ ⫽100( exp
⬙ ⫺calc
⬙ )/ exp
⬙ .
minimum away from the saturation temperature T of the 7. Comparison of the IAPWS-95
corresponding isochore 共the extrema should be directly at Formulation with Experimental Data
T 兲 but in the single-phase region up to 2.5 mK above T . and Values from Other Equations of State
However, this physically incorrect behavior has practically
no effect because it is clearly within the uncertainty of
In this section, the quality of the IAPWS-95 formulation is
IAPWS-95 with respect to c v and w along the saturated va-
discussed based on comparisons with the selected experi-
por and saturated liquid line in this very near-critical region.
mental data used to develop IAPWS-95 共see Sec. 4兲 and
Nevertheless, in this region derivatives of c v and w 关e.g., when necessary with further experimental data. Most figures
( c v / T) 兴 should not be calculated, but such derivatives also show results of the previous scientific standard equation
are not usually needed. IAPS-84 关Haar et al. 共1984兲, Kestin and Sengers 共1986兲兴 and
In our experience, the described deficiencies of IAPWS-95 of the equation of state of Hill 共1990兲; for a brief description
regarding some caloric properties in a small part of the criti- of these two equations see Sec. 1.2. Since both previous
cal region have no effects on the practical use of IAPWS-95. equations were developed on the IPTS-68 temperature scale,
However, for users who must avoid these problems, use of all temperatures were converted to the IPTS-68 scale before
the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. values were calculated from these equations. Comparisons
共2000兲 is recommended. with the experimental data of the various properties in the
⬘ ⫺calc
FIG. 7.2. Percentage deviations 100⌬ ⬘ / ⬘ ⫽100( exp ⬘ )/ exp
⬘ between
experimental data of the saturated liquid density ⬘ and values calculated
from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84 and the equa-
tion of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison.
Figure 7.1 shows the deviations of the selected experimen- FIG. 7.3. Percentage deviations of the experimental data of the vapor pres-
tal data for the vapor pressure p and the saturated liquid and sure p , the saturated liquid density ⬘, and the saturated vapor density ⬙
vapor density, ⬘ and ⬙, from the corresponding values cal- from the corresponding values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, for the
culated with IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲; for comparison purposes temperature range from 10 K below the critical temperature up to T c . Val-
ues calculated from IAPS-84, the equation of Hill 共1990兲, and the crossover
the values calculated from IAPS-84 and from the equation of equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲 are plotted for com-
Hill 共1990兲 are also given. For all three equations of state, ⬘
parison. 100⌬p /p ⫽100(p ,exp⫺p,calc)/p ,exp , 100⌬ ⬘ / ⬘ ⫽100( exp
the saturation properties p , ⬘, and ⬙ were calculated via ⬘ )/ exp
⫺calc ⬘ , 100⌬ ⬙ / ⬙ ⫽100( exp
⬙ ⫺calc
⬙ )/ exp
⬙ .
the phase-equilibrium condition, Eqs. 共6.9a兲–共6.9c兲. In order
to take into account that the scatter of the ⬘ and ⬙ data
increases for temperatures above 600 K, different deviation In the discussions throughout Sec. 7.1, the homogeneous
scales have been used for the temperatures below and above liquid region is referred to quite often, because many experi-
600 K. IAPWS-95 represents all the selected thermal satura- mental saturation data are not mutually consistent. The first
tion data to within the uncertainties given in Table 2.1. From example of this is given in the following.
the deviation diagram of the saturated liquid density, it can Figure 7.2 illustrates that, in contrast to IAPS-84 and
be seen that for temperatures between 550 and 600 K the ⬘ Hill’s equation of state, IAPWS-95 is able to represent the ⬘
values from IAPWS-95 are slightly systematically below the data of Kell 共1975兲 to within their experimental uncertainty
experimental data by about ⫺0.05% 共but still within the ex- 共⌬⬘⫽⫾0.0004% at T⫽277 K to ⌬⬘⫽⫾0.0012% at T
perimental uncertainty兲. This deviation is caused by the fact ⫽423 K兲 without significant oscillations. However, the
that IAPWS-95 was also fitted to the p T data of Kell et al. nearly constant deviation of Kell’s data from the ⬘ values of
共1978兲, which cover the homogeneous liquid region up to IAPWS-95 up to the normal boiling temperature T b could
near the saturated liquid line 共see Sec. 7.2.1.2兲. As can be not be avoided, since otherwise the correct representation of
seen from Fig. 2.2, the auxiliary equation for ⬘, Eq. 共2.6兲, the second derivatives ( 2 / p 2 ) T and ( 2 / p T) of Eq.
represents the experimental data of this region without such 共6.4兲 in the liquid region would have suffered, see Sec. 7.3.1.
systematic deviations. This is, however, a slight overfitting Behavior in the critical region. In order to show how the
because Eq. 共2.6兲 did not have, of course, the experimental IAPWS-95 formulation behaves in the critical region for the
information from the homogeneous liquid region. Thus, it thermal saturation properties, a comparison with the experi-
follows that IAPS-84, which represents the ⬘ data without mental data is given for temperatures from (T c⫺10 K) to T c
such systematic deviations, is not able to represent the men- in Fig. 7.3. Besides IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲,
tioned p T data of Kell et al. 共1978兲 to within their uncer- in the critical region of the vapor–liquid phase boundary, the
tainty. values from the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wycza-
FIG. 7.4. The vapor–liquid phase boundary in the critical region of the p –
diagram calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, the equation of
Hill 共1990兲, and the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska
et al. 共2000兲.
7.1.3. Isochoric Heat Capacities at Saturation The only measuring runs which exist for H2 O for the iso-
baric heat capacity on the saturated liquid and saturated va-
Since the data sets of the isochoric heat capacities at satu- por line are the c ⬘p and c ⬙p data of Sirota 共1963兲 which he
ration, measured by experimenters at the Dagestan Scientific derived from his c p data of the homogeneous liquid and
Center of the Russian Academy of Sciences, are unfortu- vapor. Figure 7.7 shows the representation of Sirota’s c ⬘p and
nately not very consistent with each other 共see the discussion c ⬙p data by IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. It can be seen that, particu-
in Sec. 7.2.4兲, these data were not used to develop the larly for c ⬙p , the data are clearly better represented by
IAPWS-95 formulation; for more details about these data see IAPWS-95 than by IAPS-84 and by the equation of Hill
Sec. 4.1.2. 共1990兲. This improved behavior was achieved by including
As an example, Fig. 7.6 shows percentage deviations be- these data into the fit of IAPWS-95, although the behavior of
tween the experimental isochoric heat capacities of the satu- Eq. 共6.4兲 regarding the caloric properties along the vapor–
rated liquid c ⬘v 共from the single-phase region兲 and corre- liquid phase boundary was essentially already fixed by fitting
sponding values calculated from IAPWS-95; the figure to the u ⬘ and u ⬙ values 共see Table 5.4兲. The effectiveness of
covers the temperature range up to 630 K, for the critical this measure is mainly based on the fact that, for fitting
region see Fig. 6.15. The differences between the three data IAPWS-95 to the data of c ⬘p and c ⬙p , the phase-equilibrium
sets are obvious; the deviations of the c ⬘v data of Amirkhanov condition was applied in the direct nonlinear way, see Sec.
et al. 共1969兲 from the values calculated with IAPWS-95 re- 5.5.2 and particularly Eqs. 共5.18兲 to 共5.20兲 in Table 5.1 and
FIG. 7.11. Percentage density deviations between experimental p T data and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84
and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison.
wide-range equation of state for H2 O which has such a qual- Density of the Consultative Committee for Mass and Related
ity in the liquid region at ambient pressure. The densities of Quantities, see Tanaka et al. 共2001兲.
Kell 共1975兲, to which IAPWS-95 was not fitted, are included All these liquid–density data of metrological quality at p
in Fig. 7.13 for comparison because they were the most ac- ⫽0.101 325 MPa are plotted in Fig. 7.14 in comparison with
curate liquid densities for this isobar before Takenaka and the values calculated from IAPWS-95. It can be seen that
Masui 共1990兲 reported their values. IAPWS-95 represents both the internationally agreed values
After the development of IAPWS-95 was finished, new of Tanaka et al. 共2001兲 and the data of Takenaka and Masui
liquid density measurements of metrological quality have 共1990兲 to within ⫾1 ppm; only the value of Tanaka et al.
been published for VSMOW at p⫽0.101 325 MPa. These 共2001兲 at T⫽313.15 K is with ⫺1.1 ppm slightly outside the
are the densities of Patterson and Morris 共1994兲 measured at ⫾1 ppm band. The value for the maximum density along this
the CSIRO Australian National Measurement Laboratory and isobar determined from IAPWS-95 amounts to max
the measurements of Masui et al. 共1995兲 carried out at ⫽999.9749 kg m⫺3 , which agrees almost exactly with the
NRLM; for details of these measurements see Sec. 4.2.1. value max⫽999.974 950 kg m⫺3 given by Tanaka et al.
Masui et al. 共1995兲 also reported a (T) equation which rep- 共2001兲; for the temperature of this max value and its uncer-
resents their measurements very accurately. From this equa- tainty see Sec. 4.2.1. Thus, Fig. 7.14 confirms very clearly
tion, we calculated 18 density values for temperatures from that the IAPWS-95 formulation produces accurate densities
273.15 to 358.15 K. As described in Sec. 4.2.1, for the isobar for VSMOW, even though the molar mass on which
p⫽0.101 325 MPa and temperatures from 273.15 to 313.15 IAPWS-95 is based is not identical to that of VSMOW, see
K an internationally agreed set of densities was very recently Sec. 6.1.
adopted by a Task Group formed by the Working Group of Extrapolation behavior of IAPWS-95. Recently, Wiryana
FIG. 7.12. Percentage density deviations between very accurate experimental p T data and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated
from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison.
et al. 共1998兲 reported p T data for temperatures from 353.15 646.15 to 653.15 K (T c⫽647.096 K) at densities from 0 to
to 473.15 K at pressures up to 3500 MPa. Although these 500 kg m⫺3 ( c⫽322 kg m⫺3 ); the density range clearly ex-
data are not direct density measurements but were derived ceeds the critical region. As usual, for this region with very
from their speed-of-sound measurements 共see Sec. 4.2.1兲, large values of ( / p) T , the comparisons are not presented
they can be used to test the extrapolation behavior of as density deviations but as pressure deviations. Besides
IAPWS-95 at pressures up to 3.5 times its range of validity IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲, values from the
共1000 MPa兲. Figure 7.15 shows a comparison between crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al.
Wiryana et al.’s p T data and the values calculated from 共2000兲 are plotted for comparison. It can be seen that
IAPWS-95. The maximum deviation is about 0.2% and oc- IAPWS-95 represents the p T data on the near-critical iso-
curs at T⫽473.15 K and p⫽3500 MPa. At this p T point, therms to within the scatter of the data of about ⫾0.05% in
the deviations of IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are pressure. The critical isotherm is excellently covered. The
slightly greater than 1%. This test shows the very good ex- slight systematic peak of the data for T⫽647.3 K and T
trapolation capability of IAPWS-95, at least for the thermal ⫽648 K at about ⫽370 kg m⫺3 is obviously an artifact of
properties in this temperature range. the data; none of the equations is able to follow this oscilla-
7.2.1.3. Critical Region 643.15 K⭐T⬍663.15 K. Figure tion. For the density range of about ⫾25% around the critical
7.16 presents comparisons between the experimental p T density, the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wycza-
data of the critical region and those values calculated from lkowska et al. 共2000兲 shows very good behavior as well, but
IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, covering a temperature range from outside this density range its deviations increase quite rap-
FIG. 7.16. Percentage pressure deviations between experimental p T data in the critical region and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲; the density
range of the diagrams clearly exceeds the critical region. Values calculated from IAPS-84, the equation of Hill 共1990兲, and the crossover equation of
Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲 are plotted for comparison; values from the crossover equation are only shown within its range of validity.
FIG. 7.17. Percentage density deviations between experimental p T data and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84
and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison.
as IST-85 in the following. IST-85 contains values for the p T data of Maier and Franck 共1966兲 and of Köster and
specific volume and specific enthalpy that were originally Franck 共1969兲. Although there are no p T data of Hilbert
based on the temperature scale IPTS-68; a revised release et al. 共1981兲 for T⬎873 K, the course of IAPWS-95 in the
关IAPWS 共1994兲兴 provides the values corresponding to the high-temperature high-pressure range is guided by the data
current temperature scale ITS-90. of Hilbert et al. 共1981兲.
The IAPWS task group for evaluating the IAPWS-95 for- In general, it can be stated that the thermodynamic surface
mulation ascertained that, in the high-temperature high- of water 共or of any other substance兲 can be much better de-
pressure range, the IST-85 values of the specific volume ex- fined by an accurate wide-range equation of state, such as
hibit systematically positive deviations from the IAPWS-95, than by any skeleton table, such as IST-85; an
corresponding values of IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. For tempera- equation of state contains much more thermodynamic infor-
tures from 573 to 1073 K and pressures greater than 200 mation than one can take into account when establishing
MPa, there are ranges of pressure where the deviations of the skeleton tables.
IST-85 values exceed their tolerances. Figure 7.18 illustrates
this situation for three high-temperature isotherms. It can be 7.2.2. Second and Third Virial Coefficients
seen that the IST-85 values are clearly influenced by the p T
data sets of Maier and Franck 共1966兲 and of Köster and As discussed in detail in Sec. 4.2.2, the IAPWS-95 formu-
Franck 共1969兲 which are not consistent with the data set of lation was not fitted to experimental values of the second
Hilbert et al. 共1981兲, see the discussion in Sec. 4.2.1 in con- virial coefficient B 共neither, of course, to the third virial co-
text with Fig. 4.4. Hilbert et al.’s p T data have uncertain- efficient C兲. Nevertheless, in the following the B and C val-
ties of less than ⫾0.2% in density and are therefore five ues calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, are compared with
times more accurate than the other two data sets. Moreover, the experimental data sets for the second and third virial
Fig. 4.4 shows that Hilbert et al.’s data are confirmed at coefficients. The outer diagram of Fig. 7.19 shows the sec-
lower pressures by the data of Kell et al. 共1978兲 and at ond virial coefficient B versus temperature T as calculated
higher pressures by the recent data of Wiryana et al. 共1998兲. from IAPWS-95, IAPS-84, and the equation of Hill 共1990兲;
Thus, it can be concluded that the IST-85 values are mis- since the virial equation of Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲 is
guided in this high-temperature high-pressure range by the very often used in context with virial coefficients of H2 O,
lated from the correlation equation for the second virial co-
efficient developed by Le Fevre et al. 共1975兲 or in the case of
Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲 to the data of the isothermal
throttling coefficient at zero-density limit 共see Sec. 7.2.7兲.
For temperatures below 423 K, Le Fevre et al.’s equation
was exclusively fitted to experimental B values derived from
measurements of the isothermal throttling coefficient; we es-
timate that these B values 关see Le Fevre 共1975兲兴 exhibit sys-
tematic trends to higher B values.
The third virial coefficient C calculated from the four
equations of state is plotted in Fig. 7.20. The C data, which
are also based on p T data extrapolated to →0, are still
more uncertain than the B data; thus, the data of the third
virial coefficient were not used to fit IAPWS-95 either. Fig-
ure 7.20 shows the absolute course of the C values calculated
from the four equations for temperatures from 300 to 2000
K; the experimental data are plotted for comparison. The
inner diagram of Fig. 7.20 shows an enlarged section for
temperatures from 500 to 1500 K. It can be seen that only the
equation of Hill and MacMillan agrees with the C data for
temperatures from 625 to 750 K; all three wide-range equa-
tions of state 关IAPS-84, IAPWS-95, and Hill 共1990兲兴 are not
able to cover these data. The virial equation of Hill and Mac-
Millan 共1988兲 was fitted to the B and C values discussed
here, and the requirement to cover these C data leads to B
FIG. 7.18. Percentage density deviations of experimental p T data and val- values from this equation which are in this range systemati-
ues of the Skeleton Tables IST-85 关IAPWS 共1994兲兴 together with their tol-
erances from values calculated with IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated cally slightly lower than those of the wide-range equations.
from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison. Moreover, starting at about 550 K but more clearly for tem-
peratures between 648 and 748 K at pressures above 4 MPa,
this equation cannot represent the very accurate p T data of
values from this equation and the experimental B values are Kell et al. 共1989兲 to within their uncertainty. This confirms
also plotted. For temperatures down to 275 K, all four equa- our decision not to fit IAPWS-95 to the experimental data of
tions yield a very similar plot of B, whereas for very low the virial coefficients.
temperatures the equation of Hill 共1990兲 does not go asymp- According to theoretical considerations, the third virial co-
totically to minus infinity but yields again increasing B val- efficient should reach a maximum at about the critical tem-
ues. The inner diagram of Fig. 7.19 presents the absolute perature. A qualitatively correct plot of the third virial coef-
deviations between experimental second virial coefficients ficient at high temperatures is a prerequisite of an equation of
and the corresponding values calculated from IAPWS-95. It state for it to yield a reasonable Joule inversion curve, see
can be seen that the most reliable experimental B values, Colina and Olivera-Fuentes 共2001兲. The Joule inversion
namely the data of Eubank et al. 共1988兲 at 373, 403, and 423 curve is far outside the range of validity of IAPWS-95 and
K and of Kell et al. 共1989兲 for temperatures from 448 to 723 the other two wide-range equations of state. Its representa-
K, are very well represented by IAPWS-95 to within 1–3 tion is therefore a good extrapolation test, see Sec. 7.3.3.
cm3 mol⫺1. For temperatures above 723 up to 1173 K, From the inner diagram of Fig. 7.20, it can be seen that, of
IAPWS-95 represents the B values of Vukalovich et al. the three wide-range equations of state, only IAPWS-95
共1967兲 to within 2 cm3 mol⫺1; this temperature range is not meets this criterion. IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲
covered by the inner deviation diagram of Fig. 7.19. For yield a maximum in C(T) only at temperatures T⬎3T c .
temperatures above the normal boiling temperature T b , all
four equations represent the most accurate B data 关Eubank
et al. 共1988兲 and Kell et al. 共1989兲兴 similarly well, where,
however, the equation of Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲 remains 7.2.3. Speed of Sound
below the data for temperatures above 550 K; this is of im-
portance when discussing the representation of the data of Figure 4.5 shows the distribution of the experimental data
the third virial coefficients C at about T c . All three equa- of the speed of sound w used to develop the IAPWS-95
tions, IAPS-84, Hill 共1990兲, and Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲, formulation, see also Table 4.5. In the following, these data
exhibit clearly increasing deviations from the IAPWS-95 are compared with the corresponding w values calculated
values 共zero line兲 for temperatures below about 350 K be- from the IAPWS-95 formulation, Eq. 共6.4兲, and from the
cause these equations were either fitted to B values calcu- other three equations of state mentioned at the beginning of
FIG. 7.19. Second virial coefficient B as a function of temperature as calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲; the experimental data are plotted for comparison.
The inner diagram shows absolute deviations ⌬B⫽B exp⫺Bcalc between experimental B data and values calculated from IAPWS-95. In both diagrams, B values
calculated from IAPS-84, the equation of state of Hill 共1990兲, and the virial equation of Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲 are plotted for comparison.
Sec. 7. Since the selected data summarized in Table 4.5 do the phase boundary, the w values from IAPWS-95 remain
not cover the critical region, the data sets of Erokhin and above the liquid-region data 共but within their experimental
Kal’yanov 共1979兲, 共1980兲 are used for comparisons in the uncertainty兲. This behavior was accepted since IAPWS-95
critical region but also outside the critical region. would have otherwise yielded values of w ⬘ that were too low
The percentage deviation diagrams of Fig. 7.21, with de-
viation scales between ⫾0.3% and ⫾1%, cover a tempera-
ture range from 252 to 873 K. In the two diagrams below
273 K, the stable liquid region is only located in the small
range between the two-phase-boundary lines corresponding
to the melting pressure. IAPWS-95 is able to represent these
low-temperature speed-of-sound data to within ⫾0.25%,
while the w values from IAPS-84 deviate by more than 10%
and those from the equation of Hill 共1990兲 by about 1%. For
the isotherms up to T⫽474 K, the vast majority of the w data
is represented by IAPWS-95 with deviations of less than
⫾0.1%. In particular, the measurements of the speed of
sound in the liquid phase at temperatures up to 330 K and
pressures up to 100 MPa are better covered by IAPWS-95
than by IAPS-84 and Hill’s equation. The very accurate w
data of Fujii 共1994兲 on the three isotherms 303, 313 共not
shown兲, and 323 K at pressures from 10 to 200 MPa are
represented to within ⫾0.025%, which is also not achieved
by the two other equations.
The representation of the gas-region speed-of-sound data
of Novikov and Avdonin 共1968兲 within ⫾0.2% by FIG. 7.20. Third virial coefficient C as a function of temperature as calcu-
IAPWS-95 is consistent with the representation of the w ⬙ lated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲; the experimental data are plotted for com-
parison. The inner diagram shows an enlarged section of the plot of C
data of these authors along the saturated vapor line, see Fig.
around its maximum. In both diagrams C values calculated from IAPS-84,
7.5 and the discussion in Sec. 7.1.2. the equation of state of Hill 共1990兲, and the virial equation of Hill and
From the isotherms 423–596 K, it can be seen that, near MacMillan 共1988兲 are plotted for comparison.
FIG. 7.21. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the speed of sound w and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from
IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison. In the first two diagrams, the stable liquid region is bordered by the two phase-boundary
lines of the melting pressure p m .
and would also have had difficulties with the enthalpies h ⬘ values calculated from the equation of Hill 共1990兲. IAPS-84
along the saturated liquid line at these temperatures, see the was forced to better fit the w data near the phase boundary,
discussion in Sec. 7.1.2. Obviously, there are some inconsis- but then has the difficulties mentioned above and also has
tencies between the w data in this region and the correspond- problems in the liquid region at about 60 MPa. In the dia-
ing p T data. This conclusion is supported by the plot of w gram for the temperatures between 647 and 648 K, the data
FIG. 7.23. Speed of sound in the critical region as a function of pressure on three isotherms as calculated from IAPWS-95, the equation of Hill 共1990兲, and
the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲; values from the crossover equation are only shown within its range of validity. The
experimental data of Erokhin and Kal’yanov 共1980兲 are plotted for comparison.
capacity, the IAPWS-95 formulation was fitted only to those For three characteristic isochores between about 200 and
113 c v data of Baehr and Schomäcker 共1975兲 that are in the 400 kg m⫺3 covered by the c v measurements of Baehr and
single-phase region, see also Table 4.6. Therefore, the fol- Schomäcker 共1975兲, Fig. 7.27 presents percentage deviations
lowing comparisons with the c v data are more a discussion between the experimental data and the values calculated
of the data situation and give an impression of how from IAPWS-95; the deviation scale corresponds to the un-
IAPWS-95 represents the c v surface without being fitted to certainty of the data. While IAPWS-95 and the equation of
accurate c v data. The conclusion drawn from the compari- Hill 共1990兲 represent the experimental data to within their
sons is representative for the entire range of the c v data uncertainty, IAPS-84 exhibits weaknesses when approaching
shown in Fig. 4.6. For comparison purposes, besides the c v the phase boundary from the single-phase region. The ex-
values from the IAPWS-95 formulation, Eq. 共6.4兲, most of perimental isochore that is closest to the critical isochore
the figures also contain the corresponding values from the ( c⫽322 kg m⫺3 ) is ⫽323.8 kg m⫺3; this isochore is also
other three equations of state mentioned at the beginning of very well represented by IAPWS-95. Nevertheless, from the
Sec. 7. deviation diagrams on the right of the phase boundary, it can
Starting at low densities, Fig. 7.26 shows for the range be seen that the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wycza-
near ⫽50 kg m⫺3 how IAPWS-95 predicts c v values in lkowska et al. 共2000兲 and Hill’s equation represent the ex-
comparison with the experimental data. The absolute c v – T perimental data closest to the phase boundary better than
diagram illustrates inconsistencies 共unnatural indentation兲 in IAPWS-95, see also Fig. 7.28 共top兲. Since the values from
the data set of Kerimov and Alieva 共1975兲 at temperatures IAPS-84 oscillate very strongly near the phase boundary,
between 645 and 725 K. From the percentage deviation dia- these values were omitted in this region. Although
gram of Fig. 7.26, it can be seen that the differences between IAPWS-95 was not fitted to the c v data of Baehr and
the data of Kerimov and Alieva 共1975兲 and of Amirkhanov Schomäcker 共1975兲 in the two-phase region 共left of the phase
et al. 共1969兲 amount to 5% and the data of Kerimov 共1964兲 boundary in Fig. 7.27兲, data in this region are also very well
deviate from the other two data sets by up to 15%. It is covered by IAPWS-95. We believe that c v values within the
interesting to see that the equations of Hill 共1990兲 and two-phase region can be more accurately calculated than
IAPWS-95 yield nearly the same c v values in this region measured, except very close to the critical point. This basic
and, as can be seen in the following figures, in the entire statement applies to all equations of state that accurately rep-
region considered here except for the critical region. resent the thermal saturation properties and the internal en-
FIG. 7.24. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the speed of sound w and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from
IAPS-84, the equation of Hill 共1990兲, and the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲 are plotted for comparison; the crossover
equation is only shown in the diagrams on the left and only within its range of validity. The diagrams on the left correspond to the same isotherms and the
same pressure range as given in Fig. 7.23. The diagrams on the right, which have a deviation scale of ⫾1%, cover a greater pressure range.
ergies of vaporization. This is the reason why IAPWS-95, the Schomäcker 共1975兲, which do not extend very close to the
Hill equation, and IAPS-84 yield nearly the same c v values phase boundary 共saturation temperature兲. The lower dia-
within the two-phase region 共the crossover equation is only grams present the inner temperature range around the phase
valid for temperatures above 630 K兲. boundary covered by the c v data of the Dagestan Scientific
There are two density regions where the c v data of Baehr Center; there is also one c v data point of Baehr and
and Schomäcker 共1975兲 and of three groups of authors at the Schomäcker 共1975兲 in the two-phase region at about 643 K.
Dagestan Scientific Center overlap, namely for ⬇310 One can see from the upper diagrams that the data of Po-
kg m⫺3 and ⬇344 kg m⫺3 ( c⫽322 kg m⫺3 ). Figure 7.28 likhronidi et al. 共2001兲 and of Abdulagatov et al. 共1998兲 de-
presents deviation diagrams for these two isochores. The up- viate systematically from those of Baehr and Schomäcker
per diagrams mainly contain the data of Baehr and 共1975兲, namely in the two-phase region between 7% and
12% and in the single-phase region by about 5%. From the
lower diagrams it can be seen that in the two-phase region,
and in the single-phase region as well, the data sets of Keri-
mov 共1964兲, Abdulagatov et al. 共1998兲, and of Polikhronidi
et al. 共2001兲 are not very consistent with each other; even the
two more recent data sets differ by up to 8% in the two-phase
region. These diagrams also show that IAPS-84 was misled
by the old data of Kerimov 共1964兲, and that the difference
between IAPWS-95 and the crossover equation of Kostrow-
icka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲 is not too large.
The isochore ⫽316.84 kg m⫺3 is the one closest to the
critical density ( c⫽322 kg m⫺3 ) that is covered by experi-
mental data up to very near the saturation temperature T
FIG. 7.25. Percentage deviations 100⌬w/w⫽100(w exp⫺wcalc)/w exp between ⫽647.095 K (T c⫽647.096 K). For this isochore, Fig. 7.29
the experimental data of the speed of sound w of Wiryana et al. 共1998兲 for
illustrates by an absolute c v – T diagram that IAPWS-95 is
temperatures from 353.15 to 473.15 K and values calculated with IAPWS-
95, Eq. 共6.4兲. For the pressures above 1000 MPa, IAPWS-95 was extrapo- able to follow the steep increase of the c v data when ap-
lated. proaching the saturation temperature T 共phase boundary兲,
FIG. 7.26. Comparison between experimental data of the isochoric heat ca-
pacity c v and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, IAPS-84, and the
equation of Hill 共1990兲. 共Upper diagram兲 Absolute plot of c v as a function of
temperature for the isochore ⫽49.51 kg m⫺3; 共Lower diagram兲 Percentage FIG. 7.27. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the isochoric
deviations 100⌬c v /c v ⫽100(c v ,exp⫺cv,calc)/c v ,exp for the density range heat capacity c v in the extended critical region and values calculated from
given. IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84, the equation of Hill
共1990兲, and the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al.
共2000兲 are plotted for comparison; values of the crossover equation are only
shown within its range of validity. Since IAPS-84 oscillates very strongly
near the phase boundary, the corresponding lines were omitted in this re-
see also the diagram in the upper right corner of this figure. gion.
However, compared with the crossover equation of Kostrow-
icka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲 the shape of the isochore
calculated from IAPWS-95 does not have such a steady cur- right shows the temperature range a few Kelvin around the
vature; very close to T the slope of IAPWS-95 is too steep saturation temperature T , which is dominated by the data
and further away from T it is too flat. Nevertheless, as of Kerimov 共1964兲 and of Abdulagatov et al. 共1998兲. As one
shown for the c v point of Abdulagatov et al. 共1995兲 with can see, IAPWS-95 is also able to follow the steep increase
c v ⫽6.883 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 , the difference between IAPWS-95 of the c v data when approaching the saturation temperature
and the crossover equation amounts to ⫺8.4% in c v corre- from the two-phase region. Again, close to T , the slope of
sponding to ⫺0.13 K or ⫺0.02% in temperature. This means the IAPWS-95 line is first too flat and then too steep, see the
that such differences are well within the experimental uncer- diagram on the right. This diagram also clearly shows that
tainty. Thus, such differences in c v must not be overrated if IAPS-84 yields the jump in c v in the wrong place; this be-
they occur in regions with a steep slope of the isochoric heat havior is based on the poor representation of the densities of
capacity. One can also see from the small diagram in the the saturated vapor and liquid in this near-critical region, see
upper right corner of this figure that the differences in tem- Fig. 7.4.
perature between IAPWS-95 and the crossover equation of Although the IAPWS-95 formulation is generally able to
Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲 practically vanish; yield reasonable c v values in most of the critical region,
for example, at c v ⫽18 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 the difference between IAPWS-95 has certain weaknesses in representing the isoch-
IAPWS-95 and the crossover equation is about ⫺0.04 mK. oric heat capacity, in particular extremely near the phase
This difference is well within the scatter of the data with boundary 共within 2.5 mK above the saturation temperature兲
respect to temperature. for densities about 6% around the critical density and along
Figure 7.30 presents c v along the isochore the phase boundary for densities about 4.5% around the criti-
⬇344 kg m⫺3 ⫽1.07 c . The diagram on the left covers a cal density; for details see the discussion in connection with
greater temperature range that also includes a part of the data Figs. 6.13 and 6.15 in Sec. 6.4.2.
of Baehr and Schomäcker 共1975兲, while the diagram on the In Fig. 7.31, experimental c v data at higher densities are
FIG. 7.28. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the isochoric heat capacity c v in the extended critical region and values calculated from
IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84, the equation of Hill 共1990兲, and the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲
are plotted for comparison; values of the crossover equation are only shown within its range of validity. The upper diagrams, which cover a greater
temperature range, only contain the data of Baehr and Schomäcker 共1975兲. The lower diagrams show a small temperature range around T and contain all data
available in this region.
compared with the corresponding c v values calculated from pressure of 400 MPa and a temperature of 800 K, which is
IAPWS-95, where two typical examples have been selected. comprehensively covered by accurate p T data 共see Fig.
For the density ⬇712.6 kg m⫺3, the upper deviation dia- 4.1兲, the differences in c v between the two equations of state
gram shows two data sets measured at the Dagestan Scien- are less than ⫾0.5% 共not counting the critical region of
tific Center; the data of Kerimov 共1964兲 exhibit systematic course兲. Therefore, we estimate that in this range the uncer-
deviations from the values of IAPWS-95 of about ⫹2.5% tainty of the IAPWS-95 formulation in c v is less than
while the data of Abdulagatov et al. 共1997兲 lie, within their ⫾0.75%.
scatter of about ⫾2%, around the values from IAPWS-95.
From the lower diagram, one can see that the recent data of 7.2.5. Isobaric Heat Capacity
Magee et al. 共1998兲 are represented to within their scatter of
about ⫾0.5% whereas the data of Kerimov 共1964兲 lie about The distribution of the experimental data for the isobaric
2% higher. Altogether, the c v data measured by Magee et al. heat capacity c p used to develop the IAPWS-95 formulation
共1998兲, deviate from IAPWS-95 on average between ⫺0.5% is shown in Fig. 4.8, see also Table 4.8. In the following,
and ⫺1% for ⭐967 kg m⫺3 and by ⫾0.5% for ⭓977 these experimental data are compared with the corresponding
kg m⫺3; for the density and temperature range covered by values calculated from the IAPWS-95 formulation, Eq. 共6.4兲,
Magee et al.’s data see Table 4.6. and from the other three equations of state mentioned at the
Based on the detailed investigation of the IAPWS-95 for- beginning of Sec. 7.
mulation with regard to the representation of the isochoric For six characteristic isobars at pressures below 15 MPa,
heat capacity, we believe that the IAPWS-95 formulation Fig. 7.32 presents comparisons between the experimental c p
describes the c v surface outside the immediate critical region data and the c p values calculated from IAPWS-95 where the
more accurately than the existing experimental data do. This data are only in the gas phase 共except for p⫽14.7 MPa兲.
statement is based on the fact that first, IAPWS-95 was not From the deviation diagrams, it can be seen that IAPWS-95
fitted to any c v data 关except for the 113 c v data of Baehr and represents the data to within their experimental uncertainty
Schomäcker 共1975兲, see Table 4.6兴, second, the way in which given in Table 4.8. IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲
the best data of the Dagestan Scientific Center and the data behave very similarly except for pressures below 10 MPa
of Magee et al. 共1998兲 are represented, and third, on the very when approaching the phase boundary. While in this region
good agreement between the c v values from IAPWS-95 and the deviations between the data and IAPWS-95 do not ex-
from the equation of Hill 共1990兲. In the region limited by a ceed 2%, the two other equations clearly yield lower c p val-
FIG. 7.29. Isochoric heat capacity in the near-critical region along a subcritical isochore as a function of temperature 共near-critical temperature range, T
⬎T , single-phase region兲 as calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, and from the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲. The inner
diagram shows a smaller temperature range in higher resolution and extends to higher c v values. The experimental data are plotted for comparison.
ues, which deviate from the experimental data by up to 共1990兲, and the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wycza-
⫺4%. On the other hand, a still better representation of these lkowska et al. 共2000兲 are plotted for comparison. Before dis-
data of Sirota and Timrot 共1956兲 by IAPWS-95 was not pos- cussing the representation of these data by IAPWS-95 and
sible without a significant deterioration in the representation the other equations of state, we give a brief comment on this
of the p T data and the speeds of sound in this region. ‘‘difficult’’ region. There are two basic reasons why the total
Figure 7.33 illustrates the problem described above more experimental uncertainty in c p rises drastically in the critical
clearly by plotting the absolute course of c p along some region. First, due to the strong increase of the isobaric heat
isobars and along the saturated vapor line for temperatures capacity in this region 共see Fig. 7.34兲, experimental uncer-
from the triple point to 600 K. For IAPWS-95, this figure tainties in temperature and pressure have a very strong effect
shows the good consistency between the representation of on the uncertainty in c p . For the same reason, relatively
the c p data of Sirota and Timrot 共1956兲 in the single-phase large differences in c p between the several equations of state
region near the saturated vapor line and the c ⬙p data of Sirota would result in relatively small differences when expressed
共1963兲 along the saturated vapor line. Except for tempera- in density or in temperature. The second reason is based on
tures T⬍370 K, IAPS-84 and Hill’s equation are not able to the experimental procedure to determine isobaric heat ca-
follow the c ⬙p data along the phase boundary, see also Fig. pacities. Usually, with flow calorimeters, enthalpy differ-
7.7. The c p data point of Sirota and Timrot 共1956兲 closest to ences and corresponding temperature differences are mea-
the phase boundary is in the two-phase region for these equa- sured. Due to the strong increase of c p in the critical region
tions. and the strong change of the slope of the isobars near their
The experimental c p data in the critical region are com- maximum in a c p – diagram, the exact assignment of the
pared with the values calculated from the IAPWS-95 formu- measured difference quotient (⌬h/⌬T) p to the isobaric heat
lation in Fig. 7.34 by a c p – diagram along four isobars and capacity defined by the differential quotient c p ⫽( h/ T) p is
in Fig. 7.35 by percentage deviation diagrams for the same a considerable source of error. Moreover, uncertainties in
isobars; values calculated from IAPS-84, the equation of Hill temperature or problems with its stability strongly affect the
FIG. 7.30. Isochoric heat capacity in the critical region along a supercritical isochore as a function of temperature as calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.
Experimental data and values calculated from IAPS-84, the equation of Hill 共1990兲, and the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska et al. 共2000兲
are plotted for comparison. The diagrams also cover the two-phase region (T⬍T ), where the left side shows a greater temperature range around T and the
right side a smaller one with higher resolution in temperature.
uncertainty in c p . In this difficult region, the IAPWS-95 mental c p data in this near-critical region. Outside the den-
formulation still represents the data within the experimental sity region shown in Fig. 7.35, the deviations again diminish
uncertainty, but one can see from Fig. 7.35 that the crossover to about 0.2% and less, for example along the isobar p
equation and Hill’s equation are clearly closer to the experi- ⫽24.517 MPa. In this pressure range, namely on the isobars
20, 23, 24, 26, and 28 MPa, there are also experimental c p
data of Ernst and Philippi 共1990兲, which cover the density
range from 100 to 1000 kg m⫺3. For densities greater than
550 kg m⫺3, these data do not deviate from the values of
IAPWS-95 by more than ⫾0.5%, and in most cases the de-
viation lies within ⫾0.3%.
However, very close to the critical point IAPWS-95 yields
an unnatural indentation in the plot of c p isotherms or iso-
bars over density, for details see the discussion in connection
with Figs. 6.9– 6.12 in Sec. 6.4.2.
The corresponding comparisons for five representative su-
percritical isobars from about 30 to 100 MPa are presented in
Fig. 7.36, which also includes the extended critical region.
Besides the data of Sirota’s group, this figure also contains
c p data of Ernst and Philippi 共1990兲. In contrast to Fig. 7.32,
the percentage deviations are again plotted versus density; in
this way, the region around the critical density is stretched
much more than when plotted over temperature. It can be
seen that in the extended critical region the deviations be-
tween the c p data and the values from IAPWS-95 remain
within ⫾2% for the isobar p⫽29.42 MPa and within ⫾1%
and less for the isobars up to p⫽68.65 MPa. It is not sur-
FIG. 7.31. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the isochoric
prising that the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wycza-
heat capacity c v and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values
calculated from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for lkowska et al. 共2000兲 covers the c p data in the extended criti-
comparison. cal region on average better than IAPWS-95, but attention
FIG. 7.32. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the isobaric heat capacity c p and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated
from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison.
parison between Wiryana et al.’s c p data and values IAPWS-95 are 11.4%. Due to the way in which Wiryana
calculated from IAPWS-95. It can be seen that for pressures et al. 共1998兲 obtained these c p data, we believe that the sys-
up to 1000 MPa, i.e., within the range of validity of IAPWS- tematic trend between the c p data and the values from
95, the deviations of the c p data remain within 3.5%, which IAPWS-95, shown in Fig. 7.38, is mainly due to the uncer-
is probably well within the uncertainty of the data. In the tainty of the data.
extrapolation range for pressures up to 3500 MPa, the maxi- From the statements on the uncertainty of the IAPWS-95
mum deviations of the data from the values calculated with formulation in c p made in Sec. 6.3.2 and from its compari-
FIG. 7.35. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the isobaric heat capacity c p and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated
from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison. The diagrams correspond to the same pressures and about the same density range
as covered by Fig. 7.34.
FIG. 7.40. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the Joule–Thomson coefficient and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values
calculated from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison.
one should not try to represent them to within their scatter. the statements made for Fig. 7.40 are also true here. The
Figure 7.41 presents comparisons between the experimen- peak in the deviations between IAPWS-95 and the other two
tal data of the isothermal throttling coefficient and the ␦ T equations at T⫽673 K and 28 MPa is not based on a zero
values from IAPWS-95 along four representative isotherms; crossing of ␦ T 共as for at 572 K兲, but are caused by a very
altogether the measurements of Ertle 共1979兲 cover a tempera- strong increase and decrease of c p in this small pressure
ture range from 621 to 1073 K. The comparisons are very region ( ␦ T ⫽⫺ •c p ); the ␦ T values of the three equations of
similar to those of the Joule–Thomson coefficient data and state differ correspondingly along this sharp peak of ␦ T .
FIG. 7.41. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the isothermal throttling coefficient ␦ T of Ertle 共1979兲 and values calculated from IAPWS-95,
Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison.
FIG. 7.42. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the isothermal throttling coefficient ␦ T of McGlashan and Wormald 共2000兲 and values
calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84, the equation of Hill 共1990兲, and the virial equation of Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲 are
plotted for comparison. The data shown as solid circles are ␦ T,0 data extrapolated by McGlashan and Wormald from their ␦ T data to zero pressure. Note that
the pressure unit is kPa.
Very recently, measurements of the isothermal throttling certainty. It can be seen that, except for T⫽383.26 K and T
coefficient ␦ T and of ␦ T.0 at zero pressure were reported by ⫽393.36 K, IAPWS-95 is not able to represent the ␦ T,0 data
McGlashan and Wormald 共2000兲. On 12 isotherms, these to within the uncertainty claimed by McGlashan and Worm-
data cover a temperature range from 313 to 413 K at very ald 共2000兲. In particular, the differences at the temperatures
low pressures of up to 82 kPa; for further details see Sec. 4.8. 363, 373, 403, and 413 K are not fully explainable, because
For four representative isotherms, Fig. 7.42 shows the devia- the best data of the second virial coefficient in the tempera-
tions of these ␦ T data from values calculated with IAPWS- ture range from 373 to 473 K 关Eubank et al. 共1988兲 and Kell
95. Again, this figure also contains the ␦ T values from et al. 共1989兲兴 are represented to within their uncertainty, see
IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 for comparison. Fig. 7.19. The equation that covers the ␦ T,0 data best is the
Since in the context of properties of H2 O in the diluted gas virial equation of Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲. Nevertheless,
region the virial equation of Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲 is it still cannot meet about half of the data within their uncer-
often used 共see also Sec. 7.2.2兲, ␦ T values from this equation tainty. Based on this entire investigation, it seems as if the
are also plotted. When keeping in mind the statements made experimental data for the isothermal throttling coefficient at
in Sec. 4.8 on the experimental uncertainty of these data, it
can be seen in Fig. 7.42 that in the greatest part of the mea-
suring range neither IAPWS-95 nor any of the three other
equations are able to represent the data to within the uncer-
tainties derived from the statements made by McGlashan and
Wormald 共2000兲. There are systematic deviations of the data
from values calculated with IAPWS-95, which go from
negative to positive with increasing temperature. In the
course of this trend, very good agreement is exhibited on the
isotherm T⫽393.36 K. For T⫽413.19 K the four equations
agree very well with each other, but the ␦ T data deviate
considerably from the average of the values of the equations.
For the uncertainty of the solid ␦ T,0 point at this temperature,
McGlashan and Wormald give a value of only ⫾1.4%, but
they do not exclude systematic errors.
Figure 7.43 presents absolute deviations of the data of FIG. 7.43. Absolute deviations ⌬ ␦ T,0⫽( ␦ T,0,exp⫺␦T,0,calc) between experi-
McGlashan and Wormald 共2000兲 for the isothermal throttling mental data of the isothermal throttling coefficient at zero pressure ␦ T,0 of
coefficient at zero pressure ␦ T,0 from the corresponding val- McGlashan and Wormald 共2000兲 and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq.
共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84, the equation of Hill 共1990兲, and the
ues calculated with IAPWS-95 and with the three other equa-
virial equation of Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲 are plotted for comparison. For
tions. Besides the ␦ T,0 data themselves, where ␦ T,0⫽B those data for which no uncertainties 共estimated by the experimenters兲 are
⫺T(dB/dT), this figure also contains the range of their un- plotted, the uncertainty range corresponds to the size of the symbols.
FIG. 7.44. Percentage deviations between experimental data of the isentropic temperature–pressure coefficient  s and values calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq.
共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison.
zero pressure and for the second virial coefficient are not 7.3.1. Derivatives of the Thermal Properties in the Liquid Phase
entirely mutually consistent. The reason for the opposite sign
of the deviations in Figs. 7.42 and 7.43 is that in Fig. 7.42 One important requirement for the development of the
the deviations are related to ␦ T,exp and these data have a IAPWS-95 formulation was a reasonable course of the first
negative sign. and second derivatives of the thermal properties in the liquid
region at low temperatures, see Sec. 1.3. The reason for this
requirement was that IAPS-84 manifested some weaknesses
7.2.8. Isentropic Temperature–Pressure Coefficient in this respect and it was desired that IAPWS-95 yield a clear
improvement in representing these derivatives. One example
The experimental data for the isentropic temperature– for the importance of this requirement is described in the
pressure coefficient 关  s ⫽( T/ p) s 兴 reported by Rögener following.
and Soll 共1980兲 were not used to develop the IAPWS-95 Solution chemists who study aqueous electrolytes make
formulation, because we know from the experience of Saul use of the Debye–Hückel limiting law for dilute solutions,
and Wagner 共1989兲 that the accuracy of an equation of state which produces a characteristic ‘‘Debye–Hückel slope’’ for
for  s data is comparable to that for the speed of sound in the each property. For the activity and osmotic coefficients, the
corresponding region of state. This experience has also been key parameter in the Debye–Hückel slope is the static di-
confirmed in this work. electric constant ⑀ of the solvent. However, derivative solu-
For four representative isotherms, Fig. 7.44 presents a tion properties such as the partial molar volume or partial
comparison between the experimental  s data and the values molar enthalpy are often studied. The Debye–Hückel slopes
calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲; the values from the for these properties involve the derivatives of ⑀ with respect
other two equations of state are also plotted. It can be seen to pressure and temperature ( ⑀ / ) T and ( ⑀ / T) p . Since
that IAPWS-95 represents these data to within their experi- the wide-range equations for ⑀ are given as a function of
mental uncertainty of ⌬  s ⫽⫾0.4%. The equation of Hill density and temperature, ⑀ ⫽ ⑀ ( ,T), one needs from an
共1990兲 achieves a similarly good representation of the data, equation of state the derivatives ( / p) T and ( p/ T) .
while IAPS-84 has some difficulties at low temperatures. 共Examples for such wide-range equations for the dielectric
constant are the equation of Archer and Wang 共1990兲 and the
equation of Fernández et al. 共1997兲 that was adopted as the
7.3. Selected Attributes of the IAPWS-95 IAPWS standard for ⑀ 关IAPWS 共1997兲兴.兲 For this purpose,
Formulation but also for a number of similar applications, the first deriva-
tives of the thermal properties of IAPWS-95 should be as
This section describes the behavior of the IAPWS-95 for- accurate as possible. In order to ensure this, the IAPWS-95
mulation with regard to the derivatives of the thermal prop- formulation should also yield a reasonable course of the sec-
erties, the behavior in the metastable regions, the results ond derivatives of the thermal properties.
when extrapolating to very high pressures and temperatures, With this background, Archer and Wang 共1990兲 pointed
and the behavior with regard to the so-called ideal curves. out that even small inaccuracies in the first density and pres-
FIG. 7.47. Percentage differences of values of the derivatives ( / p) T and ( / T) p for the four pressures 0.1, 1, 10, and 100 MPa calculated with IAPS-84
and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 from values calculated with IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲.
comparison. It can be seen that, in comparison with first and second derivatives of the thermal properties,
the three other equations of state, IAPWS-95 repre- then IAPWS-95 should not have any difficulties in
sents these data best, and Hill’s equation behaves this respect.
similarly well. In contrast to these two equations,
IAPS-84 but particularly the equation of Saul and For the four pressures 0.1, 1, 10, and 100 MPa and tem-
Wagner 共1989兲 show a different course in the percent- peratures from the melting temperature T m to 350 K, Fig.
age deviations, and therefore also a different course of 7.47 shows percentage differences between values of the two
the derivatives ( p/ ) T and ( 2 p/ 2 ) T . Given the derivatives ( / p) T and ( / T) p calculated from IAPS-84
quality of IAPWS-95 in this low-temperature part of and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 and the corresponding values
the liquid region, if the very good representation of calculated from IAPWS-95. In the diagrams on the left, the
the p T data in this region was indeed the decisive differences in the derivative ( / p) T between the equation
precondition for a reasonable representation of the of Hill 共1990兲 and IAPWS-95 are less than 0.1% except for
FIG. 7.48. Values of the derivatives ( 2 / p 2 ) T , ( 2 / T 2 ) p , and ( 2 / p T) as a function of pressure for the temperatures 273.15 and 298.15 K and
( 2 / T 2 ) p as a function of temperature for p⫽0.101 325 MPa as calculated from IAPWS-95, IAPS-84, and the equation of Hill 共1990兲.
the isobar p⫽100 MPa. From the diagrams on the right one formulation yields in all cases a very steady course of the
can see that, except for T⬇277 K and p⭐10 MPa, second derivatives, which is also true for the equation of Hill
IAPWS-95 and the equation of Hill agree with each other 共1990兲; the differences between these two equations are mar-
regarding the derivative ( / T) p within 0.5%. The reason ginal. In contrast, IAPS-84 shows significantly different
for the large differences at about 277 K is the density maxi- courses of these derivatives, particularly for T⫽273.15 K but
mum near this temperature; because ( / T) p ⫽0 at this also for T⫽298.15 K and along the isobar p
point, very small absolute differences in this derivative cause ⫽0.101 325 MPa; the maximum differences in the deriva-
large percentage differences. Except for the derivative tives ( 2 / p T) and ( 2 / T 2 ) p in comparison with the
( / T) p at rather high pressures 共for instance, p two other equations reach several hundred percent with
⫽100 MPa兲, the differences between IAPS-84 and the other
slopes that are even different in the sign.
two equations are not very large either. Thus, only the second
Taking into account the requirements for a reasonable rep-
derivatives are sensitive enough to detect significant differ-
ences between the equations of state in this respect. resentation of the first and second derivatives of the thermal
Figure 7.48 summarizes the plots of the three second de- properties in connection with the need for representing the
rivatives ( 2 / p 2 ) T , ( 2 / T 2 ) p , and ( 2 / p T) as a very accurate p T data and speeds of sound and the exis-
function of pressure for the two temperatures 273.15 and tence of a density maximum, the liquid range of H2 O places
298.15 K, and the derivative ( 2 / T 2 ) p as a function of very high demands on an equation of state that are unique in
temperature for p⫽0.101 325 MPa, where each derivative comparison with those placed on the liquid region for other
was calculated from IAPWS-95, IAPS-84, and the equation substances. The IAPWS-95 formulation meets these multiple
of Hill 共1990兲. The four diagrams show that the IAPWS-95 requirements.
FIG. 7.52. Percentage density deviations between experimental p T data in the superheated liquid 共left of the phase-boundary line兲 and values calculated from
IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲. Values calculated from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are plotted for comparison.
IAPWS-95 for temperatures down to 240 K. Attempts to ⫾1% at 238 K for the data of Archer and Carter 共2000兲, see
bring IAPWS-95 for temperatures T⬍265 K into better Sec. 4.5.2兴, the values of IAPWS-95 are still within the
agreement with the w data of Trinh and Apfel 共1978兲 and of coupled uncertainties 共except for the lowest temperature T
Petitet et al. 共1983兲 failed if one was not willing to accept ⫽236 K兲. The figure also shows that the equation of Hill
systematic density deviations far outside the experimental 共1990兲 follows the data of Angell et al. 共1982兲 as well.
uncertainty of the very accurate p T data of Kell 共1975兲 for IAPS-84 fails in representing the isobaric heat capacity in the
temperatures T⬍250 K along this isobar. Without forcing subcooled liquid.
IAPWS-95 to follow the w data of Trinh and Apfel 共1978兲 7.3.2.2. Superheated Liquid. In the superheated liquid,
and of Petitet et al. 共1983兲 for T⬍263 K, the p T data of there are the p T data of Chukanov and Skripov 共1971兲 and
Kell 共1975兲 and of Hare and Sorensen 共1987兲 in this region Evstefeev et al. 共1977兲 and the speed-of-sound data mea-
can be very well represented, see Fig. 7.49. Obviously, for sured by Evstefeev et al. 共1979兲. The temperature and pres-
p⫽0.101 325 MPa and T⬍263 K the speed-of-sound data of sure ranges of these data are given in Secs. 4.2.1 and 4.3,
Trinh and Apfel 共1978兲 and Petitet et al. 共1983兲 are not con- respectively.
sistent with the p T data of Kell 共1975兲 and of Hare and Comparisons between these data and values calculated
Sorensen 共1987兲. Therefore, we decided not to fit IAPWS-95 from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, are shown in Figs. 7.52 and 7.53
to any speed-of-sound data in the metastable region. by using a few isotherms as examples; the corresponding
In the subcooled liquid at a pressure p⫽0.101 325 MPa, values from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are
there are data for the isobaric heat capacity c p measured by plotted as well. Neither IAPWS-95 nor the two other equa-
Angell et al. 共1982兲 and more recently by Archer and Carter tions of state were fitted to these p T and w data. Since,
共2000兲; both data sets cover temperatures down to 236 K, see however, the course of the isotherms in the superheated liq-
Table 4.8. Figure 7.51 presents comparisons between these uid is very strongly determined by the accurate data in the
c p data and values calculated from IAPWS-95. The upper stable homogeneous liquid, none of the equations of state
diagram shows the absolute plot of the isobaric heat capacity discussed here has any difficulty in representing the p T and
as a function of temperature, and in the lower diagram the w data to within their experimental uncertainties; for the p T
corresponding percentage deviations are given; values calcu- data we estimate the uncertainties to be less than ⫾0.05% in
lated from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 are also density. However, the data do not extend very far into the
plotted. It can be seen that IAPWS-95 represents the c p data metastable region.
of Angell et al. 共1982兲, to which IAPWS-95 was fitted, to In the following the course of the spinodals on the satu-
within their experimental uncertainty, see below. Due to the rated liquid side of the vapor–liquid two-phase region calcu-
discrepancy between Angell et al.’s data and the data of Ar- lated from IAPWS-95, IAPS-84, and the equation of Hill
cher and Carter 共2000兲, see Sec. 4.5.2, there are also system- 共1990兲 is discussed. 共The vapor and liquid spinodals are lines
atic differences between the values from IAPWS-95 and the which connect, within the vapor–liquid two-phase region, all
data of Archer and Carter 共2000兲. However, when taking into minima of the isotherms 共liquid spinodal兲 and all maxima of
account the uncertainties of both data sets 关⫾3% for the data the isotherms 共vapor spinodal兲. The liquid spinodal, which is
of Angell et al. 共1982兲 and between ⫾0.3% at 285 K and of interest here, describes the location on the isotherms at
Based on our experience with the development of the ref- capacities 共Sec. 7.2.5兲. The extrapolation behavior of
erence equations of state for methane 关Setzmann and Wagner IAPWS-95 with respect to the above-mentioned item 共2兲 is
共1991兲兴 and carbon dioxide 关Span and Wagner 共1996兲兴, dur- mainly dealt with in the context of the Hugoniot curve in the
ing the entire development of the IAPWS-95 formulation we following subsection, while the extrapolation capability with
attached importance to its reasonable extrapolation behavior. regard to the above-mentioned item 共3兲 is discussed with the
The extrapolation capability relates to the following three help of the so-called ideal curves in the subsection after that.
features: 7.3.3.1. Hugoniot Curve and pT Behavior at Extreme
共1兲 representation of experimental data outside the fitting Pressures and Temperatures. The extrapolation capability
共and validity兲 range of IAPWS-95; of the IAPWS-95 formulation into the region of extremely
共2兲 extrapolation beyond the range of primary data to very high pressures and temperatures is tested with the help of
high pressures combined with high densities; and shock-wave measurements meeting the so-called Hugoniot
共3兲 extrapolation beyond the range of primary data to very relation. For details of such Hugoniot-curve data, which are a
high temperatures combined with high and particularly combination of values of the three properties pressure, den-
with low densities. sity, and specific enthalpy, see Sec. 4.9.
For water, such p h data were measured by three groups
The performance of IAPWS-95 with regard to item 共1兲 was of authors: Walsh and Rice 共1957兲, Lyzenga et al. 共1982兲,
shown by a comparison of IAPWS-95 with reliable experi- and Mitchell and Nellis 共1982兲. As already mentioned in Sec.
mental data outside its range of validity 共1000 MPa, 1273 4.9, these data were not used for the development of the
K兲. Such comparisons have been carried out for p T data IAPWS-95 formulation because their use would have re-
共Sec. 7.2.1兲, speeds of sound 共Sec. 7.2.3兲, and isobaric heat sulted in nonlinear relations that require iterative solutions
for temperature. Moreover, for an equation of state that had yields a maximum temperature of only 420 K for the p h
already been optimized with regard to its functional struc- data. Thus, the IAPWS-95 formulation is the only equation
ture, nonlinear fits involving Hugoniot data hardly exercise of state for H2 O that reasonably represents the Hugoniot data
an influence on the representation of these data—the ex- based on the shock wave measurements of the three groups
trapolation behavior of such equations of state is closely re- of authors.
lated to their functional form, see Span and Wagner 共1997兲. When testing an equation of state’s extrapolation capabil-
Any attempt to use Hugoniot data in linear optimization al- ity to extreme pressures and temperatures, a reasonable rep-
gorithms, as applied for developing IAPWS-95 共see Sec. resentation of the Hugoniot curve is a necessary but not a
5.3兲, requires a precorrelation of the temperature belonging sufficient condition. It can happen that an equation meets the
to these data points. 关Recently, during the development of the condition ‘‘Hugoniot curve’’ but displays an unphysical p T
new reference equation of state for nitrogen 关Span et al. behavior in this region. With this background, Fig. 7.56 il-
共2000兲兴, for the first time Hugoniot data were used directly in lustrates the p T behavior along the three isotherms T
combination with the nonlinear optimization algorithm of ⫽448 K, T⫽773 K, and T⫽1273 K in a p – diagram as
Tegeler et al. 共1997兲, 共1999兲.兴 However, due to the absence calculated from three equations of state. It can be seen that
of ‘‘real’’ p T data at these extreme conditions, such precor- IAPWS-95 共upper diagram兲 yields a very ‘‘harmonic’’ plot of
related temperatures cannot be checked. Therefore, such an the isotherms, while IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲
approach risks distorting the experimental information given produce physically unreasonable plots of these isotherms.
by Hugoniot data. For H2 O, one bad example in this respect IAPS-84 共middle diagram兲 yields a crossing point of the iso-
is the p T values of Rice and Walsh 共1957兲, which they therms at the same value of the density at which the Hugo-
derived from their Hugoniot measurements 关Walsh and Rice niot curve of this equation yields a solution in the solid re-
共1957兲兴, for details see Sec. 4.9. However, an equation of gion, see Fig. 7.55. Hill’s equation shows a similar behavior,
state fitted to these p T values yields totally unreasonable namely a crossing point of the isotherms at about ⫽1675
plots for the Hugoniot curve, with parts even having an un- kg m⫺3 and, in addition, at higher densities the isotherms
physical negative slope. turn downward.
Based on this knowledge, the reasonable extrapolation ca- 7.3.3.2. Ideal Curves. Plots of so-called ideal curves are
pability of IAPWS-95 was mainly achieved by choosing a useful in assessing the behavior of an equation of state in
suitable functional form for the bank of terms 共limitations on regions beyond the range of available data 关Deiters and de
the density and temperature exponents of the pure polyno- Reuck 共1997兲, Span and Wagner 共1997兲, Span 共2000兲兴, as
mial terms and the polynomial part combined with the expo- well as in revealing inconsistencies in the available data sets.
nential functions, see Secs. 5.4.1 and 5.4.2兲. These functional 共Ideal curves are curves along which one property of a real
measures were slightly supported by adding to the data set fluid is equal to the corresponding property of the hypotheti-
used to fit IAPWS-95 共with very low weight兲 so-called ‘‘ar- cal ideal gas at the same density and temperature. Based on
tificial’’ p T data determined in the optimization process this very general definition, ideal curves can be defined for
from interim equations that reasonably represented the almost every property, but usually the discussion is focused
Hugoniot curve, see Sec. 4.11. The data of the Hugoniot on the ideal curves of the compression factor and its first
curve themselves 共see Sec. 4.9兲 were only used for compari- derivatives.兲 The most common ideal curves are those of the
son. compression factor Z and its first derivatives. These curves
Figure 7.55 presents a plot of the Hugoniot curve for H2 O are also considered here and their definitions are given in
as calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, and three further Table 7.1. Besides testing an equation of state at high pres-
equations of state; the experimental data of the correspond- sures and high temperatures, these ideal curves are also very
ing shock-wave measurements, which extend to pressures well suited to test the equations at high temperatures and low
beyond 80 000 MPa, are plotted as well. The four equations pressures and low densities, respectively.
of state yield rather different Hugoniot curves. The equation Figure 7.57 illustrates in a double-logarithmic pressure–
of Saul and Wagner 共1989兲 shows, in comparison to the ex- temperature diagram the plots of the four characteristic ideal
perimental data, a Hugoniot curve that is too steep, although curves for H2 O as calculated from the IAPWS-95 formula-
it was fitted to the p T data of Rice and Walsh 共1957兲 that tion, Eq. 共6.4兲. The range in which reliable experimental data
had been derived by these authors from their Hugoniot data. exist, to which IAPWS-95 was fitted, is marked by the dotted
This confirms our statement on determining the temperature region. Although the curves in this figure do not provide any
from the p h data obtained from Hugoniot measurements, numerical information, reasonable shapes without visible os-
see above. The equation of Hill 共1990兲 is clearly too flat in cillations as shown in the figure indicate a qualitatively cor-
the lower part up to densities of about 2200 kg m⫺3 and rect extrapolation behavior of IAPWS-95. In contrast,
afterward much too steep; above the end point of this curve, IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 关and also the equa-
no further equilibrium states according to Eq. 共4.3兲 can be tion of Saul and Wagner 共1989兲, which is not shown here兴
calculated from Hill’s equation. At first glance it looks as if exhibit some serious shortcomings when describing both the
IAPS-84 represents the Hugoniot data quite well, but this Joule–Thomson inversion curve and the Joule inversion
equation yields a solution of Eq. 共4.3兲 that extends into the curve. As can be seen from Fig. 7.58, both equations show a
solid phase of H2 O for densities near ⫽1500 kg m⫺3 and physically unreasonable oscillating behavior of the Joule–
TABLE 7.1. The zeroth and first order ideal curves for the compression factor Z and their definitions in terms of
the compression factor Z( ,T) and of the residual part of the reduced Helmholtz free energy r( ,T) and the
condition for the second virial coefficient B at the temperature T enda
Definition in terms of
Boyle curve 冉冊
Z
T
⫽0 r␦ ⫹ ␦ r␦␦ ⫽0 B⫽0
a
Temperatures where the ideal curves cross the axes p⫽0 and ⫽0, respectively, are called end temperatures,
T end . At these temperatures, the second virial coefficient must meet the condition given in the column on the
right.
b
For an explanation of the quantities r␦ , r␦␦ , and ␦r , see the footnote of Table 6.5.
Thomson inversion curve to the right of its maximum. In fluence. In order to produce the desired reasonable represen-
contrast, IAPWS-95, which is also plotted in Fig. 7.58 for tation of the Joule inversion curve, ten data points of the
comparison, is able to describe the course of this curve very second virial coefficient in this temperature range calculated
smoothly and according to physical expectations, see Span from the gas equation, Eq. 共3.2兲, were incorporated into the
and Wagner 共1997兲. final data set used to develop IAPWS-95, see Sec. 4.10.
Concerning the ideal curves, Fig. 7.58 also shows that the
most significant discrepancy between IAPWS-95, IAPS-84,
and the equation of Hill 共1990兲 exists in their description of
the Joule inversion curve. Only IAPWS-95 is able to repre-
sent the theoretically expected course of this curve. 共The
only substance for which the region of the Joule inversion
curve is completely covered by experimental data is helium.
Thus, for this substance the theoretically expected course of
this curve is experimentally verified.兲 In particular, based on
the fact that the other equations of state are not able to yield
any zero crossing of this ideal curve, it can be concluded that
they also behave incorrectly regarding the second virial co-
efficient B at these high temperatures. According to Table
7.1, for this ideal curve the condition for B at this zero cross-
ing 共corresponding to T end兲 reads dB/dT⫽0, which requires
a maximum in B at the temperature T end . In this context, Fig.
7.59 presents the second virial coefficient for these extremely
high temperatures as calculated from IAPWS-95, IAPS-84,
and the equation of Hill 共1990兲. For comparison purposes,
the virial equation of Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲 is also plot-
ted. As can be seen, of all the wide-range equations of state
关including the equation of Saul and Wagner 共1989兲, which is
not shown in the figure兴, only the IAPWS-95 formulation is
able to produce a maximum in B at a reasonable temperature.
The virial equation of Hill and MacMillan 共1988兲 has the
maximum at a very similar temperature, which confirms the
course of the Joule inversion curve predicted by IAPWS-95.
FIG. 7.57. The so-called ideal curves in a double logarithmic p/p c vs T/T c
During the development of IAPWS-95, the Joule inversion diagram as calculated from IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲; for the definition of these
curve was the only ideal curve to which we had to pay at- curves see Table 7.1.
tention and on whose representation we had to exert an in-
FIG. 7.58. The ideal curves in a double logarithmic p/p c vs T/T c diagram as
calculated from IAPS-84 and the equation of Hill 共1990兲; the curves calcu-
lated from IAPWS-95 are plotted for comparison. For the designation of the
curves see Fig. 7.57.
the uncertainty in enthalpy, which will be given as an Infor- melting-curve temperature, it would be helpful to have p T
matory Note 共see the IAPWS website from 2004 on兲. data with uncertainties in density on the order of ⫾0.02%.
Outside the range of its validity, IAPWS-95, Eq. 共6.4兲, With such data, the inconsistency between the p T data of
should yield reasonable results for the basic thermodynamic Grindley and Lind 共1971兲 and of Kell and Whalley 共1975兲,
properties like pressure 共density兲 and enthalpy within the see Fig. 4.2, could be clarified. At present, the gas region is
whole chemically stable region of H2 O. Of course, the ex- covered by the p T data of Kell et al. 共1989兲, which show,
trapolation results have an increased uncertainty that cannot however, scatter on the order of ⫾0.05% and uncertainties of
be estimated. The calculation of derived properties such as up to ⫹0.2% at 423 and 448 K when approaching the phase
speed of sound or specific isobaric and isochoric heat capac- boundary 共see Fig. 4.3兲; moreover, the selected data of Kell
ity is not recommended beyond the limits of validity of et al. ‘‘only’’ extend down to 473 K. Therefore, in order to
IAPWS-95. If such properties are calculated, the results fix the derivatives of the p T surface in this region better, it
should be checked carefully. For extrapolation into the three would be desirable to have new p T data in the gas region,
metastable regions; subcooled liquid, superheated liquid, and preferably covering a temperature range from 373 to 873 K
subcooled vapor, see Sec. 7.3.2. at pressures up to the vapor pressure and for supercritical
temperatures up to about 40 MPa. However, such remeasure-
9. Recommendations for Improving ments in the gas region only make sense if uncertainties in
the Basis of the Experimental Data density of less than ⫾0.02% can be achieved; this is in prin-
ciple possible with modern two-sinker densimeters in which
The beginning of Sec. 4 stated that water is one of the best the influence of adsorption is compensated, see Wagner et al.
experimentally investigated fluids. This statement is particu- 共2002兲. For the critical region, it would be desirable to have
larly based on the very high accuracy of the p T data in the critical-region p T data with uncertainties in pressure of less
liquid region, on the accurate p T data in the gas region for than ⫾0.01%–⫾0.02%. In this way, the increase of c p in the
not too high temperatures 共see Fig. 6.1兲, and on the quantity critical region would be better fixed and water could catch up
of speed-of-sound and isobaric-heat-capacity data. However, with other very well measured substances in the critical re-
if an improved equation of state is to be developed it would gion 共for example, CH4 , CO2 , N2 , Ar, C2 H4 , SF6 , and
be helpful to have data with higher accuracies and, more C2 H6 兲. Having a p T data set of the quality described above
importantly, to have data in those regions for which, at would to a large extent compensate for the absence of very
present, reliable experimental data are not available at all. accurate data for the isobaric and isochoric heat capacity, see
While it might be somewhat surprising, we consider the below.
thermal properties 共p ⬘ ⬙ T data兲 along the entire vapor– As usual, compared with the p T data, the data situation
liquid phase boundary a candidate for a remeasuring project. regarding the caloric properties is clearly worse. For the
As discussed in several places in Sec. 7, there are inconsis- speed of sound w, the very well measured region 关283–373
tencies between the properties on the phase boundary and K, 10–100 MPa, Fujii 共1994兲 to 200 MPa兴 with uncertainties
those in the single-phase region near the saturation state. The between ⫾0.005% and ⫾0.05% should be extended to a
data for the vapor pressure p and the saturated-vapor den- greater range of temperatures and pressures. It would be de-
sity ⬙ are based mainly on data of Osborne et al. measured sirable to have such measurements for pressures up to 500
in the 1930’s, see Table 2.1. Moreover, the ⬘ and ⬙ data of MPa and up to supercritical temperatures, preferably up to
Osborne et al. 共1937兲, 共1939兲 were not directly measured, about 900 K. It would be necessary that the experimental
but were determined from measurements of special caloric uncertainties of such data be less than ⫾0.03%, at least for
data in combination with further information, see Sec. 2.3.1. temperatures up to 650 K. In this case, the reason for the
We also believe that the ⬘ data of Kell et al. 共1985兲 exhibit systematic deviation of the present w data in this region in
certain inconsistencies with the p T data in the single-phase comparison with the values from IAPWS-95 共see Fig. 7.21兲
liquid region. Thus, it would be interesting to see ⬘ ⬙ T could be clarified and the wpT surface in this region would
data measured directly with a state-of-the-art two-sinker den- be much better defined. Based on the present experimental
simeter 关see Wagner et al. 共2002兲兴 with which, for most of possibilities for speed-of-sound measurements in the liquid
the liquid–vapor phase boundary of other substances, uncer- region, uncertainties of this order are in principle achievable.
tainties in p , ⬘, and ⬙ of less than about ⫾0.015%, It would also be very desirable to have new speed-of-sound
⫾0.012%, and ⫾0.025%, respectively, have been achieved. measurements in the gas region for temperatures starting
In the single-phase region, the p T data of Vukalovich near the phase boundary and extending to 650 K 共if possible
et al. 共1961兲 should be replaced by more accurate data in the to higher temperatures兲 at pressures from 0.1 MPa to near the
temperature range above 800 K at pressures of, if possible, vapor pressure, and for supercritical temperatures up to 25
up to 500 MPa. It would very desirable if such data had MPa or even higher if possible. The experimental uncertainty
uncertainties in density of less than ⫾0.1%, preferably on the of such w measurements should be less than ⫾0.01%, which
order of ⫾0.05%. Then, the discrepancies in the p T surface is achievable with spherical resonators 关see Goodwin
of H2 O in this high-temperature region 共see Secs. 7.2.1.4 and 共2002兲兴. Then, such measurements would define a new qual-
7.2.1.5兲 could be removed. For the pressure range from 100 ity of the wpT surface of H2 O at gas densities.
to 500 MPa and temperatures below 800 K down to the At present, the best data for the isobaric heat capacity c p
are mostly confined to the middle density range from about been developed. The functional form of this formulation has
100 to 700 kg m⫺3 ( c⫽322 kg m⫺3 ), supplemented by a been determined by using a state-of-the-art linear structure-
few data in the gas region and in the liquid region at very optimization method combined with nonlinear fitting pro-
high densities and low temperatures, see Fig. 4.8. Except for cesses in an iterative procedure. The new formulation has
these very few c p data in the liquid region, the uncertainties been adopted by the IAPWS as the new scientific standard
of all the other c p data were given by the experimenters as equation of state for H2 O under the name ‘‘The IAPWS For-
⫾0.5%–⫾2%. However, in order to have a real test of an mulation 1995 for the Thermodynamic Properties of Ordi-
equation of state regarding its c p behavior outside the critical nary Water Substance for General and Scientific Use,’’ which
region, the c p data should have uncertainties on the order of we abbreviate to IAPWS-95 formulation or IAPWS-95 for
⫾0.1%–⫾0.2% in the gas and liquid region. At present, short. This IAPWS-95 formulation is valid in the fluid region
however, such a requirement cannot be experimentally real- of H2 O up to temperatures of 1273 K at pressures up to 1000
ized. A possible alternative is given below. MPa. IAPWS-95 is able to represent the most accurate ex-
Concerning the isochoric heat capacity c v , the present perimental data in the single-phase region and on the vapor–
data situation is worse than that for c p . Except for the ex- liquid phase boundary to within their experimental uncer-
perimental verification of the steep increase of the c v values tainty. In particular, in the liquid region IAPWS-95 is of an
when approaching the critical point and of the order of mag- accuracy that has never been achieved before by a wide-
nitude of this increase, and except for the high-density c v range equation of state; for example, the standard densities
data of Magee et al. 共1998兲, the existing c v data are unfor- along the isobar p⫽0.101 325 MPa are represented to within
tunately not accurate enough to serve as a real test of an the 1 ppm level. Moreover, IAPWS-95 represents the experi-
equation of state regarding its c v behavior. For this purpose mental data of the thermal properties in the critical region
one would need c v measurements with uncertainties of without any difficulty.
⫾0.1%–⫾0.2% 共except for the critical region兲, but over the Special interest has been focused on a reasonable repre-
entire relevant part of the surface of state 共i.e., temperatures sentation of the caloric properties in the critical region and
to about 900 K and pressures to 100 MPa兲. As for c p , this on a good extrapolation behavior of IAPWS-95. For the ba-
requirement is probably unrealistic. sic improvement of the caloric behavior in the critical region,
A potentially achievable experimental compromise regard- the nonanalytical terms from the reference equation of state
ing the desirable c p and c v measurements might be as fol- for carbon dioxide 关Span and Wagner 共1996兲兴 were adopted.
lows. The entire surface could be split into the gas region, for Although these terms are not perfect, they enable IAPWS-95
which c p measurements are better suited, and into the liquid to represent the isochoric heat capacity and the speed of
region, for which c v measurements are better suited. At sound even in the immediate vicinity of the critical point;
present, it should be possible to carry out c p measurements until the equation of state for CO2 of Span and Wagner
in the gas region with experimental uncertainties between 共1996兲, this attribute had only been a domain of scaled equa-
⫾0.1% and ⫾0.3% and c v measurements in the liquid region tions of state, which use iterative dependencies between dif-
on the order of ⫾0.2%–⫾0.4%, see the c v data of Magee ferent sets of variables and have a limited range of validity.
et al. 共1998兲. Based on our assessment, it is not absolutely Mostly because of its functional structure, the IAPWS-95
necessary to measure c p data in the critical region, because formulation can be extrapolated to extremely high pressures
the increase of c p in this region is mainly based on the de- and very high temperatures and densities; at least for the
rivative ( / p) T , see Eq. 共6.11兲. This means that very good basic properties of H2 O such as pressure 共density兲 and spe-
p T measurements would be sufficient to model the increase cific enthalpy, IAPWS-95 should yield reasonable results
of c p in the critical region. However, the behavior of an within the whole region of chemical stability. The good rep-
equation of state regarding the isochoric heat capacity in the resentation of the so-called ideal curves has shown that
critical region can only be reasonably modeled if one has IAPWS-95 can also be reasonably extrapolated to high tem-
good c v data in this region. Besides a reasonable experimen- peratures at low densities and low pressures.
tal accuracy, such data should particularly have very good
internal consistency to guide the equation of state appropri- 11. Acknowledgments
ately.
Finally, the inconsistency in the isobaric heat capacity in The authors are indebted to the members of the following
the ideal-gas state c ⴰp , which exists at high temperatures be- IAPWS groups 共so far as W. W. is not a member himself兲:
tween the different c ⴰp data sets 共see Sec. 4.5.1兲, should be Working Group ‘‘Thermophysical Properties of Water and
clarified. Steam,’’ and its predecessor working groups with the same
scope, Task Group ‘‘New Scientific Formulation,’’ and Task
10. Conclusions Group ‘‘New Scientific Formulation–Evaluation.’’ In par-
ticular, one of us 共W.W.兲 is very grateful to his two col-
Based on a comprehensive study of the experimental data leagues in the Task Group ‘‘New Scientific Formulation,’’ P.
for the thermodynamic properties of ordinary water sub- G. Hill and J. V. Sengers 共who became the chairman of this
stance (H2 O), a new equation of state in the form of a fun- group in 1994兲 for their very fair and friendly collaboration,
damental equation explicit in the Helmholtz free energy has and also to D. G. Friend who joined this task group in 1995.
Similarly important has been the continuous support of this Abdulagatov, I. M., V. I. Dvoryanchikov, M. M. Aliev, and
comprehensive project over all the years by the chairpersons A. N. Kamalov, in Proceedings of the 13th International
of the Working Group ‘‘Thermophysical Properties of Water Conference on the Properties of Water and Steam 共NRC,
and Steam’’ and its predecessor groups, J. M. H. Levelt Sen- Ottawa, 2000兲, p. 157.
gers 共1990兲, K. Watanabe 共1991–1994兲, and J. R. Cooper Alexandrov, A. A. and A. I. Kochetov, Teploenergetika 26,
共1995 and 1996兲. We are also grateful to the chairman of the 65 共1979兲; Thermal Eng. 26, 558 共1979兲.
Task Group ‘‘New Scientific Formulation-Evaluation,’’ J. Alexandrov, A. A. and D. K. Larkin, Teploenergetika 23,
Gallagher, and his colleagues A. Alexandrov, J. R. Cooper,
75 共1976兲; Thermal Eng. 23, 72 共1976兲.
H.-J. Kretzschmar, J. Patek, and H. Sato for their efforts in
Alexandrov, A. A. and A. I. Kochetov, The Investigation of
testing IAPWS-95 regarding the most relevant thermody-
namic properties in the various regions of state. In addition, Velocity of Sound in Water and Steam—Their Properties and
we are indebted to A. Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska and J. V. Current Industrial Applications, Proceeding of the 9th Inter-
Sengers for investigating IAPWS-95 regarding its behavior national Conference on the Properties of Steam, Munich
in the near-critical and extended critical region. Moreover, 1979, edited by J. Straub and K. Scheffler 共Pergamon, Ox-
we are grateful to all IAPWS colleagues who contributed to ford, 1980兲, p. 221.
the entire project of the development of the IAPWS-95 for- Amirkhanov, Kh. I., G. V. Stepanov, and B. G. Alibekov,
mulation. On behalf of all of them we would like to thank the in Isochoric Heat Capacity of Water and Steam, edited by M.
presidents of IAPWS who held office during the develop- P. Vukalovich 共Akad. Nauk SSSR, Dagestanskii Filial,
ment period of IAPWS-95, namely M. Pichal, J. M. H. Lev- 1969兲, p. 217; English translation 共Amerind Publ. Co., New
elt Sengers, J. R. Cooper, and K. Watanabe. We also wish to Dehli, 1974兲, p. 203.
express our warmest thanks to D. Bücker for his help in Angell, C. A., M. Oguni, and W. J. Sichina, J. Phys. Chem.
handling the computer programs for plotting all the figures 86, 998 共1982兲.
and to R. Gölzenleuchter for her postediting of these figures. Archer, D. G. and R. W. Carter, J. Phys. Chem. B 104,
Moreover, we would like to thank C. Bonsen, D. Bücker, R.
8563 共2000兲.
Kleinrahm, O. Kunz, N. Kurzeja, and particularly R. Span
Archer, D. G. and P. Wang, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 19,
for many fruitful discussions. In addition we thank A. Kos-
trowicka Wyczalkowska for providing us with the computer 371 共1990兲.
code of the crossover equation of Kostrowicka Wycza- Audi, G. and A. H. Wapstra, Nucl. Phys. A 565, 1 共1993兲.
lkowska et al. 共2000兲, I. M. Abdulagatov for providing us in Baehr, H. D. and H. Schomäcker, Forsch. Ing.-Wes. 41, 43
electronic form with many c v data measured at the Dagestan 共1975兲.
Scientific Center of the Russian Academy of Sciences, and Bedford, R. E. and C. G. M. Kirby, Metrologia 5, 83
K. Fujii for making very accurate speed-of-sound data avail- 共1969兲.
able prior to their publication. Our special thanks go to A. H. Benedict, M., G. B. Webb, and L. C. Rubin, J. Chem.
Harvey for carefully reading the entire manuscript, for sug- Phys. 8, 334 共1940兲.
gestions in improving certain details, for improving the BIPM, Supplementary Information for the International
grammar, and for some information on more recent articles Temperature Scale of 1990 共Bureau International des Poids et
on the properties of water. We also thank E. W. Lemmon for Mesures, Pavillon de Breteuil, F-92310 Sèvres, France,
carefully reading the manuscript and for giving us helpful 1990兲.
suggestions. Finally, we are particularly grateful to the Bridgman, P. W., J. Chem. Phys. 3, 597 共1935兲.
Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft 共German Research Asso-
Bridgman, P. W., Proc. Am. Acad. Arts Sci. 74, 419
ciation兲 for their financial support of the development of the
共1942兲.
IAPWS-95 formulation.
Castro-Gomez, R. C., K. R. Hall, J. C. Holste, B. E. Gam-
mon, and K. N. Marsh, J. Chem. Thermodyn. 22, 269 共1990兲.
12. References Chase, M. W., NIST-JANAF Thermochemical Tables, 4th
ed., Part II, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, Monograph No. 9
Abdulagatov, I. M. and V. I. Dvoryanchikov, J. Chem.
共1998兲.
Thermodyn. 25, 823 共1993兲.
Chavez, M., V. Sosa, and R. Tsumura, J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
Abdulagatov, I. M., A. R. Bazaev, and A. E. Romazanova,
77, 420 共1985兲.
J. Chem. Thermodyn. 25, 249 共1993兲.
Abdulagatov, I. M., V. I. Dvoryanchikov, and A. N. Ka- Chen, Z. Y., A. Abacci, S. Tang, and J. V. Sengers, Phys.
malov, J. Chem. Thermodyn. 29, 1387 共1997兲. Rev. A 42, 4470 共1990兲.
Abdulagatov, I. M., V. I. Dvoryanchikov, and A. N. Ka- Chukanov, V. N. and V. P. Skripov, Teplofiz. Vys. Temp. 9,
malov, J. Chem. Eng. Data 43, 830 共1998兲. 739 共1971兲; High Temp. 9, 672 共1971兲.
Abdulagatov, I. M., B. A. Mursalov, and N. M. Gamzatov, Colina, C. M. and C. Olivera-Fuentes, Ind. Eng. Chem.
in Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on the Res. 41, 1064 共2002兲.
Properties of Water and Steam 共Begell House, New York, Cooper, J. R., Int. J. Thermophys. 3, 35 共1982兲.
1995兲, p. 94. Czarnota, I., High Temp.—High Press. 16, 295 共1984兲.
Deiters, U. K. and K. M. de Reuck, Pure Appl. Chem. 69, Hare, D. E. and C. M. Sorensen, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 5085
1237 共1997兲. 共1986兲.
Del Grosso, V. A. and C. W. Mader, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. Hare, D. E. and C. M. Sorensen, J. Chem. Phys. 87, 4840
52, 1442 共1972兲. 共1987兲.
Ernst, G. and R. Philippi, J. Chem. Thermodyn. 22, 211 Harvey, A. H., Minutes of the Meetings of the Executive
共1990兲. Committee of IAPWS, London, 1998, p. 41.
Erokhin, N. F. and B. I. Kal’yanov, Teplofiz. Vys. Temp. Hendl, H., E. Bich, and E. Vogel, J. Chem. Thermodyn.
17, 290 共1979兲; High Temp. 17, 245 共1979兲. 29, 765 共1997兲.
Erokhin, N. F. and B. I. Kal’yanov, Teploenergetika 27, 50 Hilbert, R., K. Tödheide, and E. U. Franck, Ber. Bunsen-
共1980兲; Thermal Eng. 27, 634 共1980兲. ges. Phys. Chem. 85, 636 共1981兲.
Ertle, S., Dissertation, Technische Universität München, Hill, P. G., J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 19, 1233 共1990兲.
Germany, 1979. Hill, P. G. and R. D. C. MacMillan, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res.
Eubank, P. T., L. L. Joffrion, M. R. Patel, and W. 27, 874 共1988兲.
Warowny, J. Chem. Thermodyn. 20, 1009 共1988兲. Holton, G., M. P. Hagelberg, S. Kao, and W. H. Johnson,
Evstefeev, V. N., V. N. Chukanov, and V. P. Skripov, Jr., J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 43, 102 共1968兲.
Teplofiz. Vys. Temp. 15, 659 共1977兲; High Temp. 15, 550 IAPWS 共International Association for the Properties of
Water and Steam兲, Release on the Values of Temperature,
共1977兲.
Pressure and Density of Ordinary and Heavy Water Sub-
Evstefeev, V. N., V. P. Skripov, and V. N. Chukanov,
stances at their Respective Critical Points 共IAPWS Secre-
Teplofiz. Vys. Temp. 17, 299 共1979兲; High Temp. 17, 252
tariat, EPRI, Palo Alto, 1992兲. Also in White et al. 共1995兲, p.
共1979兲.
A101 共All IAPWS releases and guidelines can also be found
Ewers, J. and W. Wagner, Proceedings of the 8th Sympo-
on the IAPWS website http://www.iapws.org.兲.
sium on Thermophysical Properties 共American Society of
IAPWS 共International Association for the Properties of
Mechanical Engineers, New York, 1982兲, Vol. 1, p. 78. Water and Steam兲, Release on the Pressure along the Melting
Fernández, D. P., A. H. R. Goodwin, E. W. Lemmon, J. M. and the Sublimation Curves of Ordinary Water Substance
H. Levelt Sengers, and R. C. Williams, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. 共IAPWS Secretariat, EPRI, Palo Alto, 1993兲. Also in Wagner
Data 26, 1125 共1997兲. et al. 共1994兲, and in White et al. 共1995兲, p. A9.
Fujii, K. and R. Masui, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 93, 276 IAPWS 共International Association for the Properties of
共1993兲. Water and Steam兲, Release on the Skeleton Tables 1985 for
Fujii, K., ‘‘Accurate measurements of the sound velocity the Thermodynamic Properties of Ordinary Water Substance
in pure water under high pressure,’’ 12th Symposium on 共IAPWS Secretariat, EPRI, Palo Alto, 1994兲. Also in White
Thermophysical Properties, Boulder, Colorado, USA, 1994. et al. 共1995兲, p. A13.
Goodwin, A. R. H., ‘‘Experimental Methods in Sound IAPWS 共International Association for the Properties of
Speed’’, in IUPAC Experimental Thermodynamics, Vol VI: Water and Steam兲, Release on the IAPWS Formulation 1995
Measurements of the Thermodynamic Properties of Single for the Thermodynamic Properties of Ordinary Water Sub-
Phases, edited by A. R. H. Goodwin, K. N. Marsh, and W. A. stance for General and Scientific Use 共IAPWS Secretariat,
Wakeham 共Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2002兲. EPRI, Palo Alto, 1996兲. Also in Tremaine et al. 共2000兲, p.
Gonfiantini, R., Nature 共London兲 271, 534 共1978兲. A106.
Grindley, T. and J. E. Lind, Jr., J. Chem. Phys. 54, 3983 IAPWS 共International Association for the Properties of
共1971兲. Water and Steam兲, Release on the Static Dielectric Constant
Guildner, L. A., D. P. Johnson, and E. F. Jones, J. Res. of Ordinary Water Substance for Temperatures from 238 K to
Natl. Bur. Stand. 80A, 505 共1976兲. 873 K and Pressures up to 1000 MPa 共IAPWS Secretariat,
Gurvich, L. V., I. V. Veyts, and C. B. Alcock, Thermody- EPRI, Palo Alto, 1997兲. Also in Tremaine et al. 共2000兲, p.
namic Properties of Individual Substances, 4th ed. 共Hemi- A97.
sphere, New York, 1989兲, Vol. 1, Part 2. IAPWS 共International Association for the Properties of
Haar, L., J. S. Gallagher, and G. S. Kell, Proceedings of Water and Steam兲, Guideline on the Use of Fundamental
the 8th Symposium on Thermophysical Properties, edited by Physical Constants and Basic Constants of Water 共IAPWS
J. V. Sengers 共The American Society of Mechanical Engi- Secretariat; EPRI; Palo Alto, 2001兲.
neers, New York, 1982兲, Vol. II, p. 298. IFC 共International Formulation Committee of the Sixth In-
Haar, L., J. S. Gallagher, and G. S. Kell, NBS/NRC Steam ternational Conference on the Properties of Steam兲, The 1967
Tables 共Hemisphere, Washington, and McGraw-Hill, New Formulation for Industrial Use 共Verein Deutscher Inge-
York, 1984兲. nieure, Düsseldorf, 1967兲.
Hanafusa, H., T. Tsuchida, K. Kawai, H. Sato, M. Ue- IFC 共International Formulation Committee of the Sixth In-
matsu, and K. Watanabe, Proceedings of the 10th Interna- ternational Conference on the Properties of Steam兲, The 1968
tional Conference on the Properties of Steam, Moscow 1984, IFC Formulation for Scientific and General Use 共American
edited by V. V. Sytchev, and A. A. Aleksandrov 共MIR, Mos- Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York, 1968兲.
cow, 1984兲, p. 180. Keenan, J. H., F. G. Keyes, P. G. Hill, and J. G. Moore,
Steam Tables 共Wiley, New York, 1969兲.
J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, Vol. 31, No. 2, 2002
THERMODYNAMIC PROPERTIES OF ORDINARY WATER 483
Kell, G. S., J. Chem. Eng. Data 20, 97 共1975兲. Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on the
Kell, G. S., J. Phys. Chem. Rev. Data 6, 1109 共1977兲. Properties of Water and Steam, edited by H. J. White, Jr.
Kell, G. S. and E. Whalley, J. Chem. Phys. 62, 3496 et al. 共Begell House, New York, Wallingford, 1995兲, p. 78.
共1975兲. Masui, R., K. Fujii, and M. Takenaka, Metrologia 32, 333
Kell, G. S., G. E. McLaurin, and E. Whalley, in Advances 共1995/96兲.
in Thermophysical Properties at Extreme Temperatures and Mamedov, A. M., Inzh. Fiz. Zh. 36, 156 共1979兲.
Pressures, Proceedings of the Third Symposium on Thermo- McDade, J. C., D. R. Pardue, A. L. Hedrich, and F. Vra-
physical Properties, edited by S. Gratch 共American Society taric, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 31, 1380 共1959兲.
of Mechanical Engineers, New York, 1965兲, p. 104. McGlashan, M. L. and C. J. Wormald, J. Chem. Thermo-
Kell, G. S., G. E. McLaurin, and E. Whalley, J. Chem. dyn. 32, 1489 共2000兲.
Phys. 48, 3805 共1968兲. Menaché, M. and G. Girard, Metrologia 9, 62 共1973兲.
Kell, G. S., G. E. McLaurin, and E. Whalley, Proc. Roy.
Mitchell, A. C. and W. J. Nellis, J. Chem. Phys. 76, 6273
Soc. London A 360, 389 共1978兲.
共1982兲.
Kell, G. S., G. E. McLaurin, and E. Whalley, Philos.
Mohr, P. J. and B. N. Taylor, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 28,
Trans. R. Soc. London A 315, 235 共1985兲.
1713 共1999兲.
Kell, G. S., G. E. McLaurin, and E. Whalley, Proc. R. Soc.
London A 425, 49 共1989兲. Morita, T., H. Sato, M. Uematsu, and K. Watanabe,
Kerimov, A. M., Ph. D. thesis, Azneftechim, Azerbajdjan, Physica A 156, 436 共1989兲.
Baku, 1964. Novikov, I. I. and V. I. Avdonin, ‘‘Velocity of Sound in
Kerimov, A. M. and M. K. Alieva, Teploenergetika 22, 58 Saturated and Superheated Steam,’’ Report at the 7th Inter-
共1975兲; Therm. Eng. 22, 76 共1976兲. national Conference of the Properties of Steam, Tokyo, 1968.
Kestin, J. and J. V. Sengers, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 15, Osborne, N. S., H. F. Stimson, E. F. Fiock, and D. C.
305 共1986兲. Ginnings, J. Res. Natl. Bur. Stand. 10, 155 共1933兲.
Keyes, F. G., L. B. Smith, and H. T. Gerry, Proc. Am. Osborne, N. S., H. F. Stimson, and D. C. Ginnings, J. Res.
Acad. Arts Sci. 70, 319 共1936兲. Natl. Bur. Stand. 18, 389 共1937兲.
Kiselev, S. B. and D. G. Friend, Fluid Phase Equilibria Osborne, N. S., H. F. Stimson, and D. C. Ginnings, J. Res.
155, 33 共1999兲. Natl. Bur. Stand. 23, 197 共1939兲.
Köster, H. and E. U. Franck, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. Patterson, J. B. and E. C. Morris, Metrologia 31, 277
73, 716 共1969兲. 共1994兲.
Kostrowicka Wyczalkowska, A., Kh. S. Abdulkadirova, Petitet, J. P., R. Tufeu, and B. Le Neindre, Int. J. Thermo-
M. A. Anisimov, and J. V. Sengers, J. Chem. Phys. 113, 4985 phys. 4, 35 共1983兲.
共2000兲. Petitet, J. P., L. Denielou, R. Tufeu, and B. Le Neindre,
Kubota, H., Y. Tanaka, and T. Makita, Int. J. Thermophys. Int. J. Thermophys. 7, 1065 共1986兲.
8, 47 共1987兲. Philippi, R., Fortschritt-Berichte VDI, Reihe 19, Nr. 13
Kurzeja, N. and W. Wagner, Int. J. Thermophys. 22 共to be 共VDI, Düsseldorf, 1987兲.
submitted, 2002兲. Polikhronidi, N. G., I. M. Abdulagatov, J. W. Magee, and
Kurzeja, N., Th. Tielkes, and W. Wagner, Int. J. Thermo- G. V. Stepanov, Int. J. Thermophys. 22, 189 共2001兲.
phys. 20, 531 共1999兲. Pollak, R., Dissertation, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Ger-
Kurzeja, N., Th. Tielkes, and W. Wagner, Int. J. Thermo- many, 1974; English Translation, Report PC/T 共CEGB兲 14
phys. 22 共to be submitted 2002兲.
IUPAC Thermodynamic Tables Project Center, London
Le Fevre, E. J., M. R. Nightingale, and J. W. Rose, J.
共1976兲.
Mech. Eng. Sci. 17, 243 共1975兲.
Pollak, R., Brennstoff-Wärme-Kraft 27, 210 共1975兲.
Levelt Sengers, J. M. H., B. Kamgar-Parsi, F. W. Balfour,
Preston-Thomas, H., Metrologia 27, 1 共1990兲.
and J. V. Sengers, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 12, 1 共1983兲.
Pruß, A. and W. Wagner, in Physical Chemistry of Aque-
Levelt Sengers, J. M. H., J. Straub, K. Watanabe, and P. G.
ous Systems: Meeting the Needs of Industry, Proceedings of
Hill, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 14, 193 共1985兲.
Luettmer-Strathmann, J., ‘‘A Parametric Model for the the 12th International Conference on the Properties of Water
Global Thermodynamic Behavior of Fluids in the Critical and Steam, edited by H. J. White, Jr. et al. 共Begell House,
Region’’ 共private communication, 1992兲. New York, 1995a兲, p. 66.
Lyzenga, G. A., T. J. Ahrens, W. J. Nellis, and A. C. Pruß, A. and W. Wagner, Fortschritt-Berichte VDI, Reihe
Mitchell, J. Chem. Phys. 76, 6282 共1982兲. 6, Nr. 320 共VDI, Düsseldorf, 1995b兲.
Magee, J. W., R. J. Deal, and J. C. Blanco, J. Res. Natl. Rice, M. H. and J. M. Walsh, J. Chem. Phys. 26, 824
Inst. Stand. Technol. 103, 63 共1998兲. 共1957兲.
Maier, S. and E. U. Franck, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. Rivkin, S. L. and T. S. Akhundov, Teploenergetika 9, 57
70, 639 共1966兲. 共1962兲.
Masui, R., K. Fujii, and M. Takenaka, in Physical Chem- Rivkin, S. L. and T. S. Akhundov, Teploenergetika 10, 66
istry of Aqueous Systems: Meeting the Needs of Industry, 共1963兲.
Rivkin, S. L. and G. V. Troyanovskaya, Teploenergetika Span, R., Multiparameter Equations of State—An Accu-
11, 72 共1964兲; Thermal Eng. 11, 91 共1964兲. rate Source of Thermodynamic Property Data 共Springer,
Rivkin, S. L., G. V. Troyanovskaya, and T. S. Akhundov, Berlin, 2000兲.
Teplofiz. Vys. Temp. 2, 219 共1964兲; High Temp. 2, 194 Span, R. and W. Wagner, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 25,
共1964兲. 1509 共1996兲.
Rivkin, S. L., T. S. Akhundov, E. A. Kremenevskaya, and Span, R. and W. Wagner, Int. J. Thermophys. 18, 1415
N. N. Assadullaeva, Teploenergetika 13, 59 共1966兲; Thermal 共1997兲.
Eng. 13, 77 共1966兲. Span, R., E. W. Lemmon, R. T Jacobsen, W. Wagner, and
Rögener, H. and P. Soll, Brennst.-Wärme-Kraft 32, 472 A. Yokozeki, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 29, 1361 共2000兲.
共1980兲. Stimson, H. F., J. Res. Natl. Bur. Stand. 73A, 483 共1969兲.
Rouch, J., C. Lai, and S.-H. Chen, J. Chem. Phys. 66, Takenaka, M. and R. Masui, Metrologia 27, 165 共1990兲.
5031 共1977兲. Tammann, G. and W. Jellinghaus, Z. Anorg. Allgem.
Rusby, R. L., J. Chem. Thermodyn. 23, 1153 共1991兲. Chem. 174, 225 共1928兲.
Rusby, R. L., R. P., Hudson, and M. Durieux, Metrologia Tanaka, M., G. Girard, R. Davis, A. Peuto, and N. Bignell,
31, 149 共1994兲. Metrologia 38, 301 共2001兲.
Sato, H., M. Uematsu, K. Watanabe, A. Saul, and W. Wag- Taylor, B. N., W. H. Parker, and D. N. Langenberg, Rev.
ner, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 17, 1439 共1988兲. Mod. Phys. 41, 375 共1969兲.
Sato, H., K. Watanabe, J. M. H. Levelt Sengers, J. S. Gal- Tegeler, Ch., R. Span, and W. Wagner, Fortschritt-
lagher, P. G. Hill, J. Straub, and W. Wagner, J. Phys. Chem. Berichte VDI, Reihe 3, Nr. 480 共VDI, Düsseldorf, 1997兲.
Ref. Data 20, 1023 共1991兲. Tegeler, Ch., R. Span, and W. Wagner, J. Phys. Chem. Ref.
Saul, A. and W. Wagner, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 16, 893 Data 28, 779 共1999兲.
共1987兲. Ter Minissian, L. and P. Pruzan, J. Chem. Phys. 75, 3064
Saul, A. and W. Wagner, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 18, 共1981兲.
1537 共1989兲. TRC Thermodynamic Tables, Table tuv-25 共Thermody-
Schmidt, R. and W. Wagner, Fluid Phase Equilibria 19, namics Research Center, Texas A&M University, College
175 共1985兲. Station, TX, 1988兲.
Schufle, J. A., Chem. Ind. 共London兲, 690 共1965兲. Tremaine, P., P. G. Hill, D. Irish, and P. V. Balakrishnan
Setzmann, U. and W. Wagner, Int. J. Thermophys. 10, 共eds.兲, Steam, Water and Hydrothermal Systems: Physics and
1103 共1989兲. Chemistry Meeting the Needs of Industry, Proceedings of the
Setzmann, U. and W. Wagner, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 13th International Conference on the Properties of Water and
20, 1061 共1991兲. Steam 共NRC, Ottawa, 2000兲.
Sirota, A. M., Teploenergetika 5, 10 共1958兲. Trinh, E. and R. E. Apfel, J. Chem. Phys. 69, 4275 共1978兲.
Sirota, A. M., Inzh. Fiz. Zh. 6, 52 共1963兲. Vidler, M. and J. Tennyson, J. Chem. Phys. 113, 9766
Sirota, A. M. and D. L. Timrot, Teploenergetika 3, 16 共2000兲.
共1956兲. Vukalovich, M. P., W. N. Zubarev, and A. A. Alexandrov,
Sirota, A. M. and B. K. Mal’tsev, Teploenergetika 6, 7 Teploenergetika 8, 79 共1961兲.
共1959兲. Vukalovich, M. P., W. N. Zubarev, and A. A. Alexandrov,
Sirota, A. M. and B. K. Mal’tsev, Teploenergetika 7, 67 Teploenergetika 9, 49 共1962兲.
共1960兲. Vukalovich, M. P., M. S. Trakhtengerts, and G. A. Spiri-
Sirota, A. M. and B. K. Mal’tsev, Teploenergetika 9, 52 donov, Teploenergetika 14, 65 共1967兲; Thermal Eng. 14, 86
共1962a兲. 共1967兲.
Sirota, A. M. and B. K. Mal’tsev, Teploenergetika 9, 70 Wagner, W., Fortschritt-Berichte VDI, Reihe 3, Nr. 39
共1962b兲. 共VDI, Düsseldorf, 1974兲. Shortened English translation: Re-
Sirota, A. M. and A. J. Grishkov, Teploenergetika 13, 61 port PC/T15, IUPAC Thermodynamic Tables Project Center,
共1966兲. London 共1977兲.
Sirota, A. M. and A. J. Grishkov, ‘‘Experimental Investi- Wagner, W. and K. M. de Reuck, International Thermody-
gation Isobaric Heat Capacity of Water near the Solidifica- namic Tables of the Fluid State—13, Methane 共Blackwell
tion Curve,’’ Preliminary report given at the 7th International Science, Oxford, 1996兲.
Conference on the Properties of Steam, Tokyo 共1968兲. Wagner, W., N. Kurzeja, and B. Pieperbeck, Fluid Phase
Sirota, A. M., B. K. Mal’tsev, and A. S. Grishkov, Tep- Equilibria 79, 151 共1992兲.
loenergetika 10, 57 共1963兲. Wagner, W. and A. Pruss, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 22,
Sirota, A. M., P. E. Belyakova, and Z. Kh. Shrago, Tep- 783 共1993兲.
loenergetika 13, 84 共1966兲; Thermal Eng. 13, 112 共1966兲. Wagner, W. and A. Saul, ‘‘Correlation Equations for the
Sirota, A. M., A. J. Grishkov, and A. G. Tomishko, Tep- Vapor Pressure and for the Orthobaric Densities of Water
loenergetika 17, 60 共1970兲; Thermal Eng. 17, 90 共1970兲. Substance,’’ Proceedings of the 10th International Confer-
Smith, L. B. and F. G. Keyes, Proc. Am. Acad. Arts Sci. ence on the Properties of Steam, edited by V. V. Sytchev, and
69, 285 共1934兲. A. A. Aleksandrov 共MIR, Moscow, 1986兲, Vol. 1, p. 199.
Wagner, W., A. Saul, and A. Pruß, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Zubarev, V. N., P. G. Prusakov, and V. V. Barkovskii, Tep-
Data 23, 515 共1994兲. loenergetika 24, 77 共1977a兲; Thermal Eng. 24, 62 共1977a兲.
Wagner, W., R. Kleinrahm, H. W. Lösch, and J. T. R. Wat- Zubarev, V. N., P. G. Prusakov, and V. V. Barkovskii, Tep-
son, ‘‘Hydrostatic Balance Densimeters with Magnetic Sus- loenergetika 24, 80 共1977b兲; Thermal Eng. 24, 68 共1977b兲.
pension Couplings’’ in IUPAC Experimental Thermodynam-
ics, Vol VI: Measurements of the Thermodynamic Properties 13. Appendix: Tables of Thermodynamic
of Single Phases, edited by A. R. H. Goodwin, K. N. Marsh, Properties of Water
and W. A. Wakeham 共Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2002兲.
Wagner, W., J. R. Cooper, A. Dittmann, J. Kijima, H.-J. Tables are given here for the thermodynamic properties of
Kretzschmar, A. Kruse, R. Mareš, K. Oguchi, H. Sato, I. ordinary water substance (H2 O) that cover the range of va-
Stöcker, O. Šifner, Y. Takaishi, I. Tanishita, J. Trübenbach, lidity of the IAPWS-95 formulation. Table 13.1 lists the val-
and Th. Willkommen, J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power 122, 150 ues along the vapor–liquid phase boundary. In order to pre-
共2000兲. serve thermodynamic consistency with the values in the
Walsh, J. M. and M. H. Rice, J. Chem. Phys. 26, 815 single-phase region, all values along the phase boundary
共1957兲. were calculated from IAPWS-95 by applying the phase equi-
Watanabe, H., Metrologia 28, 33 共1991兲. librium condition, Eqs. 共6.9a兲–共6.9c兲, which means without
White, Jr., H. J., J. V. Sengers, D. B. Neumann, and J. C. using any auxiliary equations. Table 13.2 contains the corre-
Bellows, eds., Physical Chemistry of Aqueous Systems: sponding values in the single-phase region and covers the
Meeting the Needs of Industry, Proceedings of the 12th In- entire range of validity of IAPWS-95, namely temperatures
ternational Conference on the Properties of Water and Steam from the melting line to 1273 K and pressures up to 1000
共Begell House, New York, 1995兲. MPa. For pressures below the critical pressure (p c
Wilson, W. D., J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 31, 1067 共1959兲. ⫽22.064 MPa), the isobaric values of the single-phase table
Wiryana, S., L. J. Slutsky, and J. M. Brown, Earth Plan- also contain the values for the saturated liquid and saturated
etary Sci. Lett. 163, 123 共1998兲. vapor at the phase boundary. The values of all properties,
Woodburn, J., Trans. ASME 71, 65 共1949兲. density, and derived properties, were calculated from the
Woolley, H. W., ‘‘Thermodynamic Properties for H2 O in IAPWS-95 formulation, i.e., from Eq. 共6.4兲 in combination
the Ideal Gas State,’’ in Water and Steam—Their Properties with Eqs. 共6.5兲 and 共6.6兲. Tables 13.1 and 13.2 are given with
and Current Industrial Applications, Proceedings of the 9th five significant figures 共six significant figures for the density
International Conference on the Properties of Steam, edited up to p⫽100 MPa兲, which is appropriate with respect to the
by J. Straub and K. Scheffler 共Pergamon, Oxford, New York, uncertainties discussed in Secs. 6.3.2 and 8. However, inter-
1980兲, p. 166. polation between entries in the tables may result in uncer-
Woolley, H. W., J. Res. Natl. Bur. Stand. 92, 35 共1987兲. tainties that are significantly larger than the uncertainties of
Wormald, C. J., Ph. D. thesis, University of Reading, Eq. 共6.4兲. This must be particularly considered in the critical
1964. and extended critical region. For sophisticated applications,
Yokoyama, C. and S. Takahashi, Int. J. Thermophys. 10, properties should be calculated directly from IAPWS-95, Eq.
35 共1989兲. 共6.4兲. For suitable software, see the IAPWS website http://
Zheleznyi, B. V., Russ. J. Phys. Chem. 43, 1311 共1969兲. www.iapws.org/newform.htm.
TABLE 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on temperaturea
T p h s cv cp w
K MPa kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
TABLE 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on temperaturea—Continued
T p h s cv cp w
K MPa kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
TABLE 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on temperaturea—Continued
T p h s cv cp w
K MPa kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
TABLE 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on temperaturea—Continued
T p h s cv cp w
K MPa kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
TABLE 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on temperaturea—Continued
T p h s cv cp w
K MPa kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
TABLE 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on temperaturea—Continued
T p h s cv cp w
K MPa kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
TABLE 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on temperaturea—Continued
T p h s cv cp w
K MPa kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
TABLE 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on temperaturea—Continued
T p h s cv cp w
K MPa kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
TABLE 13.1. Thermodynamic properties of water on the vapor–liquid phase boundary as a function on temperaturea—Continued
T p h s cv cp w
K MPa kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
0.05 MPa
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
0.05 MPa—Continued
0.1 MPa
273.153a
999.843 ⫺0.028 0.072 ⫺0.0001 4.2170 4.2194 1402.4
275 999.937 7.760 7.860 0.0283 4.2128 4.2135 1411.5
280 999.910 28.794 28.894 0.1041 4.1998 4.2009 1434.3
285 999.517 49.776 49.876 0.1784 4.1848 4.1924 1454.4
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
0.1 MPa—Continued
273.153a
999.843 ⫺0.028 0.074 ⫺0.0001 4.2170 4.2194 1402.4
275 999.938 7.760 7.861 0.0283 4.2128 4.2135 1411.5
280 999.911 28.794 28.895 0.1041 4.1998 4.2009 1434.3
285 999.517 49.776 49.877 0.1784 4.1848 4.1924 1454.4
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
0.25 MPa
273.142 a
999.918 ⫺0.071 0.179 ⫺0.0003 4.2163 4.2187 1402.6
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
0.25 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
0.25 MPa—Continued
0.5 MPa
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
0.5 MPa—Continued
0.75 MPa
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
0.75 MPa—Continued
1.0 MPa
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
1.0 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
1.0 MPa—Continued
2.0 MPa
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
2.0 MPa—Continued
3.0 MPa
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
3.0 MPa—Continued
272.863a
1001.80 ⫺1.178 2.815 ⫺0.0043 4.1995 4.2013 1407.2
275 1001.89 7.794 11.787 0.0284 4.1953 4.1955 1417.8
280 1001.80 28.744 32.737 0.1039 4.1835 4.1853 1440.6
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
4.0 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
4.0 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
5.0 MPa—Continued
6.0 MPa
272.713 a
1002.80 ⫺1.772 4.211 ⫺0.0065 4.1906 4.1921 1409.6
275 1002.88 7.809 13.792 0.0285 4.1864 4.1866 1421.0
280 1002.76 28.717 34.700 0.1038 4.1753 4.1774 1443.8
285 1002.29 49.585 55.571 0.1777 4.1619 4.1714 1464.1
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
6.0 MPa—Continued
7.0 MPa
272.638a
1003.30 ⫺2.069 4.908 ⫺0.0076 4.1862 4.1876 1410.9
275 1003.37 7.816 14.792 0.0285 4.1821 4.1822 1422.6
280 1003.24 28.703 35.680 0.1037 4.1713 4.1736 1445.4
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
7.0 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
7.0 MPa—Continued
8.0 MPa
a
272.562 1003.80 ⫺2.370 5.600 ⫺0.0087 4.1818 4.1831 1412.1
275 1003.87 7.822 15.791 0.0285 4.1778 4.1778 1424.2
280 1003.72 28.689 36.659 0.1037 4.1672 4.1698 1447.1
285 1003.23 49.519 57.494 0.1774 4.1543 4.1645 1467.3
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
8.0 MPa—Continued
10.0 MPa
272.410 a
1004.79 ⫺2.972 6.981 ⫺0.0110 4.1732 4.1742 1414.6
275 1004.85 7.834 17.785 0.0285 4.1692 4.1692 1427.5
280 1004.67 28.659 38.613 0.1035 4.1593 4.1622 1450.3
285 1004.16 49.453 59.412 0.1772 4.1468 4.1578 1470.6
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
10.0 MPa—Continued
12.5 MPa
272.218a
1006.03 ⫺3.731 8.694 ⫺0.0138 4.1625 4.1632 1417.7
275 1006.07 7.845 20.270 0.0285 4.1587 4.1587 1431.6
280 1005.86 28.621 41.048 0.1034 4.1494 4.1530 1454.4
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
12.5 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
12.5 MPa—Continued
15.0 MPa
a
272.025 1007.27 ⫺4.493 10.398 ⫺0.0167 4.1519 4.1524 1420.8
275 1007.29 7.854 22.746 0.0285 4.1484 4.1485 1435.6
280 1007.04 28.581 43.476 0.1032 4.1398 4.1440 1458.5
285 1006.46 49.285 64.189 0.1765 4.1285 4.1414 1478.8
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
15.0 MPa—Continued
17.5 MPa
271.830 a
1008.50 ⫺5.263 12.089 ⫺0.0196 4.1415 4.1418 1423.9
275 1008.50 7.861 25.213 0.0284 4.1382 4.1385 1439.7
280 1008.21 28.539 45.896 0.1029 4.1303 4.1352 1462.6
285 1007.61 49.200 66.567 0.1761 4.1196 4.1335 1482.9
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
17.5 MPa—Continued
20.0 MPa
271.633a
1009.72 ⫺6.041 13.767 ⫺0.0225 4.1311 4.1313 1427.0
275 1009.70 7.864 27.672 0.0283 4.1282 4.1288 1443.9
280 1009.38 28.496 48.310 0.1027 4.1209 4.1265 1466.7
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
20.0 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
20.0 MPa—Continued
750 72.027 2884.73 3162.40 6.0411 2.1304 3.5394 599.77
775 67.280 2949.97 3247.24 6.1524 2.0593 3.2657 620.23
800 63.396 3010.92 3326.40 6.2530 2.0110 3.0783 638.50
825 60.121 3068.93 3401.60 6.3456 1.9783 2.9447 655.14
22.5 MPa
a
271.435 1010.95 ⫺6.821 15.435 ⫺0.0255 4.1209 4.1210 1430.1
275 1010.90 7.866 30.123 0.0283 4.1184 4.1193 1448.0
280 1010.54 28.451 50.716 0.1025 4.1118 4.1181 1470.8
285 1009.87 49.026 71.306 0.1754 4.1022 4.1181 1491.1
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
22.5 MPa—Continued
25.0 MPa
271.235a
1012.16 ⫺7.609 17.090 ⫺0.0285 4.1109 4.1109 1433.3
275 1012.09 7.865 32.566 0.0282 4.1088 4.1100 1452.2
280 1011.69 28.404 53.115 0.1022 4.1027 4.1099 1474.9
285 1011.00 48.939 73.667 0.1750 4.0936 4.1107 1495.3
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
25.0 MPa—Continued
30.0 MPa
a
270.829 1014.59 ⫺9.207 20.362 ⫺0.0346 4.0910 4.0910 1439.6
275 1014.45 7.855 37.428 0.0279 4.0900 4.0922 1460.5
280 1013.98 28.307 57.893 0.1016 4.0851 4.0940 1483.2
285 1013.23 48.761 78.369 0.1741 4.0770 4.0963 1503.5
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
30.0 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
30.0 MPa—Continued
40.0 MPa
a
269.997 1019.38 ⫺12.472 26.768 ⫺0.0473 4.0526 4.0530 1452.4
270 1019.38 ⫺12.460 26.780 ⫺0.0473 4.0526 4.0530 1452.4
275 1019.09 7.809 47.060 0.0272 4.0543 4.0590 1477.4
280 1018.49 28.095 67.369 0.1003 4.0514 4.0644 1500.0
285 1017.63 48.397 87.703 0.1723 4.0452 4.0694 1520.2
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
40.0 MPa—Continued
50.0 MPa
269.134a
1024.11 ⫺15.846 32.977 ⫺0.0606 4.0156 4.0169 1465.4
270 1024.07 ⫺12.369 36.456 ⫺0.0477 4.0169 4.0188 1469.9
275 1023.62 7.730 56.576 0.0262 4.0208 4.0289 1494.6
280 1022.90 27.862 76.742 0.0988 4.0198 4.0373 1516.9
285 1021.94 48.021 96.948 0.1703 4.0152 4.0446 1537.0
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
50.0 MPa—Continued
75.0 MPa
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
75.0 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
75.0 MPa—Continued
100 MPa
a
264.347 1046.87 ⫺34.278 61.245 ⫺0.1356 3.8401 3.8512 1534.2
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
100 MPa—Continued
200 MPa
252.462a
1087.98 ⫺76.248 107.580 ⫺0.3187 3.3346 3.3550 1684.9
255 1087.46 ⫺67.707 116.208 ⫺0.2847 3.4118 3.4417 1694.1
260 1086.21 ⫺50.361 133.766 ⫺0.2165 3.5251 3.5739 1712.2
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
200 MPa—Continued
400 MPa
a
259.820 1144.46 ⫺51.611 297.897 ⫺0.2741 3.0567 3.1768 2041.4
260 1144.39 ⫺51.060 298.470 ⫺0.2719 3.0641 3.1853 2041.9
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
400 MPa—Continued
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
400 MPa—Continued
600 MPa
a
271.691 1183.60 ⫺15.760 491.170 ⫺0.1929 3.1871 3.4202 2316.4
275 1181.96 ⫺4.990 502.641 ⫺0.1509 3.2654 3.5099 2320.4
280 1179.45 11.748 520.460 ⫺0.0867 3.3527 3.6116 2325.5
285 1176.90 28.893 538.705 ⫺0.0221 3.4117 3.6821 2329.8
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
600 MPa—Continued
800 MPa
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
800 MPa—Continued
1000 MPa
a
300.243 1237.39 76.834 884.986 0.0301 3.4179 3.7697 2723.3
305 1234.94 93.201 902.957 0.0895 3.4296 3.7845 2723.2
310 1232.38 110.461 921.901 0.1511 3.4337 3.7917 2723.1
T u h s cv cp w
K kg m⫺3 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 kJ kg⫺1 K⫺1 m s⫺1
1000 MPa—Continued