Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
CRE AT IV IT Y
27 INTERVIEWS FROM
INNOVATIVE EDUCATORS
02
INTRODUCTION
12
PART 1
WHAT IS CREATIVITY?
22
PART 2
WHY THE CURRENT
STRUCTURE DOES
NOT WORK
32
PART 3
INTERVIEWS WITH NEW
MINDS IN EDUCATION
INTRODUCTION
In the middle of grocery shopping with his five- boy that you can solve a problem without think-
year-old son last November, Alec Couros made a ing. And I won’t do that again.”
startling discovery about creativity.
As the natural progression of the brain would
As he and his son approached the fruit section, have it, when we are presented with a question,
his son asked, “Do bananas grow with tips up we spend time mulling over potential answers
or with tips down?” Since there aren’t a lot of to that question before arriving at an answer. In
banana plants in Regina, Seskatchewan, Couros today’s digitally advanced society, however, we
didn’t actually know off-hand. But, being the con- are presented with an answer—the answer—
nected father that he is, he pulled out his iPhone, right away, if we want it. What’s more, this kind
Googled it, and in less than 30 seconds, the two of instantaneous knowledge eliminates the risk
of them were looking at photos of banana plants of being wrong.
and no longer had to wonder.
In the field intelligence, there is a phenome-
No longer had to wonder. non called the Flynn effect: Each generation, IQ
scores increase about 10 points, indicating that
“I did that entirely wrong,” Couros, professor of enriched environments are making kids smarter.
educational technology and media at the Uni- But in the neighboring field of creativity, a re-
versity of Regina, writes in a blog post about the verse trend has been observed in recent years:
experience. “At the very least, I could have asked scores are dropping.
my boy, ‘Well, which do you think, son?’ perhaps
followed by ‘So, why do you think that?’ But I In 2010 Kyung Hee Kim of the College of William
didn’t. And because I didn’t, I messed up a great and Mary discovered, after analyzing almost
learning opportunity.” 300,000 scores of American children and adults,
that creativity had been steadily rising, just like
“Instead of providing my boy with an extended IQ scores, until 1990. Since then, creativity scores
opportunity to be curious, to imagine deeply and have consistently inched downward. “It’s very
to think creatively, I reinforced one of the worst clear, and the decrease is very significant,” Kim
habits of our generation. I demonstrated to my says. It is the scores of younger children in Amer-
ica—from kindergarten through sixth grade—for them agree that schools could do more to pro-
whom the decline is “most serious.” vide a climate that fosters creativity.
According to Kim’s analyses, which employed So could society, argues teaching mentor and
the famous Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking, creativity consultant Jeffrey Davis. “Schools don’t
scores at all grade levels began to decline in the exist inside a cultural vacuum,” he says. “You
United States somewhere between 1984 and could assign blame to schools for being test-hap-
1990, and have continued to do so ever since. py and measuring everything, thus stifling cre-
The drops in scores are highly significant sta- ativity, but the reason schools measure every-
tistically and in some cases very large. In Kim’s thing is because our culture is obsessed with
words, the data indicate that “children have measuring!”
become less emotionally expressive, less ener-
getic, less talkative and verbally expressive, less You could also argue that the “crisis” lies in the
“What if quizzes humorous, less imaginative, less unconventional,
less lively and passionate, less perceptive, less
fact that greater human creativity is required in
today’s society in order to compete in the job
measured kids’ ability apt to connect seemingly irrelevant things, less
synthesizing, and less likely to see things from a
market. “Need a job? Invent it,” writes New York
Times columnist Thomas Friedman. The high-
to question, not different angle.” wage, middle-skill job is being replaced by the
high-wage, high-skill job, and unless you have the
answer?” According to Kim’s research, all aspects of cre- adaptability and ingenuity to keep up with the
ativity have declined, but the biggest decline is in rapidly shifting landscape, you’ll be left behind.
the measure called Creative Elaboration, which Another possibility is that we have created a real
assesses the ability to take a particular idea and crisis by believing in a false one. After Kim came
Jen Medbery, Fast Company expand on it in an interesting and novel way. out with her study and Newsweek published
Between 1984 and 2008, the average Elabora- their disruptive article entitled “The Creativity
tion score on the TTCT, for every age group from Crisis” in 2010, we fell headlong into political
kindergarten through 12th grade, fell by more chaos, pointing fingers and distorting the scale of
than 1 standard deviation. Stated differently, this the issue.
means that more than 85% of children in 2008
scored lower on this measure than did the aver- In times of crisis, it often helps to see whether
age child in 1984. other nations are experiencing the same issues
and, if so, what they are doing about them. Curi-
There are several reasons to doubt Kim’s study, ously, there is very little evidence of a worldwide
the most apparent of which is that it assumes creativity crisis, even in countries with education
creativity can be measured at all. On top of that, systems similar to that of the United States,
many experts say the Torrance Tests are out- where “teaching to the test” appears to be the
dated and even irrelevant given recent advance- biggest deterrent.
ments in the fields of neuroscience and psychol-
ogy. More than a few educators simply haven’t In April 2012, ADOBE released a report on the
noticed the trend at all in the twenty-five-plus global state of creativity, which showed a decline
years they’ve been teaching. in all five participating countries—the US, the UK,
Germany, France, and Japan. 50% of respondents
But what about the most famous TED Talk of all believed there is a decline in original creation
time, Ken Robinson says schools kill creativity? Is in their nation, and 60% said that their current
saying schools kill creativity really that different education system is stifling creativity. But these
from saying creativity is declining in students? results are suspect, since ADOBE draws its profit
Isn’t one just the cause of the other? While the largely from helping clients be more creative.
majority of creativity experts and education spe- Richard Florida came out with the Global Cre-
cialists we interview at the end of this book deny ativity Index in 2011 which placed Sweden at
the existence of a creativity crisis, per se, most of the top and the United States in second. In his
report, Florida defines creativity as the three T’s ing, communication and collaboration are far
(Technology, Talent, and Tolerance) that drive more important than academic knowledge.
a country’s long-term economic prosperity. “Every young person will continue to need basic
Sweden, the United States, Finland, Denmark, knowledge, of course. But they will need skills
and Australia have the highest Global Creativity and motivation even more. Of these three ed-
Indices, all three T’s considered. Individually, the ucation goals, motivation is the most critical.
story is slightly different. Finland is top in tech- Young people who are intrinsically motivated
nology, and Japan and Israel show up in the top — curious, persistent, and willing to take risks —
five. For talent, Finland is first again, followed by will learn new knowledge and skills continuously.
other Scandinavian countries, and Singapore and They will be able to find new opportunities or
New Zealand make appearances in the top ten. create their own — a disposition that will be in-
And for tolerance, Canada ranks first, followed creasingly important as many traditional careers
by Ireland, the Netherlands, New Zealand, and disappear.”
Australia. The Scandinavian nations and the U.S.
round out the top ten alongside Spain, Uruguay, Not everyone will create brilliant, “disruptive”
and the United Kingdom. products—products that transform a market as,
say, Steve Jobs has done. But many young peo-
But this report has little to do with schooling. ple, given the right encouragement, can bring
More likely than not, Finland is top in technol- something extra to whatever they do—that spark
ogy not because its schools have outstanding of imagination and curiosity which can lead to
STEM programs but because it’s the home of the creation of better products, services, and
Nokia, the world’s second-largest mobile phone ideas.
manufacturer. Japan doesn’t boast a high Global
Creativity Index, but that’s because Japan doesn’t Our schools need to address this reality, and ed-
boast. ucation policy must be transformed accordingly.
We will certainly face challenges—including time,
According to the aforementioned ADOBE survey, resources, and training— but the truth is, we
Japan lives in the shadow of its own success: have little choice in the matter. Creativity is no
While Germany, France, and the UK all see Japan longer a luxury, but a necessity.
as the most creative nation, Japanese respon-
dents overwhelmingly believe that creativity is “Today’s students will need such tools to tackle
still reserved for artistic (78%) and elite (52%) the problems they stand to inherit,” wrote Dan
communities, and that age is a major deterrent Berrett for The Chronicle of Higher Education
to creative output.The extent of the “creativity earlier this year. “Climate change, income in-
crisis,” therefore, depends on who’s holding the equality, and escalating health-care costs cannot
measuring stick. be remedied by technocratic solutions alone,
say advocates of teaching creativity. Knowledge
will need to be combined across disciplines, and
But we all know that we could be juxtaposed in unorthodox ways.”
doing better, and that creativity is
Regardless of the instantaneousness of informa-
becoming an increasingly import- tion in today’s world, as long as we continue to
ant quality in a world where inno- use that information in creative ways, challenge
assumptions presented to us as “right” answers,
vation is the new knowledge. and embrace the possibility of being wrong, we
will retain our creative skills. “If students can gain
“Today,” says Tony Wagner, an education spe-
some facility with creative thinking now, colleges
cialist at Harvard, “the capacity to innovate — the
reason, perhaps they will be more adaptable
ability to solve problems creatively or bring new
both as employees and citizens in an uncertain
possibilities to life — and skills like critical think-
future.”
PART 1
WHAT IS
CREATIVITY?
WHAT IS CREATIVITY?
In the late 1960s, the psychologist J.P. Guilford that is required to transform the associations
drew a distinction between two forms of think- developed in the previous stage into tangible
ing: convergent and divergent. With its frequent works. The final stage, communication, involves
use of standardized tests, education today tends sharing the work with others, a process that can
to lean heavily toward convergent thinking, be challenging and requires special courage.
which emphasizes the importance of arriving at a Sharing the creative outcome with others often
single correct answer. Divergent thinking, howev- unleashes new creative processes in other indi-
er, requires coming up with alternative theories viduals, making creativity ‘contagious.’”
and ideas, sometimes many of them, to produce
a useful solution. Note that Chavez says she interviewed not only
artists but “scientists” and “social researchers,”
Guilford claims that divergent thinking is re- still identifying a singular definition of the cre-
quired during all stages of the creative process. ative process. This finding is in keeping with the
However, some degree of convergent thinking current notion that creativity should not only be
(which leads to a single solution) is also required, associated with fine artists and performers, but
particularly during the elaboration phase of the with doctors, engineers, historians, technicians,
creative process, when it is essential to discrim- and anyone else whose job requires—or even
inate and choose between alternatives (conver- allows— them to think outside the box.
gent) while at the same time generating new
ideas (divergent). But wouldn’t you call doctors and engineers in-
novative, not creative? What is the difference?
Essentially, Guilford is equating thinking cre- True, creativity and innovation are often con-
atively with thinking “outside the box,” a con- flated, and rightfully so--each contains elements
cept with which we are all familiar. Rosa Aurora of the other. The consensus appears to be that,
Chavez-Eakle of the Maryland State Department while creativity may never manifest itself in a
of Education Council for the Gifted and Talented measurable way, innovation always leads to a
goes into more detail in this passage from a 2010 quantifiable end product or result.
paper published by the Johns Hopkins School of
Education: In April, Business Insider released a piece enti-
tled, “There’s a Critical Difference Between Cre-
“During the past decade, I developed the asso- ativity and Innovation.” The author writes, “The
ciation integration-elaboration-communication main difference between creativity and innova-
phenomenological model of creativity (Chávez, tion is the focus.
1999, Chávez, 2004). This model was developed
from phenomenological observations and deep
phenomenological interviews with poets, scien-
Creativity is about unleashing the
tists, writers, music composers, social research- potential of the mind to conceive
ers, and plastic artists. The first stage of the cre-
ative process, the association-integration stage
new ideas.
involves the association of previously unrelated Those concepts could manifest themselves in
elements of inner and outer experiences, form- any number of ways, but most often, they be-
ing new associations among what is perceived come something we can see, hear, smell, touch,
through the senses, thoughts, memories, ideas, or taste. However, creative ideas can also be
and emotions. thought experiments within one person’s mind.
“The second stage, the elaboration, involves all Creativity is subjective, making it hard to mea-
the subsequent conscious and voluntary work sure, as our creative friends assert.
Innovation, on the other hand, is completely approach me with a sad face at the end of the
measurable. Innovation is about introducing semester, telling me how disappointed she was
change into relatively stable systems. It’s also because, in fact, what we had accomplished was
concerned with the work required to make an not uncreative at all; by not being ‘creative,’ she
idea viable. By identifying an unrecognized and produced the most creative body of writing in
unmet need, an organization can use innova- her life. By taking an opposite approach to cre-
tion to apply its creative resources to design an ativity — the most trite, overused, and ill-defined
appropriate solution and reap a return on its concept in a writer’s training — she had emerged
investment. renewed and rejuvenated, on fire and in love
again with writing.”
Was this always the case? A generation ago, was “The hatching of ideas is connected to this reali-
the Art scene different? ty. Ideas come through contact and interaction;
ideas are less tested in isolation. The class of
“The previous ‘age of print’ had fixed pathways today should be creating a ‘creative circle’ that
based on industry convention and production,” challenges and tests ideas. (This should be) an
explains Andrew. “In the ‘post-typographic or iterative process-space with clear signposts to-
Creative Age’ that we are now experiencing, we wards problem-solving,” the educator says.
are all re-inventing how we build, consume and
distribute content ‘live.’” Often, people who teach highly creative students
in creative disciplines find that these students
learn differently. Anecdotally, and as highlighted shifted and changed?
in various studies, some educators say that cre-
ative people are more highly strung, reactionary “Creativity has gone through a re-definition in
and sensitive. But is this always the case? recent years. In a world where ideas and innova-
tion have become a key currency for individuals
Andrew mentions that he has met and taught and organizations, understanding and harness-
many sensitive artists and students in his lengthy ing creativity and creative people is a ‘must-have.’
career. “The life of the professional ‘creative’ is a We saw the rise and passing of the information
“You don’t complete vocation,” he says, “not a pastime or a age and the knowledge economy. We are now in
necessarily need by the hour contract where you step in and out
of the process loop.”
the Creative Age where ideas rule!”
who are switched on, transform the problem at hand in to re-defined Does this affect our ability to be creative? An-
action and outcome. That’s really what creativity drew thinks that this could be something to
looking for evidence is about.” consider.
of the child’s truest Often when thinking about their students’ cre- “Standardized testing of literacy and numeracy is
inclinations and ative minds, educators look back to what they
were drawn to as young children. Does Andrew
a basic benchmark,” he says. “It should be seen
has a part of measuring a population’s place in
confirming them remember himself to have been a creative child? standard’s measuring. More complex, qualitative
methods could effective ‘de-stress’ students if
through teachers and He says, yes: “My talents seemed to manifest they know there more than one measure of their
themselves in visuals and music,” he explains. ability. A broadened approach should deliver a
trusted friends.” “And this helps to explain creativity. It’s not a broader view of ability.”
personality trait. Creativity is all about identify-
ing evidence of a person’s passion and ability to When asked to name the main creative tools he
tackle and express their ideas, whether it be vi- makes use of in everyday life, Andrew came up
Andrew Barnum sual, musical, science, fashion etc. Your first true with an understandably eclectic list.
collaborators are your parents as they identify
what you’re naturally ‘drawn to.’ Having parents
that are open to ‘seeing you as you truly are’ is
“Firstly,” he explains, I would say a
your first step to a creative future.” pen or pencil, as I write in a
How essential then, is it for children to have cre-
personal notebook as habit every
ative parents in order to thrive? Is it essential to day.”
have parents who understand the importance of
creative expression? “Secondly, my digital camera. I use either an
iPhone or a DSLR. Thirdly, I would say my Goo-
“You don’t necessarily need ‘creative’ parents,” gle Chrome browser. I use this for email, social
Andrew explains, “...you just need parents who media, news sites, blogs, projects, research and
are switched on, looking for evidence of the shopping.”
child’s truest inclinations and confirming them
through teachers and trusted friends.” Lastly, I use the Adobe Creative Suite. This includes the
programs InDesign, Illustrator Photoshop and all the
So, how has the creative’s position in the world myriad tools from Creative Cloud.”
When asked to name a major creative influence, “For some, the new generations’ experience
Andrew Barnum mentions Poetics in Song. appears like a ‘parallel universe’ that is hopefully
“In art,” he explains, “there are only three pillars destined to dry up and blow away. It won’t. The
that hold up all the disciplines of the creative youth is hell-bent on a subtle re-invention of the
arts: painting, music and poetry. My influence men- world and its problems through interactivity.
tioned contains two of them simultaneously.” Expressions like ‘all good’ and whatever’ are a
type of armour to help them remain productive
So, is creativity under threat? and engaged within the headwinds of an age of
persistent change.”
Some educators are saying that “kids today” are
often stumped by a creative task, as they are
looking for the “right” answer, which doesn’t ex-
ist. In Andrew’s opinion, is Generation Z missing
out on some of the things that gens Y, X and the
Boomers got as kids? Andrew does not think that
this is the case.
learn new technology “Historically, learning has been a lot about repe- ANNE BAMFORD
tition. If we go back to Ancient Greece all schools Centers for Research on Creativity
uses, devise new involved memorization and repetition as the first
step towards knowledge. But to this element of Professor Anne Bamford has been recognized in-
examination forms, repetition we need to add the requirement of ternationally for her research in arts, education,
application to concrete empirical cases. This is emerging literacy, and visual communication.
etc.” where academia and work life meet, and this is She is an expert in the international dimension
where creativity plays a major role.” of education and through her research has pur-
sued issues of innovation, social impact, equity,
“Academia should be better at helping students and diversity. A world scholar for UNESCO, Bam-
Anamaria Dutceac Segesten practice this applicative understanding while in ford has conducted major national educational
school. I think the difference you present in this impact and evaluation studies for the govern-
survey is explained by the difference in expecta- ments of Denmark, The Netherlands, Belgium,
tions. In school, knowing the theories and having Iceland, Hong Kong, and Norway. She has re-
the right answers were often considered the ceived awards for Best Educational Research,
measures of educational achievement. In the the National Teaching Award in the UK, and was
work life, the application of theories to concrete a runner-up for British Female Innovator of the
cases and the demand of problem-solving re- Year. Currently, she teaches at the University of
define achievement. So, for example, academia the Arts London and co-manages the Centers for
should include more problem-solving exercises.” Research on Creativity (CRoC).
As for the role technology can play in this game, We were curious to hear Anne’s thoughts on the
Anamaria says, “Technology is a tool. It can be current “creativity crisis” and whether innova-
used both for and against creativity. Universities tive tendencies are declining in today’s youth, or
should (and most actually do) educate students whether reporters have simply been spreading
not only by providing new information but also rumours and perpetuating myths.
by teaching students how to identify their need
for new information and how to obtain it. This
“It is argued that this is the case and perhaps it Bamford has a host of ideas: given encouragement to engage in the arts and
may be true,” she says, “but there is little verifi- tend to be more creative.
able research to show this one way or the other.” 1. Have a creativity corner in the classroom
Her feeling is that if creativity has indeed been where there are a range of unstructured “I think it is vital that the arts and creativity form
reduced, it is due to one or more of the following materials that encourage open ended creative a vital part of compulsory education so that all
factors: 1) Children have less unstructured play problem solving children are exposed to the potential of creativity
time; 2) Children a less likely to engage in imagi- 2. Give questions rather than answers and en- regardless of the inclinations of their parents.
native play with natural materials; 3) The school courage the pupils to take a ‘research orientat- That is why it has to be part of compulsory edu-
curriculum has become more narrow; 4) The arts ed’ approach to learning. cation (not only in after school experiences).”
have been marginalised in many schools; 5) In-
sufficient emphasis is given to creativity in teach-
3. Integrate learning (e.g. try putting science and
music together or mathematics and art)
Bamford also believes that negative early ex-
periences in childhood can stunt creativity—for “What about
er education; 6) The prevalence of high stakes
exams in schools has increased; or 7) Timetables
4. Have partnerships e.g. include museums, in-
dustry artists in the classroom or take children
good—making it vitally important for early edu-
cation teachers to focus on creative learning.
technology?
and teaching methods have become more rigid
and limit creativity.
from the classroom to these places.
5. Encourage risk taking. “In my own international research (Bamford
Does it make students
What about technology? Does it make students
6. Have flexible times for learning (rigid timeta-
bles limit creativity).
2004, The Wow Factor), around 28% of all experi-
ences have a negative impact on a child’s creativ-
less creative when
less creative when they can find instant answers 7. Provide plenty of chances for pupils to ‘per- ity,” she says. “There is a lack of research as to they can find instant
to questions with a quick Google search? form’ their learning in exhibitions, concerts, whether a child can ‘recover’ from an experience
speeches, games, online and so on. that is negative in terms of the creativity. My per- answers to questions
“When we look at what a lot of 8. Provide creative professional development
and training for all teachers and school lead-
sonal opinion would suggest that once a child’s
creative learning is stifled, it is quite difficult to with a quick Google
young people do on technology, ers. reignite it.”
search?”
it is very creative,” she says. “For When asked whether she thinks creativity can be
example, making movies, mixing measured, she says, “Yes and no. It is possible to
music, sharing poetry. So I think measure both creative behaviours and creative ANYA KAMENETZ Anne Bamford
outputs, but the type of ‘testing’ you might use The Narrow Bridge
technology can be very creative. is not very conducive to standardised forms of
testing. For example, creativity is more likely to Anya Kamenetz is a Pulitzer-Prize-nominated
“My concern, though, is that technology uses a be evident in a drama production than in a test journalist for Fast Company in New York. Her
lot of time and so people are not exploring dif- paper.” blog, The Narrow Bridge, is about the future of
ferent forms of technology. Also, particularly for
education. As a reporter, Kamenetz casts a keen
young children, I think they need unstructured Bamford is a strong believer in the effects of a eye on the higher education landscape, fielding
play and imaginative play using a range of ‘hands student’s environment on his or her behaviour. the current discourse on policy and practice,
on’ materials.” “Creativity does not occur in a vacuum. You need student loans, alternative learning paths, tech-
a rich environment and lots of creative people nology, and more.
When asked why she thinks creativity is an working in proximity to create a creative energy.
important quality to cultivate in today’s youth, “I think all people can be creative if given the In 2011, Learning, Freedom and the Web and The
she said, “I think the value of creativity in terms right environment and stimulation to encourage Edupunks’ Guide were published as free e-books
of employability is very underrated. In a study creativity. Creativity is primarily a behaviour, and by the Mozilla and Gates Foundation respective-
of graduate attributes I conducted in the UK, like all behaviours it can be enhanced or stifled ly. Generation Debt (Riverhead, 2006) dealt with
creativity was the major thing employers looked through reinforcement, modelling, and cont- youth economics and politics; DIY U: Edupunks,
for when selecting someone (along with commu- structist sharing. Edupreneurs, and the Coming Transformation of
nication and collaboration skills – which can also
Higher Education, (Chelsea Green, 2010) investi-
be gained through creative activities, especially What about a student’s home environment? gated innovations to address the crises in cost,
in the arts).” “[Students] do not need creative parents, but access, and quality in higher education.
there is evidence to suggest that the higher the
So how can teachers promote creativity and education level of the mother, the more likely Kamenetz was named a 2010 Game Changer in
imaginative play in their own classrooms? the child is to be taken to interesting places and Education by the Huffington Post, received 2009
and 2010 National Awards for Education Report- So how can teachers promote creativity in their
ing from the Education Writers Association, and own lecture rooms?
was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize in Feature
Writing by the Village Voice in 2005. “One suggestion is for educators to bring three
and four year olds into the classroom to interact
When asked whether she thought creativity with older students. This is an age of inventive-
was declining in students she said, “It’s a pretty ness that’s not tied to rulemaking but the sheer
general question, which makes it hard to answer. pleasure of the mind’s ability to invent. That, and
My guess would be that we’re simply much more getting out of our kids’ ways to enable more time
aware of the growing need for creativity, which for unstructured play and imagination.”
makes us more conscious of an apparent lack of
it.”
However, Kamenetz recognizes
But what about the way in which, say, technology the challenges teachers face,
provides us with instant answers to questions,
thereby aborting any wondering or creative
such as time constraints and be-
musing younger generations would do well to havior management dilemmas.
pursue? Finding a solution may require
“Again it all depends on the situation,” Kame- viewing things from the student’s
netz says. “Technology is a tool that can enable perspective, she says.
tremendous creativity. The work that goes in to
designing and operating our digital world can “Speaking as a kid who was always daydreaming
be incredibly creative. I think to the extent that in class, reading books under the desk, writing
students can experience tech as something that stories, drawing pictures, working on little proj-
is plastic and hackable it will become a creative ects, and otherwise getting distracted, I think it’s
medium for them. To the extent that they are fine for teachers to stick to a general plan for
using it to make routine or boring things easier, how the class is supposed to be organized. The
it might still pave the way for creativity. In the trick for a kid like me is to be able to keep up
example of Google, looking up pictures of shoes with the phonics lesson while carrying on your
you like is not particularly creative, but trying own creative affairs.”
to create a “Googlewhack” (a phrase with ex-
actly one result) could be very creative. Playing And by “carrying on your own creative affairs,”
Geoguesser, the Google Maps game, is some- Kamenetz doesn’t mean letting the student do
where in between.” whatever she wants for fear of squandering
sensitivity. “Sure, I understand the stereotype of
Kamenetz strongly disapproves of the way coun- the highly sensitive person. But in the world I live
tries like the United States go about standard- in it’s important to be kind and to know how to
ized assessments, especially since they leave take care of yourself and others. A ‘creative’ kid
little room for measuring creativity. “My next shouldn’t get a free pass to be neurotic.”
book is about how to do them better, and I think
assessing creativity may very well be part of that, In her book DIY U: Edupunks, Edupreneurs,
but it certainly won’t be with a Scan-tron or mul- and the Coming Transformation of Higher Ed-
tiple-choice items.” ucation, Kamenetz urges students to take their
educations into their own hands, which requires,
“We must be clear that this is not a content area among other things, enormous creativity. In
like science or Spanish. It’s a practice. Creativity is a Part One of the book she charts the history of
way of being in the world and imparting that has far how college-for-all became part of the American
more to do with how school is organized than any Dream and why tuition is caught in a cost spiral.
particular set of thoughts, readings, games, etc.” In Part Two Kamenetz discusses creative ways
of changing the future and cites open content; to shift our engagement level from passive con- porate these activities into your classroom,” she
virtual-reality classrooms; free and open-source sumers to active creators.” says. “Instead of teaching students history from
education; and vocational, experiential, and a textbook, have students become historians
self-directed learning as possible options. Near In her own area of expertise, Panagos says stu- and engage them with primary documents. Have
the end of the book, she provides an index of dents squelch their ideas before even attempting them draw their own conclusions about an event
resources for students who want to “hack” their to execute them. “Most students, even bright using source material.”
own education. academic overachievers, have had little practice
child currently in high different from when she was a grade school
child, and yet certain elements will always be the
ty? Often, teachers and students alike think of
creativity as “disorganized, intuitive, haphazard
expression in their children too. Even if a child’s
parents are not creative themselves, Charity
school, I can say that same. “As a child, I do feel (children of my gen-
eration were) given more time and freedom to
or uncontrollable”. Can there be such a thing as
organized creativity? Charity believes so.
feels parents who understand the importance of
creative expression can benefit their kids’ cre-
she is far less be more creative with projects, creative writing,
and the like. Today it seems as though teach- “Organization and creativity can live in one
ative minds. This later will benefit them as adult
learners.
enthusiastic about ers have far less in the way of time or freedom
even considering how to teach a concept. This
space. How creative can you be when you are
organizing? Many teachers employ this very “Just because students don’t have highly creative
learning than ever, applies when teaching adults as well as kids, she tactic when they are attempting to maximize stu- parents, doesn’t mean they aren’t able to suc-
explains. dent leaning space when the space they have to cessfully be creative. They may have to adjust
and some of that might work in is very tiny or oddly shaped. Even very how they express that creativity if it is stifled in
be due to the fact “Many learning institutions require a specific text
series and will not allow teachers to stray from it
creative thinkers usually have some sort of orga-
nized system for getting those creative thoughts
the home, but truly creative students will find a
way to express that creativity in other ways or
that much of the day is at all,” says Charity. “In my opinion, this definite-
ly limits how creative students can be. But, as
from their mind onto a tangible workspace. Cre-
ative problem solving is a skill we should hone.
places (even in non-positive ways). While we
would like to hope that parents would be sup-
spent in a lecture always, the best teachers find ways and time to
sneak in creativity in everything they do. I think
In order to function the best in society, thinking
outside of the box, while also knowing the or-
portive of creativity in their children, not all will
understand or value it. Parents that are sup-
setting” it can be done, but must be intentionally embed- ganized logistics and history of the problem at portive about anything their child is or does will
ded within the lesson plans daily.” hand, will make for the best solution finders”. always have a better situation than those that do
There is a not-new but re-emerging theory that not, whether we are talking about creativity or
There are always new methods being employed lecture and study time should be more respon- any other qualities that specific child possesses”.
Charity Preston to teach students. Often teachers teach young- sive to moments when students may get a cre- How can creativity be encouraged in a student
er children things by playing games with them ative urge, but Charity believes there needs to be that is displaying this sort of impingement?
(for example, Charity invented a ‘wordaround’ limits on this, for example, class time should be
game to teach vocabulary). However, by the time flexible, but only if the time allows for it. Charity believes it’s just like any other skill. “Cre-
children reach high school and later adult-hood, ativity can be encouraged and practiced. Having
there seems to be less interest in game-playing. teachers and caregivers who cultivate creativity
While some educators think there may be scope
“There are times where it is not in in a supportive way will help to strengthen it in
to reintroduce more game-playing for older the best interest of the entire class students. Playing creative games, using lateral
grades and even adults, Charity is quite realistic for one student to allow the rest of thinking, etcetera, is a perfect way to get learn-
about the attitudes of teens and adult learners. ers thinking creatively, and discussing possible
the students’ thought processes to solutions for those types of games, word plays,
“As a parent of a child currently in high school, go out in left field. and so on, is the key to getting students to begin
I can say that she is far less enthusiastic about to think creatively on their own.”
learning than ever, and some of that might be While I am definitely known for taking advantage
due to the fact that much of the day is spent in a of “teachable moments” and encouraging learn- Structuring effectively is the key, says Preston.
lecture setting,” Charity says. ing about specific student interests that have “The teacher should always model first, then
been expressed in and throughout a lesson, use scaffolded practice, then ask the students to
As adults, this is how we go on to interact with there will also be certain times when creative model for them, before finally asking students
our workplace. “On the other hand,” says Char- thinking is not appropriate to have a full blown- to demonstrate their thought processes on their
ity, “most places of employment don’t allow for out discussion over. Of course, encouraging own. With enough practice, the creativity be-
‘game playing’ during the work day (nor in adult comes intrinsic and students feel more confident
in their own creative abilities as well.” spent years teaching in classroom situations and is the biggest factor in the equation,” explains
has witnessed the creative thought-process first Cheri. “Allowing students to integrate tech-
Some teachers are suggesting that creativity hand in her students. nology into the creative solution, for example,
been under-valued in the past, with a focus on rather than a written report on ‘Fly Fishing as a
academic performance over creative achieve- She says, “The minute my mom gave me pencil Future Career’, the student may use the inter-
ments. Charity feels that perhaps this is shifting. and paper, I never imagined a life without writ- net to gather facts, find whose key in the field,
ing. The ultimate goal for me is to write about contact the person, get all the info needed and
“I believe there is more emphasis on academic the things people care about most. Learning then present a ‘prezi’, for example, an interactive
performance over creative achievements. This about people and discovering new places are ‘power point on steroids’ storytelling tool that “I think it may be more
is evident when academic institutions are mak- two inspirational subjects that pull me to my shares collected ideas in a virtual context.”
ing cuts in arts programming, in favour of high- computer and keep my fingers tapping on the There have been studies that indicate that cre- natural for a child of
stakes testing in core academic areas. Unfor-
tunately I don’t see it shifting in a positive way.
keys. I live in Danville, California with my two
amazing boys and am grateful to love what I do
ative people have a tendency to over-react to
stimulation. Does Cheri agree? If so, has she no- creative parents to
There are even more cuts coming in the way of
gifted education as well, where creativity is also
and do what I love: be a mom, teach, write, and
constantly learn.”
ticed this in children and teens when compared
with adult learners? Cheri confirms that she does
thrive and feel good
honed. It is obvious that creativity is an import-
ant workplace skill, yet our current system of Cheri has chosen to share her thoughts on
not notice this particular trait. about his or her
standardized testing actually focuses on lower education and creativity. It has been said that
creative thoughts can arrive at less predictable
“I don’t agree. Creative people - in my opinion - pursuit of creativity
level recall skills”. filter out the stimulation and find what fuels their
times than logical thoughts. Does this teacher fire, what works for them. There’s an intensity but I have seen plenty
In the United States, the new National Common
Core State Standards claim that they are more
think that class time should be more responsive
to moments when students may get a creative
involved with creative people that can either be
fostered and can flourish or be stifled, depend- of ‘outliers’, children
rigorous and focus on higher level thinking skills.
Charity says that this all remains to be seen as
urge? Does this apply to adult learners too? ing on the educational leader and the values of
the educational environment.”
who are creative
the new assessments come out in the next sev-
eral years.
Cheri says, “Absolutely.” She believes that this
is key, particularly when hiring good teachers. Does Cheri believe that it is essential for stu-
without creative
“Creative thinkers are the key to finding new
“Certainly, it’s important to train teachers and
give them a strong foundation for being effective
dents to have creative parents when they are
children in order to thrive? Do children that have
parents and if parents
solutions to old problems. They will be the leaders of change in technology and general cur- parents who understand the importance of cre- seek to understand, it
students who go on to cure cancer, figure out riculum, but it’s the inquiry-based learning that’s ative expression benefit creatively from this?
a way out of national debts, and hopefully ease key, those ‘teachable moments’ that are longer can be wonderful.”
the violence that seems to be so prevalent these lasting than mastering rote facts.”
days. By nurturing those creative problem-solv-
“Supportive parents are key,”
ing skills, we are encouraging our students to So what were things like when she started explains Cheri. Cheri Eplin
make the world a better place for us and for fu- teaching 20 years ago? What would have been
ture generations. Hopefully we can start making the definition of a ‘creative’ activity or class “I think it may be more natural for a child of cre-
the transition towards that emphasis in learning back then? Cheri says that times have certainly ative parents to thrive and feel good about his or
institutions as well.” changed. her pursuit of creativity but I have seen plenty of
‘outliers’, children who are creative without cre-
“Ha!” she says, “creativity would have meant get- ative parents and if parents seek to understand,
CHERI EPLIN ting students out of rows and into cooperative
groups. The truth is, it’s still a small part in look-
it can be wonderful. However, if parents do not
understand, it can provide plenty of stress for
Living in the Moment ing at what can facilitate a creative classroom.” the student. This is true as with a high-perform-
In today’s world, what does Cheri think the ing school or district can be a major stumbling
Cheri Eplin is a teacher in the San Francisco Bay current definition of a ‘creative’ activity or class block for those who don’t fit in because their
Area, working in education management. She might be? Cheri says, ‘technology’ is a tool that intellect is in the arts (for example) rather than in
is also a freelance writer and has spent time as keeps coming into focus for her students, wheth- traditional studies of math and science.”
a principal and has also worked as a corporate er they are adults or younger.
wellness manager for Quantum, a global spe- This can then affect learning as adults as not
cialist in backup, recovery and archive. Cheri has “When looking at ‘creativity’ now, technology every student has an ideal childhood. It has been
indicated that negative early experiences early in the past as we were erroneously led to be- putting on a TEDx event at a learning institution,
on can stunt creativity. How does Cheri suggest lieve that our highest academic achievers would for example. She explains, “At our place of learn-
that creativity can be encouraged in someone do the job, but that wasn’t the case. Those that ing, the TED customer portal helped with public
who is displaying this sort of impingement? break out with their own businesses (whether relations. They provided us with spreadsheets,
“A student’s environment can be the key in en- it be the Candace Nelson, founder of Sprinkles meeting and greeting speakers, and schooled us
couraging creativity. Once a student experiences Cupcakes or Oprah, who created an empire with on everything it entails to put on an event.”
some sort of “success” in creative expression, it HARPO) we see the value of creativity as a cat-
is one more loop in that belt of imagination. As a alyst for success and great contribution to our Cheri goes on to list some other ideas for teach-
student becomes older, peers play a bigger role society. Yes, cupcakes count!” ers and classes: “We do a ‘Lingo Lounge’ where
“I think as we learn in development as does the relationship/expe- the students get on the microphone at a local
riences with school and teachers. This is where Starbucks and reads poetry, we read about and
that we cannot yet teachers can have a huge impact on those stu-
So what about the rise of get involved in local and national news, learning
standardized tests? Cheri is not
prepare for future dents adversely affected.
a particular fan of them, a stance
about what goes on in the world and how we can
help, etc. We do “problems of the month,” with
careers - as many Some teachers have stated that creativity has
been under-valued in the past, with a focus on she shares with many
real-life math problems and together, they work
in groups to create solutions and understand
have yet to be academic performance over creative achieve-
ments. Others feel that this is shifting, but per-
contemporary teachers. that there may be more than one answer.”
developed, what we haps not fast enough. Cheri says that she is a
firm believer in developing the skills of those
“Put the test to rest,” says Cheri. “It is only one Does creativity come in rhythms, in Cheri’s
opinion? What could a student (adult or child) do
can do is look at the who might feel that their talents are left of cen-
of many ways to assess students. I think it’s fine
for baseline testing for certain skills pertinent when they have to complete a creative task and
tre. they have no inspiration? What has Cheri found
present successes of to succeed. It just doesn’t measure many types
of intellect, mainly someone’s capacity in their success with in the past?
people in the Cheri says, “I think as we learn that we cannot
yet prepare for future careers - as many have yet
heart to give and contribute in ways that help
everyone. It can provide immense stress and ac- Cheri says, “What I find most successful in the
technology industry, to be developed, what we can do is look at the
present successes of people in the technology
tually kill creativity for many individuals so I think
there’s a delicate balance and depending on the
recipe for creativity is to first be sure that the
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs are met. It’s im-
such as Steve Jobs, Bill industry, such as Steve Jobs, Bill Gates and Mark
Zuckerberg.”
district, college or school, some are way out of perative that basic needs are met first. Then, it’s
key to stay connected to the project.”
balance while others are insisting on balancing
Gates and Mark the scales of justice by maintaining funds or cre-
Cheri believes that these innovators all had one She explains that there is always a natural ebb
Zuckerberg.” thing in common. “The common denominator
ating funds through foundations to include art,
P.E., Science labs, and other hands-on programs and flow. “Yes, there will be rhythms of enthusi-
is that all these individuals (and even those that teach and facilitate ‘Learn by Doing’ skills.” asm and frustration, etcetera but as a class, stu-
not named) were creative thinkers who often dents can learn that this is part of the process.”
thought outside the box.” Cheri explains that considering what is still to
Cheri Eplin Does this teacher consider herself to be a cre-
happen is important when explaining the cre-
ative person? “Absolutely,” says Cheri. What
Cheri believes that “there’s this huge trend in does she think the key to her creativity is? “Get ative rhythms. “Working with others, working
equalizing opportunity for creativity by imple- to know your students. That’s the bottom line,” is on those relationships, beginning with the end
menting ‘Common Core’ standards. I think the Cheri’s direct response. in mind and realizing that that may just be the
ticket is combining both academic strides AND beginning,” says Cheri. “I always talk to the stu-
creativity. As we see our international compet- “Know where they are, what makes them tick as dents about the word ‘yet’.
itors and feel a squeeze that we are starting to individuals, and help them grow academically
‘fall behind’, the realization is that we have not and as a person. I create many opportunities for I explain that they may not know something yet
spent enough time in the classroom to allow my students to try their hand in real-life situa- but will if they work hard on wanting to get there
students to do genuine ‘problem solving’ and to tions that will only help them gain confidence they eventually will.
think on their feet as ‘real-life problems’ present and put tools in their toolbox of life skills.”
themselves.” Cheri has a couple of creative acronyms she uses
Cheri goes on to give a range of wonderful sug- in her classroom. “Also, sometimes it’s about
So, was this previously undervalued? Cheri says gestions for classroom activities. She suggests POP and BIC (pencil on paper) and (bottom in
yes. “I do think this is where it was under-valued chair.) Sometimes it takes work ethic, hard work
and determination, mixed with all the good ideas She would also advise teachers to be flexible “Individualized learning should be taken into ac-
that bring good results.” in allowing students to indulge their creative count instead of making every student proficient
impulses, especially when it comes to writing at test taking and ‘going by the rules.”
What else can teachers do? Cheri says, “It’s also narratives or creative writing.
important to understand that others (other peo-
ple) and your environment can always provide “I like for my students to imagine being in the
inspiration when needed, if open minded to un- time period we are studying to get a feel of what DANIEL WILLINGHAM
derstanding that sometimes the more complex it would have been like to live in an age where DanielWillingham.com
and satisfying projects require more than just one didn’t have everything instantly,” she says.
yourself. The most successful way to complete “It is so hard for young students to imagine a Daniel Willingham earned his B.A. from Duke
a creative task is to start with a shorter task and life without computer access, but one can find University in 1983 and his Ph.D. in Cognitive Psy-
experience the satisfaction of completing that print materials that can show them what life was chology from Harvard University in 1990. He is
task, experiencing success of beginning to end, like years ago without going to the extreme. I currently Professor of Psychology at the Univer-
then you can create longer tasks and increase feel that students should use what they know sity of Virginia, where he has taught since 1992.
endurance and stamina.” and learn about to be creative in responses to Until about 2000, his research focused solely on
essay questions. The hardest challenge now is the brain basis of learning and memory. To-
to incorporate it in with the Common Core State day, all of his research concerns the application
Standards, which seem to filter creativity out of of cognitive psychology to K-16 education. He
CHERYL JUDD ALLEN the picture.” writes the “Ask the Cognitive Scientist” column
Teacher in Jackson County, for American Educator magazine, and is an Asso-
She adds, “Patience, and understanding where ciate Editor of Mind, Brain, and Education.
Cainesboro, Tennessee the learner is coming from, are two pluses for
educators even though lesson planning and indi- He is also the author of Why Don’t Students Like
Cheryl Judd Allen is a 27-year veteran of the
vidual assessment are almost non-existent in the School? (Jossey-Bass) and When Can You Trust
classroom. She earned her B.S. in Education,
way teachers teach today. Take time to smell the the Experts? (Jossey-Bass). His writing on educa-
with an emphasis in English/Language Arts, from
roses, and don’t get so caught up in having to ac- tion has been translated into eleven languages.
the Tennessee Technological University. Allen
complish too much at the expense of a student’s You can read his Science and Education blog
is the chairman of her English department and
understanding and creativity.” here.
loves to incorporate creative assessments into
her classroom with hands-on projects.
When we asked Allen if she thought creativity When we asked Dr Willingham whether he
could be measured, she said, “Creativity is mea- thought creativity had declined in students
Allen, for one, firmly believes that creativity has
surable because students either have it or not. It across the globe, he said, “I don’t see any reason
declined in students. “I believe easy access to the
can be cultivated with hands-on learning to the to draw that conclusion. I know that there was
internet, gaming, and lack of real, in-depth read-
point where students can feel comfortable using a recent report saying that students today are
ing has caused this to happen,” she says.
the skills they have mastered. I feel it should be less creative, but I think measures of creativity
a routine part of assessment because sometimes are still pretty rough. I’m not persuaded that we
Technology is a good tool, Allen says, if not taken
words are not enough to get one’s point across.” can measure creativity with enough accuracy to
to the extreme. “I feel that students are less
Allen agrees that teachers have a responsibility make that judgment.”
creative because it is so easy to access whatever
when it comes to creativity education, but she
they need or want on the Internet. Old fash-
also recognizes the influence of a young stu- Willingham doesn’t believe science will necessar-
ioned digging for information is almost a thing of
dent’s home environment. This can later affect ily provide us with the secrets of fostering cre-
the past when there are so many ‘easy’ answers
their learning in adulthood. ativity any more than good teaching programs
available at the touch of a button.”
will, but he does think it’s especially crucial to
“Creative parents are a plus but not necessary promote “tasks that are open-ended, a spirit of
To reverse what she sees as a downward trend,
for a student to be creative,” she says. “Parents playfulness and curiosity about ideas, and, most
Allen advises fellow educators to promote cre-
should foster individuality and creative expres- important, a sense that failure is normal and part
ativity and innovation by using “more hands-on
sion in each student’s sphere of understanding.” of the learning process.”
projects like one sees in the workforce,” and not
Academics have downplayed creativity for some
just something that can be put together “too eas-
time and will also be stifled when the Common To teachers he adds, “Make time for it because
ily” by the click of a computer button.
Core State Standards come into play, she adds. there are a lot of tasks in learning institutions
that don’t lend themselves to a lot of creativity. But Willingham says a majority of the population ally have a “creativity crisis” on our hands, and
That’s probably appropriate. But you’ll find more still finds the inaccurate, left brain/right brain teachers will be the ones to blame.
opportunities for creativity than you first think theory— namely, that the right hemisphere
you will, if you’re on the lookout!” of the brain is more responsible for creative
thought than the left—so convenient that they
But Willingham acknowledges that, in principle,
it’s very hard for teachers to devote precious
can’t let it go. This is especially true for teachers. DARREN KUROPATWA
class time to indulging their students’ creative “This idea is used in education in two ways,” St. James-Assiniboia Division
impulses. “A student’s creative impulse might in- Willingham says. “Sometimes the left brain/
Darren Kuropatwa is a Curriculum Coordinator
“Thinking that we can ject a lot of excitement into a lesson, or it might
send a lesson off the rails. It’s very much up to
right brain distinction is offered as an account of
differences in ability, much as in the casual (and for Digital Learning in the St. James-Assiniboia
identify an array of the judgment of the teacher as to which it’s likely
to be.”
harmless) way I described. But when offered
as a more scientifically weighty theory, people
School Division in Winnipeg, Manitoba. For many
years he taught mathematics and worked to
these tasks--logical A good influence at home makes a big differ-
start to call for university, school or college to be
more ‘right brain oriented.’ Sometimes this call
employ technology into his lessons. Darren’s
blog, A Difference, documents not only his own
thinking, language, ence, Willingham says, but he recognizes that is pitched in terms of fairness; the right-brain keen insights into technology and learning, but
also five years of interactive class blogs reflecting
not everybody has the time or know-how to help students seem to be at unfair disadvantage.
math, and others--that students thrive creatively. “I guess it depends on his students’ views on their own learning experi-
ence.
all depend mostly on what one means by ‘thrive.’ I hate to think that
teachers, professors or even parents would feel
Sometimes it’s pitched as common
one hemisphere seems pressure to be creative or feel that they are fail- sense: we’re ignoring half of Kuropatwa, for one, believes that creativity is
ures! Understanding the importance of creative alive and well, and that digital media has only
students’ brains!
a little far-fetched.” expression in students seems part of a larger
attitude I associate with good parenting--namely,
helped it grow.
“Other people treat the left brain/right brain “No, I wouldn’t agree that there is a decline in
supporting the student, showing interest in his distinction not as a distinction of ability (what
or her pursuits.” creativity. Human evolution doesn’t happen that
students are good at) but as a learning style (how
Daniel Willingham students prefer to learn). Left-brain learners will
fast.” He says technology has been key in nar-
In 2010, Willingham wrote an article for The rowing the distance between purpose and play.
understand a concept best by talking about it, We now live in a world where the same tools we
Washington Post about new research claim- for example, but right brain learners will want to
ing that creativity is not especially a right-brain use to create memes and update our friends on
draw a diagram.” what we ate for dinner can also be used to ben-
function. “In fact,” he wrote, “two of three broad
classes of creative thought that have been stud- efit the greater good. “If you actually want to an-
This kind of misguided thinking can change not ecdotally look around the world today, you have
ied seem not to depend on a single set of brain only the way teachers treat individual students
structures.” people who start off with something like LOLCats
but the way they operate entire classes. and end up with Ushahidi. People create through
“In both cases,” Willingham says, “prescriptions play and then make a contribution.”
“What we call ‘creativity’ is so diverse that it can’t are given greater weight because of the apparent
be localized in the brain very well,” he explains. neuroscientific basis of the recommendations.
“In the usual mythology, the left hemisphere of Ushahidi, which is Swahili for “testimony” or “wit-
the brain is logical, ordered, and analytic, and it ness,” is a non-profit software company that uses
‘Students who have trouble with reading, math the concept of crowdsourcing for social activism
supports reading, speech, math, and reasoning. and science are at a disadvantage at college or
The right hemisphere is more oriented towards and public accountability purposes. In 2007, in
university’, sounds obvious and unimpressive the aftermath of Kenya’s disputed presidential
feelings and emotions, spatial perception, and when compared to ‘right brain dominant stu-
the arts, and is said to be more creative. election, the organization collected eyewitness
dents are at a disadvantage at college or univer- reports of violence sent in by text or e-mail and
sity’.” placed them on Google Maps. Ushahidi was also
“We have known for at least 30 years that this
characterization is incorrect. Thinking that we used to benefit victims of the 2010 earthquakes
Willingham’s work suggests that educators need in Haiti and Chile.
can identify an array of these tasks--logical think- to stop thinking of creativity in terms of a single,
ing, language, math, and others--that all depend isolated part of the brain that some students
mostly on one hemisphere seems a little far- True, there are fewer people developing resourc-
have and others don’t. Otherwise, we may actu- es like Ushahidi than using them, Kuropatwa
fetched. More to the point, we know it’s inaccurate.”
says, but at least those people who are making creative projects. His students supported him in coming too prohibitive and strict because of the think it would be fairer to characterize the per-
them are creating something. And the same goes this decision, agreeing that, since it can’t easily pressures of preparing students for ‘high stakes’ ceptions of a rising education technology indus-
for people who create LOLCats. be measured, creativity should only be a small tests? try that seeks to use computers to automate
part of overall assessment. schooling. The primary focus is data, generated
Obviously, not everything people create is use- David has strong feelings on the matter. “With by students’ performance and used to refine
ful, funny, or even trustworthy. But what’s less Kuropatwa firmly believes that you can’t mea- scattered exceptions, teachers in my country teaching strategies. In and of itself, this is not a
obvious, and what Kuropatwa calls a crucial part sure creativity on a black-or-white, have-it-or- are no longer encouraged to be creative, and bad thing. I mean it’s what teachers have been
of modern literacy, is that, “in order to be critical don’t scale. in instances creativity is discouraged – and this doing for decades. But just because computers
consumers of media, students need to know is largely the result of an accountability system can do it faster and more comprehensively, does
how to create it as well.” “We don’t have to foster creativity, we have to al- based on high-stakes testing. For years, scientif- not mean that it is the best use of the machines.
low it,” he says, suggesting that perhaps the data ic research-based teaching strategies were coin “Our students use technology to empower them-
Kuropatwa told us a story about an email he showing a decline in creativity is skewed since of the realm, where teachers had to be able to selves, to extend their presence and perception
received a few years back, informing him that, creativity is difficult to measure in a standardized point to research findings that supported the beyond the world that they can see and touch.
according to an online education database, his fashion in the first place. learning activities that their students were en- We’ve always want that. It’s why children pre-
blog was among the top 100 education blogs on gaged in.” tend. It enables them to form community and
the web. After a little research, he found out that The “crisis,” he says, is the growing acceptance of empowers them to work playfully. I’ve watched
the claim was only one person’s opinion and the a paradigm that treats creativity like a skill. “Just So, has this lead to a lack of creativity in the my children play their video games and to me, it
database was really a marketing website to try to because there’s an area in which you don’t excel classroom, or less of a focus on creative activ- looks like work!”
attract more traffic. doesn’t mean you’re not creative. We’re creative ities? David mentions that, “There have been
in our own ways.” teachers who have devised creative ways to So is this becoming second-nature for the
This is the kind of thing students need to protect improve their students’ test performances, but younger generation? David is really not so sure,
themselves against, he says. “You have to know Measuring creativity accurately is tricky, if not where is the inducement to imaginatively accom- quoting a Marc Prensky (an American writer and
how a message is put together and conveyed, impossible. Surely standardized tests are not the plish the goals set by unimaginative people?” speaker specializing in learning and education)
how to filter information and read the grammar answer. But perhaps we shouldn’t worry about Are some creative teachers being “punished” for piece from 2001 called Digital Immigrants and
of the internet.” The best way to understand how measuring it, for now. Creativity is recognizable; thinking outside the square? David believes that Digital Natives.
any tool works, of course, is to use it yourself.” we know it when we see it. So how do we “allow” this certainly does happen from time to time.
That’s why Kuropatwa helps learning institutions it? David says, “It was a useful observation at the
implement digital technology into their class- time. But I believe that using the technologies at
rooms and lecture rooms. As new tools are used, “Every teacher should see their classroom as
“I know of teachers who have hand are second-nature to all of us, regardless of
creativity can flourish in unforeseen ways. an excellence incubator,” says Kuropatwa. “The been urged by administrators to age. As adults have had more access to com-
Creativity had big place in his own classroom job of an educator is to help students get from scale back their creative practic- puters and the internet, and especially with the
when he was teaching math. For one assign- where they are to where they want to be.” advent of touch-sensitive tech like iPhones and
ment, Kuropatwa had his students use Flickr Creativity will follow. es because other teachers were iPads, we have devised incredibly creative ways
hotspots to take pictures of everyday objects— complaining. That’s rare, but it of using them to accomplish our goals.
window curtains, a slice of pizza, a bouquet of
flowers— and chart the trigonometry of the DAVID WARLICK does happen.” “These new technologies have threatened many
objects’ planes and curves. people of my generation (I’m 61). It is because of
2 Cents David is highly passionate about new technology the uncertainty that they imply about our future,
For another project, Kuropatwa asked his stu- in the classroom, saying in a recent blog post, and there is truth in this. However, what a future
dents to create six original math problems over David Warlick blogs on his site 2 Cents, a plat- “I think that our students have every right to of uncertainty brings is a future of opportunity. I
the course of a semester. form devoted to sharing ideas and new concepts expect that their teachers will teach more from am increasingly replacing phrases like ‘the 21st
in education. Recently, David said, “Every year, today’s information landscape.” (You also said) century’ and ‘the digital age’ with ‘The Age of
The result, he said, was that students recalled there are fewer teachers who have known the “Current students grew up with computers and Opportunities’.
their lessons much better once test time rolled experience of confidently entering their class- the internet. They become so accomplished with
around. Creating math helped them retain it. rooms with creativity, passion and the freedom these tools because it’s play for them.” So, what So, should teachers be using technology in more
As far as measuring creativity is concerned, to replace their textbooks with learning experi- difference does he perceive in the way teachers creative and unconventional ways to teach con-
Kuropatwa says, “What we value, we measure. ences that are unique, personal, powerful and and students are viewing technology for learn- ventional and core subjects? David thinks they
But lots of things we value can’t be measured.” authentic.” ing? should.
Creativity may be one of those things. In his own
classes, Kuropatwa assigned bonus points for Does he believe the classrooms of 2013 are be- David says, “It’s a good question. However, I “Yes! But (and this may surprise you) part of
the problem are the conventional/core subjects. David agrees that this could be a good idea. He ity. David has a few ideas on how creativity be
In my years, there is one thing that I am cer- says, “I believe that class time should be more encouraged in a student that is displaying this
tain about, that we are living in a time of rapid conducive to the ‘creative urge’, not just respon- sort of impingement. He says, “…we learned to
change. When so much around us is changing, sive to it. Creativity should be an integral part be creative in the sandbox, and that our formal
what our students are taught becomes less im- of what makes the class work, not just an unpre- learning environments should come to have the
portant, because the answers to the test ques- dictable by-product. Students are rarely shown qualities of a sandbox. It should be a place that
tions are changing. It’s ‘how’ they are taught that novelty and even more rarely invited to play with the learner has a certainly amount of control
has become important – or more to the point, it. Teaching should become more playful.” over, and that control empowers them to do
“how they are learning to teach themselves” that It’s thought that creative people have a tendency things that are bigger than they are.”
is important. to over-react to stimulation. Does David agree?
If so, has he noticed this in students of various A recent statistic indicated that 78 per cent of
“A time of rapid change necessitates what I call ages? people say that creativity is very important to
a ‘learning lifestyle’. Higher learning should be their careers, but only 57 per cent thought so
focused on helping students learn to be tena- “I am not sure what is meant by “over-react” or when they were in college or university. Does
cious and resourceful learners. In fact, I am also “over-reactive.” Sounds like A.D.H.D. to me,” David believe that creativity has been under-val-
increasingly replacing the term ‘literacy’ with says David. “As an adult who has been clinically ued in the past, with a focus on academic perfor-
‘learning-literacies’.” diagnosed with Attention Deficit Disorder (not mance over creative achievements?
hyperactive), I believe that what many see in me,
David recently expanded on a concept men- that looks to them like creativity, is simply the He says, yes, “Academic performance is consid-
tioned by blogger Carla Beard, stating that, “The highly random way that my mind works. I come ered more highly than creative achievements.
most important thing to remember about tech- at things from a different direction, because But some colleges and universities are starting
nology in our classrooms is that it’s not about nothing lines up on my brain. Does that make rethink their purpose and practices. There is a
the technology”. David recently asked teachers sense?” much lauded list of eight hundred colleges and
to supply the answer to the question, “What is universities (all appear to be US) that no longer
it about?” He received some very interesting How essential is it for students to require S.A.T. or A.C.T. test scores for admit-
replies from his audience of teachers and educa- tance. There are schools of design and engi-
tors. have creative parents in order to neering that are taking on a studio approach to
thrive? Or at least parents who learning in contrast to their old classroom lec-
He says, “Most frequently I hear that it’s about ture models.”
the learning or it’s about the students. I would understand the importance of
agree with both. But I suspect that when they creative expression? “But much of this comes from our notions
say that, “It’s about the learning,” they are refer- of what teaching is and what a teacher does.
ring to what they are learning, not how they are “Wow!” exclaims David, “That’s a tough one. Teachers believe that they are content experts,
learning. Personally, I do not like our reliance on the term, and that their job is to effectively convey their
creativity. Too many people think about art and expertise to their students. Anything other than
“I believe that it should be about how they are music when they see or hear the term. I prefer that, and they are not doing their jobs. I recently
learning and what they are learning to do with to talk about inventive or resourceful strategies saw a keynote address where the speaker (Su-
what they are learning. Rigour is an adverb that for accomplishing a goal.” perintendent of Philadelphia Public Schools) said
is used quite often in the U.S. to describe where that we do not need content specialists today
teaching needs to be going. But what is meant is “That said, I do believe that we come to be cre- nearly as much as we need context specialists.”
that our students need to be learning more stuff. ative by being around other creative people. It’s
To me, rigour is not how much they are learning, why I think it is so important that teachers be giv- David has a very novel way of kicking off his
but what they can do with what they are learn- en permission to be creative and encouraged to talks. He explains, “I always begin my presen-
ing. make mistakes. The best teaching might happen tations these days by sharing something that
when the teacher says, “I made a mistake yester- I didn’t know yesterday. I try to help teacher
There has been some interest worldwide with mak- day and this is what I learned from it.” come to believe that they should become master
ing class times less structured and more responsive learners.”
to creative opportunities. Does David think that There has been some reporting that negative
class time should be more responsive to those mo- early experiences in childhood can stunt creativ-
ments when students may get a creative urge?
DAWN HOGUE to create something I’ll publish on the web for
the world to see, I’m going to care a lot more
weighed down by the yoke of political influence,”
she notes. “It takes educational anarchy to push
The Polliwog Journal about that than I will care about my answers to out of the box these days, and it may simply be
ten questions about a story.” easier to do what one is told. I have known many
Dawn Hogue runs The Polliwog Journal, a blog teachers who are afraid to try something new.
about teaching English and integrating technol- During many of her classes, Hogue required stu- Some feel their jobs are at risk. Others just think
ogy into the classroom. She taught English from dents to publish their work online, an unintend- trying something new/different will be too much
1990 to 2011 and instructed students in a nation- ed result of which, she says, was that they were work and they feel overworked as it is.”
ally recognized web-based English class called “providing models of excellence for each other.”
CyberEnglish for eleven years. The goal of The “I’d hear things like, ‘Wow. That’s cool. I didn’t Even if all teachers did have the confidence, and
Polliwog Journal is to help educators embrace know you could do that.’ They would get creative were prepared to try new things, how would they
technology in their places of learning. ideas from each other in that way. It wasn’t my measure students’ creative progress?
job as the teacher to suggest all the ways they
“There is a tangible Based on her teaching experience, Hogue cites
a number of factors that she says detract from
could learn or show their learning.” “I think you can see creativity in action. When a
student (anyone) presents an idea or a point of
malaise in colleges, creative learning in today’s learning institutions:
standardization, fear of trying new things, bud-
As for tools like Google, which some educators
say stifle curiosity; Hogue says that if an answer
view so uncommon or new that it turns heads,
that’s evidence of creative thinking. I imagine
schools and get cuts eliminating talented-and-gifted pro-
grams and extracurricular clubs; lack of vision
can be arrived at so easily, the students are ask-
ing the wrong questions.
there is no accurate rubric or measurement tool
for creativity. Plus, what’s creative and what’s not
universities, too. So and leadership at the district or institutional lev-
el; and poor teacher training. She even goes so
is somewhat subjective, so I would hate for it to
Hogue is a big believer in trying new things, and be too entrenched in standard assessment. I’ve
much angst. It’s like far as to suggest there may be a creativity crisis believes some level of fearlessness is crucial if seen rubrics that refer to things like ‘uses cre-
among teachers, not just students, mentioning
everyone has to be several teachers she had in the 1970s who were
educators want to inspire creativity in their stu-
dents.
ative approach’ or ‘shows divergent thinking,’ but
I’m not sure those markers are meaningful.”
there and no one far more creative than her contemporary col-
leagues. “Toss out the textbook!” she says. “Toss out the
As far as challenges are
wants to be.” Also, she says, “there is a tangible malaise in
“one size fits all” standards movement. Al-
low—no, not allow, expect students to choose concerned, Hogue is aware of
colleges, schools and universities, too. So much
angst. It’s like everyone has to be there and no
the topics for their own learning. What is it you
want to know? How will you learn? Not everyone
many, including the influence of a
Dawn Hogue one wants to be.” needs to be learning the same thing, reading the student’s home environment on his
Hogue does not consider technology a hindrance
same books, or creating the same product or ev- or her creative potential.
idence that they have learned. It takes confident
to creativity; in fact, she has spent her career teachers secure in their role as coach/facilitator “We’ve all known students who seem to defy
proving otherwise. working in environments where administrators their genetic material; that is, they seem alien
are progressive and truly interested in fostering in their own homes. Some people will thrive
“In my classroom, having one-to-one access to a lively learning environment.” no matter what. But environment is HUGE, at
the internet and to creation tools (photo editor, a place of learning and at home. Parents who
web and blog editors, all the Web 2.0 tools) was In addition, Hogue says she thinks class time allow messy exploration and encourage unstruc-
a big deal,” she says. “I tried to engineer projects should be more open and less teacher-directed. tured play will probably help their children’s cre-
where students were not only free to explore “If classrooms were more relaxed places where ative instincts – this later influences adult learn-
ideas but also to express their knowledge in students were engaged in long term proj- ers. But students won’t thrive alone. Educators
creative ways. Not everyone did the same assign- ect-based learning, there would naturally be time might need help with techniques to help their
ment. It was fun for students to realize that what for inspiration to both happen and for students students develop creative thinking and expres-
they were learning/creating was going to look to act on the impulse.” sion. A house with no art or building materials,
different from peers. for example, isn’t going to help.
But many of the teachers Hogue knew during
“That process creates a sense of ownership that her career either didn’t share her attitude or “To encourage students impacted by negative
teachers don’t often see. If I’m researching some- couldn’t seem to rise above their reservations. experiences, places of learning should establish
thing I’m passionate about and using my talents “Too many teachers and administrators are
safe, positive, playful environments that stimu- “I’m not sure that it’s a creative thing to publish are encouraged to lead their learning, the more
late native desire. A lot of the work would be in one’s writing in a blog, but the process of sharing opportunities for creativity. I don’t see creativity
mending broken trust and building self-esteem.” what we know adds to that public conversation as something teachers should try and control. It’s
Another challenge lies in society’s attitude to- and gives us a foundation for doing creative more about giving learners time, space, encour-
ward creativity in general. things.” agement, opportunity... and letting them fly.”
“Most of the college and university students Creative teaching not only benefits students but The video What is Creativity? is uploaded onto
I’ve known are overly concerned with earning a rejuvenates educators as well, in turn benefitting Edna’s blog What Ed Said. She has written sever-
grade and subsequently their diploma so they students further. al posts on this topic, including 10 ways to give “That was a wonderful
can get a job and make money. That is probably students control and 10 ways to encourage stu-
the message they get from their parents, too. “I have always said that what I love most about dents to take responsibility for their learning. interaction and some
In that case, thinking of a place of learning as a
primarily creative environment won’t happen.”
teaching is that it allows me to be creative. It’s
so energizing to invent a new project-based unit
Edna also recently posted on the topic of “pro-
voking curiosity”. of the students
There are few colleges and other institutions
that integrates a variety of learning levels and
offers students a huge range of choices,” says
involved still connect
Does she feel that curiosity feeds
where creativity is valued over the acquisition of
knowledge, she says, but now, with the Common
Hogue.
a student’s learning? Can curiosity via Facebook several
Core Standards in place, “the scope of what is “Not only is it a kind of malpractice to use an
old unit over and over again,” she adds, “but
be provoked by creative years later. The kids’
achievable in a classroom will likely be dimin-
ished. It’s not a good time for creative students.” teachers who fail to re-imagine their lessons and exercises? For example, creative reflections here say it
Still, Hogue’s optimism rises to the top of every methods from year to year are stifling their own games as opposed to all! ”
issue, especially when it comes to the role of creative faculties.”
digital platforms in saving creativity. book-learning?
“Curiosity feeds everyone’s learning,” says Edna,
“In my teaching career, creativity was valued only
if the idea could be implemented without add- EDNA SACKSON “so we need to find exciting and engaging ways Edna Sackson
ing to the district’s budget. Or there were times What Ed Said to provoke curiosity. I don’t think ‘exercises’ are
when we’d get the message to ‘create, be risky, the way to do this, rather authentic, real life,
explore,’ but it ended up being only lip service (a Edna Sackson is a Teaching and Learning Co- complex issues, situations and experiences. I’m
checkmark on a principal’s to-do list, perhaps). ordinator at an IB PYP school in Melbourne, a proponent of inquiry learning, where students
Without administrative backing, teachers can Australia. She is an E-mediator for the SOLEs are encouraged to question, wonder, explore, ex-
only go so far.” and SOMEs project, interacting with students in periment, find and solve problems. It comes back
disadvantaged settings in India. As well as this, to student ownership again. I am a fan of Project
Despite the constraints imposed by administra- Edna is the co-organizer and initiator of #pyp- Zero’s Visible Thinking strategies to promoting
tion, Hogue says, it was the online community chat, a fortnightly global Twitter discussion for a culture of thinking in the learning space. Once
she turned to that ultimately renewed her hope. PYP teachers. She is a consultant, workshop fa- learners are aware of thinking, what it is, how it
“When I began blogging about teaching and cilitator and presenter on inquiry learning, global works and how to make it visible, it becomes a
learning, I realized that what I did in my class- connectedness, promoting creativity, integrating habit.”
room resonated with other teachers. I started technology, concept-driven learning as well as
getting comments and other feedback from learning principles. Another of Edna’s recent posts demonstrated
readers, and I saw that blogging was more than students in Australia connecting with students
personal reflection. It was a public conversation, Does Edna think that class time should be more in India via Skype. The post mentioned that they
an alive thing that helped everyone see what responsive to moments when students may get connected especially via music (in this case, a
teaching could be.” a creative urge? Enda says that she does think shared love of international artist Shakira!) Does
so. “I’ve surveyed students to ask them what con- Edna believe that teachers need to come up with
Teachers could learn from each other. By en- ditions encourage their creativity,” she says. more creative ideas like this to connect their
gaging in online communities, the uninspired or “A surprising number said they have creative classrooms with the world?
misguided could connect with the energized and ideas when they are bored in class! I think the
creative, and in that way “mitigate the impact of best learning conditions are when students have “That was a wonderful interaction and some of
a stifling local environment.” ownership of the learning. The more students the students involved still connect via Facebook
several years later. The kids’ reflections here this teacher because he tried to engage his class
say it all! Recently we had a group of younger in creative thinking instead of focusing on exam
students Skype with kids in Japan to inquire into prep!”
inter-connectedness for a geoliteracy unit. When
the teacher stepped back, they too connected What are the top ‘technology’ tools that Edna
through music and did a Gangnam dance togeth- could recommend to a teacher who might be
er!” unsure of how to integrate more creativity into
their classrooms?
Edna continues, “Taking learning beyond the
classroom makes it engaging, purposeful and “Social media,” is Edna’s simple answer. She
real and provides opportunities for all the so jokes, “Can I say social media three times?”
called 21st century skills, for example collabo- “I’ve learned more through blogs, Skype and
ration, creativity, communication, self direction, Twitter (and as a result found more triggers,
problem solving, global awareness.” ideas and opportunities for innovation and
creativity) in the last five years than through
Does Edna believe that creativity has been un- other means in the preceding 25 as an educator.
der-valued in the past, with a focus on academic Why is it not the same for our learners? Here
performance over creative achievements? More are some students’ reflections on the benefits of
importantly, does she think this attitude is shift- blogging, for instance.”
ing?
Recently Edna wrote a post on learning as an
“It’s definitely undervalued,” says Edna. adult. Does she believe that adult learners are
different from young learners?
“My daughter is incredibly “Not in my experience,” says Edna. “These days
creative, but most of her high I work more with adults than with kids. Com-
school years were less than mon misconceptions about how kids learn make
people think that adults learn differently. In most
pleasurable as she struggled to cases, the old style, conventional model of school
fit in with the expectations of the does not promote the best learning. (I’m back to
more ownership again.) Once you crystallize your
school system.“ beliefs about how real learning takes place, you
find there’s not much difference between the
“I don’t have recent experience of university, but desired conditions for young and older learners!”
it doesn’t seem to be a context where creativity is
encouraged to flourish. Especially in those large
undergrad classes where students are expected
to largely listen passively, work through exces- Geraldine Smythe
sive amounts of prescribed reading, then sit
an exam at the end, with no space for creative
Culturebooster
thought (or authentic learning.) No matter how
Geraldine Smythe is the former owner and oper-
much it is shifting in primary and middle schools
ator of an art school called Abrakadoodle. Now
(and it is!), the higher end still seems to be less
she is focusing on a program called cultureboost-
about creativity and more about compliance to
er, a curriculum and integrated crowdfunding
achieve grades.”
platform with a back end suite of teacher tools to
teach business and career skills to various stu-
She continues, “A teacher I know told me he
dents in different age categories.
struggled to get students thinking creatively
because they continually worried about what
A high achiever, passionate about getting tools
was in the exam. One student complained about
to other teachers, Geraldine is now getting ready
to publish a report called “Failing Fast: the key really learn by asking questions and by interject- that’s Evernote. There are veracious levels of
to cultivating a 100% captivated classroom” ing. It is very easy to get off topic, so it is im- user-ship from free through to paid, I use it as a
which aims to keep creative skills at the forefront portant to have a certain structure, a classroom free application on my Android phone (again, I
for helping students to learn to generate skills flow that will be successful for an enquiry-driven have a Google-based smartphone that syncs ev-
that will serve them for a lifetime, in the face of classroom. erything) so Evernote is a really great way for me
changing job and technology opportunities. to be able to collect thoughts when I’m ‘on the
Geraldine has spent a lot of time thinking about “I do think it’s incredibly important that there’s fly’. It acts like a little dictation machine or it can
how creativity impacts the classroom, so does more time allowed for creative thought than the capture pictures, so if I see something that might
she think that class time should be more respon- current teaching method allows. Our current be useful to help teach a concept to somebody
sive to when students get a creative urge? teaching method is in line with the ‘broadcast’ I can snap a shot and then edit it with a caption
She explains, “Even at the earliest level, teach- so many new tools being created She explains, “Project-based learning is all about
ers were coming in, having planned a lesson, every month that teachers might experimenting. We are in this interactive world
and wanting to ‘tell the lesson’ to the students. now and things have sped up so much because
The teachers who were more playful and more be able to utilise and share. people are now able to get immediate feedback.
creative did much better with the students, and In the classroom a student will write a paper,
that’s because they were more in line with how “Another tool that I particularly love as a teach- hand it in by the deadline and then it’s the week-
students really learn – in other words, students er who likes to put my thoughts into place and end. The student might have other thoughts
about that paper that they want to add, but can’t, ting a huge disconnect with students coming out There would be 15 or 20 of us and sometimes
because the deadline has now passed. of college or university and not having the right we’d spilt up into two groups because somebody
skills to be able to perform in the real world, in didn’t want to play ‘cops and robbers’ and some-
“If the student had the chance to have a discus- the jobs that they would really like to be in.” body else didn’t want to play ‘Charlie’s Angels’
sion with their teacher about the paper to gain Geraldine is very armament on one thing. She or whatever the game was at the time. So one
their perspective on certain sections, it would says, “It is extremely important to be able to group would go off and do its own thing. We had
“The thing about probably not be for a week, or even longer! By
then, it was usually just an arbitrary grade the
experiment and teaching to a test is reducing
students to ‘one answer’ rather than allowing
so much playtime! We had hours and hours of
dress ups and role playing with all of the other
project-based student would get back, with maybe only one or
two sentences of commenting here and there.
them to experiment.” Geraldine was one of the
co-founders of a project called Failing Fast, a
kids who lived in the neighbourhood. Everybody
was outside, and now I can see none of that
learning is that the This was not a particularly effective way of learn-
ing because the student was in the moment
system that aims to give teachers the responsi- going on. I live in Texas and it’s hot, so people
bility to make sure their students are given every can be outside but every parent is very worried
student is learning in when they were writing the paper, and quick possible chance to succeed in this rapidly evolv- about safety. I feel this is an adult-driven thing,
real time. If they feedback would have been more helpful to their
learning process. That way, the student can more
ing culture of technology and change. not a kid-driven thing.
How do the restrictions placed on contemporary
attempt to do quickly assess whether their thinking is clear or
accurate or inaccurate.
This teacher mentions how she used to express
her creativity as a child. She says, “I used to love
(Gen Z) children affect them as they grow into
adult learners?
something and it “The thing about project-based learning is that
playing dress ups and role playing! I didn’t know
that’s what it was called at the time, of course. I “The kids are still kids. I think they have been
doesn’t stick and the student is learning in real time. If they at-
tempt to do something and it doesn’t stick and
really enjoyed the theatre of it.” So have times
changed? With the focus on technology and
relegated to smaller, indoor spaces and so now
as a result the most entertaining thing they come
nobody is interested nobody is interested in it (such as in the business social media now, are we failing our kids in terms across is the computer. So, it becomes a real ef-
world) that is very real, very immediate feedback. of basic creative pursuits? fort to get them off the computer. Our son loves
in it (such as in the This says to the student, “something didn’t work”. his computer and we are constantly trying to get
business world) that is The student then has to go back to the drawing
Geraldine says maybe. “It’s even more funda-
mental than that. Students are not allowed to
him to do other, more physical things and to get
outside and play with his friends. It is tough. I
very real, very board to figure something else out. It might just
be that the product is fine, but the business for-
‘play’ anymore. They are ‘scheduled’ to play. That
doesn’t help; that’s an adult schedule. Scheduling
feel it’s a societal thing at this point, everybody is
a bit over-sensitive to this sort of stuff.”
immediate feedback. got to tell people about it, or they didn’t get it out
to enough people. Or maybe they didn’t get the
play-dates, scheduling piano lessons or painting
after school, or French classes – there’s no open
So does Geraldine believe that it’s important for
creative students to have creative experiences
This says to the product out to the right people. Project-based
learning allows the student to go back and iden-
play time! I know that in our neighbourhood early in life in order to express their talents prop-
seven years ago, we moved specifically thinking erly and to thrive?
student, “something tify the exact spots where the problems lie and that there would be a lot of kids there. As it turns
didn’t work.” isolate where they think they have failed. Based
on this immediate feedback, the student can
out, there are only two other children living in
the area who are allowed to go ‘out and about’.
“Personally, I don’t think it’s essential that par-
ents be creative but I definitely think it’s import-
quickly improve what their actions are. It seems to me that all the other parents in the ant that they understand that it’s really more
area are freaked out by having their kids out- about them having a respect for the different
Geraldine Smythe “That ability to experiment is so far removed doors and playing.” personalities that students can have. So, as long
from today’s classroom it’s depressing. Right now as they give their students space to be able to
in the US there is this horrible trend of ‘teaching have some free time to ‘play’ (whether adults
to the test’ – it’s all about making sure students
Child learners grow up to be adult or children) and are open-minded about letting
get the right answer but in the real world, there students, but many adults feel that their students take that ‘play’ to its natural end. I
are multiple right answers. It’s a very different children today may have less av- think that’s far more important than the parents
thing to be prepared and achieve an ‘A’ in a class- being creative themselves. I think that every-
room than it is to be prepared and hit a home enue than ever to express them- body is creative in their own way. Some people
run with a product in the marketplace. selves the way they did decades might think “I am not creative” because they
think that ‘creativity’ is being able to paint, or
We are training people in learning environments ago. something very narrow.”
to do the opposite of what is actually needed in
the marketplace, so the result is that we are get- “When I was a kid, we used to go out in gangs! Geraldine continues, “However, creativity can
come in so many forms. It could mean great could suffer, and in the post- NCLB era, their language and math test scores. And on tests that
communications skills with people, but perhaps teaching evaluations and job security would also don’t reward creative thinking much.”
that person may not be able to draw a picture. suffer.
Creativity comes in loads of different forms. He adds, “Creative students can disrupt instruc-
Teachers just really need to be conscious of the “The new Common Core standards pay at least tion in classrooms because they inject ideas that
differences in their students’ personalities and to lip service to critical and possibly creative think- teachers have not anticipated, and that prompt
know that their students are individuals. Teach- ing. Whether or not these will be measured in events that interfere with curriculum coverage
ers just need to give their students the space to tests that map to the CC standards remains to be plans. But often, creative students (in turn) stim-
express that.” seen. Don’t hold your breath.” ulate their classmates (and we hope their teach-
ers) in positive ways, and teachers could take
Catterall has a few ideas on how teachers can advantage of this.”
foster creativity in their students.
James Catterall Catterall also believes in the importance of rec-
CRoC blog “First, I’d say doing this well would be very worth- ognizing all types and levels of creativity in the
while. Second, I’d say that students simply like to classroom. In his new book, The Creativity Play-
James Catterall is Professor Emeritus of UCLA’s be creative and are creative in many ways much book: A Guide to our Creativity Debates, contains
Education Department. He has a Ph.D. in Educa- of the time. In a learning environment, students 29 short chapters, or briefings, on topics that
tion Policy Analysis from Stanford University and benefit from reasons to be creative (for example, are in active circulation these days. “An import-
co-manages the Centers for Research on Creativ- encouragement by teachers) and opportunities ant point I make in the book is that focusing
ity (CRoC) project with Professor Anne Bamford to be creative (for example, being allowed time on extraordinary creativity (Leonardo Da Vinci,
and runs the CRoC blog. His research interests during instruction to explore ideas and make Steve Jobs, the inventors of the Swiffer or Post-it)
include arts and human development; arts and connections to what they are learning). blinds us to the creativity so important to all of
neuroscience; evaluation of the arts, especially us in our regular lives. And where technological
in joining the visual and performance arts with “I use the terms Means, Motive, and Opportunity invention is concerned, we would best focus on
academic subjects; education policy implemen- when it comes to spawning more creative think- our using technologies in creative ways, no so
tation; and issues related to children at risk of ing in a classroom or lecture hall. The means much on inventing the next block-buster gizmo.
school failure. Catterall is also an expert in cre- for being creative can be as little as one’s mind, Billions participate in the first, a thousand in the
ativity in science learning and STEM programs. but it also includes tools and workspaces. Moti- second.”
In response to our question about the “creativ- vation can be simple intrinsic, natural curiosity,
ity crisis,” Catterall said his own research hasn’t or chances to perform, and various extrinsic When we asked Catterall how he and his team
reflected such a phenomenon. rewards, such as winning a design competition measure creativity, he said, “Creativity is defined
or earning high marks in chemistry. And as for in different ways by different people, which pres-
“We don’t know whether such a decline has opportunity? Space and time to play.” ents issues for those who want to measure cre-
occurred through any research evidence. The ativity in any global sense. But underlying most
relevant teaching population [my team] might Catterall would also advise definitions is the idea that creativity involves the
study is 50 million in any teaching year - even production of novel ideas and designs that have
more if change over time is the focus. The sam- educators to spend time being some value.
pling would be herculean. That would be way more responsive to moments when
beyond NAEP sampling and the efforts of NORC “Our work starts with basic cognitive develop-
for NELS, ELS, and other national surveys that students may get creative urges. ment that benefits from hatching ideas that con-
probe up to 25,000 students. tribute to learning -- therefore ideas novel and
“Creative thoughts often come from novel associ- valuable at a personal level. Individual capacity
“However, what the learning institutions are de- ations. We are making associations to language, and motivation for coming up with novel ideas
manding in the way of language arts and mathe- events, people, and things in our environment all that have value is measurable, although mea-
matics proficiency as measured by standardized the time. Most of these are subconscious. They sures in one domain may or not predict creative
tests is not promising for creative thinking nor depend on awareness, understandings, and to tendencies in another.
includes any measures of the same. This sug- great degree, on behind the scenes connecting.
gests that responsive teachers would not want Prompting for associations through instructional “The standard traditional instrument that goes
to waste much time on creative elements with- designs is important, and at the same time diffi- after creative thinking skills is the Torrance Test
in their subjects. Their institutions’ test scores cult, for teachers who are held accountable for of Creative Thinking, which appeared in 1964. It
relies mainly on subjects’ answers to questions things that are new and valuable, and to solve he’s not so sure that contrasts between value
probing their self-beliefs about the fluency and problems. And we are always thirsty for better placed on creativity during college and later on,
originality of their thinking, and the flexibility of technologies to do these things - which of course in the workplace, is a hugely important issue.
their approaches to problem solving. Measures keeps the technology inventors busy.” “I think a main issue here is the role of human
on the resulting scales have been tested for creativity in our economy. I think creativity en-
external validity with positive results, but quite With regard to home environment, Catterall is ters in the many ways we put ourselves to work
some time ago and with few actual studies. not convinced that children need creative par- that are under-realized and under-appreciated.
ents to be creative themselves, simply because Again, creativity in the workplace is not all, or
“The Next Generation Creativity Survey (Centers he has not seen any studies of it. “My instincts even principally, about inventing new products.
“First,” he says, “we for Research on Creativity, Los Angeles and Lon- say that creative parents are helpful, though,”
are bombarded with don U.K. www.croc-lab.org) builds on the Tor-
rance Test to add performance on actual creative
he says. “They can contribute to the means,
motives, and opportunities their kids have to be
It’s solving problems that come up frequently
for most of us -- eliminating workflow bottle-
technologies that do tasks -- not just self reports, and enlists humans
to score students’ creative products. The NGCS
creative. And modeling creative behavior almost
certainly spawns creative thinking.”
necks, mediating disputes in the customer lines
at McDonalds, helping with an on-the-job injury,
both mundane and also measures motivation and attitudes related
to creativity; creative self-efficacy, collaboration He also doubts that negative early childhood
scheduling staff to keep people productive and
happy, organizing the executive suite to avert
important things in our skills, empathy orientations. The Walt Disney
Company commissioned us to create the survey
experiences can stunt creativity, again based on
lack of evidence.
jealousy or to place leaders where they perform
best. Creative problem solving can benefit these
lives. And they keep (or test) and we piloted it during 2012-2013 with and thousands of situations at work. And in
about 1,200 students in 9 programs across the
coming, like brooms nation - in art, science, graphic design, theatre,
“We wrote the preschool learning foundations
and curriculum frameworks in the visual and
home and community of course.
“I was teaching teens who had been identified He says yes. “Every person is different – that is
clear. We need to be sensitive to the needs of then they jump to something else. We are calling we were just talking about what my role should
each student. One of the powerful things with this a ‘second iteration’ and they move to, say, a be. One of the complaints about our book is that
The Flipped Classroom is that it allows you to ‘mastery classroom’ or possibly a ‘project-based we only cited two people, me and my co-author,
personalise the learning for each student. The classroom’ or even an ‘inquiry-driven classroom’. Aaron Sams. It was just our story. Some people
subtitle is, “Reach Every Student in Every Class, said that the book was not a sufficiently academ-
Everyday.” Teachers are able to talk to each stu- There really is a second step – we want teachers ic book, that it had no validity.
dent each day and in those conversations they not to stop at the Flipped Classroom but to go
get to know the learners better and to figure through it to these deeper learning strategies. “Part of me thought that there was some truth
out ‘what makes them tick.’ As they did this, they “For example, in the second half of the book we to that. We are not academic. We are a couple of
were able to personalise the experience for their
students – and some people do need more TLC –
do talk about our first foray into flipped learn-
ing (we call it the Flipped Mastery Model) the
teachers with a good idea. This new contact said
to me, “Jon, don’t worry about that. What you
“This is the creative
it may be because they are artistic or maybe they
are needier for other reasons.
students don’t all watch the same video on the
same night – they watch the video that’s ap-
need to do is be the story teller.” So when I was
asked to do a radio show, I quickly said that what
generation and if you
“We’ve moved our institutions towards stan-
propriate for them and they move through the
content at a flexible pace. When they get to the
I want to do is tell the stories, so now I am just
trying to find people who have a good story to
do research on the
dardisation and I believe we need to move more end of the unit they take a test, but in this case, tell about the Flipped Class. jobs that are popping
towards ‘personalisation’ of the learning experi- instead of just taking the test and getting what
ence for each student. At the moment, curricu- they get they actually have to show that they “I ask them to basically tell me how they gone up these days there
lums are trying to fit everyone in the same box,
learning at the same pace. That’s not the way life
have mastered the content by scoring a good
score.
though this transformation. Eventually I want
to get some students on. I’ve heard so many are many more in the
is. Students are different and we need to treat
them as individuals not as a collective. “If they don’t, they have to stay there until they
amazing stories. I heard one yesterday about a
teacher who is teaching in a rough situation and
creative fields.”
learn it. This is particularly useful for us because her students have been crazy successful with her
Jon goes on to give a description of what a it’s very ‘building’. Let’s look at chemistry as an flipped math class.
Flipped Classroom is. example, if you don’t learn ‘A’ then ‘B’ is hard Jon Bergman
and ‘C’ is impossible. So in this case, if the stu- “In terms of other people having multi-media
He says, “Let me give you two definitions. What is dent doesn’t get the content then they tend to avenues like that, the radio show was really
commonly understood as the Flipped Classroom get lost. However, in a mastery class, they stay good for me, and I think good for a lot of people.
is what we are now trying to call Flipped Class until they actually learn it. So, that’s what we call Teachers really need to step up and put them-
101. In that class, the students typically (but not ‘second iteration’ in our flipped learning environ- selves out there and say whatever it is that they
always) watch a video at home for their direct in- ment. need to say. If you’ve got a message you should
struction, their ‘lecture’ if you will, and then they share it! I think you owe it to the bigger educa-
do their homework in class. tional community.
Jon also participates in a radio
According to a major San Diego publication, show called The Flip Side Radio So, does Jon believe that adult students should
“The model has been embraced by some local Show on BAM radio. Does Jon be engaged in more ‘creative play’ when learn-
instructors who say it gives them more time for ing?
meaningful learning encounters, which pays off think that more teachers should be
with students who are more involved and knowl- looking at multi-media opportu- Jon says, yes. “I think so. This is the creative gen-
edgeable.” eration and if you do research on the jobs that
nities like this to share information are popping up these days there are many more
Jon says teachers are finding success with the and ideas? in the creative fields. It used to be, “Art student?
concept. “We find that after maybe a year, all the Good luck getting a job!” Now, if you are an art
students watch the same video on Tuesday night Jon explains, “The idea behind the radio show student you are in high demand because of the
they all do the same activity on Wednesday and was to tell the story of the Flipped Classroom. I design elements of websites and apps now.
it’s not a whole lot different except you change was sitting at a pub in England after we keynoted Jon was recently in Iceland, giving talks on
the place where the instruction takes place. at a very big conference last January, and I was Flipped Learning. Does he believe that some
chatting with this Scottish gentleman who was countries may be more ‘ahead of the ball’ than
He further explains, “In Flipped Learning – teach- a big-wig in Scottish education at one point and others when it comes to creative learning strate-
ers do the Flipped Learning for about a year and gies?
“Yes,” says Jon. “It seems like certain parts of These institutions teach students how to follow
Europe are actually a little behind. In their edu- instructions to the letter, and how to get the right
cational field, they seem to have a textbook, it’s answer -- what psychologists call “convergent
rote learning. Recently, however, I was in Iceland thinking.” This means that the most successful
and this was very much discussed. In Iceland, students are the ones who do the best job of
they are really valuing creativity and so I do avoiding mistakes. And yet, creativity researchers
believe that there is something cultural about have demonstrated that mistakes and dead ends
that. I am no expert on culture but I think there are essential to the creative process.
are things culturally that allow for more creativ-
ity. I’m not sure that I could say, “This country is “The world is changing more quickly. 18-22 year
ahead of that country” but some cultures value olds used to find a job and stay at it for 40 years.
different things. Cultures that do not appreciate Now people switch jobs multiple times over the
the creative aspect may be left behind.” course of their lives. And with so much automa-
tion, the jobs that don’t require creativity are
going away.”
Dr. R. Keith Sawyer Sawyer also cites the outsourcing phenomenon
Creativity and Innovation as a reason behind the growing demand for cre-
ativity. Jobs that were once available at home are
Dr. R. Keith Sawyer, a professor of psychology now being forced overseas.
and education at Washington University in St.
Louis, is one of the country’s leading scientif- It’s time for places of learning to catch up.
ic experts on creativity. His new book GROUP “I would agree that there’s a mismatch between
GENIUS shows us how to be more creative in the way today’s learning institutions are de-
collaborative group settings, how to change our signed and the growing need for creativity,” he
organizations for the better, and how to tap into says. “We need to move not slowly and incre-
our own reserves of creativity. After receiving mentally but more radically towards fostering
his computer science degree from MIT in 1982, creativity.”
Sawyer began his career with a two-year stint
designing videogames for Atari. From 1984 to
1990, he worked as a management consultant
The first issue is defining and mea-
on innovative technologies; clients included suring creativity. Sawyer doesn’t
Citicorp, AT&T, and U.S. West. He has been a
jazz pianist for over 20 years, and spent several
believe in a general quotient like
years playing piano with Chicago improv theater the Torrance Test CQ (creativity
groups. His research has been featured on CNN, quotient). “The most appropriate
Fox News, TIME Magazine, and other media. A
popular speaker, he lectures to corporations, way to teach and assess creativ-
associations, and universities around the world ity,” he says, “is in specific do-
on creativity and innovation.
mains.”
In Sawyer’s view, the “creativity crisis” has less
Creativity research shows that you get the best
to do with a decline in creative thinking than a
results when you teach creativity within the con-
growing demand for it.
text of a specific discipline (rather than teaching
one “general creativity” course). This means
Our learning institutions were designed a hun-
that if you want creative physicists, then your
dred years ago, when most workers would take
physics department classes need to be changed;
factory jobs that valued consistency, standardiza-
if you want creative computer scientists, then
tion, and subservience to authority, Sawyer says.
the computer science curriculum needs to be “What about musical to a wide international audience. Like many
changed. If you just add a three-credit creativ- other teachers, Michael believes that class time
ity course, but then students get the same old performance? You’re taught to should be more responsive to students’ urges to
memorize-and-regurgitate curriculum in their memorize sheet music and learn.
STEM classes, the creativity course won’t be able
to overcome the uncreative STEM teaching. perform well. Where’s the creativity He explains, “I think for this reason and many
Creativity assessment, Sawyer says, should be in that?” other places of learning need to be more open
tailored to each subject. and flexible on the use of class time. This goes
Above all else, creativity is hard work. “People for the individual class period as well as the
Sawyer also believes there’s no such thing as an who are successful creators have a lot of ener- length of school days. We have got to get away
“uncreative” person. Everyone has innate poten- gy.” They also tend to be more aware of their from 45 minutes for every subject. Some things
tial. Even students whose parents don’t value surroundings than others, more mindful than on take less time and some take more. I hope we
creativity are somewhat immune from zombifi- autopilot. are headed towards a time where individual stu-
cation. dent’s needs are the priority and it’s not about
The role of technology, Sawyer says, is “neutral,” wrapping the lesson up before the bell rings for
“Children are quite resilient,” he says. “It’s im- meaning it depends on how it is used. Just be- next period.”
possible to squash creativity completely, and it’s cause we no longer solve complex math equa-
never too late to cultivate it.” tions by hand doesn’t make us any less creative. Recently, Michael wrote a post about wanting to
In fact, it makes us more creative. “When we be a professional ball player, where he admitted
Sawyer, a father of two, is a good creative par- have computers to automate things, we spend that he never dreamed of becoming a school
ent. He considers himself part of a generation fewer hours on the boring, mundane things, administrator! So, does he think it’s important to
of parents who were taught to be encouraging freeing up more time for creativity.” tell younger students to ‘live their dreams’ and
and to foster their children’s creative impulses. In his new book, Zig Zag: The Surprising Path to ‘do what you love’ or should teachers be telling
“There’s a common accepted wisdom,” he says, Greater Creativity, Sawyer explores the notion them to ‘do what you’re good at’ and ‘hone in on
“to praise your son or daughter instead of saying, that the creative process is so unpredictable that, the career you will be successful in’?
‘That doesn’t look like a drawing of a cow to me.’” were you to chart the career path of someone to-
He understands the challenges many parents day, it would resemble a sort of zig-zag pattern. Michael believes that it’s still important for
face, though. “My son is at a summer camp He mentions the work of Stephen Tepper, who younger students (and older ones) to follow
learning video game design,” he admitted, “but, researches and writes about creative careers. their dreams. He says, “Yes. Everyone should do
you know, we had to pay money to send him something they love and not something for a pay
there.” “It’s not that people shift from being a comedian check. This is easier said than done, but it should
to a physicist,” he says. He then tells the story of be every young person’s dream.”
Less affluent parents may not be able to expose a conference at Vanderbilt University where he
younger students to creative programs and re- listened to comedian Lewis Black talk about his There have been studies that indicate that cre-
sources. This is why it is so important for places career. Black had studied to become a playwright ative students (and creative people in general)
of learning to do their part. “It’s up to public at Yale Drama School, and then, at forty years have a tendency to over-react to stimulation. The
schools,” Sawyer says, “to close the creativity old, decided to become a stand-up comedian. ‘sensitive artist’ stereotype is one that most peo-
gap.” “There’s coherence to it. It builds upon itself.” ple are familiar with. Michael has said that he
You can read more of Keith Sawyer’s work on his has encountered these types of learners before.
He fully supports the “creative expression” re- blog, Creativity and Innovation. He says, “I think as educators we do a much bet-
quirements currently being enforced at a grow- ter job identifying those students and promoting
ing number of institutions across the U.S. Stan- their growth than we did 20 years ago. I believe
ford and Carnegie Mellon, for example, require we do a much better job at recognizing individual
creativity courses as part of their curriculum
starting this fall.
Michael Smith strengths than we did when I was a kid.”
“Unfortunately, it has been undervalued,” she She says, “Creativity does come in spurts and Steve has pointed out that there are tests on
agrees, “and with excessive emphasis on stan- can be accompanied by dry spells. As a facilita- divergent thinking in children and adults. For
dardized test performance, creativity (viewed as tor of learning, my best piece of advice involves example people are instructed to think about
time consuming) has been relegated to enrich- allowing students to talk with others about their how many uses there are for a house brick or a
ment or elective status. The shift is over-due, ideas. The synergy between like minds, and even paperclip.
although more emphasis has been directed opposing thoughts, can stimulate thinking and
toward curriculum programming reform.” concepts. Human beings are social beings and
ideally “grow” when stimulated by the readings,
Steve says, “When you are five,
There has been controversy and discussion over writings, dialogs, and interactions with others. you can think of hundreds,
the last few years about the increasing pressures When we isolate students in learning environ- because there is no limit to your
of standardized tests. How do you think the rise ments, we deprive them from essential inter-
of standardized tests affect creativity? and intra-personal development.” imagination but somehow by the
time you are 14 years old you
Sandra says, “In the last 28 years of teaching,
I have seen substantial decline in the ability of can only think of about ten. And
students to think critically, creatively, and in- Steve Wheeler as an adult, you can think of even
dependently. Specifically, in the last decade, Learning with ‘e’s less, because it seems almost as if
learners have been conditioned to only find the
“correct” answer, and are hesitant to take risks, The Learning with ‘e’s blog focuses on technolo- school has knocked the creativity
hence the decline of creativity. gy for the classroom. Steve Wheeler is a British
academic, author, speaker and learning technol-
out of you!”
Personally, I’ve seen students’ stress levels rise ogist. He is the Associate Professor of Learning So what does Steve put this down to? “I think
when assigned creative projects – they continu- Technology in the Faculty of Education at the that’s partly to do with the kind of ‘factory’ or the
ally want to know what the final outcome should University of Plymouth where he teaches on a ‘industrialised model’ of education,” he says, “but
look like, rather than become enthusiastic about number of undergraduate and postgraduate it’s also to do with other things as well, like peer
the potentials. It makes a seasoned educators teacher education programs. He also tweets un- pressure and family life and so on.” So does he
disillusioned about the state of education.” der the handle @timbuckteeth and has nearly 23 think that technology could help with this?
000 twitter followers at last count. “I think technology is not the only answer but it
Does Sandra consider herself a creative person?
will help young people to be more creative and
“Yes!” she says. Steve believes that technology can be a major
to put those creative acts “into being” through Steve has a gentle warning for his co-educators, about this? You know, we’re changing our mod-
tools like cameras and mobile phones, for in- however. “They also need to be careful that they els.’ I told them, ‘You’re not changing them fast
stance.” don’t overstep the line – it’s like ‘down at the enough!’ I’ve withdrawn all my support for closed
disco’ – you go into Facebook and you try to use journals I’m going for open access journals now,
Steve is quite an advocate for game playing, their language and you get it wrong and you look I’m going for blogging now, because it gains you
citing the fact that it can help students retain stupid. So don’t try to ‘get down with the kids’ but a bigger audience.”
the information and engage with it in new ways. do try to understand what they are doing!”
However, it seems in the current school system, The world of publishing information has dras-
the older a student gets, the less “playtime” they Some critics of the genre have mentioned that tically changed as new technologies have
are given. blogging is a ‘disposable’ form of journalism. emerged: “For example, I produced two papers
Steve disagrees. “I don’t think it is disposable; I in 2006 and one of them took three years to pub-
Does this educator think that it could be possible think blogs are in a new culture, this new culture lish in a closed journal. Three years is unaccept-
(and beneficial) for secondary students and adult that has emerged. I wrote a book on this a few able in any sense, let alone the field of technolo-
and university/college students to receive more years ago called Connected Minds, Emerging Cul- gy where things are changing. So I produced this
time to ‘play’ while learning, for example, with tures: Cybercultures in Online Learning and in it paper, it was reviewed and (the publisher) sent it
games and active exercises? we talked about a number of emerging cultures back to me. It took them 18 months to review it,
– things that are changing the paradigm, things because they couldn’t find two reviewers (would
Steve says, yes. “Absolutely, and in fact, I do I that are disrupting what we’ve considered to be you believe!) that would look at it and I sent it
give my students a lot of playtime I give them the social norms up until now. back to them with the corrections fairly quickly.
new tools to play with I give them new ideas to It then took them another 18 months for it to
kick around. It’s a good way to experiment with And how does Steve think this will this affect appear in paper because of the backlog.”
making mistakes. What better way than finding mainstream publishing? “I have to say that a lot
out what those errors could be, except in a simu- of publishers are getting worried, a lot of record Steve feels (understandably) that this is an exam-
lation, or a game?” producers and film makers are getting worried ple of a wasted opportunity. “It was coming up to
because their territory, their hegemony, is being the time of our research excellence framework
Steve points out that simulations and computer eroded by these new technologies.” exercise; this is the time of year when every-
programs are often used to train many medical, body starts publishing,” he explains. “The second
armed forces and health students. These simu- Steve says, “People are coming in paper was sent to an open access journal and it
lation ‘games’ allow them to practise their skills was reviewed by three people, openly. There was
with games-based learning. These students can and publishing for themselves, this no blindness; I knew who they were, they knew
make their mistakes, and learn from them with- kind of Levi Strauss notion of bri- who I was, and all the names were open.”
out having to endanger themselves or others.
colage that started with the punk Steve continues, “It was ‘open review’ and there-
In the past, it could be said that initially people era of the 70s and the music and fore had a kind of transparency. I am attracted
thought computers were frivolous, gaming was to the openness of journals and blogs; you can
just for fun, blogging wasn’t a serious way to fashion industries.” usually see who is writing. Both versions of my
write and facebook was to be avoided. Times are papers were published online as were the review
changing, in particular, for advocates of social “People started doing it (publishing) themselves, comments from the journal reviewers, as were
media. Is technology opening us up to how we I was a punk musician and we created our own my responses to them.”
look at these ‘more disposable’ forms of creativ- record label because we just couldn’t break into
ity? Does Steve feel that some teachers are slow the mainstream, so we sold our own vinyl disks, Steve parallels this to more traditional publish-
to take up these new technologies? and distributed them ourselves. We created our ing: “My closed journal has had 36 citations to
own fanzines and so on, we didn’t go though any date and my open access journal has had 550.
Steve says, “Facebook is important because publishers.” There’s no comparison. Anybody who reads
it’s where young people are and if you want to that paper can see where it comes from and the
know where young people are and what they are The educator continues, “In today’s world things provenance of it, how it was responded to, and
doing you need to go to Facebook. Any lecturer are different. One publisher came to me recent- so on. For me, that’s the future of publishing
or teacher who is avoiding the use of Facebook ly and said to me, ‘Steve, we’re very concerned academically. Forget the closed journals, they are
because they think it’s frivolous...well, they need because you are no longer writing, reviewing dead.”
to rethink and change their minds!” or editing for any closed journals – can we talk
Blogs, journals, papers, social media, convention- So, does Steve find that the students are teach- related to each other and if you back to the great awards, including the Top 50 School Technology
al news: there are so many creative resources in ing the teachers about these technologies in classic Greek educators they educated students blogs, the Top Reading and Writing blog, and the
the marketplace now, it might be fair to say that some cases? When answering, Steve cites the in every which way all the time constantly asking Top 40 Most Trusted Education blogs. Nash also
many educators may not know where to begin opinion of an American-Canadian novelist: questions.” received an award for being one of the Top 50
when sourcing resources for their students. If “William Gibson said, ‘The future is already here Education Innovators on the Web.
an educator wanted to try to get started with but it’s just not evenly distributed.’ What he Steve goes on to mention another example of
new media in a classroom situation, what would means by that is, not everybody will adopt every- modern ‘deconstructed’ education practices. Nash says she has read Dr. Kim’s report and
Steve recommend? thing, there’s always going to be innovators and “There’s also a school in England called Skipton finds it pretty compelling.
early adopters and late adopters and laggards.” High School for Girls, which is innovating in dif-
“Firstly, I would suggest some kind of social me- ferent ways too. It’s a girls’ engineering college, “The crux of the issue is that we’ve made
dia link,” he says. “Obviously, you need hand held “My belief is that we all have a huge potential, it’s the only one I know of anywhere in the world. child-rearing a factory in many ways, and have
devices too, so those are the two things I would to be who we want to be, to make sense of the It’s a secondary school and engineering is at the completely industrialized education in public
choose.” Steve mentions that, “Handheld devices world in new and creative ways to be creative heart of everything they do. This relates to de- schools, where teachers and administrators live
where students can move around are essential. in terms of inventiveness and in terms of how sign, ergonomics, how to use technology, how to in dread of underperforming on standardized
The students should be able to take the portable we connect with each other. I utterly reject the apply science; all that is within their curriculum. tests,” she says. “The consequences are noth-
devices with them, so they are not tethered to a learning styles theories that exist that say, ‘He’s They’ll do things like study physics with music, or ing to be scoffed at -- after all, if you miss your
table or desk. It’s important that they can move an analyst, she’s a reflector, he’s a pragmatist.’ art with science, or maths with English.” target, you’ll potentially lose funding for your
around the space...they can go outside...they can Each of us has the ability to all of those things in school, which consequently means job losses
use the hand held device anywhere,” Steve feels different contexts we just need to give people Steve was there fairly recently. He says, “I asked and other punitive actions.”
that these things are the most essential to con- the opportunities to express themselves in these one of the girls, she was only about 13 years old, However, Nash believes Dr. Kim’s findings might
temporary learning. ways.” during a presentation, ‘What was it about doing benefit from a little investigation.
all these curriculum things together that you
“I think Howard Gardener (an American develop- like?’ and she said ‘It helps me to understand the “Would everyone agree with her metrics? Are
“Whether it’s a mobile phone, an mental psychologist) has the most appropriate world better.’ they simply supporting a convenient narrative
iPad, Android, whatever it is, it model where he talks about multiple intelligence that is, at its heart, a jeremiad and vaguely apoc-
doesn’t matter! As long as they – that each of us can specialise according to what Steve, like many other educators is spreading alyptic? I would argue that one problem may be
we want to be. But we all have all of those ele- the messages of new media in learning to other in how we’re measuring creativity. If creativity
can gain access to all the same ments inside us.” students and teachers who are ready to step up means finding unusual and unexpected ways
resources as everybody else,” he to new challenges in education. to do a task, or make something into existence,
Looking towards the year 2020, could the class- which has at its heart a unique process or out-
explains. room of the future have one kid at the front come, then aren’t we by definition unable to
studying math and one kid at the back studying assess creativity with an uncreative instrument
“The second thing I would recommend is some Shakespeare? Is that a good idea, or is there Susan Smith Nash or evaluation tool?”
kind of social media link. I advocate Twitter, in something to be said for collaborative group E-Learning Queen
fact I have Twitter walls in my classroom so we learning? Although she doesn’t necessarily buy the pitch
can converse not just with everybody within the Susan Smith Nash has a diverse background. that creativity has declined in the human popula-
group (with the back channel that Twitter offers) Steve says that this is already in effect in some She is both an energy industry professional with tion, Nash says she thinks “our socialization pro-
but also, we converse with experts outside the places. “There’s a school in Auckland called Alba- graduate experience in economics and an active cesses can punish deviance. After all, by all qual-
room, somewhere else in the world.” Steve has ny Senior High School which is a very innovative e-learning consultant with a Ph.D. in English. In itative measures, creativity is deviant. It deviates
been very progressive with adopting this tech- school. They were one of the first schools I’ve e-learning since the early 1990s, Nash is involved from the norm. In that, it requires freedom.”
nology. seen to do this. Albany has open spaces, open in e-learning and hybrid learning at universities, Even what we often call “creativity” is simply con-
software, open ‘bring your own device’ policies corporations, and not-for-profits. Her books formity, she says. “Being truly creative, and hav-
“Twitter is really cool because they can actual- and the teachers there all teach in the same include E-Learning Success (2012); E-Learners ing creative solutions and creative self-expres-
ly converse with the authors of books they are space and the students are allowed to move Survival Guide (2010); Moodle 1.9 Teaching Tech- sion are not always recognized as such because
reading,” Steve says. “A lot of people are locked around between classes as they wish.” niques (Packt Pub, 2010); Klub Dobrih Dijanj (Lju- we tend to have conformist ways of thinking
into my Twitter stream. I have over twenty thou- bljana, 2009); and Excellence in College Teaching about creative processes and output.”
sand followers and when they see me tweet He continues: “This way, you are seeing a break- and Learning (CC Thomas, 2008), co-authored
something out from one of the students, they ing down of the silos of curriculum, breaking with George Henderson. She is currently writing When we asked her about the role of technology
will respond and it comes up live on the screen down of the compartmentalisation, which is a book on The Fourth Industrial Revolution. Her in creativity, she said, “I like to think of various
and the students think that it’s amazing!” false anyway. It shouldn’t exist as all subjects are blog, E-Learning Queen, has received multiple philosophers and their stance on technology
when I think of the role of technology in creativi- When we asked her if this technology could be of trust, and unconditional love (which is not the
ty. Here are a few: used to measure creativity, Nash said, “People same as accepting all kinds of behavior). Rejec-
think that creativity is measurable. Isn’t that all tion can never be a factor. People do not take
“Heidegger: Technology is about finding ways you need in order to develop instruments and creative risks when they are suffering from fear.”
to understand the essential ontology of things to measure whatever it is you’ve decided is the Nash says creativity is vital in her own life and
and the cosmos. Technology reveals ‘being in phenomenal manifestation of creativity? profession. “It’s the key to my success,” she says.
the world’ -- it makes things possible to unveil “I have to create - and, I have to get a little messy
themselves, and to understand the ‘frames’ in “The problem is, the moment you define creativ- as I do so, because I have to be aware of how
which the world is truly built. Technologies let ity and then make it measurable, you defuse its knowledge is being used, why it’s used, how it’s
something come forth; they open up reality into power, and destroy the magic of what it is that measured, why and how it’s useful -- all that is
something bigger, deeper, and more profound. elevates creativity to the truly life-engendering. considered ‘education’ - but it’s really a tech-
They teach us about the world. All cynicism aside, creativity should be rewarded, nology -- a great unveiling and revealing of the
especially if it manifests itself in the germination frames of consciousness and ontological possi-
“Marcuse: Marcuse looks at technology as a of new life, marked by unusual pathways, proce- bilities in the world and of the world.”
form of control, and suggests it controls our dures, products, etc.”
lives. That said, it’s easy to see how Marcuse was In terms of teaching, Nash finds herself first ad-
responding to those he viewed as technocrats, Nash shared a few practical tips for educators vocating a vision, and then defusing the pressure
and the way that the factories of the 20th centu- looking to foster creativity in their classrooms: by introducing the absurd and the experimental.
ry controlled workers, and essentially dehuman- “It’s fun to see just what we can do. We start with
ized them.” a vision, and then we gather around and see just
“I’d advocate a new approach what might be brought into the frame -- with the
Nash says she thinks it’s clear that information to socialization -- it would involve goal of pulling the curtain back and revealing
technology both unveils the world and also ‘inverse role-playing’ -- role-play- an entire new body of existential scaffolding. It
exercises control over our minds, behaviors, and makes us accept ourselves and our bonds with
destinies, insofar as human beings can be con- ing upside down and to go back- others -- we must not judge; on the other hand,
trolled. wards in processes, to break ste- let’s judge as harshly as we feel -- after all, it’s the
subjectivity within our own essence that causes
“Given that toys are very preprogrammed these reotypes.” us to passionately believe in our own emotional
days, particularly those based on computers responses. They’re valid. On the other hand,
(tablets, smartphones, etc.),” Nash says, “it al- “I’d also advocate a great deal of ‘alone time’ perhaps they are not. Society decides. So, why
lows a child to be passive and let the device do -- allowing students to think by themselves and not conform? The reason is simple. Survival re-
the creating for him or her. On the other hand, have their own private journals, projects, math quires risk and risk-taking, and creative produc-
a good video game allows a child to envision equations, chemistry experiments, engineering tion involves the very essence of risk.”
new worlds and to consider the possibilities that creations (robots running amok!) and more.
magic can happen and that infinite agency is just “I’d also advocate reading and listening to short As far as “creative people” are concerned, Nash
around the corner. Superhero status is democra- stories, tales, and novels from the 19th century. believes we should abandon the notion of the
tized.” That was a time of great self-reflection due to overly sensitive artist who reacts impulsively to
rapid change -- both in the beginning of the 19th bouts of inspiration.
What are the implications for education and century and at the end of the century.”
e-learning? “Creative people are very disciplined and
Flipped classrooms are also part of Nash’s pre- self-regulated,” she says. “Otherwise, they would
“They’re pretty profound. It places within those scription: “The beauty of the flipped classroom not have the ability to practice, practice, practice
who would define knowledge (via standards and is that it encourages action and experimentation -- which is what really is required in order to per-
assessment) a deep desire to use technology to in the classroom. Reading, media, and practice form at all, with any assurance of a recognizable
control all aspects of the learning and the assess- assessments have been done in anticipation of outcome.”
ment processes.” class time, which is designed for the application
of knowledge.” As far as background or home environment is
“Thus, the race is on,” she says. “Whoever creates the concerned, Nash says, “I think that parents who
most amazing technology controls the world. Is that As far as the student-teacher relationship goes, understand the importance of creative expres-
the case? Based on behaviors and beliefs, I’d say ‘yes.” Nash says, “There needs to be a predictable level sion are vital. On the other hand, ‘creative’ par-
ents may unconsciously imprint the student with used against teachers. We all build up relation- to me. Really, this was a form of collaboration,
his or her own form of conformity and unwilling- ships with our students and sometimes in social and it was very good.”
ness to try new things.” media that relationship can become confusing.
Many school districts and parents take it the However, it was not always perfect, says Whitby.
In addition, “a child who has been abused, ne- wrong way.” “The problem would come in if I said to them, ‘I
glected, or in the midst of radical uncertainty want to use technology to present some kind of
(war, constant moving, lack of bonding) may not Whitby mentions that not all teachers and stu- Shakespearean lesson.’ At that point, those nine
thrive if they are pressured to demonstrate ‘cre- dents use social media effectively. “On the other people were usually not as well-versed in tech-
“Today, we don’t need ativity.’ What they need is tantamount to a kind
of Maslow’s hierarchy -- before embarking on the
side of that, there are also educators who are
‘not smart’ because they do occasionally ‘do the
nology as I was,” he says. “So I could not collab-
orate with them about an essential need that I
a publisher. The requisite risk-taking required for creative en- wrong thing’ and unfortunately the media seizes had.”
deavors, he or she will need to feel solid, stable, on the people who do the wrong thing as if that
computer is a supported.” is the norm and it isn’t. I’ve read blogs of teach- The education landscape is constantly shifting.
publisher, so these Finally, we asked Nash if she thinks graduates
ers who were knocking parents and making fun
of their students on their blog and I feel that’s
What skills are teachers emphasising towards
2015 more than they did in previous genera-
students are able to and professionals value creativity more than
they did when they were in college, and, if so,
just not right. It’s dumb! There was one teacher
in particular that the press picked up on, and as
tions? Are teachers focusing on creativity more
or less?
publish at will and it how that can be remedied. a result many administrators started coming up
with policies to prevent teachers from contacting Whitby believes that new technology is much
doesn’t have to be “Education focused narrowly on the acquisition students through social media. So that scared more a factor in teachers’ rooms discussions
of a single skill set has a very short shelf life quite a few people off.” today than it ever was. “Technology has changed
text, it could be music, unless it’s combined with more of a meta-edu- the way we do things,” he explains.
“I consider myself a creative person,” Nabors By way of advice, Nabors says to “start off small”
says. “I am 39 years old and I know that I can and “encourage, validate, and reward projects/
overreact to stimulation. I can get super jazzed products that are being created.” Even if a student’s
about something and I better jump on it right work does not quite make the mark, but reflects
then because when the excitement is gone, I effort and personal investment, you have to en-
no longer want to do the project. My students courage them or they will not try again. “The next
and I get super obsessed with things, and when one will be better. Creativity takes practice just like
the energy is gone, it is just gone and you are math.”
exhausted. The problem with that is, if you were
not finished with the project/product it is hard “I see people fighting to get creativity and the arts
to go back and finish it. Many things often go back in, but it is a tough fight,” Nabors says. “This
uncompleted.” all gets tied into politics, money, and how the job
market is going. It is hard for parents and adminis-
trators to push creativity when they want to make
As far as measuring creativity is sure these students can get a job when they leave
concerned, Nabors says it may the education system. I just think that people have
be safer to recognize, rather than forgotten how much creativity is needed to be suc-
cessful in anything. Creativity is being talked about
quantify, creative expression. a lot more these days, and that is making me much
more hopeful.”
Conclusion
So what exactly can be classed as ‘creativity’? In ever, was the 17th-century Polish poet Maciej
fact, there have been many perceptions of this Kazimierz Sarbiewski — but he applied it only to
word throughout history. Consulting one of the poetry. For over a century and a half, the idea of
major sources of information for the modern human creativity met with resistance, because
era, Wikipedia, we can find an idea that the ‘cre- the term “creation” was reserved for creation
ativity’ that we know today was not always the “from nothing”.
feeling, emotion or attribution that we under-
stand in this current era. In the 19th century, art took its revenge: now not
only was art recognized as creativity, but it alone
To quote Wikipedia: ‘The ways in which societies was. When later, at the turn of the 20th century,
have perceived the concept of creativity have there began to be discussion as well of creativity
changed throughout history, as has the term in the sciences and in nature, this was taken as
itself. The ancient Greek concept of art (in Greek, the transference, to the sciences and to nature,
“techne” — the root of “technique” and “tech- of concepts that were proper to art’.
nology”), with the exception of poetry, involved
not freedom of action but subjection to rules. So, it seems that creativity has been as
In Rome, the Greek concept was partly shaken, much-maligned in times past as it is in the
and visual artists were viewed as sharing, with current age. Scott Barry-Kaufman, a cognitive
poets, imagination and inspiration’. So – it fol- scientist and leading researcher in the field of
lows that creativity must have rules, it must be neuroscience has said, “The entire creative pro-
metered, constrained; which some would argue cess– from preparation to incubation to illumina-
goes against the embodiment of the word, the tion to verification– consists of many interacting
concept, itself. cognitive processes and emotions. Depending
on the stage of the creative process, and what
This suggests that if creativity is to have rules, you’re actually attempting to create, different
how are these to be obeyed and when can they brain regions are recruited to handle the task.”
be broken? It seems that the ideas captured
within this E-Book lend scope to the notion that Convergent thinking is a concept
there is a general feeling in the wider education
community that creativity is being largely ig- first introduced to the world by
nored in favor of measurable outcomes – i.e. test psychologist J. P. Guilford in the
scores, as this is a goal that is not easily mea-
sured and therefore of little use to the teaching 1880s. It is normally touted as the
community when the community is being seen ability to give the ‘correct’ answer
as a merely profitable, functional venture.
Creativity is not always profitable. Creativity is
to a standard question. The idea
not easily measured. Creativity is subjective and is that the answer should not
therefore, immeasurable and loose. These are require significant creativity;
words that place fear into the hearts of super-
intendents and school boards across the globe. convergent thinking is the type of
If something cannot be measured and tested, thinking that focuses on coming up
then what place does it have in the world of aca-
demia? with a single, well-established
answer to a problem.
From Wikipedia: ‘Renaissance men sought to give
voice to their sense of their freedom and creativ- Some might say that inventors who stuck to this
ity. The first to apply the word “creativity”, how- method of thinking would never create anything
new. It is divergent thinking that allows for this: friends, or commenting anonymously on blogs,
the re-packaging and re-working of old ideas into or filtering the world with algorithms to fit our
new compartments of thought. interests, we must engage with strangers and
strange ideas,” he writes. “The internet has such
The 18th-century philosopher David Hume, creative potential; it’s so ripe with weirdness and
argued that invention was often an act of recom- originality, so full of people eager to share their
bination, of compounding an idea or transposing work and ideas. What we need now is a virtual
it from one field to another, a notion repeated world that brings us together for real.”
on occasion by the contributors to this book. For
example, the first printing press was the result One must remember that the word “creativity”
of the re-construction and re-use of a commer- derives from the Latin: “from nothing”. In order
cial wine press. The technology needed for this to truly be creative, do we have to release, let go,
leap in human consciousness was actually within of this idea that creativity is a measurable ‘thing’?
reach for the compatriots of the day – they just That it can be metered, taught, enhanced or
needed someone to think outside the square. embodied within the next generation – or should
it merely be nurtured when recognized? How can
something that is so inherently convergent to
The benefits of the printing press regular thinking be understood?
would be seen later down the line.
Having said that, it is pertinent The teachers, trainers, philosophers and mod-
ern guides who have shared their opinions,
to surmise that perhaps Johannes thoughts, techniques and dreams in this book
Gutenberg (the inventor of the have made one thing very clear: creativity may in
fact be under threat in this modern world and it
printing press) had met with is up to the teachers and guides of this world to
opposition at some point in his make sure that there is always a place for “think-
ing outside the square”.
inventive strategy, perhaps along
the lines of, “So what good will this ...and for being recognized for
thing be, then?” doing it.
Only history has revealed to us (as future gen-
erations) the impact of such an invention as the
printing press. In Gutenberg’s day, there may
have been other, more exciting, more accessible
and relevant inventions that were taking prece-
dence in popularity. Equally, the first airplane,
as Lehrer points out, was really just ‘a bike with
wings’. Only future generations would come to
understand the significance of what these two
bicycle salesmen had actually achieved.
In these two cases as Lehrer points out, “the
radical concept was merely a new mixture of old
ideas.”