Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Wellness, By Design
Anurag Mairal
B
ioimplants and devices sector, turned their attention to medical devices. academia, and the government. Most of
also known as the medical device In fact, 2009 saw a number of large these start-ups are acquired by large
sector, is a key part of the mergers and acquisitions in the device companies after the concept or the
healthcare industry worldwide. The sector sector, despite the global economic technology has been validated through
covers a wide spectrum of devices slump. animal and early clinical trials. Large
including diagnostics, imaging, dental, companies then take over the later stages
surgical, ocular, wound care, orthopedic Structure of and Evolution within the of product development, perform more
and cardiovascular devices. Although the Medical Device Sector extensive clinical trials, seek regulatory
$250-billion medical device sector is Medical device sector, much like the approval and insurance coverage, and
substantially smaller than the $750-billion pharmaceutical industry, is dominated carry out product commercialization.
pharmaceutical industry, it is growing 6- by some very large players who have Substantial capabilities of large
8% annually compared to 2-4% growth market leadership in a number of companies in these areas built through
rate of the global pharmaceutical market. segments within the sector. While these heavy investment of resources create a
The faster growth in the device large companies have internal product barrier to entry for any new entrant. The
sector is driven in large part due to the development teams, the thousands of select few companies that do grow to
substantial clinical needs that have start-ups funded by venture capital form become a mid-size enterprise (say, >$100
remained unaddressed by drugs. The the backbone of device innovation, million in sales) often get acquired in
growth is substantially higher over 10% contributing a majority of new products large acquisition deals.
in the emerging markets as they become in the market. The entrepreneurial Leading device companies are
increasingly affluent and adopt culture of the device industry is widely active in multiple therapeutic areas (see
technologies widely accepted in the recognized and well-supported by all the table on page 4 for a list of largest global
developed markets. As the stakeholders in the medical device eco- medical device companies and their
pharmaceutical industry growth slows system, including large device device sales figures. Many of these also
down, large healthcare companies companies, investors, inventors, have substantial presence in the
looking for growth have increasingly clinicians, vendors and service providers, pharmaceutical industry). uu
Anurag Mairal PhD is Associate Director, Program Development, Stanford-India Biodesign, Stanford University, USA
(E-mail: mairal@stanford.edu)
u The global medical device industry can decade. As the healthcare costs have This has made the device industry
in fact be classified in terms of the skyrocketed in the U.S. and are projected rethink its product development
disease segments or treatment areas. (see to account for one-fifth of the entire approach. For decades, the medical
figure on top of page. 5 for an overview GDP, there has been a vigorous debate device industry developed increasingly
of the top-10 device segments in terms about ways to control the costs. Aging complex technologies to treat a range of
of their contribution to the total market population, inefficiency in the complex conditions from blocked arteries to
in the U.S). healthcare system, and rising cost of arrhythmia and obesity. With the
therapies have been among the many increase in the sophistication and
Globalization in the Medical Device reasons cited for the rise in costs. A complexity of the technology, the cost of
Sector growing number of healthcare experts therapies also went up. As FDA
A remarkable shift is taking place in the are pushing for prevention as a cost- demands more rigorous, expensive trials
medical device sector. This shift has effective alternative to more expensive before approval and insurance
been in the making for much of the last treatment-and-management paradigm. companies tighten their reimbursement u eu
u pipeline of technologies that meet the allocation by most developed nations. from non-implantable devices (classified
needs of a redefined healthcare market Most of this spending is borne by the as Class I medical devices), much of the
in the West. The timing in uncanny private payers; government contributes revenues come from lower-volume Class
countries like Brazil, Russia, India, and less than 20% to the healthcare tab of II and Class III devices, many of which
China (the BRIC countries) are growing the nation. India must increase its are implantables such as the stents and
economically and can afford to seek new healthcare spending substantially to pacemakers (see table below for types of
therapies for their growing healthcare meet its needs (see figure above, on the devices that comprise the various device
burden. right, for current and historical spend segments).
and the optimal level for a well-run
India: A Booming Economy and healthcare system). Changing Face of Indian MedTech
Disease Burden Industry
India is in the midst of a major Medical Device Industry in India Until recently most indigenous
economic growth, and has more than India's medical device industry is manufacturers of medical devices
doubled in GDP in the last decade. Most estimated at $2.5 Billion and is expected focused on supplying low-cost devices
economists project India to be one of the to cross $4 Billion by 2012; growing at such as tubing and syringes, whereas
top three economies, after United States more than 15% annually (see figure on large global players dominated the high-
and China, within the next three page 5 for contribution of the various end medical equipment and device
decades. (see figure above on the left) therapeutic areas to the total market). segment. In the last decade, however, a
However, as the country has While most of the device volume comes new generation of device companies has
become more affluent, the clinical
burden in India has shifted gradually
from infectious diseases to the lifestyle
conditions such as coronary heart
Types of Devices Comprising Device Segments in India
disease and diabetes. India is now home Device Segment Device
to the largest population of heart disease Cardiovascular and Cardiac Surgery stents, cardiac surgery tools, pacemakers
and diabetes patients. The country General Surgery sutures, surgical tools
spends just over 4% of its GDP on Diagnostics and Imaging CT, MRI, X-Ray, diagnostic kits
healthcare, substantially less than the Orthopedics screws, artificial knees and hips
Ophthalmology devices and surgical tools
u entered the market. These companies are proposing a major overhaul of the over the last two years. India still does
started by determined entrepreneurs, often regulatory framework governing medical not have a critical mass of venture
working closely with clinicians and device development, import, and sale. In capitalists who would invest in very risky
investors, and have global ambitions. addition, several federal and state early-stage ideas of the eager
Although still small in terms of share of the agencies are supporting initiatives entrepreneurs. Moreover, the army of
high-end device market, the companies (including Stanford-India Biodesign and smart engineers and designers is not
have demonstrated the viability of a programs that fund entrepreneurs) to experienced in the device industry,
domestic player in advanced technologies. promote the domestic industry. The raising the bar for their success. Vendors
Their initial success has sparked an interest government is also in the process of providing prototyping, manufacturing,
in larger domestic corporations, catalyzing rolling out an ambitious health testing, regulatory, and commercia-
a flurry of investments, in particular in the insurance program that will cover lization services are few and far
diagnostics segment. Concurrently, hundreds of millions of people in rural between. Such vendors have proven to
multinationals like GE, Stryker, and India. be very valuable in facilitating medtech
Johnson & Johnson (J&J) have increased Concurrently, the health innovation in the West. Finally, the
their efforts towards fostering innovation insurance industry is rapidly expanding biggest challenge in creating a robust
for meeting India's needs first, and for coverage to urban population. Nearly medtech industry in India is the lack of
exporting it to the West in the longer term. 20% of India's population, up from 5% a systematic market development. The
For example, two years back, J&J decade back, has some form of coverage. country lacks a well-trained and
developed a simple, inexpensive, and robust Also expanding is the healthcare organized device distribution
glucose meter for BRIC markets that was delivery infrastructure; high-quality infrastructure that is capable of
later introduced to the U.S. market with private hospital chains are now educating patients and physicians alike,
great success. The Table above shows the exploring Tier II and Tier III cities, is able to navigate the complex medical
international and domestic medtech beyond the big-city India, for growth. devices through clinical adoption, and
companies active in India. Finally, as mentioned earlier, a pool of has deep penetration into all of India.
talented engineers and doctors are eager Yet the optimism in India's
Future of Medical Technology in India to engage in medical device innovation medtech industry is palpable. Leading
A number of factors are coalescing to for India's needs. industry groups such as CII and FICCI
provide the necessary boost to the Indian Despite these significant have both formed special interest groups
MedTech Industry. With the increased factors supporting a potentially vibrant to lobby on behalf of the medtech
focus on the potential of the industry, the medical device industry, many industry. Future of the device industry
government is actively formulating policies challenges remain. For instance, the in India looks promising.n
that create a conducive environment for the regulatory reform process has stalled
industry. In particular, the government is