Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00247-012-2544-6
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Received: 3 April 2012 / Revised: 5 July 2012 / Accepted: 26 August 2012 / Published online: 22 December 2012
# Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2012
C. Falip C. Job-Deslandre
AP-HP, Pediatric Imaging Department, AP-HP, Rhumatology Department, Cochin Hospital,
St. Vincent de Paul Hospital, Paris, France
Paris, France
M. Alison A. Cotten
Faculty of Medicine, Paris Diderot University, Musculoskeletal Radiology Department, Roger Salengro Hospital,
Paris, France Lille, France
M. Alison : R. Azoulay
AP-HP, Pediatric Imaging Department, Robert Debré Hospital, C. Adamsbaum
Paris, France Faculty of Medicine, Paris Sud University,
Le Kremlin Bicêtre, France
N. Boutry : A. Cotten
Faculty of Medicine, Lille 2 University,
Lille, France C. Adamsbaum (*)
AP-HP, Pediatric Imaging Department, Bicêtre Hospital,
N. Boutry 78 rue du Gal Leclerc,
Pediatric Imaging Department, Jeanne de Flandre Hospital, 94275, Le Kremlin Bicêtre Cedex, France
Lille, France e-mail: c.adamsbaum@bct.aphp.fr
356 Pediatr Radiol (2013) 43:355–375
In 24 children, a biopsy was performed to rule out an Table 2 Percentage of children affected for each site (total number of
children n031)
infectious or tumoral process. One child underwent two
biopsies in the course of his disease. The site of the biopsy Sites n %
was in a long bone in 20 children, the mandible in 3 children
and a vertebra in 1 child. The histological and bacteriolog- Femur 13 42%
ical results from these bone biopsies showed a pattern sug- Tibia 12 39%
gestive of subacute or chronic osteomyelitis and no Pelvis 10 32%
microorganisms were isolated. In seven children, the clinical, Spine 9 29%
biological and radiographic features were initially suggestive Clavicle 6 19%
of CRMO and thereby, no biopsy was performed. The favor- Fibula 5 16%
able outcome under anti-inflammatory treatment retrospec- Tarsus (calcaneus: 4; talus: 3) 5 16%
tively confirmed the diagnosis in all of the children. The Radius 4 13%
mean follow-up was 5 years (range 18 months to 21 years). Ulna 4 13%
The mean number of pathological sites during the follow- Metatarsal 4 13%
up was 3.5 (range 1–14). Six children (19%) had only one Mandible 3 10%
disease focus, with recurrent pain at the same location (clav- Humerus 2 6.5%
icle, n02; tibia, n02; femur, n01; and mandible, n01). Patellae 1 3%
Twenty-five children (81%) had multifocal disease, i.e., at Carpus 1 3%
least two sites of CRMO. Rib 1 3%
In all, 108 bony locations were identified and imaged; Phalanx 1 3%
they were located, in descending order of frequency, in the
femur (18/108 in 13/31 children), the tibia (17/108 in 12/31
children), the spine (18/108 in 9/31 children), the pelvic
bones (12/108 in 10/31 children) and the clavicle (7/108 in overall, 64.5% (20/31) of children had femoral or tibial
6/31 children) (Tables 1 and 2) involvement sometime during the course of their disease.
A total of 56 long bone lesions were investigated:
Long bone involvement
– 46 symptomatic sites
Seventy-seven percent (24/31) of the children had involve- – 10 subclinical sites diagnosed by whole-body imaging
ment of at least one long bone during their illness. The bone (bone scan or MRI) and later studied by radiograph.
involved was the femur or tibia in 83% (20/24) of cases;
All 56 of those lesions were studied using radiographs;
11 were also studied by CT, and 42 by MRI.
Table 1 Distribution of disease sites Ninety-three percent (52/56) of the lesions were cen-
tered on the metaphysis. Involvement was juxtaphyseal
Sites (n0108) n %
in 64% (36/56) of cases. Extension into the diaphysis
Femur 18 16.5% was seen in 18% (10/56) of cases. Epiphyseal involve-
Spine 18 16.5% ment was seen frequently on MRI (55%, or 23/42), but
Tibia 17 16% rarely on radiograph (5%, or 3/56). Rarer still were
Pelvis 12 11% exclusively epiphyseal (n03) and exclusively diaphyseal
Clavicle 7 6.5% (n01) lesions.
Fibula 5 4.6% Radiographs were normal in 39% (22/56) of cases.
Tarsus (calcaneus: 4; talus: 3) 7 6.5% In the remaining 61% of cases, radiographs demon-
Radius 5 4.6% strated a focal lesion, either mixed, lytic or sclerotic.
Ulna 4 3.7% Thirty-six percent (20/56) of the lesions were mixed,
Metatarsal 4 3.7% i.e. both lytic and sclerotic. These tended to have two
Mandible 3 2.7%
distinct appearances: either several lytic elements within
Humerus 2 1.8%
an area of sclerotic bone (n014) (Fig. 1) or, less com-
Patellae 2 1.8%
monly (n06), a single lytic element surrounded by an
area of osteosclerosis, sometimes creating a “pseudo
Carpus 2 1.8%
nidus” appearance (Fig. 2). The other lesions were
Rib 1 0.9%
purely lytic (11%, 6/56) (Fig. 3) or purely sclerotic
Phalanx 1 0.9%
(14%, 8/56) (Fig. 4). The size of the lytic areas varied
358 Pediatr Radiol (2013) 43:355–375
from a few millimeters to several centimeters. Lesions— CT scan was used to explore long bone involvement
whether mixed or purely lytic—with a lytic component in 11 cases. In the majority of these cases (63%, 7/11),
were frequently juxtaphyseal (64%, 36/56). In eight the appearance on CT was consistent with the radiologic
cases, this juxtaphyseal lysis made it look as if the appearance and no additional elements were found. In
growth plate itself was widened (Fig. 5); in four cases, two cases, CT scan revealed a lytic component, while
this pseudo-widening was the only radiologic abnormal- radiographs showed only sclerosis. In one case, CT
ity noted. showed a mixed lesion, though the radiographs showed
In addition to these focal lesions, diffuse bone abnormal- only lysis; in another child, CT showed a mixed lytic
ities were also noted in some of the children; there was and sclerotic lesion involving both the tibia and the
hyperostosis (Fig. 6) in 11% of cases (6/56), and periosteal distal fibula, while the radiograph showed only the
reaction (Fig. 7) in 7% of cases (4/56). fibular lesion (Fig. 8).
Spinal involvement
Fig. 3 Juxtaphyseal osteolysis in the distal tibial metaphysis of an 8-
year-old girl Nine children (29%, 9/31) had a spinal lesion sometime
during their illness. The spine was the presenting site of
involvement in four of them. In two children, the spinal
Fig. 5 a Pseudo-widening of
the growth plate in the distal
fibula (arrow) in an 11-year-old
girl. b Pseudo-widening
of the growth plate in the left
femoral trochanter (arrow) in
an 8-year-old girl
lesions were completely asymptomatic, even as the disease the perivertebral soft tissue (three children) less commonly
progressed. The most common clinical presentation was seen than in long bone involvement, involvement of the
stiffness of the spine, together with inflammatory pain. neural arch (one child).
Three of the children had kyphosis. The thoracic spine was In the two children with vertebra plana, no recovery of
most frequently affected (78% of spinal sites, 14/18). None vertebral body height was observed (after an average of
of the lesions involved the cervical spine. While involve- 18 months). No spinal cord compression or neurological
ment was often multifocal within the spine itself (in two- signs suggesting spinal cord or nerve root involvement were
thirds, or 6/9, of the children), in one case only, two contig- observed.
uous vertebral bodies were involved.
In 55% (10/18) of the cases, the radiographs were nor- Pelvic and pectoral girdle involvement
mal. In the other cases (8/18) the vertebral end-plate had an
irregular, notched appearance that was often associated with Pelvis
a loss of vertebral body height. In one of these, there was
frank vertebra plana. Eleven percent (12/108 lesions in 10/31 children) of sites
Performed in four of the children, CT—as expected— studied involved the pelvis. One-third of the children
always demonstrated the mixed lytic and sclerotic appear- thus had at least one iliac lesion in the course of their
ance of the lesion, as well as the notched appearance of the illness. In more than half of the cases, these lesions
vertebral end-plate. In one child, CT showed flattening of remained asymptomatic. They occurred either on the roof
the T3 vertebral body (vertebra plana) that was missed on of the acetabulum or in contact with the areas of syn-
the radiographs due to the superposition of the humeral chondrosis. Two of the children had associated involve-
heads (Fig. 17). ment of the sacroiliac joint (Fig. 19). The radiograph was
On MRI, osseous edema of the vertebral body was noted usually normal (9/12). Otherwise it showed a mixed lytic
in all of the cases where vertebral body height was pre- and sclerotic lesion (n02) or a purely lytic lesion (n01).
served. When vertebral collapse was present, the signal was One girl had iliac periosteal reaction associated with two
variable. In two children there was a low signal intensity mixed lesions.
line (T1 and STIR) parallel to the vertebral end-plate Out of the 12 lesions, 9 were studied with MRI and
(Fig. 18). Other abnormalities were observed here and there: showed bone marrow edema in all cases (Fig. 20).
associated disk signal changes (two children), infiltration of Contrast uptake was generally uniform within the area
Pediatr Radiol (2013) 43:355–375 361
Mandibular involvement
Other sites
of edema. Soft-tissue infiltration could be seen in four
cases. – A single rib lesion was observed, on the posterior
costal arch of the right 7th rib. Radiograph and CT
Clavicle showed osteolysis associated with a widening of the
costal arch. Periosteal reaction was visible, and
Six children had clavicular involvement during the course of there was significant infiltration of the adjacent soft
the disease; one child had simultaneous bilateral involve- tissue, marked by a filling in of the costovertebral
ment. In all cases, it was the inner third of the clavicle that gutter (Fig. 25).
was involved. It was asymptomatic in only one child, where – Bilateral patellar involvement was observed in one child
it was discovered by whole-body MRI. No sternoclavicular in the form of purely sclerotic lesions on the radiograph.
involvement or extension to the lateral end of the clavicle MRI showed bone marrow edema with no extension
was observed. into the soft tissue (Fig. 26).
On radiograph, the most frequent presentation was scle- – Five children had involvement of the tarsus. Three children
rosis with hyperostosis (6/7). In two cases, lytic changes had involvement of the calcaneus. The involvement was
362 Pediatr Radiol (2013) 43:355–375
Fig. 8 Value of CT in long bone lesions. Right ankle involvement in an 11-year-old girl. The radiograph shows a lytic juxtaphyseal lesion in the
distal fibula (arrow). CT scans reveal another lacular juxtaphyseal lesion in the distal tibia with subtle peripheral osteosclerosis (dotted arrow)
always posterior, in contact with the growth cartilage tissue. The Achilles tendon appearance remained normal.
(Fig. 27). All cases showed infiltration of the adjacent soft The talus involvement found in two children took the form
Whole-body MRI
Discussion
Fifteen children had a whole-body MRI scan. In 12 children
(80%), whole-body MRI disclosed a multifocal pattern of bone CRMO is seen mainly in children and adolescents. It is
lesions. It was decisive in the diagnosis of eight children, characterized by recurrent non-bacterial osteomyelitis (NBO)
showing subclinical inflammatory lesions (Figs. 28 and 29). [12]. The metaphyses of the long bones, clavicles, spine and
In two other children, whole-body MRI disclosed a symptom- pelvis are the sites most commonly affected [1, 4, 7, 13, 14].
atic lesion that was not seen with radiographs (vertebra T11 and The disease is marked by exacerbations and remissions and
tibia). The localizations seen with whole-body MRI were lo- the outcome at adulthood is generally good [6, 22–25].
cated mainly within the metaphyses of long bones (six children) CRMO was first described in 1972 by Giedion et al. [1],
and the pelvic bones (five children). Whole-body MRI dis- who called it “chronic symmetrical osteomyelitis.” It was later
closed spinal thoracic localizations that were subclinical in renamed CRMO by Gustavson et al. [26] and Probst et al.
364 Pediatr Radiol (2013) 43:355–375
[27], who found that the lesions were not always symmetrical. antibiotics have no effect on the course of the disease [5, 14,
Hundreds of cases have since been described in the literature 16]. An autoimmune etiology has also been suggested, but
[3–16, 19]. no significant antibodies have been found in these children.
The pathophysiology of the disease has not been Histological examination reveals nonspecific acute, sub-
explained. The post-infectious origin suspected initially acute or chronic osteomyelitis. Early lesions are character-
has now been ruled out. No pathogen has been found, and ized by a predominance of polymorphonuclear leukocytes
and osteoclastic bone resorption. Later, lymphocytes come
to predominate, along with new bone formation [28]. There
Fig. 17 Bifocal (T3/T9) involvement of the thoracic spine in a 10- osteosclerosis; vertebral body height preserved. c MRI, sagittal T2-
year-old girl (arrows). a Radiograph of the thoracic spine. T3 is not weighted sequence with fat saturation. T3: vertebra plana, subtle bow-
visible due to superposition of the humerus. No significant T9 abnor- ing of the posterior wall with no spinal cord signal abnormality. T9:
mality is seen. b CT. Sagittal reconstruction. T3: Vertebra plana. T9: osseous edema of the vertebral body
notched appearance of the lower vertebral end plate with peripheral
Fig. 18 Multifocal spinal involvement in a 9-year-old girl. a Radio- sequence with fat saturation. L4: Osseous edema, small loss of verte-
graph of the thoracic spine (lateral view). Loss of vertebral body bral body height. A low signal intensity rim parallel to the upper
height, T4/T5/T6. Thoracic kyphosis. b Radiograph of the lumbar vertebral end plate reflects bone impaction (arrow). Note concomitant
spine (lateral view). L4: Loss of upper end plate cortical bone. Hetero- involvement of the left acetabulum and the right ischiopubic ramus
geneous density of the vertebral body. c MRI, coronal T2-weighted
Pediatr Radiol (2013) 43:355–375 367
Fig. 19 Sacroiliitis in a
12-year-old girl. CT. Coronal
reconstruction shows widening
of the right sacroiliac joint
space (arrow). Bone erosion is
visible on the iliac side
to the radiologist, highlighting the importance of being Our study confirms the excellent sensitivity of MRI
able to recognize the different imaging phenotypes. Our in detecting CRMO lesions with bone marrow edema at
study confirms a number of classic clinical and labora- all but the spinal sites [12–15, 19]. While the area of
tory findings: mean age around 11 years and female osseous edema is usually uniformly and moderately
predominance [3, 4, 6, 9, 12–14, 16, 34, 35]; frequent, but enhanced, in some cases there can be more intense
not inevitable, elevation in ESR (62% in our series) with nodular or annular juxtaphyseal contrast uptake—an ap-
generally normal WBC and CRP [3, 6, 11, 13, 14, 16, 35, pearance that, to our knowledge, has not been described
36]; occasional associated skin involvement [8, 14, 25, 34, previously, though it appears in some illustrations [13].
35]; and nonspecific histopathology [1, 11, 12, 28, 36]. This pattern of annular uptake is quite atypical in
This study also confirms some classic radiologic features CRMO and raises the question of an abscess, which
[1–13, 16, 34]: in particular, the predilection for long bone may look similar. However, we have never observed
metaphyses (77%)—primarily femoral and tibial—and the the characteristic layered or target appearance reported
most common appearance at the time of diagnosis being a in Brodie’s abscess [37]. Our study also confirms the
mixed lytic and sclerotic juxtaphyseal lesion of variable size presence of associated epiphyseal signal abnormalities in
[8–10, 13, 16, 27]. In particular, we stress the widening of more than half of the children studied [19]. This epiph-
the growth plate, which may be isolated, regular, and very yseal involvement, which is probably osseous edema, is
subtle in the early stage of the disease. Left–right compar- rarely visible on conventional radiographs [1, 4, 9, 16].
isons can be misleading due to the sometimes bilateral, Generally speaking, bone inflammation is much more
synchronous and symmetrical nature of the lesions, as in extensive on MRI than radiographs would suggest [14,
four of our children. This sign, also described by Manson 15]. On the other hand, joint involvement seems fairly
[16], seems to us very specific to CRMO, and is easily rare (19%), though there are conflicting data on this in
differentiated from the radiolucent juxtaphyseal bands that the literature, where the number of cases is small and
are seen in leukemias or other general pathologies. the criteria for defining joint involvement are variable
Hyperostosis and periosteal reaction are also suggestive (sometimes only clinical). Some authors have found
features, though less frequently observed. joint stiffness in as many as 50% of cases [6, 27, 38].
We found soft-tissue inflammation in 52% of children; or soft-tissue fistula [7, 13–15]. This suggests that intrave-
this was sometimes quite marked, creating an actual soft- nous contrast material is unnecessary in cases where CRMO
tissue mass. Such an appearance—probably underestimated is certain or very likely.
in the literature [7, 15]—should not rule out CRMO. Indeed, Though spinal involvement is a classic finding in
Sundaram et al. [39] describes a soft-tissue mass with no CRMO, there is still debate about its frequency. Some
initial adjacent bone lesion. We never observed a soft-tissue authors believe it is rare [6, 13, 18]. Others present it as
infiltration without an adjacent osteitic focus in our series. one of the most common sites [3, 4, 12, 17]. This lack of
Consistent with the literature, we found no cases of abscess agreement might be due to diagnostic underestimation. In
major diagnostic factor, and the increasing emphasis on whole-body MRI is clearly superior to that of conven-
radiation dose reduction has made whole-body MRI the tional radiography. Relatively few authors have com-
advanced modality of choice. To date, the value of pared the values of bone scintigraphy and whole-body
whole-body MRI has been studied in pediatrics mainly MRI (or even MRI) given the latter’s obvious perfor-
for oncological disorders and benign multifocal pathol- mance and the lack of radiation exposure in accordance
ogies such as neurofibromatosis or dermatomyositis, and with the ALARA principle [20, 49]. The sensitivity of
whole-body MRI has received yet relatively little atten- whole-body MRI in detecting subradiological lesions
tion in the diagnosis of CRMO [40, 46–48]. Fritz [19] was always better than the sensitivity of bone scintigra-
reports excellent sensitivity of whole-body MRI in a phy, with the possible exception of extreme anterior and
series of 13 CRMO children, where it showed “multi- posterior bone lesions, such as sternoclavicular and
focality in all.” Not surprisingly, the sensitivity of costovertebral joints, which can be missed due to the
technique of acquisition based on coronal planes [20]. However, difficulties of interpretation related to suscepti-
In our series, whole-body MRI disclosed a multifocal bility artefacts and marrow conversion in young children must
involvement in 80% of children. Five children had be taken into account. In particular, the late physiological
whole-body MRI and a bone scan within 2 weeks of persistence of hematopoietic marrow in the metaphyses that
each other. In four of them, whole-body MRI revealed are a main target of CRMO can be a pitfall [50]. Contrast
lesions that had been missed on scintigraphy because medium is not necessary at the time of the whole-body MRI. It
they were located at metaphyseal or metaphyseal-equiv- may be discussed at the time of standard localized MRI in
alent sites, which are areas of physiological uptake. In cases of doubtful findings such as pseudo abscess pattern.
the last case whole-body MRI demonstrated that the In terms of diagnostic strategy, we agree with Gikas et
uptake of the sacroiliac joint can correspond to sacral al. [8] and Fritz et al. [19] that, once CRMO is suspected,
edema even when the joint is spared. Finally, in all of bone biopsy should not be routine (Fig. 31). Indeed, when
the children in whom we compared whole-body MRI the sites of involvement and radiographic appearance sug-
and scintigraphy, whole-body MRI provided additional gest CRMO and the clinical and laboratory findings cor-
information and did not overlook any lesion seen with roborate this (good general health, relatively mild
scintigraphy. Moreover, MRI has excellent spatial reso- inflammatory syndrome, moderately elevated ESR),
lution, allowing an anatomical assessment of lesion ex- whole-body imaging is indicated. If whole-body MRI
tension in both bone and soft tissue at the same time, confirms or reveals multifocality, radiographs of subclini-
and it can be used in children where pain recurs at a cal sites are indicated. If the radiographic appearance is
previous site—a situation in which radiograph interpre- also suggestive, a trial of anti-inflammatories with close
tation can be difficult [47]. clinical supervision might be started. If symptoms resolve,
Whole-body MRI must include the entire body. T1- this would help confirm the diagnosis. The frequency of
weighted (either gradient-echo technique or turbo spin- radiograph checks and MRI follow-up needs to be deter-
echo) and STIR imaging pulse sequences must be acquired mined prospectively. Finally, bone biopsy is indicated
in the coronal plane to provide water-sensitive images that only in cases where the clinical or radiologic findings
can detect most lesions. DWI is a promising tool but yet not are inconclusive or multifocality has not been demonstrat-
evaluated in CRMO to the best of our knowledge. In this ed. Its main purpose is to rule out other diagnoses, par-
retrospective study, DWI sequences were not performed. ticularly infectious osteomyelitis, Langerhans histiocytosis
Nevertheless, DWI sequences may have a potential role in or malignant processes, depending on the presentation of
differentiating CRMO from a neoplastic disease in some the child as previously discussed.
cases, such as a vertebral collapse. In general, diffusion of Several authors have studied the outcomes for CRMO
water becomes restricted when there is a decrease in the children in adulthood [6, 22–24, 51]. Though the pro-
extracellular space, i.e. increase of membranes of tumors longed, several-year course of the disease can disrupt
and fibrosis. On the other hand, water diffusion is high when the child’s education, the long-term prognosis is good,
the extracellular space increases as in vasogenic or inflam- and the majority of children are asymptomatic as adults.
matory edema observed in infectious or inflammatory pro- Among the complications that have been described in
cesses [40, 41]. the literature, several authors report persistent, disabling
372 Pediatr Radiol (2013) 43:355–375
Fig. 28 Multifocal
involvement in a 13-year-old
girl. The girl experienced left
2nd toe pain and left ankle pain,
2 weeks apart. a Radiograph
shows sclerosis and hyperosto-
sis in the proximal phalanx of
the left 2nd toe (arrow). b Ra-
diograph shows juxtaphyseal
osteolysis in the distal end of
the fibula (arrow). c, d Whole-
body MRI, sagittal STIR (c)
and coronal STIR (d) images
show asymptomatic inflamma-
tory foci in T4 (arrow in c), in
the right ala sacralis and the left
acetabulum (arrows in d)
clavicular hyperostosis that in some cases caused neuro- been described in the literature [52], and we found
vascular compression (thoracic outlet syndrome) [13, kyphosis at the time of diagnosis in three children.
24]. A few cases of leg length inequality have also Several authors have also reported thoracic spine defor-
been described, secondary to premature epiphyseal fu- mities (kyphosis and scoliosis), underlining the need for
sion. The most common and troublesome complications monitoring—probably long-term—at a frequency that
are spinal. One case of spinal cord compression has remains to be determined. The three children in our
Pediatr Radiol (2013) 43:355–375 373
Fig. 29 Multifocal involvement in a 10-year-old girl. Initial symptomatic lesions were located in the thoracic spine (illustrated in Fig. 17). Whole-
body MRI showed additional subclinical lesions (arrows) in the left acetabulum (a), distal right tibia (b) and in both distal femurs (c)
series were still kyphotic after 18 months of follow-up. [11, 13, 18]. Like Fritz et al. [19], we believe that it is
In addition, vertebral bodies do not seem to return to very important to detect spinal lesions as early as possible,
their initial height once the disease has run its course at the subclinical stage, in order to quickly start appropriate
References
imaging with radiography and correlation with clinical and labo- 37. Pöyhiä T, Azouz EM (2000) MR imaging evaluation of subacute
ratory data. Radiology 252:842–851 and chronic bone abcesses in children. Pediatr Radiol 30:763–768
20. Guérin-Pfyffer S, Guillaume-Czitrom S, Tammam S et al (2012) 38. Wang A, Babyn P (2008) Joint lesions in children with chronic
Evaluation of chronic recurrent multifocal osteitis in children by recurrent multifocal osteomyelitis. RSNA. http://rsna2008.rsna.org/
whole-body magnetic resonance imaging. J Bone Spine [epub event_display.cfm?em_id06005684. Abstract
ahead of print] 39. Sundaram M, McDonald D, Engel E et al (1996) Chronic recurrent
21. Stedman TL (2003) Stedman’s medical dictionary, 27th edn. Lip- multifocal osteomyelitis: an evolving clinical and radiological
pincot Williams & Wilkins, Philadelphia spectrum. Skeletal Radiol 25:333–336
22. Girschick HJ, Raab P, Surbaum S et al (2005) Chronic nonbacterial 40. Jaramillo D (2010) Whole-body MR imaging, bone diffusion
osteomyelitis in children. Ann Rheum Dis 64:279–285 imaging: how and why? Pediatr Radiol 40:978–984
23. Catalano-Pons C, Comte A, Wipff J et al (2008) Clinical outcome 41. Baur-Melnyk A (2009) Malignant versus benign vertebral collapse:
in children with chronic recurrent multifocal osteomylitis. Rheu- are new imaging techniques useful? Cancer Imaging 9:S49–S51
matology 47:1397–1399 42. Girschik HJ, Krauspe R, Tschammler A et al (1998) Chronic
24. Huber AH, Lam PY, Duffy CM et al (2002) Chronic recurrent recurrent osteomyelitis with clavicular involvement in children:
multifocal osteomyelitis: clinical outcomes after more than five diagnosis value of different imaging techniques and therapy with
years of follow-up. J Pediatr 141:198–203 non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. Eur J Pediatr 157:28–33
25. Job-Deslandre C, Krebs S, Kahan A (2001) Chronic recurrent 43. Appell RG, Oppermann HC, Becker W et al (1983) Condensing
multifocal osteomyelitis: five-year outcomes in 14 pediatric cases. osteitis of the clavicle in childhood: a rare sclerotic bone lesion.
Joint Bone Spine 68:245–251 Review of literature and report of seven children. Pediatr Radiol
26. Gustavson KH, Wilbrand HF (1974) Chronic symmetric osteome- 13:301–306
litis. Report of a case. Acta Radiol 15:551–557 44. Kahn MF, Hayem F, Hayem G et al (1994) Is diffuse scleroting
27. Probst FP, Bjorkstein B, Gustavson KH (1978) Radiological aspect osteomyelitis of the mandible part of the synovitis, acne, pustulo-
of chronic recurrent multifocal osteomyelitis. Ann Radiol 21:115– sis, hyperostosis, osteitis (SAPHO) syndrome? Oral Surg Oral
125 Med Oral Pathol 78:594–598
28. Björkstén B, Boquist L (1980) Histopathological aspects of chronic 45. Suei Y, Taguchi A, Tanimoto K (1996) Diffuse sclerosing osteo-
recurrent multifocal osteomyelitis. J Bone Joint Surg 62:376–380 myelitis of the mandible: its characteristics and possible relation-
29. Earwaker JWS, Cotten A (2003) SAPHO: syndrome or concept? ship to synovitis, acne, pustulosis, hyperostosis, osteitis (SAPHO)
Imaging findings. Skeletal Radiol 32:311–327 syndrome. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 54:1194–1199, discussion
30. Beretta-Piccoli BC, Sauvain MJ, Gal I et al (2000) Synovitis, acne, 1199–1200
pustulosis, hyperostosis, osteitis (SAPHO) syndrome in childhood: 46. Darge K, Jaramillo D, Siegel MJ (2008) Whole-body MRI in chil-
a report of ten cases and review of the literature. Eur J Pediatr dren current status and future applications. Eur J Radiol 68:289–298
159:594–601 47. Goo HW, Yang DH, Ra YS et al (2006) Whole-body MRI of
31. El Shanti H, Ferguson PJ (2007) Chronic recurrent multifocal Langerhans cell histiocytosis: comparison with radiography and
osteomyelitis: a concise review and gentic update. Clin Orthop bone scintigraphy. Pediatr Radiol 36:1019–1031
Relat Res 462:11–19 48. Chavhan GB, Babyn PS (2011) Whole-body MR imaging in
32. Ferguson PJ, Bing X, Vaself MA et al (2006) A missense mutation children: principles, technique, current applications, and future
in pstpip2 is associated with the murine autoinflammatory disorder directions. Radiographics 31:1757–1772
chronic multifocal osteomyelitis. Bone 38:41–47 49. Martin JC, Desoysa R, O’Sullivan MM et al (1996) Chronic
33. Grosse J, Chitu V, Marquardt A et al (2006) Mutation of mouse recurrent multifocal osteomyelitis: spinal involvement and radio-
Mayp/Pstpip2 causes a macrophage autoinflammatory disease. logical appearances. Br J Rheumatol 35:1019–1021
Blood 107:3350–3358 50. Ording Müller LS, Avenarius D (2011) High signal in bone mar-
34. Quelquejay C, Job-Deslandre C, Hamidou A et al (1997) [Chronic row at diffusion-weighted imaging with body background suppres-
recurrent multifocal osteomyelitis in children]. J Radiol 78:115–121 sion (DWIBS) in healthy children. Pediatr Radiol 41:221–226
35. Mandell GA, Contreras SJ, Conard K et al (1998) Bone scintigra- 51. Duffy CM, Lam PY, Ditchfield M et al (2002) Chronic recurrent
phy in the detection of chronic recurrent multifocal osteomyelitis. J multifocal osteomyelitis: review of orthopaedic complications at
Nucl Med 39:1778–1783 maturity. J Pediatr Orthop 22:501–505
36. Chow LT, Griffith JF, Kumta SM et al (1999) Chronic recurrent 52. Baulot E, Bouillien D, Giroux EA et al (1998) Chronic recurrent
multifocal osteomyelitis: a great clinical and radiological mimic in multifocal osteomyelitis causing spinal cord compression. Eur
need of recognition by the pathologist. APMIS 107:369–379 Spine J 7:340–343
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without
permission.