Agencies: be canalized in order to keep the bonds 1. Rule Making Power from overflowing. There is a law which provides for a policy by which the Congress cannot Barcelote V. Republic implement such law because of their One couple who were not married had a absence of their legal expertise child. Since their bond was not pertaining to that specific law. Such protected by the sanctity of Marriage, implementation must yet to be done by their child was considered illegitimate. an administrative agency. However, The Father registered the name of their there are laws that provides that the child in his Surname. When the time Administrative Agencies, in order to came when the child was supposed to enforce these laws, will issue be registered by his mother, the Civil administrative Rules and Regulations Registrar refused because he was conditioned upon the intention of the already registered in his Father’s name. Congress. The Implementing Rules and The mother filed a petition in the court to Regulations must not deviate from the declare the Registration of Birth void or intention of the Congress. It must also the Cancellation of the Certificate of Live be reasonable and be published in Birth or Record of Birth. The Supreme proper. Court ruled in favor of the Mother. Under the Family Code, it must named under Grande V. Antonio the Surname of the mother. IF the father In Family law it was stated if the child should insist to do so, it must with the was illegitimate, and recognized by the consent of the mother which is absent in father, the child may carry the surname this case. Such certification shall only be of his father. This law is to authorize the a mere recognition. It cannot be allowed agency to promulgate rules and if there is no signature of the mother. regulation to implement the same. However, the implement administrative 2. Adjudicatory Power agency in providing the implement rules It is the power to decide the case based and regulation used the word “Shall” on the expertise of the administrative and not “may” as provided under the agencies. Under the Doctrine of Primary Family code. The Supreme Court ruled Jurisdiction, there are cases that are that the act of the administrative agency required to be decided by the jurisdiction was wrong in replacing the word “may” of those administrative agencies. from “shall” because it had violated what Otherwise, it will be dismissed. The is provided under the Family Law. It case must be decided by the must be in contemplation with what is Administrative Agency first. provided for by the law. It must also be
Transcribed by: anja fuentes
HYPO: A certain person whose name is their institution. According to the recorded as “Pedro” but he is using the teachers, anyone will fail to participate name “Juan” in all purposes. Can Pedro will not be able to take their Final change his name? Yes. Where? It must Exams. One child who came from a filed before the Local Civil Registrar poor family failed to contribute. As a under the Doctrine of Primary result, he failed to take the Final Jurisdiction. If Pedro will go before the Examination. That certain child brought courts as his first choice, it would violate an action for Damages under Article 19 the Doctrine of Exhaustion of of the Civil Code before the courts. The Administrative Remedies. Thus, the contention of the School and its court will only just dismiss the case on teachers is that the child failed to failure to comply with the condition exhaust his administrative remedies precedent. when he filed directly to the court. It must be filed before the CHED. The HYPO: There is an entry in the Record contention of the school and its teachers of Birth which appears to be material were not correct because the claim was and substantial. But looking at the an action for Damages. This case records in the naked eye, it was patently involved a legal issue because the child erroneous. Normally if it appears to be was not able to graduate because of his material and substantial, it should be failure to contribute with the fundraising before the courts. However, RA No: event o f his school. The CHED cannot 10172, allows the change of name by award damages. This is an exception of reason of typographical errors before the exhaustion of the administrative the Local Civil Registrar, even if the remedies. such change appears to be material and substantial.
Exceptions to the Doctrine of
Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies: 1. There is lack of Due Process. 2. There is grave abuse of discretion amounting to Lack or Excess of Jurisdiction. 3. When it pertains to purely legal issues.
The Pangasinan College of Science and
Technology promulgated a program raising funds for as particular project in