Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abelina Salyer
EDMA 6421
Dr. Brian Lawler
18 November 2019
Then, continue the lesson by watching the Proportional Relationships Making Punch
introduction video. Students will begin to see or state wondering how unit rate,
ratios, and proportional relationships are related through the Making Punch scenario.
Pause the video to reinforce the concepts of unit rates as it relates to proportional
relationships.
(Note: At this point, it is acceptable for students to be slightly confused and have
some disagreements. These disagreements with be explored through the Making
Punch partner activity that follows.)
The teacher should now clearly explain the directions and expectations for Part 1 of
the Making Punch activity. Explain to students they have to prove the punch mixes
taste the same/different.
Structured Practice Students will pair up to solve Part 1 of the Making Punch problem. The problems
require students to think both multiplicatively and additively. Through this practice,
__15_____Minutes students will develop their proportional reasoning skills. Students will use
proportional reasoning techniques (simplifying and/or cross product methods) to
figure out how the different punch mixtures relate. Students will also use the
pictorial representation to come to conclusions on the different punch mixes.
The teacher will circulate the room to make sure students are on task. If the students
are only justifying their reasoning using the pictorial representation of the
ingredients, the teacher will ask how the punch mix can be represented
mathematically. If the students are only using the numerical mathematical
representation of ratios to justify their reasoning, the teacher can ask if the pictorial
Each partner should be able to explain their reasoning to each other – using
either/both the numerical representation (ratios) and the pictorial representation. If
there is confusion with one or both student partners, encourage them to discuss their
understandings and misunderstandings with each other.
Closure As a whole class review the conclusions made about each of the given punch mix
scenarios. Ask students if they found the comparisons of the different punch mixes to
__5___Minutes be proportional or nonproportional relationships. Ask students to explain how they
determined if the punch mixes were proportional or nonproportional. Students
should be able to use the pictorial representation as well as the numerical
mathematical representation with ratios to justify their reasoning. Students can
come to the board to explain their mathematical reasoning behind their choices.
To provoke thought pertaining to Part II of the Making Punch activity, ask students of
all the punch recipes in the problem, which one taste the juiciest? Which one taste
the least juicy?
Differentiation/Planned The choice of multiple representations to solve the making punch problem
Support differentiates the students’ responses and justifications. ELL and RTI students will
most likely use the pictorial representations of the different punch mixes to build on
and justify their proportional reasoning.
Other students will be able to use the numerical representation by using ratios to
build on and justify their proportional reasoning of the different punch mixes.
In order to support the gaps in individual students’ understanding of proportional
relationships, the teacher will encourage partners to explain any differing methods of
justification to each other.
Student Interactions Students should be able to form groups on their own to foster a sense of student
autonomy in the classroom. The teacher should evaluate groups that ELL, RTI and
any 504 or IEP students pick in order to ensure their individual needs are adequately
supported. There should be no groups of all students with accommodations.
Students pairs should be able to provide necessary supports for each other’s learning
needs. If needed, the teacher can adjust/rearrange student groups in order to
maintain behavioral expectations and adequate support for student needs.
Theoretical Perspectives The Part 1 of the Making Punch activity focuses on students’ exploration of
proportional relationships through a real-world example. This exploration time, or
“mess around” time allows students to create their individual mathematical
reasonings. Further, by allowing students to work in pairs and requiring them to
explain their reasoning to each other, students will begin to develop a positive
interdependence between each other. Creating this sense of interdependence in the
classroom is crucial to facilitating students’ mathematical identity as math doers, not
just math learners (NCTM, 2017). Through the real-world application of making
punch, students will be given the opportunity to recognize patterns of proportional
relationships and be able to formulize that proportional punch mixes have a
multiplicative relationship. Allowing students to come to this formalization on their
own promotes a more thorough conceptual understanding of proportional
relationships (NCTM, 2017). Further, allowing students multiple punch mix examples
to analyze allows students to recognize patterns which is one of the 3 habits of mind
that foster algebraic thinking (Driscoll, 1999).
What Ifs If students finish Part I with time leftover after the class discussion, allow students to
continue the Making Punch activity by starting Part II.
If students do not behave appropriately when working with their chosen partners,
select new partners for the students, as needed. If students still do not model
appropriate behaviors, switch the task to an individual activity.
If students do not finish Part I in time or if there is not enough time summarize Part I
with a class discussion, finish as needed on day 2 of the learning segment before
moving on to Part II of the Making Punch activity.
Common Core State Standards Initiative. (2010). Standards for mathematical Practice.
Retrieved from http://www.corestandards.org/Math/Practice/
Driscoll, M. (1999). Fostering Algebraic Thinking: A Guide for Teachers, Grades 6-10.
Portsmouth (NH): Heinemann.
Mathematics Georgia Standards of Excellence (GSE) 6-8. (n.d.) Retrieved November 16, 2019,
from https://www.georgiastandards.org/Georgia-Standards/Pages/Math-6-8.aspx.
Miles, R. H., & Williams, L. A. (2016). The Common Core Mathematics Companion: The
Standards Decoded, Grades 6-8: What They Say, What They Mean, How to Teach Them.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin.
NCTM. (2017). Setting the Stage. In Taking Action: Implementing Effective Mathematics
Teaching Practices (pp. 1–14). Reston, VA.
Proportional Relationships. (2019, October 28). Retrieved November 16, 2019, from
https://www.pbslearningmedia.org/resource/muen-math-rp-
proportionalrelationships/proportional-relationships/.
Students will begin Part II of the Making Punch activity. Students answer #3 and #3a
of the Making Punch activity in which they are required to create an original punch
recipe that uses at least five cups total of juice and ginger ale.
Students should begin thinking the relationship between the amount of ingredients
used and the amount of punch being yielded.
Explore/Instruct & Discuss The teacher will ask for one of student’s original punch recipe to use as the class
example for creating a table and graph.
___25_____Minutes The teacher will ask for student volunteers to help fill in two tables based on the
punch recipe. After the first row of the first table is completed with the appropriate
information, the teacher will prompt students to use their proportional reasoning by
asking:
How many cups of juice and ginger ale are needed to produce three-times the
amount of punch?
The teacher will continue with another similar prompt to complete the final row of
the first table.
The teacher will continue by asking students to take the information from the first
table to complete the second table.
After the second table is completed, students should realize the three different
punch mixes have the same simplified ratio (represented by the last column in the
second table). The teacher should ask students why they think the different mixes
have the same simplified ratio. Students should be able to reason that the similarity
between the different mixes is because the mixes have a proportional relationship.
After the students reach this realization, the teacher should introduce this concept as
the constant rate of proportionality (the constant rate is represented by the last
column in the second table).
Structured Practice The students will receive a handout with two tables and a blank coordinate plane
(similar to the ones used during the Explore portion).
__5____Minutes Students will practice representing proportional relationships in tables and graphs by
completing the two tables and creating a graph based on their original punch recipes.
Students should be able to identify the constant rate of proportionality from their
tables and graphs.
Closure After students have completed their original tables and graphs, the teacher will ask
for two different punch mixes that yield the same amount of punch.
__5___Minutes The teacher will bring the students attention back to the example used in the Explore
segment. The teacher will ask students if they can create an equation representing
the proportional relationship of the punch mixes represented by the tables and
graph. The teacher will facilitate discussion among the students depending on their
responses.
Differentiation/Planned All students will be given labeled tables and a blank coordinate plane to create their
Support tables and graphs based on their original punch recipes. Providing the labeled tables
will provide appropriate support for ELL students to complete their original tables.
Providing the students with the same tables and graph will promote equal access to
the task in order to ensure all students can reach the learning objectives of the
lesson. Providing and modeling two representations of proportional relationships
(tables and graphs) differentiates the learning objectives of the lesson to match all
students’ learning styles.
Common Core State Standards Initiative. (2010). Standards for mathematical Practice.
Retrieved from http://www.corestandards.org/Math/Practice/
Mathematics Georgia Standards of Excellence (GSE) 6-8. (n.d.) Retrieved November 16, 2019,
from https://www.georgiastandards.org/Georgia-Standards/Pages/Math-6-8.aspx.
Miles, R. H., & Williams, L. A. (2016). The Common Core Mathematics Companion: The
Standards Decoded, Grades 6-8: What They Say, What They Mean, How to Teach Them.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin.
Proportional Relationships. (2019, October 28). Retrieved November 16, 2019, from
https://www.pbslearningmedia.org/resource/muen-math-rp-
proportionalrelationships/proportional-relationships/.
The teacher should emphasize the concept that multiple packs of M&M’s are needed
in order to determine if there is any pattern of the M&M color quantities. The teacher
can prompt students to understand this by asking if they think one fun-sized bag of
M&M’s is a good representation to generalize a pattern for all fun-sized M&M bags.
After students determine what information is needed, the teacher should emphasize
that everyone’s knowledge and analysis is needed in order to determine if there are
any color patterns in the fun-sized M&M bags.
Structured Practice The students will work in pairs of 2-3 to complete the M&M activity.
Students will be required to model the quantities of each color M&M using a bar
__15____Minutes graph. Students will be required to write the ratios of given comparisons of their
M&M’s using both part: part and part: whole comparisons. Students will be required
to write the ratios in the three different ways a ratio can be written:
X to Y
X: Y
X/Y
Students will complete the Critical Thinking questions that require students to use
proportional reasoning to solve the problems.
Closure After students have finished the M&M activity, the teacher will ask the students if
they recognized any patterns between their bag of M&M’s and their partners’ bag of
__10___Minutes M&M’s. The teacher will facilitate discussion among the students depending on their
responses. The class will compare the different ratios of each color to the whole
number of M&M’s in order to determine if there is any pattern in the quantities of
each color in a fun-sized bag of M&M’s.
Differentiation/Planned The students’ bar graphs, ratios, and proportional relationships will all vary
Support depending on the contents of their fun-sized M&M bags. The differentiation of the
manipulatives allows students to practice the mathematics individually while also
working in groups in order to have the opportunity to peer-teach if there are any
questions regarding the mathematical procedures and/or concepts.
The teacher should be aware of who ELL, RTI, and 504 students work with. Teachers
need to ensure that these students’ needs and accommodations are supported by
their selected partners.
Student Interactions Students will be allowed to work in pairs or groups of three of their choice. Students
will be allowed to work with their chosen partners as long as students model
appropriate classroom behaviors.
Theoretical Perspectives The mathematical principle of attending to precision and procedural fluency is one of
the learning objectives of this lesson. In many instructional practices used, the focus
of procedural fluency is often prioritized over students’ development of conceptual
If the students do not find a pattern by analyzing their M&M’s the students will have
to conclude that an estimation of the amount of each color M&M cannot be made
based on their findings. Students will conclude the quantities of each color M&M are
random and cannot be mathematically estimated.
What if there are a different number of M&M’s in multiple of the fun-sized bags?
If there are different numbers of M&M’s in the fun-sized bags, the teacher should
explain that using a ratio analyze the quantities of each color creates a percentage
which allows the differing amounts to be compared.
Academic Language Demands
Language Function Analyze, Compare, Produce
Content Specific Terms Ratio, proportions, quantities
Specific way(s) students will Students will discuss ratios and proportions corresponding to the activity questions
use language with their partners.
Students use the content specific terms by comparing their findings with their
partners and the whole class to try and determine if there are any patterns in the
quantities of each M&M color.
Support Students will use the M&M activity worksheet to help analyze their M&M fun-sized
bag. The bar graph has each of the M&M colors labeled in order to help students
model the quantities of their M&M colors. Students will also use their M&M’s as a
physical manipulative to support language objectives.
Language Objectives Students will produce a bar chart representing their fun-sized M&M bag by using the
chart provided in the M&M activity.
Students will produce multiple ratios by using their M&M’s as a physical
manipulative.
Students will analyze their fun-sized M&M bag writing the ratios given by the M&M
activity.
Students will compare their M&M colors by discussing the similarities, differences,
and any patterns of the ratios of each M&M color with their partners’ M&M’s.
Assessment
Describe the Tools/Procedures that will be used in this lesson to monitor students’ learning of the objectives. Attach a copy
of the Assessment and the Evaluation Criteria/Rubric
Type of Assessment The M&M activity will be a summative assessment for what students have learned so
far in Unit 3 regarding computing, understanding, and modeling ratios and
proportional relationships. Through the activity, students’ work should show
procedural fluency in writing the appropriate forms of ratios and solving for
unknowns using proportional relationships.
Common Core State Standards Initiative. (2010). Standards for mathematical Practice.
Retrieved from http://www.corestandards.org/Math/Practice/
Mathematics Georgia Standards of Excellence (GSE) 6-8. (n.d.) Retrieved November 16, 2019,
from https://www.georgiastandards.org/Georgia-Standards/Pages/Math-6-8.aspx.
Miles, R. H., & Williams, L. A. (2016). The Common Core Mathematics Companion: The
Standards Decoded, Grades 6-8: What They Say, What They Mean, How to Teach Them.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin.
NCTM. (2017). Build Procedural Fluency from Conceptual Understanding. In Taking Action:
Implementing Effective Mathematics Teaching Practices (pp. 49-70). Reston, VA.