Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1
0
:
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 2 of 16 Page ID #:2
1 PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
2 1. As an engineering student at Tel Aviv University in 2012, then-24-year-
3 old Sharon Rabi conducted an experiment that would change her life in ways she
4 could never have expected: she cut her thick, curly hair very short. She bought two
5 straightening irons to help tame her new hairdo, but naturally curly hair combined
6 with the humidity in Israel meant she had to wake up twenty minutes earlier each
7 day. Sharon thought there must be an easier way for women to tackle uncooperative
8 tresses.
9 2. Sharon talked to her father Kobi Guy, also an engineer, and they put
10 their heads together to develop an alternative to the traditional flat iron. What they
11 thought would be a six-month project required five prototypes and years of trial and
12 error before the product was ready. In September 2015, Sharon posted a video on
13 YouTube in which she straightened her (now long) hair with the straightening brush
14 she and her father had created, called the “DAFNI” brush.1
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
1
28 Available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ey5eAZXSGlA (last accessed
Dec. 15, 2019).
2
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 3 of 16 Page ID #:3
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
3
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 4 of 16 Page ID #:4
4
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 5 of 16 Page ID #:5
5
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 6 of 16 Page ID #:6
1 THE PARTIES
2 8. Plaintiff Guy A. Shaked Investments Ltd. is a corporation duly
3 organized and existing under the laws of Israel, having its principal place of business
4 at 20, Lincoln St., Rubinstein Bldg. 15th floor, Tel-Aviv, Israel.
5 9. Guy A. Shaked Investments Ltd. is the assignee and owner of the
6 Patents-in-Suit.
7 10. Plaintiff Dafni Hair Products, Ltd. is a corporation duly organized and
8 existing under the laws of Israel, having its principal place of business at 10 Zarchin
9 Street, Raanana, Israel.
10 11. Dafni is the exclusive licensee of the Patents-in-Suit.
11 12. On information and belief, Defendant Chiang Ka Man is a natural
12 person residing at 1413 Matchleaf Avenue, La Puente, California.
13 JURISDICTION AND VENUE
14 13. This Court has subject matter jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C.
15 §§ 1331 and 1338(a).
16 14. The Court has personal jurisdiction over Defendant because, among
17 other things, upon information and belief: (i) Defendant resides in La Puente,
18 California; (ii) Defendant has done and continues to do business in California; and
19 (iii) Defendant has committed and continues to commit acts of patent infringement
20 in the State of California, including by making, using, offering for sale, and/or
21 selling accused products in this District, and/or inducing others to commit acts of
22 patent infringement in this District.
23 15. Venue is proper in this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391(b),
24 1391(c), and 1400(b) because, among other things, on information and belief:
25 (i) Defendant resides in La Puente, California; (ii) Defendant has done and continues
26 to do business in California; and (iii) Defendant has committed and continues to
27 commit acts of patent infringement in the State of California, including by making,
28
6
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 7 of 16 Page ID #:7
1 using, offering for sale, and/or selling accused products and services in in this
2 District, and/or inducing others to commit acts of patent infringement in this District.
3 INVENTION OF THE DAFNI BRUSH
4 16. For nearly a century, there was very little innovation in hair
5 straightening technology. The primary option for men and women alike was to
6 sandwich hair between two heated plates and literally iron the hair straight. Over
7 time, the types of metal and temperature controls for flat irons may have changed,
8 but all use the same principle that is inconvenient, unhealthy for hair, and time-
9 consuming.
10 17. In 2012, 24-year-old Sharon Rabi suffered an unfortunate haircut,
11 leaving her thick, curly hair too short and nearly unmanageable. Her only option
12 seemed to be using traditional straightening irons using high temperatures to tame
13 her hair into place, an arduous task in humid Israel. She tried two different
14 straightening irons, but was frustrated at having to wake up early to style shorter
15 hair.
16 18. An engineering student at Tel Aviv University, Sharon decided there
17 must be a better option. Together with her father Kobi Guy, a senior engineer,
18 Sharon spent several years designing, testing, and perfecting a styling tool with the
19 ease of use of a hair brush and more straightening power than a flat iron. The end
20 result was a new type of hair styling tool, a ceramic heated straightening brush,
21 named the “DAFNI” brush, in honor of Sharon’s sister.
22 19. Developing an effective styling brush proved far more difficult than
23 Sharon and Kobi imagined when undertaking the project. What they thought might
24 be a six month project took several years and multiple prototypes to develop the final
25 product. The inventors faced—and ultimately overcame—a number of design and
26 engineering challenges.
27 20. For example, the device needed to provide sufficient heat to hair strands
28 to straighten them, while not damaging the hair during repeated use, a common issue
7
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 8 of 16 Page ID #:8
8
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 9 of 16 Page ID #:9
1 developed a smaller version with detachable cord called the DAFNI go, and
2 rechargeable cordless version, the DAFNI Allure.
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12 DAFNI Original DAFNI go DAFNI Allure
13 25. Sharon’s husband, Kobi Rabi, a former fighter pilot in the Israeli
14 military, is the current Chief Executive Officer of Dafni.
15 26. Despite being a revolutionary invention in the field of hair
16 straightening, Dafni has struggled as the company attempts to compete with copycats
17 popping up around the world, disregarding Dafni’s intellectual property rights,
18 undercutting Dafni on price, and in many cases undermining the brand’s growth
19 potential by manufacturing and selling lower quality brushes.
20 PATENTS-IN-SUIT
21 27. Dafni has obtained two design patents and three utility patents for its
22 brushes in the United States.
23 28. On May 8, 2018, the United States Patent and Trademark Office duly
24 and lawfully issued U.S. Design Patent D817,007 (the “D’007 Patent”), entitled
25 “Hair Straightening Brush.” A true and correct copy of the D’007 Patent is attached
26 hereto as Exhibit A.
27 29. On February 28, 2017, the United States Patent and Trademark Office
28 duly and lawfully issued U.S. Patent No. 9,578,943 (the “’943 Patent”), entitled
9
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 10 of 16 Page ID #:10
1 “Hair Straightening Brush.” A true and correct copy of the ’943 Patent is attached
2 hereto as Exhibit B.
3 30. On March 14, 2017, the United States Patent and Trademark Office
4 duly and lawfully issued U.S. Patent No. 9,591,906 (the “’906 Patent”), entitled
5 “Hair Straightening Brush.” A true and correct copy of the ’906 Patent is attached
6 hereto as Exhibit C.
7 31. On January 30, 2018, the United States Patent and Trademark office
8 duly and lawfully issued U.S. Patent No. 9,877,562 (the “’562 Patent”), entitled
9 “Hair Straightening Brush.” A true and correct copy of the ’562 Patent is attached
10 hereto as Exhibit D.
11 DEFENDANT AND THE ACCUSED PRODUCT
12 32. Not long after the DAFNI brush took the internet by storm, the copycats
13 began to appear, including from Defendant. On information and belief, since 2016
14 Defendant has sold the “VETROO” electric hair straightening brush, which copies
15 the look, feel, and straightening technology developed by the daughter/father
16 inventors over the course of several years:
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26 33. On information and belief, Defendant sells its VETROO electric hair
27 straightening brush directly through Amazon.com.
28
10
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 11 of 16 Page ID #:11
11
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 12 of 16 Page ID #:12
1 that meet the elements of the asserted claims. By way of non-limiting example, the
2 VETROO electric hair straightening brush practices the invention of claim 1 because
3 it is a brush with a heating place on the face of the brush with multiple heating
4 elements thermally coupled to and protruding from the plate. The rows of heating
5 elements on the VETROO electric hair straightening brush are arranged in
6 lengthwise, offset rows, surrounding by heat-insulating bristles. Each heating
7 protruding heating element also has a heat insulating spacer projecting outwardly
8 from the heating element.
9 43. Defendant has infringed at least claims 1-4, 8, 9, 11, 12, and 15-21 of
10 the ’943 Patent, pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) by making, using, offering to sell,
11 and/or selling in the United States, and/or importing into the United States the
12 VETROO electric hair straightening brush. Upon information and belief,
13 Defendant’s infringement is ongoing.
14 44. Dafni Hair Products loses sales for each of the accused brushes that is
15 sold. But for the availability of accused products, a customer would purchase a
16 DAFNI brush. Plaintiffs therefor seek recovery of all lost profits associated with the
17 sale of accused brushes.
18 45. Alternatively, Plaintiffs seek to recover all of Defendant’s profits on the
19 infringing goods under 35 U.S.C. § 289, or a reasonable royalty.
20 46. Plaintiffs seek recovery of their attorney’s fees.
21 THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION
22 (INFRINGEMENT OF THE ’906 PATENT)
23 47. Plaintiffs incorporate by reference Paragraphs 1-46 as if fully set forth
24 herein.
25 48. The ’906 Patent generally relates to a brush with protruding heating
26 elements and spacers to maintain distance between the heating elements and the
27 user’s skin. The asserted claim of the ’906 Patent is directed to a method of
28 manufacturing a brush, comprising arranging spacers protruding from the face of the
12
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 13 of 16 Page ID #:13
1 brush to maintain a distance between the heating elements and the user’s scalp,
2 additional spacers around the heating elements, and a relationship between the
3 density of the spacers and their flexibility to ensure protection of the scalp.
4 49. Defendant infringes the ’906 Patent by making, selling, and/or offering
5 for sale in the United States, and/or importing into the United States, ceramic brushes
6 that meet the elements of the asserted claims. Defendant practices the invention of
7 claim 18 by manufacturing brushes with multiple spacers to maintain a specific
8 distance between the ends of the heating elements and the user’s scalp, additional,
9 shorter spacers around the heating elements, and a density of spacers designed to
10 ensure space between the user’s scalp and the heating elements when the spacers are
11 flexed.
12 50. Defendant has infringed claim 18 the ’906 Patent, pursuant to 35 U.S.C.
13 § 271(a) by making, using, offering to sell, and/or selling in the United States, and/or
14 importing into the United States the VETROO electric hair straightening brush.
15 Upon information and belief, Defendant’s infringement is ongoing.
16 51. Dafni Hair Products loses sales for each of the accused brushes that is
17 sold. But for the availability of accused products, a customer would purchase a
18 DAFNI brush. Plaintiffs therefor seek recovery of all lost profits associated with the
19 sale of accused brushes.
20 52. Alternatively, Plaintiffs seek to recover all of Defendant’s profits on the
21 infringing goods under 35 U.S.C. § 289, or a reasonable royalty.
22 53. Plaintiffs seek recovery of their attorney’s fees.
23 FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION
24 (INFRINGEMENT OF THE ’562 PATENT)
25 54. Plaintiffs incorporate by reference Paragraphs 1-53 as if fully set forth
26 herein.
27 55. The ’562 Patent generally relates to a brush with protruding heating
28 elements and spacers to maintain distance between the heating elements and the
13
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 14 of 16 Page ID #:14
1 user’s skin. The asserted claims of the ’562 Patent are generally directed to a
2 hairbrush with a heating plate, a plurality of heating elements monolithic with and
3 protruding from the heating plate arranged in lengthwise rows, heat insulating
4 spacers projecting from a bore in a heating element, and peripheral spacers on at
5 least two sides of the brush.
6 56. Defendant infringes the ’562 Patent by making, selling, and/or offering
7 for sale in the United States, and/or importing into the United States, ceramic brushes
8 that meet the elements of the asserted claims. By way of non-limiting example, the
9 VETROO electric hair straightening brush practices the invention of claim 1 because
10 it is a brush with a heating place, a plurality of heating elements monolithic with and
11 protruding from the heating plate arranged in lengthwise rows, heat insulating
12 spacers projecting from a bore in the protruding heating elements, and peripheral
13 spacers on all sides of the brush.
14 57. Defendant has infringed claims 1-10 of the ’562 Patent, pursuant to 35
15 U.S.C. § 271(a) by making, using, offering to sell, and/or selling in the United States,
16 and/or importing into the United States the VETROO electric hair straightening
17 brush. Upon information and belief, Defendant’s infringement is ongoing.
18 58. Dafni Hair Products loses sales for each of the accused brushes that is
19 sold. But for the availability of accused products, a customer would purchase a
20 DAFNI brush. Plaintiffs therefor seek recovery of all lost profits associated with the
21 sale of accused brushes.
22 59. Alternatively, Plaintiffs seek to recover all of Defendant’s profits on the
23 infringing goods under 35 U.S.C. § 289, or a reasonable royalty.
24 60. Plaintiffs seek recovery of their attorney’s fees.
25 PRAYER FOR RELIEF
26 WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs Guy A. Shaked Investments, Ltd. and Dafni Hair
27 Products, Ltd. pray for judgment in their favor and against Defendant Chiang Ka
28 Man and specifically for the following relief:
14
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 15 of 16 Page ID #:15
15
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 16 of 16 Page ID #:16
16
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 1 of 6 Page ID #:17
EXHIBIT A
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 2 of 6 Page ID #:18
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 3 of 6 Page ID #:19
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 4 of 6 Page ID #:20
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 5 of 6 Page ID #:21
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-1 Filed 12/16/19 Page 6 of 6 Page ID #:22
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 1 of 12 Page ID #:23
EXHIBIT B
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 2 of 12 Page ID #:24
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 3 of 12 Page ID #:25
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 4 of 12 Page ID #:26
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 5 of 12 Page ID #:27
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 6 of 12 Page ID #:28
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 7 of 12 Page ID #:29
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 8 of 12 Page ID #:30
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 9 of 12 Page ID #:31
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 10 of 12 Page ID #:32
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 11 of 12 Page ID #:33
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-2 Filed 12/16/19 Page 12 of 12 Page ID #:34
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 1 of 12 Page ID #:35
EXHIBIT C
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 2 of 12 Page ID #:36
I IIIII I IIIIII Il llll lllll lllll lll l lllll l lll lll l lllll 111 111111 1 111111
US009591906B2
(65) Prior Publication Data International Search Report from Interntional Application No. PCT/
IL2013/050420 dated Aug. 28, 2013.
US 2015/0101139 Al Apr. 16, 2015
Primary Examiner - Rachel Steitz
Related U.S. Application Data (74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm - Dorsey & Whitney LLP
(63) Continuation of application No.
PCT/IL2013/050017, filed on Jan. 6, 2013. (57) ABSTRACT
A brush is provided herein, the brush having heating ele
(30) Foreign Application Priority Data ments dispersed on and protruding from its face and spacers
arranged to maintain a specified distance between protruding
May 17, 2012 (IL) .......................................... 219875 ends of the heating elements and a scalp of a head that is
being brushed. The spacers are dispersed on the brush's face
(51) Int. Cl. at a specified density that assures maintaining the specified
A45D 24/10 (2006.01) distance with respect to a resilience of the spacers.
A45D 7100 (2006.01)
(Continued) 20 Claims, 5 Drawing Sheets
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 3 of 12 Page ID #:37
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 4 of 12 Page ID #:38
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 5 of 12 Page ID #:39
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 6 of 12 Page ID #:40
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 7 of 12 Page ID #:41
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 8 of 12 Page ID #:42
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 9 of 12 Page ID #:43
US 9,591,906 B2
1 2
HAIR STRAIGHTENING BRUSH elements may have a cross section that varies in shape, and
heating elements of varying forms may be combined on a
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED single brush.
APPLICATIONS The term "spacer" as used herein in this application refers
5 to any structure arranged to keep a clearance or a specified
This application is a National Phase Application of PCT distance between heating elements of the brush and the scalp
International Application No. PCT/IL2013/050420, Interna of the user's head. Spacers may have any form and may be
tional Filing Date May 16, 2013, claiming priority of PCT positioned on the brush and/or on the heating elements.
Patent Application No. PCT/IL2013/050017, filed Jan. 6, Spacers may be made of any material, preferable a heat
2013, and Israeli Patent Application No. 219875, filed May 10 insulating material. Different types of spacers may be used
17, 2012, all of which are hereby incorporated by reference. at different regions of the brush.
With specific reference now to the drawings in detail, it is
BACKGROUND stressed that the particulars shown are by way of example
and for purposes of illustrative discussion of the preferred
1. Technical Field 15 embodiments of the present invention only, and are pre
The present invention relates to the field of hair heat sented in the cause of providing what is believed to be the
treatment, and more particularly, to brush-like hair straight most useful and readily understood description of the prin
eners. ciples and conceptual aspects of the invention. In this regard,
2. Discussion of Related Art no attempt is made to show structural details of the invention
Hot combs have been used since the late l 9'h century, 20 in more detail than is necessary for a fundamental under
however operational considerations and safety requirements standing of the invention, the description taken with the
have been limiting their applicability. drawings making apparent to those skilled in the art how the
several forms of the invention may be embodied in practice.
BRIEF SUMMARY Before explaining at least one embodiment of the inven-
25 tion in detail, it is to be understood that the invention is not
One aspect of the present invention provides a brush limited in its application to the details of construction and
comprising a plurality of heating elements protruding from the arrangement of the components set forth in the following
a face of the brush, the heating elements dispersed on the description or illustrated in the drawings. The invention is
brush's face at a specified density; and a plurality of spacers applicable to other embodiments or of being practiced or
arranged to maintain a specified distance between protruding 30 carried out in various ways. Also, it is to be understood that
ends of the heating elements and a scalp of a head that is the phraseology and terminology employed herein is for the
being brushed, the spacers dispersed on the brush's face at purpose of description and should not be regarded as lim
a specified density that assures maintaining the specified iting.
distance with respect to a resilience of the spacers. FIGS. lA-lC are high level schematic illustrations of a
These, additional, and/or other aspects and/or advantages 35 brush 100 according to some embodiments of the invention.
of the present invention are set forth in the detailed descrip FIG. lA is a perspective view, FIG. lB is a cross sectional
tion which follows; possibly inferable from the detailed view and FIG. lC is a side view. FIGS. 2A-2C and 3A-3D
description; and/or learnable by practice of the present are high level schematic illustrations of various arrange
invention. ments of heating elements 120 and spacers 130 of brush 100
40 according to some embodiments of the invention. Brush 100
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS comprises heating elements 120 dispersed on and protruding
from its face and spacers 130 arranged to maintain a
For a better understanding of embodiments of the inven specified distance between protruding ends of heating ele
tion and to show how the same may be carried into effect, ments 110 and a scalp of a head that is being brushed.
reference will now be made, purely by way of example, to 45 Spacers 130 are dispersed on the brush's face at a specified
the accompanying drawings in which like numerals desig density that assures maintaining the specified distance with
nate corresponding elements or sections throughout. respect to a resilience of spacers 130.
In the accompanying drawings: FIGS. lA and lB illustrate flat, essentially one-sided
FIGS. lA-lC are high level schematic illustrations of a brush 100, having a back 91, a handle 90, an operation
brush according to some embodiments of the invention; 50 button 95 and optionally an operation indicator and a heating
FIGS. 2A-2C and 3A-3D are high level schematic illus level selector (not shown). In the cross sectional view of
trations of various arrangements of the heating elements and FIG. lB, heat source 110 is visible, as well as the internal
spacers of the brush according to some embodiments of the structure of elements in handle 90. FIG. lC illustrates a
invention; and cylindrical brush 100 having dispersed heating elements 120
FIG. 4 is a high level schematic flowchart illustrating a 55 and spacers 130. In these embodiments, some of spacers 130
method according to some embodiments of the invention. may be connected on top (126) of some of heating elements
120 (130B) or among heating elements 120 (130C).
DETAILED DESCRIPTION FIGS. 2A and 28 illustrate two configurations of heating
elements 120 and spacer 130 on brush's face 92. FIG. 2A
Prior to setting forth the detailed description, it may be 60 illustrates a dense arrangement of heating elements 120 and
helpful to set forth definitions of certain terms that will be spacer 130 in which there is a high probability of each hair
used hereinafter. 80 contacting at least one heating element 120 and each hair
The term "heating element" as used herein in this appli 80 is likely to be extensively heated. FIG. 28 illustrates a
cation refers to any type of heat conductive element, in less dense arrangement of heating elements 120 and spacers
particular metal (e.g. aluminum) heat conductors. Heating 65 130 in which heating elements 120 are spread apart in
elements may have any shape, e.g. elongated, flat, conical, respect to FIG. 2A. As heating elements 120 are more
have a cross section that is round, elliptic or flat etc. Heating remote from each other, there is a lower probability of each
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 10 of 12 Page ID #:44
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 11 of 12 Page ID #:45
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 12 of 12 Page ID #:46
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 1 of 12 Page ID #:47
EXHIBIT D
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 2 of 12 Page ID #:48
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 3 of 12 Page ID #:49
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 4 of 12 Page ID #:50
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 5 of 12 Page ID #:51
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 6 of 12 Page ID #:52
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 7 of 12 Page ID #:53
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 8 of 12 Page ID #:54
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 9 of 12 Page ID #:55
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 10 of 12 Page ID #:56
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 11 of 12 Page ID #:57
Case 2:19-cv-10589 Document 1-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 12 of 12 Page ID #:58