Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: The objective of this investigation was to develop a systematic method for the determination of optimal pro-
Amorphous solid dispersion cessing temperatures of drug-polymer mixtures for the development of amorphous solid dispersion (ASD) by
Rheology melt extrusion. Since melt extrusion is performed at high temperature, it is essential that the processing tem-
Melt extrusion perature should be as low as possible to minimize degradation of drug and polymer, and yet the temperature
Polymers
should be high enough that the drug-polymer mixture attains certain viscosity that is extrudable and the drug
Processing temperature
Rheological analysis
dissolves in the molten polymer. By using itraconazole (ITZ) and polyvinyl caprolactam-polyvinyl acetate-
Plasticization polyethylene glycol graft co-polymer (Soluplus®, BASF) as, respectively, the model drug and the polymeric
Melt viscosity carrier, melt viscosities of drug-polymer mixtures with 5, 10, 20 and 30% ITZ were studied as functions of
temperature and angular frequency. All these concentrations were below the miscibility limit as it was shown
separately by film casting that ITZ was miscible with the polymer up to 40%. Since the angular frequency of a
rheometer may not be high enough to simulate the shear rate within an extruder, torque analysis as a function of
temperature during melt extrusion of selected drug-polymer mixtures was also conducted. The presence of
dissolved ITZ had a plasticizing effect on the polymer used, and an intersection point around 150–155 °C was
observed, above which viscosities of drug-polymer mixtures were lower than that of polymer itself. Drug-
polymer mixtures with 5 to 30% ITZ were extrudable at 150 °C, and torque analysis showed that the mixture
with 20% ITZ can be extruded even at 145 °C. These temperatures were 17 to 22 °C below the melting point of
ITZ (167 °C). ITZ dissolved due to the drug-polymer miscibility, the viscosity attained, and the shear rate gen-
erated. It was confirmed by PXRD and DSC that the extrudates were amorphous. Viscosity and miscibility of
drug-polymer mixtures during melt extrusion were identified as critical factors in determining optimal proces-
sing temperature.
1. Introduction shelf life of the formulation. As defined by Baghel et al. (2016), the
drug-polymer miscibility is the ability of the drug to remain dissolved in
Amorphous solid dispersion (ASD) has been investigated extensively the polymeric carrier by molecular distribution, interstitial distribution
to increase dissolution rate and bioavailability of poorly water-soluble or random distribution. Water-soluble amorphous polymers are com-
drugs (Leuner and Dressman 2000; Tong et al. 2008). Depending on the monly used in the ASD of poorly water-soluble drugs. Once the poly-
nature of drugs and carriers used and their relative concentrations, meric carrier is dissolved in aqueous media in the gastrointestinal tract
drugs may be molecularly dispersed in ASD as follows: (a) solid solu- after oral administration of such a formulation, the drug is released in
tion, where the solute (drug) replaces solvent (carrier) molecule, (b) the form of an aqueous solution or in the finely divided state having
interstitial solid solution by the distribution of solute in the interstices, high surface area that redissolves rapidly (Tong et al. 2008).
and (c) random distribution of solute in the amorphous carrier, which is Despite many potential advantages of ASD, its use in drug products
sometimes referred to as amorphous solid solution (Baghel et al. 2016). was hampered for a long time because of various issues related to its
How the drug is dispersed in the carrier may influence the miscibility preparation and processing into dosage forms (Serajuddin 1999). For
between them. However, for the successful development of ASD as the example, the solvent evaporation was for a long time the most common
pharmaceutical product, it is essential that both drug and carrier are method of preparing an ASD, where large amount of organic solvent
miscible in such a way that there is no crystallization of drug during was necessary to dissolve a water-insoluble drug and the water-soluble
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: serajuda@stjohns.edu (A.T.M. Serajuddin).
1
Current affiliation: Teva Pharmaceuticals USA Inc., 577 Chipeta Way, Salt Lake City, UT 84108.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejps.2017.10.034
Received 13 April 2017; Received in revised form 29 September 2017; Accepted 24 October 2017
0928-0987/ © 2017 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
N. Solanki et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 111 (2018) 482–491
carrier in a common medium, and the solvent handling during sub- rheology of drug-polymer mixtures, such as acetaminophen-poly-
sequent drying created formulation and manufacturing difficulties ethylene oxide (Suwardie et al. 2011; Yang et al. 2011), ibuprofen-ethyl
(Serajuddin 1999; Tong et al. 2008). The situation has improved greatly cellulose (De Brabander et al. 2002), indomethacin-HPMCAS MF
during the past 10 to 15 years because of the introduction of hot melt (Sarode et al. 2013), indomethacin-polyethylene oxide (Aho et al.
extrusion (HME) for the preparation of ASD, and, indeed, HME has now 2016) and indomethacin-Eudragit EPO (Liu et al. 2012). Aho et al.
emerged as the most promising technique for this purpose. Using HME, (2016) asserted that the rheological measurement should be a standard
the drug is dissolved in the amorphous polymer at an elevated tem- part of material characterization for hot melt extrusion. However, no
perature (Breitenbach 2002; Crowley et al. 2007; Patil et al. 2016) to systematic study to take advantage of the plasticizing effect of drug in
produce ASD. However, there are only very limited reports in the lit- identifying processing conditions has been reported in the literature.
erature on the identification of optimal temperature for melt extrusion As mentioned above, the Soluplus®-CBZ mixture was considered to
of drug-polymer mixtures. The chemical stability of drug could be a be a miscible system where the drug dissolved in molten polymer at
major issue with HME, especially at or near the melting point of drug temperatures almost 60 °C below its melting point of 191 °C (Gupta
(Lakshman et al. 2008; Verreck et al. 2006). There is also the potential et al. 2015). This may not be a model system for all drugs as there may
for the degradation of polymer at a high temperature (Sarode et al. be drug-polymer combinations that may not be as freely miscible and,
2014). It is, therefore, essential that the drug-polymer mixture should even when they are miscible, they may not adequately reduce the
be processed in a melt extruder at as low temperature as possible. Even viscosity of the system for melt extrusion. In order to investigate such a
when there is no thermal degradation, the temperature should not be so possible scenario, we chose itraconazole (ITZ) as a model drug in the
high that the extrudates are very soft and do not form filaments that can present study. ITZ (Fig. 1) with molecular weight of 706 g/mol is a
be further processed into dosage forms. At the same time, the tem- much bulkier molecule than CBZ (236 g/mol). Parikh et al. (2015) re-
perature should also not be so low that the drug does not dissolve in the ported that ITZ is miscible with Soluplus® up to 40% w/w. Given that
polymer or the material is not extrudable. It is essential to select an ITZ is miscible with Soluplus® and it has a lower melting point (166 °C)
operating temperature such that the drug dissolves in the polymer than that of CBZ (191 °C), one could hypothesize that melt extrusion of
during extrusion, the drug-polymer mixture is extrudable and there is Soluplus®-ITZ mixture could be performed at lower temperatures than
no chemical degradation. Soluplus®-CBZ systems. Because of the much lower melting point of ITZ
For melt extrusion, the drug-polymer mixture has to be heated to a than CBZ, one could also consider the viscosity of Soluplus®-ITZ system
temperature where the melt viscosity of drug-polymer mixture inside at different drug concentrations and various processing temperatures
the barrel is within the extrudable range (Aho et al. 2016; Gupta et al. could be lower than that of the Soluplus®-CBZ system. In the present
2014). Such a processing temperature has to be above the glass tran- investigation, we put this hypothesis to test.
sition temperature (Tg) of polymer used. However, if the drug has a Earlier, Six et al. (2004) performed melt extrusion of ITZ with
melting point higher than the Tg of polymer, it is not necessary that the Kollidon® VA 64 (vinylpyrrolidone-vinyl acetate copolymer) at a barrel
drug-polymer mixture has to be heated above the melting point of drug. temperature above the melting point of the drug without considering
The mixture may be extruded to form ASD at a temperature much lower the possibility of performing the experiment below the drug melting
than the melting point of the drug, provided (a) the drug dissolves in point. Zhang et al. (2013) reported the preparation Soluplus®-ITZ melt
the molten polymer and (b) the viscosity of the polymer is within the extrudates at a lower temperature of 160 °C; however, there was no
extrudable range. justification given for the selection of this specific extrusion tempera-
Although it may be possible to decrease melt viscosity and thus ture. Yang et al. (2016) demonstrated that nifedipine-copovidone
lower processing temperature for hot melt extrusion by incorporating a amorphous solid dispersion can be prepared by extrusion at 13 °C below
plasticizer, the added plasticizer may not be miscible with the polymer the melting point of nifedipine (173 °C), which they referred to as the
and its presence may cause crystallization of drug from the system critical temperature. The processing temperature had to be at or above
(Gumaste et al. 2016). Gupta et al. (2015) demonstrated that it may not the critical temperature for optimal melt extrusion and molecular level
be necessary to add a separate plasticizer during melt extrusion as the mixing of drug and polymer. However, the authors used only 50:50-
dissolved drug may itself serve as the plasticizer. They were successfully mixture of nifedipine and copovidone in their study and there was no
able to prepare ASD by extruding mixtures of carbamazepine (CBZ) and mention of whether the critical temperature would vary depending on
Soluplus® (Tg = 72 °C) at a temperature almost 60 °C below the CBZ drug to polymer ratios. In the present study, we conducted rheological
melting point of 191 °C as the drug had major impact in lowering analysis of Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures at different ratios to identify pro-
viscosity of the polymer. For the drug to be able to act as a plasticizer, it cessing conditions for the preparation of ASD by melt extrusion. The
has to be miscible with the polymer, where the degree of plasticizing results obtained from rheological analysis were confirmed by preparing
effect depends on drug concentration and processing temperature. extrudates, which were then analyzed by modulated differential scan-
There are also several other reports on the effect of drug on the ning calorimetric (mDSC) analysis and powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD)
483
N. Solanki et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 111 (2018) 482–491
2. Materials and methods As mentioned above, oscillatory rheological test rather than the
rotational (flow) rheology was performed in the present investigation.
2.1. Materials This is because it is difficult to determine the steady shear viscosity of
polymeric melts using rotational rheology as the sample tends to frac-
Itraconazole was donated by a major manufacturer of generic ture at the edge and flow out of the plate geometry (Tanner and
pharmaceuticals located in the US. Soluplus®, which is chemically Keentok 1983). This is especially true when the analysis is performed at
polyvinyl caprolactam-polyvinyl acetate-polyethylene glycol graft co- high shear rates. Thus, the results of the viscosity measurements could
polymer, was donated by BASF Corporation (Tarrytown, New York). be misleading and might not be representative of processes involving
Because of its relatively low Tg (~ 72 °C), Soluplus® has extensively higher shear rates like melt extrusion and injection molding. On the
been investigated for melt extrusion. Structures of both itraconazole other hand, oscillatory rheological tests can be performed to measure
and Soluplus® are given in Fig. 1. complex viscosity over a wide angular frequency (rad/s) range keeping
the strain low on the sample. Tests were conducted to ensure that the
2.2. Rheology rheological testing in the present investigation follows the empirical
Cox-Merz rule, which essentially states that steady state viscosity as a
The rheological analysis was carried out to determine effects of function of shear rate can be estimated from the complex viscosity as a
angular frequencies, temperature and drug concentrations on the function of angular frequency if the two curves generated by such de-
complex viscosity of drug-polymer physical mixture(s). The experi- terminations coincide with or overlay on each other (Cox and Merz
ments were performed using Discovery Hybrid Rheometer-2 equipped 1958 and 1959). Thus, the Cox-Merz transformation can be applied to
with an oven heating assembly using 25 mm parallel plate geometry determine steady shear rate viscosity from oscillatory (dynamic) fre-
(TA Instruments, Newcastle, DE). The samples were prepared by com- quency sweep, and if Cox-Merz rule is validated, the results obtained
pressing uniform ITZ-polymer mixtures by Carver Press into slugs of from this oscillatory test can be used to predict viscosity for processes
25 mm diameter and 2 mm thickness as described earlier (Gupta et al. involving high shear rates, such as HME (Kulicke and Porter 1980). To
2016; Meena et al. 2014; Parikh et al. 2014). The rheometer was cali- test the Cox-Merz rule, Fig. 3 gives the overlay of flow sweep and os-
brated for zero gap prior to the analysis at starting temperature of the cillation frequency sweep (dynamic frequency sweep) for Soluplus®,
experiment. where the flow sweep was performed at lower shear rates of 0.01 to 0.5
Two different types of rheological tests were performed to evaluate 1/s) and the oscillation frequency test was performed at higher angular
samples: frequencies of 0.1 to 100 rad/s. The Cox-Merz transformation was ap-
i) Oscillation temperature sweep was performed to determine the plied using TRIOS software by TA instruments on oscillation frequency
effect of temperatures on complex viscosity at angular frequency of results to obtain shear rate data. It can be seen in Fig. 3 that the two
0.1 rad/s, oscillation strain of 0.5% and ramp rate of 5 °C/min. In this curves overlap in the shear rate range of 0.1 to 0.5 1/s, thus validating
test, samples were heated from low to high as well as from high to low Cox-Merz rule. Therefore, the results of oscillatory rheological tests for
temperatures. Prior to analysis, each sample was equilibrated at the Soluplus® can be used to infer processing conditions involving higher
starting temperature for 120 s. For the low to high temperature test, the shear rate, such as HME.
samples were heated from 135 to 180 °C, and for the high to low
temperature test, different starting temperatures of 170, 160, 150 and 2.5. Torque analysis by hot melt extrusion
140 °C were used and then the samples were cooled down to ~110 °C at
5 °C/min. The torque analysis of the neat polymer and the drug-polymer
ii) Oscillation frequency test was performed to determine the effect mixtures (10, 20 and 30% w/w drug) was performed using Process 11
of angular frequency on complex viscosity. For this test, the complex Parallel Twin-Screw Extruder (Thermo Scientific Inc., Bridgewater, NJ,
viscosity was studied at different temperatures in the range of 140 to USA). Physical blends of drug and polymer were prepared using a
170 °C at the interval of 10 °C by varying the oscillation frequency Turbula mixture, and the mixtures were then fed into the extruder at
gradually from 0.1 to 100 rad/s at the oscillation strain of 0.5%. the rate of 1 g/min using Thermo 11 mm single screw volumetric
feeder, while maintaining the screw speed of 100 RPM and the barrel
2.3. Establishment of linear viscoelastic region temperature of 150°C. Screw configuration of three kneading zones
containing forward kneading elements and series of conveying elements
To compare viscoelastic properties of different materials and for- was used to conduct extrusion of Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures. The screw
mulations, it is essential that the rheological analysis is conducted in configuration is given in Fig. 1 of the Supplementary Material. In the
the linear viscoelastic region (LVE). In this region, the complex visc- first kneading zone, near the feeding area, 7 kneading elements with
osity and modulus (storage and/or loss) remain constant. Therefore, to offset angle of 30° followed by 7 kneading elements of 60° were used. In
determine linear viscoelastic range (LVE), the oscillation amplitude test the second kneading zone, 6 kneading elements with offset angle of 60°
was performed for Soluplus® and a Soluplus®-ITZ mixture (30% ITZ) at were used. In third kneading zone, 4 kneading elements of 60°, followed
160 °C by keeping the angular frequency constant at 0.1 rad/s, while by 7 kneading elements of 90° were used. The extrudates were obtained
the strain or stress was varied by increasing the oscillation amplitude. on a conveyer belt, where they cooled down at room temperature. The
As shown in Fig. 2, the complex viscosity, the storage modulus (G’) and torque generated during melt extrusion was recorded as a mean torque
the loss modulus (G”) of Soluplus® remain fairly constant up to 100% value of six observations and plotted against the drug concentration to
strain. In case of the ITZ-Soluplus mixture, although some decrease in determine the effect of drug concentration on the torque. To study the
the storage modulus (G’) was observed, complex viscosity and loss effect of temperature on torque, a constant drug concentration of 20%
modulus remained practically unchanged. In the present study, we w/w was used for extrusion at different temperatures.
conducted all oscillatory tests only at 0.5% oscillation strain, which is
well within the linear viscoelastic range of Soluplus® and other test 2.6. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC)
samples. In the present study, the maximum drug concentration used
was 30% w/w. Therefore, these results indicate that the determination The thermal analysis of physical mixtures and milled melt-extruded
of complex viscosity would be reproducible irrespective of the change samples was performed using a modulated DSC (DSC Q200, TA
in drug concentration and conditions. Instruments, Newcastle, DE). Briefly, about 5 mg of sample was placed
484
N. Solanki et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 111 (2018) 482–491
Fig. 2. Plots of viscoelastic properties of Soluplus® and Soluplus®-ITZ mixture (70:30 w/w) at 160 °C and angular frequency of 0.1 rad/s as a function of oscillation strain: (A) complex
viscosity vs oscillation strain, and (B) storage and loss modulus vs oscillation strain. All oscillatory tests in the present study were conducted at 0.5% oscillatory strain, which is within the
linear viscoelastic range (LVE) of polymer and drug-polymer mixtures.
3. Results
485
N. Solanki et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 111 (2018) 482–491
486
N. Solanki et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 111 (2018) 482–491
to the method reported earlier by Aho et al. (2016). The Y-axis in the
figure is the logarithmic value of the ratio of viscosity of the mixtures to
that of neat Soluplus® at angular frequency of 0.1 rad/s. The ratio of
greater than zero indicates the anti-plasticization effect of drug on the
polymer at the particular temperature, while the ratio of less than zero
shows the plasticization effect of drug on polymer. Thus, values above
the dashed line in the figure may be interpreted as anti-plasticization
effect and below the dashed line as the plasticization effect. The anti-
plasticizing effects at 140 °C indicate that ITZ did not completely dis-
solved in Soluplus® during the viscosity test and certain fractions re-
mained undissolved at this temperature at any of the drug concentra-
tions used, while it did not dissolve completely in the polymer at 150 °C
only at 30% drug concentration. The plasticization effects observed at
160 and 170 °C at all drug concentrations indicate dissolution of ITZ in
Soluplus® up to 30% drug concentration. Based on such normalized
viscosity vs. drug concentration profiles at different temperatures,
processing temperatures for different drug concentrations may be
identified.
Fig. 5. Effects of change in angular frequency on complex viscosities of Soluplus® and The effect of increasing temperature on viscosities for different
different Soluplus®-itraconazole (ITZ) mixtures at (A) 140 °C, (B) 150 °C and (C) 160 °C. drug-polymer ratios are shown in Fig. 7. At 140 °C, all drug-polymer
The decrease in viscosity with an increase in angular frequency was recorded for all mixtures exhibited higher viscosities than that of the neat polymer.
temperatures. Each data point represents the average of two determinations. The legends
Viscosities of drug-polymer mixtures decreased with an increase in
for B and C are the same as that of A.
temperature, and, at 0.5% oscillation strain and 0.1 rad/s angular fre-
quency, an intersection point in the approximate temperature range of
When the starting temperature for the determination of viscosity 150 to 155 °C was observed, above which viscosities of all drug-
was increased to 160 °C (Fig. 5C), the rheological profiles at all drug polymer mixtures were below that of the polymer itself. Lower viscos-
concentrations were either the same or lower than that of Soluplus® ities after the intersection point can be attributed to facilitated solubi-
itself, and there was a progressive decrease in viscosity when the con- lization and increased dissolution of itraconazole in Soluplus® at ele-
centration was increased to 20% and then to 30%. These results de- vated temperatures. Viscosities of drug-polymer mixtures were higher
monstrate that all drug concentrations used dissolved in Soluplus® and than that of polymer below the intersection temperature due to un-
exerted plasticizing effect at 160 °C. Similar results were also obtained dissolved drug. When extrusion is performed below the intersection
at 170 °C, although the viscosities were much lower (viscosity profiles temperature, drug might remain undissolved in the extrudates. Thus,
not shown). the temperature above the intersection point may be considered as an
optimum temperature to conduct melt extrusion and prepare homo-
3.3. Combined effects of drug concentration and temperature on rheological genous solid dispersion for the particular drug-polymer ratio. It should,
properties of Soluplus®-itraconazole mixtures at different temperatures and however, be mentioned here that the intersection point observed at 150
angular frequency of 0.1 rad/s to 155 °C obtained at the angular frequency of 0.1 rad/s only. This gives
preliminary guidance with respect to the processing temperature of
To summarize the effects of drug concentrations on the viscosity of drug-polymer mixtures during melt extrusion. The intersection point
polymer, the normalized viscosity values of ITZ at different tempera- could be lower if the angular frequency is increased. It has been shown
tures as a function of drug concentration are plotted in Fig. 6 according later in this paper that the ITZ-Soluplus® mixtures may indeed be
487
N. Solanki et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 111 (2018) 482–491
150 °C was ~7.5 Nm, and it decreased to 6.5, 5.8 and 4.7 Nm at, re-
spectively, 10, 20 and 30% w/w ITZ concentrations in the mixtures. A
straight-line correlation for decrease in torque with an increase in drug
concentration with R2 value of 0.9951 and a slope of − 0.089 was
observed. It is interesting to note that the torque generated by 30% ITZ
was lower than that of Soluplus® and all other drug-polymer mixtures.
This is unlike the complex viscosity of 30% ITZ at 150 °C observed in
Fig. 5B, where viscosities at all angular frequencies were higher. The
torque analysis, therefore, indicates the possibility of 30% ITZ being
dissolved in the polymer under the experimental conditions of high
pressure and high shear rate during melt extrusion.
488
N. Solanki et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 111 (2018) 482–491
3.6. Effect of temperature on melt extrudability The effect of drug concentration on the extrudability of Soluplus®-
ITZ mixtures at 140 °C may be explained by the results of the rheolo-
As mentioned above, Soluplus® itself and all its mixtures with ITZ gical analysis. As shown in Fig. 4, complex viscosities of Soluplus® and
ranging from 5 to 30% drug could be extruded at 150 °C, which is 17 °C Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures with 5 and 10% ITZ were similar when the
below the melting point of ITZ. Since the shear rate during rheological rheological analysis was conducted with starting temperatures of 140
analysis is much lower than that in a melt extruder, it was of interest to and 150 °C, and it may be observed in Fig. 5 that their viscosities were
determine whether Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures could also be extruded at also very close to each other when the angular frequency at 150 °C was
temperatures lower than 150 °C. Therefore, attempts were made to increased. It is, therefore, expected that the extrudability of these ma-
extrude the neat polymer and the mixtures at 140 °C. However, it was terials could also be similar or very close to each other. As may be
not possible to extrude the neat Soluplus® and its mixtures with 5, 10 observed in Fig. 8, torque values generated by Soluplus® itself and 10%
and 30% ITZ at this temperature, and only the mixture with 20% ITZ ITZ in the mixture at 150 °C were, respectively, 7.5 and 6.5 Nm. These
could be extruded. The 20% ITZ mixture was also extruded at 145 °C. values increased beyond the extrusion limit when the temperature was
Fig. 11 shows that torque values generated during melt extrusion of decreased to 140 °C.
20% ITZ at 150, 145 and 140 °C were, respectively, 5.8, 6.8 and 8 Nm, The situation was somewhat different in case of 20% ITZ con-
which are below the maximum torque of the melt extruder used. In case centration. The viscosity of the mixture with 20% ITZ was much lower
of the neat polymer and the mixtures with ITZ concentrations of 5, 10 than that of Soluplus® and Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures when both compo-
and 30%, the torque generated at 140 °C was > 12 Nm, which stopped nents were miscible with each other. Although the viscosity analysis in
the rotation of screw shafts. Fig. 4 shows that 20% ITZ dissolved in Soluplus® at 150 °C and not at
140 °C, it is possible that the high shear rate within the extruder could
dissolve a higher amount of drug in the molten polymer. This would
decrease viscosity and thus increase melt extrudability. However, DSC
analysis of the extrudate at 140 °C with 20% ITZ exhibited an en-
dotherm at 161 °C for ITZ (Fig. 9). It is possible that although a higher
concentration of ITZ might have dissolved in the polymer at 140 °C
during melt extrusion, the dissolution of ITZ in the polymer was not
complete, i.e., a small fraction ITZ might not have dissolved in the
polymer. In contrast to the DSC analysis, PXRD (Fig. 10) did not show
any characteristic peak for ITZ, indicating that the ITZ might have
converted to the amorphous form. This contradiction of DSC and PXRD
for 20% ITZ mixture processed at 140 °C could be related to the con-
centration of ITZ that remained undissolved; it was possibly below the
detection limit of PXRD (Saleki-Gerhardt et al. 1994).
In case of 30% ITZ concentration, there was excessive amount ITZ
present that did not dissolve in Soluplus® and, as a consequence, the
viscosity remained high and the mixture was not extrudable at 140 °C.
Fig. 11. Effect of change of barrel temperature on torque generated by 20% w/w drug-
polymer mixture during melt extrusion. Below 140 °C, the maximum limit of torque was
reached. Each data point represents the average ( ± SD) of six determinations.
489
N. Solanki et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 111 (2018) 482–491
4. Discussion molecular weight will exhibit higher dissolution rate of drug in the
molten polymer and higher plasticizing effect and, therefore, lower
Since high temperature is used for melt extrusion, one of the ob- melt extrusion temperature at a particular drug concentration.
jectives of the development of processing conditions is to select as low a The results of the present investigation with Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures
temperature as possible where the drug-polymer mixtures can be ex- along with that of the previous investigation with Soluplus®-carbama-
truded. Although there are numerous reports on various processing zepine mixtures (Gupta et al. 2015) in our laboratory provide a con-
conditions, such as screw configurations, screw speeds, etc., for melt venient method of identifying optimal melt extrusion temperatures for
extrusion (Thiele 2003), studies on the identification of appropriate drug-polymer mixtures in the development of amorphous solid disper-
temperatures for melt extrusion of drug-polymer mixtures have been sions. The following systematic approach may be followed:
limited. The present study demonstrates that the rheological analysis 1. Determination of drug-polymer miscibility – The maximum con-
can serve as a useful tool for the identification of melt extrusion tem- centration of drug that will be miscible with the polymer, i.e., the
perature. amount of drug that will dissolve in the polymer matrix to form a single
In this study, complex viscosities of Soluplus® and its mixtures with phase and there will be no drug crystallization during the product shelf-
ITZ at 5, 10, 20 and 30% as a function of temperature were determined. life, will be determined separately. In the present investigation, the film
It was determined previously by the film casting technique that ITZ was casting method developed by Parikh et al. (2015) was applied, which
miscible with Soluplus® up to 40%. Therefore, all drug concentrations showed that up to 40% ITZ was miscible with Soluplus®. Gupta et al.
selected should in theory be miscible with Soluplus®. However, for (2015) ascertained by analyzing the extrudates that the carbamazepine
successful melt extrusion to obtain amorphous solid dispersion, it is was soluble in the polymer for > 30% w/w. Other methods, such as
essential that the drug must dissolve in the polymer under the proces- Hildebrand-Scott theoretical model (Hildebrand and Scott 1962) and
sing condition of melt extrusion. Therefore, the extrusion temperature Florey-Huggins method (Flory 1953), may also be applied to determine
must be selected where the drug would dissolve in the molten polymer drug-polymer miscibility.
during the short transit time within the extruder. The more ‘fluid’ or 2. Determine complex viscosity as a function of temperature – As shown
less viscous a polymer is, the higher will be the dissolution rate of the in the present investigation, the viscosity can be studied in two different
drug in the polymer. When the viscosity of Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures was ways: (a) Determine the viscosity of drug-polymer mixture at a parti-
determined at the angular frequency of 0.1 rad/s with the starting cular temperature above the Tg of polymer, but below the melting point
temperature of 140 °C and then lowering the temperature, no plasti- of drug. Then, record viscosity by lowering the temperature. This will
cizing effects of ITZ on the polymer was observed, indicating that ITZ show whether the two components will be dissolved at the starting
was not dissolved in the polymer during rheological analysis at this temperature used under experimental conditions of viscosity determi-
temperature. In addition, the complex viscosities of the mixtures at this nation and what impacts the lowering of temperature will have on
temperature were higher than the extrusion range of 10,000 to viscosity. Such determination of viscosity will also show whether the
1000 Pa.s. at angular frequency of 0.1 rad/s (Gupta et al. 2014). In viscosity at the temperatures studied is within the extrudable range.
contrast, the rheological analysis showed that drug-polymer mixtures The study can be repeated with different drug concentrations and dif-
with 5, 10 and 20% ITZ were extrudable at 150 °C and all mixtures, ferent starting temperatures. (b) Alternatively, the viscosity of the
including 30% ITZ, were extrudable at 160 °C. mixture can be determined by raising the temperature from low to high.
The above results gave a preliminary estimate of temperatures that One disadvantage of this method, however, is that, at low temperature,
may be used for the melt extrusion of Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures. However, the two components are solid under conditions of the viscosity de-
it should be recognized that the shear rates of mixtures inside barrels termination and there may not be adequate mixing between them to
during melt extrusion is much higher than what can be generated in a elicit any plasticization effect by the drug. Nevertheless, a transition
rheometer. The rheological analysis at different temperatures as the temperature may be observed when different concentrations of drugs
function of angular frequency showed that the viscosity decreases with are used, which is a good estimate of melt extrusion temperature,
the increase in angular frequency and, therefore, the viscosity within provided the viscosity is within the extrudable range.
the extruder barrel during melt extrusion would be much lower due to 3. Determine viscosity as a function of angular frequency – This will
shear and pressure. This would accelerate the dissolution of drug in the show the effect of angular frequency on viscosity at a particular tem-
polymer. The torque analysis of Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures showed that perature. Although the high pressure and high shear rate of a melt
even 30% ITZ can be extruded at 150 °C. Although the mixture with extruder may not be simulated in a rheometer, this study will show a
20% ITZ could be extruded at a temperature as low as 140 °C, the DSC trend and indicate whether there could be higher dissolution of drug at
analysis indicated that the drug was not completely dissolved. higher shear rate during melt extrusion.
However, the extrusion of drug-polymer mixture containing 20% w/w 4. Conduct torque analysis by passing the mixtures through a melt ex-
drug was still possible at 140 °C because of the drop-in viscosity by the truder – As mentioned earlier, there is a limit how much shear rate can
fraction of the drug dissolved. A complete solubilization with 20% ITZ be exerted by a rheometer. The melt extruder can provide much higher
was, however, observed at 150 °C. To summarize, Soluplus®-ITZ mix- shear rate than a rheometer and thus the torque analysis can further
tures with 5, 10 and 30% ITZ can be extruded at 150 °C and 20% ITZ optimize the extrusion temperature. For example, in the present study,
can be extruded at a temperature as low as 145 °C where the drug it was observed that Soluplus®- ITZ mixtures up to 20% drug con-
dissolved completely in the polymer. The above processing tempera- centration may be extruded at 150 °C and a higher temperature in the
tures of 150 °C and 145 °C identified for Soluplus®-ITZ mixtures were, range of 155 to 160°C may be required for 30% ITZ concentration.
respectively, 17 and 22 °C below the melting point of ITZ (167 °C). In However, the torque analysis indicated that even 30% ITZ may be ex-
contrast, mixtures of another drug, carbamazepine, with Soluplus® truded at 150 °C due to dissolution of the drug during extrusion because
could be extruded at 140 °C with 10% w/w drug load, 135 °C with 20% of high shear rate and pressure.
w/w drug and 125 °C with 30% w/w drug, which were, respectively, 5. Conduct melt extrusion – Finally, the melt extrusion temperature
50, 55 and 65 °C below the melting point of 191 °C for carbamazepine identified by conducting viscosity analysis should be confirmed by
(Gupta et al. 2015). Thus, it is apparent from the two studies that dif- preparing melt extrudates and analyzing them using suitable techni-
ferent drugs would have different plasticizing effect on a polymer and, ques, such as DSC and PXRD.
as a result, their processing temperatures would differ. The difference In the present study, only drug-polymer mixtures were used for the
between carbamazepine and ITZ could possibly be related to their determination of melt extrusion temperature. The method can also be
molecular weights, respectively, which are 236 and 706 g/mol. How- applied when plasticizers, surfactants and additional polymers are
ever, further studies are necessary to establish whether the lower present in the mixtures. Then, the effects of those additional
490
N. Solanki et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 111 (2018) 482–491
components on miscibility and viscosity will need to be considered. HME polymers. AAPS PharmSciTech 17, 148–157.
Hildebrand, J.H., Scott, R.L., 1962. Regular Solutions. Prentice-Hall.
Hornsby, P.R., 1994. The application of magnesium hydroxide as a fire retardant and
5. Conclusions smoke-suppressing additive for polymers. Fire Mater. 18 (5), 269–276.
Kulicke, W.-M., Porter, R.S., 1980. Relation between steady shear flow and dynamic
rheology. Rheol. Acta 19, 601–605.
The present study provides a systematic method of identifying op- Lakshman, J.P., Cao, Y., Kowalski, J., Serajuddin, A.T.M., 2008. Application of melt ex-
timal melt extrusion temperature based on the determination of com- trusion in the development of a physically and chemically stable high-energy
plex viscosity as functions of temperature and angular frequency, fol- amorphous solid dispersion of a poorly water-soluble drug. Mol. Pharm. 5, 994–1002.
Leuner, C., Dressman, J., 2000. Improving drug solubility for oral delivery using solid
lowed by torque analysis during extrusion. It was observed that ITZ- dispersions. Eur. J. Pharm. Biopharm. 50, 47–60.
Soluplus® mixtures with drug concentrations ranging from 5 to 30% Liu, H., Zhang, X., Suwardie, H., Wang, P., Gogos, C.G., 2012. Miscibility studies of in-
may be extruded at 150 °C, which is 17 °C below the melting tem- domethacin and Eudragit® EPO by thermal, rheological, and spectroscopic analysis.
J. Pharm. Sci. 101, 2204–2212.
perature of ITZ. It was further observed based on torque analysis that
Lu, J., Obara, S., Ioannidis, N., Suwardie, J., Gogos, C., Kikuchi, S., 2016. Understanding
the mixture with 20% ITZ can be extruded at a temperature as low as the processing window of hypromellose acetate succinate for hot-melt extrusion, part
145 °C. DSC and PXRD showed that amorphous solid dispersions of ITZ I: polymer characterization and hot-melt extrusion. Adv. Polym. Technol.
in Soluplus® were formed in all cases. The ability to extrude drug- Meena, A., Parikh, T., Gupta, S.S., Serajuddin, A.T., 2014. Investigation of thermal and
viscoelastic properties of polymers relevant to hot melt extrusion, II: cellulosic
polymer mixtures at temperatures below the melting point of drug can polymers. J. Excip. Food Chem. 5, 46–55.
be attributed to the plasticizing of dissolved drug on the polymer and Parikh, T., Gupta, S.S., Meena, A., Serajuddin, A.T., 2014. Investigation of thermal and
the rate of dissolution of drug in the molten polymer. Such a plasti- viscoelastic properties of polymers relevant to hot melt extrusion, III: poly-
methacrylates and polymethacrylic acid based polymers. J. Excip. Food Chem. 5,
cizing effect and the rate of dissolution of drug in the polymer, how- 56–64.
ever, vary from drug to drug. Unlike the results of present study where Parikh, T., Gupta, S.S., Meena, A.K., Vitez, I., Mahajan, N., Serajuddin, A., 2015.
ITZ-Soluplus® mixtures could be extruded at 17–22 °C below the Application of film-casting technique to investigate drug–polymer miscibility in solid
dispersion and hot-melt extrudate. J. Pharm. Sci. 104, 2142–2152.
melting point of ITZ, a previous study from our laboratory showed that Patil, H., Tiwari, R.V., Repka, M.A., 2016. Hot-melt extrusion: from theory to application
the mixtures of Soluplus® with another drug, carbamazepine, could be in pharmaceutical formulation. AAPS PharmSciTech 17, 20–42.
extruded at 50–65 °C below the melting point of carbamazepine Saleki-Gerhardt, A., Ahlneck, C., Zografi, G., 1994. Assessment of disorder in crystalline
solids. Int. J. Pharm. 101, 237–247.
(191 °C).
Sarode, A.L., Sandhu, H., Shah, N., Malick, W., Zia, H., 2013. Hot melt extrusion (HME)
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https:// for amorphous solid dispersions: predictive tools for processing and impact of
doi.org/10.1016/j.ejps.2017.10.034. drug–polymer interactions on supersaturation. Eur. J. Pharm. Sci. 48, 371–384.
Sarode, A.L., Obara, S., Tanno, F.K., Sandhu, H., Iyer, R., Shah, N., 2014. Stability as-
sessment of hypromellose acetate succinate (HPMCAS) NF for application in hot melt
References extrusion (HME). Carbohydr. Polym. 101, 146–153.
Serajuddin, A., 1999. Solid dispersion of poorly water-soluble drugs: early promises,
Aho, J., Edinger, M., Botker, J., Baldursdottir, S., Rantanen, J., 2016. Oscillatory shear subsequent problems, and recent breakthroughs. J. Pharm. Sci. 88, 1058–1066.
rheology in examining the drug-polymer interactions relevant in hot melt extrusion. Six, K., Verreck, G., Peeters, J., Brewster, M., Mooter, G.V., 2004. Increased physical
J. Pharm. Sci. 105, 160–167. stability and improved dissolution properties of itraconazole, a class II drug, by solid
Baghel, S., Cathcart, H., O'Reilly, N.J., 2016. Polymeric amorphous solid dispersions: a dispersions that combine fast-and slow-dissolving polymers. J. Pharm. Sci. 93 (1),
review of amorphization, crystallization, stabilization, solid-state characterization, 124–131.
and aqueous solubilization of biopharmaceutical classification system class II drugs. Suwardie, H., Wang, P., Todd, D.B., Panchal, V., Yang, M., Gogos, C.G., 2011. Rheological
J. Pharm. Sci. 105, 2527–2544. study of the mixture of acetaminophen and polyethylene oxide for hot-melt extrusion
Breitenbach, J., 2002. Melt extrusion: from process to drug delivery technology. Eur. J. application. Eur. J. Pharm. Biopharm. 78, 506–512.
Pharm. Biopharm. 54, 107–117. Tanner, R.I., Keentok, M., 1983. Shear fracture in cone-plate Rheometry. J. Rheol. 27 (1),
Cox, W.P., Merz, E.H., 1958. Correlation of dynamic and steady flow viscosities. J. Polym. 47–57.
Sci. 28, 619–622. Thiele, W., 2003. Twin-Screw Extrusion and Screw Design. In: Ghebre-Sellassie, I.,
Cox, W., Merz, E., 1959, October. Rheology of polymer melts—a correlation of dynamic Martin, C. (Eds.), Pharmaceutical Extrusion Technology, (Informa Healthcare).
and steady flow measurements. In: International Symposium on Plastics Testing and Tong, W.-Q., Vasanthavada, M., Serajuddin, A., 2008. Development of Solid Dispersion
Standardization. ASTM International. for Poorly Water-Soluble Drugs, Water-insoluble Drug Formulation, second edition.
Crowley, M.M., Zhang, F., Repka, M.A., Thumma, S., Upadhye, S.B., Battu, S.K., McGinity, CRC Press, pp. 499–529.
J.W., Martin, C., 2007. Pharmaceutical applications of hot-melt extrusion: part I. Van Renterghem, J., Vervaet, C., De Beer, T., 2017. Rheological characterization of
Drug Dev. Ind. Pharm. 33, 909–926. molten polymer-drug dispersions as a predictive tool for pharmaceutical hot-melt
De Brabander, C., Van den Mooter, G., Vervaet, C., Remon, J.P., 2002. Characterization of extrusion processability. Pharm. Res. 1–10.
ibuprofen as a nontraditional plasticizer of ethyl cellulose. J. Pharm. Sci. 91, Verreck, G., Decorte, A., Heymans, K., Adriaensen, J., Liu, D., Tomasko, D., Arien, A.,
1678–1685. Peeters, J., Van den Mooter, G., Brewster, M.E., 2006. Hot stage extrusion of p-amino
Flory, P.J., 1953. Principles of Polymer Chemistry. Cornell University Press. salicylic acid with EC using CO2 as a temporary plasticizer. Int. J. Pharm. 327, 45–50.
Gumaste, S.G., Gupta, S.S., Serajuddin, A.T.M., 2016. Investigation of polymer-surfactant Yang, M., Wang, P., Suwardie, H., Gogos, C., 2011. Determination of acetaminophen's
and polymer-drug-surfactant miscibility for solid dispersion. AAPS J. 18, 1131–1143. solubility in poly(ethylene oxide) by rheological, thermal and microscopic methods.
Gupta, S.S., Meena, A., Parikh, T., Serajuddin, A.T.M., 2014. Investigation of thermal and Int. J. Pharm. 403, 83–89.
viscoelastic properties of polymers relevant to hot melt extrusion, I: poly- Yang, F., Su, Y., Zhang, J., DiNunzio, J., Leone, A., Huang, C., Brown, C.D., 2016.
vinylpyrrolidone and related polymers. J. Excip. Food Chem. 5, 32–45. Rheology guided rational selection of processing temperature to prepare
Gupta, S.S., Parikh, T., Meena, A.K., Mahajan, N., Vitez, I., Serajuddin, A.T., 2015. Effect Copovidone–Nifedipine amorphous solid dispersions via hot melt extrusion (HME).
of carbamazepine on viscoelastic properties and hot melt extrudability of Soluplus®. Mol. Pharm. 13 (10), 3494–3505.
Int. J. Pharm. 478, 232–239. Zhang, K., Yu, H., Luo, Q., Yang, S., Lin, X., Zhang, Y., Tian, B., Tang, X., 2013. Increased
Gupta, S.S., Solanki, N., Serajuddin, A.T.M., 2016. Investigation of thermal and viscoe- dissolution and oral absorption of itraconazole/Soluplus extrudate compared with
lastic properties of polymers relevant to hot melt extrusion, IV: Affinisol™ HPMC itraconazole nanosuspension. Eur. J. Pharm. Biopharm. 85 (3), 1285–1292.
491