Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 10

Edward Valves

Pressure Locking and Over-Pressurization


of Double-Seated Valves
V-Rep 91-1
Pressure Locking and Over-Pressurization of Double-Seated Valves
E. A. Bake ABSTRACT Introduction Seat Sealing Effectiveness
Research Manager Double-seated valves provide benefits over Plug valves, ball valves, and gate valves Before discussing potential problems with
Edward Valves valves with single seats and create few dis- usually have two seats in series. There are double-seated valves, it may be helpful to
First Published 1991 advantages. However, field experience many sub-types of each of these valves, consider the forces that influence the effec-
reveals that trapped pressure in the center and there is considerable variation in the tiveness of the individual seats. Figure 2
cavity of these valves can be a source of sealing effectiveness of upstream and illustrates simplified force balances on
occasional problems. Because actuators downstream seats in different designs. Two closed floating ball and gate valves. Note
are normally sized based primarily on seats in series are often thought of as an that the differential pressure acting across
downstream loading, trapped pressure advantage, and they sometimes provide the closure member (ball or gate) provides
loading on both seats may greatly exceed genuine benefits. When a valve is opened, a sealing force on the downstream seat at
design limitations and cause the valve to closed, or throttled with a high differential the low pressure side of the valve. Thus,
become pressure locked. Trapped pressure pressure, upstream and downstream ports these valves are sometimes referred to as
may also damage valves if over-pressuriza- provide two orifices in series to reduce the downstream sealing.
tion occurs, through heating or freezing of pressure drop across each port (Figure 1).
the line fluid. Improvements in packing, When closed, two seats in series may pro-
bonnet seals, and seats have reduced the vide a sealing advantage in the event one
means of pressure relief in the center cavi- of the seats is damaged.
ty. Fortunately, operating procedures and While problems with double-seated valves
special design features may be employed are not usually common or serious, there
to relieve trapped pressure and prevent are some rather simple characteristics of a.
both pressure locking and over-pressuriza- these valves that should be considered by
tion. system designers as well as valve users.
Failure to attend to these characteristics
may lead to valve malfunction or, in some
cases, hazardous conditions.

b.

Figure 2: Simplified force balance diagram on


closed valves:
Figure 1: Horizontal cross section of throttled ball a. Floating ball valve
valve showing two orifices in series. b. Wedge gate valve

2
Pressure Locking and Over-Pressurization of Double-Seated Valves
Since the seating forces due to differential P1. If the valve is closed under a flowing • If the downstream seat leaks to the
pressure may be inadequate to produce condition, the center cavity pressure after depressurized side of the valve, the
effective tight sealing when differential closure might be less than the upstream center cavity pressure would decrease,
pressure is low, it is common practice to pressure due to “Bernoulli effects” or pres- but, since the upstream seat often seals
assemble floating ball valves with interfer- sure drop across the upstream port during less effectively than the downstream seat,
ence (e.g. controlled “squeeze” on soft closure. it could “feed” the center cavity to main-
seats) which provides some upstream seat- The behavior of the center cavity pressure tain the pressure. Precise prediction of
ing force. In wedge gate valves, as illus- after closure depends on many things, such this pressure after closure is impossible,
trated, stem load and wedging produce a as (1) temperature, (2) type of line fluid, but it would tend to remain near the
loading on upstream seats. Gate valves and (3) individual valve design characteris- upstream pressure.
with parallel seats sometimes employ tics. For example: • If the line fluid is at an elevated tempera-
springs or internal wedges to provide sup- ture, the valve would normally tend to
plemental loading for low pressure sealing. • If the line fluid is either a liquid or gas at
ambient temperature (and there is no cool and approach ambient temperature
Thus, while all of these valves are normally after closure and cessation of flow. The
considered as downstream seating, there is subsequent temperature change), the
pressure Pc would remain constant unless fluid in the center cavity would tend to
usually moderate to significant loading contract, reducing Pc. The behavior will
which provides some sealing effectiveness there is seat leakage.
be affected significantly by the type of
of upstream seats as well. line fluid:
The sealing of two seats in series can pro- – If the fluid is a liquid (e.g. hot water),
duce a pressure trapping condition which, the pressure would decrease rapidly,
in turn, can produce an increase in the possibly approaching a vacuum and
force required to open a valve — pressure producing a vapor cavity. If the
locking. Heating or freezing of trapped Pc upstream seat is not effective at high
fluid between the two seats may also pro- differential pressure, leakage into the
duce conditions that are hazardous to center cavity would tend to offset this
pressure boundary parts of a valve. pressure decrease in time. Precise pre-
diction of Pc is not possible, but the
Pressure Trapping P1 P=0
center cavity would normally be liquid
Referring to Figure 3, consider the sce- filled after cool-down, with a pressure
nario which accompanies and follows clo- near the upstream pressure P1.
sure of a double-seated valve. A “flexible
wedge” gate valve is shown in the illustra- – If the fluid is a gas (e.g. hot air), the
tion, but other double-seated valves react pressure would tend to decrease slow-
similarly to one degree or another. ly in proportion to the absolute temper-
ature. As in the case of closure with a
If the valve is closed with a high line pres- Figure 3: Horizontal cross section of closed flexi- liquid, upstream seat leakage would
sure and the downstream pressure decreas- ble wedge gate valve, showing tend to offset this decrease, and the
es slowly, the pressure in the valve center upstream pressure P1 and center cavity
center cavity would be filled with gas
cavity, Pc, immediately after closure would pressure Pc.
after cool-down at a pressure near P1.
be substantially the upstream line pressure,

3
Pressure Locking and Over-Pressurization of Double-Seated Valves
– If the fluid is a condensable vapor (e.g. Since the pressure trapped within double- force with a trapped pressure Pc may be
steam), the process in the center cavity seated valves may not be foreseen, two as much as twice that required with the
after closure is complicated by conden- conditions might present hazards during same pressure as an upstream pressure. If
sation when the pressure decreases to shutdown if not properly attended to:
the saturation pressure of the trapped 1. Leakage from the trapped center cavity
line fluid. As in the case of closure with might complicate maintenance on near-
a liquid or gas, upstream seat leakage by equipment. This could be of concern
would tend to offset the decrease in Pc if the trapped fluid is flammable or haz-
due to cooling, but the incoming leak- ardous in any other way. a.
age would also condense.
2. Opening of the valve during shutdown
In the vapor case, prediction of center could cause an unexpected energy
cavity pressure after cool-down is release due to relief of trapped pressure
again impossible, but it would normal- to the upstream and downstream lines.
ly be near P1 Significantly, the center This would be of particular concern with
cavity would be partially or completely trapped gas.
full of condensate (e.g. water), even
with a vapor in the upstream line. Pressure Locking
To explore the pressure trapping issue Pressure trapping in the center cavity of
further, consider what happens if the system some valve types can lead to another prob-
b.
(boiler, chemical process) containing a lem if not foreseen and attended to. In the
closed double-seated valve is shut down, case of the gate valves illustrated in Figure
letting P1 go to zero. The fluid left in the 4, note that the seating loads applied to
center cavity after closure (above) would be both seats would tend to increase the stem
trapped indefinitely until relieved by leak- load required for opening.
age. If a valve in a hot line cools off further Gate valves and actuators are normally
after shutdown, pressure may be relieved designed for opening with a differential
by contraction of liquid or condensation of pressure applied as shown in Figure 2,
vapor, but significant pressure might remain with loading primarily on the downstream
trapped in the valve cavity in some cases; seat. The load required for opening is
in the case of a gas, the stored energy obviously a function of the seat area, the c.
would remain significant. This could occur differential pressure, and the friction coeffi-
with any type of double-seated valve; as cients at sliding interfaces on seats and
shown in Figure 4, both seats in some types guides. Actuators may not be sized to
of valves can be loaded by the center cavi- open a valve against full system pressure
ty pressure Pc, thus enhancing seat tightness P1if operation is required only for compo- Figure 4: Cross sections of closed valves to show
and increasing probability of long-term nent isolation during shutdown. seat sealing loads with both sides of
pressure trapping. valve de-pressurized:
Since the seating loads shown in Figure 4 a. Flexible wedge gate valve
are applied to both seats, the opening b. Split wedge gate valve
c. Parallel slide valve
4
Pressure Locking and Over-Pressurization of Double-Seated Valves
an actuator is sized for low differential A corollary to the theories behind thermal ly doubled if it heated from 70 to 600°F. If
operation only, the required opening force expansion of fluids is that pressure increas- the value of P1 is close to the rated pres-
may be much more than that available, es if expansion is restrained. While theory sure of the valve, the valve might be seri-
and the valve will not be operable in the is not as easily grasped in the case of ously over-stressed as a result of heating.
normal manner. This condition is described freezing of trapped water, it is widely Heating of a constant volume of trapped
as pressure locking. recognized that extreme stresses and liquid produces a much more drastic effect
The practical significance of pressure lock- strains may be produced in confining on fluid pressure than a corresponding
ing was demonstrated clearly in a series of parts. Thus, it should be readily understood change with trapped gas. According to
problems encountered in nuclear power that trapped fluids in double-seated valves data in the ASME Steam Tables, an
plants in the U.S. and France in the early should be considered carefully; unfortu- increase in temperature of as little as 40°F
1980s2. Three cases were identified where- nately, the possibility for such trapping is can produce an increase in pressure of
in flexible wedge and parallel seat gate sometimes overlooked in the case of valves 3000 psi or more if water is totally
valves failed to open due to entrapment of in complex systems. restrained from expanding. In practice, the
high pressure water between the seats. Heating of trapped fluid in a closed dou- volume of the valve would increase some-
Nuclear power plant operators were ble-seated valve may occur due to conduc- what due to thermal expansion of the
advised by INPO to consider several solu- tion and convection in the upstream pipe metal and elastic expansion under stress
tions to this problem, which will be dis- when,a nearby system is heated, as in the due to increasing pressure, but it can be
cussed below. These measures should also start-up of a boiler or a process. Smaller shown that these effects are very small.
be considered in all other applications of but significant temperature increases may The potential for damaging pressure
doubleseated valves where reliable open- also occur due to seemingly innocuous increases should be considered if there is
ing is required. conditions such as sunlight or a change in a possibility for heating of trapped liquid
It should be recognized that increased cen- ambient temperature. The most extreme in a closed double-seated valve. Even such
ter cavity pressure due to heating of known case of center cavity heating arises moderate heating as that due to tropical
trapped fluid (below) will aggravate pres- in the event of exposure of a closed valve sunshine might produce a pressure that
sure locking problems as well as possibly to fire; safety in a fire is not normally a could be hazardous in some valves.
cause over-pressure hazards. design requirement for valves in general While the potential for development of
industrial or power plant service, but it is high pressures due to heating of trapped
Heating (Or Freezing) Of often important in refinery and petrochemi- liquids is usually recognized, some people
Trapped Fluids cal applications. question the risks due to practical experi-
Early in their training, engineers learn that According to Charles’ law, heating of a ence and lack of catastrophic experiences.
fluids (both liquids and gases) expand constant volume of trapped gas tends to Some of the ameliorating influences cited
when heated; in fact, most non-technical increase its pressure in proportion to its (and associated fallacies) are:
people also learn this fact from schooling absolute temperature (°F + 460). This pro- • Trapped air or gas will prevent excessive
or everyday practical experience. In addi- duces a major pressure increase only with pressure increase. In fact, trapped air or
tion, most people recognize that water, a relatively large temperature changes. noncondensable gas in a liquid does
rather unique liquid, expands significantly Nevertheless, if a maximum upstream gas moderate the pressure increase due to
when it freezes. pressure P1 (Figure 3) is trapped In a valve heating, but it will remain much larger
during closure and cool-down, the valve than the rise that would occur with gas
body cavity pressure could be subsequent-

5
Pressure Locking and Over-Pressurization of Double-Seated Valves
alone due to Charles’ law. Since the vol- the bolt preload and causes bolt stretch, rating after manufacture, it has been esti-
ume of the liquid expands with heating, However, pressure-seal bonnets common- mated that the pressure was 2 to 3 times
the volume available for gas contracts, ly used on higher pressure valves typical- the valve rating when it was heated in the
tending to make the combination more ly seal tighter with increasing body pres- start-up incident,
completely liquid on a volume basis. For sure. The valve described above had failed to
example, pressurized water increases in • Seat leakage, upstream or downstream, open due to pressure locking (see above),
volume by approximately 16% if heated will prevent excessive pressure increase. and the damage due to over-pressurization
from 70 to 400°F, so an “air bubble” Some old design, solid wedge gate was not recognized until the valve was
occupying 10% of the volume of the cen- valves had difficulty sealing simultane- inspected to investigate the failure to open.
ter cavity of a cool, de-pressurized valve ously on both the upstream and down- There was no catastrophe, but the pressure
would not be of much help if subjected stream body seats because of dimension- had exceeded the valve rating by so much
to significant heating. al inaccuracies or inability to accommo- that it is obvious that the safety factor was
• Valve stem packing leakage will prevent date valve body flexure. Some flexible significantly reduced. This valve was sal-
excessive pressure increase. Hard wedge gate valves also lack sufficient vaged and returned to service, but exten-
asbestos-base packings like those used flexibility to seal well at both sides. sive rework was necessary to repair the
with older high pressure valves often However, some modern flexible wedge damage that had occurred due to over-
leaked moderately at pressures around valves and most two-piece wedge and pressurization.
15 times the valve pressure rating, and parallel seat gate valves have sufficient In another power plant experience, minor
this would limit the pressure increase due freedom to seat upstream and down- external damage was observed in a gate
to liquid thermal expansion. Newer stream, particularly with high center cavi- valve during plant construction. The valve
graphitic stem packings typically seal ty pressure. Thus, seat leakage cannot was outside, and it was closed while.
much better; this is normally considered be counted upon to prevent over-pressur- water-filled after hydrostatic testing. An
an improvement, but it increases the risk ization. unexpected cold weather condition pro-
of over-pressurization. duced an ambient temperature below the
Note: Some experienced engineers rec- Some Cases Of Field Problems freezing point of water. Internal inspection
ommend loosening packing gland bolts Several instances have shown that haz- of the valve after this incident revealed
when closed gate valves are heated. ardous pressures may be developed in severe yield of pressure boundary parts,
However, Edward experience shows that valves with trapped liquids where tempera- not unlike the conditions observed in the
previously compressed graphitic pack- ture increases of several hundred degrees valve that had been overpressurized
ings often continue to seal well on a sta- Fahrenheit may occur. In one power plant (above). This valve was also salvaged and
tionary stem, even with a loose gland. experience, all internal dimensions in a returned to service, but extensive rework
Thus, loose gland bolts will not ensure high pressure gate valve were found to was required.
safety when a valve is heated. have exhibited a permanent strain (yield)
of over one percent after it had undergone Requirements Of Codes
• Valve cover gasket leakage will prevent a boiler startup, while closed, with water
excessive pressure increase. And Standards
trapped between the seats (from a prior
Conventional low pressure valves with A number of codes and standards address
hydrostatic piping test). Since the valve
bolted bonnets and compression gaskets possibilities of over-pressurization from a
itself had passed a hydrostatic test without
may leak if internal pressure overcomes safety standpoint. For example pipe could
damage at, 15 times its 100°F pressure
be damaged by heating of trapped fluid
6
Pressure Locking and Over-Pressurization of Double-Seated Valves
between two closed valves or in an isolat- or hazardous center cavity pressures in age due to erosion. There might still be
ed dead-end run. The Power Piping code, double-seated valves. Nevertheless, as pressure locking problems during shut-
ASME B31.1, requires piping design to noted at the outset, there are few serious down with both sides of valves depres-
withstand the increased pressure or a pro- problems. Most piping designers and valve surized. However, no special valve fea-
vision for pressure relief where expansion users address the problem in accordance tures are required, and the valve retains
of a fluid may increase the pressure (para- with the standards mentioned above to bidirectional shutoff capabilities.
graph 101.4.2). Since valves are recog- avoid safety hazards, and INPO SOER • Hole in upstream side of gate or ball
nized as piping components, this code 84-7 provides good guidelines on avoid- A hole can be drilled in the upstream
requirement may be interpreted to require ance of pressure lock to nuclear power side of a flexible wedge, two-piece
the piping designer to consider possible plant operators. wedge, or parallel seat valve gate as
thermal expansion in double-seated valves. While the methods for avoiding problems shown in Figure 5; a similar change can
With specific reference to valves, are not new to many people in the valve be effected in the ball in a floating ball
ASME/ANSI B16.34 (Valves – Flanged, and piping industries, the fact that prob- valve.
Threaded, and Welding End) references lems are still encountered occasionally sug- This change effectively bypasses the
double-seated valves and states that it is gests that these solutions are not known upstream seat, assuring that the center
the responsibility of the purchaser to pro- widely enough. The specific functional cavity pressure is the same as the
vide means to assure that the allowable requirements of a valve should be consid- upstream pressure. Since these valves
pressure is not exceeded due to thermal ered carefully in selecting the best are primarily downstream sealing, the
expansion (paragraph 2.3.3). These approach. Several of the measures in com- only loss in normal unidirectional appli-
means may involve design, installation, or mon use and their advantages and disad- cations is the extra insurance that would
operating procedures. For example, partial vantages will be addressed: be provided by the upstream seat in the
opening of a double-seated valve during • Operating procedures event of downstream seat damage.
start-up is cited as a procedural method to As suggested in ASME/ANSI B16.34,
address the problem. special plant operating procedures, such
Since codes primarily cover pressure as partially opening doubleseated valves
boundary safety, not functional reliability, before starting a heat-up of a piping sys-
the possibility of failure of a valve to open tem, may be quite effective in preventing
due to pressure locking is not addressed in hazardous over-pressurization.
any known binding standard. Since the This approach requires (1) identification
capacity of an actuator to open a valve of valves that may be most hazardous,
might be exceeded by pressure locking with trapped liquid, (2) cracking valves
without exceeding a safe pressure bound- away from fully seated positions with HOLE
ary rating, system designers and valve handwheels or actuators before start-up,
users should consider this point carefully. and (3) resealing of valves that must
remain closed after heating. This may
Prevention Of Pressure Lock And produce unacceptable leakage in some
Hazardous Center Cavity Pressure component isolation valves, and the leak-
There is, at this time, no known single age during start-up may cause seat dam- Figure 5: Illustration of hole in upstream gate of
“ideal” means of preventing pressure lock gate valve.
7
Pressure Locking and Over-Pressurization of Double-Seated Valves
While this change may be the simplest orifice size used for the hole. Some A hole in the valve body or seat insert,
one for correction of a field problem or wedge gate valves seal reasonably well as shown in Figure 6, bypasses the
for use of a standard valve out of stock, at their upstream seats with low and upstream seat in the same manner as a
one disadvantage is that the gate or moderate pressures, so a valve with a hole in the upstream side of a gate. A
gate assembly cannot be reversed; hole might be suitable for some reversed similar change could probably be effect-
reversing a gate assembly is one com- pressure conditions. High reversed pres- ed in a ball valve.
mon method of extending life of parts sures would probably cause significant As compared to the hole in the gate, this
after extensive valve maintenance, but leakage in all gate valves and might change is preferable from, a long term
placing the gate with the hole on the over-stress gates not designed for high maintenance standpoint, because the
downstream side would cause leakage. differential on the upstream side. If this gate or gate assembly could be reversed
As in the case of following changes with change is to be made to correct a prob- for extended life. The body drilling
internal and external equalizers, the hole lem with an installed valve, the manufac- would be difficult in an installed valve,
in the upstream part of the gate makes turer’s recommendations should be but it is easily accomplished during
the valve unidirectional to some degree. obtained. manufacturer of a new valve. The only
High leakage would be experienced • Hole in seat insert or body bridge wall at concern is to be sure that the valve is
with many valves if the, differential upstream side (internal equalizer) marked and installed in the proper
pressure is ever reversed, although the direction.
amount of leakage may be limited by the This feature might be difficult to modify
in a valve in line if there were ever a
system change that would require seal-
ing in the reversed direction.
HOLE a. • Pipe connecting center cavity to upstream
IN BRIDGE
WALL valve nozzle (external equalizer) –
without or with valve
The external equalizer pipe, shown in
Figure 7a, also bypasses the upstream
seat. The directional nature of the valve
should be obvious to one viewing the
valve. It can be incorporated in a new
HOLE IN
SEAT RING valve, or with more difficulty to an
b. installed valve. This feature would be rel-
atively easy to modify in line if there is a
system change requiring reversed seat
tightness.
Figure 7: Illustration of pipe between gate valve As shown in Figure 7b, a valve (typically
center cavity and upstream nozzle a small globe valve) can be installed in
Figure 6: Illustration of hole in upstream seat (external equalizer). the external equalizer and be left nor-
ring or bridge wall in gate valve a. Without valve mally open (locked open if necessary) to
(internal equalizer). b. With valve
8
Pressure Locking and Over-Pressurization of Double-Seated Valves
provide the upstream seat bypassing Summary Footnotes
function. Closure of the small valve Double-seated valves have established his- 1. Trunnion mounted ball valves, as
would permit reversed seat tightness for tories of safe and successful operation in a commonly used in pipeline services,
special purposes (e.g. hydrostatic testing multitude of applications in general indus- employ trunnions to support the main
of downstream piping); obviously proce- trial service, as well as in power plants, differential pressure loading, and they
dures would have to be enforced to refineries, and petrochemical facilities. The are normally upstream sealing. These
assure opening of the valve before nor- two seats provide benefits, but some rela- valves are outside the scope of this
mal operation. tively simple technical issues should be article.
• Connect pressure relief valve to center considered to prevent problems due to 2. Institute Of Nuclear Power Operations
cavity and connect with piping to a safe trapped fluid between the seats. Piping sys- (INPO), Significant Operating
discharge point. tem designers, valve users, and valve man- Experience Report (84-7, Pressure
A relief valve may be used, as shown in ufacturers should cooperate to establish the Locking and Thermal Binding of Gate
Figure 8, to prevent hazardous over-pres- best measures to assure reliability, safety, Valves, December 14, 1984.
surization of double-seated valve bodies. and sealing effectiveness if a potential
Codes and standards applicable to over- problem is identified. Since individual
pressure protection devices have to be valve applications involve specific function-
checked and complied with. The set al requirements, a combination of the mea-
point has to be enough above the high- sures cited above (operating procedures
est normal operating pressure to prevent and design features) may be necessary to
weepage and inadvertent operation. provide best performance.
Since this approach requires an active
component (the relief valve), it is not rec-
ommended unless the preceding passive
approaches are not acceptable.
Since the valve center cavity could trap a
pressure up to the relief valve set point,
pressure locking could still interfere with
valve opening with reduced upstream
pressures. Thus the relief valve would
offer pressure boundary safety, but it
would not ensure operational reliability.

Figure 8: Illustration of relief valve connected to


gate valve center cavity.

9
Flow Control Division

Edward Valves

Flowserve Corporation has established industry leadership in the design and manufacture of its products. When properly selected, this Flowserve product is designed to perform its intended function safely during its useful life. However,
the purchaser or user of Flowserve products should be aware that Flowserve products might be used in numerous applications under a wide variety of industrial service conditions. Although Flowserve can (and often does) provide general
guidelines, it cannot provide specific data and warnings for all possible applications. The purchaser/user must therefore assume the ultimate responsibility for the proper sizing and selection, installation, operation, and maintenance of
Flowserve products. The purchaser/user should read and understand the Installation Operation Maintenance (IOM) instructions included with the product, and train its employees and contractors in the safe use of Flowserve products in
connection with the specific application.

While the information and specifications contained in this literature are believed to be accurate, they are supplied for informative purposes only and should not be considered certified or as a guarantee of satisfactory results by reliance
thereon. Nothing contained herein is to be construed as a warranty or guarantee, express or implied, regarding any matter with respect to this product. Because Flowserve is continually improving and upgrading its product design, the
specifications, dimensions and information contained herein are subject to change without notice. Should any question arise concerning these provisions, the purchaser/user should contact Flowserve Corporation at any one of its world-
wide operations or offices.

For more information about Flowserve Corporation, contact www.flowserve.com or call USA 1-800-225-6989.

FLOWSERVE CORPORATION Toll- Free Telephone Service US Sales Offices


FLOW CONTROL DIVISION (U. S. and Canada) Phone: 919-832-0525
Edward Valves Day: 1-800-225-6989 Facsimile: 919-831-3369
1900 South Saunders Street Facsimile: 919-831-3376
Raleigh, NC 27603 USA After Hours Customer Service
Visit Our Website
1-800-543-3927
www.edwardvalves.com

© 2003 Flowserve Corporation, Irving, Texas, USA. Flowserve and Edward Valves are registered trademarks of Flowserve Corporation. V-Rep 91-1 3/03 Printed in USA

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi