Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Justin Brown, MPhil, MS,1 Andrew T. Del Pozzi, PhD,2 and Charlie Hicks-Little, PhD1
1
Department of Exercise and Sport Science University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah; and 2Integrative Exercise
Physiology Laboratory, School of Kinesiology, Ball State University, Muncie, Indiana
41 Copyright Ó National Strength and Conditioning Association Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Anxiety and Exercise Prescription
with increases in circulating serotonin exercise and suggest a decrease in state levels and to help ensure long-term com-
and decreased perception of stress and anxiety after a workout (4,6,29). For pliance (29). Using the transtheoretical
hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis acti- example, Broocks et al. (4) investigated model, Findorff et al. found elderly adult
vation. The benefits of exercise clearly the efficacy of aerobic exercise, clomipr- women were more likely to adopt an
indicate that it should be considered as amine, and a placebo pill in a group of exercise program if they had close con-
a treatment modality when working with subjects suffering from moderate to tact with the provider and continuous
clients who have an anxiety disorder. severe panic disorder. Treatment was feedback which allows for identification
randomized, and results of the study re- of personal obstacles to exercise along
EXERCISE MODALITIES vealed a significant improvement in anx- with strategies to overcome them (13).
Inactivity and increased sitting time are iety scores for aerobic exercise. In The authors also state to be successful
associated with numerous diseases such addition, patients taking clomipramine any intervention to improve exercise
as obesity, type 2 diabetes, hypertension, along with aerobic exercise demon- compliance should be tailored to the cli-
and metabolic syndrome (39,45). Indi- strated the greatest improvement in anx- ent’s motivational stage (30).
viduals who are affected by an anxiety iety scores. In another study, researchers
disorder tend to have large amounts of demonstrated an improvement in mood RESISTANCE TRAINING
sedentary time and fail to meet exercise in patients with post-traumatic stress Resistance training is an exercise modal-
guidelines (21,52), which puts them at an syndrome after completing 30 minutes ity that has a positive influence on mus-
increased risk of chronic diseases associ- of moderate intensity (70–75% maxi- cular strength, endurance, bone density,
ated with low physical activity. A care- mum heart rate) (11). Other investiga- and body composition. Like aerobic
fully designed exercise program should tions using interval training as the exercise, individuals who are coping with
include goals that are specific to improv- exercise mode have documented im- an anxiety disorder that partake in resis-
ing fitness, decreasing muscle tension, provements in aerobic capacity and tance exercise training have responded
improving cardiovascular risk factors, lower depression scores (14,20). Those well with a decrease in anxiety (7,49),
mood, and decreasing the negative ef- results also demonstrated lower scores improved mood (7,49,51), decreased
fects of anxiety disorders (6,29,37). Exer- worry (3,22), decreased depression
for anxiety and insomnia; however, they
cise should be carefully planned for the (35,38,41,43), increased cognition (43),
were not statistically significant. Shapiro
client to avoid any increase in anxiety. and reductions in cardiovascular re-
and Cline (40) examined the effective-
This will mean the health and fitness sponses to mental stress (51). Research
ness of meditation, exercise, or a combi-
professional (HFP) needs to have an has found that when state anxiety levels
nation of the 2 on post-traumatic
understanding of the specific triggers are elevated before exercise, there is a re-
cognitions, ruminative thoughts, and
for their client, and do their best to avoid sulting decrease in state anxiety indepen-
memories in young women with a his-
them, so the risk of injury due to dent of intensity (15). Strickland and
tory of sexual violence. They found med-
increased anxiety can be avoided. In Smith suggest using a low- to
itation alone was effective at reducing
addition, it would not be unreasonable moderate-intensity (,70% one repetition
trauma-related thoughts; however, the
to suggest to a client that they engage in maximum [1RM]) load to improve feel-
group activities such as fitness classes or combination of meditation and exercise ings of anxiety (44). Cavaretta et al. (8)
boot camps because it has been previ- had a synergestic effect and resulted in also suggest using lower intensity (50–
ously shown that the support one re- a greater improvement in both and 70% 1RM). However, Sjogren et al.
ceives by becoming a regular member improved feelings of self-worth (40). 2006 found a light intensity of 30%
of a group fitness setting is a leading In addition to reduced panic, anxiety, 1RM was too low to reduce anxiety,
determinant to exercise adherence (18). and depression, exercise helps improve which suggests a threshold may exist
coronary artery health (36). If the client’s for resistance training to improve anxiety
AEROBIC EXERCISE goals for exercise are independent of state (42). Also, longer rest periods seem to be
The avoidance of physical activity and anxiety reduction, higher intensity aero- more effective on psychological states
exercise may result in the individual hav- bic exercise may be a better option. In the than shorter rest periods (2,8). For exam-
ing a lower fitness level and increased case where the HFP prescribes higher ple, Herring et al. (22) allowed a rest inter-
fatigue on exertion, thereby inducing intensity exercise, the duration should val of 80 seconds between each set of
a negative impact on health. It is, there- be decreased, keeping the volume each exercise and reported no adverse
fore, important to engage the clients roughly the same, and a mode selected events. Comparison of intensity has dem-
with anxiety disorders in some form of in which the activity can be safely com- onstrated high-intensity progressive resis-
physical activity or exercise program to pleted. Regardless of exercise intensity, tance training had a greater effect on
avoid the increased risks of all-cause mode, or duration, the HFP should mon- mental states than low-intensity progres-
mortality and chronic conditions associ- itor the client using heart rate and rating sive resistance training or standard care
ated with a sedentary lifestyle. Reviews of perceived exertion. In addition, the cli- (pharmacotherapy and/or counseling)
of exercise and anxiety disorders demon- ent should be granted breaks during exer- from a general practitioner (41). Although
strate no negative effects of aerobic cise to accommodate low initial fitness the reduction was lower for standard care
43
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
44 VOLUME 41 | NUMBER 5 | OCTOBER 2019
1RM 5 1 repetition maximum; HRR 5 heart rate reserve; RPE 5 rating of perceived exertion; min 5 minute.
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Table 2
Second 8-week exercise prescription for individuals with anxiety disorders
Crossed-leg trunk
rotation
Achilles stretch
Pelvic tilt
Towel stretch
Triceps stretch
Neck rotation
Warm-up/cool-down Low intensity Before and after each 10 min Stays the same throughout. Should be in the mode you will be
workout session performing for that day.
However, even during
resistance training, you should
perform an aerobic warm-up
and cool-down
Following the second 8 weeks, all assessments should be performed and intensity reevaluated to ensure that participants continue to progress within their exercise program.
1RM 5 1 repetition maximum; HRR 5 heart rate reserve; RPE 5 rating of perceived exertion; min 5 minute.
45
Anxiety and Exercise Prescription
47
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.