Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Non-linear Storytelling:
Journalism through “Info-spatial”
Compositions
G I O RG I A LU PI , M . Arch , BFA
P R OJE C T D AT E 2012
UR L http://www.accurat.it/visualdata/
TO WA R D A N O N - LINEA R , MU LT I- L AY ER ED
S T O RY TELLIN G L O GIC
For each week the team considers and pursues
a topic we believe may be of particular
interest to explore. Topics may range from
current affairs to historical or cultural issues;
we then analyze different kind of datasets
trying to identify and reveal a central story—
hopefully a not-so-expected one. As the effort
to generate quality information graphics is
not an insignificant one we are dedicated to
undertake a topic that is worth of being
Figure 2,3,4, & 5: A very simplified transmission of the “INFO-SPATIAL” JOURNALISM: THE LAYERING PROCESS
states of visual journalism is depicted in these four repre- Following is the general sequence of design, the sequence
sentative images. The oldest example shows text with heads. is here argued parallel to the building of the layers. So
The heads help to navigate and identify what is purely the editorial process of selection, analysis, comparison,
a literate delivery of news. commentary, and idea. These are building hierarchies, etc., is in direct conjunction to the
shown supplemented by photography or adjacent diagrams development of the layers. The editorial logic follows the
in the next examples. The last example, taken from the set design logic, layer by layer.
within the series discussed in this paper, shows the current
generation with a richly supported textual diagram. (1) Composing the main architecture: this is the basis that
The future might dispense with supporting text altogether— acts as the formalized base through which the main story
interactive models support such visualizations well as they will be mapped and displayed, upon this one will see
permit text to be ascertained only when it is deemed necessary the most relevant patterns emerging from the story: the
or of interest. essential “map” that shall conceptually identify where we
are. This base is essentially a matrix or pattern that will
serve as our organizer. It may be composed of cells,
visualized toward a rich contextual lesson. The story must or distances, or other interrelated multiples.
be worth being told through data visualization. The story
and the composition is key, we aim to move away from (2) Positioning singular elements (essentially dots) within
mere quantity in order to pursue a quality transformation the main framework. This process is also one which will
of raw statistical material into something that will provide test the effectiveness of the main architecture; the placement
new knowledge. In this respect info-spatial journalism is of elements reveals or confirms weaknesses and strengths
not data-visualization in the pure sense. We are not just which may lead to modification of the main architecture.
providing insight into numbers but into social issues or
other qualitative aspects as well. (3) Constructing shaped elements of dimensionality, and
2
t2
t6
t7
t8
t9
t1
t1
t1
t1
t3
t4
t5
x
x
x
x
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
are to be located where they best help to enrich the overall Text 01
comprehension. They must not distract from the main story. Text 02
2
t2
t6
t7
t8
t9
t1
t1
t1
t1
t3
t4
t5
Text 03
x
x
x
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Text 04 Text 01 PIE DRAGÉE FRUITCAKE.
Text 07
Text 08 Text 05
of data visualization. These are composed to enlighten Text 06 Pie dragée fruitcake.
(5)
Sweet icing chupa chups.
Text 08
2
t2
t6
t7
t8
t9
t1
t1
t1
t1
t3
t4
t5
x
x
x
x
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
and dimensions of singular elements. These explanations Text 01 PIE DRAGÉE FRUITCAKE.
SWEET ICING CHUPA CHUPS.
ICE CREAM FRUITCAKE
TIRAMISU TIRAMISU
t2
t6
t7
t8
t9
t1
t1
t1
t1
t3
t4
t5
BROWNIE
Text 03
x
x
x
volumes, etc.
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
Te
CANDY CANES
Text 07 Text 04
and weights to make hierarchies pop out. Highlighting the Text 08 Text 05
relevant and visual constructing other several background (7) Text 06 Pie dragée fruitcake.
Sweet icing chupa chups.
Text 08
Figure 7: English version of the visualization, originally published on La Lettura#34 (8th July, 2012)
EXA M PL ES O F T H E I N FO RM ATI O N GR APH I CS its actual position, where we simply cut the geographical
In this part of the paper the process become evident morphology in order to enlighten this imaginary idea
through the post-published analysis of the visualizations of traveling below the earth. Each city is represented by
themselves. An explanation of the layering process, a circle the radius of which is the total length of its subway
or aspects of certain steps within the layering process is extension. The main tale is immediately recognizable:
provided for selected examples. These general descriptions which cities are overlapping or so close to one another
also address some of the editorial considerations that lead that they may almost be reached by subway?
to their selection and development. The visualization then provides lots of other informa-
tion by which each city subway system could be compared
Subterranean veins of Europe was initiated with the should readers desire to spend additional review: daily
concept of building a “what if ” map of European subways. consumption (number of passengers represented with
Have you ever though about going from London to Paris light pictograms), the colors of the lines (numerically
riding the tube? What if we take the total length of ordered and represented by colored tiny squares), the cost
underground veins that run below european major cities of one-way ticket (indicated by the stroke thickness of
and put them one after the other from the center of the each circle). It’s then suggested that a possible evaluation
city, building a novel map of imaginary travels? This is of estimated distance from Milan (where Corriere della
our first story. We found it compelling that European Sera is headquartered) with white (cutting the background)
cities could potentially be reached by their subway lines. light lines pointing Milan as the center.
The visualization is based on a map locating each city in
Painters’ time is inspired from an article by Malcolm centuries as well as the average age of painters producing
Gladwell published in the New Yorker, in which he tries their masterpieces
to unveil the rules behind creativity and genius. Gladwell
compares those artists that succeeded very early in their
career, the young geniuses like Picasso, with those who
had to wait until their mature years and had to practice
far more to see their true art take form, such as for the
old masters like Cezanne. Was it possible to draw a timeline
that showed in what period of their lives the most famous
painters of all times painted their masterpieces? The
general architecture of the visualization became clear
to us: painters should have been situated along a vertical
timeline (enlightening centuries) according to their birth Figure 8: Zoom on painters handling: main piece by
year, the painter “entity” represented as the line of the length Garzanti Art Encycloped recognizable for each artist by using
of his life with productive periods defined within 3 main continuous stroke line; first piece resulting on Google images
parts: young (up to 35 years old), adult (36 to 60 years recognizable for each artist by using dashed line; period of
old) and mature (61years old and over). We normalized life he composed the master piece is recognizable as filled
intervals according to the average life expectancy for with darker grey (and masterpiece according to Garzanti
each century. We then defined our own criteria as used Art Encycloped is joining painter’s life line in the precise
to define which paintings are considered as a masterpieces. moment.) Sizes and colors of paintings are comparable by
To do this we positioned on the life-line that first “official” the actual size and filling colors of squares.
point where the Italian edition of the Garzanti Art
Encycloped refers as the masterpiece; secondarily we also
placed a “people’s” choice indicator; the first result related
to the name of the painter on Google Images. In addition,
we added further layers of information through color
codes and shapes; such as main colors of the art piece,
size of the frames, and the painting technique. Trying to
look at the big picture of the story we wanted to suggest
patterns’ changing in time with a reference table enlight-
ening main colors, techniques, sizes changing through
Figure 9: Original version of the visualization, published on La Lettura#47 (7th October, 2012)
A geography of detectives and authors in crime novels 100.000 citizens, helping to contextualize fiction stories
Could geography be the key for understanding the context in real life.Within the legend we then tried not only to
with a collection of crime novels? We tried to see if it explain main visualization features (positioning, dimensions
could do this according to some initial insights we had and colors), but also to cover all the possible situations
while analyzing a selection of 68 detectives in crime novels (geographical coincidence/geographical, not coincidence/
we compiled together with Corriere della Sera experts and, same author creating more than one character).
The visualization analyzes the geography of these 68,
enlightening relations between authors’ home-town (and
country) and where their detectives operate. Detectives
are located horizontally according to their first appearance
(chronological), and then represented with their main role
(color), and number of novels they appear in compared to
the total novels written by their author: these are rendered
by the dimension of circles. The main story (geographic
correspondence) is immediately noticeable by looking at
where detectives circles (colored ones, according to roles)
are inscribed in respective authors’ circle (grey ones).
Intriguingly, many actually match!
We then provided further levels the general story
could be explored through: an inclined line which comes
out only from those authors who published novels before
giving birth to their most famous detective; connections Figure 9 (zoom): We tried to balance circle colors and
are notated among those detective belonging to the same opacities, main connection lines and text in order to make
author (underlining eventual geographical patterns chang- hierarchies immediately clear.
ing through time); a further sub-layer of explanation is
given by an actual statistical data we provide for each
country (extreme right side of the visualization): a simple
bar chart showing the number of attempted murders every
Figure 10:
English version of the
visualization, originally
published on La Lettura
#35 (15th July, 2012)
Figure 11:
Original version of the
visualization, published
on La Lettura#44 (16th
September, 2012)
January if you want to be a football player explores the idea of a “relative age phenomenon”,
and if such is verifiable even for soccer major teams. We reference the author Malcolm Gladwell,
respective to his book Outliers, where he describes how he found a very high concentration of
hockey-players born in the first months of the year, particularly in the youngest leagues. This
is supposed to be because of the sport selection rules of the western system: children are divided
into classes based by the year of birth: “bigger” ones are most likely selected for higher leagues
and so have more chances to practice at higher levels while they’re growing, this ends up in
a huge disproportion in the distribution of months of birth even in the NHL.
Figure 12:
Original version of the
visualization, published
on La Lettura#46 (30th
September, 2012)
Visualizing the future bases on a selection of speculative fiction captions collected here:
(http://www.theawl.com/2012/08/a-timeline-of-future-events) by Jane Hu. The visualization
analyses 62 foretold future events. Each event is described within main typologies (are they
mainly social, scientific, technologic, politic?), exploring the year it was predicted, the genre
of the book, the age of the author, and more than all, dividing them into positive, neutral
or negative events. Finally, good news, in 802.701 the world will keep on existing.
Figure 13:
English version of the
visualization, originally
published on La Lettura
#40 (19th August, 2012)
Time machine for art movies explores the 52 best movies of all time, according to the British
Film Institute (http://www.bfi.org.uk/news/50-greatest-films-all-time), and investigates the
relationship between the year of release and the time-setting of the story. Further details (provided
close to the time-setting of the story) show interesting patterns on genres, durations, reality vs.
fantasy, nationality, and awards over time.
Empires Strike Again explores the reason why the biggest empires
collapsed. The visualization proposes a new historical, geographical
and demographical render of 21 big emperors since 2,500 years ago.
Empires are visualized according to the moment and reason of their
fall: more information about size, population, govern and geography
are visually provided for each one.
CO N CLU SI O N A C KN O W LE D GEM E N TS
To conclude, we would argue that the positive opinions My appreciation to Prof. William Bevington for suggestions
we’re receiving back from general public as well as from on formatting and logic within the abstract, design process
the editors could sustain our idea to achieve the goal details, and the final editing of the manuscript.
of a formal journalism based information design and
info-spatial aesthetic. An interesting point is that we did N OT E S
receive significant appreciation of educators and educa- 1 Anderson, William, and Bevington, William,
tional book publishers. This does argue that some of “Complications and Adjacencies: An Organizing Logic for
our pieces could be worthy of use as synoptic charts Information Graphics” The Parsons Journal for Informa-
for explaining complex systems of information. We make tion Mapping, Volume II, Issue 3, New York
no claim to have settled any universal information design
and information mapping creating method, this is just R E F E R E N CE S
ours, derived from our different backgrounds and attitudes. Corriere della Sera webpage:
Further we were influenced (directed) by editorial http://www.corriere.it/
constraints that are either narrowing topics we may want
to explore, or constraining graphic freedom. However, La Lettura webpage:
these also may serve to advance and streamline the process. http://lettura.corriere.it/
Perhaps, due to my (Giorgia Lupi) architectural background (working team: Serena Danna e Pierenrico Ratto)
I sense the blank space of a spread-page needs to be filled
with materiality somehow, even space, and it’s because Accurat webpage:
of this idea of materiality that blank space is a part of the http://www.accurat.it/
composition that has to be made tangible as well. I would (working team: Giorgia Lupi, Simone Quadri, Gabri-
like to conclude by quoting Alberto Cairo, whose last ele Rossi, Davide Ciuffi, Federica Fragapane, Francesco
book “the functional art: an introduction to information Majno, Stefania Guerra, Matteo Riva, Anna Bassi, Mario
graphics and visualization” compares the relationship Porpora)
between visualization and art with the one between
journalism and literature “A journalist can borrow tools Full gallery:
and techniques from literature, and be inspired by great http://www.visualizing.org/galleries/la-lettura-visual-data
fiction writing, but she will never allow her stories to become
literature. That notion applies to visualization, which is, Density Design webpage:
above all, a functional art. The role of an information http://www.densitydesign.org/
architect is to anticipate this process and generate order Thanks to Paolo Ciuccarelli (Associate professor at Milan
before people’s brains try to do it on their own.” In this Politecnico and Scientific Director of Density Design Lab)
manner the story matters and Aesthetics matter because for introducing me to the data-visualization world
they make the story when journalism is constructed
into dimensionality. F O RME R A RT IC LE S O N OU R V I S U A LIZAT IO N S:
Accurat and Drew Skaw on Visual.ly
BI O GR A PHY “mixed skillsets produce great infographics”
Giorgia Lupi is an architect, designer, and researcher. http://blog.visual.ly/mixed-skillsets-produce-great-info-
After graduating in Architecture at Ferrara University graphics/
in 2006 she has been involved in multidisciplinary projects
exploring urban phenomena, information and technology. Andy Kirk on visualisingdata.org
Ms. Lupi is a PhD candidate at Milan Politecnico, Design “visual data section in Corriere della Sera”
Department, within DensityDesign Lab; her PhD research http://www.visualisingdata.com/index.php/2012/08/week-
aims at designing new methods for interpreting urban ly-visual-data-section-in-corriere-della-sera/
phenomena through digital traces. (giorgialupi.net)
Currently, Giorgia is a visiting scholar at Parsons Institute
for Information Mapping in New York. In may 2011 she
founded the design company Accurat. This allowed he to
build working partnerships upon past professional with
Simone Quadri and Gabriele Rossi.